Your Favorite Girl Next Door - FX TV syndicated show - 1999-2001 - Stephanie Lydecker

Here is a description I found fandom.com/wiki - website:
You Favorite Girl Next Door was a short-lived, weekly game show that solicits videos from five women who believe they represent the "Girl Next Door" and then have the studio audience decide on a weekly favorite.
Thanks to You Tube user Brian Washington Jr.@spwash1000 for leading me to the title of this show!

[@spwash1000]

I believe the title of this show was Your Favorite Girl Next Door which however was short lived that aired on FX for 1 season between 1999 or 2000

[@andya5755]

You are awesome. I changed the title and description and gave you a shout out!