@@arafuruwaters lu karena liat video ini doang, aslinya diluar sana ada perdebatan entah ini udh dikreditkan ke almarhum benjamin ato engga. karena abba version sendiri minta kredit sama lagu mereka yg versi 2005 (hung up) masa benjamin gk dikasih kredit?! santai dulu makanya, apa apa ngatain overproud. missused af.
@@Surcradis2525 Keempat personel itu gak prnh -ta izin sm Benjamin Sueb hingga kematiannya. Mrk GBs dituntut para ahli wrs alm Bang Ben soalnya Undang2 Hak Cipta baru ada di 🇮🇩 thn 1982.
ABBA and the music Producer had to give a credit to Benyamin, an actor and singer from Indonesia as I thought, ABBA was inspired by BUL BUL Effendi that was released in 1978, one year before ABBA released their music.
@@christine479 Well, seeing as it's actually the remix version of Bul Bul Effendi that plagiarises Gimme! Gimme! Gimme!, and not the other way round...
That indonesian song isn't from 1978. Search on youtube "bulbul efendi original vinyl" and you will find it's the other way around-- The indonesian artist sampled ABBA in a re-release.
This is a little annoying bc Madonna wrote a personal letter to ABBA asking permission to sample it, and they said yes as long as they could have half the rights and royalties from the song and she agreed. They should be doing the same for the Indonesian guy.
@@bpcgos The original version of Bul Bul Effendi from 1978 sounds nothing like Gimme! Gimme! Gimme! A new flute riff similar to ABBA's hit song was actually added in the 80s.
@@rivani2005 Christine Aguilera juga nyampling lagu Take On Me buat diselipin ke lagu Feel The Moment sebagai melodi, tapi tetep ngasih kredit kpd A-HA.
ala , jangan overproud lah indon , tiada siapa yang hairan dengan penyanyi kau yang miskin lagi hina itu , orang luar tiada kisah dengan benyamon endon kau tu faham!?
It's actually the other way round. It's the new version of Bul Bul Effendi, with a new flute melody added in the 80s, that plagiarises Gimme! Gimme! Gimme! The original version from 1978 is entirely different.
Nope. That indonesian song isn't from 1978. Search on youtube "bulbul efendi original vinyl" and you will find it's the other way around-- The indonesian artist sampled ABBA in a re-release.
@@JojohnWick They didn't steal it. This new flute riff that sounds like Gimme! Gimme! Gimme was actually added in the 1980s. The original version of Bul Bul Effendi from 1978 has an entirely different flute melody, and you can listen to it on the album "Benyamin & Ida Royani / Pop Gambang", track #4.
The song 'Bul Bul Efendi' by Benjamin S was produced and released on 01 Feb 1978. Meanwhile, the song 'Gimme gimme after midnight' by ABBA was produced on 12 Oct 1979. That means ABBA has plagiarized Benjamin S's songs in terms of musical intro
You are wrong - its not plagiarism. You know nothing about it. Your logic like - you left your house and after that it started raining, so its your fault.
@@shadow-js2hnyour explanation is utter bullshit. Moreover abba asked for royalties from madonna to sample this tune. If they were not thieves stealing music they would have directed madonna to this guy for copyrights.
This video is the prime example that people are sheep and believe everything. Bul bul efendi sounded different when it came out. This riff was added after gimme gimme came out
They stole it lets just say it how it is please inspired would be if they gave him due credits now that the cat is out of the bag they'll probably do some half hearted beating around the bush apology and play victim to make it about themselves
@@throwaway2129whatever that means I heard the original bulbul efendi and the flute part wasn't really there it was probably edited and ABBA's one is the original
The Ben S. version in this shorts is actually the unauthorized sample. It was made by an obscure musician and uploaded it on Spotify. I have an answer to this on my channel.
@@rihamashraf4493 Proof? You can listen to the original version of Bul Bul Effendi from 1978 on the album "Benyamin & Ida Royani / Pop Gambang". It's track#4 and it has *nothing* in common with Gimme! Gimme! Gimme! The version of the song heard in this video is actually a remix with a new flute riff that was added in the 80s...
Benyamin - Bul Bul Effendi, with an entirely different flute melody 1978 ABBA - Gimme! Gimme! Gimme! 1979 Benyamin - new version of Bul Bul Effendi with a new flute riff that copies Gimme! Gimme! Gimme! sometime in the 80s Madonna - Hang Up 2005 Fixed that for ya 😉
Does anyone have the original vinyl recording? It has NOTHING to do with the rest of the song and only occurs at the beginning - an easy place to overdub before releasing on CD. If anyone has, could they play it on UA-cam to prove it either way (lift the stylus paet way through to show it is genuine).
You can easily find the original song: all you have to do is look for "Benyamin & Ida Royani / Pop Gambang". It's track #4, and the original flute melody has absolutely *nothing* in common with Gimme! Gimme! Gimme! A new flute riff similar to ABBA's hit song was added in the 1980s.
No. The difference in melody is very obvious . Also the energy of the ABBA version is in contrast to the lacklustre use by Benyamin. At very best, B and B may have heard Benyamin's use of the instrument but realised its potential and took the sound in an entirely new direction.
@@billiejoearmstrong3741 Easy! Just listen to the original version of Bul Bul Effendi from 1978. It's track#4 on the album "Benyamin & Ida Royani / Pop Gambang", and it has aboslutely *nothing* in common with Gimme! Gimme! Gimme! The original flute melody is entirely different.
و الله مش عارفين في ناس بتقول انها صدفة و في ناس بتقول ان اللحن ده اصلا مش موجود في الاغنية الاندونيسية و ان في ناس عدلوا عليها و ضافوا الموسيقي دي ف مش عارفين حتي لو دورتي هتلاقي كل الفيديوهات بتاعتالاغنب جديدة ٢٠٢٠ و ٢٠٢٣ لازم حد يبقي سمع الاغنية الاصلية عشان نقيم اذا كان فعلا ماخوذ من الاغنية الاندونيسية او لا
They didn't, sis. The original version of Bul Bul Effendi from 1978 has a totally different flute melody that doesn't remotely sound like Gimme! Gimme! Gimme! It's actually the new flute riff, added in the 1980s, that plagiarised ABBA's hit song.
Siapa yg duluan jadi rancu, benyamin sueb bul bul efendi tahun 1878, dia meninggal 1995.. hak paten di Indonesia baru ada 1982.. sedangkan ABBA ngeluari lagunya 1979, dan tentu langsung dipatenkan lebih dulu.. mungkin wajar madona ngasih royalti ke ABBA soalnya dah hak patennya.. kemungkinan Benyamin sueb kalah start soal hak paten.. padahal sejarahnya tetep benyamin sueb lah yg lebih dulu music aransement diciptakan, tahun 1978.
@@billiejoearmstrong3741 They didn't. The original version of Bul Bul Effendi from 1978 has a totally different flute melody that sounds nothing like Gimme! Gimme! Gimme! The new flute riff that is similar to ABBA's hit song was actually added in the 1980s. You can listen to the original version of the song on the album "Benyamin & Ida Royani / Pop Gambang", it's track #4.
So proud of you, Maestro late almarhum Benyamin S.
Adaaaa.......lagi kaum overproud.
@@arafuruwaters lu karena liat video ini doang, aslinya diluar sana ada perdebatan entah ini udh dikreditkan ke almarhum benjamin ato engga. karena abba version sendiri minta kredit sama lagu mereka yg versi 2005 (hung up) masa benjamin gk dikasih kredit?! santai dulu makanya, apa apa ngatain overproud. missused af.
@@Surcradis2525 Keempat personel itu gak prnh -ta izin sm Benjamin Sueb hingga kematiannya. Mrk GBs dituntut para ahli wrs alm Bang Ben soalnya Undang2 Hak Cipta baru ada di 🇮🇩 thn 1982.
@@Surcradis2525I wonder why that is you uneducated 0 critical thinking I’m going to believe everything I see on the internet looking sand guy
how to spawn Indonesian netizens:
😂
Shut up
Emang faktanya gtu beda 1 tahun lebih dlu benyamin
@@silliy_mlbb orang barat lebih susah buat nerima fakta ya daripada malaysia
@@silliy_mlbb 72 Benyamin 79 abba drmana 1 thn.
ABBA and the music Producer had to give a credit to Benyamin, an actor and singer from Indonesia as I thought, ABBA was inspired by BUL BUL Effendi that was released in 1978, one year before ABBA released their music.
❤❤❤
Ada instrumen music Betawi nya
but Indonesian music copyright only came to existence in 1982; so, perhaps ABBA can't be sued
@@christine479 Well, seeing as it's actually the remix version of Bul Bul Effendi that plagiarises Gimme! Gimme! Gimme!, and not the other way round...
This has to be the most blatant example of 0 fucking access to online information or formal education.
The legendary actor, singer & comedian...from indonesia..
I have no idea who that is
@@throwaway2129That's why ABBA choose that song for inspiration, coz they think not so many people would recognize, moreover in that era.
@@chaserbaamalch757 Actually it's been proven that he stole it from abba
@@throwaway2129 Pay attention the year, moreover you said that you don't know who he is, so how did you know he stole?
@@chaserbaamalch757 I googled it and he admitted to stealing it
if we notice the year of their released album i think "yes."
That indonesian song isn't from 1978. Search on youtube "bulbul efendi original vinyl" and you will find it's the other way around-- The indonesian artist sampled ABBA in a re-release.
@@Tulanir1Search in google, not youtube.
This is a little annoying bc Madonna wrote a personal letter to ABBA asking permission to sample it, and they said yes as long as they could have half the rights and royalties from the song and she agreed. They should be doing the same for the Indonesian guy.
Harus nya Benyamin Sueb dapat dari royalti dari instrumen karena di instrumen itu ada budaya Betawi
Ele deveria receber também, sacanagem.
Madonna should have write it directly to Benyamin instead of ABBA, it would probably be cheaper
@@bpcgos The original version of Bul Bul Effendi from 1978 sounds nothing like Gimme! Gimme! Gimme! A new flute riff similar to ABBA's hit song was actually added in the 80s.
@@Megrez-Alberichwhere did you listen to that version?
ABBA ( 1979 )
Benyamin S ( 1978 )
Indonesian Netizen! 🔥🤓
Abba memplagiat Lagu Indonesia!
siapa tau sample, kan cuma intro bukan keseluruhan, sample mah banyak lagu lain juga
@@rivani2005still doesnt give you the rights to steal from somebody.
@@rivani2005 Christine Aguilera juga nyampling lagu Take On Me buat diselipin ke lagu Feel The Moment sebagai melodi, tapi tetep ngasih kredit kpd A-HA.
Mungkin kebetulan 😅
ala , jangan overproud lah indon , tiada siapa yang hairan dengan penyanyi kau yang miskin lagi hina itu , orang luar tiada kisah dengan benyamon endon kau tu faham!?
Didn't the original bul bul effendi not have the abba sound? And then he added it after abba made gimme gimme gimme?
Yup, I just listened to the original version and it sounds nothing like the Abba song
Sayangnya saat itu undang undang hak cipta masih diabaikan kalo tidak Alm.benyamin syuaib bisa tuntut ABBA
Yes I think so. The song title is also similar.
Yt botak itu kok hebat banget ya nemuin lagu² mirip
Real
awalnya kan emg udh rame di twt sblm si botak bikin konten
Kebiasaan si jarred wkwk
Jir ngatain si jarred botak😂
@@FatanNabilatp byk yg d spill dia g cuman ini
ABBAもサンプリングしてたんだw
BULL BULL EFFENDl →Gimme! Gimme! Gimme!→Hung up
Now i know Benyamin S also a singer instead of only acting.
Lol, he got dozen of album and songs
Does Abba's song imitate Bunyamin's song Bul Efendi?
they imitate the musics
It's actually the other way round. It's the new version of Bul Bul Effendi, with a new flute melody added in the 80s, that plagiarises Gimme! Gimme! Gimme! The original version from 1978 is entirely different.
Sayang juga, Dani Ahmad masih SD waktu itu. Sebab yang sangat getol menyuarakan hak cipta, ya cuma mas Dani.
benyamin is original melody.
Nope white melody is OG suck it
Nope. That indonesian song isn't from 1978. Search on youtube "bulbul efendi original vinyl" and you will find it's the other way around-- The indonesian artist sampled ABBA in a re-release.
you're so funny 😂 @@Tulanir1
In the indonesian song, the flute sound is only played for the first 10 seconds and you don't hear it again.
So you can steal it?
@@JojohnWick They didn't steal it. This new flute riff that sounds like Gimme! Gimme! Gimme was actually added in the 1980s.
The original version of Bul Bul Effendi from 1978 has an entirely different flute melody, and you can listen to it on the album "Benyamin & Ida Royani / Pop Gambang", track #4.
Benyamin s tahun 1977, truss abba 1978, keren deh babeh Benyamin s orang luar udah nyontek lagu babeh
Benyamin 78
Abba 79
ABBA members are inspired by their love to each other and their love to music! Thanks them for their talent !
In the past, foreigners imitated us, but now we imitate them😅
I remember them
Yes, it is! The melody of ABBA's Gimme Gimme Gimme is inspired by Benyamin Sueb's song Bul Bul Efendi.
It is called stealing.. Not inspired.. Even madonna have to ask permit to abba.. And give them credit and royalty😂
@@yafettuwanakotta8929idk man If you look at hip hop industry almost everything is sampled exactly like in this case
Sy mencium aroma2 GBs ngebedain M*L*NG vs "terinspirasi".
It's the other way round. The original version of Bul Bul Effendi from 1978 has an entirely different flute melody...
Mantap
The song 'Bul Bul Efendi' by Benjamin S was produced and released on 01 Feb 1978. Meanwhile, the song 'Gimme gimme after midnight' by ABBA was produced on 12 Oct 1979. That means ABBA has plagiarized Benjamin S's songs in terms of musical intro
You are wrong - its not plagiarism. You know nothing about it. Your logic like - you left your house and after that it started raining, so its your fault.
@@shadow-js2hndamn, what about tellin the guy how he's wrong. Instead of just saying he's wrong no explanation, eh?
@@shadow-js2hnyour explanation is utter bullshit. Moreover abba asked for royalties from madonna to sample this tune. If they were not thieves stealing music they would have directed madonna to this guy for copyrights.
@@shadow-js2hn its not plagiarism but stealing
Uhhh i don't understand
bro summoned a whole damn country.
(dont worry you also spawned me)
Seumur umur bru kali ini denger lagu bang benyamin
Bapak-bapak angkringan langganan gw nyetel lagu jadul terus 😂 Rhoma irama, Benyamin Sueb, dll
Mirip...banget.kebalikan bang Haji yg Black Sabbath fan
Copied, not inspired from
Wait till you hear the original tune from Black Eye Peas Pump it from Misirlou 1927
Satu alasan, sampling.
Sampling adalah tameng mereka wkwkwkwkw
Yuppp..bisa jdi jga nehh ABBA neru babe Benyamin S...
Genius Benyamin sueb
This video is the prime example that people are sheep and believe everything. Bul bul efendi sounded different when it came out. This riff was added after gimme gimme came out
How To becoming popular in 1 simple ways
Pasti bikin konten ini habis nonton kontenny orang luar berkepala botak ya 😂
bnr baru gw jg ini barusan
haha iya past
Jared😭
Apa kanapa tidak
Bald Head?
100% (shockingly).
The music sound is same
From indonesian
Dari data yang ada untuk sementara ini lagu bul bul efendi memang lagu yang di produksi lebih dulu yang memakai intro tersebut
They stole it lets just say it how it is please inspired would be if they gave him due credits now that the cat is out of the bag they'll probably do some half hearted beating around the bush apology and play victim to make it about themselves
Beyamin stole the tune it's already been proven
@@throwaway2129how??
@@rihamashraf4493 through science
@@throwaway2129whatever that means I heard the original bulbul efendi and the flute part wasn't really there it was probably edited and ABBA's one is the original
@@rihamashraf4493 correct
Abba should written to benyamin sueb for using the melody
It's the other way around, duh !
Madona hung up juga mirip
madona emg remake lagu abba "gimme gimme"
@@fathanov oh
Itu samplenya
Sy mencium aroma2 pd blm tahu & ngedengerin lagu Engkau Tampan Jadi Rebutan (Rosemaria, 1980).
The Ben S. version in this shorts is actually the unauthorized sample. It was made by an obscure musician and uploaded it on Spotify. I have an answer to this on my channel.
proof??
@@rihamashraf4493 Proof? You can listen to the original version of Bul Bul Effendi from 1978 on the album "Benyamin & Ida Royani / Pop Gambang".
It's track#4 and it has *nothing* in common with Gimme! Gimme! Gimme!
The version of the song heard in this video is actually a remix with a new flute riff that was added in the 80s...
@@Megrez-Alberich yes, I did long time ago actually after watching this video months ago I know now it's different but thank u anyways
Dengerin lagu pertama ikonik pas lagu kedua ko ngakak yh salute credit buat babeh Benjamin
Benyamin - Bul Effendi 1978
ABBA - Gimme! Gimme! Gimme! 1979
Madonna - Hang Up 2005
Bul not Dul.
Rosemaria - Engkau Tampan Jadi Rebutan 1980
Benyamin - Bul Bul Effendi, with an entirely different flute melody 1978
ABBA - Gimme! Gimme! Gimme! 1979
Benyamin - new version of Bul Bul Effendi with a new flute riff that copies Gimme! Gimme! Gimme! sometime in the 80s
Madonna - Hang Up 2005
Fixed that for ya 😉
❤🇮🇩
Of course
Yes they was.
No doubt about it Lah
Does anyone have the original vinyl recording? It has NOTHING to do with the rest of the song and only occurs at the beginning - an easy place to overdub before releasing on CD. If anyone has, could they play it on UA-cam to prove it either way (lift the stylus paet way through to show it is genuine).
You can easily find the original song: all you have to do is look for "Benyamin & Ida Royani / Pop Gambang". It's track #4, and the original flute melody has absolutely *nothing* in common with Gimme! Gimme! Gimme!
A new flute riff similar to ABBA's hit song was added in the 1980s.
After 40yrs only now they realised it.. 😂😂
Definitely
😮
No. The difference in melody is very obvious . Also the energy of the ABBA version is in contrast to the lacklustre use by Benyamin.
At very best, B and B may have heard Benyamin's use of the instrument but realised its potential and took the sound in an entirely new direction.
Indonesian melody
Pink phanter from warkop DKI
effect tictoc make music keep exis
Siapa sangka🤯
I'm people indonesia☝😅
inspired by abah Benyamin
bul bul bul Efendi bul bul 😁... Haji Efendi
Wow... really?! I didn't know that Abba actually inspired by Benyamin S....
😂
yes they did.
Benyamin Sueb 🎉 t
Benyamin s 1978 😮
I think that Abba inspired by Benyamin su'eb. but I'm not sure whether they have permission or not
Nope, they never asked him for permission 'till his death.
It's actually the remix version of Bul Bul Effendi, with a new flute riff added in the 80s, that plagiarises Gimme! Gimme! Gimme!
Why you summon me😃
dulu mana ada hak cipta
Bul bul bul F&B
gw bru 2th lagu" nie dah ada 😅
"INSPIRED"
It wasn't plagiarism, trust!
Benyamin S was jimi hendrix from asia
Nyari viewer Indonesia ni ye
INDONESIAN people is number ONE
Makan nasi pake kebul
Abba doesnot give cridit title to benyamin sueb..but madonna did that do abba
Also Madonna use the intro part on 'Hung up' 😁🎉
It's a fake. The flute was added to the indonesian song after 1979. The original 1978 version does not have the ABBA sample...
Prove it
@@billiejoearmstrong3741 Easy! Just listen to the original version of Bul Bul Effendi from 1978. It's track#4 on the album "Benyamin & Ida Royani / Pop Gambang", and it has aboslutely *nothing* in common with Gimme! Gimme! Gimme! The original flute melody is entirely different.
It's literally stealing wtf
I have been called
Real jiplak ni... Cuma di percepat aja versi mereka biar keliatan ori
Tidak ada jiplak. Benyamin s yang jiplak
@@exuaf palelu pitak.
Sowek kali kupinglo...🤣😆🤣🙊
@@exuaf wkwkwk tolol bener
@@exuaf dari tahun rilis aja dah kelihatan. dasarpenyepong bule
@@exuaf lah tu liat taunya bro
Que plágio mais perfeito do ABBA hahahaah amo essa música
It's not inspired, it's plagiarism, Abba need charge in the law
Fix ABBA maling.
so what ..
im proud to be indonesian
This means that ABBA imitates BEJAMIN, right
No
It's the other way round, actually.
أثار دهشتي أن هذا اللحن لمغني اندنوسي سرقة أدبية فضيحة من الفنانين الاوربيين
They have done it a lot 😂
و الله مش عارفين في ناس بتقول انها صدفة و في ناس بتقول ان اللحن ده اصلا مش موجود في الاغنية الاندونيسية و ان في ناس عدلوا عليها و ضافوا الموسيقي دي ف مش عارفين حتي لو دورتي هتلاقي كل الفيديوهات بتاعتالاغنب جديدة ٢٠٢٠ و ٢٠٢٣ لازم حد يبقي سمع الاغنية الاصلية عشان نقيم اذا كان فعلا ماخوذ من الاغنية الاندونيسية او لا
لا انا سمعت الاغنية الاندونيسية الاصلية تعبت لحد ما لقيتها و فعلا اللحن مش موجود في الاغنية الاندونيسية يعني الاغنية الانجليزية هي اللحن الاصلي
Bruh Abba stole it, 😂
They didn't, sis. The original version of Bul Bul Effendi from 1978 has a totally different flute melody that doesn't remotely sound like Gimme! Gimme! Gimme!
It's actually the new flute riff, added in the 1980s, that plagiarised ABBA's hit song.
Siapa yg duluan jadi rancu, benyamin sueb bul bul efendi tahun 1878, dia meninggal 1995.. hak paten di Indonesia baru ada 1982.. sedangkan ABBA ngeluari lagunya 1979, dan tentu langsung dipatenkan lebih dulu.. mungkin wajar madona ngasih royalti ke ABBA soalnya dah hak patennya.. kemungkinan Benyamin sueb kalah start soal hak paten.. padahal sejarahnya tetep benyamin sueb lah yg lebih dulu music aransement diciptakan, tahun 1978.
nope
pervert Facts
@@THEVANWINLE ??
how lol
1978>>1979 lmao
benyamin's song came first Bruh
I don’t think they’d even heard this track
They stole it bro 😂
@@billiejoearmstrong3741 They didn't. The original version of Bul Bul Effendi from 1978 has a totally different flute melody that sounds nothing like Gimme! Gimme! Gimme! The new flute riff that is similar to ABBA's hit song was actually added in the 1980s.
You can listen to the original version of the song on the album "Benyamin & Ida Royani / Pop Gambang", it's track #4.
Indonesia coy
ada Indonesia cuy
Reddit says so
Ada indonesia coy
Cringe comment, Idi*tnesia
@@Senaga.Felicya Imagine not taking a joke lmao, couldn't be me.
Ada Indonesia coy
Bruh its sampling
Nah u trippin😂😂
no it wasn't
Well, the intro sucks anyway so... 😑
💀
Don't slam the door on your way out.