Paul being very respectful Showing George Martin the real G minor chord to the song and laughing a bit to almost not correct the school master who had taught him so much. Paul was always so diplomatic because he doesn’t want to disrespect anyone, especially people he loves and admires.
McCartney is a genius, he knows all the westernized music theory intuitively, and at a really high level, even if he's not able to dictate it exactly in musicological terms, he's a genius, he figured out how to be Mozart his way, his ideas are infectious, I'm a classical musician, I have a BA music degree in classical music from an esteemed higher educational institution, I've studied Shenckerian analysis, and counterpoint, more often than not, McCartney hits it out of the park, both my parents had a doctorate in string pedagogy/music performance, my father is a cellist and my mom was a pianist, they met at the Manhattan School of music, I come from a classical music background, Paul McCartney is a musical genius, bar none, don't believe him when he says that he doesn't read music, the guy knows everything, even if he doesn't read music extremely well, he knows everything, he's just super humble about it, you listen to the late '60s interviews and he understands what an aeolean climax and mellismatic phrases are/were...
Paul was massively talented for sure but look at the interplay between the two of them. George Martin is and always was the enabler. ‘I’ve had an idea George. Let’s make it into a beautifully produced song’. George Martin truly was the fifth indispensable Beatle.
Carl Nyberg....that's the magic of film. He looks like a kid to me too, but if I saw this back when it happened I'd have said he looks like a grown up ☺️
IMO, this song is one of Linda's best performances. Her subtle keyboard work and lilting voice add so much to the overall feel of it. The 1993 remaster on 'Give My Regards To Broad Street' is my favourite. Of course Macca, Gilmore and the rest are pretty good too. 😉
As much as people could view Paul’s constantly playing that riff as annoying or rudderless, you can tell he’s got an idea that he’s not only trying to bring out but also somehow convey to George Martin who is trying his best to pick it up. It’s cool to watch this all in action.
Pareciera que Paul experimentaba algunas sonoridades con su Bajo y de pronto George identifica los acordes de lo que más adelante se convertiría en No more lonely nights.... cosas de genios.
RANDY JUDAH TORREZ < I really like that delayed effect Billy, is using. 👍 It works really well, I know I have one and I love it, especially when I'm playing Bass guitar 🎸
Not exactly having the Lennon McCartney magical teamwork. Paul having to keep it rolling. But he still is writing and performing well, and I'm greatful we still have him.
I never saw maca play without a pic before. Also, this confirms what I always suspected. The 5th Beatle was very instrumental in helping the fabs write many of their songs. George Martin was in many ways, the most important of all of them.
@cherbutler85 They would have been a terrific bunch of rockers. But not the progressive group they became with classical/jazz/ period music and George's innovative studio magic. Martin is the man that made them highbrow as maca used to call it. And he was the true definition of an English gentleman.
Martin contributed but was lucky to work with the Beatles. The song writer is the genius. There are others that could add the classical assist if it weren’t Martin. Ever hear of the Phil Spector and wall of sound? Are u aware gamble and huff did much of many Motown artists. That is bunk Beatles would not b great without Martin. Other greats- Quincy jones. George duke. Google the stars they worked with. Rod temper ton wrote many of Michael Jackson’s solo hits including thriller , lady in my like. Quincy jones also worked with early Beatles. So explain to me like a 6 year old why Beatles could not have found another classically trained musician. Martin could not have found another McCartney Lennon
@Kenn Gor Your all over the place. But yes I heard of Phil Spector and could name every member of his players the wrecking crew. And discuss what rolls they played . So, don't get condescending about my knowledge of rock music. Its quite possible I have forgotten more than you will ever no about music. As far as Spector goes, great players he assembled. The wall of sound was just doubling, trippling, overdubs. Nothing that sophisticated. Same with Quincy. Nothing fancy engineering wise. Martin was much more innovative than both combined. At first, things like adding a string quartet and writing the music for yesterday. That helped create the most played pop song of all time. He did the same with Elanor Rigby. He wrote and played the piano solo for Rita and in my life. Then he played with the tape speed of it to make it sound like a harpsichord. He also played tape loops backwards, like in the song rain. He spliced together two different takes of strawberry fields in different keys to create its magical sound. He also invented track bouncing which made the wall of sound look like child's play. All techniques which were unheard of at the time. So save your sarcasm and stop showing the whole UA-cam community you know nothing about rock engineering, production, or Beatles history. Without Martin, the Beatles would have been just better rolling stones. He was truly the 5th and most important Beatle.
Just read your comment buddy .... and i've wondered the same all my boring days of existence ??? . I only say that because everything is very difficult to do by yourself !!! . I've always wondered with the band "The Police" ? . They used his recording studios and i gently smile to myself !!
All bands have producers and engineers, etc. who contribute the the bands success. Why is it only the Beatles who are treated as if this is unique and gave them an advantage that others did not have? Watching this video I see Paul telling Martin how he wants it played on the piano and George going along with it and saying that will be a lovely song.
@@braemtes23 I'm a massive Beatles fan, I love Paul's work but the reality is that the Beatles were never hitting the heights they did without George Martin. He was amazing
@@derekbyrne6575 have you seen the Hulu show, “McCartney 3,2,1”? It’s sweet the way he talks about George Martin in the docuseries and about everyone else that contributed. Hard to believe McCartney is going to be 80 this summer…no sign of slowing down with his performances yet! Just amazing.
@@derekbyrne6575 I love how Paul said that whereas some producers would say “we’ll try that another day,” Martin listened to their ideas and really worked with them as both a father figure and teacher with experimenting with new sounds and instruments etc. and giving them room to try out new ideas.
Si, así suena la intro a la canción,...pero siempre me ha parecido, y mas con la conversación entre Martin y Macca en el video, que esas cuatro notas tocadas al bajo fueron detonante en la mente de Paul para "parir" toda la canción, y que despues al terminar la canción la dejó a modo de intro,...McCartney le pide los acordes al piano de lo que le sugieren esas notas de bajo con efecto de Delay o eco y George Martin los busca digamos...
This is a GREAT song - marred only by the guitar solo (shame, that). So interesting seeing him work out the beginning melody with George Martin! I didn't know George was there from the compositional start on this one. I've seen McCartney lives many times over the years; haven't seen him perform this. This is one that's worthy. Another one is With a LIttle Luck. Never heard him do that live. Might be tough vocally at this point.
My love for Paul is infinite & never-ending, but my God he so desperately needed the quality control that he lost when John, George and Ringo weren't around.
stop with the silly debates and arguments- much of music is based on chemistry, which can't be created or even defined, only found. Yes, Martin never did anything approaching the beatles greatness when not working with them. and none of them did anything approaching the greatness of what they created with his help. it is what it is. it's not one or the other. No different than Jagger and Richards or Elton and Bernie. Something happens when the right people are together.
Yeah... Paul died in '66. Anyone who believes this urban legend is on drugs or a fool. It's easy to find a physical likeness. But, one with the same talent, genius and voice? In your dreams
You can change a face with plastic surgery if you wanna go that route what you CAN'T change are your fingerprints. Your DNA and bloodtype..the PID thing ...the one thing it did do for the Beatles was make them massively rich by people buying more records looking for clues and playing them backwards..nice marketing ploy...pretend to be dead
Ufff!! Era más interesante la Armonía que sugirió el genial George Martin. Vanguardista, impresionista. Pero McCartney lo endulza con su armonía tradicional y con un sentido más comercial. Aunque me gusta la música de McCartney después de vídeos como éste me queda la intriga de qué hubiera sido si McCartney hubiese aceptado sugerencias tan geniales. Creo que él pudo aprender más y trascender musicalmente pero se quedó encasillado en hacer baladas.
A canção Yesterday devia ser atribuída a McCartney/Martin e não Lennon/McCartney. O quarteto de cordas composto por George Martin eleva a canção para um nível. estratosférico. (Desculpa responder em Português)
Paul being very respectful
Showing George Martin the real G minor chord to the song and laughing a bit to almost not correct the school master who had taught him so much. Paul was always so diplomatic because he doesn’t want to disrespect anyone, especially people he loves and admires.
McCartney is a genius, he knows all the westernized music theory intuitively, and at a really high level, even if he's not able to dictate it exactly in musicological terms, he's a genius, he figured out how to be Mozart his way, his ideas are infectious, I'm a classical musician, I have a BA music degree in classical music from an esteemed higher educational institution, I've studied Shenckerian analysis, and counterpoint, more often than not, McCartney hits it out of the park, both my parents had a doctorate in string pedagogy/music performance, my father is a cellist and my mom was a pianist, they met at the Manhattan School of music, I come from a classical music background, Paul McCartney is a musical genius, bar none, don't believe him when he says that he doesn't read music, the guy knows everything, even if he doesn't read music extremely well, he knows everything, he's just super humble about it, you listen to the late '60s interviews and he understands what an aeolean climax and mellismatic phrases are/were...
Absolutely agree!!! Lovely comment :)
Paul was massively talented for sure but look at the interplay between the two of them. George Martin is and always was the enabler. ‘I’ve had an idea George. Let’s make it into a beautifully produced song’. George Martin truly was the fifth indispensable Beatle.
He is the 8th wonder of the world ❤
You're talking way above my head but I know this for sure: Paul has a better sense of melody than anyone I have ever had the pleasure of listening to.
I'm not sure there is such a thing as music theory.
Quite possibly the Greatest Musician of all Time.
Fascinating . It's like a teacher and his most prized student in class. A nice glimpse at how Paul and George worked so well together.
I'm so old 1980s Paul McCartney looks like a kid.
Carl Nyberg....that's the magic of film. He looks like a kid to me too, but if I saw this back when it happened I'd have said he looks like a grown up ☺️
en ese momento tenia 40 años
No more lonely nights (ballad version) is one of the most underrated Paul´s song ever! It even has David Gilmour in the guitar.
Heck yeah! That outro solo is killer over that chord change.
For heavensake I hope he got out!
One of my favourite Paul songs.
top 10 in most countries, no. 6 in billboard and no. 2 in uk. i don't think that's underrated.
Underrated by whom?
Paul McCartney is Bach of our time
Será recordado como uno de los mayores genios de la música mucho talento creativo la verdad me hacen falta The Beatles bueno aquí está Paul
Qué belleza ver este proceso creativo ❤ hermoso registro audiovisual.
Man this is awesome!!!Paul always ahead of his time
Man that bass line ❤️
It must be a pleasure to be one of these two geniuses and share so many years of recording and production with the other genius.
Paul is such an awesome song writer! music just pours out of him and his wonderful creative abilities are enhanced greatly working with George Martin.
Yes, an awesome song writer and a major a**hole.
What about Barry Gibb
@@jorgealvaradohernandez5329 Barry Gibb is great but even he cant even come close to the music that Paul McCartney has given the world!
@@jorgealvaradohernandez5329 l was just thinking same.
@@allymayful okay
He looks like he’s in a Beatle tribute band.
No, it was the style then. Notice the back is cut off quite short., and no sideburns.
Because Paul Is Paul
Growing it out after the Pipes of Peace video
I don't think it's the real Paul.
@@pleasepermitmetospeakohgre1504 YAWN!
Un par de genios
Es notable cómo en el minuto 1:18 se resume toda la esencia de la canción con ese acorde de Si bemol.
Gm es
Es Gm7/F
Thank you for uploading this clip, Mr. Jorge Alejandro... nice, behind-the-scenes footage of the recording process.
IMO, this song is one of Linda's best performances. Her subtle keyboard work and lilting voice add so much to the overall feel of it.
The 1993 remaster on 'Give My Regards To Broad Street' is my favourite.
Of course Macca, Gilmore and the rest are pretty good too. 😉
I always love seeing Paul with his daddy George working together ♥️
Classically trained musician mets musical genius
You hit it right on the mark
As much as people could view Paul’s constantly playing that riff as annoying or rudderless, you can tell he’s got an idea that he’s not only trying to bring out but also somehow convey to George Martin who is trying his best to pick it up. It’s cool to watch this all in action.
it is such a great song too bad we never hear it on the radio anymore.
There are still many radio stations who play classics every day.
Radio sucks these days!
Pareciera que Paul experimentaba algunas sonoridades con su Bajo y de pronto George identifica los acordes de lo que más adelante se convertiría en No more lonely nights.... cosas de genios.
This is real intertainment. I enjoyed this as much as listening to the song. Like to c more Mac and George composing
Geniuses at work!!!
Una rareza muy agradable de ver, Paul con un bajo Yamaha y tocando sin púa. Que buen video !!!
Y haciendo slap sobre todo. Re wtf
Ese bajó lo uso con Wings, así que no es raro que lo tenga
Fantastic clip!!!!!!
That bass must've driven George martin nuts after awhile.
It's so sweet
Love this clip!
RANDY JUDAH TORREZ <
I really like that delayed effect Billy, is using. 👍
It works really well, I know I have one and I love it, especially when I'm playing Bass guitar 🎸
This is so wonderful
Not exactly having the Lennon McCartney magical teamwork. Paul having to keep it rolling.
But he still is writing and performing well, and I'm greatful we still have him.
because Martin wasn't a writer or even composer. he was an amazing arranger, scorer and of course producer
Two masters at work .
George Martin was the 5th Beatle. Their secret weapon 😉. RIP
I never saw maca play without a pic before. Also, this confirms what I always suspected. The 5th Beatle was very instrumental in helping the fabs write many of their songs. George Martin was in many ways, the most important of all of them.
The Beatles don’t exist without him.
@cherbutler85 They would have been a terrific bunch of rockers. But not the progressive group they became with classical/jazz/ period music and George's innovative studio magic. Martin is the man that made them highbrow as maca used to call it. And he was the true definition of an English gentleman.
Martin contributed but was lucky to work with the Beatles. The song writer is the genius. There are others that could add the classical assist if it weren’t Martin. Ever hear of the Phil Spector and wall of sound? Are u aware gamble and huff did much of many Motown artists. That is bunk Beatles would not b great without Martin. Other greats- Quincy jones. George duke. Google the stars they worked with. Rod temper ton wrote many of Michael Jackson’s solo hits including thriller , lady in my like. Quincy jones also worked with early Beatles. So explain to me like a 6 year old why Beatles could not have found another classically trained musician. Martin could not have found another McCartney Lennon
@Kenn Gor Your all over the place. But yes I heard of Phil Spector and could name every member of his players the wrecking crew. And discuss what rolls they played . So, don't get condescending about my knowledge of rock music. Its quite possible I have forgotten more than you will ever no about music. As far as Spector goes, great players he assembled. The wall of sound was just doubling, trippling, overdubs. Nothing that sophisticated. Same with Quincy. Nothing fancy engineering wise. Martin was much more innovative than both combined. At first, things like adding a string quartet and writing the music for yesterday. That helped create the most played pop song of all time. He did the same with Elanor Rigby. He wrote and played the piano solo for Rita and in my life. Then he played with the tape speed of it to make it sound like a harpsichord. He also played tape loops backwards, like in the song rain. He spliced together two different takes of strawberry fields in different keys to create its magical sound. He also invented track bouncing which made the wall of sound look like child's play. All techniques which were unheard of at the time. So save your sarcasm and stop showing the whole UA-cam community you know nothing about rock engineering, production, or Beatles history. Without Martin, the Beatles would have been just better rolling stones. He was truly the 5th and most important Beatle.
@@cherbutler85 Absolute cack!
Best thing about the whole movie
This is gold
Most everything Paul writes is good stuff
The mistake people make about the Beatles is that they were a brilliant team. Geoff Emerick, George Martin. Everyone chipped in with the creativity.
Just read your comment buddy .... and i've wondered the same all my boring days of existence ???
.
I only say that because everything is very difficult to do by yourself !!!
.
I've always wondered with the band "The Police" ?
.
They used his recording studios and i gently smile to myself !!
All bands have producers and engineers, etc. who contribute the the bands success. Why is it only the Beatles who are treated as if this is unique and gave them an advantage that others did not have? Watching this video I see Paul telling Martin how he wants it played on the piano and George going along with it and saying that will be a lovely song.
@@braemtes23 I'm a massive Beatles fan, I love Paul's work but the reality is that the Beatles were never hitting the heights they did without George Martin. He was amazing
@@derekbyrne6575 have you seen the Hulu show, “McCartney 3,2,1”? It’s sweet the way he talks about George Martin in the docuseries and about everyone else that contributed. Hard to believe McCartney is going to be 80 this summer…no sign of slowing down with his performances yet! Just amazing.
@@derekbyrne6575 I love how Paul said that whereas some producers would say “we’ll try that another day,” Martin listened to their ideas and really worked with them as both a father figure and teacher with experimenting with new sounds and instruments etc. and giving them room to try out new ideas.
Wow dito nag umpisa no more lonely nights nya parang discovery by chance..
They talk a language only musicians understand.
Omg he's so young there! Boyish looks. Linda had it great!
That riff sounds like the underground theme from Super Mario Bros
I always thought it was David Gilmour playing this line on his guitar, Not Paul on bass. Shows what i know.
George Martin had the best relationship with Paul
It was very evident and this clip was a prime example.
"That's a nice cut, g." - John Lennon's ghost
He has a Beatle haircut in the 80s
Quiero ver David Gilmour tocar el parte de el.
BELA MÚSICA... ALIÁS, TODAS DE PAUL...SOLO DE GILMOUR...SHOW...
The 4th Beatle... Sir George Martin!
Let's write the song right here. -- Sir Paul
So cool
George Martin get any credit for writing this song?
❤
Very good!!!
That's was the Yamaha's Bass sold on the Auction (2021)?
Everything indicates..Yamaha BB-1200
@@renatomoraes1900 Thank's, Man. (Se for Brasileiro, valeu aí meu querido).
Who auctioned and for how much?
Mario Bros got their music from McCartney!!
Welcome to Paul’s kitchen. Homemade treats
Si, así suena la intro a la canción,...pero siempre me ha parecido, y mas con la conversación entre Martin y Macca en el video, que esas cuatro notas tocadas al bajo fueron detonante en la mente de Paul para "parir" toda la canción, y que despues al terminar la canción la dejó a modo de intro,...McCartney le pide los acordes al piano de lo que le sugieren esas notas de bajo con efecto de Delay o eco y George Martin los busca digamos...
Yamaha BB??
Yes
And they had no idea the camera's were rolling.....uh huh. Not a good movie but a great song though.
dargelos y el Tigre Gareca
what is this taken from?
this guy play good the bass.
Sounds like Joy Division.
Is it me or that bass riff without the piano is somehow similar to the intro of Styx's too much time on my hands?
I totally hear it!
This is a GREAT song - marred only by the guitar solo (shame, that). So interesting seeing him work out the beginning melody with George Martin! I didn't know George was there from the compositional start on this one. I've seen McCartney lives many times over the years; haven't seen him perform this. This is one that's worthy. Another one is With a LIttle Luck. Never heard him do that live. Might be tough vocally at this point.
David Gilmore from Pink Floyd played the solo. I know it doesn't match.
The true fifth beatle is right there.. I love billy preston but george martin had been with the boys all the way in all recording session
Que buen corte de pelo el de Paul.
Ya no imponía moda , se adaptaba a ella.
@@jorgealejandro4859 siempre está bien hacer un cambio, en la vida nos debemos adaptar.
Pinche Paul se cargaba un look bien vergas
Llegué a pensar que ese intro lo hacía David Gilmour con su guitarra.
I did feel the same 👍🎸
La estructura de la canción en si no tiene intro, arranca con una estrofa o "parte A". Gilmour toca los solos de guitarra y algunos pasajes.
O cabelo do Paul está igual ao do Moe dos 3 Patetas...
jajaja muito legal
George Martin I presume.
Of course
Henry Stanley with David Livingston
Never seen this bass in Macca's hands before. Some JB / PB derivative, so many of them around.
Anyone?
With the 5th Beatle George Martin
...y que tal si llamamos a David Gilmour?
Even the great ones can have a bad hair day.
That is envy, man. They both looked great.
Delay the Amp. And piano george it was great.
I want what he’s had ;-)
He's not from this planet... G. Martin as well.
That haircut, though
My love for Paul is infinite & never-ending, but my God he so desperately needed the quality control that he lost when John, George and Ringo weren't around.
bullshit
stop with the silly debates and arguments- much of music is based on chemistry, which can't be created or even defined, only found. Yes, Martin never did anything approaching the beatles greatness when not working with them. and none of them did anything approaching the greatness of what they created with his help. it is what it is. it's not one or the other. No different than Jagger and Richards or Elton and Bernie. Something happens when the right people are together.
no i know the first line "I can wait another day"
Without George Martin the Beatles would have sounded so different
The Beatles would be still stuck in the phil Spector era type music
Great song.
Terrible film
👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍✌️😬😬✌️
Se parece a Paul Mccartney pero no creo que sea Paul Mccartney
👏👏👏🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷
I would love John to walk in with a tray of tea and biccies....Tea anyone?
Yeah... Paul died in '66. Anyone who believes this urban legend is on drugs or a fool. It's easy to find a physical likeness. But, one with the same talent, genius and voice? In your dreams
And play left handed, like Paul? How could anybody believe the greatest songwriter of the 20 century could be replaced? It is beyond absurd!
You can change a face with plastic surgery if you wanna go that route what you CAN'T change are your fingerprints. Your DNA and bloodtype..the PID thing ...the one thing it did do for the Beatles was make them massively rich by people buying more records looking for clues and playing them backwards..nice marketing ploy...pretend to be dead
It was a good song but it was too long towards the end
If he had tried harder and studied for his grade 8 in piano he could have achieved some big things...😉
Well, anyone can SEE he's not playing what we are hearing 🙄🙄
Great effect fo sho
Ya vi cómo compuso Get back. Nada me impresiona. Xp
Ufff!! Era más interesante la Armonía que sugirió el genial George Martin. Vanguardista, impresionista. Pero McCartney lo endulza con su armonía tradicional y con un sentido más comercial. Aunque me gusta la música de McCartney después de vídeos como éste me queda la intriga de qué hubiera sido si McCartney hubiese aceptado sugerencias tan geniales. Creo que él pudo aprender más y trascender musicalmente pero se quedó encasillado en hacer baladas.
Trascender dices? 🤣 Maaaaas??? Jajajaja 🤣😂🤦♂️
A canção Yesterday devia ser atribuída a McCartney/Martin e não Lennon/McCartney. O quarteto de cordas composto por George Martin eleva a canção para um nível. estratosférico. (Desculpa responder em Português)
Trascender más sería ser popular en otro planeta. En este imposible.
La coupe de paul
If Paul and John were together writing the song there would be a ton of disagreements between both of them
That's not an intro??? No more lonely nights are singing straight from beginning.