Fiery Exchange between Karen Read Defense, Witness Erupts in Murder Trial
Вставка
- Опубліковано 27 вер 2024
- Digital forensics analyst Nicholas Guarino was back on the stand Thursday morning breaking down evidence in the boyfriend cop murder trial. Under cross examination, Karen Read’s defense attorney and Guarino exchanged several fiery comments while discussing cell phone data. At one point, the judge had to ask both the attorney and witness to pause and not to speak over each other.
Subscribe to Law&Crime Trials for More Courtroom Coverage: bit.ly/LawAndC...
Watch More Karen Read Trial Clips: bit.ly/KarenRe...
Karen Read faces several charges including second-degree murder, manslaughter while operating under the influence of alcohol, and leaving the scene of personal injury and death. She was arrested in February of 2022, a few days after John O’Keefe died. If convicted, Read faces life in prison.
#KarenRead #MurderTrial #LawAndCrime
STAY UP-TO-DATE WITH THE LAW&CRIME NETWORK:
Watch Law&Crime Network on UA-camTV: bit.ly/3td2e3y
Where To Watch Law&Crime Network: bit.ly/3akxLK5
Sign Up For Law&Crime's Daily Newsletter: bit.ly/LawandC...
Read Fascinating Articles From Law&Crime Network: bit.ly/3td2Iqo
For Licensing Inquiries, Please Contact: licensing@lawandcrime.com
LAW&CRIME NETWORK SOCIAL MEDIA:
Instagram: / lawandcrime
Twitter: / lawcrimenetwork
Facebook: / lawandcrime
Twitch: / lawandcrimenetwork
TikTok: / lawandcrime
LAW&CRIME NETWORK PODCASTS: lawandcrime.co...
SUBSCRIBE TO ALL OF LAW&CRIME NETWORK UA-cam CHANNELS:
Main Channel: / @lawandcrime
Law&Crime Shorts: / @lawandcrimeshorts
Channel B: / @lawandcrimetrials
Channel C: / @lawandcrimebodycam
Watch More Karen Read Trial Clips: bit.ly/KarenReadTrial
This whole department needs to be investigated
@@Tmiscia DIDN'T YOU HEAR THE LAWYER AT PRETRIAL HEARING BRIAN ALBERT COLIN AlBERT HIGGINS AND PROCTOR ARE NOT UNDER FEDERAL INVESTIGATION
@@Tmiscia THEY ARE MAKING A LIST
Starting with the judge!
If I was a juror, I would have a big problem with the demeanor of the witness. Does he think it’s impressive to be such a jerk?
To be fair, a witness on cross examination is a hostile witness. Nor do you answer with any additional information than what is asked for. That is why the defense has to peel back the information the witnesses don't provide. This also allows for the witnesses to trip over themselves or testimony by other witnesses.
@@everybuddy5924you can’t have a hostile witness on cross. That’s only on direct.
@@everybuddy5924 That is not the definition of a hostile witness
@@Remmysage Correct
But you are not... as such nobody cares what you think. I'm sure you are used to that by now.
It’s highly concerning that this man is a public servant, a person sworn to protect and serve. He doesn’t seem like he’s very interested in justice- he actively seems like he’s avoiding the truth. He seems arrogant, shady, and callous. Those are the worst possible characteristics for a public servant.
scary!
Agree 100%. How does he still have a job? Stunning.
@@MarieAntoinetteandherlittlesis READ THE ARTICLE FROM THE STATE POLICE UNION THE DA KNOWS CREATORS AND SUBSCRIBERS ARE PAID BY YANNETI AND JACKSON TO PROMOTE PROGANDA CHECK MASS LAW THIS IS A CRIME SHARE ON YANNETI AND JACKSON
This is what happens when protecting one another in the department/wearing the badges/the thin blue line is more important than the fundamentals of our Constitutional Republic and justice system...the rule of law and judicial procedure. LE is NOT supposed to determine what evidence is important to the defense. This is why Alec Baldwin's case was dismissed with prejudice and why KR's case should have been dismissed w prejudice for precisely the same reasons. Misconduct by LE and therefore by the prosecution.
@@rightsarentwrong DIDN'T YOU HEAR THE LAWYER AT PRETRIAL HEARING STATE BRIAN ALBERT COLIN AlBERT HIGGINS AND PROCTOR ARE NOT UNDER FEDERAL INVESTIGATION
His smirking and lying and laughing and contradicting is Reprehensible!
How do you know it was you where he was
@@janpararas2266?
He is laughing at that clown Yanetti
@@GailRichards-l3sCop thinks he’s a lawyer not
@@GailRichards-l3snope. no cop the clown
To call that guy an "Expect Witness" is truly an insult to "Expect Witnesses."
Expert witness - seems entirely inaccurate
He wears a suit though!! That doesn’t make him an expert? He knows more than engineers for Apple products too!!
This trial is outrageous. The prosecutor said in his opening statement that Karen hit John at 12:45 and we learn today that she got back to John's house at 12:36! The jury has to be furious at this waste of their time.
Stop making things up as you go. You sound like yanetti.
Yeah that did happen today.
@@stevenprice6957 are you saying that Lally didn't say that in his opening statement? If so, I suggest you review it. Trooper Paul also stated she hit him at 12:45. If you aren't aware of these facts, then you haven't watched every moment of this trial.
Making what up? That’s what was said.
nobbee Please play closer attention or withhold comments
EDIT My apologies for my "pay attention" comment. It may be ME that needs to take that advice.
I like how the defense got him to say he's not sure if the Canton PD was the scene of a crime. That leaves open the door that Proctor committed obstruction of justice by removing taillight pieces to take back to the crime scene, which also would violate Karen Read's civil liberties. The cop is right - maybe it really was the scene of a crime!
That’s what high powered lawyers do. If you tell them you don’t know what you are that morning they will make the jury believe that’s because you are on a hunger strike. They would make innocent people look guilty to a jury. After all, that is their job.
These officers are smart wonder what trail you watching a lot of dirty defense and killer K R with their lies maybe they are too bright for some watching !
@@cookieramlall9178 the cops are smart? But they’re also obviously too sloppy to get away with it.
These cops throughout this trial are an embarrassment.
As is the judge.
Absolutely 100%!!!
They're also dangerous.
Is the the character we want police to possess?
@Cherokee51774 the police unions have got more and more powerful over the years, and police accountability is virtually non-existent, which all leads to more crappy and aggressive cops on the streets. I think that's why the police don't garner as much respect from people as they use to. All the UA-cam videos of them acting like tyrants doesn't help much either. 🤷♂️
yeah but not when they're butt-humping each other in public places.
I have no idea why he was laughing. This is about a police officer that was murdered 😮
It’s okay for KR to be smirking though is it?
Whataboutism
@@lynseydavies6785Karen's cold eyes, her anorexia is kinda gross
@@jamie.777 Have you been listening? She has a medical condition. Go back and listen. Hopefully you will at some time develop empathy.
@@jamie.777Anorexia and eating disorders are not a joke. You’re sick to let your feelings re a case allow you to demonise serious illness. Shows you care more re bullying and taunting than justice.
This guy is hostile, avoiding, playing word games, laughing inappropriately and I can’t take him serious. 🤡
Hopefully, the jury takes notice. I sure noticed.
Crazy despicable actually
Very Disrespectful like most all of the Prosecution witnesses have been ! And I noticed and I have no ties to either family or defendant!! Very Hostile argumenative this crew is!
His bothered as his education and experience was put in doubt by defense!!!
exactly he’s laughing at a trial for a police officer killed by THEM!! what’s so funny??
Everyone involved, with the Prosecution of this case, should be ashamed of themselves.
I agree the prosecution should be ashamed but to be ashamed u must have a conscience
Your bias is shameful. 🙄
Absolutely disrespectful to officer John O’Keefe ! This officer should be ashamed of himself.
Ashamed of himself …for what?? You people are ridiculous!
This sad excuse of an officer is laughing on the stand?? If they truly believe Karen is guilty? They shouldn’t be being so disrespectful as to prove what POS they all r and instead doing their best to being justice to their fellow officer and peer. Karen Reed is innocent.
@CK61721 WHILE I believe Ms. Read has been set up and is a victim in all this I also believe that her dead boyfriend and her were a part of this crowd/circle of friends and are not exactly stellar humans themselves.
Can't wait to hear the not guilty verdict.
@@leanneharrington8669wow what an arrogant attitude he has..
This guy just confirmed that they locked on to Karen Read BEFORE all the information was known. They also bought time for everyone to get their stories straight and ignored any other possible suspect.
Cmon bro we all know she did it.
It was obvious to them because all the evidence, her actions, and her very own confession told them she did it. I Why would they look anywhere else?
She didn’t want to take responsibility for what she had done and decided to stick it to the people who had been in the house, and Chloe, their pet dog. You go Karen!
Why didn't they search the house of the property he was found on?
@@barbaramay1866Where is the evidence? Which of Karen’s “actions” prove she ran over John? You’re clearly just biased and incapable of comprehending evidence.
@@barbaramay1866Canton Amnesia. We must be watching and hearing different things
The sad fact is unless the feds get involved there will no repercussions in anyway because of this trial.
Majority will get a slap of the hand and all forgotten in time.
That’s been the scenario the past 30-40+ years.
Ppl of MA need to speak up.
I think they have because of the grand jury. The defense has some great unbiased witnesses lined up if the judge allows them in
@@SarinaSazi I think this is the judge's last trial. I see her retiring .
Feds are investigating
How do you not even bother to investigate inside the house
flock together like a feather, cops covering for cops, had they looked inside it would have made it more difficult to cover up
I do find it “surprising” that Brian Albert rehomed Chloe, had the basement redone, and sold it for $50K undervalued. Something happened in the basement…
@scoutsquad59 exactly because if they did go inside, they would have all the answers for the questions in court
@samiam1509 yes all of those actions they made makes it look suspect, even just the house they have lived there in multiple generations and then you suddenly sell it, and having the basement re done to is just wild
because it’s an inside job.
Another arrogant cop!
Brutal!
ARROGANT LAWYER
Excellent defense Lawyers!
Not perfect enough for you. I’m guessing you believe Karen isn’t arrogant. If you say she isn’t, then you are kidding yourself.
@@stevenprice6957and…relevance? I don’t care if she’s arrogant or not - the CW must show that they conducted an entirely unbiased and thorough investigation that identifies and establishes “whodunnit” beyond a reasonable doubt. Arrogant and evasive cops, and the absolute scumbag Procter, should have been fired years ago.
“I only looked at Karen’s phone.” No need to look at the others because they’re part of my team 👮
A little slip. Canton PD is def a crime scene! 😮
And an open sewer as well
Most def was
The way these witnesses are so hostile is just ridiculous! All it’s doing is making them look incredibly bad in the eyes of the jury. If I were a juror I would be absolutely flabbergasted.
The defense are equally hostile.
@@mizteek5024the defence are furious at the blatant misconduct and miscarriages of justice against their client. I knew nothing about this case before the trial started and have been following it day by day watching testimony like the jury and it’s making me mad and sick at the way the CW, the witnesses, Canton PD and especially Proctor have behaved in this. The victim & his family deserved better than this mess and I can’t wait to find out the outcome of the FBIs investigation etc.
@@mizteek5024they have a RIGHT to be hostile. like they are trying to charge someone with murder who is being framed!
@@laurenmontine You weren't there so you don't know what happened. Your assumptions do not make facts.
Emotional intelligence zero.
Like most cops.
This witness is a liar
Haha. All liars but Karen and her team right ? Yeah ok🙄🙄😂😂😂
@@stevenprice6957 onl;y scumbags like you would defend the Nazi police force that had the gall to think they could get away with murder
@@stevenprice6957Is this Al Albert?
@@stevenprice6957 he contradicted himself in a massive way. "i don't recall if all data points were included in what was dropped off on DAs server" and then "this data report extraction is not inclusive of all potential data included in this evidence" i would say that is lying.
@@stevenprice6957Karen is the biggest out of all of them! Haha!!
Not only was he smiling but he was HUMMING 😭
Says the emoji using loser...
I thought it was OK to laugh and smile Karen does it all the time doesn't she this whole thing is a dn joke to bad for John and his family it's clear they won't get justice
@@Look_What_You_Didsounds like you’re just a lame 🤷🏽♀️😂
What do you expect? This is “kill me” cop witness.
@@Look_What_You_Did🤡
Once again Bev makes snarky "let's speed things up" only with the defense. It's like she wants the jury to think it's the defense making this trial drag on. She never tells the CW to "speed things up" I'm SO sick of her biasness.
Exactly! But Bev has no problem with Lalli dragging this shitshow out. His questioning of witnesses is so repetitive and drawn out. The jurors have to check out 5 mins after he starts yapping🤦🏻♀️
@fabnforgotten6061 and maybe if she took less beach days the trial would be over by now
@@fabnforgotten6061 I also wonder a little if Lally is being so boring on purpose to make the jury tired/bored etc
@@TanyaQueen182 Idk. I think it might just be his vibe...boring😉 He's been so quiet & hard to hear this whole trial. Then today when he started on cross, he's no longer quiet and it's like he just found his voice box...very loud. Not once did Bev have to tell him to keep his voice up. Like why now Lalli after 29 days of trial🤦🏻♀️
Auntie Bev. This says it all. She belongs behind bars as well.
I’ve never heard such BS that iPhones now record on the health app that you walk when you don’t walk? If you move the phone it records that your walking what a load of complete BullShi€
These police officers don't even care about JO disgusting x10
No they don't. Don't even refer to him a officer o Keefe. Disgusting.
And you know that how?
This is the same guy who said “kill me” into the mic on Monday
No that was trpr paul
@@mandeemckenzie537nope it was this guy bc he had to read the texts
I actually believe it was lally because the video slowed down and zoomed in at the highest quality setting it doesn't look like he said it but it had to be him or lally so either way....
Wish someone would tho 😅 he is a smug pos
@@mandeemckenzie537no, it was this guy.
Imagine what would’ve happened if Karen Read didn’t have the money to hire this defense team? This has probably cost her into the hundreds of thousands. Imagine how many people this HAS happened to.
Either way she will be indigent once all this is over. Civil and criminal
This poor lady is innocent and everyone knows it.
That’s as ridiculous as bugs bunny is your president.
@@stevenprice6957I would take Bugs Bunny in a heartbeat over Biden! 😂😂
@@Johnnyjonas274lol
Bugs Bunny would be a much better President!!!
Yeah I’m Australian so know little about Biden. All I do know is it seems you always have crazy presidents 😂
I really hope these cops are held accountable and Karen Read is acquitted this is insane
What a disgrace. She’s innocent. These cops killed their “buddy“ and then tried to frame her to cover it up
She was drunk and angry she killed him in a blind rage (bunnyboiler) couldn't take being dumped and she killed him...imo
WHERES'S THE PROOF THAT SHE WAS SET UP??????????????????????
You people who love to cry, "cover up" for everything have no idea how impossible it would be to arrange. Too many people would have to be involved and be willing to put their lives on the line - the police force, forensic experts, etc... Very difficult (impossible) for this many people and/or their families to keep quiet - somebody always talks.
This person has been listening to police officers, FBI agents, Prosecutors, DA's, DEA agents and they are all saying the same thing. This case stinks, it's a joke and the feds will show you that what the prosecution is arguing is not possible. I've never seen more reasonable doubt in my life.
Exactly this happened at another officer’s house and he didn’t even come out to see what was going on with police cars and emergency vehicles give me a break and then someone who was in the house googles how long does it take for someone to freeze to death. He was attacked by an animal and the dog that was in he house was gotten rid of! right…. Please don’t tell me this is not a cover-up. We know how many people this would take to cover this up… all of them that were involved hello
These hinky prosecution witnesses have done nothing but build loads of reasonable doubt.
Because they’re hiding something
They seem to not be making their points
because they are LYING.
This judge is a clown!!! She’s in on it isn’t she??
With this whole trial, honestly I feel so so bad for The O’Keefe family- they lost a sister/daughter/mom and then son/brother/uncle. Having to sit through this trial must be so hard for them. 😢
Don’t feel too bad as they are w the prosecution.DA n Mc alberts. They don’t want to know the truth but want to cont blaming Karen . Look Paul hasn’t stopped scowling n glaring at Karen when he should have given the death glare to Procter. As for Peggy she wants Karen to be guilty as she believes the meatloaf Morrisey and all these fool of an expert it seems like the defense is trying to bring the truth out. N they shoukd be supporting them Fools n like Sean n TB I not feel anything for them anymore
Do the O’Keefe’s family work? Paul and his wife. They are always in the courtroom
@@samiam1509Are you seriously trying to say they shouldn't be at their loved ones trial. Makes zero difference if they work or not, they have every right to be in court daily to see that JO gets justice.
@@samiam1509 Maybe their job gave them paid leave/family leave, in order to be there for their brother’s trial? Idk 🤷🏻♀️ Paul lost both of his siblings, I can’t imagine 😔
Another Trooper that’s ego is to big for his big rubber boots
Every one of the McAlbertards needs to be brought up on conspiracy charges here.
If this isn't a hostile witness, then one doesn't exist.
what a hoax is this trooper ,again epic incompetent
Jackson , Read n Okeefe family must be fuming at this guys arrogamce
This is a trial about a murder, and someone possibly going to prison for life so regardless of reasons, I dont think its proper for this guy to be laughing about anything while testifying!
You're one of those typical ameritards....
but it's OK for KR to be laughing and joking w/attnys ???
@@barbaradodge1442 KR is not a professional called to the stand by the State as a witness, swearing to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth
Actually KR has a right to Laugh, cry, stare or whatever…. She’s paid for this trial.
The ppl of MA is paying this guy 140,000+ according to Boston Herald.
Earning 140,000+ to play around and misconducts for many years of corruption.
He’s classless and unprofessional.
Mistrial!!!!!
This man’s class act should be lying 🤥 because how did Jen not search for Hos long to die in the cold at 2:27 am. It all doesn’t make sense.
That has been explained though testimony of TWO expert witnesses. That search at 2:30 am did not happen. It happened at Karen’s request at the 6:30 a.m. time. Period.
@@barbaramay1866 Two experts... Like trooper Paul? He has to be getting calls from attorneys around the country wanting his services.
@@barbaramay1866it happened by Jen at 227 nice try
@@barbaramay1866when has it been proven that KR requested JM to search for it, ever??? Keep in mind the word “PROVEN!”
@B_Bodziak LMAO! I’m sure he’s screening his calls on all the request !!😂
This guy and the troopers before him are pathetic. They should not be in any position of power ever.
This clown was so focused on playing to the jury, he looked at the jury and answered " yes, sir "
Web of deceit and lies
Why are these policeman so hostile. Only someone with something to hide answer questions the way they do.
This is the same cop who ran cover for the Birchmore case and cops. Cleaning phone records.
Granny Bevy once at her best, protecting the prosecution side@
Are all canton cops a holes like this guy!?
Not all, but the ones involved in this case seem to be.
Why don't you ask them instead of asking a bunch of keyboard warriors on a UA-cam platform who don't know any of them from a hole in the wall.
@mizteek5024 maybe because most people wouldn't trust what they say anyway based on this case
@@johannawigg6921 So why bother asking people on here who have even less of a clue.
@mizteek5024 it's ta UA-cam comment section what do you want a dissertation?
Another one who should be charged with PERJURY. I have stopped counting all the lies.
There's no way the jury is going to convict.
I hope you’re right!!
Are you a mind reader? 🙄
@@mizteek5024You’re probably family to one of these pricks
I have suspicions about Colin and cops covering it up for a cops son.
Colin left the house at 12:10 confirmed by texts by his phone and pickup driver. His father is not a cop
Proctor and his cronies are the people you avoid at all costs, not one of them has any redeemable qualities. All about the brotherhood, who is going to worry about this woman and those two kids?! Truly disturbing.
Bouncing in his chair and grinning
LOL😅 Dude,
You can't be Robert Dinero.
The world already has one. LOL😅
What?
Excellent combative cross examination showing this guy to be in on the fix. Feel sorry for the decent people of Canton. Their cops are crooked.
It must be a frustrating and helpless feeling to know that in a time where you may need PD assistance, these are the guys who will show up.
Wait until he testifies about the data extraction in the Sandra Birchmore case
Sustain Aunt Bev not asking him “what’s so funny”.?
This is a HUGE cover up by the cops.
These police clearly think they’re above the law.
The angry then alarmed voicemails and his confirmation Read was back at John O’Keefe’s house by the latest 12.36 prove her innocence. (The drive was in a blizzard too.)
True!
Only a few miles away, no cars on the road. Library video shows her car
I’ve noticed a common personality trait between all these LEO.. excuse me policy enforcers (they haven’t enforced the law they broke the law) is they all have zero self awareness.
He keeps looking at the jury when answering the question, Amber Heard had that same tactic.
It’s proper
Way to much reasonable doubt
Exactly. Commenters are arguing over who really did it when all that is needed is reasonable doubt for this particular case.
This guy is a disgrace to MSP
Why didn’t the judge admonish him for being so disrespectful?
He is looking at the jury when he answers, just like Amber Heard did when she was on the stand 🤭
Doopers approval
That’s what he’s looking for
Shameful witness.
@3:00 this witness just admitted that there "might" be a crime at Canton PD.....>>> Did someone commit a crime at the PD that you are aware of because evidence was TAMPERED with !!! Only the crime scene investigator should authorize movement of evidence !!!
This guy “ missed, couldn’t extract “ 32,000 messages from arrested police officers phone in another murder case.
This was the most fiery exchange ever in history.....
On scene does not mean that crime scene? Really? You want to testify to that?
Big ego here, this cop acted like an arrogant child.
Why are all state's witnesses so defensive?
Why indeed. Only people who have something to hide act this way. It’s quite different from the defenses witnesses today, who are open and willing to share whatever they know.
What a tool !
Ha was just thinking that! 😂
I thought the same about the defense attorney.
The Canton police department was actually the scene of many crimes.
A liar like all the rest
He was a better prosecution witness than Proctor.
Got so sick of the objecting and sustaining in this case. And this witness was evasive and argumentative. The judge did not address witnesses arguing with the defense, very odd.
Someone's son is dead and this clown cop is laughing like it's a joke.
This witness has a major attitude problem. Embarrassing.
Some people cope with stress/anxiety by "laughing" or "smiling". We all have our ways to manage high pressure situations. He isn't laughing hysterically or constantly meaning that he obviously doesn't find anything funny and is just coping. Read any psychology book
Absolutely you are correct.
A cop/trooper should be able to handle pressure. He’s not some lay witness.
This cop is smug and arrogant. Not "hysterical" or nervous. He's experienced and he's expressing his contempt for the defence. He reminds me of Mark Fuhrman of OJ fame.
@@RemmysageHe clearly is managing with the pressure.. Like i said he has his own coping mechanism (like we all do).
@@TheHypnotstCollectorHe's being polite and not argumentative at all. I think you mistake having confidence for being arrogant. Also why would any state witness not have contempt for the defense? They are trying to discredit you.
If this guy lived anywhere but Canton, MA he’d be out of work & sleeping on a park bench
Turn everything over to the FBI….
Ask it differently ? Sounds like judge in this trial , was playing defense to all witnesses . 😢
That's a scary police force of snarky arrogant entitled men. I could absolutely see them colluding and conspiring.
I love how this witness laughs at the defense lawyer. He is laughable the way he questions people like he is Perry Mason 😂😂😂😂
Did all the prosecutors witnesses go to the same school of let’s make this the most difficult in answering questions from the defense???? Ugh
He doesn’t deserve a tax funded job and pension.
It is crazy that he gets admonished for embellishing his answers with comments while every single prosecution witness did far more commentary during their cross examination testimony. What a joke of a trial.
This witness lied, there was no elevation on another street , turtle boy went there and tested it that street is flat..
Auntie Bev did not ask him “ is this funny to you officer?”😮😂
Witness has amnesia
he neefs to b jailed too
@AussieInsider - This trooper was REALLY thirsty during this cross-examination. I think I counted 3 or 4 different times in this nine minute clip that he got REALLY thirsty!! 😂
His face from the get go, body language says it all. He’s embarrassed because he’s LYING
Bev, always makes the defense speed it along, but never boring Lally with his how if and what if? Karen Read is 💯innocent of these charges! He was killed inside 34 Fairview Road, Brian Albert’s house!
So why write the report if he DOESN'T KNOW ANYTHING ABOUT THE REPORT. don't you need to have the facts before writing the paper. This is a circus, I really started to believe this is a cover up.
This cop didn’t fully read his own reports before taking the witness stand? I don’t know & I don’t remember = lying!!!
I swear Bev has a wig on. Anybody else? Also Chris Alberts wife.