Great reaction guys . . . Many more from them to react to . Dust to dust . . . Survive . . . Nacisista . Even a ballad like . Boy . . . . Tickets for the toronto gig last week were 37.50 canadian . .
Ash you have a very deep rabbit hole to go down. They have been writing for nine years and they have almost 50 originals (all bangers), 2 EP's, 3 albums, 1 is a concept album, and they have a newish single with a couple more to come. They also have enough for a new album. They are currently touring while opening Guns and roses in north America. They are then heading to south America. Ale the bassist is still a teenager (18). They are all sisters and have been supported by their family from the start and their parents still tourer with them.
That’s so much fun watching someone discover TW for the first time. They are “proper” everything. High level of musicianship, deep and meaningful lyrics and amazing song composition that can’t really be pigeon-holed into a single genre. Great contrast between early TW and current TW. Little Ale grew into a stunning young woman that absolutely lays down thunderous bass lines. Pau is even better as a complete drummer who’s theatrics are as impressive as her technical skill and her outstanding lead and backing vocals. Dany is the consummate front person for a band keeping the crowd involved and she is an incredible vocalist and plays the most beautiful melodic solos. So much more to discover and anything from this show is top notch.
I'm a 66 yo rocker here... I've been watching 100's of TW reactions since I came across the band three months ago, and the two of you provided my favorite reaction to date!! Thanks, keep smiling and rockin' out!! 🎉😊❤😂
Love these ladies. I'm from the same part of the world as you, I think, North West England, and I drove down to that there London to see The Warning at the UK private show in May at Bush Hall. All I can say is, what a privilege to see these young ladies so up close and witness their talent and personality. I cannot wait until they are back here in the UK for a full headlining tour.
Well that was delightful. Thanks, Ash! Suggestion: "Dust to Dust" from the same concert. Pau sings lead *the entire song* while hammering that kit. But you cannot go wrong with any of their live performances or music videos.
Head to Mexico this October! on the 28th, they'll be putting on a show, at the Pepsi Arena, in Mexico City, which is, more than likely, going to blow this one away. Just do it! Take that once in a lifetime trip, and see a once in a lifetime concert. Many of The Warning's fans have flown from the UK, and all over Europe, to Mexico and/or the US, to see them. I flew from Connecticut to California, to see The Warning for the first time. The whole trip only cost $1000. USD; that included lodging for two nights, food, merch, concert ticket, everything. It was the the coolest, most radical thing I've ever done, and I do not regret it one bit. My channel icon is me with The Warning, on that California trip. I have now seen The Warning six times, and I can tell you, with all sincerity, all the other concerts I've been to, and there have bee a lot, as I'm 54 years old, simply pale in comparison. There is nothing quite like being in the same room with The Warning doing their thing.
Great reaction!! I discovered TW during the pandemic in 2020 when they did a live concert from their basement, which btw they call it “The Cave” and like you, I fell in love with them. Great band and very down to earth.
This song is about how social media controls us with fabricated info. Pau, the drummer, got inspired about the main riff in a Canadian supermarket in 2019. She came home, composed the song on her piano including the bass intro and called her sisters. They were 19, 17 & 14 then. That is why Dany, guitarist, starts the song as an antagonist with "The sun is YOUR enemy today" while Pau picks it up as a disciple in the 2nd verse with "The sun is MY enemy today". The sisters trade off lead vocals as demanded by the script. You can make out the difference in their vocal textures. Ale, the bassist, mainly harmonizes in the lower frequencies with infrequent falsettos as required by the song. The Warning are masters in composing in minor scales. Quite often they introduce a full sequence of major chords for the same verse to break the monotony. And that downward bend in vocals here is typically The Warning with this progression G Bb E A G#m . I mean G & G#m in the same sequence - are you kidding me?
The real story as told by Pau on video on either IG live or twitch live shortly after the song came out, was she had an idea for this song told Dany about it while on their vacation in western Canada, then when they got back home they worked on it together (the 3 of them), as they do with most of their songs Fans still don't get it. Pau has to sell her idea for a song to her sisters and they have to approve of the idea. They then work on the song together lyrics/arrangement/all instruments.. that's the working model for most of their songs. How far along the idea for a song differs from song to song but once the 3 of them dig into it takes on a new life, sometimes it may remain close to the original idea and sometimes it goes in a different direction.
@@awadoma2702 Thanks for your input. The Canadian supermarket part was from Dany's vlog which was ratified by all 3 girls in an interview later on with a Mexican host. And in Pau's masterclass in Soundcheck Xpo, 2022 she specifically talked about creating the bass intro for Disciple & composed the main structure before presenting to her sisters. While we all love to think that an artistic effort can be a joint collab the truth is the first idea comes from someone's brain. And that person is treated as gold in any creative industry because of his / her ability to create a concept. Polishing a concept into a finished product is the next step which can be done by others. BTW fans are aware of how The Warning creative process works - courtesy numerous interviews & documentaries. In fact Pau has to compose the basic pitch keeping in mind who will be singing which part. 😀
@@MrSudeepdas Yes longtime fans know how the creative process works but new fans don't and they pick up info from detailed posts like the one you just did here where you gave all the credit to Pau for writing the song by such words as "Pau wrote" and from that a new fan will believe that Pau wrote the song by herself with very little input from Dany and Ale. The way you put it she came up with the idea on vacation then went home and worked on it them after mostly finished presented it to her sisters.... the truth is she had an idea presented it to Dany while on vacation then when they got back home they at some point worked on the idea together and apart as per all other songs. You took the story they told everyone and instead of repeating as they told it you revised for whatever reason. They keep telling fans that that they each have ideas for songs then ideas get approved and then they work on them together, Pau is the most creative of the 3 and more of her ideas end up approved but each song is a product of the 3 of them working together. the only problem is there are too many fans that like to use "Pau wrote" when in fact it should be "they wrote" Fans also have no idea how much each contribute to a song because in most cases they do not go into a detailed play by play about how each song evolves to the finished product. Other then a handful of songs when educating new fans it should be "they wrote" not the usual "Pau wrote" because it does not matter how much each person had a hand in the creative process, if you were involved then you are part of the creative team. I'm sure sometime in the future as they get older and more experienced they will each write songs alone and at that point fans can say that person wrote it alone but for now they are a team and credit should be given to all 3 and not just to the most creative of the 3.
@@awadoma2702 Most songs are written by Pau as per Dany & Ale in numerous interviews. She is their primary songwriter - as Dany says "Pau has the creative muscle". They all work on the instrumentation part of Pau's basic song starting with the guitar & bass and ending with drum parts. If there are any changes required in lyrics they get it done by Pau because she is the main lyricist. Disciple was written by Pau. She composed a basic tune including the bass intro & then pitched it in front of Dany & Ale. She got the idea of the riff in a Canadian supermarket & immediately ran upto Dany to let her know. As I said before in any creative process the person who gets that first spark of inspiration is regarded special. Developing a concept is easier than creating something out of nothing. So saying "Pau wrote" Disciple is not a misrepresentation of facts. And its deep metaphorical lyrics are a testament to the song being her creation rather than Dany's who is more straight forward in her poetry. Goodbye and thanks for your time. 😀
While it is true Pau is the most prolific of the three, Dany and Ale do contribute with ideas and basic Melodies as well. For instance, Choke was conceived by Dany, and pitched it to both of her sisters, and then the three of them collaborated to give it form.
Great reaction! These sisters are overwhelmingly talented!! They born to be super rock stars! They are the best power trio of XXI century! Viva The Warning!! ⚡⚡⚡
Either 'Evolve' or 'Dust to Dust' (Pau the drummer does a lot of singing on this song too) Also you need to itroduce Ash to one of the bands that not only helped motivate these ladies, but also gave them a huge push: Halestorm! Lzzy Hale is a HUGE fan of this band, that she even gifted Dani one of her custom guitars when Halestorm took them on tour as an opening band a while back. And you definitely need to catch these ladies if they come across the pond!
Great reaction! Ash you have a very infectious smile and I for one couldn't stop smiling either! They have that this uncanny ability to bring out joy in every one around them, whether they be performing or just being themselves (in the many interviews, live chats, and other videos of their lives that they share with us). it's just impossible to not like them and feel happier after hearing them. Welcome to TWA (The Warning Army), and as we like to say: You Have Been Warned!
LOL, Ash's face looked kind of like mine did back in 2017 when I saw their TedX performance which finished up with 'Survive', and one of the coolest outro instrumentals I have heard since the 1980's or so. I was IN, hook, line, and sinker! There is so much more where this came from. Pick a song, any song, and you'll be good.😉 There are no bad ones in their repertoire. Some are better than others, depending on your musical tastes, but I have never seen any rock band since the late 1960's, that could write hit after hit, after hit, and never really write a bad one.😮 3 full albums, 2 EPs, and several singles later, and they're still going strong and will continue to do so, from what I can see! Please enjoy your trip down The Warning 'rabbit hole'.😄 🤘😎🤘
I think you actually have to do their live version of "Enter Sandman" from Teatro Metropolitan since you listened to their early version and watched the studio mix music video. You will absolutely go wild over the live version from this venue! Great reactions you two! 🔥🤘⚡
I think it will be very interesting to see her react to "Dust to Dust" because the lead vocal on that song is Pau. And it doesn't matter if it's the old performance from "Lunario" or the new one from "Teatro Metropólitan" both are great, just like you two, both are great. Thanks and greetings from México!! 🇲🇽 🤘😁✌️
Great reaction! And dont worry! I believe in 2024 The Warning will be close to you soon, because they have to play in the Wacken 2024 in Germany, for sure they will make a tour close to you for that date.
I'm guessing they'll be back to England next summer. They had a couple headlining shows and opened for Muse and were extremely well received. Keep a lookout after the 1st of the year. In the meantime, every song from this concert is bonkers. So incredibly good. Just follow the other suggestions here and you can't go wrong.
I would suggest the tidal rising documentary where you will see a lot of info. Truth is they are everywhere with each of them having a weekly chat with fans on "Dany day" "Pau day" and "Ale day". Their interaction with each other and those around them is the stuff role models are made of. The royals should keep these girls on speed dial and watch their interaction with fans... this is how "empires" are built to last. Nice response. David
You have to see Enter Sandman from this concert. It's better and also different as that from the girls when they were younger. In fact every song from this concert is great and best quality. But as I said, Enter Sandman is different in this version than it was years ago.
This is one of my favs live but they don't have a bad song any performance from this concert is awesome. They just dropped a bunch on their page which would be great to react to. It's so cool to watch Ashley we've all been there this is a fun rabbit hole and TWA will gladly guide you two. Great reaction cheers from Canada
Pau, the drummer, sings while doing aerobic exercises specifically to build and maintain her breath capabilities and vocal balance while being so energetic beating her drums into submission... she has been singing while drumming since pretty much the beginning of their journey... Welcome to the TW Rabbit Hole! come on in and join the rest of us! 😹 TWA ⚡🤘😸🤘⚡ TWA
Along with Nightwish, The Warning is my favorite band. Please continue!!!!! Like Nightwish, The Warning does NOT have a bad song. My favorite TW music video is XXl Century Blood(Twenty-first Century Blood). They received awards for it.
Nice Reaction! Little Ale from the Enter Sandman cover you watched is now taller than both of her sisters. This concert is from August 2022 just a few months after their 3rd album (called Error) was released. This song was from that album. If you are interested in seeing them do an Acoustic song, react to the song Revenant from the same concert. Pau sings lead on that song and they are sitting on chairs at the front of the stage. They are multi-talented!
Awesome reaction Ash and Dave and Ash get ready to smile every single time you experience The Warning DPA Goddesses. I hate to insist on you guys reacting to The Warning TEDx 2017 before you goo on with their newer stuff, believe me you be truly truly amazed. Either way my beautiful UK people I'll be here along with the rest of The Warning Army to help you in your amazing journey. By the way The Warning have a few shows here Mexico, I'm seeing them for the first time here in Guadalajara October 21st and there's still some tickets left, you pay the round trip and I'll provide my house for you to stay, as we always say. Mi casa es su casa!
Hey Dave and Ash! It's a shame you missed them while they were in the UK earlier this summer, headlining and opening for Muse. They also played Download Fest. All of these songs they have released from Teatro Metropolitan are amazing. Also take into consideration they are from Monterrey, MX (elev. 600m or 2000 feet) and they were playing in Mexico City at an elevation of 7200+ feet (2200 Meters) in the thin air. Much more difficult to sing and exert so much effort on stage.
I love Pau (the drummer), she always has insane Tigger levels of bouncy energy and beats the drums like they owe her money. They are legit as they've played with Three Days Grace, Halestorm,, Foo Fighters, Gun's N' Roses and (probably) their favourite band Muse.
Buena reacción!🤘🇲🇽🤘🇲🇽🤘🇲🇽 Viva the Warning!! (cuando no es la boca abierta por la sorpresa de escuchar y ver a las hermanas en acción, entonces es la sonrisa permanente admirándolas)
Ok I'm back. It's a great reaction. Trust me, we a lot of us had had the same reaction, deep rabbit hole. Seem them 3 times live,once in a small venue, just amazing humble ladies, great parents. Rhey are the whole package. I recommend you watch the documentary Tidal Rising at some point, amazing inspirational story, WELCOME TO TWA❤🤘
They are simply the best out there right now . . by far! They put the same incredible energy and passion in every song - every performance they do! So much fun!!
This is one of the best first reactions to The Warning I've seen. They really are shockingly good. They're not a good girl band, or even a good band. They're a GREAT ROCK BAND, period. They have "paid their dues" for over ten years, and are about to explode on the world scene in 2024. This is a PRIME example of what finding your passion at an early age does to you. It fills you with a drug rush-like surge of creative energy and commitment to do your very best. This isn't just a great band. It is a fascinating success story for the whole family. Parents, Luis and Monica, must be special people to have raised such dedicated performers. I'm in awe of all of them. They have a rather extensive team of dedicated and professional support people who make things happen. Watch out, world!
They are from Monterey Mexico. They are each other's best friends. Ale goes from the shortest to the tallest. Dany is 5'3 Pau is 5' and Ale 5'7. Ale can sing lead for a couple of songs : Red Hands Never Fade and 😂 most recently and River's Soul. In Toronto recently Ale sang two songs. Dany is 23,Pau 20 and Ale 18. They have been in London this summer opening for Muse . They opened for Muse in Mexico and Muse asked them personally to be in Londo with them. They opened for the Foo Fighters two weeks before Taylor Hawkins died.
Welcome to The Warning Army Ash. I hope you get a chance to see Dust to Dust from Lunario, Dull Knives from The Warning Cave, Evolve, Animosity, Choke, who am I kidding any Warning song is worth a listen Enjoy! ⚡⚡⚡
Maybe if you want to give Ash's cheeks a rest you can skip over "Dust to Dust" Live at Teatro Metropolitan for any other song from Teatro Metropolitan for her third exposure. But if she wants her mind blown for the 4th video I would suggest "Dust to Dust" Live at Teatro Metropolitan. If Dave has seen "Dust to Dust" at Lunario... that was 5 years ago... it is so much better now!! Ale drives "Dust to Dust". The song was built on her bassline. There are other surprises in the song as well.
Great reaction unfortunately you just missed The Warning they played a number of dates in England in May and June of this year. They are for sure worth travelling to see perform live. Thx.
it's really cool to see the couple reacting together, you and your wife are adorable I loved it, the reaction to TW was great show her the version of Enter Sandman now with them grown up this will be very good.
I'm glad your cheeks hurt Ash. You'll have the strongest cheeks in the UK because you have a lot of TW to react to. My suggestion is a song Paulina the drummer sings lead. The song is "Narcisista" released as a single in 2019 and is their first song recorded in Spanish. This is the premiere live performance of the song from the Foro Didi entertainment complex in their hometown of Monterrey, Mx. Daniela guitar 19; Paulina drums, lead vocals 17; Alejandra bass 14. ua-cam.com/video/O7IAEhN4RMM/v-deo.html
Awesome React !!! yes indeed The Warning is the "Real Deal" SEE THEM LIVE if youget a chance... It will blow your mind... I'm 60 yrs old and just saw them... as well as A Ton of people My age with their childeren and Familys to wittness these Lovely Ladies !!! There's no swearing... no slutting ... Just Pure Powerful rock music... and yeah I pretty much gave up on any of the Bands I grew up with..... The Warning is the Future of Rock..... FINALLY !!!! (that's why ya see us geezers in the audience 😂) Cheers !!! p.s. Any song from Teatro Metropolitan should be worth looking at.. Not a bad one !!
I saw them 3 times in the UK this summer and they were awesome! I saw them open for Muse in Huddersfield - great but big stadium and short set although they rocked it! I saw them at Download where they opened the day on the Opus stage and I reckon 30k turned out to see them and they went down a storm. Then they announced a final UK date (the last date of the European tour) at the O2 Islington and we got tickets. Nothing prepares you for.how good they are live. UA-cam videos no matter how good, can't prepare you for how much energy they have, how tight they are, how good they work the crowd and how LOUD they are! My ears were ringing for days! I drove from 11:00 Sheffield and back.on the night to see them and they were awesome. You have to see them. They are playing Wacken OA next summer so.theyll be in Europe so there's a good chance they'll make the UK again I hope. They are a must-see if they do. Great reaction by the way!!
Woooow great reaction. Thanks for that love it ❤.. I recommend to react to dust to dust for the same concert or dulll knives from the warning cave live version.ROCK ON VIVA THE WARNING💥🤟💯
I think you just missed them. They just finished playing in the UK/Europe last month. The videos from this show are amazing quality. Evolve, Error, Choke, WHen I'm Alone, etc.
Yeah, the three of them put out hella noise. Hey rock world, the future is female, embrace it. I think these three sisters are helping to lead the way. I love it. I second the suggestion of the TedX talk from 2017. There is good stuff in there. Then add anything from the Teatro concert. It was so well recorded and filmed.
Great reaction, This really shows you what can happen in a 10 or 11 year span. I am A71 year old hippie freak more freak than a hippie, But I thought rock and roll was dead I would have to listen to reruns from back in the 60s and 70s and part of the 80s. But who would have known that 3 beautiful sisters from Monterey Mexico would bring back real rock and their own original. You cannot pigeonhole their type of music because you never know what you're gonna get But you do know it's gonna be great, Because all 3 are great musicians and love playing music. I don't know if I said it are already or not but welcome to the rabbit hole you are going to love this ride and love of music You have been warned ⚡️⚡️⚡️⚘️⚘️⚘️
Great reaction again, looks like Ash has already fallen into that rabbit hole! I would say either do a double of 2021 Enter Sandman with Alessia Cara and the same song at Teatro Metropolitan CDMX for the studio / live comparison or Marterio for a Spanish song! Didn’t realise that you’re from the UK, so am I - from around Brum!
The lady is very sharp - her logical deduction that a band formed by friends will unlikely have such a young bassist hence this is a band of sisters. Elementary my dear Watson. It seems that you missed 7 performances in the UK by The Warning from end May to End June. - 4 openers for Muse at Plymouth, Huddersfield, Glasgow & Milton Keynes - a private concert at Bush Hall, London - opening day 2 of Download at 1 pm on a side stage with a packed field of about 25,000+ - headlining sold out show at O2 Islington, London
When they aren't touring they have an exercise routine that includes weights and running on the treadmill while singing. That's why Pau can drum and sing and not be tired now. When they first started they had two TED talks at the University of Nevada and Pau was breathing hard when they talked in between songs.
Think of the thousands of devices made to tone the facial muscles, over the years…. Turns out all those people needed was to listen to The Warning, daily 🤣
Stick with the Teatro live performances for now. The Warnings first MV was XXI Century Blood. Title track off their first album. It has won several awards and is captivating and eye opening. Worth a watch. My favorite two songs are Crimson Queen, and Money. Good luck.
If your intro to them was when they were children doing Enter Sandman, you need to react to how they do the song today. NOT the one with Alessia Cara, but the one from this same concert at Teatro Metropolitan. It'll BLOW your mind.
Show her the new enter sandman from the same show. These girls were born with talent
Yes
Any song from this gig is awesome . .
Both the official video and live at Teatro Metropolitan of Enter Sandman. Thsts the trifecta since you already did the one that got them noticed!
Watch them play piano when they're 6 or 7. They were not born with talent. They earned all of this through hard work. That is much more impressive.
Great reaction guys . . . Many more from them to react to . Dust to dust . . . Survive . . . Nacisista . Even a ballad like . Boy . . . . Tickets for the toronto gig last week were 37.50 canadian . .
Ash you have a very deep rabbit hole to go down. They have been writing for nine years and they have almost 50 originals (all bangers), 2 EP's, 3 albums, 1 is a concept album, and they have a newish single with a couple more to come. They also have enough for a new album. They are currently touring while opening Guns and roses in north America. They are then heading to south America. Ale the bassist is still a teenager (18). They are all sisters and have been supported by their family from the start and their parents still tourer with them.
That’s so much fun watching someone discover TW for the first time.
They are “proper” everything. High level of musicianship, deep and meaningful lyrics and amazing song composition that can’t really be pigeon-holed into a single genre.
Great contrast between early TW and current TW.
Little Ale grew into a stunning young woman that absolutely lays down thunderous bass lines.
Pau is even better as a complete drummer who’s theatrics are as impressive as her technical skill and her outstanding lead and backing vocals.
Dany is the consummate front person for a band keeping the crowd involved and she is an incredible vocalist and plays the most beautiful melodic solos.
So much more to discover and anything from this show is top notch.
I'm a 66 yo rocker here... I've been watching 100's of TW reactions since I came across the band three months ago, and the two of you provided my favorite reaction to date!! Thanks, keep smiling and rockin' out!! 🎉😊❤😂
Love these ladies.
I'm from the same part of the world as you, I think, North West England, and I drove down to that there London to see The Warning at the UK private show in May at Bush Hall. All I can say is, what a privilege to see these young ladies so up close and witness their talent and personality.
I cannot wait until they are back here in the UK for a full headlining tour.
Pau not only sings while drumming, but she sings while playing proper drum fills.
This is a perfect follow-up song to introduce the diverse talents and amazing stage presence of The Warning.
Dust to Dust at the same venue - dang the smiling was contagious and my cheeks are sore. MORE please
These amazing young ladies were the first band to get me excited about new music in over 30 years! They are the real deal!
Well that was delightful. Thanks, Ash! Suggestion: "Dust to Dust" from the same concert. Pau sings lead *the entire song* while hammering that kit. But you cannot go wrong with any of their live performances or music videos.
Just saw them live this past week for the 11th, 12th and 13th times in the past 15 months. They are everything live
Head to Mexico this October! on the 28th, they'll be putting on a show, at the Pepsi Arena, in Mexico City, which is, more than likely, going to blow this one away. Just do it! Take that once in a lifetime trip, and see a once in a lifetime concert. Many of The Warning's fans have flown from the UK, and all over Europe, to Mexico and/or the US, to see them. I flew from Connecticut to California, to see The Warning for the first time. The whole trip only cost $1000. USD; that included lodging for two nights, food, merch, concert ticket, everything. It was the the coolest, most radical thing I've ever done, and I do not regret it one bit. My channel icon is me with The Warning, on that California trip.
I have now seen The Warning six times, and I can tell you, with all sincerity, all the other concerts I've been to, and there have bee a lot, as I'm 54 years old, simply pale in comparison. There is nothing quite like being in the same room with The Warning doing their thing.
It's my understanding that Paulina practices singing while running on the treadmill! She is, as are all the girls, absolutely incredible!!
Live is where they shine the most. All the performances at Teatro at fantastic and you can't go wrong with any of the songs.
Love watching her fall in love with The Warning (and your Jinjer reactions) so cool seeing this! Awesome as always!
Great reaction!! I discovered TW during the pandemic in 2020 when they did a live concert from their basement, which btw they call it “The Cave” and like you, I fell in love with them. Great band and very down to earth.
Great reaction from both of you, 🤘rock on, friends 🤘
Great reaction guys! Love your chemestry together, and love The Warning ❤❤❤
Loving these reactions. Looking forward to the next one. 🤘😎❤️⚠️
This song is about how social media controls us with fabricated info. Pau, the drummer, got inspired about the main riff in a Canadian supermarket in 2019. She came home, composed the song on her piano including the bass intro and called her sisters. They were 19, 17 & 14 then.
That is why Dany, guitarist, starts the song as an antagonist with "The sun is YOUR enemy today" while Pau picks it up as a disciple in the 2nd verse with "The sun is MY enemy today". The sisters trade off lead vocals as demanded by the script. You can make out the difference in their vocal textures. Ale, the bassist, mainly harmonizes in the lower frequencies with infrequent falsettos as required by the song.
The Warning are masters in composing in minor scales. Quite often they introduce a full sequence of major chords for the same verse to break the monotony. And that downward bend in vocals here is typically The Warning with this progression G Bb E A G#m . I mean G & G#m in the same sequence - are you kidding me?
The real story as told by Pau on video on either IG live or twitch live shortly after the song came out, was she had an idea for this song told Dany about it while on their vacation in western Canada, then when they got back home they worked on it together (the 3 of them), as they do with most of their songs
Fans still don't get it. Pau has to sell her idea for a song to her sisters and they have to approve of the idea. They then work on the song together lyrics/arrangement/all instruments.. that's the working model for most of their songs.
How far along the idea for a song differs from song to song but once the 3 of them dig into it takes on a new life, sometimes it may remain close to the original idea and sometimes it goes in a different direction.
@@awadoma2702 Thanks for your input.
The Canadian supermarket part was from Dany's vlog which was ratified by all 3 girls in an interview later on with a Mexican host. And in Pau's masterclass in Soundcheck Xpo, 2022 she specifically talked about creating the bass intro for Disciple & composed the main structure before presenting to her sisters.
While we all love to think that an artistic effort can be a joint collab the truth is the first idea comes from someone's brain. And that person is treated as gold in any creative industry because of his / her ability to create a concept. Polishing a concept into a finished product is the next step which can be done by others.
BTW fans are aware of how The Warning creative process works - courtesy numerous interviews & documentaries. In fact Pau has to compose the basic pitch keeping in mind who will be singing which part. 😀
@@MrSudeepdas Yes longtime fans know how the creative process works but new fans don't and they pick up info from detailed posts like the one you just did here where you gave all the credit to Pau for writing the song by such words as "Pau wrote" and from that a new fan will believe that Pau wrote the song by herself with very little input from Dany and Ale.
The way you put it she came up with the idea on vacation then went home and worked on it them after mostly finished presented it to her sisters.... the truth is she had an idea presented it to Dany while on vacation then when they got back home they at some point worked on the idea together and apart as per all other songs.
You took the story they told everyone and instead of repeating as they told it you revised for whatever reason.
They keep telling fans that that they each have ideas for songs then ideas get approved and then they work on them together, Pau is the most creative of the 3 and more of her ideas end up approved but each song is a product of the 3 of them working together.
the only problem is there are too many fans that like to use "Pau wrote" when in fact it should be "they wrote"
Fans also have no idea how much each contribute to a song because in most cases they do not go into a detailed play by play about how each song evolves to the finished product.
Other then a handful of songs when educating new fans it should be "they wrote" not the usual "Pau wrote" because it does not matter how much each person had a hand in the creative process, if you were involved then you are part of the creative team.
I'm sure sometime in the future as they get older and more experienced they will each write songs alone and at that point fans can say that person wrote it alone but for now they are a team and credit should be given to all 3 and not just to the most creative of the 3.
@@awadoma2702 Most songs are written by Pau as per Dany & Ale in numerous interviews. She is their primary songwriter - as Dany says "Pau has the creative muscle". They all work on the instrumentation part of Pau's basic song starting with the guitar & bass and ending with drum parts. If there are any changes required in lyrics they get it done by Pau because she is the main lyricist.
Disciple was written by Pau. She composed a basic tune including the bass intro & then pitched it in front of Dany & Ale. She got the idea of the riff in a Canadian supermarket & immediately ran upto Dany to let her know.
As I said before in any creative process the person who gets that first spark of inspiration is regarded special. Developing a concept is easier than creating something out of nothing.
So saying "Pau wrote" Disciple is not a misrepresentation of facts. And its deep metaphorical lyrics are a testament to the song being her creation rather than Dany's who is more straight forward in her poetry.
Goodbye and thanks for your time. 😀
While it is true Pau is the most prolific of the three, Dany and Ale do contribute with ideas and basic Melodies as well. For instance, Choke was conceived by Dany, and pitched it to both of her sisters, and then the three of them collaborated to give it form.
Great reaction!
These sisters are overwhelmingly talented!!
They born to be super rock stars!
They are the best power trio of XXI century!
Viva The Warning!! ⚡⚡⚡
Either 'Evolve' or 'Dust to Dust' (Pau the drummer does a lot of singing on this song too)
Also you need to itroduce Ash to one of the bands that not only helped motivate these ladies, but also gave them a huge push: Halestorm! Lzzy Hale is a HUGE fan of this band, that she even gifted Dani one of her custom guitars when Halestorm took them on tour as an opening band a while back.
And you definitely need to catch these ladies if they come across the pond!
Great reaction! Ash you have a very infectious smile and I for one couldn't stop smiling either! They have that this uncanny ability to bring out joy in every one around them, whether they be performing or just being themselves (in the many interviews, live chats, and other videos of their lives that they share with us). it's just impossible to not like them and feel happier after hearing them. Welcome to TWA (The Warning Army), and as we like to say: You Have Been Warned!
Love the unbridled enthusiasm that Ash gives. So much to share. Keep it going. It’s a deep rabbit hole.
LOL, Ash's face looked kind of like mine did back in 2017 when I saw their TedX performance which finished up with 'Survive', and one of the coolest outro instrumentals I have heard since the 1980's or so. I was IN, hook, line, and sinker! There is so much more where this came from. Pick a song, any song, and you'll be good.😉 There are no bad ones in their repertoire. Some are better than others, depending on your musical tastes, but I have never seen any rock band since the late 1960's, that could write hit after hit, after hit, and never really write a bad one.😮 3 full albums, 2 EPs, and several singles later, and they're still going strong and will continue to do so, from what I can see! Please enjoy your trip down The Warning 'rabbit hole'.😄 🤘😎🤘
More of this please. Ash needs lots of Warning in her life as soon as possible. I love this band, and I love her enthusiasm for the music.
Always fun to see someone else discovering and enjoying The Warning as much as we do! Keep them coming.
I think you actually have to do their live version of "Enter Sandman" from Teatro Metropolitan since you listened to their early version and watched the studio mix music video. You will absolutely go wild over the live version from this venue! Great reactions you two! 🔥🤘⚡
I think it will be very interesting to see her react to "Dust to Dust" because the lead vocal on that song is Pau.
And it doesn't matter if it's the old performance from "Lunario" or the new one from "Teatro Metropólitan" both are great,
just like you two, both are great.
Thanks and greetings from México!! 🇲🇽
🤘😁✌️
I'm the guy stood at 3:08 😅, i was on first row front right 😊😊
Great reaction! And dont worry! I believe in 2024 The Warning will be close to you soon, because they have to play in the Wacken 2024 in Germany, for sure they will make a tour close to you for that date.
I'm guessing they'll be back to England next summer. They had a couple headlining shows and opened for Muse and were extremely well received. Keep a lookout after the 1st of the year. In the meantime, every song from this concert is bonkers. So incredibly good. Just follow the other suggestions here and you can't go wrong.
I would suggest the tidal rising documentary where you will see a lot of info. Truth is they are everywhere with each of them having a weekly chat with fans on "Dany day" "Pau day" and "Ale day". Their interaction with each other and those around them is the stuff role models are made of. The royals should keep these girls on speed dial and watch their interaction with fans... this is how "empires" are built to last.
Nice response.
David
Love seeing people checking out The Warning the first few times, they are awe inspiring. Thank you for sharing your reaction with us.
We all know how you feel Ash, all of us have experienced the shock of hearing them for the fir😢
Pau, the drummer is the complete set of what you call A BEAST. This girls are just making history
They never disappoint
You need to do "Dust to dust" at Teatro Metropolitan too 😀
You have to see Enter Sandman from this concert. It's better and also different as that from the girls when they were younger.
In fact every song from this concert is great and best quality. But as I said, Enter Sandman is different in this version than it was years ago.
The majority will be their home crowd, but their shows have always had people flying in from all over the world!
This is one of my favs live but they don't have a bad song any performance from this concert is awesome. They just dropped a bunch on their page which would be great to react to. It's so cool to watch Ashley we've all been there this is a fun rabbit hole and TWA will gladly guide you two. Great reaction cheers from Canada
Pau, the drummer, sings while doing aerobic exercises specifically to build and maintain her breath capabilities and vocal balance while being so energetic beating her drums into submission... she has been singing while drumming since pretty much the beginning of their journey...
Welcome to the TW Rabbit Hole! come on in and join the rest of us! 😹
TWA ⚡🤘😸🤘⚡ TWA
Pau sing lead in about 10 songs . You have to hear these ones too.
Along with Nightwish, The Warning is my favorite band. Please continue!!!!! Like Nightwish, The Warning does NOT have a bad song. My favorite TW music video is XXl Century Blood(Twenty-first Century Blood). They received awards for it.
Nice Reaction! Little Ale from the Enter Sandman cover you watched is now taller than both of her sisters. This concert is from August 2022 just a few months after their 3rd album (called Error) was released. This song was from that album. If you are interested in seeing them do an Acoustic song, react to the song Revenant from the same concert. Pau sings lead on that song and they are sitting on chairs at the front of the stage. They are multi-talented!
Awesome reaction Ash and Dave and Ash get ready to smile every single time you experience The Warning DPA Goddesses. I hate to insist on you guys reacting to The Warning TEDx 2017 before you goo on with their newer stuff, believe me you be truly truly amazed. Either way my beautiful UK people I'll be here along with the rest of The Warning Army to help you in your amazing journey. By the way The Warning have a few shows here Mexico, I'm seeing them for the first time here in Guadalajara October 21st and there's still some tickets left, you pay the round trip and I'll provide my house for you to stay, as we always say. Mi casa es su casa!
This was so fun to watch 🫶🤘
now youboth just got to do more of The Warning :)
This was was they opened with when I saw them last week in Cincinnati. They were intense and charismatic and fun. I'd definitely see them again.
Hey Dave and Ash! It's a shame you missed them while they were in the UK earlier this summer, headlining and opening for Muse. They also played Download Fest.
All of these songs they have released from Teatro Metropolitan are amazing. Also take into consideration they are from Monterrey, MX (elev. 600m or 2000 feet) and they were playing in Mexico City at an elevation of 7200+ feet (2200 Meters) in the thin air. Much more difficult to sing and exert so much effort on stage.
Keep in mind this show was done in Mexico City which is 7200 feet above sea level!
I love Pau (the drummer), she always has insane Tigger levels of bouncy energy and beats the drums like they owe her money. They are legit as they've played with Three Days Grace, Halestorm,, Foo Fighters, Gun's N' Roses and (probably) their favourite band Muse.
Buena reacción!🤘🇲🇽🤘🇲🇽🤘🇲🇽 Viva the Warning!! (cuando no es la boca abierta por la sorpresa de escuchar y ver a las hermanas en acción, entonces es la sonrisa permanente admirándolas)
Whilst you can single out any of the ladies it takes all three of them to sound this good
I'm getting ready to see reaction, but I wanted to say I loved you picked this song for your wife to enjoy❤
Ok I'm back. It's a great reaction. Trust me, we a lot of us had had the same reaction, deep rabbit hole. Seem them 3 times live,once in a small venue, just amazing humble ladies, great parents. Rhey are the whole package. I recommend you watch the documentary Tidal Rising at some point, amazing inspirational story, WELCOME TO TWA❤🤘
I ♥ The Warning 🎶🎶
Bout time I’ve been waiting minutes for y’all to react to this one. lol 🔥🇺🇸🇨🇱🤘🏻😎
Great reaction! 😂🔥🤘
Please listen to Dust To Dust or Evolve from the same concert. 🔥🤘🤟
Greetings from the Netherlands
They are simply the best out there right now . . by far! They put the same incredible energy and passion in every song - every performance they do! So much fun!!
Crimson Queen from the QUEEN OF THE MURDER SCENE ALBUMN live. What an awesome emotional rendition. Dany at her best acoustic.
My checks hurt watching your reactions. Been a fan of the Warning for 4 years now so I get it. They are just awesome.
Yup this is a proper rock band.
This song chugs along perfectly ... ⚡🤘⚡✊⚡✌️⚡
Only 40-something more songs to go!
This is one of the best first reactions to The Warning I've seen. They really are shockingly good. They're not a good girl band, or even a good band. They're a GREAT ROCK BAND, period. They have "paid their dues" for over ten years, and are about to explode on the world scene in 2024. This is a PRIME example of what finding your passion at an early age does to you. It fills you with a drug rush-like surge of creative energy and commitment to do your very best. This isn't just a great band. It is a fascinating success story for the whole family. Parents, Luis and Monica, must be special people to have raised such dedicated performers. I'm in awe of all of them. They have a rather extensive team of dedicated and professional support people who make things happen. Watch out, world!
They are from Monterey Mexico. They are each other's best friends. Ale goes from the shortest to the tallest. Dany is 5'3 Pau is 5' and Ale 5'7. Ale can sing lead for a couple of songs : Red Hands Never Fade and 😂 most recently and River's Soul. In Toronto recently Ale sang two songs. Dany is 23,Pau 20 and Ale 18. They have been in London this summer opening for Muse . They opened for Muse in Mexico and Muse asked them personally to be in Londo with them. They opened for the Foo Fighters two weeks before Taylor Hawkins died.
Great! Good job! Thank you! Ustedes han disfrutado esto, nosotros también!
Uh oh, looks like she's got a rabbit hole to investigate
YES!!!!!!!!!!!
Welcome to The Warning Army Ash. I hope you get a chance to see Dust to Dust from Lunario, Dull Knives from The Warning Cave, Evolve, Animosity, Choke, who am I kidding any Warning song is worth a listen Enjoy! ⚡⚡⚡
Great reaction!! 🔥⚡💖🎯
Next year they will be in Wacken. This will certainly not be their only concert in Europe. For this year I recommend a fall vacation in Mexico.
Maybe if you want to give Ash's cheeks a rest you can skip over "Dust to Dust" Live at Teatro Metropolitan for any other song from Teatro Metropolitan for her third exposure. But if she wants her mind blown for the 4th video I would suggest "Dust to Dust" Live at Teatro Metropolitan. If Dave has seen "Dust to Dust" at Lunario... that was 5 years ago... it is so much better now!!
Ale drives "Dust to Dust". The song was built on her bassline. There are other surprises in the song as well.
I absolutely love you're reactions to the Warning 😊
Great reaction unfortunately you just missed The Warning they played a number of dates in England in May and June of this year. They are for sure worth travelling to see perform live. Thx.
it's really cool to see the couple reacting together, you and your wife are adorable I loved it, the reaction to TW was great show her the version of Enter Sandman now with them grown up this will be very good.
You were Warned the addiction is real 🤘 😎 ⚠️
The entire show you just watched is what I would recommend
I'm glad your cheeks hurt Ash. You'll have the strongest cheeks in the UK because you have a lot of TW to react to. My suggestion is a song Paulina the drummer sings lead. The song is "Narcisista" released as a single in 2019 and is their first song recorded in Spanish. This is the premiere live performance of the song from the Foro Didi entertainment complex in their hometown of Monterrey, Mx. Daniela guitar 19; Paulina drums, lead vocals 17; Alejandra bass 14.
ua-cam.com/video/O7IAEhN4RMM/v-deo.html
Awesome React !!! yes indeed The Warning is the "Real Deal" SEE THEM LIVE if youget a chance... It will blow your mind... I'm 60 yrs old and just saw them... as well as A Ton of people My age with their childeren and Familys to wittness these Lovely Ladies !!! There's no swearing... no slutting ... Just Pure Powerful rock music... and yeah I pretty much gave up on any of the Bands I grew up with..... The Warning is the Future of Rock..... FINALLY !!!! (that's why ya see us geezers in the audience 😂) Cheers !!! p.s. Any song from Teatro Metropolitan should be worth looking at.. Not a bad one !!
I saw them 3 times in the UK this summer and they were awesome! I saw them open for Muse in Huddersfield - great but big stadium and short set although they rocked it! I saw them at Download where they opened the day on the Opus stage and I reckon 30k turned out to see them and they went down a storm. Then they announced a final UK date (the last date of the European tour) at the O2 Islington and we got tickets. Nothing prepares you for.how good they are live. UA-cam videos no matter how good, can't prepare you for how much energy they have, how tight they are, how good they work the crowd and how LOUD they are! My ears were ringing for days! I drove from 11:00 Sheffield and back.on the night to see them and they were awesome. You have to see them. They are playing Wacken OA next summer so.theyll be in Europe so there's a good chance they'll make the UK again I hope. They are a must-see if they do. Great reaction by the way!!
Woooow great reaction. Thanks for that love it ❤.. I recommend to react to dust to dust for the same concert or dulll knives from the warning cave live version.ROCK ON VIVA THE WARNING💥🤟💯
They write there own music (Paulina mostly). They had a few concerts in the UK this year. Next year there back to Europe.
I think you just missed them. They just finished playing in the UK/Europe last month. The videos from this show are amazing quality. Evolve, Error, Choke, WHen I'm Alone, etc.
Good video! 👌🏼🇲🇽 They R the best! ⚡
My favorite rock band since they released the first album 6 years ago, amazing discography.
Yeah, the three of them put out hella noise.
Hey rock world, the future is female, embrace it. I think these three sisters are helping to lead the way. I love it.
I second the suggestion of the TedX talk from 2017. There is good stuff in there.
Then add anything from the Teatro concert. It was so well recorded and filmed.
Great reaction, This really shows you what can happen in a 10 or 11 year span.
I am A71 year old hippie freak more freak than a hippie, But I thought rock and roll was dead I would have to listen to reruns from back in the 60s and 70s and part of the 80s.
But who would have known that 3 beautiful sisters from Monterey Mexico would bring back real rock and their own original.
You cannot pigeonhole their type of music because you never know what you're gonna get But you do know it's gonna be great, Because all 3 are great musicians and love playing music.
I don't know if I said it are already or not but welcome to the rabbit hole you are going to love this ride and love of music
You have been warned
⚡️⚡️⚡️⚘️⚘️⚘️
⚡The Warning⚡
🔥👸👸👸🔥
Animosity
Live at Teatro Metropolitan
🤘😎
Great reaction again, looks like Ash has already fallen into that rabbit hole!
I would say either do a double of 2021 Enter Sandman with Alessia Cara and the same song at Teatro Metropolitan CDMX for the studio / live comparison or Marterio for a Spanish song!
Didn’t realise that you’re from the UK, so am I - from around Brum!
The lady is very sharp - her logical deduction that a band formed by friends will unlikely have such a young bassist hence this is a band of sisters. Elementary my dear Watson.
It seems that you missed 7 performances in the UK by The Warning from end May to End June.
- 4 openers for Muse at Plymouth, Huddersfield, Glasgow & Milton Keynes
- a private concert at Bush Hall, London
- opening day 2 of Download at 1 pm on a side stage with a packed field of about 25,000+
- headlining sold out show at O2 Islington, London
Why didn’t you introduce her to The Warning earlier since they just had a European tour? You could’ve taken her to one of their concerts.
I like your reactions to The Warning and would love to see your next to any of their songs from this same show (Teatro Metropolitan) 😊🤟
When they aren't touring they have an exercise routine that includes weights and running on the treadmill while singing. That's why Pau can drum and sing and not be tired now. When they first started they had two TED talks at the University of Nevada and Pau was breathing hard when they talked in between songs.
Think of the thousands of devices made to tone the facial muscles, over the years…. Turns out all those people needed was to listen to The Warning, daily 🤣
For your reactions...keep doing live performances. Once you're done with your reactions... it doesn't matter, there entire library is good 😊
Stick with the Teatro live performances for now. The Warnings first MV was XXI Century Blood. Title track off their first album. It has won several awards and is captivating and eye opening. Worth a watch. My favorite two songs are Crimson Queen, and Money. Good luck.
If your intro to them was when they were children doing Enter Sandman, you need to react to how they do the song today. NOT the one with Alessia Cara, but the one from this same concert at Teatro Metropolitan. It'll BLOW your mind.
All Teatro Metropolitan's gig videos are Amazing