To register for the Abdullah al Andalusi's upcoming in-depth course on Palestine, please visit: advocateforpalestine.com The video mentioned by Abdullah of a Jewish Israeli journalist living in Gaza can be found here: ua-cam.com/video/I5xjMa128ng/v-deo.html
JazzakAllah, it's simple AshkaNazi Zionism is built on racist ideology . Right of return for non inhabitants. No right of return for the generational inhabitants
Only One you need to publish now, if you don't your a zionist. NSA MEMO JFK00067 , GOOGLE IT. ZIONISTS KILLED KENNEDY AND NSA WARNS LAWMAKERS. DON'T PRETEND.
Please check "rabbi yaakov shapiro" on the topic of The Jews of Palestine , and How Zionists Treated them . his interview with Miko Peled worth Studying as well: Episode 10 Rabbi Yaakov Shapiro from New York (Part One/ Part Two)
Origins of Palestinians banned since 2001 please check brother Eid Mubarak Antonio Arnaiz-Villena Complutense University of Madrid | UCM · Department of Immunology Professor
Salam alaykum Paul, I have just recently heard about you and the more i look into your videos of just logically looking at religion and God from an unbiased view the more impressed I am. Subhanullah
Your comment section alone shows the incredible fraternity of Islam and it's representative of the unity and brotherhood of mankind. I understand you are doing the best you can with your platform because of the brotherhood you feel for our brothers in Palastine. May Allah accept your efforts and all Muslim duas and may He hasten his relief to the Ummah in Gaza in particular. Ameen
Mind Begs the Question: - If God exiles a people from a land - For their Transgressions,Evil - To reestablish State with Messiah - If reestablish State before Messiah - Following God or Satan?
George Curzon, the British Secretary of State for Foreign Affair, 1911 - 1921. "We must put an end to anything which brings about any Islamic unity between the sons of the Muslims. As we have already succeeded in finishing off the Caliphate, so we must ensure that there will never arise again unity for the Muslims, whether it be intellectual or cultural unity."
I think the "war on terror" and the total massacre of alot of North Africa, really show this quote. I think you could even say the westernisation of countries like Saudi and U.A.E are also an example of this
So many horrific things went on then. And, sadly, continue to this day. Horrific. What people will do for more money and more power and more prestige. Ugh
Dawah will liberate humanity from ignorance. The work of current Muslim academic and preachers is truly impressive. May Allah aid you both and your fellow preachers.
Speak for yourself. Islam has an apostasy problem for a reason. The place with the fastest growing Christian population is in IRAN of all places. The more the youth are asking questions and finding out more about Islam the faster they run away. Inshallah more and more people will see the TRUE love and PEACE in Jesus Christ. God bless
Dawahganda will make people ignorant by first manipulating them emotionally and then presenting the "proofs" for Islam, which they will accept ignorantly mostly due to The emotional connection that dawahclowns have made in them first.
The ignorance that Muslims have about the history of their own religion as well as the conflict in Israel is incredible. Children in Gaza have been brainwashed to hate Jews and Islam has always been about forcefully conquering every square inch of the earth. Just read the Hamas charter. Just look at Islamic history..from the beginning Muslims were killing each other..even in mosques during prayer they killed each other. Every society dominated by Islam produces no flourishing for humanity and keeps all its members hampered in obsession with adapting their lives to believing God wants them to act like they live in 7th century Arabia. They do not produce any useful technology, hate everyone who doesn't think exactly as they do, and if it weren't for oil literally spewing up from right under the ground wouldn't be able to contribute at all to the world economy. The only good things which come from these places come because these people deviate from Islam and the only reason their societies remain is because the rest of the world is too humane to come in and force them to convert away from this demonic religion. Dawah will not work and has not worked in the past. Islam relies on searing the conscience of its followers into believing other people are subhuman and then treating them like animals until they convert to Islam. Afterward they are forced to tell their kids that Islam was the best thing to ever happen to their land when it is a poison.
Br. Abdullah really is right up there if you want to learn about Zionism. I signed up to the Palestine Advocacy course he runs for the Qur'an Institute. Highly recommended.
34:00 this aged perfectly, the ICJ ruled in July 2024 that the prolonged occupation of the Palestinian Territories including East Jerusalem are illegal
Allah is our Lord, Islam is our religion, Muhammad is our prophet, and the Qur’an is our book. We believe in the Lordship of Allah, His Divinity, His Names, His Attributes and their rules as stated in the Qur’an and Sunnah.
Does the God you worship deem some beautiful humans who have transgressed him in this finite life deserve to be incinerated for a *_INFINITE_* duration causing terrifying unimaginable suffering as per many verses in the Quran?
I just wanna say Eid Mubarak Paul. I hope it wasn't a hard Ramadan on you. I saw the discussion of this weekend when you were next to Zeshan. You minced the opposite speaker, not Zeshan of course That was really entertaining 😊
J'adore franchement beaucoup vos contenus... Très instructif comme toujours. C'est juste dommage que je ne parvienne pas à tout bien comprendre. Je passe par la traduction automatique en langue française pour comprendre. Et la traduction automatique est bien souvent médiocre. Ce serait un pur bonheur si vous pouviez ajouter des sous-titres officiels en FRANÇAIS pour vos prochaines vidéos 🙏🏽.
Abdullah al Andalusi is a treasure to the ummah. May Allah reward you and brother al Andalusi for this critical discussion, refuting the Zionist position. EID MUBARAK 🌷
1st argument 2:00 Zionism isn't settler colonialism because Jews are native to Palestine. 2nd argument 34:00 Occupying Gaza and the West Bank is not Illegal because Jews were given right to have a national home 3rd argument 53:50 Israel isn't an apartheid state because 20% of citizens are non jews and enjoy equal civil and political rights 4th argument 1:07:50 Attack by Israel on Gaza is legit in its initiation just ad bellum and conduct just in bellum. 5th argument 1:28:26 Zionists believe that Israel has not nor has ever deliberately committed genocide or ethnic cleansing. 6th argument 1:44:00 Israel has always desired peace and has never been expansionist or belligerent, all wars by Israel have been defensive. 7th argument 1:59:15 Israel isn't a racist state. 8th argument 2:04:54 The end goal of popular opposition to Israel is the ethnic cleansing or genocide of jews 9th argument 2:34:20 The Palestinians and Pro Palestine activists support a apartheid against Jews because no Jews are permitted to live in Gaza under Hamas. 10th argument 2:46:35 Anti Zionism means Anti Semitism because Zionism simply means self determination for Jews in their own land and therefore the only explanation for explaining this is Anti Semitism.
The massacre of the Amalekites is mentioned in several passages in the Bible: 1. Exodus 17:14 - "Then the Lord said to Moses, 'Write this on a scroll as something to be remembered and make sure that Joshua hears it, because I will completely blot out the name of Amalek from under heaven.'" 2. 1 Samuel 15:3 - "Now go, attack the Amalekites and totally destroy all that belongs to them. Do not spare them; put to death men and women, children and infants, cattle and sheep, camels and donkeys." These verses depict God's command to the Israelites to completely destroy the Amalekites as a form of divine judgment. A God will never commend to massacres from this verses we can understand that the Bible was distorted by the priests
This guest does not speak and does not express himself in a way that is easy for people to follow. I am 11 minutes in and I feel like closing down this discussion. This is such an incredibly important discussion that could be so helpful to those people who are "less than average" on this topic and who really need empowering insight on how to understand these arguments and how to respond to it. When I think about some of the people I have interacted with, there is NO WAY they would be able to follow this or stay with this. They really need the insight & would welcome being educated on how to engage on this matter...but they would never be able to stick with this. If I am feeling this 10 minutes in...they will not even last 5 minutes. I really wish you could revisit this in a more palatable way for those who really need to be able to use this information.
a true knight of islam. thank you brother paul for all the good you're doing for the umma and the world. may allah aza wa jal grant a palace in paradise 😊😊😊
A simple point. What right did Britain have to to decide any policy in plastine?? Again a racist point about a white European power who can decide the fate of a land that they have nothing to with...they did this everywhere they went.
The Ottomans were the aggressors in WWI with hopes to expand their empire. They got their butts kicked and as a condition to stop getting their butts kicked, they agreed to give Britain Palestine (what is today Israel and Jordan) to create a Jewish state. This was part of the Treaty of Versailles that also caused Germany to lose 15% of her lands for her part in WWI. Moral of the story: don’t start a war against a superior power.
I hope we see one of these videos for the Kurds. Hopefully we can get some world marches for their cause as well. There needs to be a Kurdistan for the indigenous Kurds. ❤
I’m Kurd You are Not We Don’t Need Kurdistan We need Justice Differences is to know Each other not Rule the Other Thanks Almighty For Brotherhood I Love My Brothers in Faith/Belief Anyone can take Racial Disgrace Your Mental Illness Already Expired We don’t want to taste poisonous Ideas Keep it for yourself
@@To-whom-it-may-concern1 Where is it that you live? And tell that to our Kurdish brethren who are fighting for their independence. 🤔 … Over 90% of them would disagree with you.
57:07 if they could have had better life style, no oppression, no loanliness, if they had no risk of loosing their children in gunshot for pleasure by idf then they would have had less children, if the people was free from bullying, persecution, oppression, torture then they would have had less children, see the psychology behind this is they survive the hardship by seeing their children's affectionate expression, this is in order to not feel the memories of their past miseries. Look what happens when they have no one to express feelings, no one to cling on to feel that there is someone for whom they need to be alive, tremendous darkness, a void of loanliness, hopelessness and retribution of their past miseries, no purpose to live on , this is all because of the illegally occupancy . This over population would not have happened if they had proper life style in their own sovereign nation . They are skillful race, look how well they play soccer even in that condition . What to say 36000+ people death is not genocide to people's eye then you can't expect anything in this shameful complicit world.
George Curzon, the British Secretary of State for Foreign Affair, 1911 - 1921. "We must put an end to anything which brings about any Islamic unity between the sons of the Muslims. As we have already succeeded in finishing off the Caliphate, so we must ensure that there will never arise again unity for the Muslims, whether it be intellectual or cultural unity."
There is no reasonable solution but resistance! God gave us that right, no one else can take it away! No law, no ruling class, no race, no entity but Allah has jurisdiction on this matter!
🇵🇸 I am the Palestinian flag my colors represent my People and my Land. My colors have a meaning; ⚫ stands for the darkest day in our History the catastrophe May 15 1948 🤍 Represent the purity in our hearts to seek Justice Freedom and Peace with resilience 🩸Red is the sacrifice we pay in blood to protect our families and our homes 🌿🟩🟢🌱💚 stands for our fertile Land of Palestine 🇵🇸 I am the Palestinian flag I represent the Children Women and Men of Palestine.
Your flag was created in the 80's and is just a ripoff of Jordan's which was also a country that was created for the "palestinians" you have no nationality your ancestors were settling on conqured occupied jewish land of Judea. And there is no purity in your people, only terrorism and hatred is found.
Professor Avi Shlaim said that when his family arrived in Israel from Syria they were treated as second class citizens. He was personally insulted at school for having an association to an Arab country. His father had to leave his wealth in Syria which was built up over generations and come to a foreign land with fifty dollars in his pocket.
Paul, regarding your point about "settler-colonialism" I've left you a comment on your post with the map showing Palestine in the 1720s on X. You'll find it of much benefit, iA.
said it.. i read a lot about this. DNA test and studies from non government linked lab in "the country" is illegal for a reason. they kidnapped yemenite j3w babies just to keep middle eastern dna in the population. this is fact.
That is the crux of the entire matter. Judaism has always been and remanis religion. The consequemce of haskalah and reformed Judaism is treating Jews as race which can access their Hebrew hertitage via Englihtment, where Jewishness is a race and Judaism nationality.
Completely untrue to say that the democratic process allowed mass immigration into the UK. No party ran a manifesto saying they were in favour of unrestricted immigration, quite the opposite. In essence all political parties have lied about it.
Wow! As a South African brown Muslim some 82 years ago I sadly understand every word of your discussion. We need to turn our backs on the arrogance of the Zionist western world. My only response is when a Jewish lady got so fed up with life in current Israel that she wanted to return to her neighbourhood in North Africa. She loved her friendly neighbours and lived peacefully.How peaceful Palestine would be for the three faiths to live together without outside interference. Brilliant for all other faiths and none to visit. Hello my western world. Wake Up or is there no profit in peace!!!
" WAR PROFITEERING " MISOLOGY , A. D. EGORENCE VS CROSS - SWORD DOWN for HUMUNITY become " FISHERMEN " )( BIBLE )( WOMB - " ALL MEN " RECOGNIZE YOUR MOTHER MATT 5 ; 43 - 48 SEE ASAP " KINGDOM OF HEAVEN " movie with insighT ALSO " GOD KNOWS WHERE I AM " documentary ALL MUST SEE CONTEMPT for " BIRTH OF A GIRL 1ST " AND " A HOUSE DIVIDED " documentary SMART UP AMERICA from " DUMMIED DOWN AMERICA " APARTHEID OCCUPATION CRIMINAL GREED and CRIMINAL RACISM TUTOR CC 33 M. "PATSY" FAUNTLEROY Maggie OXY PEACEMA' NY !
While I believe some of the points made were a disingenuous interpretation (which was intended to be avoided), I believe Abdullah did a great job in general. For example, when speaking about expulsions that had occurred, he delivered an appeal to the ridiculous and ipso facto explanations (not based in fact but general knowledge) in his rebuttal. I’m not a historian, but I am well read… I could deliver concise rebuttals to most if not all of his points. But still, very well argued Abdullah. I would love to see him formally debate these points on a diverse panel of experts
@@abdullahx4908I’m not going to go back through and it’s been three days, so I won’t get into specifics. his history while it’s mostly factually correct, where things are left up to interpretation or situations are nuanced or he talks about the mindset of Israelis or their supporters… he doesn’t give them the benefit of the doubt , plays into tropes, generalizes, gives a single example (as if it explains the entire situation while other examples contradicts his opinion), told the opinion or account of a single group or government and applied that opinion to entire communities or entire nations people, etc. I can keep going… but if you can’t hear that or see that for yourself, there’s really no point. He wants the Israelis and their supporters to be wrong on all things and that’s very apparent. Yes he is trying to offer rebuttals to these ten points, but if you reframe their argument or offer a rebuttal painting the other side with a broad brush, you’re not doing that… you’re further proving their point to those who don’t have a side.
Again he’s not giving the Israeli side the benefit of the doubt because it is inherently contradictory. For example he brought up the contradictory Israeli stances on West Bank and Gaza. I have no reason to believe he’s wrong if you haven’t given me one and your reasons are quite flimsy and misrepresentative
@@abdullahx4908 yes, but there’s detailed history, negotiations and interests that are completely generalized. I’m sure we could have a much better discussion over three hours and come a better understanding than what is shown here. I could argue either side and bring up points and counter points, contradictions, and exceptions to generalizations. They said they were going to debate against the ten best arguments… they didn’t. They debated their own preconceived and disingenuous opinions relating to ten topics
Mashallah. One thing, though: when you make analogies you should talk about a hypothetical immigrant group wanting to replace British people (not white nationalists; British people being indigenous to Britain and wanting to keep it British is the position).
So olden times travellers? Are the links to Mesopotamia accurate? Did the people of the Middle East and Arabia suffer as a result of say flood,earthquake volcanic activity or serious climate change,and so became travelling people moving to more habitable areas.
Hewbrew definition is traveling tribe.. actually the records show that they didn't buy any land from anyone..the Palestinian ruler at the time refused to sell the land.
Guess what? It wasnt his, he was under british controll and he was settling in a land that did not belong to him. Judea which was conqured 2200 years ago by the romans from the jews.
It is untrue that the British unfairly sold state land to jews. All Jewish settlements were purchased from the local landlords. Plus the mandate laws required that the purchaser come to terms with the tenant farmers. So the tenant farmers were not kicked out unfairly
Great concepts and facts, but you lost me at the idea that Britain has voted for unlimited immigration. Like the US, or in fact any EU citizen, we are not asked to vote on these issues, so this sort of disingenuety made me opt out.
According to the Orthodox Jews & The Talmud (Torah) & the Bible Allahu wa’tala exiled the Jews because of their continuous disobedience to Allahu wa’tala such as gambling in the Synagogue amongst other forbidden sins. This is why Prophet Isa threw the disobedient Jews out of the Synagogue which led to his betrayal (remember Judas30peices of silver?). Allahu wa’tala said they will roam the earth until the day of the return of the Messiah when he will tell them why Allahu wa’tala exiled them.
I could litterally take each of the points you made and refute them. I might actually do it because you are putting aside so many facts, and defining zionism in such a narrow way to fit your narrative.
To his point 1.. The jews of Palestine are NOT the same as eastern European jews. Although one can share a religious beliefs. Does not correlate to a cultural connection...
@@epistemophile369 thousands of years of persecution of others being invisible means you are already blind and will never see only learn the very hard way.
I am profoundly believing Christian, and before I'll watch this video to the end, let me tell you, that there's no need to such a very long talk, to prove, that Jews are not the "natives" people of Palestine. Not only that, but the TRUTH is, that God NEVER gave the land of Canaan, now called Palestine, to the Jews for permanent possession! This might be shocking news, even to the millions of Christians, because most of them never bothered to read the Bible, and only believe what the Jews and all Christian priests and preachers are telling them, but it is absolutely clearly written in the Bible, in the Book of Leviticus, Chapter 25, Verse 23: -- * "Your land must NOT be sold on permanent bases, because you do not own it; it belongs to God, and you are like the foreigners, who are allowed (ONLY) to make use of it." (Lv. 25:23). God allowed the Jews to settle there and use His land ONLY on the condition, and only as long as they kept faithfully ALL of his commandments. They did not do so, and were expelled by God for good, and never had any rights, or permission by God, to return.
To register for the Abdullah al Andalusi's upcoming in-depth course on Palestine, please visit: advocateforpalestine.com
The video mentioned by Abdullah of a Jewish Israeli journalist living in Gaza can be found here: ua-cam.com/video/I5xjMa128ng/v-deo.html
JazzakAllah, it's simple AshkaNazi Zionism is built on racist ideology .
Right of return for non inhabitants.
No right of return for the generational inhabitants
Only One you need to publish now, if you don't your a zionist. NSA MEMO JFK00067 , GOOGLE IT. ZIONISTS KILLED KENNEDY AND NSA WARNS LAWMAKERS. DON'T PRETEND.
Please check "rabbi yaakov shapiro" on the topic of The Jews of Palestine , and How Zionists Treated them .
his interview with Miko Peled worth Studying as well:
Episode 10 Rabbi Yaakov Shapiro from New York (Part One/ Part Two)
Abdullah from Spain what about Spain should it be returned to the morabiton?
Origins of Palestinians banned since 2001 please check brother
Eid Mubarak
Antonio Arnaiz-Villena
Complutense University of Madrid | UCM · Department of Immunology
Professor
I've always heard of that saying that criminals return to the scene of the crime. It's never been more true than today.
I can confirm this is 100% true
Dude left out a lot. He's speaking from one side you need both to understand regardless of where u land
Why is everybody being so vague ?
Sounds like y'all are grasping at straws,and just need to throw shade from 30,000 feet
Salam alaykum Paul, I have just recently heard about you and the more i look into your videos of just logically looking at religion and God from an unbiased view the more impressed I am. Subhanullah
wa alaikum assalam
3 hours of Andalusi, what an Eid gift.
Uncle Paul giving us the best Eidi of our lives💖
You meant grift?
@@Bamifun are you blind?
Thanks!
Many thanks!
Land you kill for is not your Land, you die for your Land.
That is so true ...
Hamas are killers.
Hamas are killers
FU
OCT 7Th ?????????????????????
Your comment section alone shows the incredible fraternity of Islam and it's representative of the unity and brotherhood of mankind. I understand you are doing the best you can with your platform because of the brotherhood you feel for our brothers in Palastine. May Allah accept your efforts and all Muslim duas and may He hasten his relief to the Ummah in Gaza in particular. Ameen
Ameen
We're blessed to have someone like Abdullah this day and age.
Where is that location in your image? Pretty beautiful.
@@snakejuce Big Beehive hike on Lake Louise, Banff National Park, Canada
Yes, its breathtaking.
Mind Begs the Question:
- If God exiles a people from a land
- For their Transgressions,Evil
- To reestablish State with Messiah
- If reestablish State before Messiah
- Following God or Satan?
@@HumanBeingsRThinkingBeings illogical question
@@SquaredCircIe Awesome, thank you brothaman.
George Curzon, the British Secretary of State for Foreign Affair, 1911 - 1921.
"We must put an end to anything which brings about any Islamic unity between the sons of the Muslims. As we have already succeeded in finishing off the Caliphate, so we must ensure that there will never arise again unity for the Muslims, whether it be intellectual or cultural unity."
is there a source for this quote?
@@BloggingTheology The Judgment Against Imperialism, Fascism and Racism Against ..., Volume 1
By Khondakar Golam Mowla page 541
I think the "war on terror" and the total massacre of alot of North Africa, really show this quote. I think you could even say the westernisation of countries like Saudi and U.A.E are also an example of this
100% fake quote
So many horrific things went on then. And, sadly, continue to this day. Horrific. What people will do for more money and more power and more prestige. Ugh
Eid Mubarak to all the Muslim brothers and sister and to you Paul
Excellent analogy with French colonial settlement of Algeria.
Dawah will liberate humanity from ignorance. The work of current Muslim academic and preachers is truly impressive. May Allah aid you both and your fellow preachers.
Speak for yourself. Islam has an apostasy problem for a reason. The place with the fastest growing Christian population is in IRAN of all places. The more the youth are asking questions and finding out more about Islam the faster they run away. Inshallah more and more people will see the TRUE love and PEACE in Jesus Christ. God bless
Dawah capitalizes on human ignorance and then increases it.
Dawahganda will make people ignorant by first manipulating them emotionally and then presenting the "proofs" for Islam, which they will accept ignorantly mostly due to The emotional connection that dawahclowns have made in them first.
The ignorance that Muslims have about the history of their own religion as well as the conflict in Israel is incredible. Children in Gaza have been brainwashed to hate Jews and Islam has always been about forcefully conquering every square inch of the earth. Just read the Hamas charter. Just look at Islamic history..from the beginning Muslims were killing each other..even in mosques during prayer they killed each other. Every society dominated by Islam produces no flourishing for humanity and keeps all its members hampered in obsession with adapting their lives to believing God wants them to act like they live in 7th century Arabia. They do not produce any useful technology, hate everyone who doesn't think exactly as they do, and if it weren't for oil literally spewing up from right under the ground wouldn't be able to contribute at all to the world economy. The only good things which come from these places come because these people deviate from Islam and the only reason their societies remain is because the rest of the world is too humane to come in and force them to convert away from this demonic religion. Dawah will not work and has not worked in the past. Islam relies on searing the conscience of its followers into believing other people are subhuman and then treating them like animals until they convert to Islam. Afterward they are forced to tell their kids that Islam was the best thing to ever happen to their land when it is a poison.
Dawa ☪️ancer
What a tremendous amount of knowledge is exposed mentioned here. Thank you gentlemen.
Thank you so much for this amazing Eideyye!
Assalamualaikum Warohmatullahi Wabarokatuh, Great talks Paul, and Eid Mubarak 🙏
wa alaikum assalam and Eid Mubarak!
Asalam Ailaykum Paul. Eid Al fitr Mubarak brother.. May Allah bless you for all the important work that you do.
Allahuma barik 🤲🏼
wa alaikum assalam
Br. Abdullah really is right up there if you want to learn about Zionism. I signed up to the Palestine Advocacy course he runs for the Qur'an Institute. Highly recommended.
34:00 this aged perfectly, the ICJ ruled in July 2024 that the prolonged occupation of the Palestinian Territories including East Jerusalem are illegal
Eid Greetings to you Paul and your blogging theology team. One channel giving me daily dose of intellectual vitamins.
Allah is our Lord, Islam is our religion, Muhammad is our prophet, and the Qur’an is our book.
We believe in the Lordship of Allah, His Divinity, His Names, His Attributes and their rules as stated in the Qur’an and Sunnah.
Jesus christ is far Holy than muhammad.
@@miscgar9663 we love all Allah prophets and believe in all of them.
@@114alltimeAs a Roman Catholic, your response was PERFECT!
Thank you 🙏🏻
@@Italiana71 Thank you
Does the God you worship deem some beautiful humans who have transgressed him in this finite life deserve to be incinerated for a *_INFINITE_* duration causing terrifying unimaginable suffering as per many verses in the Quran?
Thank you very much for an honest effort to shed light on truth.
Beautiful content as always, brother Paul.
I just wanna say Eid Mubarak Paul. I hope it wasn't a hard Ramadan on you. I saw the discussion of this weekend when you were next to Zeshan. You minced the opposite speaker, not Zeshan of course That was really entertaining 😊
Eid Mubarak and thanks!
It's finally here!
J'adore franchement beaucoup vos contenus... Très instructif comme toujours. C'est juste dommage que je ne parvienne pas à tout bien comprendre. Je passe par la traduction automatique en langue française pour comprendre. Et la traduction automatique est bien souvent médiocre. Ce serait un pur bonheur si vous pouviez ajouter des sous-titres officiels en FRANÇAIS pour vos prochaines vidéos 🙏🏽.
Thank you!
Abdullah al Andalusi is a treasure to the ummah. May Allah reward you and brother al Andalusi for this critical discussion, refuting the Zionist position. EID MUBARAK 🌷
May Allah Bless and Reward Both of You in this Life and in the Hereafter.
This is exactly the video we all needed!!! Thank you so much for doing this!!!
Everyone needs to listen to this
Thanks brother ❤
3 hours?? Mashallah, thank you for this gift! Just what was needed to start the day
Hope you enjoyed it!
Hamas are killers
Hamas are killers
Hamas are killers
Hamas are killers
Please time stamp this. This is such valuable information.
Eid Mubarak 🌙
This is legendary and free free free!!
Dr.. Rashid Khalidi is one of the most famous historians of the Palestinian issue and has a distinguished book about it
1st argument 2:00
Zionism isn't settler colonialism because Jews are native to Palestine.
2nd argument 34:00
Occupying Gaza and the West Bank is not Illegal because Jews were given right to have a national home
3rd argument 53:50
Israel isn't an apartheid state because 20% of citizens are non jews and enjoy equal civil and political rights
4th argument 1:07:50
Attack by Israel on Gaza is legit in its initiation just ad bellum and conduct just in bellum.
5th argument 1:28:26
Zionists believe that Israel has not nor has ever deliberately committed genocide or ethnic cleansing.
6th argument 1:44:00
Israel has always desired peace and has never been expansionist or belligerent, all wars by Israel have been defensive.
7th argument 1:59:15
Israel isn't a racist state.
8th argument 2:04:54
The end goal of popular opposition to Israel is the ethnic cleansing or genocide of jews
9th argument 2:34:20
The Palestinians and Pro Palestine activists support a apartheid against Jews because no Jews are permitted to live in Gaza under Hamas.
10th argument 2:46:35
Anti Zionism means Anti Semitism because Zionism simply means self determination for Jews in their own land and therefore the only explanation for explaining this is Anti Semitism.
History and Science say it all. thank you for this formidable lecture.
The massacre of the Amalekites is mentioned in several passages in the Bible:
1. Exodus 17:14 - "Then the Lord said to Moses, 'Write this on a scroll as something to be remembered and make sure that Joshua hears it, because I will completely blot out the name of Amalek from under heaven.'"
2. 1 Samuel 15:3 - "Now go, attack the Amalekites and totally destroy all that belongs to them. Do not spare them; put to death men and women, children and infants, cattle and sheep, camels and donkeys."
These verses depict God's command to the Israelites to completely destroy the Amalekites as a form of divine judgment.
A God will never commend to massacres from this verses we can understand that the Bible was distorted by the priests
Please sir Mr. Paul, make a review/ lecture on the Scofield bible and it's role in fueling zionsim, and the lawyer from the FED who funded Scofield
Eid Mubarak ☝🏽☝🏽☝🏽
I hope some of them see this and open their eyes.
MashaAllah may the Creator increase all our Knowledge, Aameen
masha allah. eid gift from brother paul to us!!!
May Allah bless you both.
Thank you for this Paul. May Allah Almighty continue to bless you.
“Funny Whammy” Good one Paul 😂
Thank you.. Alhamdolilah.
This is a great video. I suggest having time stamps to show topics.
This guest does not speak and does not express himself in a way that is easy for people to follow. I am 11 minutes in and I feel like closing down this discussion.
This is such an incredibly important discussion that could be so helpful to those people who are "less than average" on this topic and who really need empowering insight on how to understand these arguments and how to respond to it.
When I think about some of the people I have interacted with, there is NO WAY they would be able to follow this or stay with this. They really need the insight & would welcome being educated on how to engage on this matter...but they would never be able to stick with this. If I am feeling this 10 minutes in...they will not even last 5 minutes.
I really wish you could revisit this in a more palatable way for those who really need to be able to use this information.
what is the issue with the presentation? it is fine.
a true knight of islam. thank you brother paul for all the good you're doing for the umma and the world. may allah aza wa jal grant a palace in paradise 😊😊😊
I don't even listen to any zionist.
Why?
@itsikmiz Lying,murderous psychopaths,enemies of the mankind.p
04:06 “They muddy the water to make it seem deep.” ~Friedrich Nietzsche
A simple point. What right did Britain have to to decide any policy in plastine?? Again a racist point about a white European power who can decide the fate of a land that they have nothing to with...they did this everywhere they went.
The Ottomans were the aggressors in WWI with hopes to expand their empire. They got their butts kicked and as a condition to stop getting their butts kicked, they agreed to give Britain Palestine (what is today Israel and Jordan) to create a Jewish state. This was part of the Treaty of Versailles that also caused Germany to lose 15% of her lands for her part in WWI. Moral of the story: don’t start a war against a superior power.
Assalamualicum, even before the start of the video, I felt my love for you. May Allah you in honor.
I hope we see one of these videos for the Kurds. Hopefully we can get some world marches for their cause as well. There needs to be a Kurdistan for the indigenous Kurds. ❤
We need less division, not more.
I’m Kurd You are Not
We Don’t Need Kurdistan
We need Justice
Differences is to know Each other not Rule the Other
Thanks Almighty For Brotherhood
I Love My Brothers in Faith/Belief
Anyone can take Racial Disgrace
Your Mental Illness Already Expired
We don’t want to taste poisonous Ideas
Keep it for yourself
@@CraigTheBrute-yf7no Do you mean we should get rid of states all together?
@@To-whom-it-may-concern1 Where is it that you live? And tell that to our Kurdish brethren who are fighting for their independence. 🤔 … Over 90% of them would disagree with you.
57:07 if they could have had better life style, no oppression, no loanliness, if they had no risk of loosing their children in gunshot for pleasure by idf then they would have had less children, if the people was free from bullying, persecution, oppression, torture then they would have had less children, see the psychology behind this is they survive the hardship by seeing their children's affectionate expression, this is in order to not feel the memories of their past miseries. Look what happens when they have no one to express feelings, no one to cling on to feel that there is someone for whom they need to be alive, tremendous darkness, a void of loanliness, hopelessness and retribution of their past miseries, no purpose to live on , this is all because of the illegally occupancy . This over population would not have happened if they had proper life style in their own sovereign nation . They are skillful race, look how well they play soccer even in that condition . What to say 36000+ people death is not genocide to people's eye then you can't expect anything in this shameful complicit world.
George Curzon, the British Secretary of State for Foreign Affair, 1911 - 1921.
"We must put an end to anything which brings about any Islamic unity between the sons of the Muslims. As we have already succeeded in finishing off the Caliphate, so we must ensure that there will never arise again unity for the Muslims, whether it be intellectual or cultural unity."
@@mohammedmostapha5887 They still uphold their divide and rule policies over the whole world 😔
There is no reasonable solution but resistance! God gave us that right, no one else can take it away! No law, no ruling class, no race, no entity but Allah has jurisdiction on this matter!
Whoever has the power makes the rules. There is no place for the weak in this jungle or some call it world.
What are your thoughts on the "Hidden History of Zionism" by Robert Sepehr? Or can you do a similar video based on your research...
May Allah’s mercy and blessings be upon you and your loved ones. Eid Mubarak!
Great vid
is someone able to type out the latin word used at 44:27 ? thanks
Jajakallah khairakuma
reserved
🇵🇸 I am the Palestinian flag my colors represent my People and my Land.
My colors have a meaning;
⚫ stands for the darkest day in our History the catastrophe May 15 1948
🤍 Represent the purity in our hearts to seek Justice Freedom and Peace with resilience
🩸Red is the sacrifice we pay in blood to protect our families and our homes
🌿🟩🟢🌱💚 stands for our fertile Land of Palestine
🇵🇸 I am the Palestinian flag I represent the Children Women and Men of Palestine.
Your flag was created in the 80's and is just a ripoff of Jordan's which was also a country that was created for the "palestinians" you have no nationality your ancestors were settling on conqured occupied jewish land of Judea. And there is no purity in your people, only terrorism and hatred is found.
Professor Avi Shlaim said that when his family arrived in Israel from Syria they were treated as second class citizens. He was personally insulted at school for having an association to an Arab country. His father had to leave his wealth in Syria which was built up over generations and come to a foreign land with fifty dollars in his pocket.
from Iraq not Syria
Paul, regarding your point about "settler-colonialism" I've left you a comment on your post with the map showing Palestine in the 1720s on X. You'll find it of much benefit, iA.
thanks! very useful
@@BloggingTheology Glad you came across it, enjoy!
they said the land belong to the jews like jew is a race. a lot of palestinian DNA is acient, they were the canaanites.
said it.. i read a lot about this. DNA test and studies from non government linked lab in "the country" is illegal for a reason. they kidnapped yemenite j3w babies just to keep middle eastern dna in the population. this is fact.
Do you think that socalled nonblack people are indigenous to anywhere on the planet?
That is the crux of the entire matter. Judaism has always been and remanis religion. The consequemce of haskalah and reformed Judaism is treating Jews as race which can access their Hebrew hertitage via Englihtment, where Jewishness is a race and Judaism nationality.
Completely untrue to say that the democratic process allowed mass immigration into the UK. No party ran a manifesto saying they were in favour of unrestricted immigration, quite the opposite. In essence all political parties have lied about it.
Wow! As a South African brown Muslim some 82 years ago I sadly understand every word of your discussion. We need to turn our backs on the arrogance of the Zionist western world. My only response is when a Jewish lady got so fed up with life in current Israel that she wanted to return to her neighbourhood in North Africa. She loved her friendly neighbours and lived peacefully.How peaceful Palestine would be for the three faiths to live together without outside interference. Brilliant for all other faiths and none to visit. Hello my western world. Wake Up or is there no profit in peace!!!
" WAR PROFITEERING "
MISOLOGY , A. D.
EGORENCE
VS
CROSS -
SWORD DOWN for
HUMUNITY become
" FISHERMEN " )( BIBLE )(
WOMB - " ALL MEN "
RECOGNIZE YOUR MOTHER
MATT 5 ; 43 - 48
SEE ASAP
" KINGDOM OF HEAVEN "
movie with insighT
ALSO
" GOD KNOWS WHERE I AM "
documentary
ALL MUST SEE CONTEMPT
for " BIRTH OF A GIRL 1ST "
AND
" A HOUSE DIVIDED "
documentary
SMART UP AMERICA from
" DUMMIED DOWN AMERICA "
APARTHEID OCCUPATION
CRIMINAL GREED
and
CRIMINAL RACISM
TUTOR CC 33
M. "PATSY" FAUNTLEROY
Maggie OXY
PEACEMA' NY !
While I believe some of the points made were a disingenuous interpretation (which was intended to be avoided), I believe Abdullah did a great job in general. For example, when speaking about expulsions that had occurred, he delivered an appeal to the ridiculous and ipso facto explanations (not based in fact but general knowledge) in his rebuttal. I’m not a historian, but I am well read… I could deliver concise rebuttals to most if not all of his points. But still, very well argued Abdullah. I would love to see him formally debate these points on a diverse panel of experts
And why were these disingenuous? He’s using real history
@@abdullahx4908I’m not going to go back through and it’s been three days, so I won’t get into specifics. his history while it’s mostly factually correct, where things are left up to interpretation or situations are nuanced or he talks about the mindset of Israelis or their supporters… he doesn’t give them the benefit of the doubt , plays into tropes, generalizes, gives a single example (as if it explains the entire situation while other examples contradicts his opinion), told the opinion or account of a single group or government and applied that opinion to entire communities or entire nations people, etc. I can keep going… but if you can’t hear that or see that for yourself, there’s really no point. He wants the Israelis and their supporters to be wrong on all things and that’s very apparent. Yes he is trying to offer rebuttals to these ten points, but if you reframe their argument or offer a rebuttal painting the other side with a broad brush, you’re not doing that… you’re further proving their point to those who don’t have a side.
Everything he says is literally attested to by history, human rights organisations and basic logical thinking. The only ones lying here are Zionists
Again he’s not giving the Israeli side the benefit of the doubt because it is inherently contradictory. For example he brought up the contradictory Israeli stances on West Bank and Gaza. I have no reason to believe he’s wrong if you haven’t given me one and your reasons are quite flimsy and misrepresentative
@@abdullahx4908 yes, but there’s detailed history, negotiations and interests that are completely generalized. I’m sure we could have a much better discussion over three hours and come a better understanding than what is shown here. I could argue either side and bring up points and counter points, contradictions, and exceptions to generalizations. They said they were going to debate against the ten best arguments… they didn’t. They debated their own preconceived and disingenuous opinions relating to ten topics
Mashallah. One thing, though: when you make analogies you should talk about a hypothetical immigrant group wanting to replace British people (not white nationalists; British people being indigenous to Britain and wanting to keep it British is the position).
Its the Jews fault when they failed to manage the great "Solomon" Kingdom
I know I'm to love everyone, but I'm having a really hard time with the Zionists. Any suggestions?
So olden times travellers? Are the links to Mesopotamia accurate? Did the people of the Middle East and Arabia suffer as a result of say flood,earthquake volcanic activity or serious climate change,and so became travelling people moving to more habitable areas.
Hewbrew definition is traveling tribe.. actually the records show that they didn't buy any land from anyone..the Palestinian ruler at the time refused to sell the land.
Guess what? It wasnt his, he was under british controll and he was settling in a land that did not belong to him. Judea which was conqured 2200 years ago by the romans from the jews.
Interesting as usual. History of ancient Levant, now called Palestine and Isreal.
It is untrue that the British unfairly sold state land to jews. All Jewish settlements were purchased from the local landlords. Plus the mandate laws required that the purchaser come to terms with the tenant farmers. So the tenant farmers were not kicked out unfairly
It's been happening in America since 2008 or even Prior, purchasing properties in huge bulks. ❤E
Great concepts and facts, but you lost me at the idea that Britain has voted for unlimited immigration. Like the US, or in fact any EU citizen, we are not asked to vote on these issues, so this sort of disingenuety made me opt out.
Zionists left the chat..
thanks from chilliwack b.c. canada
May ALLAH bless you, protect you and elevate you in ranks, Aameen.
Free PALESTINE 🇵🇸
Bro Paul, please ask your guests in very simple English whether being a Jew is of race, ethnicity or faith? No clear answer yet.
Eid Mubarak paul ❤
Why Rome evict jews from Palestine but not from Rome?
They didn’t evict Jews, Jews stayed but many immigrated
If tomorrow people in eurpoe became Buddhist would they have a right to invade India and settle the land?????
According to the Orthodox Jews & The Talmud (Torah) & the Bible Allahu wa’tala exiled the Jews because of their continuous disobedience to Allahu wa’tala such as gambling in the Synagogue amongst other forbidden sins. This is why Prophet Isa threw the disobedient Jews out of the Synagogue which led to his betrayal (remember Judas30peices of silver?). Allahu wa’tala said they will roam the earth until the day of the return of the Messiah when he will tell them why Allahu wa’tala exiled them.
Jews 3000 years ago were not Jew but Zoroastrian
Hell exists and it is hungry and roaring for the souls of oppressors and disbelievers.
Real history to confront Zionism.
I could litterally take each of the points you made and refute them. I might actually do it because you are putting aside so many facts, and defining zionism in such a narrow way to fit your narrative.
Go ahead
you somehow forgot khazarians?
Please make this chanel in spanish 🙏❤️✨
JazakAllah Khair.
To his point 1..
The jews of Palestine are NOT the same as eastern European jews.
Although one can share a religious beliefs. Does not correlate to a cultural connection...
None of these were refutations.
So this justifies mistreatment?
What mistreatment?
@@epistemophile369 thousands of years of persecution of others being invisible means you are already blind and will never see only learn the very hard way.
Source?
@@sameerxneleon Oppenheimer.
@@notinterested8452 that's not relevant to this video. They are talking about israel -palestine issue
I am profoundly believing Christian, and before I'll watch this video to the end, let me tell you,
that there's no need to such a very long talk, to prove, that Jews are not the "natives" people of Palestine.
Not only that, but the TRUTH is, that God NEVER gave the land of Canaan, now called Palestine, to the Jews
for permanent possession!
This might be shocking news, even to the millions of Christians, because most of them never bothered
to read the Bible, and only believe what the Jews and all Christian priests and preachers are telling them,
but it is absolutely clearly written in the Bible, in the Book of Leviticus, Chapter 25, Verse 23: --
* "Your land must NOT be sold on permanent bases, because you do not own it; it belongs to God,
and you are like the foreigners, who are allowed (ONLY) to make use of it." (Lv. 25:23).
God allowed the Jews to settle there and use His land ONLY on the condition, and only as long as they
kept faithfully ALL of his commandments.
They did not do so, and were expelled by God for good, and never had any rights, or permission by God,
to return.