Heru Ptah - Why

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 1 жов 2024
  • Ptah questions "Why?"
    I've been reading some of the comments and I'm amused with some of them. Keep them coming. :)

КОМЕНТАРІ • 269

  • @londronoroso2023
    @londronoroso2023 12 років тому +15

    A history teacher a long time ago once asked.
    Are you an optimist or a pessimist for the future.
    I answered, "how about being realistic for a change?".

  • @DocBrown3000
    @DocBrown3000 6 років тому +9

    God's name gets called out equally in brothels and in churches. You certainly look to reach the heights of rapture in both. And you leave with your wallet lighter and your heart happier after visiting each.

  • @odabuu
    @odabuu 17 років тому +3

    this man is just too nice and I'm glad he hit these boundaries that many dare not to cross

  • @Ziggu12
    @Ziggu12 16 років тому +3

    this is the one of the best poems i have ever listend to and i love how he combines his literal sense and religion and turns it into an enjoyable show for any faith.

  • @Diamonddina
    @Diamonddina 12 років тому +2

    Clown.... but thought provoking and real!! loved it

  • @nukirkdigital
    @nukirkdigital  17 років тому +1

    Sadly, no. To my knowledge, this is his only appearance. I know of him via his book "A Hip-Hop Story", which is a great novel. You should pick it up.

  • @ricardoknightgooner
    @ricardoknightgooner 15 років тому +1

    I CAN HEAR THE JAMAICAN IN HIM

  • @reginaldfairfield
    @reginaldfairfield 11 років тому +1

    so it's "okaye" for men to have 2 women because there are less men than women & it's crazy for men to be faithful?

  • @KUDANTOURAGE
    @KUDANTOURAGE 15 років тому

    us humans are 3-dimensional entities and thats how we see the world. If God is however a four-dimensional being then he would be able to travel through. this implies that he can be at the origin and at the end of mankind just simply by moving in time through the fourth dimensional plane. he would be able to do this even if his life was only one year.

  • @nukirkdigital
    @nukirkdigital  17 років тому

    tinyurl dot com/2u4doy - purchase directly from this link and help a brother out.
    I have a copy myself. The first edition. I met him on the streets of NYC before the "MTV Edition" came out. This is truly a great read (which is one of the reasons why I uploaded his video).

  • @j2jpop
    @j2jpop 16 років тому

    I get what you're saying and I was about to agree, but I think maybe he's comparing it to when people say "I don't believe in marriage" or "I believe in myself," because those statements lead to existences. I think he's just pointing out that more precise language would be, "I don't believe in the existence of God." It's implicit, but imprecise, like when people say "I could care less" even though that technically means that they DO care and they should really be saying "I couldn't care less."

  • @lifendsoon
    @lifendsoon 14 років тому

    I think His Muslim. He said he wasn't Christian. His nt an Atheist. I bet his Muslim, some of da points he covered with his questions can make me tell... And my interpretation on the 'Why is God,' it is not literal as in Why=God, or any of that Maths like Y=God, and he already said it is not a question, but the question n the answer 2 everything.

  • @kevindelgado20
    @kevindelgado20 15 років тому

    not true i dont believe in religion but i believe in God...just dont believe in.religion because it is man made and all the stories are so similair look up other "god-like men" who performed miracles and came back from the dead...dating back to 1500 BC (Attis of Phrygia,Krishna of India,Mithra of Persia) just to name a few..explain that

  • @owyana
    @owyana 15 років тому

    But alot of non believers in God state that they do not believe in God. So really, what he is saying makes sense at the core. They are denouncing a God that they are supposedly non-believers of. Then again, athiests are former adherents of a faith alot of the time, so they may of the right to say that, since their former belief was actual existent.

  • @krissyheartyou
    @krissyheartyou 14 років тому +3

    statistically there are more men in the world than women.... so i guess that means.. lol, yep.

  • @vixxa
    @vixxa 16 років тому

    lolll, was THAT supposed to be provocative as well? nice try, i guess. lol i'm almost tempted the deconstruct it line by line and show you how daft most of this is, but i'd rather be watching other UA-cam shenanigans so i'll pass. if you enjoyed it, lovely!

  • @anjellenee
    @anjellenee 14 років тому

    Bad math, he got bad stats! Male/female world population is berely different. Females outnumber males just a bit. And in Asia men outnumber women significantly in China, Iraq/Iran. CHeck wolfram alpha for stats.

  • @Trenholmes
    @Trenholmes 17 років тому

    You can't concede something exists in order to not believe it. If you say you don't believe something exists, you're saying exactly that. Atheists say god doesn't exist because that's their conclusion.

  • @TheWiseTruth90
    @TheWiseTruth90 13 років тому +1

    "that's bad math!!! ... and a bit selfish." lmfao that line cracks me up every time.

  • @nukirkdigital
    @nukirkdigital  17 років тому

    I dunno. Why is their racist in the world?
    Simple... because we are humans. If you can't think why I would say that, then that's on you...

  • @kendellroney1154
    @kendellroney1154 10 років тому +2

    great examples of logical fallacies

  • @OnlyGreatness007
    @OnlyGreatness007 12 років тому +3

    Very well explained.

  • @j2jpop
    @j2jpop 16 років тому

    Haha, yeah, it could go either way. I'm loving the way you think, though. I don't see many people besides me using pointing out logical fallacies on the internet. =)

  • @lifendsoon
    @lifendsoon 14 років тому

    So what I think his point is: Is that Everything is due to God's will, God's decree. So when you ask 'Why this? Why that?' The answer is: God deceed it.

  • @LILSONIC88
    @LILSONIC88 17 років тому

    Why is there someone who called themselves athiest? when just to say u don't believe in God u have to aknowledge that there is a God not to believe in.

  • @j2jpop
    @j2jpop 16 років тому

    That's just my explanation of his statement, though. I could be wrong; maybe he didn't realize the fallacy in that statement.

  • @keemy18
    @keemy18 16 років тому

    its like he stepped on everyone's toes. not like he was takin sides but genuinely wondering why.

  • @nukirkdigital
    @nukirkdigital  17 років тому

    I'm not saying it's the best nor the worse. I'm just popping the questions here. That's all.

  • @nukirkdigital
    @nukirkdigital  17 років тому

    What's so terrible about it? Feel free to discuss, my friend. We're all open minded here.

  • @KidInsain
    @KidInsain 14 років тому

    @livedalife1 yeah but ours in tarnished , for example murder is ilegal but we have things like abortion and the death penalty. And weed is illegal but alcohol and cigarettes aint when their far more worst substances. And have a government that worries more about other nations problems then ours. If ppl used their commonsense then we wouldnt be fighting a lost war. So when the laws are fair and logical , then step to me on it.

  • @KurdaC
    @KurdaC 14 років тому

    @mrarmaggedon31415926 this is really cool that people like u bring stuff up like this, because it opens other doorways to expression... but u must see i do not believe in religion, because it was manufactured as early as the ancient egyptians and plagiarised by the romans unto jesus... so even though god doesnt exit in the heavens, i can see the god in u, and everyone else, because i dont believe in religion, but i believe in u...

  • @ronaldcuriel4398
    @ronaldcuriel4398 15 років тому

    Why is god? we are all debating this, we all have our own interpretations. So i'll give it a try....i didn't see it as a math problem, but i can understand why sopeople do...and thats okay too. At the end of the day i interpret this "what is god propose?" "why is god?" fuckign A...i hate questions like these..."Man is not meant to understand everything, but to live through it" ....."why?"umm....because you only have a limited about of days, before you have to role over and just die....."why?

  • @mayraj
    @mayraj 15 років тому

    im expecting you to support the claims of wat u believe in,not wat u dont!
    no religious book is perfect 2 YUO bcoz its not compatible wth ur world,u dont like wat religion offers.
    to billions of people around the world, their holly book is perfect in every way
    so while u may think ur opinion counts n makes sense statistics will tell u otherwise.d amount of ppl tht believe in religion simpy out do those that dont.u slandering religions is realli offensiv so kik bak

  • @mayraj
    @mayraj 15 років тому

    a childrens novel would be able to giv u more knowledge then a science book
    it is evident u get all ur facts 4rm der so u dont have the intellectual to argue any valid points!
    get with it dude,der is obviously a purpse 2 life.we didn come about simultaneously jus 4 the sake of it and GOD doesn't have a gender nor can God be compared to by those GOD created..
    GOD almighty is wat we must cherish at all tyms, not only times of need
    we must submit ourselvs 2 our creator THATS THE LEAST WE CAN DO

  • @Butta718
    @Butta718 15 років тому

    while humorous, his logic is faulty. Atheists don't believe in the concept of a "god", so entitled by those who subscribe to those beliefs. there needed to be a concept of god before one could deny the existence of such a being. u can't say there's no such thing as santa claus unless someone has said there was such a thing in the first place! his was an oversimplification that has annoyed this atheist endlessly.

  • @mugantenshen
    @mugantenshen 16 років тому

    oh please if so i'll see you there. god is compasionate and i dont believe that just because your not christian you go to hell. for instence jews arnt considerd christians but im positive that god wont send all jews to hell in fact the bible said god chose them as his favorites. actually it even says in the bible that those who lead a clean life he will take with him nomatter there religion. sooo i guess somone needs to read there bible.

  • @ohitsliz
    @ohitsliz 15 років тому

    which is also correct..
    saying you dont believe in religion makes the statement more general but if you think about it, it still goes back to being the same.
    you would still have to believe this religion exist to not believe in it.
    its one big cycle, you cant get around.
    religion is a very touchy topic!!

  • @ohitsliz
    @ohitsliz 15 років тому

    its more like..
    ok i believe in God, so i say there is a God.
    so techinically speaking i'm already making an inference that he exist.
    so if your an athiest your just saying you dont believe in God making an inference back to, what the believer in God, i said.
    so i guess in a way you have to believe im right, by saying that God exist, for you to believe he doesnt?

  • @BBoyFury
    @BBoyFury 15 років тому

    I'd have to go with not Christian. Actually, thats the only one he specifically says he's not, somewhere in the middle, and he makes a quip about Christianity too. Seems to me he's just trying to keep it balanced, so people see it as a poem about questioning things and finding truth rather than a poem attacking a particular belief.

  • @timbocaff86
    @timbocaff86 16 років тому

    to be honest guitarskills, im not stupid, im not 14, and there is no idillic 'God' who will save u from your sins etc etc etc, and who will judge you on good and bad things uve done in your life. people who believe this is the case either have nothing else in their lives, or have turned to 'God' to rid problems in their life.

  • @Gurragurk
    @Gurragurk 16 років тому

    "all started from when people started to disagree with the bible" I find that very funny since a lot of things in the bible has been translated badly and a lot of the stories are just based on previous religons. But by all means, belive in a higher power if you want to, just don't bother talking shit about a man speaking the truth.

  • @AnonymousBlackguy
    @AnonymousBlackguy 17 років тому

    im 20 im a christan its hard 4 me 2 let people talk like God dosent exeist all thoese ?s the KJV Bible can answer we r here couse wanted someone to talk 2 us.Jesus is not lost u r of ur not followin Christ. a christan can show u the way to Him so if u do ur not lost anymore so ur found Him ur not lost ur saved. FYI i beleved in evloution sense the 4th grade.now i c the truth

  • @SunAndMirror
    @SunAndMirror 16 років тому

    its like
    why is god
    why=god
    its a question
    "remember always that the answer you seek is the question"

  • @usupreme
    @usupreme 15 років тому

    God is man. Anotha point I'd like to make is when he said people look at the glass as half full or half empty. When this causes division. The common denominator is just to say, HALF. We see the common denominator in all our religions, all our ideologies,we wud be able to gain unity.

  • @BBoyFury
    @BBoyFury 16 років тому

    i'm not sure he means Y. I think he means "why is God," cause he says its the question and the answer, i.e. why is God? God is why. Sort of referring to circular thinking. But hey, maybe he even meant to have a dual or even triple meaning there. Thats the greatness of poetry.

  • @unmutedvoicez
    @unmutedvoicez 16 років тому

    The answers that we long for are questions. Why is such a powerful word, it allows us to escape conformity and embrace wisdom. This poem is funny but also it provides enlightenment. Why do women expect a man to have only one, for those of u that do go back to math class.lol

  • @mugantenshen
    @mugantenshen 16 років тому

    just because your not christian doesnt mean you dont believe in god it just means your not christians. for example jews believe in the same god we do they just have different beliefs about jesus. it doesnt mean they will go to hell because of it, they just have different beliefs.

  • @xblindx
    @xblindx 16 років тому

    lol there was no word play wish socrates, he was concerned with how we used our words and how people misconstrued them. it was moreso the people he pissed off that were too in to word play. socrates was concerned with getting down to the true meaning of things.

  • @xblindx
    @xblindx 16 років тому

    this guy doesn't really do anything to elicit any REAL thought. he may stir some emotion, but you're an idiot if you're easily seduced by the simple word play he's using. this stuff is for "lovers of sights and sounds" and shouldn't be taken seriously. purely entertainment.

  • @only1rksweet
    @only1rksweet 13 років тому

    @uadem227 its really all in how u word it..... there is no boogie man verses i dont believe in the boogie man. i think thats what he meant.... when he made that atheistic statement...and he said why not just say i believe in nothing.

  • @kaleexto
    @kaleexto 15 років тому

    read the bible psalms 82 verse 6... jesus said that we all can be like him... a God...
    even Buddhism believes we all kan go Buddha , most philosophies talk about how we can achieve... enlightment... you kno? you gotta dig a little

  • @truthbetold89
    @truthbetold89 15 років тому

    speaking As a philosopher, an atheist shouldn't not say that he doesn't believe in god, instead he should say that he doesn't believe in religion, because if you don't believe in religion, you automatically do not believe in god.

  • @Difrint
    @Difrint 16 років тому

    "tempted the deconstruct it"... at least you know how to construct a sentence. You show me a poem that you wrote that's even half as thoughtful as this and maybe I'll respect you. There's a reason Heru Ptah is on TV and you are not.

  • @mugantenshen
    @mugantenshen 16 років тому

    you should shut up and pay attention to the poem he does believe in god and jesus, he just feels church and other things arnt required to be a believer. just because he said hes not christian doesnt mean he doesnt believe in god.

  • @onelovekidd
    @onelovekidd 14 років тому

    @livedalife1 "Nobody knew right from wrong until Jesus himself was on earth" is bad doctrine Look at the prophets, and King David. Sure they weren't perfect, but following Christ isn't about "rights and wrongs."

  • @hunni221
    @hunni221 14 років тому

    we know he is a muslim because he said "there is 4 more women than men" ... and "why the hell is everybody following jesus"
    i love how simple this poem is :] "and now finally there are no more dam questions!!!!! lol

  • @mayraj
    @mayraj 15 років тому

    'i dont believe in god' and 'there is no god' says the same thing...his point is if athiests are even ackowledging the very thought or meaning of the word GOD den then that is enough to proove themselves wrong

  • @mayraj
    @mayraj 15 років тому

    alnakhli999- apparntly der r some ppl out der dat dont believe in religion but du believe in god ..gues they're ackowledging god exists but dont follow the sentiments and values religion holds

  • @Difrint
    @Difrint 16 років тому

    Like you could come up with these interpretations of everyday issues...this piece makes you think, and if it didn't make you think then perhaps you lack the capacity to comprehend what you are hearing.

  • @plipmanzz
    @plipmanzz 16 років тому

    his poem is funny. but the poem itself is not that good.
    love this guy. im a christian. jesus is love and is the only way. everyone has the right to choose any path to take. God gave us freedom to choose.

  • @kingmomo010
    @kingmomo010 15 років тому

    you javin right shihan saul williams and black ice are the grestest poets 2 ever bless def poetry jam this dude just made a point im not gone lie he good but not the best
    ~Yung Escobar

  • @sal8do
    @sal8do 16 років тому

    I loved it... It was hot and everyone who is talking smack is not really understanding the poem...and anyways i don't see Russel Simmons casting you for the next season of Def Poetry Jam

  • @sogginwithyou
    @sogginwithyou 15 років тому

    why= God
    not so much why is God *blank
    we question ourselves and the questioning leads us to think there is a higher power concluding we think therefore God exists

  • @TeasyMan
    @TeasyMan 15 років тому

    The problem lies with trying to apply logic to something that is FAITH based.. Faith is believing in that which is unseen and unknown.. Stop trying to figure it out..

  • @DiamondThrasher
    @DiamondThrasher 16 років тому

    anyways...
    you obviously didnt see what i wrote. i said to me. jus cuz you think its ok to mock Jesus like that don mean that everyone should think like that.
    get real

  • @maryiettaksmith2
    @maryiettaksmith2 16 років тому

    He is correct God is in the brothel...he just isn't pleased with the actions that are taking place there...God is within you where ever u go..so if your there God's there

  • @tootifrooti1101
    @tootifrooti1101 14 років тому

    that was so bad, that was random shit that I say all the time...i dont know...it wasn't the most thought provoking ting i ever heard. but still good on ya.

  • @Tiarka
    @Tiarka 15 років тому

    Saying that I don't believe in the Easter Bunny isn't an acknowledgement that there is an actual easter bunny out there somewhere to acknowledge....great poem tho.

  • @DiamondThrasher
    @DiamondThrasher 16 років тому

    wow you really cant comprehend wat i write
    lemme simplify it fir you
    if you think its ok for HIM to mock jesus
    but watever
    it really isnt that serious tho

  • @candyman1818
    @candyman1818 16 років тому

    Christian's tell me i need to find jesus. as if jesus were lost.and now if jesus is lost why the hell is every1 followin him!? lol much respect on this poem man

  • @ConverseSC
    @ConverseSC 17 років тому

    Actually, it is correct.
    "I don't believe in God" - Presupposes God exists.
    That's why atheists define themselves by a disbelief and not an actual belief.

  • @KidInsain
    @KidInsain 14 років тому

    @anicashh ok christian answer me this , if everything was created on this Earth and gave man domain over the Earth , Y is it wrong to smoke weed????

  • @MrSixFive
    @MrSixFive 16 років тому

    If GOD is everywhere, why wouldn't he be in a 'brothel?' Unless God's making decisions as to where to appear and not telling us to say otherwise? ;-)

  • @nukirkdigital
    @nukirkdigital  17 років тому

    Last I check, this is America, where anyone can talk about anything.

  • @xblindx
    @xblindx 16 років тому

    i've read all these philosophers just recently. Post-modernism may however challenge the existence and role of God. ( i'm not an atheist btw )

  • @ieatglue44
    @ieatglue44 15 років тому

    Okay...he's not saying Y=God. He's simply saying that questions are universal - "'Why' is God." You're putting too much thought into it.

  • @murdok620
    @murdok620 13 років тому

    yo if you wanna place where you can submit your OWN poems, go to this facebook page, "potent poetry" and submit like crazy!! thanks..

  • @shedsgurl86
    @shedsgurl86 18 років тому

    thATS my brotha i love him and not so only because his piece is both funny and tru but because hes my favorite kind of guy jamaican

  • @10for10films
    @10for10films 12 років тому +1

    "I'd rather not live like there isn't a God, than to die and find out there really is" -Kendrick Lamar

  • @joseph33634
    @joseph33634 15 років тому

    "Why is God?" is the question but "Why is God!" is the answer. He's saying that asking questions is the answer to everything.

  • @wikkedchik90
    @wikkedchik90 15 років тому

    he was probably a slick little boy, I almost feel sorry for his mother, she was probably bombarded with so many questions.

  • @imimorgan
    @imimorgan 16 років тому

    I just watched that again and that shit was even better the 2nd time. LOL the stuff about finding jesus haha jokes!

  • @xblindx
    @xblindx 17 років тому

    sounds like a lot of rhetoric -_-
    silver tongue maybe? meh... words to have a sense of seduction, i guess.

  • @maakheru001
    @maakheru001 17 років тому

    pleaze dont get too much into the humor, but remember this when you need it most"why is god" that is ur answer

  • @phresh07
    @phresh07 15 років тому

    I'm spacing...why is God? I keep trying to figure that out, and I keep coming up with "Why is God what?"

  • @uadem227
    @uadem227 15 років тому

    so when i say that I don't believe in the boogie man, I am acknowledging that there is a boogie man too?

  • @xblindx
    @xblindx 16 років тому

    =P yeah, i'm a philosophy major. and while i do appritiate oratory skill, this guy ain't nothing new.

  • @brownsugar3192
    @brownsugar3192 14 років тому

    @imnobody002 in order to be an atheists you have to admit that there is a god not to believe in

  • @Iwilldoyes
    @Iwilldoyes 16 років тому

    This Guy has some great works... This poem is not as good as his greatness...
    Good poem though

  • @usupreme
    @usupreme 15 років тому

    Y is God. The Y chromosome is the male chromosome. Y is the 25th letter. 2+5=7,God's number

  • @SauerkrautProduction
    @SauerkrautProduction 13 років тому

    Why is God. Why is a question. God is then why. So God is a question. I been mind fucked.

  • @spikeleesa
    @spikeleesa 18 років тому

    he's good, like him, especially the atheist question.

  • @alleyesonme410
    @alleyesonme410 16 років тому

    i like this poem it was funny ...it wasnt ment to be taken as serious as yall taking it

  • @omnithink
    @omnithink 15 років тому +1

    one of the greatest explanations of human questioning and rationale. genius.

  • @hayatme
    @hayatme 16 років тому

    i wonder what he id\s if he isn't christian? anyway that was sick and really funny 2.

  • @Shiftee88
    @Shiftee88 13 років тому

    Why is God, Why=God. ie. the universal equation. this is a lot smarter than u think

  • @vixxa
    @vixxa 16 років тому

    probably the dumbest poem i've heard on Def Poetry

  • @bboyblacksheepable
    @bboyblacksheepable 13 років тому

    if god is in the brothel and in the church, then why do i have to go to church!!?

  • @letusmake7093
    @letusmake7093 6 місяців тому

    Enjoyed his mind... someone else could have delivered it better though.

  • @Novarakasem
    @Novarakasem 13 років тому

    that was the shitttttttttttttttttttttttttttt