Arun Shourie: Prashant Bhushan's Contempt Conviction Shows Court's Insecurity Bordering on Paranoia
Вставка
- Опубліковано 6 жов 2024
- In an to Karan Thapar for The Wire Arun Shourie said that he had no doubt Judges have assisted in the erosion of democracy. In fact, he went further and said they were guilty of assisting in an assault on democracy. “I say this as a person who knows Modi better than the judges. Democracy has been eroded. Have they assisted in it? … they should look at the mirror and ask themselves that question.”
Arun Shourie said Prashant Bhushan’s tweet alleging the Supreme Court and the last four chief justices have played a particular role in destroying democracy “is an understatement”. He said the Court “has assisted in an assault on democracy”, not just in an erosion of it.
Like our work? Click here to support The Wire: thewire.in/sup...
The founding premise of The Wire is this: if good journalism is to survive and thrive, it can only do so by being both editorially and financially independent. This means relying principally on contributions from readers and concerned citizens who have no interest other than to sustain a space for quality journalism. As a publication, The Wire will be firmly committed to the public interest and democratic values.
We publish in four different languages!
For English, visit www.thewire.in
for Hindi: thewirehindi.com/
for Urdu: thewireurdu.com
for Marathi: marathi.thewir...
If you are a young writer or a creator, you can submit articles, essays, photos, poetry - anything that’s straight out of your imagination - to LiveWire, The Wire’s portal for the young, by the young. livewire.thewi...
You can also follow The Wire’s social media platforms and engage with us.
Facebook
/ thewire
/ thewirehindi
/ thewireurdu
/ thewiremarathi
Twitter
/ thewire_in
/ thewirehindi
/ thewireurdu
/ thewiremarathi
/ livewire
Instagram
/ thewirein
/ livewirein
Don’t forget to hit the subscribe button to never miss a video from The Wire!
Extremely happy to see Arun Shourie back. He is looking nice and healthy. He does not know how much India needs him during these times. Welcome back Sir.
Yes really me to very happy to see Mr Shouri wish him best of health & happyness.🙏🏼🙏🏼🇮🇳🇮🇳
I agree.
We were influenced.by his fearless attitude.
Though I don't agree with his views on all matters.
He now has to speak only truth after being kicked out by BJP, a Party he nurtured. So sad.
@@soonyanaidu7875 we don't need to agree on all aspects with anyone. Democracies need fearless critics of the establishment. Successful democracies need to keep executive in check.
Prashant Bhushan stands tall on the shoulders of giants--Socrates, Thoreau, Gandhiji and so many others. We stand with Prashant Bhushan #Humdekhenge
I quote my late father Prof Shanti Swarup (a freedom fighter) who passed at 96 in March 2020, "In the years since Independence, I became certain that Indian democracy had become firmly rooted; that freedom, and liberty, and faith in the judiciary as the conscience of the Constitution had taken hold, that these were settled matters. But this belief has been badly shaken by recent events. I refer of course to the undemocratic manner in which Article 370 was revoked; the thoroughly inadequate response of the Supreme Court to civil liberties cases; the blatantly unconstitutional CAA, NPR and NRC." Please see his videos on his concerns for our secular democracy and the independence of the SC.
ua-cam.com/video/PRR9EPNUUJw/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/OMjEzJ1JgZ0/v-deo.html
At this lowest point and darkest day in the history of our democracy, I declare that we are now in Baba Ambedkar's freedom struggle 2.0 with a demand for some variant of NYAY and a restoration of our constitutional democracy and its sacred institutions. In this struggle, we should bring together all our honest politicians including Rahul Gandhi, Moitra Mitra, Yogendra Yadav and Kanhaiya Kumar who have as our advisors elders like Rajmohan Gandhi, Arun Shourie, PM Manmohan Singh, Sonia Gandhi, Arun Shourie, Kapil Sibal, Anand Sharma. All those who clearly have no soft or hard Hindutva links. We stand with Prashant Bhushan #Humdekhenge
This is an amazing interview by Wire. Arun Shorie's excellent comments on the judgement and reference of 'The last seven pages' is the best citation. Hats off to Karan Thapar & Arun Shorie. This stays one of the best interviews of Mr Thapar & Shorie.
Arun shourie and excellent thoooooo yuuuck
It is always an eye opener listening to Mr Shourie. And, as far as Karan is concern there's no one better in India interviewing the guest.
This is pure journalism without bias not that CHOOTIYA COMING on republic tv at 9 pm and barking with his fellow paid dogs and bitches around him one new to their team /gang is kangna
@@shanshanz8637 haha
Third class Arun shourie.
*Prashant Bhushan sir, honest fighter against the corruption , great honest advocate in India,*
*Satyamev Jayate*
*Jay Hind sir 🇮🇳🙏🏻*
Down with Nazi Godse patriots in black gowns!
Indian history will not forget Mr. Bhushan for his fearless, honest tweets which are in no way an insult but an eye opener for the judiciary and Government. It is now immaterial for how long punishment is given but at least Indians will be proud some body had morals and strength to raise voice of millions.
@@vijaykumarjain4422 Sach bolane wala *Mahatma*. Sach Ko Saja dene wala*duratma*
I would like to thank from the bottom of my heart to "The Wire" for providing us with such useful and productive views of experts and protectors of democracy. Further, in the era when this nation is surrounded by fake news and misinformation new channels like this only can help this country to sail through this unprecedented crisis. We hope you will continue to do the same. Once again thank you and all the members of you team.
Kaun si duniya mein ho Mishraji
Kaun si duniya mein ho Mishraji!!!
@@abhr74 in an educated duniya
made my day man, i was have been thinking about Arun Shourie that haven't seen him in public space in a long while. good to see him well.
Prashant Bhushan stands tall on the shoulders of giants--Socrates, Thoreau, Gandhiji and so many others. We stand with Prashant Bhushan #Humdekhenge
I quote my late father Prof Shanti Swarup (a freedom fighter) who passed at 96 in March 2020, "In the years since Independence, I became certain that Indian democracy had become firmly rooted; that freedom, and liberty, and faith in the judiciary as the conscience of the Constitution had taken hold, that these were settled matters. But this belief has been badly shaken by recent events. I refer of course to the undemocratic manner in which Article 370 was revoked; the thoroughly inadequate response of the Supreme Court to civil liberties cases; the blatantly unconstitutional CAA, NPR and NRC." Please see his videos on his concerns for our secular democracy and the independence of the SC.
ua-cam.com/video/PRR9EPNUUJw/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/OMjEzJ1JgZ0/v-deo.html
At this lowest point and darkest day in the history of our democracy, I declare that we are now in Baba Ambedkar's freedom struggle 2.0 with a demand for some variant of NYAY and a restoration of our constitutional democracy and its sacred institutions. In this struggle, we should bring together all our honest politicians including Rahul Gandhi, Moitra Mitra, Yogendra Yadav and Kanhaiya Kumar who have as our advisors elders like Rajmohan Gandhi, Arun Shourie, PM Manmohan Singh, Sonia Gandhi, Arun Shourie, Kapil Sibal, Anand Sharma. All those who clearly have no soft or hard Hindutva links. We stand with Prashant Bhushan #Humdekhenge
Indeed; good to see him well; as well as at his incisive best.
/// HATS OFF TO HONEST AND TRUE NATIONALIST MR. PRASHANT BHUSHAN ///
/// HATS OFF TO HONEST AND TRUE NATIONALIST MR. PRASHANT BHUSHAN ///
/// HATS OFF TO HONEST AND TRUE NATIONALIST MR. PRASHANT BHUSHAN ///
Hail India. Stand by Prashant bhushan
#iamwithprashantbhushan
@@mnc392 you can't see beyond politics and it's bosses
Thats why he was beaten very honourably in his chamber by nationalist forces for his open support to Kasmiri seperatists
@@mr.x1923 one who takes law in their hand do not believe in law of the land. In local parlance "goondas", and you feel proud on their action ...? Wah!
@@mnc392 bhakt you are happy , because you don't use your vital organ
Mr.Thapar and Mr. Shourie, when I was doing LL.M. in Constitutional Law from the University of Bombay 1982-1983,I was taught that if there was another Court above the Supreme Court, half of its decisions would be set aside.
Well said sir
True indeed ❗Good thought to ponder over ❗Also equally if there was another over that , the consequences could be the same for the other half as well !
So what is the real problem - Think about it - would be an eye opener !
What a powerful interview, Mr Thapar!! It will scintillate even the future generations!
The moot point is if a person is unable to absorb criticism,is he entitled to occupy the post of a judge of a court or render justice or even protect anyone, intolerance galore.
Same can be said about PRASHANT , WIRE , NDTV etc 😂😂😂 Why create confusion if u lost the battle , it means your view point must be respected 🤧
@@rksharma2220 sir,they r not holding constitutional posts
@@RoseRose-uu3ps But criticism for the sake of criticism WILL MAKE A GENIUS LOOK DWARF . MR SHOURI is an excellent man BUT he miscalculated that MODI is a Push-Over . He was sure that he is going to be next FM and so is the case of Eccentric Genius Mr . Swamy . Your Loyalty should be with your COUNTRY even if u r in opposition 🙏
@@rksharma2220 my way or highway for these leftist rascals.
@@abhinavsrivastava8615 😂😂😂 EXPOSED
They took up a private person, Arnab Goswami's case of Police not to file an FIR on him - as if this is more important than J&K or cases on CAA
When CJI Sitting on bike owned BJP member surely it means he is in favour of BJP
Now that the SC is taking up cases arbitrarily, it's clear the SC of today is not doing whatt it was supposed to do by the Constitution... 370 removal - we will look into that later.
CAA- We will take it up later.
Electoral bonds- later
Habeas corpus, judge loya case, bhima koregaon-- we will hear them later.
Arnab goswami petition, and Prashant Bhushan contempt case--- These are of grave concerns for our country and democracy, we willhear it now.
We should ensure that collegium system of courts should end that only last hope in our judiciary until there is transparency in appointment of judges nothing is going to change
Yes . Arnab case is important . What is wrong
We The People CAA and 370 are correct legislation’s passed by parliament . No need to hear and waste court time. All others will be taken up once pandemic is over .
I am very much thankful to you sir,to arrange this interview with respected janab Arun shorie saheb.He is a true legend,i have lot of respect and regard for both of you ,sir.I enjoyed every word of ,when the two legend were talking during this interview.We are lucky enough that we are having such a great personality.I pray for both of you,sir.🤲
Good to hear from Sir Arun Shoueir and Sir.Karan Thapar . Living Almighty God bless both for spreading Truth.
When crores of people criticizing SCI and other judges of High court and Supreme Courts why the SC selectively taking so moto cases of contempt of court and why not taking other crores of people the SC fabricated the
against Prasant Bhushan when the judges seems to be afraid face him in the court, so the best way to silence Bushan voice both in court and outside is, to put him either behind the bar or some other punishment on the advice of their boss
The Modi and BJP government in the last six years controlled ED, I.T., CBI ECI. and also high court and Supreme and killed the democracy in India and the protector of constitution are part of this dictator ship rule where the BJP had no
Prashant Bhushan stands tall on the shoulders of giants--Socrates, Thoreau, Gandhiji and so many others. We stand with Prashant Bhushan #Humdekhenge
I quote my late father Prof Shanti Swarup (a freedom fighter) who passed at 96 in March 2020, "In the years since Independence, I became certain that Indian democracy had become firmly rooted; that freedom, and liberty, and faith in the judiciary as the conscience of the Constitution had taken hold, that these were settled matters. But this belief has been badly shaken by recent events. I refer of course to the undemocratic manner in which Article 370 was revoked; the thoroughly inadequate response of the Supreme Court to civil liberties cases; the blatantly unconstitutional CAA, NPR and NRC." Please see his videos on his concerns for our secular democracy and the independence of the SC.
ua-cam.com/video/PRR9EPNUUJw/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/OMjEzJ1JgZ0/v-deo.html
At this lowest point and darkest day in the history of our democracy, I declare that we are now in Baba Ambedkar's freedom struggle 2.0 with a demand for some variant of NYAY and a restoration of our constitutional democracy and its sacred institutions. In this struggle, we should bring together all our honest politicians including Rahul Gandhi, Moitra Mitra, Yogendra Yadav and Kanhaiya Kumar who have as our advisors elders like Rajmohan Gandhi, Arun Shourie, PM Manmohan Singh, Sonia Gandhi, Arun Shourie, Kapil Sibal, Anand Sharma. All those who clearly have no soft or hard Hindutva links. We stand with Prashant Bhushan #Humdekhenge
Mind Begs the Question:
If an ex-CJI accused of Rape,
Adjudicates own case,
If Current CJI was on panel,
Judiciary secure,prone to be Compromised?
All is well with brahminical rss india
National chauvinism will lead to dictatorship , here is the baby stage of it..let us vigil..
I will not be surprised if Karan and Shourie are charged with contempt. We are the largest democracy?
கோட்ஸே தேசபக்த நீதி புரட்டன்கள் வந்தேறி ஆரியனின் மனுஸ்ம்ரிதி படி வாயிலிருந்து பிறந்தவனுக்கு ஒரு நீதி, வாலிலிருந்து பிறநரதவனுக்கு ஒரு நீதி என்றே வழங்குவான்! காஞ்சி சங்கராச்சாரியை ஜெயிலில் போட்டானா? கோட்ஸே பயங்கரவாதி அத்வானி? பயங்கரவாதி மோடி? பயங்கரவாதி அமித்ஷா? இவர்களெல்லாம் நவீன இந்தியாவின் மகாத்மாக்கள்! காந்தி,நேரு,காமராஜ்,இராசகோபாலச்சாரி, சாஸ்த்ரி,தேவகவுடா,அப்துல் கலாம், பாரதி, திப்பு சுல்த்தான்,பகத் சிங் ஆகியோர் தேச துரோக பயங்கரவாதிகள்!
Anyone can accuse you too, that doesn't make anyone guilty.
Very true. At present Supreme Court is on trial !!
Also Supreme Court have shown the judges are so weak that the SC is trembling due to the two tweets of Prashant Bhusan.
அங்கே குசராத்து மாவீரன் பத்திரிகையாளர்களை சந்திக்கப் பயந்து நடுங்கி ஆறு வருடங்களாக ஓட்டம்! இங்கு ஊரடங்கில் சட்டத்துக்கு எதிராக பி.சே.பி பண முதலையின் ஐம்பது லட்ச மோட்டோர் பைக்கில, பத்து லட்ஷ லண்டன் சூட் அணிந்து அசத்திய அவர் எஜமான் பாணியில் ஊர் சுற்றிய மாவீரன் இரண்டு ட்வஈட்டுக்குப் பயந்து நடுங்கி, பதில் சொல்ல முடியாமல் கண் பிதுங்கி,ஒரு குற்றவாளி நீதியின் குரல்வளையை நெரித்துக் கொல்ல போலி சட்ட ஒழுங்கு மீறல் தண்டனை! தண்டிக்கப்பட வேண்டியவனே தண்டனை கொடுப்பதா? போப்டே பதவி விலகி, நாக்பூரில் ஐம்பது லட்ச பைக்கில் ஊர் சுத்தப்போ! எழுபதை நெருங்கும் கிழட்டு வாத்தியான் அறிவுறையைக் கேள்! கணக்கு வாத்தியாரிடம் முதுகில் அடிவாங்கிய அனுபவம் இல்லை போலும்! தண்டவாளத்தில் உழைக்கும் மக்கள் சாகிறார்கள்.போய் பார்க்கவில்லை; அவர்களுக்கு போக வேண்டிய நன் கொடைகளை ஒரு மகா திருடன் கோடிகளை திருடி தன் கணக்கில் போடுகிறான்.அரசாங்க பணம் பட்டப்பகலில் கொள்ளை.ஆனால் போப்டே கண்ணில் அது திருட்டுக்கணக்காக தெரியவில்லை! ஒன்றும் ஒன்றும் ஒன்று! தம்பி, நாக்பூரில் படித்தது எந்த பள்ளி? சட்டம் படித்தது பம்பாய் தேசப்பிதா அம்பேட்கர் கல்லூரியிலா வேறு கோட்ஸே கல்லூரியிலா? சட்டம் தெரியாமல் பதவிக்கு வந்தது எப்படி?
SC judges knows better they are guilty and accomplish with government in destroying democracy and truth.
the citizens of India already know that judiciary has already lost its trust since 2014 itself.
lol use burnol.
@@sksajidali5004 all decision in favour of BJP
@@abhinavsrivastava8615 such morons who do not even have an iota of wisdom n talk all senseless.
@@abhinavsrivastava8615 stop attacking each just use the brain to analyse facts. Intellectual leaders ask their followers to criticize them so that they correct themselves if there is any fault in their policy or action.
Prashant Bhushan stands tall on the shoulders of giants--Socrates, Thoreau, Gandhiji and so many others. We stand with Prashant Bhushan #Humdekhenge
I quote my late father Prof Shanti Swarup (a freedom fighter) who passed at 96 in March 2020, "In the years since Independence, I became certain that Indian democracy had become firmly rooted; that freedom, and liberty, and faith in the judiciary as the conscience of the Constitution had taken hold, that these were settled matters. But this belief has been badly shaken by recent events. I refer of course to the undemocratic manner in which Article 370 was revoked; the thoroughly inadequate response of the Supreme Court to civil liberties cases; the blatantly unconstitutional CAA, NPR and NRC." Please see his videos on his concerns for our secular democracy and the independence of the SC.
ua-cam.com/video/PRR9EPNUUJw/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/OMjEzJ1JgZ0/v-deo.html
At this lowest point and darkest day in the history of our democracy, I declare that we are now in Baba Ambedkar's freedom struggle 2.0 with a demand for some variant of NYAY and a restoration of our constitutional democracy and its sacred institutions. In this struggle, we should bring together all our honest politicians including Rahul Gandhi, Moitra Mitra, Yogendra Yadav and Kanhaiya Kumar who have as our advisors elders like Rajmohan Gandhi, Arun Shourie, PM Manmohan Singh, Sonia Gandhi, Arun Shourie, Kapil Sibal, Anand Sharma. All those who clearly have no soft or hard Hindutva links. We stand with Prashant Bhushan #Humdekhenge
Without listening to his interview; I am
Thanking you.
Karan for interviewing Arun Shorie...🙏💖🎵
Excellent interview with many valid points.. the SC should watch this before sentencing Bhushan!
When retired judge started taking BJP political office, then doubt arises, SC is highly respected post for justice, so don't lure our judge offering them post of politics after retirement
Good work must be rewarded; can't leave that for the next life.
यह नई प्रथा नहीं है
Ache din only for supreme court judges
MADAM you are very much right. Further I wish to say these type of justice are true white collar criminals.
Many judges served as a Congress mp and hold offices. Please check this too mam.
What Justice we can expect from CJ who is publicly enjoying luxury of a political party which is now dictating the outcome of every case in the highest court
👍
Highest/supreme institution are eroding our country's democracy internationally.RSS is interfering in every imp government decision it's very dangerous???
Supreme has said repeating those quote is also wrong and u can be taken to court for the contempt.
We need people like Prashant Bhusan at this critical juncture. We all should support him.
S. L.
This interview was worth watching. A very honest n intellectual talk by Arun shouri deserves a high appreciation 👍.
BJP and RSS are using Supreme Court Judges with carrots and sticks to control judiciary. The largest democracy has become a Banna Republic. They destroying secular characters in persuit of Hinduvata.
@@mnc392 in case of shabrimala so call right wing were crying from rooftop,
Black Day for Indians
Credibility Lost By such Revenge By Our Systems
They have captured each and every institution and are on their way of ruining the basic fabric of the country.
Theses so called liberals kicked out from darbari jobs from Delhi and now only one job is remaining " criticism of suprime court if there narrative doesn't work". Government not appointed SC judges . Only SC appointed the judges in their own choices.
SORRY FORGOT TO SAY--HOW LUCKY WE ARE TO HAVE GREAT ARUN SHOURIE BACK IN GOOD HEALTH. I WISH HIM MANY DECADES OF BLOOMING HEALTH SO THAT HE CAN CONTINUE TO ENLIGHTEN US.
The judiciary is in ICU. There is least chance of recovery so long BJP is uprooted.The perception of Indian juctice system almost matches with the media tuning to the line of the party in dispensation.
जनतंत्र में केवल जनता की राय सर्वोच्च होती है
Thank you.Corona Virus has blackened their eyes!
The doctors need replacement urgently ❗
Presence of 2 peanut size brains bobade n misra is the issue. Did court asked bobade to publish picture in lockdown to make it contempt of court? That's so stupid.
Its bike of BJP MLA
Both are mouth born Aryan nuts who act like clowns in Modi circus! Black gowns to blacken justice? Begone Godse patriotic perverters of justice! Quit to save the judiciary!
Yes, but who put them there? Prashant Bhushan stands tall on the shoulders of giants--Socrates, Thoreau, Gandhiji and so many others. We stand with Prashant Bhushan #Humdekhenge
I quote my late father Prof Shanti Swarup (a freedom fighter) who passed at 96 in March 2020, "In the years since Independence, I became certain that Indian democracy had become firmly rooted; that freedom, and liberty, and faith in the judiciary as the conscience of the Constitution had taken hold, that these were settled matters. But this belief has been badly shaken by recent events. I refer of course to the undemocratic manner in which Article 370 was revoked; the thoroughly inadequate response of the Supreme Court to civil liberties cases; the blatantly unconstitutional CAA, NPR and NRC." Please see his videos on his concerns for our secular democracy and the independence of the SC.
ua-cam.com/video/PRR9EPNUUJw/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/OMjEzJ1JgZ0/v-deo.html
At this lowest point and darkest day in the history of our democracy, I declare that we are now in Baba Ambedkar's freedom struggle 2.0 with a demand for some variant of NYAY and a restoration of our constitutional democracy and its sacred institutions. In this struggle, we should bring together all our honest politicians including Rahul Gandhi, Moitra Mitra, Yogendra Yadav and Kanhaiya Kumar who have as our advisors elders like Rajmohan Gandhi, Arun Shourie, PM Manmohan Singh, Sonia Gandhi, Arun Shourie, Kapil Sibal, Anand Sharma. All those who clearly have no soft or hard Hindutva links. We stand with Prashant Bhushan #Humdekhenge
Souri Ji u r welcome. India has many hope from u. Salute u sir for conducting such interview . SC should show his nail ,tooth and iron hand in justice Lohiya case.
*very right and grateful interview 👌👍🙏🏻🇮🇳*
At this stage people are terrified that we may lose our hard-earned democracy
Only in dreams we can enjoy fruit of independence and shelter in Constitution.
@@vijaykumarjain4422 do you mean we have to turn a blind eye to the abuse of power by these insolent judges, is tht wat u r saying. have some shame to speak in defense of CJI.
The hierarchy of priorities of the Hon'ble SC seems to have gone awry. With due respect to the Hon'ble judges Iwould like to submit : Kindly do not diminish this great Institution you belong to .
To paraphrase Shakespeare :
It is great to have a giant's strength ; but to use it like a giant is tyrannous.
Timely reminder! Thank you.
Totally true that giant's strength should never be used like a giant.
I stand with & support Prashant Bhushan..👍👍🇮🇳🇮🇳
How wonderfully forthright and articulate ? This interview is what interviews are meant for !
This man needs to be inducted as a Supreme Court judge for life ! Wonder how many judges of the current higher courts can match his judicial knowledge and grasp of the issues .
He has shred the motorcycle judgement of Arun Mishra ! Credit to Bobde not sitting in the case !
The nation would be relieved to see Arun Shourie back with his intellect just as sharp🙏🙏🙏🙏
Happy to see Arun Sir back.
It's a privilege and a pleasure to see Mr Arun Shourie ( good to see him in good healtb) being interviewed by you, once again, after a long time ! Thank Mr Karen Thapar.
Mr Thapar and Mr Shourie,Mr Madhu Limaye, a great parliamentarian once said that the judges of the Supreme Court were residing in ivory towers.This is from my memory and Mr Limaye made this remark after the Bank Nationlization case.
Why there was no contempt on Balasaheb thackery, when he called , i dont believe in this supreme court at front of Rajat Sharma's aap ki Adalat ..
If that's the case 15% population will go in.. 🤣🤣 pair pe khuladi kyu mar rahe ho.. Miya
Oh my God! Chief Justice was sitting on 50 lakh MC? Is it true?
Surender Toora CJI didn’t tell the difference of feel he felt when sitting on the seat of MC of 50 lakhs and the seat he sat in in supreme court
Yes
2 Intellectual Enlightened Minds Discuss the Disturbing Contempt Judgement ...
Delight....
Sir Arun Shourie Love Respect and Prayers ..God Preserve Men like U ❤💞🙌💫🙏
I am very happy feeling and listen interview by Arun Shourie
Very glorious interview
I wish these discussions and editorials in newspapers, on the SC's verdict somehow reaches the judges.
Of course they are all aware of such interviews. But as long as their master is with them they care two figs for Arun Shourie.
Prashant Bhushan stands tall on the shoulders of giants--Socrates, Thoreau, Gandhiji and so many others. We stand with Prashant Bhushan #Humdekhenge
I quote my late father Prof Shanti Swarup (a freedom fighter) who passed at 96 in March 2020, "In the years since Independence, I became certain that Indian democracy had become firmly rooted; that freedom, and liberty, and faith in the judiciary as the conscience of the Constitution had taken hold, that these were settled matters. But this belief has been badly shaken by recent events. I refer of course to the undemocratic manner in which Article 370 was revoked; the thoroughly inadequate response of the Supreme Court to civil liberties cases; the blatantly unconstitutional CAA, NPR and NRC." Please see his videos on his concerns for our secular democracy and the independence of the SC.
ua-cam.com/video/PRR9EPNUUJw/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/OMjEzJ1JgZ0/v-deo.html
At this lowest point and darkest day in the history of our democracy, I declare that we are now in Baba Ambedkar's freedom struggle 2.0 with a demand for some variant of NYAY and a restoration of our constitutional democracy and its sacred institutions. In this struggle, we should bring together all our honest politicians including Rahul Gandhi, Moitra Mitra, Yogendra Yadav and Kanhaiya Kumar who have as our advisors elders like Rajmohan Gandhi, Arun Shourie, PM Manmohan Singh, Sonia Gandhi, Arun Shourie, Kapil Sibal, Anand Sharma. All those who clearly have no soft or hard Hindutva links. We stand with Prashant Bhushan #Humdekhenge
We are in dire need of you.You are the one who can show the Mirror to our So called democratic govt.
Remember this is an EVM government.
Glad to have viewed this video. It's a great intellectual discussion and learning.
Excellent,sir.What a great finish.Amazing.🙏
It's not the Prashanth's tweets that lowered the image of the courts , but the successivejudgements and behavior of the judges of theory's for the last 6 years
Things have become so bad that we have to explicitly say it out loud what is tangible enough to be seen.
They are not insecure. They are stubbornly representing an ideology.
Murali Kirshna very true
What a elucidation by a great Mr shouri on current state of affairs. GOD BLESS HIM. Take care stay safe.
Crores people know that all judgement are taking according the consent of rulling parting. Why sc don't filled contempt of court agaiñst crore people sumoto.?
Prashant Bhushan stands tall on the shoulders of giants--Socrates, Thoreau, Gandhiji and so many others. We stand with Prashant Bhushan #Humdekhenge
I quote my late father Prof Shanti Swarup (a freedom fighter) who passed at 96 in March 2020, "In the years since Independence, I became certain that Indian democracy had become firmly rooted; that freedom, and liberty, and faith in the judiciary as the conscience of the Constitution had taken hold, that these were settled matters. But this belief has been badly shaken by recent events. I refer of course to the undemocratic manner in which Article 370 was revoked; the thoroughly inadequate response of the Supreme Court to civil liberties cases; the blatantly unconstitutional CAA, NPR and NRC." Please see his videos on his concerns for our secular democracy and the independence of the SC.
ua-cam.com/video/PRR9EPNUUJw/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/OMjEzJ1JgZ0/v-deo.html
At this lowest point and darkest day in the history of our democracy, I declare that we are now in Baba Ambedkar's freedom struggle 2.0 with a demand for some variant of NYAY and a restoration of our constitutional democracy and its sacred institutions. In this struggle, we should bring together all our honest politicians including Rahul Gandhi, Moitra Mitra, Yogendra Yadav and Kanhaiya Kumar who have as our advisors elders like Rajmohan Gandhi, Arun Shourie, PM Manmohan Singh, Sonia Gandhi, Arun Shourie, Kapil Sibal, Anand Sharma. All those who clearly have no soft or hard Hindutva links. We stand with Prashant Bhushan #Humdekhenge
Admirable and just discussion. Salute to both of you. It's the need of the hour.
Indian judiciary is matching with courts of pakistan , Bangladesh, Maldives, in terms of integrity,trust and belief of people of these nations. Of late Courts of India failing nation n its people all the times these days. Prashant is the voice of crores of citizens of this country.
With due respect disagree Pakistan Supreme court shows spine to disqualify a corrupt P.M. Nawaz Shareef
Many mouth born Aryan judges outnumber tail born Dravidian judges, and the Aryan black gowns sent their own Dravidian fellow judge Justice Karnan, who headed the Calcutta high court to jail, and dismissed the murder of fellow judge Lohia by Nagpur Nazis to free Amit Shah as "suicide"! They legalised trespassing as a lawful activity by Nazi thugs to take over the property of the victims!
Watch 3years a head , there will be great Change in the world Political Scenario.
How wonderfully presented ! Simply amazed ? Many thanks and a very high regard Mr. Karan Thapar... Keep continue... Yes peoples are the judges to judge the judges...
There are no blasphemy laws in India,but Indian judiciary has equated contempt of court into Judicial blasphemy.
BRAVO ! BRAVO !! BRAVO !!! No WORDS to describe this INTERVIEW. These TWO BRAVE & VERY OUTSTANDING INTELLECTUALS of OUR TIME DESRVE OUR THANKS AND GRATEFULNESS FOR STANDING UP FOR US AND SPEAKING ON OUR BEHALF. PRASHANT BHUSHAN MAKES A TRIO WITH THEM.
The biggest contempt of SC was when four SC Judges held a public press conference few years back and raised questions about the institution of Supreme Court itself. Why wasn't any action taken then ?
Well said Arun Shourie. Democracy is threatened when SC behaves in such a partial manner. We dont need Prashant Bhushan to influence our minds on SC judges. We r Intellugent enough to see how democracy is crumbling for the last 6 years n how institutions r favouring the present govt..
Arun Shourie answered many questions bravely without any fears. Great
And Modi is hiding from the press for six long years, the one who boasted of a 56" chest!
Dear Arun Shourie, After many months, had the opportunity of seeing & listening to you. I am ever grateful to Mr Karan Thapar. For vibrant Democracy to survive & thrive, we need a voice of sanity. God bless you Take good care of yourself & family
Gangster paradise!! India is heading towards a very dark age.
Yes since very long sir..it is the ineffeciency of the all knowing but spineless citizens.. we ourselves don't have the sense of responsibility towards our nation.
Yes India was in dark last 60 years of congress government
Seedha seedha bolo ruling wala Hindu desh chahiye, rest should go away. But ek Baat Yaad rakho, Hindu dharam ka Naam kharaab ho raha hai. Pehle sab ko bohot zaroori hai ye jan na ki Hindu dharm sikhata kya hai.
All prime minister of India expect manmohan singh were Hindu... Hindu will be in always in majority becoz High population and the founding fathers of country were Hindu the harm to India was done by Congress due to there policy
@@ravikirantelewar7738 it's not about they were Hindu or any other religion. Hindu zyada hai ya kum doesn't matter. But what matters is be a good Hindu. Don't be a killer or a murderer. Don't let anyone fool you or teach you how to be a good hindu. Learn yourself because the world has become too deceptive. Orange used to be my favourite colour but now I like it less because I associate it with something so evil.
Good to see Shourie sahib back .. absolutely love listening to him .. God bless him
This is what happens when you “work from home” doesn’t matter if you’re a judge 😂
lol
It's always a pleasure to watch and listen you Shourie Sahab.
The way Karan Taper puts question, it answers it in full... 😅
Great to see Mr. Shourie is back. A wonderful discussion.
Till a few years ago I was thinking India’s judiciary especially the higher judiciary was always a hope of last resort for justice
Hope shattered from 2014 onward.
Marvelous interview. I am pleased to listen two great personalities and feel that democracy of our country will definitely survive. This is a temporary face and people wil defeat anti-democratic forces. Lastly I will praise Mr Prashant Bhushan who raised his voice so strongly.
Arun Shourie is correct on BJP person motor cycle of 55 lakh government personal must not even sit on it
Good to watch Arun shouri ji such a long time a intellectual person have to live long for India
Harasser Is deciding His own Case This is called Make in India
No Sir, made in India of Modi, by Modi and for Modi to destroy the India of Dr Ambedkar's dream, Nehru's vision of a free, peaceful godly, literate, united, secular, scientific, progressive, happy, democratic, prosperous and righteous India, and the democratic socialist India of King Maker Kamaraj.Quit Modi Quit!
Atmnirbhar, khudmukhtar and self dependent in one man
Nothing: made in India / make in India. Everything: MAD in India
This was a WONDERFUL and EXCEPTIONAL interview. The SC should have a "suo moto viewing".
Now people have completely lost faith in judiciary when it came to the notice of the pulic the fixing of benches in the time of Deepak Mishra. In continuance to it the verdicts come in favor of crimes like karnataka, maharashtra and indifference to Rajasthan issue when there was attempt to topple the government.
Sirs, Sometime back one retired judge of West Bengal High court had cast observations on Judges of Madras High court the same judge was arrested and no action was taken on his complaint
Nice to Shourie Sir, what a comeback. God bless
It is a treat when two intelligent people talk to each other is what we experienced after seeing this interview.. With due respect to the supreme Court and the judges, few thoughts that come to my mind in the context of the recent judgment on contempt given incase of Mr Prashant bhushan..
1. Was there no contempt when four sitting judges came out in public criticising openly the functioning of the supreme Court??
2. Can a couple of tweets tarnish the image of the CJI or his office or the supremacy of the court?? Should the supreme Court take these tweets so seriously in order to pass a judgement running over hundred pages??
3. In the entire judgment, as Mr Arun has pointed out why there is no discussion as to exactly how and where the contempt has taken place??
4. Can a criticism be a contempt??
5. If someone gets so hurt by a tweet, then why not file a defamation suit in personal capacity against the person writing that tweet?? Why to blow this issue out of proportion??
6. People holding top positions rarely have a distinction between their personal and professional life and this applies to all the professions..
It is indeed worrying to see the direction in which our country is heading where a voice of dissent is seen as a contempt... A word of criticism against a government is seen as an act of sedition..
2 brilliant personalities discussing another brilliant person of india👏👏
Lovely Choice of words
You Stalwarts r second to none in terms of Prophetic Vocabulary
Thanks for Educating
Absolutely delighted to see and hear Arun Shourie on the show....Great mind with clarity of thoughts and sense of judgement..wanna hear more certainly....Karan as always the best guy for the job...wow
NO JUDGE FROM THE SC IS ABOVE CRITICISM. ALSO CORRUPTION IS NOT ALIEN TO SC.
Very good 👍 speech, thank you very much appreciated,arun shourie
अंग्रेज तो चले गये लेकिन देश को काले अंग्रेज़ो के हाथ में छोड़ गये।
souls of our freedom fighters, father of nation, architect of constitutions will be with mr.prashanth bhusan.
It took a lot of thought to designing an institution like our Supreme Court. Much bigger men were involved in creating and make it functional. Some real men and women made it trust worthy. It took only one comedian and few pretenders to destroy it. What a tragedy! But, that is the rule nature. It Wil will take a lot of time, efforts by some real human beings to rebuild it. That too, if they come around.
Very nice to hear you both. Good day.
Supreme Court has already lowered their image in the eyes of common citizen...
U R wrong.. now onwards supreme court will not tolerate SHITT??
Excellent. Magnificent. A most scholarly interview. Arun Shourie is an incomparable and the boldest scholar in lndia today. Perhaps in the world. My humblest regards to him.
// TXS. & GREETINGS TO ALL MATURED PENALISTS FOR BRAVE AND HONEST PRESENTATION ///
"Insecurities bordering on paranoia." Such apt description....Alas, such small men are adorning such prestigious position....Great interview The Wire.
Really, is the judiciary so flimsy a nose that drops off with a sneeze??
Then, is it worth having?
That is the best anology I have heard in years..Great.
Rightly said.
Well conducted interview bringing out prevailing infirmity in our system
/// SC IS THE GATE WAY TO " RAJAY ~ SABHA " FOR SELECTED FEW RETIRING JUDGES - ACHHA HAI ///
/// SC IS THE GATE WAY TO " RAJAY ~ SABHA " FOR SELECTED FEW RETIRING JUDGES - ACHHA HAI ///
/// SC IS THE GATE WAY TO " RAJAY ~ SABHA " FOR SELECTED FEW RETIRING JUDGES - ACHHA HAI ///
Worth to watch it...!
Thanks for thoughtful conversation.
Nation required this kind of interview on the main stream media.
🎓
You talking about Judge Mishra? He is acting like the HMV's add line "His Master's Voice"
He is the handyman black sheep of the Gujarati Corporate thieves in the Supreme Court, and a mouth born Aryan too!
Prashant Bhushan stands tall on the shoulders of giants--Socrates, Thoreau, Gandhiji and so many others. We stand with Prashant Bhushan #Humdekhenge
I quote my late father Prof Shanti Swarup (a freedom fighter) who passed at 96 in March 2020, "In the years since Independence, I became certain that Indian democracy had become firmly rooted; that freedom, and liberty, and faith in the judiciary as the conscience of the Constitution had taken hold, that these were settled matters. But this belief has been badly shaken by recent events. I refer of course to the undemocratic manner in which Article 370 was revoked; the thoroughly inadequate response of the Supreme Court to civil liberties cases; the blatantly unconstitutional CAA, NPR and NRC." Please see his videos on his concerns for our secular democracy and the independence of the SC.
ua-cam.com/video/PRR9EPNUUJw/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/OMjEzJ1JgZ0/v-deo.html
At this lowest point and darkest day in the history of our democracy, I declare that we are now in Baba Ambedkar's freedom struggle 2.0 with a demand for some variant of NYAY and a restoration of our constitutional democracy and its sacred institutions. In this struggle, we should bring together all our honest politicians including Rahul Gandhi, Moitra Mitra, Yogendra Yadav and Kanhaiya Kumar who have as our advisors elders like Rajmohan Gandhi, Arun Shourie, PM Manmohan Singh, Sonia Gandhi, Arun Shourie, Kapil Sibal, Anand Sharma. All those who clearly have no soft or hard Hindutva links. We stand with Prashant Bhushan #Humdekhenge
Definitely to shake the confidence of the public in justice system by judges
/// WE ARE LIVING IN FOOLS' PARADISE MITRON ///
Its feeling so nice to see Arun shourieji back again.miss him from a long time.happy to see him as energatic and mindful as before. he is a true and bold voice in this atmosphere when voice of discontent regarded as contempt of court or disloyalty to nation.the atmosphere is such that people fear to say truth.emergency is here in disguise of nationalism.
A mind blowing interview with too many facts presented for the people at a time when speaking and listening a truth has become a thing of golden times.
The reasons given by the Supreme Court has exposed its own hollowness , by writing a 109 pages , full of sound and fury without any substance !!!!!
A very sad situation, these three judges have placed themselves in !!!
The criminal politicians and their criminal acts should have been dealt with firmly by this court which it doesn't seem to be concerned with....... otherwise how can so many MPs with criminal cases reach the Parliament ?
India is serious drought of intellectuals like Mr. Shouire......
Yes, it was a pleasant surprise to see Mr Shorie after a long interval. I think he met with an accident and got head injury. PM Modi met him personally while he was recouping. Then only it was a sigh of relief for me.
Never silent infront of suppression
After watching this Interview one can safely conclude That Prashant Bhushan has won the Case in the Court of Public Opinion.
Insecurity boardering paranoia : a perfect description.
Always a pleasure to listen to mr. Arun. Thanks Wire and Karan as usual👍