They don't call it rush because then the minion doesn't get the Charge bonus from Warsong Commander, _and_ it will get the bonuses of being a Rush minion (such as Woodcutter's Axe Deathrattle). So it changes the interactions with the cards.
@@alarmoboterinokripperino2713 Regardless of whether it makes it better, it still changes the purpose of the card, all because it's too hard for people to read like 10 words.
@@chayse2556 I would argue that weird, uncommon card interactions were not the intent of the card. Changing it makes it nicer to read and a good way of introducing newer players to the rush mechanic. No one uses it currently and it's not like they haven't changed the card multiple times before. hell the problems they had with this card were the onus for creating Rush to begin with... at this point just change its name to Rush! and fix the text.
Blizzard doesn’t change cards like “charge” because they don’t like rewording old text. That’s why cards before the “enrage” keyword was launched still contain the words “When damaged: “ like angry chicken. This also applies to many cards with joust effects before joust was introduced
Fun Fact: The "Charge" card actually works ever so slightly different to Rush. If you have an exact scenario where you can cast the spell on a minion in your hand (usage of Illidan and other cards), you can actually grant that effect to a minion in your hand. Wait one turn, and then the minion you cast it on can now immediately hit the opponent in the face. (How do I know this? Because I have tested multiple different possible hand buff effects. Charge // Poisonous // Lifesteal // Taunt work. Divine Shield doesn't. Deathrattle has a unique effect in which the minion will have a deathrattle but the deathrattle doesn't do anything.)
@@deday6525 It's a year but who cares. You can have a combination of illidan (spawn 2/1 when you play a card), knife juggler (do 1 damage to random enemy when something is spawned), two explosive sheeps on opponent side (1/1 with deathrattle deal 2 damage to all minions) and, also on opponents side, that one rogue minion that has as deathrattle 'play sap'. So with this setup, whenever you play a card let's say give your minion (with more than 4 health) charge, this happens: - illidan spawns before the card you played is triggered (!) - juggler shoots sheep - 2 sheep explode, 4 damage to all minions, killing all minions expect your minion with more than 4 health - deathrattle minion triggers sap on your minion, returning it to your hand - Only now your actual card effect is triggered, so you give charge to the minion you have currently in hand A very weird interaction but kinda funny and logical in some way.
And clearly it would be too much work to change the text on a card. But seriously they nerfed that card so hard that nobody uses it anyway so I can see why its low on the priority list.
"I'm being a better warrior then my opponent. He started off as Garrosh and transitioned into a goblin. I started as a woman and transitioned into an evil orc death knight." -Toast 2018.
@@danielmaster8776 probably because the enemy is armored and dealing one damage to that isnt worth the durability. Better use to clear a minion than chip away 1 armor.
well charge is actually different from rush, even without attacking heroes. And not so much in its effect, but how other cards interact with it. The only difference in effect is if you have a minion that can attack and use this card, it actually just denies a attack to a hero while adding rush to a minion doesnt do anything really
There is another difference. Warsong Commander buffs charge minion, so it will buff cards didnt have charge in original but buffed by that spell. And that Witchwood axe (dont remember full name) which buffs rush minions makes a difference too.
These things are all technically true, but doubtfully considered on why they didn't change the text to rush. Simpler answer- they don't use new keywords on classic cards because they phase out new key words, and don't want to change the classic cards over and over.
There's a Kibler video where he also managed to get 4 sherazins at once in the board as a warrior, hilarious video, I think the title is "Magni, corpse flower gardener", look it up :)
The reason why they don't change it to rusg is because rush is not surely ment to stay for future expansions and not fade away like inspire like adapt and some other key words.
The card charge has a different effect to rush... If you play charge on a minion it cannot attack face that turn even if it was played last turn, if the card gave rush it could attack as normal. It would be important with cards like yogg or deck of wonders where charge could get randomly played on a minion you wanted to hit face with that turn.
I love match-ups against warriors who think that they actually have a chance of winning even tho you have already won from the start by just playing academic espionage but they still don't concede and they let you have fun
Hello Toast, Imagine when you send Yogg, and somehow the spells give you a (can attack face) then a random "Charge" spell comes from yogg, now that can't attack the heroe... * Blizzard big thonk *
I like double elekk and then prep espionage prep espionage..... its not very likely to happen but that is 20 new cards with 20 duplicates. On the other hand, when you elekk and espionage on turn 4 into priest deathknight..... they usually concede.
renaming the card effect of "Charge" is because the very essence of giving a minion "charge" but can't attack the hero is like a buff when you're running the "Warsong Commander". giving a minion rush wouldn't get buffed by warsong commander. just saying my thoughts on this one
If u use it on a minion which already has charge, it wont allow it to attack face, but if u give a charge minion rush with e.g. Houndmaster Shaw, it will still able to attack face, There is a difference. Free video idea.
Damn, someone make an animation of it! xD At least of some moments, such as Garrosh stomping on a Garrosh, stomping on a Garrosh and getting 4 Sherazin's xD
If you play faceless manipulator on a minion with charge, it will be able to attack heroes. If you would copy a minion with rush, it wouldn't be able to.
So uh how good is your win rate on this deck... i tried playing it around rank 5 and the best I could do was a 1 win streak with around 3 losses in between.. everything is just so fast now I was never able to make it to turn 10 most of the time
Ya I play Kiblers version.. I wont deny that they probably play around more stuff than me due to how much they play, but I also wont say I am a horrible player.. I have been playing for a long time too, know how the decks work, what is being run in them, when things are normally played and what might they being setting up to play, etc. I just get screwed by opponent rng everytime I play this deck
Haha, see I knew I wasn't the only one thinking that it should be renamed to Rush. But it can't. It's succinctly different, as giving a minion rush after it's already been able to attack previously, won't stop it from going face. They could rename it to "Give a minion Rush, it can't attack heroes this turn", though, I guess.
I had a similar game but I was the warrior and I got down to 3 health and then zilliaxed a middle launcher, then dr boomed the next turn to snowball to win the game with 48 health/armor
Rush does not benefit from the card that gives 1 attack to all minions with charge, charge that cannot attack heroes in that sense is better on the otherhand charge doesn't benefit from Rush synergy.
Looking back at this and since rastakhan's rumble is out, charge should be called rush instead because it means the same thing but only " give a minion rush" , which is the same meaning as the spell effect for charge
Well, then you probably have realized by now that there is a difference between the card Charge and and the keyword Rush. The difference may not occur very often, but I have seen it happen. If your minion for example can attack this turn normally, but for some reason Charge gets played on it (Scroll of Wonder, Tess Greymane, etc.), the option to attack the enemy hero is now no longer available. Also, I guess it would interact with Charge specific cards (Warsong Commander), but not enable Rush cards (Woodcutter's Axe).
yes but the reason they didn't change it isn't because of some minor quirky interactions but just because they can't be bothered to change it even though it would make sense... but tbh it's probably quite hard to change a card text when you only have a small indie company at your disposal
I was screaming for him to use shield slam for finisher.. I forget it can only target minions. I guess that would be way too OP if shield slam could hit face.
Toast is acting stupid. If you put that spell on a minion, and then copy that minion, the copy has charge and can attack face. It's different than just giving it rush. It's like Devilsaur. It doesn't have rush. If you pull it out of your deck or copy it with Menagerie Warden, the copied Devilsaur will be able to attack face.
@@Dotoricus first of all u mean board control, which he has to clear for yes, but he floated 9 mana so he couldve heropowered twice and then attack the 3/1 to clear the board without giving the opponent 2 health.. small things like these is what i am thinking about every turn bc every hp matters in this game :D
Wow, rogue is so fucking op. Blizzard nerfed the real winaxe, then gave rogue its own, which also gives 5 armor and hits adjacent minions, AND ONLY COSTS ONE MANA?!?!?!?!?!?!?!1
The card charge is not changed because rush is diffrent than what the card read, if you give a minion normal rush it still can attack face 2 turn after you placed the minion, but with the card charge they wont be able to do so, the card that you do need to expect a change from is Y'Saarj, Rage Unbound because he is just recruit a random minion at the end of the turn
Remember when Valeera turned into Garrosh's corpse and then rose back from the dead two times to beat living Garrosh who somehow became a goblin?
John Smith yeah that was a super important lore moment
Is it really rising from the dead if you are already dead?
i member.
Ahh it was a good cinematic
An important lore moment? Involving Valeera but that's unheard of!
**give a friendly minion F A S T**
@@gamebarlang2193 You don't
They don't call it rush because then the minion doesn't get the Charge bonus from Warsong Commander, _and_ it will get the bonuses of being a Rush minion (such as Woodcutter's Axe Deathrattle). So it changes the interactions with the cards.
First comment I've seen that makes the same point I was thinking
Chayse Poikea Then again, that would be a reasonable card, probably better.
Warsong Commander...man RIP in peace, never seen a nerf become a total nuke like that one got.
@@alarmoboterinokripperino2713 Regardless of whether it makes it better, it still changes the purpose of the card, all because it's too hard for people to read like 10 words.
@@chayse2556 I would argue that weird, uncommon card interactions were not the intent of the card. Changing it makes it nicer to read and a good way of introducing newer players to the rush mechanic. No one uses it currently and it's not like they haven't changed the card multiple times before. hell the problems they had with this card were the onus for creating Rush to begin with...
at this point just change its name to Rush! and fix the text.
Blizzard doesn’t change cards like “charge” because they don’t like rewording old text. That’s why cards before the “enrage” keyword was launched still contain the words “When damaged: “ like angry chicken. This also applies to many cards with joust effects before joust was introduced
Fun Fact: The "Charge" card actually works ever so slightly different to Rush. If you have an exact scenario where you can cast the spell on a minion in your hand (usage of Illidan and other cards), you can actually grant that effect to a minion in your hand. Wait one turn, and then the minion you cast it on can now immediately hit the opponent in the face. (How do I know this? Because I have tested multiple different possible hand buff effects. Charge // Poisonous // Lifesteal // Taunt work. Divine Shield doesn't. Deathrattle has a unique effect in which the minion will have a deathrattle but the deathrattle doesn't do anything.)
what do you mean? how do you cast a spell on a minion in your hand?
@@deday6525 It's a year but who cares. You can have a combination of illidan (spawn 2/1 when you play a card), knife juggler (do 1 damage to random enemy when something is spawned), two explosive sheeps on opponent side (1/1 with deathrattle deal 2 damage to all minions) and, also on opponents side, that one rogue minion that has as deathrattle 'play sap'.
So with this setup, whenever you play a card let's say give your minion (with more than 4 health) charge, this happens:
- illidan spawns before the card you played is triggered (!)
- juggler shoots sheep
- 2 sheep explode, 4 damage to all minions, killing all minions expect your minion with more than 4 health
- deathrattle minion triggers sap on your minion, returning it to your hand
- Only now your actual card effect is triggered, so you give charge to the minion you have currently in hand
A very weird interaction but kinda funny and logical in some way.
@@1998marijn1998 iconic
Why doesn‘t blizzard just call it rush?
streiffFaRo Because “Rush!” isn’t very catchy as a card name.
Because this card was created before the expansion that introduced rush
And clearly it would be too much work to change the text on a card.
But seriously they nerfed that card so hard that nobody uses it anyway so I can see why its low on the priority list.
Pittfull I know, but they keep buffig and nerfing other card. Why wouldn‘t they such a card text (+ name)?
Yeah but you can't recruit it because it's a spell.
"I'm being a better warrior then my opponent. He started off as Garrosh and transitioned into a goblin. I started as a woman and transitioned into an evil orc death knight." -Toast 2018.
honestly can't tell the difference.
trans rights B)
I love how he panicked at the end and didn't even use his hero power to find an answer lol
he even had the copied 3/4 that deals 5 damage to non mech mnions.......so he had a way to clear that board...........he just panicked hard as hell
GamePlayMetal Why is Toast not using his weapon on the opponent in his first 2 turns? It's free damage that he's just wasting.
@@danielmaster8776 probably because the enemy is armored and dealing one damage to that isnt worth the durability. Better use to clear a minion than chip away 1 armor.
Actual state of warrior; druid and rogue can be better warriors.
That was super effective. Goblins are allergic to sher'ing.
well charge is actually different from rush, even without attacking heroes. And not so much in its effect, but how other cards interact with it. The only difference in effect is if you have a minion that can attack and use this card, it actually just denies a attack to a hero while adding rush to a minion doesnt do anything really
There is another difference. Warsong Commander buffs charge minion, so it will buff cards didnt have charge in original but buffed by that spell. And that Witchwood axe (dont remember full name) which buffs rush minions makes a difference too.
*And not so much in its effect, but how other cards interact with it.*
So basicly my sentence, but you added some examples :p
@Luckynumber slevin
He never said that you were wrong lol
There is another difference.
Well he made it sound like i forgot it, so i thought id say its included in that sentence lol
These things are all technically true, but doubtfully considered on why they didn't change the text to rush.
Simpler answer- they don't use new keywords on classic cards because they phase out new key words, and don't want to change the classic cards over and over.
These academic espionage/Tess videos are lit 🔥 Only thing keeping me playing HS
I do like how when you academic with animated elekk shuffles in copies of of the 10 random cards not 10 more random cards.
Well it says when I shuffle a card shuffle a copy of it
0:01 There is a card called Warsong Commander, it buffs minions with charge.
There's a Kibler video where he also managed to get 4 sherazins at once in the board as a warrior, hilarious video, I think the title is "Magni, corpse flower gardener", look it up :)
Or don't because Kibler is a hack and his videos are shit
Hack? Lol ok, chill dude
@@TheOriginalElkstone Mr no chill
@@TheOriginalElkstone any arguments to back that statement up?
David Adrian O Mais Brabo cool the title should be 3 IRON HIDES NEVER ONE PLAYED
16:37 toast that changes a card interaction. If given charge it can synergize with that warrior minion that gives charge minions +1 attack
*Academic Espionage* HAHA I FUCKIN LOVE IT!!
They should make a King K'Rush. 8 mana 8/8 with rush instead
“NEW” Warrior Legendary
King K'Rush for smash bro confirmed
they already have charged devilsaur that does just that but is a 7/7
Or just named it king k'charge
devilsaur can get recruited/cheated out and then it is much stronger
when your playing at rank 25 and getting queued into people net decking disguised toast's decks, how fun.
The spell charge works differently to rush, because if you faceless a minion with the buff charge you can hit face immediately unlike with rush
best part of the video was when toast starts singing "Rise" to himself
Nitrusiide been looking for a comment about RISE
12:28 Yes me too! Don't know why most people hate it, but it's my favorite matchup, long game back and forth :D
Toast singing rise. What a betrayal ;)
Slightly better than rush because if you cast it on a minion, and then the next turn faceless the minion, it will be able to charge and attack face
The reason why they don't change it to rusg is because rush is not surely ment to stay for future expansions and not fade away like inspire like adapt and some other key words.
The card charge has a different effect to rush... If you play charge on a minion it cannot attack face that turn even if it was played last turn, if the card gave rush it could attack as normal. It would be important with cards like yogg or deck of wonders where charge could get randomly played on a minion you wanted to hit face with that turn.
Charge Spell is not rush. If you give a minion on the board rush it can still attack heroes, so in that sense charge is worse
For those of you who just want to enjoy the show
He plays Tess at 18:40
16:35 give a minion rush. Then name it Rush.
I love match-ups against warriors who think that they actually have a chance of winning even tho you have already won from the start by just playing academic espionage but they still don't concede and they let you have fun
21:39 Toast summarizes this game
Hello Toast, Imagine when you send Yogg, and somehow the spells give you a (can attack face) then a random "Charge" spell comes from yogg, now that can't attack the heroe... * Blizzard big thonk *
I like double elekk and then prep espionage prep espionage..... its not very likely to happen but that is 20 new cards with 20 duplicates. On the other hand, when you elekk and espionage on turn 4 into priest deathknight..... they usually concede.
"I started off as a woman, and transitioned into an evil orc death knight" I'm dying lol
renaming the card effect of "Charge" is because the very essence of giving a minion "charge" but can't attack the hero is like a buff when you're running the "Warsong Commander". giving a minion rush wouldn't get buffed by warsong commander. just saying my thoughts on this one
i think it isn't renamed to rush because if you put it on a minion that an already attack the charge card will make it not be able to go face
Now THAT’S a lot of value
I play this deck for ladder, it's fun to bully other control deck, but you really need to pray for miracle when facing all those aggro/tempo deck
Rest In peace Toast You Will Never Be Forgotten ...
If u use it on a minion which already has charge, it wont allow it to attack face, but if u give a charge minion rush with e.g. Houndmaster Shaw, it will still able to attack face, There is a difference. Free video idea.
Academic Espionage may be very slow, but damned if it isn't one of the most fun cards ever created in HS (in my opinion)
Get it while you can toast the ad- Pacalypse is coming to twitch
Damn, someone make an animation of it! xD
At least of some moments, such as Garrosh stomping on a Garrosh, stomping on a Garrosh and getting 4 Sherazin's xD
If you play faceless manipulator on a minion with charge, it will be able to attack heroes. If you would copy a minion with rush, it wouldn't be able to.
Q:
If you play prep, then play tess while not a rogue, does the next spell get -6 or -3? What if you played 2 preps? Does the recast use up prep?
Warsong Commander gives minions who you cast the spell on +1 attack
So uh how good is your win rate on this deck... i tried playing it around rank 5 and the best I could do was a 1 win streak with around 3 losses in between.. everything is just so fast now I was never able to make it to turn 10 most of the time
Same here!
Probably just the fact hes a better player, predicting stuff you might not have thought about. Kibler also has a pretty decent winrate with this deck
Ya I play Kiblers version.. I wont deny that they probably play around more stuff than me due to how much they play, but I also wont say I am a horrible player.. I have been playing for a long time too, know how the decks work, what is being run in them, when things are normally played and what might they being setting up to play, etc.
I just get screwed by opponent rng everytime I play this deck
Haha, see I knew I wasn't the only one thinking that it should be renamed to Rush.
But it can't. It's succinctly different, as giving a minion rush after it's already been able to attack previously, won't stop it from going face.
They could rename it to "Give a minion Rush, it can't attack heroes this turn", though, I guess.
Very interesting. Thanks for video
Hey, I play an elekk espionage deck as well, mine has pretty much all card draw and then those 4. Its not very reliable, but very fun.
16:35 2 years later maiev got introduced kek
I remember you defeated this guy with your wc warlock 3 times hahaha, again you beated him. Congrats!
Trying Sheri in my espionage deck. Not great, but I do like to do a Frasier impression and offer my opponent a glass of Sheri
This deck is awescome!
Tess Greymane is the new yogg-saron!
14:08 is "Rise" from lol?
Yes it is.
dayman fighter of the nightman champion of the sun
15:21 me at the party
I had a similar game but I was the warrior and I got down to 3 health and then zilliaxed a middle launcher, then dr boomed the next turn to snowball to win the game with 48 health/armor
the charge spell its almost like it should be renamed Rush, but no, toast is right its just not possible.
Wondered how long it would be until someone pointed out, it is two sentences, that is why there is a full stop.
Rush does not benefit from the card that gives 1 attack to all minions with charge, charge that cannot attack heroes in that sense is better on the otherhand charge doesn't benefit from Rush synergy.
I saw that card when I was making a warrior deck and I was thinking about why they did not change it to rush.
Because of the commander that buffs charge minions
Looking back at this and since rastakhan's rumble is out, charge should be called rush instead because it means the same thing but only " give a minion rush" , which is the same meaning as the spell effect for charge
I think they may have rushed that card speed makes much more sense
Hello toast I am a new to hunter Ive loved watching you ever since I started playing hearthstone. Love the memes
Dude, I am thinking about the card 'Charge' since weeks!
Well, then you probably have realized by now that there is a difference between the card Charge and and the keyword Rush. The difference may not occur very often, but I have seen it happen. If your minion for example can attack this turn normally, but for some reason Charge gets played on it (Scroll of Wonder, Tess Greymane, etc.), the option to attack the enemy hero is now no longer available.
Also, I guess it would interact with Charge specific cards (Warsong Commander), but not enable Rush cards (Woodcutter's Axe).
yes but the reason they didn't change it isn't because of some minor quirky interactions but just because they can't be bothered to change it even though it would make sense... but tbh it's probably quite hard to change a card text when you only have a small indie company at your disposal
Charged Devilsaur is very interresting for that, it's a rush minion if you play it and a charge one if you summon it
What about bloodlust
Was he singing the tune to the song 'Sarah' when he was singing 'Sherry'?
Good old Rush
Oh baby a Triple!
Hey toast, When you play mage copy secret, it wont copy the mech that will merge with another one, the secret will not trigger at all! :(
Did I just hear "new episodes of always sunny" holy shit why did no one tell me.
Its just .. Give a minion rush
I was screaming for him to use shield slam for finisher.. I forget it can only target minions. I guess that would be way too OP if shield slam could hit face.
Charge the card = rush?
Whooooshhhh
Toast is acting stupid. If you put that spell on a minion, and then copy that minion, the copy has charge and can attack face. It's different than just giving it rush. It's like Devilsaur. It doesn't have rush. If you pull it out of your deck or copy it with Menagerie Warden, the copied Devilsaur will be able to attack face.
Any replacements for face collector and gigglings? (Don't have collector and nerfed gigglings, any idea?)
Prove yourself and RISE 14:10
toast is top kek
That was an anti-climatic end xD
21:21 missed lethal
How????????
Shield slam face 4Head
@@MEGURMAN toast has charge and 1 mana crystal
Charge? Giva a friendly minion Rush :D Problem solved
Wait... did Blizzard not update those cards to have "rush"?
Why?!
16:50 u gave him 2 health for no reason btw :)
Actually there is a pretty good reason :)
@@Dotoricuswhich is?
It's really simple. Board clear.
@@Dotoricus first of all u mean board control, which he has to clear for yes, but he floated 9 mana so he couldve heropowered twice and then attack the 3/1 to clear the board without giving the opponent 2 health.. small things like these is what i am thinking about every turn bc every hp matters in this game :D
How about some cards that deal double damage to heroes with armor or that just take away twice the armor from heroes?
Yeah it’s pretty stupid how they call it charge. They should rename it rush? Or fast and furious?
Disguised Toast : I started off as a woman and transitioned into a evil orc death knight.
21:45
Rumpant Shpeed
Give a Minion Rush
Control Warrior being grinded out by Value Rogue?
Now there is assault XD, you asked for it 8)
It'd be alot nicer if blizzard kept echo and not the 2nd most toxic keyword of all time (the first one's literal)
Is there a decklist for this?
Not for you Mister ppap
hsreplay.net/decks/ifDz7qh6bmRE5yCvQAUYOh/
Thanks
Back. Your. Watch.
Wow, rogue is so fucking op. Blizzard nerfed the real winaxe, then gave rogue its own, which also gives 5 armor and hits adjacent minions, AND ONLY COSTS ONE MANA?!?!?!?!?!?!?!1
hey Toast, add the deck recipes or a link to the deck recipes in your videos pls
The card charge is not changed because rush is diffrent than what the card read, if you give a minion normal rush it still can attack face 2 turn after you placed the minion, but with the card charge they wont be able to do so, the card that you do need to expect a change from is Y'Saarj, Rage Unbound because he is just recruit a random minion at the end of the turn
im a monster i silenced a test subject with his buff cards in it today and he ragequit
No Myra’s unstable element? 😏
What if you play Prince Liam (that you stole) after playing Espionage? Does it work?