Can We 3D Print a Driver? 3D Printing & Golf!
Вставка
- Опубліковано 1 лип 2024
- Can a driver be 3d printed? Can we use resin 3d printing to make a golf club that works? Let's find out! Using Siraya Tech FAST and BLU resin on the Peopoly Phenom Noir!
Peopoly Phenom Noir:
3d.pn/peopoly
Siraya Tech FAST resin:
geni.us/fastgrey
Siraya Tech BLU resin:
geni.us/sirayatechblu
Thank you Puetz Golf for letting us have some 3d printed fun :)
www.puetzgolf.com/
0:00 - Intro at Puetz Golf
0:55 - First look at models
6:26 - Building the Golf Clubs
7:15 - Testing the Golf Clubs
You can support what we do in many way!
Buy me a coffee: buymeacoff.ee/3dprintingnerd
Ko-fi: www.ko-fi.com/joeltelling
Patreon: 3d.pn/patreon
Floatplane: www.floatplane.com/channel/3d...
Follow Sean Connelly on Patreon:
/ theseanconnelly
Follow David Tobin on Instagram
/ david_tobin
Some of the following are affiliate links:
Amazon (aff): geni.us/shopatamazon
Raise3D: raise3d.com
Magigoo: thought3d.com
Matterhackers BUILD series filaments (aff) : 3d.pn/mhbuild
Matterhackers 3D Printers (aff) : 3d.pn/mhprinters
Proto Pasta (aff): 3d.pn/protopasta
Prusa (aff): 3d.pn/prusa
Puget Systems: 3d.pn/pugetsystems
Channel Merch Shop : 3d.pn/shop
--------------------------------
Find Me Socially!
--------------------------------
Twitch : / joeltelling
Twitter : / joeltelling
Facebook : / 3dprintingnerd
Instagram : / joeltelling
Discord: / discord
--------------------------------
Want to send me something?
--------------------------------
3D Printing Nerd
PO Box 55532
Shoreline, WA 98155
USA
Music provided by futurevega.sourceaudio.com
Royalty Free Music by www.audiomicro.com/royalty-fre...
FTC Disclaimer: A percentage of sales is made through Affiliate links - Наука та технологія
I'd LOVE to see this again with some PC or Nylon ! 😍
Maybe adding in weights too
A better design and different materials
GFRN FTW
"Tim is a 'Golf enthusiast' is a FAIR WAY to put it" - 3D Punning Nerd
That was awesome
right, how does me miss his second swing and hit a pole, wtf. Enthusiast my ass, more like a beginner.
That was fun!
I wasn't even focussing on whether the clubs would hold up, I was just focussing on Tim's facemask.
The struggle was real man. 🤣🤣
He just needs to stretch it out more and it would stay up.
I've never had problems with my facemask and I have a real big schnoz myself. So I am not sure what this guy's prolem was, but if the disposables aren't staying on his face,m he should consider a cotton washable. The big ones, not the piddly ones.
He also doesn't have the metal insert shaped to his nose to keep the mask up.
Not only is he wearing it incorrectly (the metal insert is not shaped to his nose), but he constantly keeps touching it so if it did have anything on it, it's now on his hands and everything he touches.
You're just increasing your chance of getting sick or spreading it by wearing and using the mask incorrectly.
Please try FDM. with polycarbonate or something like that =D
I imagine even PETG could do fine 🤔
@@infernaldaedra actually, PETG has a very low impact resistance.
Yes... it seems very tough and ductile and all that but that's just at low loading speeds but if you hit it, it shatters =/.
The modified PLAs aka tough PLA, PLA+, PLA pro, etc, have better impact resistance than PETG
@@santiagoblandon3022 Yes Petg shatters but Printes Solid PETG or thick Petg ~10-20mm thick probably isn't gonna shatter. Perhaps though this is time gor 3D printing nerd to delve into industrial materials like PC or Ultem.
@@infernaldaedra I agree, that would be awesome =D
ABS
That - was bloody good. Excellent and thanks. Destructive testing - so satisfying.
This is super cool!!!
Thanks for the cool content
i cant wait to see part 2 now
Your club handles need to go down further into the club
Awesome video!! Thanks!
This is a really good video. Joel in his element!
Great vid Joel! This was very interesting. The shaft length needs to be consistent and there needs to be ridges on the club face or you will never be able to hit a ball straight with any sort of consistency. Can wait for round 2!
Should have added a metal face insert to spread out the impact energy and an infill pattern and it might have been successful.
Yea, either infill or solid print. Also, since he knows that the 3D printed material isn't as strong as the original club head material, he really should have gone into the 3d model and significantly increased the amount of material around the point where the head meets the shaft (both wall thickness as well as depth of the hole..
Thanks for the interesting video. My takeaway would be that when designing something for 3D printing you have to take the material into consideration. You can't just take measurements of the existing thing and model it 1-to-1. You've generally got to make things a lot more beefy for them to hold up. If you look at something like 3D printed joints on some 3D printers, they are way thicker than metal counterparts.
Love to see more on this
Good stuff😄
I'm no golfer, but that is cool.
That was great. Id even say it was both interesting for the science and super entertaining! I really want to see more designs and works until a 3D printed driver can work at full power, even if it takes 10 episodes! I wanna see the next episode!!!
This is interesting, I should try it out
Great video! Funny thing is at that same driving range my buddy who’s left handed wanted to swing my driver and I let him for some reason. He ended up hitting the ground before the ball and sent my driver head out into the range just like with your blue resin driver head haha!
Super nice 👍🏼
All the editing tropes I was expecting, and loved!
I don't have resin printer (yet) but have been brainstorming ways to improve strength of my FDM prints via grassroots methods. One of the new-to-me materials I've been working with recently, albeit for heat-testing reasons, is chopped strand basalt. I suspect getting a VERY short shredded version into your resin pool would add a moderate amount of strength, provided it doesn't interfere with light transmission. If that were to be the case, chopped fiberglass mat comes in such sizes and becomes translucent in resin.
And if you really want to play scientist, silicon carbide can be had in a variety of grits. Currently I'm working with 1500 grit as a topical additive in combination with other sprayable ceramics. I doubt that would work in suspension, but you could certainly blow it through an airbrushed-sized sandblaster (the exact method I use for my testing with composite materials; it's a light, airy powder so be prepared for a big flippin' mess) as a topcoat with a traditional epoxy resin binder, building up a layered shell.
Awrsome. I like that impact resistant resin.
I would love to see how this holds up if it was printed in the Siraya Tech Tenacious resin and printed solid.
I love science!! Great experiment!!!
Only Resin? Why not FDM using Nylon/CarbonFiber or Polycarbonate?
My thoughts exactly
It is necessary to work more on a good design of the metal-resin bond. Good illustrative video.
I just had the thought of taking that huge printer and printing a laundry basket with your logo on it!
This is a really challenging thing to do. It takes things like titanium to make a reliable club for a reason.
This is one case where I would have thought thermoplastic might be better. While it would deform over time, I think it would at least survive a round
Put support material inside each and try again....would love to see that.
17:14 Wow, Joel called out specifically to me. Thanks!
I’m a novice so was surprised the orientation of the putter for printing. Could you do a video on thought process for print orientation for the two types of heads.
Looks like I'll have to just buy that TaylorMade set I've been wanting 🤔 Great vid!
This video reminds me of a time in high school when my friend and I were at the driving range. The head on his brand new driver broke on his first swing and went rolling away into the field. He ended up having to trash that driver. If only we knew 10 years later that we'd be able to just print a new head.
You should remove those supports before curing. Shove that under some hot water and they should come off with little or no damage to the piece saving you a bunch of cleanup time.
"these results were kinda unexpected"...no every result was EXACTLY what I expected lol
If you could reach the shaft further down, maybe with threads, it might be more stable, like it the shaft reached the bottom of the head so that the neck didn't take all of the force.
Was the weight right? You meekness the drain holes but not how you handled the weight. I was thinking if it was too light you could add sand and plug the holes.
Tim's golf club has been pretty visible. :)
lol glad i'm not the only one that noticed.
So for future reference you can remove the head of a golf club. There might be a screw holding it so look for that first. After that(or if you don't find a screw) use a heat gun to heat up the joint between the head and the shaft. After a bit the glue will start to soften and you can start yanking on it and after a bit of work it will come off. Then you don't have to rely on the epoxy joint.
the biggest one though Joel is that a driver isn't 1 material as others have noted.. its typically 2 or even 3, but primarily its a shell wood or composite with a denser wood or metal core often with a plate across it, both for energy transfer and to spread out the impact across the head itself etc.. the structure of the neck is also important as no doubt you've seen.. Still fun and interesting vid... would be interesting to see if you added some flex material to cushion the shaft itself how things might go.
You should collaborate with and send it to Rick Shields Golf in the UK for a full test.
It just so happens that I know quite a lot about 3d printing, play golf close to scratch and work in an engineering field. This is enough to ensure you not to do part two on this... I've never said no to something stupid and fun, but this one is maybe a little too challenging.
On the other hand, I'll watch part two...may be painfull but who knows, you might as well surprise me 👍🏻
The line has to do with the z lift distance 3dprintingpro has a great video about it.
Fill the heads with some casting resin. And it looks like the JB weld is not holding well to the blue resin.
Lol, how he's stuggling with the mask :) You need to push the metal insert to fit your nose :) Having eye protection for the test is a big plus :)
You should work a metal strike face onto the club heads, like real woods have. Also yes, more reinforcement at the hosel.
where the metal meets the 3d print you need like 20mm if not more to hold around the metal area so it dont break
I realy love this video. Can you also test if it is posible with normale 3DPrinting (No resin)
testes means something else entirely
I wonder what looks you will get when you come to the course with a set of 3D printed clubs.
Awesome
Try a mix of 75% blu and 25% tenacious, it's a great mix.
Dude, Tim's face mask keeps falling off lmao.
Coolness
Get Vision Miner to make a CF PEEK for Ultem 1010 one.
I would say you design the reinforcement on the shaft connection maybe make the connection part longer
hi, i heard burying the something printed in the salt and heating it up makes it smoother.
wanna try it?
That is for FFF printed parts, not resin
Thank Yo
How would carbon fiber reinforced nylon filament hold up?
Why am I not surprised that the blu isn't exactly blue. Might be because their Fast Green looks yellow in pictures. I love seeing people trying to come up with practical uses for 3D printing more, please.
The hubs last week: I think I want to take up gold
*Somewhere Joel’s maker senses tingled*
Would be interesting to see some generative design used to design the head
You should do a project where you do a silicone mold and a cast of a golf head in some kind of metal. aluminium brass maybe
Joel there was a show on the golf channel about designing golf clubs. maybe try and find that for a little help
I want to see a 3D printed BOWLING BALL!
COOL! I didn't know Sean was back in Seattle! When did this happen?
I return to visit once a month or so!
@@Aidenn23 Cool! Keep up the good work!
It really disturbed me with Tim's mask sliding down all the time. I kept thinking, "Is that why we are experiencing such an increase in cases from younger adults?"
It might have something to do with that fact that the chance of serious complications for people under 30 is incredibly, incredibly low. Therefore they really aren’t taking precautions. Agree or not, that’s what’s happening.
dsgarland there’s someone with common sense! Thank you.
PLEASE. Has nothing to do with that. Younger adults are basically at 0% risk of anything negatively affecting their health other then around a week of being sick like any common cold ever. Maybe do some research. With people like you is why the world has been destroyed in a way and will continue to be with your lack of knowledge and blindness.
My guess it's just a poorly made mask.
@@ikew3150 You are wrong. dsgarland
just stated why young people not wearing masks. He didnt say if he agree with it.
Cool
Now that's what I call a print driver!
when I saw that boy hit the handle of that broken driver the disappointment was too much. lol and he did not even tell you that he missed but you see him look down at that ball still there at 15:33
I don't know what's worse: that you used clips from Caddyshack 2; or that I recognized them.
Hahahaha!
if you printed and then fill out the space with some foam i think you get a much better resoult and the weight not change that much!
Also, a high speed camera would come in handy to better find out what goes wrong
The slow mo we used was 1500fps@720p. We don't really have the budget for a phantom camera. Trust me, I wish we did!
@@Aidenn23 isn't there that cheaper one a guy made that How Ridiculous uses and TAU Fledermaus too.
@@Aidenn23 found it! The kronos $3K... www.krontech.ca/
I would like to see drivers with FDM using filament with carbon fiber, nylon, metal, or even wood in them. Rotating driver to print on flat face. After couple layers with place for adding a metal face plate with some added holes for screws to hold in place. Why only 200 grams? Try different infills, different layer thickness, how many outer layers especially around shaft. And vary shaft hole shape, like wider at bottom to give “glue” more surface and less chance of pulling out. That is - If you really want to experiment!🤪🤪🤪 these are times I wish I could afford a printer.😭
more!
Feels like there's wasted material making the entire thing a shell and putting thick resin where there isn't impact. Ideally there should be resin from the strike face back to the shaft. I'd also like to see a triangle infill going from the strike face to the back, allowing air to flow through the print and reduce drag.
Humble request: FDM golf club follow up video
The material needs to be more dense than the ball to get good distance. The ball needs to deform more than the driver head on impact.
stl for the driver head?????
try cf pc or some other engineering filament
I said "theyre all going to break"
they all broke
I was not surprised in the least.
Especially since resin prints have some of the absolute worst toughness
I wanna See FDM ABS and Nylon! :)
please note that all clubs sold are set to strict regulation to the point that it talks about how heavy and how much bounce the club has.
New 2020 sport: the nose struggle
Infill, thicker walls on the stressed areas and threaded inserts are all really basic design elements in 3D printing even for noobs. I guess maybe you are starting a series and wanted to use the simplest design from the beginning?
Dudes contact with his club head is horrendous.
Make a better club and bring blueboy back. I would be interested to see it. I can imagine one day making my own custom clubs. Also make one with a huge head.
Please use METERIC, or put some text on screen in metric when it's needed...
To be honest (can't tell from the video) but with both blue heads, I think the head hay have been coming off the shaft before the ball strike. I don't think Tim whiffed by that much on the first attempt and shaft and his swing looked good compared to how far the club went off target.
Four!!
You can tell he only wore the mask for this video. Someone who's been wearing one for months will have figured it out.
You’re the problem to why our country or world has been temporarily destroyed. Hundreds of millions of lives ruined because of a HUGELY falsely reported and high jacked virus numbers with STILL barely any Science to back. Such a joke that people are stilling talking like you. When will they ever wake up.
@@ikew3150 lmfao, "barely any science to back?" What? You are the sheep for listening to whatever daddy trump says or what your mom shared on Facebook.
SacriPudding haha. Don’t eve have Facebook and the last fact I got on Covid from trump was never. Shows how much you no. Nothing.... dude it literally changes nearly everyday. First masks are Everything then they’re nothing. Then they reduce the amount of virus particulate you inhale to lessen the sickness. It has permanent lung damage. Like such Bs for only be around for several months. They have NO CLUE if it’s permanent(it’s not) shocker.
Keep getting your brainwashed information on this type of virus from whatever news station shoves it down your throat.
You mean figured out that you pinch the bendy metal on top of your nose to get the mask to stay in place?
@@ikew3150 Maybe you should try listening to the victims, instead of 3rd parties with an agenda to push? Covid is fatal in a small percentage of cases ( increases with age ), and has long-lasting side affects in a larger number of cases ( internal organ & neurological damage ). In most cases people will recover, but not all- just because you haven't been affected or know anyone that has doesn't mean it isn't real nor serious. Spouting off that you know better when you are neither a victim nor medical professional ( who doesn't have a political agenda ) is never a good look...
Thank you Joel. Wish you the best. Time to leave.
Hey I know that golf course I live near there
Whats those patties in your face?
5:28 Seafoam Blue
Lol what a great idea! Maybe try 3d print not resin next time test it ;)
Or maybe can make baseball bat try on $38.000 printer not print stand up so lay in flat with support on or hockey stick as well could be lot fun lol
On our way to 3D printing Mythbusters.
I want this shirt