Is the Cadillac ELR worth the money?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 8 вер 2024
  • Eight Months ago, Matt got a Chevy Volt as a daily driver, and won't shut up about how awesome it is. The problem is, it's rather dull looking, so no one understands how awesome it is unless they drive it. To fix that, GM gave Cadillac it's own Volt, called the ELR. It looks like the future, but is it any good to drive? We drive them back to back to find out.

КОМЕНТАРІ • 524

  • @globuslive
    @globuslive 5 років тому +5

    Just got my 2016 ELR and Im the one damn happy man on the planet ))

  • @user-lp9ye1po3w
    @user-lp9ye1po3w 10 років тому +3

    You have some of the best car reviews on UA-cam. I love how you review all types of cars and not just the baddest and fastest. It's so clear you are a true car guy who appreciates all types of cars and really learns them instead of reading crap off a spec sheet. Keep it up!

  • @DaN6maN
    @DaN6maN 10 років тому +8

    I like Zach being in the video, i think he does a great job and something like this where you guys compare cars he brings something different to the video

  • @BillDeFalcoGFE
    @BillDeFalcoGFE 7 років тому +4

    Is the Cadillac ELR worth it? ABSOLUTELY! - Especially when you get a Mint Condition Fully Loaded ELR with an 80k sticker that was never sold but instead used as a Fleet Vehicle by the Cadillac Dealer that I purchased it from. I got the Car of my Dreams with only 11,400 miles on it for $31,500.00!!! This is Hands Down The Most Incredible Car I have ever owned! Once you experience the great handling and quick pick up (from a dead stop or from highway cruising speed) of a car driven solely by electric motors producing 295 Ft. Lbs. of Torque - you will be Spoiled Rotten and will never again want to drive a car driven by a conventional gasoline engine (that needs to rev up to develop power). Since taking delivery on my ELR this past April (2017) I've been doing a lot of driving, but I've only been topping off the small 9 gallon gas tank once a month. And though the ELR is EPA rated at 37 miles of electric driving range (to accommodate average brick-foot drivers) - I've been having no problem getting up to 48 miles on the batteries alone! This can easily be achieved by taking full advantage of the 4 different levels of regenerative braking and by carefully managing power from the batteries and the Quiet gas powered electric generator. For example - I live 60 miles north of New York City. I use the gas generated electricity on the highway, but when I get off the West Side Highway and hit the streets of Manhattan and Brooklyn - I switch over to the batteries, which are perfect for the stop and go driving of city traffic. On my second fill up (it only took 6.9 gallons to top it off) I did the math and found that I got over 111 miles per gallon on my 2nd tank - using just over 2/3 of the 9 gallons of gas. Don't believe the reviews! The trunk is Huge, the back seats easily accommodate a 6 ft. 200 lb. person. The CUE works Great - after you Calibrate it to your touch - which I'm sure None of the reviewers did! To drive the Cadillac ELR (Electric Long Range) is to fall in love with it. And the on board gas generator lets you take long trips (like the 850 mile drive from my home to Hilton Head South Carolina) without the need for lengthy down times to recharge the batteries, as you'd have to do in a Tesla which would drag out the same trip by an additional 6 hours or more each way - making it impossible for my wife and I to make the 5 day 4 night trip in a Tesla. Even better - we’ve got a far more luxurious car with much more exotic styling and ZERO Driving Range Limitations - all for 13 of the price of a Tesla. Too bad Cadillac only made 2,950 ELRs before discontinuing production - but for sure I've got a very rare collectible car from the world's Most Iconic Luxury Car Brand - Cadillac - of course!

  • @TheHomeExpert5
    @TheHomeExpert5 4 роки тому +3

    The Caddy is gorgeous, inside & out. Pick up one used in the 20's.

  • @GSGFlash
    @GSGFlash 10 років тому +2

    Volt owner here. You stated something wrong in your video, the 2013 model year of the Volt introduced a hold mode, so it's not an ELR only feature. And, just my opinion, but the Volt isn't "ugly", it's just acceptable. The front of the car looks good, but unfortunately the rear is not so hot thanks to the Kammback shape(which helps make the car more aerodynamic). Wish they offered more premium options (like LED headlamps) though.

  • @stevelang6342
    @stevelang6342 10 років тому +6

    This is a very well thought out video. It's easy to see the passion within it. Thanks for putting it together.

  • @KTPurdy
    @KTPurdy 10 років тому +5

    Fun video to watch. With 400+ comments, these have probably already been stated but just in case here are my comments:
    - To be clear, the Volt also has Hold Mode in the 2013 & '14 models so it's not exclusive to the ELR. I agree it's a very cool feature. The generator is very efficient on the freeway and the electric motors are very efficient in the city so when used together in a smart fashion you can get very good mileage going a fairly long distance
    - Chevrolet offers modified rear view mirrors available that significantly reduce the severe wind buffeting. This buffeting is my biggest complaint about the Volt
    - I agree electric cars are fun to drive and so is the Volt. Driving the Volt has software feel to it. It's very quiet and has tons of engineering that makes it very efficient to drive in spite of the fact that it's quite heavy. It's girth gives it a substantial feel while driving down the road.
    - For those that drive mainly in EV mode the Volt is very cheap. I drive in EV mode 97% of the time; I'm currently at 300+ mpg at 30k+ miles. The money I save in gasoline pays for a large portion of my car payment. For some reason people are not able to figure out how cheap it can be to have a very nice car. It drives like a dream and personally, I like the looks.

    • @babybirdhome
      @babybirdhome 10 років тому +1

      "The money I save in gasoline pays for a large portion of my car payment."
      This is true for me with my Prius as well. Mainly because I deliver pizza in it and actively work to keep my mileage as high as I can within the confines of my job, but it's pretty sweet to drive a new car effectively for free. The savings literally does pay the car payment, and once it's paid for, that will be like getting a $400 a month raise for doing nothing but making one smart choice 5 years earlier. I imagine people like you with a Volt feel much the same way.

  • @ColeTrickle13
    @ColeTrickle13 10 років тому

    I leased a volt 3 months ago as a commuter car. My Lifted 2013 Rubicon was killing me on gas. I was able to replace a corporate gas card with a volt for the same monthly cost. This review is spot on. The volt dosent handle good and the wind buffering sucks but it is the ultimate comfortable commuter tool.

  • @cvetters1
    @cvetters1 10 років тому +1

    I have to agree. I bought a Volt as well, a 2013 model that has Hold and the leather and suede interior with the grey center stack instead of the white, A MUCH more refined interior, and Hold allows me to choose when and where I use the gas generator. I've got 12k miles on my blue Volt (I do have to disagree about the color, I prefer the blue and red to the black and silver versions) and have used only about $120 in electricity to drove that many miles, and only about $100 in gas, due to 4 long trips from Baltimore to CT and back, and to Maine and back. I also drive the Volt in L and Sport mode, so i get the most regen possible, even on the highway, and have managed to get upwards of 60 miles from a charge without hypermiling. It takes me 2 miles of indicated charge to drive the 6 miles to work. The Volt is a great car. And as was said, at $50k, the ELR would be a spectacular car. But not at $75k+

  • @ldodom
    @ldodom 10 років тому +2

    An excellent comparison/review, Matt & Zach. More informative, in terms of comparison, than any other Volt/ELR comp on UA-cam.
    Thanks!
    Postscript: Agreed on the value aspect; on both cars.

  • @MattMaranMotoring
    @MattMaranMotoring 10 років тому +31

    Great review guys! I really need to drive a Volt!

    • @clarksoncote
      @clarksoncote 10 років тому +5

      The drive is amazing. The Volt is the best kept secret out there. Everyone's instant reaction is to think "Oh, that's one of those Prius type vehicles" but the performance, handling, acceleration, and yes, fuel savings, is all superior. I'm not much of a car guy myself, but now every day I get into my car I smile. It's just a fun quiet ride.
      It's too bad the car got caught up in so many politics. Between that and many dealers not understanding how it works, it's hard to get people to just try it. Also doesn't help when the dealers leave the battery discharged so the engine runs during a test drive (which for 75% of people, would never happen during their normal commute, 38 miles a day is enough for many to use zero gas for daily driving and that really adds up.)

    • @babybirdhome
      @babybirdhome 10 років тому

      ClarksonCote It really is the sales people (dealers etc.) who seem to not want to see electric succeed. Anyone who has driven electric loves it, or at least doesn't hate it. The only people who hate it are people who like shifting gears, smelling gas, or hearing loud engines. And a whole lot of sales people for some reason.

    • @BroccoliBeefed
      @BroccoliBeefed 10 років тому +2

      babybirdhome Salespeople don't like it, because the petrol industry is holding a gun to their head to force them to act like they don't like electric cars

    • @danwat1234
      @danwat1234 8 років тому

      It's a great looking car, especially in blue or red, I'll be looking for a used fully loaded one by the end of the year I think. The Chevy Bolt coming out and the 2nd gen Volt out, they will be getting a bit cheaper still I hope. Early adopters not too happy tho

    • @supervisor404atlanta3
      @supervisor404atlanta3 6 років тому

      I downed electric cars for years. I'm a late 60's old school muscle guy. I laughed at them as I passed them on the streets and talked trash about them at parties...now I own one. And kick myself everyday that I don't bUy one sooner. I have had MANY jobs that were LESS that 40 miles away from my house...and you tell me that the same car, the very same car that I have dogged and joked about for all these years could have saved me over $3,600-$4,500 a year in fuel cost FOR THE PAST 4-5 YEARS.... Ill never buy a full gasser again.

  • @hayksamvelyan
    @hayksamvelyan 10 років тому +3

    Zac completely missed me with his statement at 8:44. I think a better way to put it would be "Is this a $75,000 Volt?"
    Other than that, this was a nice comparison between the two. And thank you Matt, for sharing your thoughts on the Volt, as I always wanted to know why people bought them.

  • @kirksway1
    @kirksway1 8 років тому +10

    that Caddy is Delish!!

  • @nathangebben5738
    @nathangebben5738 4 роки тому +3

    This powertrain in other GM models would be amazing! I dont get why GM is so stuck on keeping it in the Volt and ELR

  • @taiwanjohn
    @taiwanjohn 5 років тому +1

    I just bought a 2013 Volt a couple of weeks ago, and I love it. That said, the thing I find attractive about the ELR is that it's a 2-door instead of a 4-door. At 6'2"/250 I have the seat all the way back, which means the B-pillar is slightly in the way when I get in the car. This is a minor inconvenience that I put up with because the car is so awesome in every other way. But it would be nice to have those few extra inches of doorway on the ELR.

  • @kaliko15
    @kaliko15 10 років тому

    At the beginning of this video Zack mentioned the ELR has "hold" mode. I drive a 2014 base Chevy Volt and it has "hold" mode that can be used whenever driver choses too. He also mentioned it has shift pedals that make the regenerative braking more aggressive. (I know they really aren't "shift pedals") In the Volt changing the shifter to "L" or low will have the same affect. And you don't have to sit there holding it. I use it all the time since I spend most of my day driving in traffic. And it is cool to see the gains in driving range. Matt mantioned the terrible wind noise if all the windows aren't down. Last I heard Chevy was working on a fix for this thay was going to be free for volt owners.
    Finally the amount of space and the very useful 4 doors the volt has was never mentioned. We use this car to replace a Toyota Highlander as a company vehicle. With all the seats down in both cars. We only lost some height by the hatch in the volt.

  • @Trades46
    @Trades46 8 років тому +4

    I think the Cadillac ELR is a beautiful car. Looks awesome from any angle. I like how the 2016 ELR got a power upgrade it so desperately needed to separate itself from the Volt.
    Still, at $75k for a FWD compact luxury coupe especially that from a not-too-prestigeous brand is too much. At $~60k the ELR would make a lot of sense & make a compelling entry-level coupe that can compete against the likes of the Audi A5, Lexus RC350 and BMW 2 coupe.

    • @333angeleyes
      @333angeleyes 8 років тому +4

      +Trades46 But that is the problem, cadillac thinks people still see them as being as prestigious as Mercedes Benz and BMW.

    • @Trades46
      @Trades46 8 років тому +3

      Gabri'el Alexander
      I argue their current lineup of cars does; I've driven an ATS a while back and it felt better to drive than the equivalent C300.
      Image-wise, it's not quite there. Lexus is the closest to the Germans in that regard, but some Euro-centric fanboys never change.

  • @Lakefield_
    @Lakefield_ 10 років тому +2

    Nice seeing Zack doing a review again. Hope this happens more often.

  • @eliblanton6604
    @eliblanton6604 10 років тому +2

    Good to see Zack in the video. I've always liked his delivery and personal opinions that come up in the podcast. It's a nice, new dynamic to have Matt and Zack, with their different delivery styles in the same video. I'd love to see more. TheSmokingTire

    • @TheSmokingTire
      @TheSmokingTire  10 років тому +1

      Yup, we're turning TST into more of a team dynamic. Zack will be doing more videos on his own soon too.

    • @eliblanton6604
      @eliblanton6604 10 років тому

      Brilliant move guys, keep up the great work.

    • @BroccoliBeefed
      @BroccoliBeefed 10 років тому

      Zack is much more pleasant to look at and listen to than the older obese guy

  • @scottusaroxs
    @scottusaroxs 9 років тому +6

    I traded in my 2013 Black Chevy Volt for a 2014 Cadillac ELR. Two things: even though the list price was $84,000 with all of the extras, I didn't pay anywhere near that price; second, the ELR is by far one of the most comfortable car I have driven. I traded in a 2008 Mercedes e350 for the Volt, so I'm familiar with comfort. I am definitely a fan of the ELR. I noticed on carfax that Cadillac dealerships are selling new ELRs for $55K. Both cars are great. I'm a huge fan of the Chevy and Cadillac EV approach.

    • @PopsRacer61
      @PopsRacer61 9 років тому

      ..I'm seriously thinking of getting the new 2016 VOLT. I currently have an all wheel drive Lexus, which I love and is great in the snow. My question to you is how does the VOLT behave in the snow and bad weather?

    • @Pranks313
      @Pranks313 9 років тому +1

      I work at the assembly plant that builds both the ELR and Volt. They are nice vehicles. We just started building ELRs again. The battery's are HUGE. 700lbs

    • @Auton1forone
      @Auton1forone 9 років тому +1

      Scott Schwerdt Thank you Sir

    • @Auton1forone
      @Auton1forone 6 років тому +1

      it is because of you , I purchase a Cadillac ELR , I think sometimes people like to hear themselves talk , there is so much talk about the price and it's not a Tesla , News Flash , it's Cadillac and full of Technology not found in the Tesla which by the way looks like outdated Japanese mess , while everyone is concentrating on how fast they can i'll be laughing , because they will need to stop and charge and I will be relaxing at my destination . Lol

  • @MikeAndTum
    @MikeAndTum 10 років тому

    I leased a Smart Electric Drive in January since with Georgia tax credits if costs almost nothing. I previously commuted to work 22miles each day in a ML63 AMG and have rarely driven it since getting the smart. There is something so refined about the electric drive train that you have to experience. It's nothing like driving a hybrid. And I'm saving almost $400/month in gas. I tested my smart and got 0-60 in 7s vs about 4.8s for my ML. I like that I can floor the smart at every light and not waste gas $$$ and never get a super speeder ticket.

  • @BradPickett685
    @BradPickett685 10 років тому +1

    this was a very good video i liked the two person review format

  • @pex3
    @pex3 10 років тому +16

    hey matt, when are you gonna show us your entire car collection? from what i can tell, you have a C5 vette, delorean, vanquish, a foxbody, and now a volt?

    • @HAACKER45
      @HAACKER45 10 років тому +3

      And a honda odyssey, that's all of them.

    • @paralleltimelines
      @paralleltimelines 10 років тому +2

      HAACKER45
      did he sell his raptor?

    • @BdaB164
      @BdaB164 10 років тому +1

      always_lookin_up Yes

    • @TheSmokingTire
      @TheSmokingTire  10 років тому

      always_lookin_up yeah

    • @itsminas25
      @itsminas25 10 років тому

      and the Honda Odyssey as wel

  • @Reggie6447
    @Reggie6447 10 років тому

    At first when i saw the title I thought Matt had shamelessly sold out, but he made a good case and i'd consider buying the next gen now. Thanks for opening my eyes a little Matt, good piece.

  • @frouwoulou
    @frouwoulou 10 років тому +1

    Great review from both of you

  • @itsminas25
    @itsminas25 10 років тому +6

    Good to see Zack get some air time!

    • @blakegrady1216
      @blakegrady1216 10 років тому

      x2 really enjoyed hearing his opinions

  • @im1greatman
    @im1greatman 10 років тому

    They look like twins. One is just shinier and has a Cadillac badge on it. Overpriced is an understatement!

  • @orangebeachisstinkly
    @orangebeachisstinkly 10 років тому

    Solid combination review style. Nice change up from the main. Matt was still Matt but more direct. Zack was also direct but a compliment not conflict to Matt. Thanks Guys

  • @judaboi44
    @judaboi44 10 років тому +2

    Zack is such a smartass and I love it

  • @darek4488
    @darek4488 10 років тому +24

    Zack is right and I think everybody that don't expect any excitement should be driving electric cars instead of wasting resources. Petrol should have been saved for those who gets smiles from it.

    • @THEZEST1357
      @THEZEST1357 10 років тому +1

      im a petrol head but if someone handed me the keys to a tesla model s in exchange for crushing my car which is an australian made 2008 ford falcon XR6 $50000 (new) I wouldn't hesitate.

    • @darek4488
      @darek4488 10 років тому

      Irrelevant. Tesla S is $100000 car.

    • @THEZEST1357
      @THEZEST1357 10 років тому +2

      It also isn't offered in Australia, but my point is even if I had the choice between say a Jaguar XFR or and audi RS5 I'd still choose the Tesla.

    • @ReticentIndignation
      @ReticentIndignation 10 років тому

      How right you are Darek! Well said! Everyone who isn't an enthusiast should be driving a damn appliance!

    • @darek4488
      @darek4488 10 років тому

      WTF is appliance?

  • @liverpooleban910
    @liverpooleban910 10 років тому +1

    Wow, Matt! I wouldn't think that you owned a hybrid car. :) Great review

  • @voltecrules624
    @voltecrules624 7 років тому

    All true comments on the Volt. The good, the bad, and the really good! My 2014 Volt has 66,000 miles now. Flawless. I have 135 mpg Lifetime mpg. There is. O other car like it. It is really amazing. This guy speaks the truth about the. OLD and mirrors how I feel about it. My Volt cost $22,195 after rebates and tax credits. New 2017 Volts are cheaper.

  • @InSaN3ViSioN
    @InSaN3ViSioN 9 років тому +1

    The Volt is not ugly, just has very weird proportions, from driver seat level it looks really cool, and the front end is sexy

  • @gab13005
    @gab13005 10 років тому

    I think it's really cool that someone like Matt who likes machines and engines has a chevy Volt as a daily driver, I think it shows where we are going!

  • @jimmmyz169
    @jimmmyz169 10 років тому +1

    Good stuff guys! To see a guy so passionate about a car with an electric motor in it that normally is big on muscle cars is a very cool assessment of the hybrids to be able to enjoy here. I see you're thoughtful and practical, so I'm going to be enjoying your reviews a lot more now seeing that you're really on the same page with a lot of average folks and not only gear heads. I think after seeing this video, an even bigger audience will be able to relate with your thoughts on a vehicle.

  • @Luisvegabroker
    @Luisvegabroker 10 років тому +1

    Very interesting and direct point , you control it ! Not it controls you .

  • @bob76059
    @bob76059 10 років тому +1

    I wish they compared the higher end volt (luxury package) to the Caddy. The higher end version isn't nearly as cheap feeling with the stand out upgrade being the steering wheel wrapped in leather (the one thing you touch all the time in a car).
    Also, the 2013 Volt also has the hold mode so it's a moot comparison.
    Also, the buffeting :There is a kit for window down people to change the mirror covers and another small change to stop the issue. In stock form the buffeting is horrible.

  • @MrGovenator1
    @MrGovenator1 9 років тому +5

    Sooooo, why would any one ever consider a Prius when it gets what, a third the fuel economy of this nearly?

    • @Nosloveingneko
      @Nosloveingneko 9 років тому

      price

    • @MrGovenator1
      @MrGovenator1 9 років тому

      Nosloveingneko
      I am more talking comparing it to the Volt though.

    • @ItsJosh
      @ItsJosh 9 років тому

      Nosloveingneko The Volt is $35k for the base model. Then you get a $7,500 federal rebate, and a State rebate which is up to $5k in California. So now the Volt would be a $23k car, not only is that cheaper its also a way bigger value.

    • @Geckogold
      @Geckogold 9 років тому

      MrGovenator1 Sadly, not everyone has a garage where they can plug in a vehicle, such as apartment dwellers.

  • @jtmcdole
    @jtmcdole 10 років тому +1

    I've got the leather interior, which makes it feel several grades above the cloth commuter. I have to completely agree that the drive selector is horrible and wastes space.
    For 75k, give me more range and power.

  • @Jesusmakesmelovelife
    @Jesusmakesmelovelife 10 років тому

    Well done on the back-and-forth discussion-style comparison. I will be taking my parents to test drive a Volt. They need to replace a small truck with a 4 door and the range extender is HUGE over the Leaf. I do wish the Volt had the hold setting and the regenerate controls. In an electric car I want to challenge myself to get the most range possible but also be able to drive it without caring if I so desire.

    • @TheSmokingTire
      @TheSmokingTire  10 років тому

      My Volt is a 2013 model so it doesn't have Hold. The 2014's do, as I just found out.

  • @Customisbetter2
    @Customisbetter2 10 років тому +1

    Great job Thaddeus! Excellent shots!

  • @manoman0
    @manoman0 10 років тому

    The 2012 Euro-spec Volt has the HOLD-mode. Don't wanna miss that mode!

  • @NoahBB
    @NoahBB 10 років тому +1

    But on a serious note, great review. Love seeing Zack in it, adds an extra dimension to the video. Another perspective is always good.

    • @turddle23
      @turddle23 10 років тому

      In one of his podcasts, he described the process of the reviews. It's not just Farah that drives them. Klapman, Brown, and a couple of other guys test them as well, they talk about it, and then they come to a consensus. We see it through Matt's lens because, he's the presenter, but it's not just his voice. That said, Zach is pretty good on camera, and obviously makes things interesting when he speaks.

    • @NoahBB
      @NoahBB 10 років тому

      turddle23 Ya I listened to that one. The reason I bring it up is when it's just Matt on camera, his "opinion" is just a homogenization of everyone's opinion, where as when there are 2 different people on screen, you can really show the divide between the opinions of the 4 or 5 people who test the cars. Just my .02 though.

    • @TheSmokingTire
      @TheSmokingTire  10 років тому +1

      ***** We agree, which is why we're trying to include not only Zack, but Thad and other members of the team on camera as well.

    • @NoahBB
      @NoahBB 10 років тому

      TheSmokingTire Awesome, looking forward to more great content as per usual! :)

  • @stanleychung88
    @stanleychung88 10 років тому

    Great video as usual. I think it's great to see Zach co presenting. He is hilarious on the podcast and it's good to see some of that humour coming onto the video. Good contrast to Matt's style of presenting. The volt is not very cheap or popular in New Zealand not sure about leasing one but to buy it's about $85k NZD with no government subsidies available. The Prius is more affordable here.

  • @ArthurSperotto
    @ArthurSperotto 10 років тому

    No noise, no smoke, no good, in my book. An old school book, definitely haha...

  • @iSOBigD
    @iSOBigD 10 років тому

    The 100+ mpg is very impressive when I see my V6 doing 25 under perfect conditions and 17-18 in the city. Not sure if I could give up the nice interior and performance, but as a second cheap car just to drive around the city, a used Volt could be an amazing value and the gas savings are crazy.

  • @pgrens
    @pgrens 10 років тому

    I run it, it doesn't run me. Amen. That is the key. With over 100 mpg, this should be Chevy's sales pitch!

  • @Dwealdric
    @Dwealdric 10 років тому +1

    Great review, definitely.

  • @Mr.Mike510
    @Mr.Mike510 10 років тому +16

    Chevy Volt beats Toyota Prius hands down any day

  • @JanMichaelFranklin
    @JanMichaelFranklin 10 років тому

    I totally agree with this review. I think the Volt is much better than many people believe and I also feel that it isn't a bad looking car. As I figured, the XLR is a better looking, improved Volt, but the $35K price hike just isn't worth it. Caddy fail on that stupid pricing.

  • @danwat1234
    @danwat1234 7 років тому

    If the ELR was a hatch, it would of been less of a disaster. It's not practical at all with a little trunk, very little leg room in the back seats. Would love to get the 2016 ELR drivetrain in a 2011-2015 Volt!

  • @beans301
    @beans301 10 років тому +1

    125 mpg? Geezus that's awesome gas numbers...wth. and I have no issues with the volt. I actually think it looks pretty good. Just my opinion though.

    • @jfv65
      @jfv65 10 років тому +1

      agreed, it looks different to anything else out on the road except for the Opel Ampera which is basically the same car.
      And i like names like Volt, Ampera, Tesla for electric cars. We need a hardcore electric sportscar which they should name AC/DC ;-)

  • @dunkshot32
    @dunkshot32 10 років тому

    I have to agree with just about everything this guys said. This was a well thought through report and I want to applaud their honesty. In truth, that was probably the most complimentary I have ever heard someone speak of the Volt.

  • @danwat1234
    @danwat1234 8 років тому +1

    5:45, driving with the windows down. There is a wind buffeting kit so there will be less air buffeting with just 1 window down.
    6:14, There is now a divisor in the 'canoe' for the Tesla you have come with the car.

    • @Frost517
      @Frost517 7 років тому

      With both windows down up front its terrible... :-( lol Oh well its still a pretty awesome car. :-)

    • @sinhalo
      @sinhalo 7 років тому

      Volt = cheap piece of garbage but then again I own a ELR , New stingray and a 2016 jeep srt gc. Screw gas mileage to all these broke ass motherfuckers.

    • @danwat1234
      @danwat1234 7 років тому

      Volt has a hatch, and can get a trailer hitch for it. It can actually do more than haul 2 people.

  • @GrotrianSeiler
    @GrotrianSeiler 10 років тому

    Very very good review. Seemed to cover all the points + and -. Well done.

  • @TheJ387
    @TheJ387 10 років тому

    It was cool seeing Zach in the video! Great change of pace. Is it a coincidence that there was a volt commercial before the video??

  • @Zach-eb1jd
    @Zach-eb1jd 10 років тому

    Zac did a good job keep him around Matt!

  • @razorseal
    @razorseal 10 років тому

    I have a Volt which I bought to save miles for my Corvette. I love the car. I guess great minds think alike. I'm currently at 296 MPG with my car.

  • @MichaelKirven
    @MichaelKirven 10 років тому +2

    Good review. Matt, let us know if the kit to eliminate the wind buffeting works for you. I'm enjoying not spending $150 per month on gas since I bought my Volt in October of 2013. I was quite surprised by the build quality of the Volt, and the absolute lack of noise and vibration in the drivetrain. I agree that the ELR is overpriced at 75K. The Tesla is a much better looking and performing car, but the interior is a real letdown for me - there is nowhere to put anything, and it's rather drab and dull on the inside. It doesn't look like an interior of a 100K car.

    • @KTPurdy
      @KTPurdy 10 років тому

      There are a bunch of Tesla's at our local hospital and Adobe building. I agree the interior is disappointing, especially for a $100k car. After a years worth of wear and tear the interior looks very average. If I were rich and thought about buying a Tesla it would be in spite of the interior.

    • @wantsanewvehicle
      @wantsanewvehicle 10 років тому

      What exactly does everybody carry in their car that they need tons of storage? It's a car, not a storage container.

    • @reidhester
      @reidhester 10 років тому +1

      The kit to eliminate the wind buffeting works for us!

  • @arleyki
    @arleyki 10 років тому

    I really hope we can get the Volt or ELR in Oz soon... (2yrs later). We have a serious lack of viable hybrid cars to choose from and are about 2 years behind the States and Europe with availability. I see fleets of Prius Taxi's in most major cities and the occasional Leaf, but nothing I would go out and buy or more likely lease. This has to be fixed.

    • @arleyki
      @arleyki 10 років тому

      *Actually we did get the Volt this year in Oz but I'm yet to see one on the road, and I guess at around $70 000 this is pretty self explanatory as to why. What a joke.

  • @MrNicholg
    @MrNicholg 10 років тому +2

    This would have been so much better if gramps over at TFLcar did this review. Stay out of Los Angeles with your crazy hybrid driving, Farah!

  • @misujerr
    @misujerr 6 років тому

    Ha, just came across this four years later. Right on, didn't know you had a Volt. I just got one, love mine too :)

    • @misujerr
      @misujerr 6 років тому

      And I guess history has spoken on Volt vs ELR...

  • @bobjordan5549
    @bobjordan5549 10 років тому

    While the Volt is not as cool looking as it might have been (too bad they used the beta styling on the Camaro - wonder how sales might have been if they had?), but it sure as hell looks great compared to the Prius. That said, the designer-label-conscious will probably opt for the more expensive Tesla over the ELR, until Apple comes out with something at a super-premium price lol.
    I've had my Volt for over 2 years and love it!

  • @venom5809
    @venom5809 10 років тому +4

    I agree, the ELR max is a $50,000 car fully loaded, maybe.

    • @beanjapan
      @beanjapan 10 років тому

      you have to get in one. the interior is pretty amazing. I think it's worth over 50k easily, but it would be hard to justify 80k. don't forget it still qualifies for the $7500 government rebate.

    • @venom5809
      @venom5809 10 років тому

      beanjapan I have been in it, it is still not worth more than $50K. Leather is not that expensive, especially in a car that small.

    • @BroccoliBeefed
      @BroccoliBeefed 10 років тому

      venom5809 Besides the fact that there might as well be NO back seat. I'll take a Tesla, thank you

  • @matthewkrahn3
    @matthewkrahn3 10 років тому

    Wind buffeting is the biggest complaint about my car as well.
    I love cruising with the windows down but anything over 30mph and you can't hear yourself think plus the sunroof starts vibrating. Must be a GM thing. 08 Cobalt SS coupe,

  • @jmac240sx
    @jmac240sx 10 років тому

    Not a single tire was smoked this episode! Haha. Great review though! I like seeing Zach getting some camera tine too.

  • @Nightbird.
    @Nightbird. 9 років тому

    I like the Volt and would love to purchase a used one for regular chores..but I dislike the fact that I can't get one with a moonroof nor separate AC controls for the front passengers. Why Chevy didn't offer this on such a techy car is beyond me.

  • @TailinLaer
    @TailinLaer 10 років тому

    4:11 - 2013 and newer Volt's have hold mode as well. I used it exactly how you described when commuting in Austin.

  • @urnzwayzmoove
    @urnzwayzmoove 10 років тому +1

    Love my Volt!

  • @SonOfTamriel
    @SonOfTamriel 10 років тому

    That Volt is hideous to look at as most GM cars are, but that Caddy is a beauty.

  • @T3c4x3r0
    @T3c4x3r0 10 років тому

    What would an ELR-V look and drive like? Higher horsepower electric motors and generator and a higher capacity Battery pack? Capacitors hidden somewhere for quick power output? Interesting to think about. I think a fast ELR-V could make electric cars very cool and desirable.

  • @nickflic3
    @nickflic3 10 років тому +1

    Shout out to the matte black 5 series running the red light 6:54

  • @ChrisbyChickenMan23
    @ChrisbyChickenMan23 9 років тому

    These are great videos. Really entertaining.

  • @sammyhtb
    @sammyhtb 10 років тому

    like the new review format with zack!!

  • @oldmanship
    @oldmanship 10 років тому

    For the buffeting you can go to your dealer under your 3/36k new car warantee and they will order the mirror and aero deflector kit, paint the skullcaps and install them. There is a TSB that they look up for wind noise, had this done on my 2013 Volt. You can roll one window down and enjoy it, I like driving with my windows down, so the negligible impact to efficiency was worth it to me.
    Yeah if the ELR was at 50k, I would likely be a lessee, for 75k I can live without the butt coolers that my last STS had.

    • @TheSmokingTire
      @TheSmokingTire  10 років тому

      Good tip. I'm going to have those installed at my first service.

  • @PlasticRocket
    @PlasticRocket 10 років тому +1

    A great review of two of my favorite cars!

    • @pclark1980
      @pclark1980 10 років тому

      Shit cars, both overpriced and have extra ordinary depression rates!!

  • @Jesusmakesmelovelife
    @Jesusmakesmelovelife 10 років тому

    +TheSmokingTire thanks for that detail. Everyone in my family knows how to drive stick, so we will enjoy that little bit extra evolvement in driving.

  • @RedOcktober
    @RedOcktober 9 років тому

    Great Comparison Guys... THANKS For The Ride... Matt, Looking Forward To See What You Think Of The 2016 Volt... See If You Can Get One For A Hands On...

  • @alexbrown8994
    @alexbrown8994 10 років тому

    Totally agree...The price prevents me from buying this car!

  • @lnsaneZane
    @lnsaneZane 10 років тому

    Damn might have to consider getting a Volt in the future. In Ontario, Canada the government offers you a $8200 incentive towards the full purchase of this car

  • @maciejbialy4115
    @maciejbialy4115 10 років тому

    If you had 80 miles+ of electric range you could be 100% emissions free. My Leaf doesn't dictate my life and I go where I want. I have a fuel efficient car that I use for roadtrips but otherwise all my city and surrounding driving is 100% electric. Range anxiety is not an issue. I think the Volt is a good solution for those who can only have one car but with a 200 mile Gen 3 Tesla sub 40k you can drive anywhere you want 100% electric, skip the pumps and lineups, no oil changes, and with the robust Supercharger network that will be done by then, you can roadtrip anywhere in practically the same time as a gas car!

  • @danwat1234
    @danwat1234 8 років тому +1

    How much quieter is the ELR at deadening the outside noise versus the Volt? The Volt is not ugly! Red! That plastic trim below the door looks good. But, have you heard of plastidip?

    • @Frost517
      @Frost517 7 років тому +1

      I thinkt he Volt looks awesome and it turns heads too even in 2016 three years later! LOL

    • @sinhalo
      @sinhalo 7 років тому

      Volt is ugly period. Even the 2017 one

    • @sonyawilliams4989
      @sonyawilliams4989 7 років тому

      I agree and believe the Volt turns head simply because it's ugly.

  • @JamesYoung61
    @JamesYoung61 10 років тому

    Keep up the good work guys.

  • @WN427
    @WN427 10 років тому

    When the BMW I3 comes out, it'll be very interesting to see how that compares to the Volt. With the range extender, the I3 should be around $50,000 or so.

  • @ProGoerHero
    @ProGoerHero 10 років тому

    Great job presenting Zack!

  • @joelklaus902
    @joelklaus902 10 років тому

    Nice review guys, I had never really though about these cars, especially the Volt in this particular way. I feel as though every time I took my 'fun' cars out for a drive when I owned a Volt I would feel guilty in some way, just knowing I don't have to be burning gasoline when I am. Does the Volt ever make you feel this way when you drive your C5 for example Matt?

    • @TheSmokingTire
      @TheSmokingTire  10 років тому +2

      No, not at all. The Volt is great for day to day use, and the fun cars are great for fun.

  • @4dshow
    @4dshow 10 років тому

    I wish we would have Volt at similar price here in New Zealand,a 2013 with about 3100miles is $52k USD!! And with a new price of $74k USD.

  • @YungMarsh
    @YungMarsh 10 років тому +1

    HOly crap can't believe how illegal that turn was that that 5 series made at 6:55 ...

  • @ScottZ370
    @ScottZ370 8 років тому +1

    I really loved the ELR for some reason but I completely forgot about it

    • @sonyab523
      @sonyab523 7 років тому

      S Miller I did too. I couldn't wait for the car to come and then never heard anything about. It wasn't until googling "best looking hybrid cars" did this show up. I'm glad I forgot since they are now 30k-40k now.

    • @ScottZ370
      @ScottZ370 7 років тому

      Thinking about it a year on I think I loved how it combines some American muscle car styling with some futuristic styling (or what was considered futuristic back them) and the proportions kinda worked

    • @sonyawilliams4989
      @sonyawilliams4989 7 років тому

      Yes they nailed the design, just bought one and waiting for it to arrive.

  • @Tbrick563
    @Tbrick563 10 років тому +4

    the elr looks like shit in my opinion.the volt looks fucking awsome tho. how can people call it dull looking

  • @TurboLag23
    @TurboLag23 10 років тому

    Great video!! Definitely changed my outlook on both these cars!! I mean, I live in LA too and I drive a 2008 Acura TL; I'm lucky if I average 23 MPG combined cycle because I rarely drive on the highway. 105 MPG just blows my mind!!!
    Quick question for Matt though: how much did your electric bill rise when you acquired the Volt?? Is the cost of the electricity plus the (albeit minuscule) price of fuel for the Volt still less than the price of fuel would be for a similarly-specced car, like a 2015 Mazda 3?

    • @TheSmokingTire
      @TheSmokingTire  10 років тому

      maybe $15 per month? It's like, such a small change that I don't notice it at all. The only way I got to that figure was by doing out the math of my energy bill x how often I charge. It's so small I don't notice.

  • @bgd73
    @bgd73 10 років тому +2

    120mpg?! I cannot even compute it in my brain. I spent 7 bucks once to drive 260 miles, a vw rabbit diesel with 50hp, fuel was a buck a gallon. I was in awe again at 35mpg and a cruising speed of 90mph with a 90hp boxer.. late 80s. But 120mpg, that is incredible.

    • @TheSmokingTire
      @TheSmokingTire  10 років тому +6

      this was filmed about a month ago. It's up to 127 mpg average now, haven't used fuel in a while.

    • @bgd73
      @bgd73 10 років тому

      TheSmokingTire truly incredible.

    • @TheSmokingTire
      @TheSmokingTire  10 років тому +3

      ***** There are people who have 200, 250, 300 mpg in their Volts. Leno has one (granted, he only drives it under specific circumstances) but he's done 11,000 miles on half a tank of fuel. That's like 3,000 MPG

    • @Augustus222
      @Augustus222 10 років тому

      TheSmokingTire
      Hey Matt, whats your electrical consumption in kWh? You should try to calculate the fuel equivalent of your electric energy costs. Fuel and electricity are cheaper in the US but based on a test i read, you'd end up with about 60 mpg (on electricity alone) in Germany.

    • @TheSmokingTire
      @TheSmokingTire  10 років тому

      fesch03 It's so cheap that I don't notice it on my power bill.

  • @rotaryenginepete
    @rotaryenginepete 3 роки тому

    weathertech sunvisors kill the wind buffeting

  • @PB190793
    @PB190793 10 років тому

    Great review! I still don't like the looks from both of these cars. For my part, I hope there is going to be something like synthetic fuels in the future, which would give us the chance to drive V8's and V12's forever, without the consideration of having an electric car. I would miss the original feeling of a real gas motor way too much. Anyway, to convince me of an electric car, the outter appearance has to improve!

  • @Rudyslife
    @Rudyslife 10 років тому

    Can you please do a review on a 2011 Mercedes-Benz C300 luxury and a 2009 Audi A5 3.2 really thinking about getting one of these and I trust your judge meant a lot!

  • @palakaman
    @palakaman 8 років тому +1

    You know Chevy has a wind buffeting kit and will install it under as a recall or something like that. Is that not a '13 model? Both the ELR and Volt should have hold mode.

  • @andrewfox96
    @andrewfox96 10 років тому

    If you think about it, the money that Matt Farrah doesn't spend on gas end up back into the fox body mustang. Which is a lot over time.

  • @ThereAreNoHandlesLeft
    @ThereAreNoHandlesLeft 10 років тому

    Zack Klapman did a good job as guest presenter. Bring him back again, he works on either side of the camera
    Also, as I'm assuming I know the answer to the implied question of whether or not you did race, who won the drag race between Volt and ELR?

    • @zackklapman3569
      @zackklapman3569 10 років тому

      Thanks! We didn't actually race them. They both put you in a chill mood, and the police constantly patrolling LAX frown on racing. I assume.

    • @ThereAreNoHandlesLeft
      @ThereAreNoHandlesLeft 10 років тому

      Hopefully they give you some more driving gigs. The more opinions and different voices we hear them in the more rounded view of a car we feel we get.
      The upside to the car that doesn't thrill with speed is that nobody can tell when you race.
      IE my old 77 Dodge van vs a buddy's 2.5L Cherokee. 0-60 in 16 seconds means you can drag race every light and still be slower than traffic. Not that we did

  • @TheMaxundmoritz
    @TheMaxundmoritz 10 років тому

    Back in 55 BMW made some radical cars. For example one got in from the front. They were cheap and did 50mpg. Now plain cars costing big bucks with not invented yet systems give 50mpg.