Arcade Fire - This Must Be The Place (Naive Melody)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 12 вер 2024
  • Arcade Fire feat. David Byrne
    This Must Be the Place (Naïve Melody)
    Track recorded Live at Irving Plaza, New York City, NY, USA
    February-2005
    △△△
    Drawing by Shane Snow
    aionnaturals.com

КОМЕНТАРІ • 152

  • @crashwarrior
    @crashwarrior 9 років тому +465

    Can you play This Must Be The Place by Arcade Fire? This Must Be The Place is by The Talking Heads.

  • @netipothead
    @netipothead 12 років тому +27

    This is such a sad/happy song. It has that longing feel but also says that we're exactly where we need to be. It's such a beautiful song... I love it....
    and so far I'm liking this cover a lot

    • @Fretless99
      @Fretless99 Рік тому

      One of the best love songs ever written

  • @4shanksful
    @4shanksful 12 років тому +34

    my tastes change like the wind but today these are the best lyrics ever. i forgot how much i loved this song. like falling in love all over again with a man youve been married to for years. thanks for this video!

    • @facu_avm
      @facu_avm 2 роки тому +1

      10 years in the future now.
      Has something changed for you?

    • @despicableone4495
      @despicableone4495 2 роки тому

      @@facu_avm change is the only constant

  • @ch1nmuzak
    @ch1nmuzak 11 років тому +85

    David Byrne himself has said "I don't believe vocals that are pitch perfect". Real music is not "the Voice" or "AI" folks. As redifreddy says above, Dylan and Neil Young are just 2 examples of singers with poor pitch, but with great "feel", who can actually write great songs.
    Given that the Talking Heads were all about musical experimentation, and that DB has actually appeared on stage with AF to perform this very song, I think its safe to say AF hit the nail on the head with this adaptation.

    • @jghotier167
      @jghotier167 4 роки тому

      ch1nmuzak perfectly said...I won’t embarrass myself by even trying to add to that!

    • @untitled101
      @untitled101 3 роки тому

      Hit the nail on the Talking Head

  • @jekk23
    @jekk23 4 роки тому +9

    My heart feels tender and open.
    I’m still here and so, you reading this, are you.

  • @ThePoeticEdge
    @ThePoeticEdge 12 років тому +13

    This is everything a cover should be. Magnificent.

  • @shteeeeeven12345
    @shteeeeeven12345 12 років тому +5

    It's nice to know that David Byrne actually likes Arcade Fire in real life, and they're good friends as well.

  • @7freddie7
    @7freddie7 5 років тому +9

    Wild concept folks, I love the original and this cover. What a shock.

  • @zacmorri
    @zacmorri Рік тому +14

    I'm so proud of being in the select group of people that know how to appreciate this song

  • @MagicGiant
    @MagicGiant 8 років тому +11

    We really loved your clip. You need to make many more

  • @MicaelaBicudo
    @MicaelaBicudo 8 років тому +32

    I love David Byrne and i think that he should be recognizer by more people. ..

    • @stevewilson5402
      @stevewilson5402 5 років тому +3

      I'm in agreement with you. His solo music with Brian Eno is as good as anything

  • @boboften9952
    @boboften9952 3 роки тому +3

    Home is where I want to be
    Pick me up and turn me round
    I feel numb, burn with a weak heart
    I guess I must be having fun
    The less we say about it the better
    Make it up as we go along
    Feet on the ground
    Head in the sky
    It's ok I know nothing's wrong... nothing
    Hi yo I got plenty of time
    Hi yo you got light in your eyes
    And you're standing here beside me
    I love the passing of time
    Never for money
    Always for love
    Cover up + say goodnight... say goodnight
    ...
    Home, is where I want to be
    But I guess I'm already there
    I come home, she lifted up her wings
    Guess that this must be the place
    I can't tell one from another
    Did I find you, or you find me?
    There was a time before we were born
    If someone asks, this where I'll be where I'll be
    Hi yo we drift in and out
    Hi yo sing into my mouth
    Out of all those kinds of people
    You got a face with a view
    I'm just an animal looking for a home
    Share the same space for a minute or two
    And you love me till my heart stops
    Love me till I'm dead
    Eyes that light up, eyes look through you
    Cover up the blank spots
    Hit me on the head ah ooh
    Songwriters: C. Frantz / T. Weymouth / D. Byrne / J. Harrison
    This Must Be the Place (Naive Melody) lyrics © Wb Music Corp., Index Music, Inc.

  • @medicatedmarrionet
    @medicatedmarrionet 14 років тому +2

    A great version of this song...and I normally hate remakes, this makes me so happy. =]

    • @cristiancastro597
      @cristiancastro597 2 роки тому

      This ramke makes me sad. The most sadness person in the world. Even could try to rip off my b4lls whe i hear it.

  • @lucyelkins7731
    @lucyelkins7731 Рік тому

    Most interesting cover I've heard yet. I like it, I like it a lot 😜

  • @Insaneronald
    @Insaneronald 13 років тому +1

    great cover, AF puts its energy and creativity in it, not just copying. Great !!!

  • @GrisGrisOnUrDoorStep
    @GrisGrisOnUrDoorStep 13 років тому +3

    awesome I love the talking heads but this is very interesting and original we need more new wave influence in music today

  • @numbertwosis
    @numbertwosis 13 років тому

    I'm a talking heads of old fan, and love arcade fire too. Great rendition. I like their twist on a lovely song.

  • @KhalsaJones
    @KhalsaJones 3 роки тому

    Wherever I want 2 be = Omnipresence

  • @dominiqueriosDP
    @dominiqueriosDP 9 років тому +5

    I just thumb up this video because I admire David Byrne's music work. I don't know what happened to his voice here but he's a genius anyways.

    • @roberttaber3023
      @roberttaber3023 8 років тому +1

      +Dominique Ríos This is Arcade Fire lol

    • @DigitalVomitTV
      @DigitalVomitTV 8 років тому +2

      +Robert Taber says ft. david byrne

  • @FrankCircles
    @FrankCircles 12 років тому +1

    FEET ON THE GROUND, HEAD IN THE SKY! no head in the sky, feet on the ground

  • @biancaarvizuflores6132
    @biancaarvizuflores6132 5 років тому +1

    I fucking love this.

  • @nicolaattilioromano4545
    @nicolaattilioromano4545 4 роки тому +1

    Nice cover

  • @kingbarrage2267
    @kingbarrage2267 5 років тому +2

    Oh yeah yeah

  • @geefly71
    @geefly71 14 років тому +1

    You're a fucking genius, mate. Thanks for making my day. Beautiful...:)

  • @PatrickStunner
    @PatrickStunner 11 років тому

    Very nice.

  • @Merely
    @Merely 11 років тому +2

    Wiki says David Byrne IS doing these vocals!

  • @bugsy2468
    @bugsy2468 3 роки тому +2

    As far as covers go this is perfect and so reverent. May even surpass the original for its delicateness

  • @IndieMusicFan13
    @IndieMusicFan13 14 років тому +1

    Great cover! You're a great artist, I enjoyed this video very much! Poor Win sounds like he is sick, though still a great cover!

  • @Sternertime
    @Sternertime 7 років тому

    love

  • @SeanLulis-uj9wv
    @SeanLulis-uj9wv Рік тому

    I wonder what kinda drive he uses for that tone on his guitar. Goes to show easy repetitive music lines can be cranked by adjusting you preamps.
    You don't have to be a "legendary" guitarer to be an AWESOME one

  • @AreYouOffended
    @AreYouOffended 11 років тому +12

    You are some clown. David Byrne featured vocals on this track because he adores Arcade Fire.

  • @aboutkieokieo
    @aboutkieokieo 10 років тому +7

    super cute song

  • @iampower714
    @iampower714 13 років тому

    good stuff!

  • @MacakFric-dt3qg
    @MacakFric-dt3qg Рік тому

    Talking Heads was really something special

  • @TheNellamaria
    @TheNellamaria 11 років тому

    Good band!

  • @ant0586
    @ant0586 13 років тому

    i actually like it

  • @dolly8596
    @dolly8596 6 років тому +3

    I love arcade fire but I think I'm gonna have to go with the original song

  • @jasonb.3902
    @jasonb.3902 3 роки тому

    If someone asks....THIS is where I'll be.

  • @lifeislife4life
    @lifeislife4life 11 років тому

    I love this version of Naive Melody. Dat voice.

  • @FrankCircles
    @FrankCircles 11 років тому +4

    Wall Street by Oliver Stone brought me here.

  • @emilm6474
    @emilm6474 5 років тому +2

    His voice man, it's sunding like he really needs to clear his throat but never does it. Kind of annoyong but still wonderfull to listen to.

  • @doctorgeek1561
    @doctorgeek1561 8 років тому +1

    I love everything else about this cover, just always wondered why Win's voice sounded so strained. Maybe if it wasn't you wouldn't constantly get Talking Heads fans repeatedly calling it "Awful" or "Horrible".

    • @RmB9104
      @RmB9104 8 років тому +9

      I believe David was guest singer in this

    • @JamieR2062
      @JamieR2062 6 років тому

      some parts of it sound like Win though, so idk

  • @symalus
    @symalus 11 років тому

    dat shit be cray

  • @Idonteatdog
    @Idonteatdog 12 років тому

    That was David Byrne and The Cure. Search for this.

  • @purifyz
    @purifyz 13 років тому +12

    talking heads did pretty good cover of this

  • @nataliecarlin5764
    @nataliecarlin5764 11 років тому +2

    spot on freddy. takin heads version is better , but this is a great cover though. arcade fire are the best musicians these days.

  • @Sandwhaler
    @Sandwhaler 11 років тому +2

    For some reason this reminds me of Winnie the Pooh. Maybe it's his voice.

  • @TheSample123
    @TheSample123 11 років тому

    David Byrne wrote the song, whilst Talking Heads were still together. So, it's no surprise really that he sings on this. Regardless, not a bad cover.

  • @anlacombe
    @anlacombe 10 років тому +4

    Great Cover.. almost original

  • @Uyeda98
    @Uyeda98 6 років тому +2

    David Byrne is in this? I can't hear him. I only hear the Arcade Fire singer.

    • @freedomofmotion
      @freedomofmotion 5 років тому +1

      Listen to the bit where the lyrics is " love me till my heart stops" you can him there. This is badly mixed heh.

  • @HCDeathAngel
    @HCDeathAngel 11 років тому +1

    such a underrated film.. many people claim they like it just because of Sean Penn, thus completely ignoring the underlying magic and meaning. but anyway, good choice ;)

  • @Fuchsia_tude
    @Fuchsia_tude 13 років тому

    What happened to Win's voice?

  • @pattyislive
    @pattyislive 12 років тому +5

    Probably the only band that could ever attempt to cover this and get away with it. Just.

    • @ethangarcia6014
      @ethangarcia6014 6 років тому

      treeisthemagiclumber I can't even hear the fucking singer. he sounds like he's had one too many cigarettes

    • @KnoseDoge
      @KnoseDoge 6 років тому

      Ethan Garcia that is david byrne lmao

  • @AndrewThreeThousand
    @AndrewThreeThousand 13 років тому

    I like the real one.

  • @mk196a
    @mk196a 13 років тому

    D byrne sang with them, I would think that means soething

  • @THISHERESREAL2011
    @THISHERESREAL2011 11 років тому +1

    I love Arcade Fire to death, but there is a difference between not sounding perfect and sounding horrible. It sounds like he has a fucking stoma.

  • @pythag123
    @pythag123 13 років тому

    I saw David last year or a two ago and he sounded nothing like this, I doubt it is him singing.

  • @20syncopate10
    @20syncopate10 12 років тому +1

    im just an animal lookin for a home...

  • @cheungzane
    @cheungzane 5 років тому +2

    Omg so much negativity. It’s a great cover. Relax everyone knows it’s a talking heads song.

  • @cadamham
    @cadamham 7 місяців тому

    This is great but Perpetual Groove is the best cover

  • @leonardoc993
    @leonardoc993 11 років тому

    Same here ! I liked that movie the original song is a little better...

    • @edfoss7561
      @edfoss7561 5 років тому

      Saw talking heads and arcade fire live do this song. David Byrne gave his blessing, so do I

  • @joebaumgart1146
    @joebaumgart1146 2 роки тому

    David Byrne should have dropped it down an octave, he's not 25 anymore. Otherwise great song.

  • @bburditt
    @bburditt 13 років тому

    @EvenZappa hehehe

  • @sharonmtvharrison
    @sharonmtvharrison 11 років тому +1

    NOTHING Arcade Fire does is pointless. Nothing. I love Talking Heads. I saw them when they just started out in a small little dive in New Town Chicago. But as innovative and ahead of their time, they helped spawn Arcade Fire but AF took the torch and ran with it and left Talking Heads in the dust.

  • @yudesc
    @yudesc 11 років тому +1

    Nah I love Talking Heads version more. This is alright

  • @4thekingdom100
    @4thekingdom100 5 років тому

    Best version, after the original of course

  • @gibberish4545
    @gibberish4545 11 років тому

    Wish he could sing the words right though....

  • @polterrghost
    @polterrghost 6 років тому

    Instrumentals up until the vocals were spectacular. Then this guy comes singing like a smoker on his deathbed. Holy fuck dude.

  • @chrishefner3869
    @chrishefner3869 7 років тому +1

    Its a shame when an iconic song is covered and not done justice.

  • @07foxmulder
    @07foxmulder 12 років тому +1

    I love both bands, but I'm not feeling this at all.

  • @sreesanthsasidharan3841
    @sreesanthsasidharan3841 6 років тому +11

    Anybody who thinks this is an original, trust me, you are delusional.

  • @oskiewhoaskie
    @oskiewhoaskie 12 років тому

    Helps to have a voice before ya sing

  • @tomelifeisjustonebig
    @tomelifeisjustonebig 4 роки тому

    This version is so fucked it makes the Lumineers version tolerable.

  • @Bombfox94
    @Bombfox94 10 років тому +33

    wow this is bad haha

    • @matthieudavette
      @matthieudavette 7 років тому +2

      C'est super ! qu'est ce que vous racontez ?

  • @Baggot444
    @Baggot444 9 років тому +14

    Horrible. I'm offended.

    • @theattachecase6666
      @theattachecase6666 9 років тому +6

      kitty vargas I'm offended by your shitty personality.

    • @Baggot444
      @Baggot444 9 років тому +1

      HAHAHAHHA wtf? 😂 0-100 real quick. Take a nap dude

    • @JockoJonson17
      @JockoJonson17 7 років тому +1

      This cover is a bit of a Dumpster Fire.

  • @erikaruggeri4876
    @erikaruggeri4876 12 років тому +1

    My god, this is horrible!

  • @markkickmark
    @markkickmark 8 років тому +1

    the vocals are quite bad.

  • @rodrigogomes4677
    @rodrigogomes4677 2 роки тому

    My god this cover sounds bad, is the singer dying?

  • @frankbranchini8938
    @frankbranchini8938 6 років тому +1

    What a way to ruin a wonderful song. The vocalist is truly awful. Although this claims to feature David Byrne, he is obviously not singing.

    • @rainierr9356
      @rainierr9356 5 років тому

      They can't even claim to be amateurs, which would give them a plausible excuse..

  • @JayDeath1
    @JayDeath1 9 років тому

    No me gusta.

  • @molecularash
    @molecularash 13 років тому

    this is...pretty terrible

  • @cityraintunes
    @cityraintunes 13 років тому

    Gotta be honest. This is really horrible. Instrumentation is great. The voice is truly awful.

  • @EvenZappa
    @EvenZappa 13 років тому

    This guy can't sing.....

  • @rogerrtewwr4723
    @rogerrtewwr4723 3 роки тому

    this version sucks tbh

  • @kingidiot4423
    @kingidiot4423 5 років тому

    Bad