I love this song just like I love B1A4 this was one of the songs that got me into B1A4 and I love it. BANA 4 EVER I PROMISE and it's gonna be almost 5 years since I made this promise and I don't regret it or will ever, my #1 group since the start till the end.
I'm glad this melancholy song ended on a rather positive, healing note. I like that this song told a whole story within mere minutes with a satisfying ending.
The 14 years old me didn't know the meaning of this lyrics and now I'm 21 listening to this song again, I felt it tho. Cause I experience this kind of situation now with my ex bf, like 💯 of the lyrics reflect his situation. 😂
It's now 2018 and for me, this music is still legend. I was a bana since 2013 but then, i heard jin of bts was sandeuls friend, that's why i became an army! I miss b1a4 already... i became more focus on bts than b1a4, then i heard about produce 101, then heard the new project group called wanna one then became wannable! Omg
What's up with Asians and asking their girlfriends if they have eaten yet? Is that like a cultural thing? I'm really curious. Nuest said something along the lines of like did you eat.
Paraphrasing from a Korean friend who explained this to me... Korea went through a post-war period of widespread hunger and famine, and during this time, everyone was pretty concerned about whether or not their loved ones had eaten. It stuck, and nowadays, it's more of a courtesy than a real question. It's basically like asking "how are you doing?".
Some parts of the instrumental sounds like Jay Z ft. Alicia Keys - 'Empire State of Mind' to me For some reason, the video and audio of the song is blocked on youtube but you can have a listen to it here - vimeo.com/29885705
와..몇년이 지나도 멜로디 생각나서 검색해서 옴 ㅠㅠ띵곡이야
저두요 ㅠㅠㅠ
@@김주희-j7q1y +1
2020년 추억회상 ㅠㅠ
여전히 목소리 좋은 우리 비포오빠들...
사진 대박 앳됐다 ㅠㅠㅠ 예뻐 ㅠㅠ
와 이노래 엄청들었는데.. 넘추억 ㅜ
2020 and suddenly remember about this song and being heartbroken person even im single
Ghost Season 3 ah Me too
지금 들으니 뭔가 추억회상같다..ㅎㅎ
the blending of their voices its wow!
I miss them :( their songs will always be my favorite :)
I love this song just like I love B1A4 this was one of the songs that got me into B1A4 and I love it. BANA 4 EVER I PROMISE and it's gonna be almost 5 years since I made this promise and I don't regret it or will ever, my #1 group since the start till the end.
For me this is Sandeul best vocal😍😍😍
I'm glad this melancholy song ended on a rather positive, healing note. I like that this song told a whole story within mere minutes with a satisfying ending.
just listen to this song again , this song was my childhood song, really missed b1a4 even tho baro and jinyoung already left b1a4.
노래 존니 좋네
The 14 years old me didn't know the meaning of this lyrics and now I'm 21 listening to this song again, I felt it tho. Cause I experience this kind of situation now with my ex bf, like 💯 of the lyrics reflect his situation. 😂
same
가장 처음으로 좋아했던 아이돌
suddenly remembered this song ✨ ART
Back then I was 13 and just got into kpop when I first heard this song, its been 10 years since then..... wow
공찬오빠♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥
It's now 2018 and for me, this music is still legend. I was a bana since 2013 but then, i heard jin of bts was sandeuls friend, that's why i became an army! I miss b1a4 already... i became more focus on bts than b1a4, then i heard about produce 101, then heard the new project group called wanna one then became wannable! Omg
진짜 비포 사랑한다 ㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜ
사랑한다 진짜
2019?
a memory song when I was in middle school 😭😭😭
Its 3rd January 2020 guys and here meeeeee 😭
Esta cancion tambien marco mi juventud ,😖🤗
아아아... 찐자 사랑스럽다.😭
I feel this to the core...wish my Ex bf said this to me... When I broke up with him this song came into my mind ...
my fave song pf bipo :((( it's give so much memory and now they're having a comeback!
2020 and i'm still a bana
2021?
Jinyoung!!!😘💖
I can't help but hear CNU sing: I don't wanna leave your girl a baby!
haha still love my bias
.
2020
2023 yet still here
이때 진짜 산들 오빠 파트 많다♥♥
2021년에 듣는 사람 손🤚
너무 좋아요^^
공찬오빠파트가적다...그래도♥.♥
내 꺼야아아!
b1a4
진영 오빠 지금 어디있어요?
i miss my boyyys 😟
♥♥♥♥♥♥
What's up with Asians and asking their girlfriends if they have eaten yet? Is that like a cultural thing? I'm really curious. Nuest said something along the lines of like did you eat.
Paraphrasing from a Korean friend who explained this to me... Korea went through a post-war period of widespread hunger and famine, and during this time, everyone was pretty concerned about whether or not their loved ones had eaten. It stuck, and nowadays, it's more of a courtesy than a real question. It's basically like asking "how are you doing?".
oh okay thanks for explaining that to me
It's kind of endearing, too. It's one way of knowing that he/she cares for you
Saranghae❤️
ㅎ 넘 좋당~~~!!
The instrumental sounds REALLY familiar! Can anyone help please?
Some parts of the instrumental sounds like Jay Z ft. Alicia Keys - 'Empire State of Mind' to me
For some reason, the video and audio of the song is blocked on youtube but you can have a listen to it here - vimeo.com/29885705
lavhhhhh 💕💕💕💕
2022 년에 온나
2020?
너무 좋은데 슬픈 노래 같아요.
2020?