Are ghost ships real? - Peter B. Campbell
Вставка
- Опубліковано 25 лип 2024
- View full lesson: ed.ted.com/lessons/are-ghost-s...
Please note: we are currently working on a fix for an error spotted in the video. The error relates to the behavior of the water filling the hole in the Mary Celeste's hull. The water would reach equilibrium with the outside water level, not cease filling at the hole. We thank you for your patience as we work on a fix.
In 1884, the British steamer “Rumney” crashed into the French ship “Frigorifique.” Seeing their ship filling with water, the French crew climbed aboard the “Rumney.” But as they sailed towards port, a silent form emerged from the fog - the abandoned “Frigorifique,” seemingly back for revenge. So what happened? Peter B. Campbell investigates the fascinating phenomenon of ghost ships.
Lesson by Peter B. Campbell, animation by Zedem Media.
Paranormalists will hate this video.
But is 'how does the boat keep sailing?' the more important question for paranormalists, or is it 'why did the crew suddenly abandon all at once a ship capable of continuing to sail for a long time further?'. Though I guess in some cases the 'how does the boat keep sailing?' is also important for cases where it seems implausible for the ship to have not encountered weather that would require active crew to keep the ship afloat between when the boat was abandoned and when it was rediscovered.
You require sailor to operate a vessel - just floating on ocean current, not so much. And you abandon the ship before it sinks (or you think will be sinking) so obviously miss judgement might cause pre-mature abandonment.
When you are stuck on a wooden ship with only a few crew, in the empty nothingness for months at a time, imagination takes over. Why do you think people say sailors are (or were) a superstitious lot? The rest of us land people just like a good ghost story than boring reality hence all the supernatural stories.
Seeno ah I remember the good ol' days when it was a trend to say "49 paranormalists just watched this video"
+SQW0 that makes sense
physics is made by ghosts
The animation was so great, I almost forgot to listen.
wxactly
yeah ^^
yeah!
Galaxy Cat, Destroyer of Worlds nothing, NOTHING special you say? They are special, the style, the details, every animation is special! Now, these animators worked really hard to animate these!
Galaxy Cat, Destroyer of Worlds You absolutely have no senses sensitive to art. What a pity. Let's see you animate something as beautiful as this. Yeah, someone like you could never pull it off so I hope you are at least capable of shutting your mouth.
Explaining ghost stories with science facts is probably my new favourite thing
Debunking science is my favorite!
@@IsraelCountryCube debunking ghost stories with science is my favorite thing
No Flying Dutchman?! How dare you!
The Flying Dutchman is an example of another phenomena entirely (i.e. superior mirage), this video is about physical ghost ships.
Aldo ikr. I came for the tittle that may be mention about it, but it ends up not. How disappointing.
LMAO seems I wasn't the only one hoping for this.
HAsh sliNging bash blinging crash slash slingin slasher?
oh there is... hes my dutch boss, he ripped off 4 customers for their deposit and flew off lol
"YOU BEST START BELIEVIN' IN GHOST STORIES MISS TURNER"
-"You're in one!"
pirategirlfan301 LIAR LIAR
actually its possible to call her elizabeth swan, depend on the movie and time
David Kim he was quoting a dialogue from the first movie, so no.
3:20 oh so that’s why the ocean taste salty
Yes
Ha
* ba-dum- chhh! *
Not rlly...
@@overcookedwater1947 no 🙄
I feel bad laughing at Mary Celeste. They jumped into life boats and died at sea while the Mary Celeste stayed afloat. The irony in that situation is hilarious.
The irony of tragedy
Yes, but if they had stayed then the relative weight would have increased, causing the ship to go further down, under equilibrium, and sink. lol they would have died both ways
Yes, but if they had stayed then the relative weight would have increased, causing the ship to go further down, under equilibrium, and sink. lol they would have died both ways
@@dhruvrao18 Throw the cargo away to keep the balance, problem solved.
@@JonatasAdoM true
The Mary Celeste is intriguing not because it still floats around... but rather where & why the people are gone.
BioCapsule because the ship was sinking
BioCapsule He says it in the video like it's fact, but then said all of the crew died at sea. So then, how does he know that it definitely what happened?
Yes I know this is old
@@jeremy5602 if 90% of the time a ship filling w water is gonna sink and ur boat fills with water, you'd prolly abandon ship. Same goes here, it's pretty safe to assume they abandoned ship if it was filling with water. They obviously abandoned ship but nobody knows if the crew died if that's what you're asking. The crew never showed up so it's safe to assume they died at sea
@@jasonpeng5798 well if that's just a rumor then our savior is the word "likely"
@@jasonpeng5798 the boat wasn’t filled 90% with water when abandoned, only a little bit of water that would be normal in a storm. Any experienced captain/crew would know that the boat would survive that small amount of water. If you look more deeply into all the details its actually a very strange situation. 9 barrels of denatured alcohol were empty, a frayed rope trailed behind the ship, one water pump was damaged, and the lifeboat was gone. However, everything else was in its place and undamaged.
The most plausible theory in my opinion is that the alcohol spilt and the fumes fill the ship, cause an explosion hazard. so the captain wanted everyone to to get in the lifeboat and tie It to the ship to trail behind it while the ships fumes aired out. However the rope snapped and the lifeboat with everyone on it was lost at sea.
buzzfeed unsolved's last upload was about ghost ship (Queen Mary) and now Ted Ed....what a time to be alive.
I really hope they are not connected!
just came to say this. Fuck Buzzfeed
Joy Balmes buzzfeed is fake news
just like WSJ
Queen Mary is a Haunted Ship, not Ghost ship i think? Haunted because multiple sightings of ghost due to many death in the ship. But i think ghost ship refers to unmanned ship? Ship that sailed without crew?
Welp time to go to the Bermuda Triangle and test this out myself!
live stream it
I fully support this
Jaiden Cross Lol i hope you know the bermuda triangle has just as many boat and plane disappearances as any other place.
Jaiden Cross r u dead yet
Or do u have an amazing story to tell now
i dnt get the Bermuda Triangle at all lol
Science is cool and all but the idea of ghost ships is much funner than just a bunch of boats floating around.
Limerence I may be in primary school, but I still love science!
Zainab Tahir WOW!!! REALLY? MY GOODNESS!! WE ALL CARE SO MUCH, NOW DONT WE?
Thanks for the enthusiasm Marx, your opinion is utmost important to us.
More fun*
Limerence 🇦🇺🇦🇹🇧🇪🇧🇷🇨🇦🇨🇱🇨🇳🇨🇴🇩🇰🇫🇮🇫🇷🇩🇪🇭🇰🇮🇳🇮🇩🇮🇪🇮🇱🇮🇹🇯🇵🇰🇷🇲🇴🇲🇾🇲🇽🇳🇱🇳🇿🇷🇺🇸🇦🇸🇬🇿🇦🇪🇸🇸🇪🇨🇭🇹🇷🇬🇧🇺🇸🇦🇪🇻🇳
Do ghosts have relation-ship to those ships?
Armas Tikko should be pun-nished for this lame 1!
Nice joke to be honest
Dan Iel Tom hanks m8
shipt
I got no puns sorry😞🏝⛴⛴⛴⛴⛴⛴⛴⛴⛴⛴⛴⛴⛴⛴⛴⛴⛴⛴⛴⛴⛴⛴⛴⛴⛴⛴⛴⛴⛴⛴⛴⛴⛴⛴⛴⛴⛴⛴⛴⛴
Armas Tikko Hahaha so fun-ny
Just imagine how scary a ship would be, sailing along filled with corpses and in the middle of an ocean, hella spooky, especially on a foggy night.
*gets hit by another ship*
*gets abandoned*
*hits the other ship and all those who abandoned it while it sinks*
Frigorifique is on the levels of petty I aspire to reach.
The incredible effort put into this video's animations has not been lost on me. It is very clear the creator(s) put a great deal of thought into this piece. The detail is really extraordinary. Just look at how the compass' (bottom right) motion was reconfigured at 1:43 so that it swings in tandem with the ship.
I don’t think anyone questioned how the Mary Celeste was floating, but rather they questioned where the crew went
Captain Barbossa made all of them drown.
They went to the Davy Jones locker
lifeboats missing and water in the hull. Doesnt take a genius to figure out what happened mate
@@abdullahimran4624 they freaked out, released life boats in a panic then jumped after it and drowned?
*Titanic's ghost ship*: These petty humans already made a movie of my demise..?? I'm still here..!!
Watch your language pony mouth
fuck off kid
whatever it's at the bottom of the ocean...
Maybe he meant ... pretty* :/
waiittt.. than whats the ship at the bottom of the north atlantic?
When they collected data it reminded me of those rubber duckies they keep track of in the ocean
Bella1candy k
@@PhartingFeeting kkk
2:48 The lesson learned is if ya think your boat's sinking, stay on it and scream YOLO
a potato a
a potato well that is what captains actually did (except from yelling yolo)
But can you explain what happened to the things that go missing in the Bermuda Triangle
+TheOMGsee
Why not sail in and conduct an experiment for yourself?
Watch the video of Lemmino based on Bermuda triangle..
U will like it.
TheOMGsee g
Sea farts.
Ryan Low
Might not be as effective as you think.
Most ships and aircraft that go in it, come out safely.
As a matter of fact, there are just as many disappearances in the Bermuda Triangle, as there is anywhere else waterborne.
What truly stumps researchers is how strange the disappearances are, and also how strange the stories of those that have been in it are.
See I never really put the boat continuing to sail as something supernatural. It's a boat, it's built to do that and unless something bad happens that requires urgent attention from a crew it's going to keep sailing. I thought the weird ghost part of these ghost ships was that the crew just up and left all at the same time even though evidently the ship was still functional.
True though humans making poor judgements based on inaccurate or incomplete information is hardly anything new. I could quite easily see how this could happen if the crew became convinced the ship was doomed by flooding, fire, storms or even as a result of hallucinated problems due to the consumption of contaminated foodstuffs (The fungus Ergot has a history of this sort of mass hysteria before we had the means to test for it's presence in grain stores).
hn
It's just good business.
As a dutchie I'm kinda offended that the Flying dutchman didn't appear in this video :/
Speechless Gamer as a human I don't care.
As another fellow human I too feel inclined to be a condescending dick.
As another human being, I feel inclined to type my worthless reply and put my two cents into this even more worthless comment chain.
Speechless Gamer same here
As another human I’m gonna do something humany
"STOP BLOWING HOLES IN MY SHIP!"
How disappointing it is when you are expecting some haunted reason and the narrator is always like:
*it’s a natural phenomenon!*
The story of the Mary Celeste seems pretty misrepresented here from what I know about it.
When the ship was found, the boat held only a little bit of water, which would’ve been expected in any sea storm. Any experienced captain/crew would know that the boat would survive that small amount of water. Only a few things were out of place: 9 barrels of denatured alcohol were found empty, a frayed rope was trailing behind the ship, one water pump was damaged, and the lifeboat was gone along with all the crew. However, everything else was in its place and undamaged. There was no signs of a struggle. There were plenty of supplies left and all personal items were still on the ship. It seems that they either left extremely urgently OR they left thinking they would be back on the ship shortly.
The most plausible theory, in my opinion, is that the denatured alcohol spilt and filled the ship. The alcohol released fumes (making it hard to breathe) and was an explosion hazard. So, the captain told everyone to get in the lifeboat, tie it to the ship, and trail behind it while the fumes aired out and the alcohol was pumped out by the water pumps. One of the water pumps was broken, so the alcohol was taking a long time to get pumped out. Eventually, the rope snapped and the lifeboat, with everyone in it, was lost at sea while the ship sailed off unmanned.
DELETE THIS NOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Would love to see more videos about the paranormal and superstitions.
AlwaysBored Ted-Ed has a video about superstitions. The video is okay but I wish they had covered more in it and made it much longer than it is.
You need Jesus 😂
@@MOCCHA101 bruh. No thanks
@@starberry22 5 years now
Watches pirates of Caribbean an hour ago.
UA-cam: so you like ghost ships eh?
Me: *is watching cats video.
Ted-Ed: Why do cats act so weird - James Buffington
You best believe in ghost stories, cus you're in one
liked before even watching
Why?
Every video is worth liking
Because kick-ass topic.
Anonymous seeker
I didn't, because I wasn't sure how this could be interesting to me. turns out it was though..
*_”I See the ghosts of navigators_*
*_But they are lost_*
*_As they sail into the sunset_*
*_They’ll count the cost_*
*_As their skeletons accusing_*
*_Emerge from the sea_*
*_The sirens of the rocks_*
*_They beckon me”_*
LOVE the animation!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
This video just took the thrill out of ghost concepts now
Ikr 😤
At 2:07, the video was actually wrong in describing why certain objects always float. It's actually because the buoyant force is always EQUAL to the gravitational force, due to the object (such as ice) always got enough volume to displace the weight of the water.
*_and now i'm googling all these ghost ships_*
Very interesting video. For that reason, it's disappointing that it ended so quickly. I'm sure many more "ghost ship" sightings could have been explored.
This is one of the most informative TED videos. Good work, thanks!
I like the animator added the same archimedes from the video of archimedes' Eureka.
Reminds me of the Flying Dutchman from Spongebob 😂 #Childhood
simplymaci as I am below the age of 13, I love Spongebob Square pants!!!
You used a Hashtag and an emoji in the same comment, you should feel ashamed, lol.
simplymaci yup #missmychildhood😂
simplymaci k
Dude The Flying Dutchman is the real ship of Davy Jones
Oh, the Flying Duchtman!!!
Very interesting! Love the video and the animations! :D
The animation is incredible! Ted is just amazing!
So science can really prove ghost ships are real.
Science can prove nearly everything is real
When you're an engineer, nothing impressionates you anymore, you know every possible trick .. Life is sad !! 😂😂
The best thing about Ted-ed is their animated videos which make the whole information, an entertaining and immersive experience.
this is one of my favorite ted-ed videos ever
3:07 No wonder the ocean is salty...
my childhood is over ;-;
AlliCat Martinez and so mine
Remember sailors, don't leave your engine running.
I really enjoy your videos and learning more about history and cool facts. I think that your videos are also very helpful with my school assignments and even though some aren't used for school, they are still enjoyable to watch! I really love your myths and thinks their amazing but other videos and just as enjoyable!💞💞♥️
notification squadddddd onwards and forwards
FOR HOONOOOR
1:35
When I saw the pool floaty and the drink and the I was like was it because they were partying
Thankyou for not talking about ghosts I would of gotten rid of the channel. Keeping it real and scientific much respect
Ted Ed, you guys have become my most favorite channel in youtube.
Ey,Pirates of the Caribbean!
The best movie franchise for me
come on ghosts arent real
go to graveyard in 12pm and you will find out.. can you?
sajan ll lol 12pm is noon
haha i mean 12am XD...:)
then film it for a proof...i dare you.
Did you even watch the video?
I enjoyed this video a lot, thank you Ted
The archimedes picture frame at the end is so cute 😂😂😂😂😂😂💕
유령선이 실제로 존재하지 않다는것을 배우고 잘 알려진 유령선들이 유령선이 아닌것을 증명해보는 시간이 되었습니다. 정말 재미있는 시간이 되었습니다. 감사합니다. 응원합니다!
Maybe you'll Found Jack there ( Titanic Vibes )
Man I am loving these videos, please keep them coming first Frankenstein now ghost ships its like a childhood dream.
there's nothing more satisfying than an already fascinating legend combined with the science behind it
I love it also! A few weird coincidences or unfortunate circumstances, leads to "a mystery or paranormal activity"! Whereas, it's just science and the conditions that lead to the event to happen.
I’m fourth grade, my teacher read us the “mystery” of the Mary Celeste. I always wondered what actually happened. Thank you!!!
3:15 "but as the salt dissolved in the water...."
Me: So that's how the salt water was born....
Very interesting, and thank you very much for the subtitels.
I loved the the picture of Archimedes sitting in a tub of water at 4:39, referring to the time when he discovered the Archimedes's Principle of weight displacement/buoyancy and running down the street shouting "Eureka". :D
*I IS NEEDS FLY DUTCH DUDE*
I like typing like that
Did anyone see the picture in the bottom left corner at 4:45? Or was I the only one...
This channel is an endless stream of joy
Man anyone else hate that instead of scary ghost ships this was a lesson?
Christopher Sob it’s called Ted-Ed , what did you expect?
Ever been so backed up you got bigger?
Who comes up with these questions for the videos?
Star Friend my mada
Star Friend They have people who smoke weed and read history and science books 24/7
Love these videos.
this video animation was awesome. keep it up dude and make more ghostly videos
I'm still scared though . sadly my brain can't apprehend common sense
Matenjeh Sarif send your brain to feminism head-quarter,they will fix it for you.
ko aung
No, they will make it worse!
I don't get the physics in this clip. The water doesn't fill until it has reached the hole, it continues until the water level is the same in the ship and outside the ship (that's when it's in equilibrium) In this case, no water is displaced and the ship sinks.
The only way I can think of is if the water gets isolated in chambers so that it doesn't reach into the rest of the ship. This would stop the inflow of water.
Blobfisher yeah. and somehow the ships crew that probably had decades experience of sailing. abandoned the ship immedietly without checking if the ship sink
This is correct. The video is mistaken, or misleading at best.
They realized this mistake. Read the description.
but the ship only gains weight when the salt isn't dissolved so when it desolves the ship becomes boyant again
Love this episode!
Awesome way to combine physics principles and strange, but interesting phenomenon
200 ghosts disliked this video
Demons do exist they are powerful wicked spirits, but there is one in whom the demons fear...
dafuq u talkin
Cyvan John 8:32 Then you will know the truth and the truth will set you free.
Learn the truth about the bible for more info visit jw.org
Truth about the bible? You mean the fact, that it's a random made-up man-written book?
Cyvan SmH...
Braum sucs way more than the Bible
Thank you Ted-Ed....smarter every day!
This ultrasonic noise while the icons pop in through.. :3
how were there engines in 1800s????
Rohan Singh ever heard of steam engines?
Yeah but, as far as I know they were used for traveling places nearby and for transcontinental journeys sail ships were used(in 1800S)
Well, the collision took place in 1884, by that time a lot of transcontinental ships were steam powered and had sails only for backup, besides, it is not mentioned what kind of ships these two were
maybe a confusion with the (Put a century here) s?
1800s refer to 1700 to 1800, not to 1800 to 1900
woops a bit of confusion on my side...
'Are ghost ships real?'... WTF?... No! They're 'GHOST' Ships. Duh!
For some reason, I find it really cool that empty ships just continued on their merry way for years after being abandoned.
I almost didn't click this video because I thought the title was referring to spooky transparent white ships with no mass, which obviously don't exist.
this was actually way more interesting than real ghost ships
early asf..
first
Helena Kidacka to get some milk and cookies😝😝😝😝😂😂🍼🍪🍪 but others are allowed to share😜😁
okay
Helena Kidacka First
*BLUE SHELL*
Ocean: "It's my ship now! Imma take this bad boy for a spin!"
I don't get how TED-Ed can make money off these videos. They are such high quality and must take much more to make then they make from them.
Ghosts aren't real!!! God is not real!!! There is no after life!!!
Just the here and now!!! So make the most of it!!!
👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍
Jay Kay god is real and ghost
Jay Kay cuse i have seen s ghost
Jay Kay Troll.
WhqAm_I - Norsk Gaming! No you haven't! 🙄
I have one day i wass in my room and then i heard a screem and i got worried i walked down and the my sister was sitting in the sofa crying i asked her what it was she sayd it was like a jumpscare and like 10 min late the same happened to me
ted ed: are ghost ships real?
the ad before the video: join the navy
When the guy said they left the engine running, i made a sound between a snort and laugh.
That picure of Archimedes at 4:44 is too cute
Welcome 5 years later
I want my essays written like this 😔
When crew leaves the ship, the weight decrises too
I think it's far more amazing that those abandoned ship are found again.
Far slimmer chances than a needle in a haystack.
Archimedes in a bathtub in a picture on the desk on the last frame. Funny.
fantastic. very well presented
man these videos are beautiful to watch
As a Mainer seeing images and depictions of ship tracking and seeing the ships were built in local towns around me is such amazing history!
Loved this video ❤️