How does the Global South see Ukraine crisis?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 30 бер 2022
- For more:
www.cgtn.com/video
The world is still waiting for the Russian response to proposals made by Ukraine during peace talks in Turkey. Meanwhile, as Western opinions dominate the media, how do countries in the Global South view the ongoing crisis? What will be the consequences of the war and the crushing sanctions? Are their interests being taken care of as the West pressures the rest of the world to line up with them?
Subscribe to us on UA-cam: goo.gl/lP12gA
Download our APP on Apple Store (iOS): itunes.apple.com/us/app/cctvn...
Download our APP on Google Play (Android): play.google.com/store/apps/de...
my hats off and high respect for the Indian professor's articulation and courage in exposing the western elites ruler's visceral hatred and racist proclivity towards Russia .........excellent interview !!!
BRAVO TO THE PROFESSOR FROM INDIA. I did not catch his name. HE IS SO SO RIGHT.
Admire the Indian professor's insightful wisdoms and fairness of this excellent discussions !!!❤ Glad to see and is about time the Three Amigos of the East can be join forces !!!❤
I admire him for his stance to help Russia against the US's sanction, but what about the US's sanctions against Venezuela, Afghanistan, Libya, Cuba, Yemen, Sudan, Nicaragua, North Korea, Syria, Iraq, Haiti, the Congo, etc? These are all countries that the US illegally invaded and sanctioned illegally for no reason whatsoever simply because of the fact that the US wants their country to be destroyed because they refused to take orders from the US or their leaders refused to step down from office and allow the US to take over their government. Why hasn't India stand up for those countries as well like it has been doing for Russia?
@@grandwonder5858 India DID have a voice on all that, it just never got reported by MSM.
Nah!
@@grandwonder5858 india stood up for syria yemen afghanistan north korea and iran you can check we always supported them
Does that short sighted professor realize that he is contributing to the genesis of an enmity that Ukrainian will now justly have toward India and Indians for a long time to come? He's concerned about Russians, whom India is anyway saving with its increased trade during the war and increased purchases of Russian oil, but hardly a tear for the death, suffering and destruction Ukrainians are enduring from Russian hands. Half of Ukraine has been destroyed through merciless and indiscriminate Russian bombing, the Ukrainian economy has sustained an extremely serious blow yet the fascist professor waves it off as not Russia's doing but entirely Ukraine's fault. And the moderator even smiles when he repeats the professor's snide remark "such a tragedy." Americans and the West gave enormous help for decades when India was facing famine even though India kept being pro-Soviet, but he only sees Russia's side and the need to be forever loyal to Russia, no matter what. What an inhumane, ugly stance to take. Maybe all the contracts of US and international with Indian IT workers need to be broken off and replaced entirely by even more talented young Ukrainians for Indians to become more appreciative of what the west has been trying to do for them. That would spell the decimation of the Indian middle class, dear shortsighted "professor."
Tanzanian students who were stuck in Ukraine were also helped by Russians troops to return home. Long live Russia, Long Live Putin 🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺
@North Korea Is Best Korea The west are overrated. Start learning Chinese
US, NATO and Biden is certainly unfair not to help much on some "NATO" nations in need, but the worst part is...
HELPING A "NON-NATO NATION" UKRAINE!!! And helping by the billions of dollars!!!
Helping Ukraine with Weapons is like Helping a swimmer to drown. 😄😄😄
Glad to see someone is addressing the concerns of tricontinental nations. The west should understand that, World is not just Anglophone nations (US, UK, Canada, Australia & New Zealand) and Western Europe..!
Has anyone asked Eastern Europeans? This all happens in Eastern Europe, and you lot seem to talk a lot of smack while not asking any of us. I'll let you know the vast majority of East Europeans fears and hates Russia, because they've invaded and tried to genocide us for hundreds of years. We explicitly asked US military to be present in our countries, not because we like America, but because we fear Russia. We don't care about your political games between America and China and the like, for us, it's about survival. Whether our country will continue to exist, or whether it will be annexed by Russia. So understand that we enter Nato to protect ourselves. We're all small countries, threatened by the biggest country in the world. Stop listening to all these people, and listen to us for a change, we have our reasons for being against Russia. How would Indians feel about the UK taking over Gujarat? Or Chinese about the UK taking back their colonial cities in China? Not good? Well we feel the same about Russia.
Slave Masters looking for servants to hear them! I am listening, we are listening……..nit to their noise but to the sweet sound of freedom…..it’s coming…..soon no ONE will care what the bully does n soon the bully won’t be able to buy or bribe any ONE……the day the dollar died by Peter Tosh! Dollar is dead……..along with all the lies it embraces……yes we will suffer , but soon the world is a better place with smaller doorways for regular folks to fit through with less egotistical heads🥲😎🙏🏽😇
They won't know it, until someone like Russia reminded them....Russia has taken the first step, and now the whole world must come together to contain US, once US is destroyed, the other allies will go back under the rock.
The world must destroy USD hegemony creatively, bypass any and all sanctions which is working already.
@North Korea Is Best Korea keep on smoking.
15 Dec 2021 Ukrainian Parliament approved 10 NATO military exercises on the territory of Ukraine at the Russian border !! can you imagine Russian, Iranian, N Korea military exercises in Mexico at texas bordrer ????
Please, Australia and America is 💩 their 🩲 because the Solomon Island signed a security agreement with China.
The Cuban missales crisis in 1962. Again
There were US UK excercises summer 21 in Ukraine and at sea off Crimea.
You forget about China. I think they quickly join Russia, because USA diplomats are attacking China now on the matter of Taiwan and the oeigoers. Together they are stronger. Look at Shanghai eye on UA-cam. The Chinese are not happy how the US behave.
@@449Raphael you are corekt that is the plan Russia and China together.
True, it is so funny that US and NATO make a sweeping statement, as "rest of the world, international community" is with us and is against Russia. But the community consists of US, 27 EU/NATO, Australia and Japan, a total of 33 countries, out of 193 countries in the world. Again some of the EU countries are not together eg, Hungary, Croatia, etc
That is the beauty of US propaganda, you see most americans can't count beyond their fingers and toes.
Finally hearing frank discussion and people talking about reality and speaking truth! Truth is illegal in Canada and the USA now. At least for a short time still, we still have access to rational balanced information such as this.
Channels like CGTN (and RT) are very informative. Thank you.
Giv me more of dat kool-aid, masta!
It's only a matter of time before US orders CGTN's removal.
If China and India could form an alliance the world could be transformed in a positive way.
You forget, India has a right wing govt, they will NEVER work with communism, they are polar opposite, that is why no matter how India upsets US, US will let it be, because India is US's cannon fodder in the event of a war with China.
That Indian Gentleman is fantastic!
I think leaders of nations outside the West who joined the US sanctions against Russia should listen to this group discussion ! Well done !
Thankyou for the diverse discussion
The Interviewer asks a question and lets the interviewee answer fully. In the West, be it Sky News, CNN, ABC, BBC, DW, France 24, etc. it doesn't matter, so many platforms, the people are talking over one another, including the interviewer! I just watched a 30-minuet video Sky News had with Putin's press official; I was watching a Sky News journalist tell a Russian official what's 'actually' happening rather than them asking a question and receiving an answer in return! We've completely cut off Russian media! Shouldn't we be using that rare interview as an opportunity to understand what's happening!? Not support it, but try to understand? Ask a question and then remain silent! Thank you CGTN for behaving with decorum, I wish we still had that in the West!
Peter Lavelle Crosstalk-iEarlgrey-George Galloway MOATS Scott Ritter-Richard Medhurst
@@carmenlajoie2719 I watch all of those programs now, thank God they exist. But I was lamenting the fact that the mainstream media doesn't do the same.
This is the best commentary I have seen on CGTN since the crisis in Ukraine began. Stay strong Russia! I believe in you....I believe in China....and now, I believe in India! You are the future!!!
Have any NATO Members got Sanction in all these 20+ years of illigal wars??? Please enlighten me if any.
Why an invader want to sanction themselves 😅
Unblock you internet and your mind, Germany and Japan are 2 of the most sanctioned countries in history by the USA after WW2 when they saved China from Japan.
Both were made to sign treaties restricting them from arms till today. The same way they are trying to save Ukrainian women and children from the animals infected by the disease of greed and corruption today.
@@timmckillop944 lol... Foolish European nations. Still haven't realised the west intention to destroy Europe. I may not be an expert, but still I can forse the possible out come of Nuclear war if incase it happens. Whole of European nations will annihilate eachother, there won't be Europe anymore. ur Master US will prevail and flourish even better, fancing around China.....😆✌️🎀
Nope, they also don't inform about it, instead they will present the victims as uncivilised, thus deserving.
AMEN to the Indian speaker I CONCUR !!
When you have a corrupt regime that takes money and listens to outside forces, you can't make a sane decision for the best interest of your own people. This is why Ukraine has come to this.
So true
Basically here corrupt are supporting other corrupt. All dictator are supporting Russia for reason. And they are more worried about sanctions and Russia economy then innocent people killing by Putin war.
America is also controlled by israeli lobby groups
China and India need to watch out the Malacca straits and Chagos archipelago (Diego Garcia) where the UK have nukes aimed at India. The huge American millitary present in the gulf and south China sea is also appalling! This discussion comes to the crux of the issue: blatant racism and imperialist Ideologies of the white world.
У Индии все хорошо с береговой обороной. Россия ей передала технологии нашей береговой защиты " бастион " гиперзвук и у Китая есть такое же орудие. Своих союзников мы обезопасили
ok, we need to be together to against west. from China
@شيماء الخزاعي no. he says Strait of Malacca.
@@user-si7if2ej1u thankx good friend.❤
@@oooo-fw2gf the guest speaker from india said, let us lecture and enlighten the west world...
Russia with the support of friendly nations will overcome all hostilities and adversities imposed on them 🇵🇰❤️🇷🇺
all sensible countries support russia...
@@wynn3077 They are nicer, compared the "civilized" world. They have not invaded other countries like the uncivilized world, raining deaths and destructions.
Putin is an aggressor and he doesn’t care about Russian people.
@@wynn3077 yes, they are victims of theft and imperialism of the anglo Saxons
@@wynn3077 at least China is better than all european countries together.
Hope to see more content featuring the global south's perspective. Thank you.
Fine discussion with a diverse panel of guests! When this 'transition' to a world that is not dominated by a Global Hegemon is finished, the U.S./West will have to ask permission to re-join the Global Community of Nations committed to constructive relationships built on common development and prosperity instead of Neo-Colonialism and War profiteering.
@North Korea Is Best Korea Keep watching, you will see his 'potency' in the Donbass Region very soon. The Special Military Operation will only end when Russia has completed its objectives. The West/U.S. must watch and wait.
Most Latin America supports Russia, it's a handful of countries that follow United States orders
Maduro has suddenly become a good guy! Russia's spanking of Ukraine is having magical effect on USA/UK/EU. They now think Maduro is great... and they hope Maduro will give them a bit of oil :)
We should be All in non-alignment country. Actually I can't see a any reason for NATO to exist for last 30 years. UN should be reorganize and take care of global peace keeping and Americans should start loving idea of peace and prosperity of others. World can't take American aggressions any more.
I don't think UN can help for world peace at all. It has allowed US to invade, bomb and kill for the last 50 years.
Um wow ok, as an American I actually learned something from CGTN today. John Foster Dulles just got put on my radar screen.
Lots of other videos on previous issues before the Ukraine crisis happened.
We American can only learn about the truth of the rest of the world from foreign news channels.
Insanity. This is what war is.
Great Discussion.
Great discussion from another viewpoint. Hope UA-cam or EU won’t ban the channel.
I am watching from the Philippines, a professor of law and as evangelist, there is truth for the contention of Vice Chairman of the Global South
Great conversation.
Wonderful discussion
We all breath the same air and we all feel the same sun and see the same clouds, stop and think.
Proffessor is not happy, not happy at all. 😂😂😂😂 I admire his patriotism.
great broadcast!
A very interesting discussion. Could you please invite again the three guests, especially Hannah from Africa Reimagined and the Indian professor more often?
There is a fact that should make us happy and is how the sanciones turn to hurt the perpetrators. Rusia rublo is back to its normal valiu
Thank you for this essential perspective.
Good, balanced, informative reporting...
The bonus in creating tons of refugees: Creating tons of mercenaries.
just a suggestion -- video info section should include at least name and positions of the interviewees.
great discourse... honesty as policy is best and amusing...
The Indian professor was great. The person from Brazil was good also. Hanna talked about a whole bunch of nothing.
I’m loving this Indian guy🌈🙏🏽……live brethren……he nails it with a calm upset-ness😅……waiting to erupt with truth…..bubbling with indignant vexation for the hypocrisy of western media n westerners……it seems we like being lied to! I’m American but I always feel like this guy……so alone out here I am….need to travel …..get around decent people that can cook……I would enjoy eating food with your panelists……..I really would….a peaceful meal without pretense ……I can taste it already….Amen🙏🏽😎
Great presentation
Based Indian professor 🔥
The host should have not interrupted the Indian professor talking about the West critiquing India’s purchase of Russian oil.
They are on a time limit. If the guest goes over his allowed time or off topic, he'll interrupt.
Great panel which presents the view of the rest of the world. Western nations see their interests as the interests of the whole of the world.
Spain biggest export is saffron it doesn't grow it they get it from Iran, so were do sanctions make sense
Neo colonists continue their rules.
Spain biggest export is not saffron, Spain supplies all of Europe's groceries like tomatoes, also tourism. Saffron is definitely not Spain's biggest export.
Hello oo 😊
INTRIGUING!!!
Apparently there're other countries in the world with different views of the Russia/Ukraine War.
9s1
It's difficult to interpret how the international community intentionary abuse the currency rates including printing of money. It's hard to evaluate the benefits of foreign investment Foreign investors go outside with unfairly sourced funds which are produced in opaque stock exchange values while 3rd world nations loose their resources with resultant impact is ensuring poverty.
Yes the resources of the global south have been appropriated for too long without caring for their development. Hence the GDP disparity.
Ukraine will join B&RI afterwards!!
Ukraine is already part of BRI
Russia and Ukrain both are China's friends. May they always are peaceful to each other. ❤❤ from China
Living in NATO Canada Supporting Russia. Looks like the Ukrainian Azov Waffle SS Battalion will soon be eliminated. Respect to Russia for doing the best job of Keeping Ukraine N*zi Free since 43
US/NATO have poked the bear --- watch out for the panda bear
💯
How is a Chinese person representing Brazil? Kenya, the Kenyan perspective speaks and represents ALL of Africa? There are definitely different views and perspectives from the global south, I'm not sure these guests speak to them. Appreciate raising the questions.
Most radio stations in my country here in Africa are seriously pointing out the hypocrisy of the west
@@francismusali676 same here in India
What Russia has done for the Ukrainian citizens in the Donbass who are mainly Russian; is no different than Africans sailing across the Atlantic to what is now the Americas. Once reaching the Americans, Africans would have fought their way to the plantations and rescued enslaved Africans.
Hold on a second. What Russia has done by invading Ukraine is exactly what the USA did when it joined WWII to stop Nazis. So it was good to stop Nazis in the 1940's but it's somehow evil now?
How many times have you heard people criticize Allied leaders for not stopping Hitler sooner as a way to avoid WWII?
I am sure that almost 3 milion people that pour to my country escaping those butchers really see that way.
I respect China stance on the matter, but most of you commenting people are scum of the earth. Enjoy yourself i guess
It's much more complicated than that.
@@anaibarangan4908 How? Awful simple claim to something supposedly more complicated. Nothing said about a competition of complexity.
@@ewalker1057 Sometimes replies are based on as if know everything about who comments. I'm kind of tired of that kind of people in the US. Everyone else is based exclusively on how think as individuals, no matter if have barely moved from wherever live in the world.
The Rand project - to topple Russia 🇷🇺
The same people who ran the Vietnam war. It will be another fiasco.
American mirrors can talk, and they say "You are the Fairest of them All".
Business woman from Kenya, "I'm part of the non-alignment movement, but what Russia did is bad."
What a crock.
If she truly were non-aligned, she's would not have left the US out of her reckoning . . . She clearly know who's buttering her toast.
What means the global south? Which countries are involved?
Thx to China and all their real friends
Barzil has the biggest forest. The lungs of the earth. Its weird how they throw around dependencies.
Brazil?
The Indian Professor says it as it is.
I love the Chinese guys provocative questions.
Ha3…! Buffalo’s bones.
how do you negotiate with a puppet from the empire of lies?
Yea same energy given thats given to Russia and Ukraine should be given to other civil wars. Don’t hear anything from West except blurbs.
You should have the woman on again! That was rude to give her only a minute!
Justice is justice, and injustice is injustice; thus one can not confuse one with the other, though one may take a pragmatic and advisory way in dealing with the unjust side.
this is correct and even diplomatic
too bad Xi decided to be putins little bitch :/
someone should tell them that the peoples of Europe are of a diverse genetic history hear in Scotland my Wife has blood group that it only found in China She is of Scots /Irish decent for countless generations and has very Asian appearance and I have Sami People Hplo! Gene So we are all the same but different and we must learn to respect that .
Everybody respect people from the west , the problem is the west mostly don't respect other people!
Your wife must be pretty to have asian features
@@kuga7423 my wife is the most beautiful woman i have ever seen ,but i must say she also has a European aspect to her appearance ,there is a blend in her and in me and in most Europeans this is a fact of genetic science.that can be observed ,if we chose! to see
@@fannybirot2362 who is the WEST!?,the west as i see it ,are a bunch of psychotic thugs trying to rule the would ,because after subjugating and enslaving their own population is not enough for them! their psychopathy drives them! to want more power and more control.the west is a small group of individuals ,crating havoc for the world
Blood groups have little relationship with race or ethnicity, because they are much older than "races".
BBQ
At 22:25 the moderator compares how the west views conflict in the west as racism and double standard, then Hannah completely ignores this fact and downplays the comparison as “inconsistency”. She identifies her Kenyan heritage but exposes herself as an apologist for the business class. It’s racism, Hannah. Although you identify as Kenyan, you have a western name, light skin, well groomed, and looks like you are safe for the business interests, while enjoying your status.
I believe she was actually agreeing with the moderator, but using a more diplomatic word ‘inconsistent’ rather than the more blunt ‘double standard’.
Why have so many former Soviet countries joined NATO I just don't understand that
Leaders of smaller nations join global powers due to insecurities they have of neighboring big power.
Another spectacle I forced myself to finish, all 29 and a halff minutes. It is important to understand how some persons' minds operate. It would be a worthless effort to refute anything. I marvel at the mentality of the commentators below.
Keep marvelling and maybe eventually it'll click and your ingrained West-centric worldview will break, and reveal a broader reality.
World Politics= a game of Poker, the chip leader wants to maintain its lead n will do anything to maintain it's position, But in politics is far far worse cause it's not a game for money But a game of people's lives
Western opinions are visibly very varied. To suggest that there is a one size fits all position on the war in Ukraine is disingenuous. Neither are Western journalists racist. It is irresponsible to keep fomenting this racist agenda against " the West". The West is a diverse mix of political cultural and social groups like any other region. The war in Ukraine,as it is described in this piece- but denied by Putins foreign policy,military etc ( you are prohibited from using the word 'war') has global repercussions not local. I commend the South's decision to stay neutral - wise view. India should not punish their citizens by paying more than they can afford for oil and gas- USA will survive - they were not supplying India's needs anyway. But please don't denigrate every "white" western citizen as " privileged, racist and war mongoring.
Afghanistan, Latin America, Vietnam, Libya, Siria, Iraq. Where is the western media where are the sanction against the aggressors. Case closed "the west" is the enemy of the rest of the world.
From a Latin America. Long live BRI and global south alliance against NATO and the dangerous West
Perhaps you and your country should make it clear you are not part of those bad "west", and openly denounce the US actions around the world. May I ask which country are you from? I am US citizen but I never agreed to my gov't's sanctions and military bully in the world.
@@hyc1266 are you saying this to me? You better not be a us citizen telling a Latinoamérican to declare we are not part of West. We are not! We are USA backyard....for now can't wait for this to end. Welcome Mr Xi to Latin America, you people can start packing your bags.
@@hyc1266 It is never so simple,is it-? The region I live in has denounced the military operation in Ukraine and taken in 1000's of refugees. It has also delivered aid overland - humanitarian aid . It is a neutral country.
The commentator is boring, a bit more "pep".
See global citizens post of Boris Johnson and one of his peers-“right people” not “people in rubber boats”. Smdh.
Дякую Господу Богу і людям які захищають права та свободу і незалежність України дякую Вам Дай Боже Україні та в усьому світі миру здоров'я щастя та благополуччя всім дякую Вам
I appreciate the criticism of the West, but the attitude towards Russia seems bizarre. Several outbursts were made at the US for illegaly invading Iraq, but Russia is doing the exact same thing to Ukraine and the response is a timid "Let´s make peace". Where are the outbursts on Russia? I agree that peace is the answer but it all seems very biased
Whichever part of the world you come from. Whichever national interests you want to protect it is not difficult to call evil for what it is; evil. Pls condemn Russia and stop this barbaric war of aggression
Sanction USA and UK first, liberate puerto rico, Diego García. Apologize to the invaded countries the past 20 years.
✔
This Charles guy only see one side.
The Indian professor is too emotional in his sayings!
He's still 100% right, though.
Yes, he is 100% right and too emotional.
India is obviously not on the side of justice. Putin's invasion should be condemned , though other countries may take a pragmatic approach to Russia. However, if Russia is going on the direction of creating more and more disasters, then the world have to be united in stopping Russia, even by force if all diplomatic means have failed. Otherwise, the world situation will be worsening till everyone will suffer. Sanction can be used if it is not affecting others and creating more problems.
No, the US started this war and is paying all the bills to continue it. Tell me uoyre comfortable with Russia and China putting military bases in Mexico and Canada and I'll believe you actually thought about it
Russia is no more on the side of justice than the US is.
Get off your high horse cowboy!
First thing that needs to stopped is NATO.
@@vchowdhrie yes. But invasion is evil . Moreover, Russia has done too much, having killed too many people and destroyed too much and made tens of millions of people refugees, while Ukraine hasn't done anything harming it.
@@leebarry5686 What about civilians killed by USA in Iraq, Afghanistan, Libya etc. and their refugees. Just because this war is in Europe and victims are white blondes, so their lives matter more?
What an awful chinese propaganda to curry favour with Russia.
White people are minorities, the other countries of the world don't share the anti-Russian sentiment,sorry.
@@alphabogeyman7462 yes, a totalitarian regime that uses propaganda to spread lies , limits the access to the Internet for it people, put its own people in concentration camps to "re-educate"(brainwash) them is where the rest of the world wants to be, for sure. I also don´t see the point with "white people" . Russian and Ukraine share the same ethnicity. But maybe that was the beast you got for a cheap shot.
@@Empusas1 Yes,totalitarian regimes are regimes that ban media outlets that don't follow the narratives dictated by the state department. Lets wait an see if the USxwill ne sanctioned for occupying part of Syria despite the objections from the Government of the country.
@@alphabogeyman7462 So comparing a wrong with another wrong makes it right? Is that your view of the world? But I think there is a big difference to fight a regime that subdues its citizens, ignores Human rights, uses torture and murder and bans all opposition and free speech, or helping a country to fight such a regime that raid its neighbors based on lies, kills civilians and commits unbelievable war crimes. If you want to compare then Afghanistan or Irak would have been the better example. But again, all wrongdoings by the US does not undo the wrong doing of the russians.