Read about it in a very good book. Stalinists hated Trotskists, both disliked anarchists, non Moscow communists wanted true independence while Moscow wanted the Trostskists dead or disempowered and as a whole to create some tributary state.
@@destroyerinazuma96 The Trotskyist POUM were allied with the CNT for a time when the "May Day's" happened and fighting against the Stalinists occurred.
Vaughan Bussard thank you for providing this, whenever I watch a war movie, I walkways want to know what guns they have. Usually if it’s a historical war film. (With guns, not swords or bows and arrows)
Not at all. The POUM and the IBs where completely different! I mean, how can you possibly toss in an egalitarian and nationally integrated organization that rejected both the reformism of the Second International and the pro-Moscow orientation of the Third International and tied to the "London Bureau" with units made mostly of French, Italian and German Communists in their own seperate units. Sheesh! why not just throw the CNT and the IWA together!
@@MichaelCorryFilms The Carlists and the Requetes are the best no one can reject this idea. Franco is fake traditionalist only the king of the Carlist line should rule.
In the Spanish Civil War, Mexico was the only reliable supplier of armaments for the Spanish Republic, in addition to the Soviet Union, in the Republican Spanish army there was Mexican weaponry. By the way, Manuel Azaña, the president of the Spanish Republic, died in the Hotel du Midi in Mountaban, France, which, having been rented by the Mexican embassy, was considered Mexican territory. When Marshal Petain denied him at the funeral to be buried with the republican Spanish flag, he was buried with the flag of Mexico.
Cardenas demostró tener mas valentía que varias potencias europeas cuando se trataba de denunciar a los fascistas antes de la guerra, en dicha embajada también se salvaron miles de vidas de judíos, republicanos y disidentes en desafío a los opresores de Pétain y Hitler, aun cuando al consul le costó ser apresado en Alemania por ello
@Fascista Mexikaner Que idiota eres, no sabes lo que dices! Los bolcheviques fueron ayudados por la familia Rothschild, quienes so los mas influyentes masones del mundo! Los Rothschild ayudararon a Rockefeller a convertirse en el gigante que es hoy dia. Los Rothschild son el brazo derecho del Vaticano
Yes, but there were some in the 30s and of course there's For Whom the Bell Tolls. Also there's a post Civil War French movie from the 60s with Yves Montand and Ingrid Thulin La Guerre est Finie directed by Alain Resnais.
This is from the Ken Loach movie 'Land and Freedom' and they are POUM militia NOT International Brigade even though many of the fighters portrayed are international volunteers (author George Orwell fought with the POUM).
Not gonna lie even tho this video is a bit old I do wish that movies would start portraying both sides competently instead of one side being absolutely incompetent while the other kicks it's ass with ease
Absolutely agreed… we Italians are always (just for example) portrayed as shitty cowards while in reality Italian soldiers fought pretty well even during ww2, and no I don’t mean the ones that fought alongside the Allies.
@@italianduded1161 I am not greek, and even if I like Italy, The Italians show Extreme weakness against Greece 🤣😂 and that day is even a national holiday in Greece, the Oxi day 😅 If it was not Brasil, Italy would be German today mate, think
@@italianduded1161 Too true! WWII Allied propaganda lives on...130,000 Brits surrender to inferior Japanese forces = bloody good show. 133,000 Italians surrender in the Western Desert = Italians are incompetent cowards. Altho they had some setbacks early on, the Italian forces in Spain were doing very well after they had some experience and some shaking out of the leadership.
when trying to sneak up on a target- wearing red scarves and waving a red flag always helps- as does positioning your machine gun directly on top of a ridge
@Irvin O -Well, as a way of “unifying” their forces the communists in the Republican command eradicated the “chaotic” Anarchists and Syndicalists, but in the process lost much of their support among the people.
As for the red scarves and flags: it was meant to be a pre-dawn attack so things can get chaotic in half-light, and you don’t want friendly fire. As for the MG, well those things have such a huge range that they were almost immune to the paltry rifle fire the Nationalists could throw back.
@@Amoore-vv9wx - I’m no expert on the MG08, but the MG34 when tripod mounted was certainly able to put out fire to well over a kilometre, if not to 2km. I got the impression that most rifles used in the SCW were poorly maintained and so inaccurate beyond a few hundred metres, especially when used by part-time milicianos. Always happy to learn and be corrected.🤓
I just finished reading "Renegades" it's about Canadians who faught in the international brigade. It did a great job on showing how divided the republican forces were compared to the fascists. The republicans didn't lose because of lack of bravery, but a combination of paranoia, in fighting, and terrible generalship.
I'm not sure about the "terrible generalship", the Republicans had fine generals like Generals Miaja and Rojo too, but the political divisions were damaging. The massive support Hitler and Mussolini gave Franco was also vital of course.
@@zavi13 the Republican forces seemed to suffer from the same human wave statics that the Russians would use against the Germans. Which worked for Russia for many reasons, but would not work in Spain. The best quote that describes the Republican forces is "bravery is never lacking, but when it comes to tactics. We are surely lacking." Plus, Franco's forces were way more experienced and were use to working with each other.
@@TheChuckfuc The Russians really didn’t use human wave tactics nearly to the extent that is portrayed in popular media. For the Republicans they were at a pretty substantial disadvantage in equipment and political unity.
@@dantecaputo2629 I'm know that the media has overblown the human wave tactics, but they did happen. Mostly due to bad generalship and bad coordination. The saying that keeps popping up in the Spanish civil war. That sums it up nicely is "There's no lacking when it comes to bravery. What we need is tactics."
"Sonaba la sirena. Corríamos hacia el búnker con miedo y a prisa. En esa ocasión no nos dió tiempo, mi padre, que es tu bisabuelo se tiró encima mía cuando empezaron los aviones a tirar bombas. Qué hambre pasábamos, yo sólo era una niña que no entendía nada, no teníamos apenas pan." Part of a conversation I had with my grandmother a few weeks ago. This war was the sadest thing ever. Brothers killed each other.
I know about people who killed their sons without knowing it. The father was a soldier from the military and the son was caught by Republicans who convinced him to join them, in one of the battles near Madrid the father took another republican life, it was a young man, at the end of the battle all of his partners screamed and celebrated their victory, curious, the father went to see the corpse of the young man, there was something familiar, his face was covered with a scarf, it was very similar to the one he gave his son 3 years ago for Christmas, then suddenly he realised and covered in tears started to uncover the part of the head which was still intact (the bullet perforated his skull and that's why the soldier didn't recognise him at first) there he was, with half of his skull blown up, his son. He fell on his knees and painfully screamed onto the air, he killed the one he was supposed to be protecting, he enlisted in the army to save his poor child and now he was the only responsible for his death. This might sound like a movie or a sci-fi book, but is a true story an old friends of mine told me, it's sad, but even until now he has nightmares seeing his son with half of the skull open... The only thing he wants is not the republicans to die, not to win that war, not to be praised with medals, he wants his child back. That's the saddest part of civil wars, u don't know who is who...
The human shield escape strategy did not work. Shoot through the hostages to stop the ones hiding behind to show them your resolve to win and nothing will save them from your wrath.
@@facuuu2809 what? That has nothing to do with falangists being Nazis. Nazism is unique only to Nazi Germany. Not all fascism. Nazism includes aspects of liberal socialism, which doesn't exist in Falangism or Italian Fascism. You clearly know nothing about ideologies. Ok so FDR and Churchill were allies with the USSR. Does that mean the UK and US are communist? Your logic is messed up.
Si no me equivoco, no són de las brigadas internacionales, en este caso són voluntarios extranjeros que se integrarón en las milicias del POUM y no en las brigadas. Por cierto el video está muy bién, es de alguna peli o es un corto. De ser una peli, cual es el nombre?
My Grandfather 17 and his brother from Nebraska walked into Spain across the Pyrenees and became part of the Abraham Lincoln brigade. Grandpa made it home his brother Albert was KIA at the Ebro during the retreats with Mackenzie’.s.
@@superiorshotgun4348They fought for democracy and against fascism. If anyone’s in hell, it’s Franco. Franco’s forces and later regime murdered up to 200,000 civilians, many of which were catholics, and included Protestant priests and clergy, political opponents and Jews.
In George Orwell’s homage to Catalonia, he talks about his time fighting for the Republicans. He spoke about the rusty 19th century weaponry which often had to be shared amongst the troops, an interesting read
Actually the Republican talks a lot of Orwell's, and they hate him so much. This is because 1# He hate working people. 2# He doesn't actually fight with them. 3# he was making list of Irish Republican for arrest and assassination and submit them to the British monarchy under the title of "Enemy of the British Empire". Not to mentions just how absurdly Racist he is. Like HP Lovecraft have mental problems, but Orwell's doesn't, and he is even more Racist than Lovecraft.
You have no idea what you are talking about, Orwell had a great disdain for what is known as the British Empire, for the time spent as a torturer in Burma in his military days, he loved the working people, he wrote books out of their voices.@@Huy-G-Le
@@fintanmccann1128 I do know what I'm talking about. He hate his job doesn't mean he have great disdain for his empire nor his empire crime of colonialism. You want proof?
@@Huy-G-Le Most Republicans hate people like Orwell because journalists and writers supportive of them saw their war as a spectator sport and never helped them versus the Nationalist journalists actually seeing combat with the units they attached to.
@@frankverdino477 Twas a joke really, kinda like the Negrin government. :) You do have to admit that the Germans and the Italians where more tickling than punching. Plus the geography of Spain itself is as formidable an opponent as the disunited Republic.
Loaded headline. It is more accurate to call the village Nationalist held. One could call the International Brigade Communist or even Stalinist, maybe add the word controlled.
@@chestermosburger3113 that film is historically inaccurate, still is a good movie to watch, but there are many things that are modified in order to appeal to certain public... Even if the war was a tragic event that ended long ago there is people who still want to continue (I've talked to people who literally said "war is not over and you all going to die for being traitors") More than 80 had passed and there are ignorants who "want to win this war" without knowing that both sides ended up devastated and rose a monument called "valley of the fallen" where republicans and nacionalists where buried in the same place as a reconciliation and a way to say "no matter what is your ideology, death will be the same for everyone, never do this again". Cruelty was common for both sides, but military never used civilians not implicated in war for their purposes, in the movie they use two women, something that the military have strictly prohibited, they used Republican hostages and tortured them (which I personally disagree, but is war and your life depends on it, same as the Republicans who used nuns as hostages or to... Ya know, there are some nasty people on both sides).
They most certainly were not Stalinists or Soviet controlled, especially seeing as how many of the fighters were Anarchists and had a shit ton of infighting between them and the communist forces, which was one of the major factors for why they lost. The nationalists were equally if not more back/controlled by Nazi Germany than the Republicans were backed by the Soviet Union, i mean there literally were German plains that bombed Republican controlled cities while the Russians didn't come close to doing something on par with that in it's aid of the Republicans. Certainly they received support/aid from the Russians, but it's complete historical revisionism to assert that they were "controlled" by the USSR.
@@dipendrashah4314 Actually no.POUM which are shown here as the "good" republicans were mostly communists from around the world."Fascists" shown in the movie were Nationalists based from their equipment.
@@namelessidiot667 The nationalists did not have much support from foreign nations, the nationalists won because they were more organized, all had the same leader and the same ideas for what Spain should become. The republican army was very disorganized and beliefs varied widely.
![Land and Freedom (1995 Ken Loach) [ENG Sub]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/HKfvFgj69-s/mqdefault.jpg)
Is this land and freedom?
Yes
¡Ya hemos pasado! :p
@@tp_petain6836 Si hubiera sido por vuestros medios, nunca.
¿QUIÉN PA' CULIAR?
@@victorv3814 Josef Stalin y sus T-26 discrepan.
0:33 The guy with bad internet in a multiplayer lobby
Lmao
4:27, Harry potter and the Spanish civil war
Lol
nice shoot
Harry Potter and The Order of Comrade Stalin
You're a communist Harry
2:09 Con la ayuda del profesor Quirrell y Ron Weasley echándole un par de cojones.
The Republican faction was quite disorganised and they were always infighting. The anarchists and communists were always at each other's throats
Read about it in a very good book. Stalinists hated Trotskists, both disliked anarchists, non Moscow communists wanted true independence while Moscow wanted the Trostskists dead or disempowered and as a whole to create some tributary state.
It’s almost like they were going to lose from the start. Good riddance tbh.
@@destroyerinazuma96 The Trotskyist POUM were allied with the CNT for a time when the "May Day's" happened and fighting against the Stalinists occurred.
@@davidmartinez688 thanks, I didn't know there was was such a time
Well yeah they didn’t want to be a puppet state of the ussr
Spanish weapons of the Spanish civil war:
Rifles:
M1893 Mauser
M1916 Mauser
M1905 “true” carbine
Machine guns:
Labora LMG
M1914 Hotchkiss
Star Si-35
Pistols:
Astra 900
Campo-giro
Astra Model 1921
Also the "mexicanski's " a Mexican made copy of the moisin nagant
Vaughan Bussard thank you for providing this, whenever I watch a war movie, I walkways want to know what guns they have. Usually if it’s a historical war film. (With guns, not swords or bows and arrows)
@@davidparsons452 also the TRUE Moisin Nagant or Degtyarov light machine gun come directly from Moscow, like the best soviet planes
@@davidparsons452 No such thing as a Mexican made Mosin.
Totaly Outdated
They're POUM, not international brigade. Do I win the pedant award?
Not at all. The POUM and the IBs where completely different! I mean, how can you possibly toss in an egalitarian and nationally integrated organization that rejected both the reformism of the Second International and the pro-Moscow orientation of the Third International and tied to the "London Bureau" with units made mostly of French, Italian and German Communists in their own seperate units. Sheesh! why not just throw the CNT and the IWA together!
@@MichaelCorryFilms The Carlists and the Requetes are the best no one can reject this idea. Franco is fake traditionalist only the king of the Carlist line should rule.
@@protonmaximum6193 All monarchies beling in the dustbin of history, Viva la Republica!
zavi13 Republic is corrupt and weak
Yes specialist
This war had the super powers involved. I call it the ''Now a word from our sponsors'' war/
This war is sponsored by War Thunder.
That's typically how civil wars are
This war is sponsored by The Soviet Union and Nazi Germany
war/
😂😂
In the Spanish Civil War, Mexico was the only reliable supplier of armaments for the Spanish Republic, in addition to the Soviet Union, in the Republican Spanish army there was Mexican weaponry.
By the way, Manuel Azaña, the president of the Spanish Republic, died in the Hotel du Midi in Mountaban, France, which, having been rented by the Mexican embassy, was considered Mexican territory.
When Marshal Petain denied him at the funeral to be buried with the republican Spanish flag, he was buried with the flag of Mexico.
Cardenas demostró tener mas valentía que varias potencias europeas cuando se trataba de denunciar a los fascistas antes de la guerra, en dicha embajada también se salvaron miles de vidas de judíos, republicanos y disidentes en desafío a los opresores de Pétain y Hitler, aun cuando al consul le costó ser apresado en Alemania por ello
@Fascista Mexikaner xd
Yes. Cardenas was the only democratic leader to get behind the republic.
@Fascista Mexikaner Que idiota eres, no sabes lo que dices! Los bolcheviques fueron ayudados por la familia Rothschild, quienes so los mas influyentes masones del mundo! Los Rothschild ayudararon a Rockefeller a convertirse en el gigante que es hoy dia. Los Rothschild son el brazo derecho del Vaticano
God bless him.
4:27 Harry Potter used a time turner to change the course of the Spanish Civil War, but his efforts were in vain.
Lol
Lol man good one
lol
Harry Potter and the Second Spanish Republic.
Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Barcelona
No son brigadas Internacionales,son del poum
PUT THE MOVIE NAME IN THE DESCRIPTION DAMMIT
Land and Freedom by Ken Loach
While at war
@@ydr445 not that one but its a good one too
An excellent film! Thank you for posting that. The Spanish Civil War is a rare topic for war movies.
Yes, but there were some in the 30s and of course there's For Whom the Bell Tolls. Also there's a post Civil War French movie from the 60s with Yves Montand and Ingrid Thulin La Guerre est Finie directed by Alain Resnais.
This is from the Ken Loach movie 'Land and Freedom' and they are POUM militia NOT International Brigade even though many of the fighters portrayed are international volunteers (author George Orwell fought with the POUM).
This is the most important comment. International Brigades were Marxist-Leninists aka pro-Stalin.
@@marko1263 actually the POUM were anti-stalinists, the actually followed Trotsky.
@@shannonsteam8744 International Brigades =/= POUM
@@marko1263 Well they are still both Communists
@@marko1263 Not really.
Not gonna lie even tho this video is a bit old I do wish that movies would start portraying both sides competently instead of one side being absolutely incompetent while the other kicks it's ass with ease
Absolutely agreed… we Italians are always (just for example) portrayed as shitty cowards while in reality Italian soldiers fought pretty well even during ww2, and no I don’t mean the ones that fought alongside the Allies.
@@italianduded1161 I am not greek, and even if I like Italy, The Italians show Extreme weakness against Greece 🤣😂 and that day is even a national holiday in Greece, the Oxi day 😅 If it was not Brasil, Italy would be German today mate, think
@@italianduded1161 Too true! WWII Allied propaganda lives on...130,000 Brits surrender to inferior Japanese forces = bloody good show. 133,000 Italians surrender in the Western Desert = Italians are incompetent cowards. Altho they had some setbacks early on, the Italian forces in Spain were doing very well after they had some experience and some shaking out of the leadership.
@@UltraStormGamers Italy conquered whole British Somalia, a country larger than Britain itself.
when trying to sneak up on a target- wearing red scarves and waving a red flag always helps- as does positioning your machine gun directly on top of a ridge
well the lack of organisation was one pillar which caused the republicans to loose the war
@Irvin O -Well, as a way of “unifying” their forces the communists in the Republican command eradicated the “chaotic” Anarchists and Syndicalists, but in the process lost much of their support among the people.
As for the red scarves and flags: it was meant to be a pre-dawn attack so things can get chaotic in half-light, and you don’t want friendly fire. As for the MG, well those things have such a huge range that they were almost immune to the paltry rifle fire the Nationalists could throw back.
@@Amoore-vv9wx - I’m no expert on the MG08, but the MG34 when tripod mounted was certainly able to put out fire to well over a kilometre, if not to 2km. I got the impression that most rifles used in the SCW were poorly maintained and so inaccurate beyond a few hundred metres, especially when used by part-time milicianos. Always happy to learn and be corrected.🤓
@@Amoore-vv9wx No it did not.
The movie name is 'Tierra y libertad'
Quite an interesting find, a movie about the Spanish Civil War
And I want to see this movie.
@@murrayaronson3753 it's called land and freedom
There be dragons is wayyyyy better
@@cj16423 decent movie too.
Surely this is the POUM militia, not the Stalinist International Brigade.
The Spanish Civil War 🇪🇸 (1936--1939)
,à
I just finished reading "Renegades" it's about Canadians who faught in the international brigade. It did a great job on showing how divided the republican forces were compared to the fascists. The republicans didn't lose because of lack of bravery, but a combination of paranoia, in fighting, and terrible generalship.
I'm not sure about the "terrible generalship", the Republicans had fine generals like Generals Miaja and Rojo too, but the political divisions were damaging. The massive support Hitler and Mussolini gave Franco was also vital of course.
@@zavi13 the Republican forces seemed to suffer from the same human wave statics that the Russians would use against the Germans. Which worked for Russia for many reasons, but would not work in Spain. The best quote that describes the Republican forces is "bravery is never lacking, but when it comes to tactics. We are surely lacking."
Plus, Franco's forces were way more experienced and were use to working with each other.
@@TheChuckfuc
The Russians really didn’t use human wave tactics nearly to the extent that is portrayed in popular media. For the Republicans they were at a pretty substantial disadvantage in equipment and political unity.
@@dantecaputo2629 I'm know that the media has overblown the human wave tactics, but they did happen. Mostly due to bad generalship and bad coordination.
The saying that keeps popping up in the Spanish civil war. That sums it up nicely is "There's no lacking when it comes to bravery. What we need is tactics."
They also trusted that Stalin would help them. Never a good idea to trust Stalin.
I like classic fighting with bolt action rifles 💗🔥
Yes
Reminds me of the old school ww2 shooters
@@Paches92- what ?
@@Rm-ss5gv he said it reminds him of the old school ww2 shooters
@@voidwalker9223 Yes but I don’t understand what he means does he mean shooters as in a person or as in a weapon
Wow, what an unbiased film
I'm sure this comment section isn't going to be full of salty Spaniards from each side
"Sonaba la sirena. Corríamos hacia el búnker con miedo y a prisa. En esa ocasión no nos dió tiempo, mi padre, que es tu bisabuelo se tiró encima mía cuando empezaron los aviones a tirar bombas. Qué hambre pasábamos, yo sólo era una niña que no entendía nada, no teníamos apenas pan." Part of a conversation I had with my grandmother a few weeks ago. This war was the sadest thing ever. Brothers killed each other.
I know about people who killed their sons without knowing it. The father was a soldier from the military and the son was caught by Republicans who convinced him to join them, in one of the battles near Madrid the father took another republican life, it was a young man, at the end of the battle all of his partners screamed and celebrated their victory, curious, the father went to see the corpse of the young man, there was something familiar, his face was covered with a scarf, it was very similar to the one he gave his son 3 years ago for Christmas, then suddenly he realised and covered in tears started to uncover the part of the head which was still intact (the bullet perforated his skull and that's why the soldier didn't recognise him at first) there he was, with half of his skull blown up, his son. He fell on his knees and painfully screamed onto the air, he killed the one he was supposed to be protecting, he enlisted in the army to save his poor child and now he was the only responsible for his death.
This might sound like a movie or a sci-fi book, but is a true story an old friends of mine told me, it's sad, but even until now he has nightmares seeing his son with half of the skull open...
The only thing he wants is not the republicans to die, not to win that war, not to be praised with medals, he wants his child back. That's the saddest part of civil wars, u don't know who is who...
You can only be brothers with humans. Communists aren't humans.
Those res Bastards would never care about civilian hostages :-/
CapitanoGUC Read a book
Well, how about win the election, fascists?
the staging of this film is very real.
Pura propaganda esa película
The human shield escape strategy did not work. Shoot through the hostages to stop the ones hiding behind to show them your resolve to win and nothing will save them from your wrath.
all this effort and you still lose the war, viva cristo rey
Don't worry, we lost this one but we won against the nazis later, we humiliated them and sent them to the only place they can be useful: Siberia
@@facuuu2809 that literally has nothing to do with the falangista in the slightest. Falangists aren't Nazis, they're extremely different.
@@za.monolit yeah obviously not, Franco, Hitler and Mussolini weren't allies
(sarcasm btw)
@@facuuu2809 what? That has nothing to do with falangists being Nazis. Nazism is unique only to Nazi Germany. Not all fascism. Nazism includes aspects of liberal socialism, which doesn't exist in Falangism or Italian Fascism. You clearly know nothing about ideologies. Ok so FDR and Churchill were allies with the USSR. Does that mean the UK and US are communist? Your logic is messed up.
Title: International BRIGADE
Movie: Shows 30 to 50 men
Is it just me or the enemy goons can't seem to hit anything vitals.
V.A.T.S.
Fun fact during the civil war the tac tic blitzkrieg saw its first use
Si no me equivoco, no són de las brigadas internacionales, en este caso són voluntarios extranjeros que se integrarón en las milicias del POUM y no en las brigadas.
Por cierto el video está muy bién, es de alguna peli o es un corto.
De ser una peli, cual es el nombre?
Did the human shield thing really happen or was that added for flare?
Republicans used them to deter German air support or Nationalist artillery.
I can't see the other guys comment for some reason. Censorship I guess. As for your question, I doubt it.
Far worse things were done by both sides. Remember, it was a civil war fueled by inflammatory and dehumanizing ideologies.
Totalitarian vs totalitarian
it feels good to be bilingual
0:33 BUG
Ur right
Lag
High ping
1:33 what hat is that guy wearing ?
My Grandfather 17 and his brother from Nebraska walked into Spain across the Pyrenees and became part of the Abraham Lincoln brigade. Grandpa made it home his brother Albert was KIA at the Ebro during the retreats with Mackenzie’.s.
Name movie's please / nombre de la película por favor
Tierra y libertad 1995 Dir. Ken Loach
@@PedroGarcia-od3xc muchas gracias
Just so you know guys, the republicans were no heroes
only the democratic ones, anarchists did some horrible stuff and Stalinists are pure evil
150,000 dead in the white terror
Shut up facha
It’s like ww1 again but the servers are dead
Now the international brigades are in hell
Why?
@@High_rise12 they fought against Catholicism and kill priests.
They are in hell. I’m the fascists won
@@superiorshotgun4348They fought for democracy and against fascism. If anyone’s in hell, it’s Franco.
Franco’s forces and later regime murdered up to 200,000 civilians, many of which were catholics, and included Protestant priests and clergy, political opponents and Jews.
@@guiltysponge3297 they fought for democracy against fascism? More reason why they are in hell
@@guiltysponge3297 they fought for democracy? More reason to hate them
1:24 Professor Quirrell? What are you doing in the middle of the Spanish Civil War?
4:27 Harry Potter
History is fascinating who else agrees 😊
Not sure if the Lincoln brigade was this combat effective
1) this is POUM.
2) Even if they were part of an international brigade, they're british so it's obviously not going to be the Lincoln brigade.
@@magic-pf6yd No, there is an Irish volunteer, an American and at least one Italian as I recall.
@@zavi13 whatever, my point stands. not Lincoln brigade.
@@zavi13 one american, one english, one irish, one italian, one french, one german as well as spanish fighters (obviously)
Won't be long before that group in Seattle and Portland starting acting this way.
The last part is what broke my immersion
This is so realistic..
No
@@mustardandcorn2905 they did put a lot more effort than most of the war movie.
I don't understand, who is a fascist, who is a communist, who is an anarchist, who is free and who is from the republic? It already looks like HOI4
What movie is that
Land and Freedom, a film by Ken Loach. It's pretty good IMHO
The title should be Communist attacks Nationalist held village.
Fix the damn title
Stop watching this brother, WE MUST FIGHT THE SBI!
Countrymen killing each other for two different systems that weren’t good for anything.
arriba españa
Who wined the civil war?
the Anarchist :o
El ejército nacional ganó la guerra civil a la República socialcomunista...por que de democrática no tenía absolutamente nada
@@josejaviermarques5324 Franco Gano y era amigo de Hitler
The nationalists with Franco.
@@methodeetrigueur1164 thanks
What movie?
Mi bisabuelo fue a esa guerra :(
name of film?
Alguien sabe como se llama la película
NAME OF FILM???
its a movie or a short?
Movie
What is the name of this movie?:)
It was not the Int Brig, but the POUM
Rip to the Republican heroes
No todos lo fueron
They’re burning in hell rn
In George Orwell’s homage to Catalonia, he talks about his time fighting for the Republicans. He spoke about the rusty 19th century weaponry which often had to be shared amongst the troops, an interesting read
Actually the Republican talks a lot of Orwell's, and they hate him so much.
This is because 1# He hate working people. 2# He doesn't actually fight with them. 3# he was making list of Irish Republican for arrest and assassination and submit them to the British monarchy under the title of "Enemy of the British Empire".
Not to mentions just how absurdly Racist he is. Like HP Lovecraft have mental problems, but Orwell's doesn't, and he is even more Racist than Lovecraft.
You have no idea what you are talking about, Orwell had a great disdain for what is known as the British Empire, for the time spent as a torturer in Burma in his military days, he loved the working people, he wrote books out of their voices.@@Huy-G-Le
@@fintanmccann1128 I do know what I'm talking about. He hate his job doesn't mean he have great disdain for his empire nor his empire crime of colonialism. You want proof?
@@Huy-G-Le If you can show me proof, make it something that would change my mind.
@@Huy-G-Le Most Republicans hate people like Orwell because journalists and writers supportive of them saw their war as a spectator sport and never helped them versus the Nationalist journalists actually seeing combat with the units they attached to.
Name of this movie?
Lies. Those damn Commies where never this competent. What movie is this, btw?
That's why it took Germany, Italy and Franco three years to beat them. Lol!
@@frankverdino477 Twas a joke really, kinda like the Negrin government. :) You do have to admit that the Germans and the Italians where more tickling than punching. Plus the geography of Spain itself is as formidable an opponent as the disunited Republic.
Whats the movie name
The Spanish civil wars where they took it in turns to massacre villages
Yes, check out the film Land and Freedom a Ken Loach film. This is a short clip from it.
Movies' names for 👍👍
Ya hemos pasado
POUM militia, not International Brigade but great scene. Visca POUM!
Arriba España, traidores!
4:27 Harry Potter and the Chamber Is Loaded
4:28 Harry Potter y la Guerra civil de españa
Bueno y muy buen. Ole!
Brigadas internacionales vs nacionalistas
More left-wing nonesense.
good lord...
Movie
"La parola d'ordine dei rossi era No Pasaran: SIAMO PASSATI! E IO VI DICO CHE PASSEREMO!"
Sempre a Noi
Siete passati e vi abbiamo ricacciato nelle fogne, e siamo pronti a rifarlo ogni volta che sarà necessario
@@nicholasf.3968 in Spagna vi abbiamo cacciato noi ahahaha
Whick on is spain the sniper with no scope?
Loaded headline. It is more accurate to call the village Nationalist held. One could call the International Brigade Communist or even Stalinist, maybe add the word controlled.
watch the film- more is revealed
@@chestermosburger3113 that film is historically inaccurate, still is a good movie to watch, but there are many things that are modified in order to appeal to certain public...
Even if the war was a tragic event that ended long ago there is people who still want to continue (I've talked to people who literally said "war is not over and you all going to die for being traitors") More than 80 had passed and there are ignorants who "want to win this war" without knowing that both sides ended up devastated and rose a monument called "valley of the fallen" where republicans and nacionalists where buried in the same place as a reconciliation and a way to say "no matter what is your ideology, death will be the same for everyone, never do this again".
Cruelty was common for both sides, but military never used civilians not implicated in war for their purposes, in the movie they use two women, something that the military have strictly prohibited, they used Republican hostages and tortured them (which I personally disagree, but is war and your life depends on it, same as the Republicans who used nuns as hostages or to... Ya know, there are some nasty people on both sides).
They most certainly were not Stalinists or Soviet controlled, especially seeing as how many of the fighters were Anarchists and had a shit ton of infighting between them and the communist forces, which was one of the major factors for why they lost. The nationalists were equally if not more back/controlled by Nazi Germany than the Republicans were backed by the Soviet Union, i mean there literally were German plains that bombed Republican controlled cities while the Russians didn't come close to doing something on par with that in it's aid of the Republicans. Certainly they received support/aid from the Russians, but it's complete historical revisionism to assert that they were "controlled" by the USSR.
Here after the last surviving member, Josep Eduardo Almudéver Mateu has just passed away. Rest in Peace!
burn in hell lmaoooo
S
Communists Attack a nationalist held village. There fixed the title 😊
Communists attack a fascist held village or republicans attack a nationalist held village. Can't have it both ways :P
@@dipendrashah4314 they are literally waving commie flags.... no they are not Republicans lol. If they were they would wave the republican flag.
@@dipendrashah4314 Actually no.POUM which are shown here as the "good" republicans were mostly communists from around the world."Fascists" shown in the movie were Nationalists based from their equipment.
Sometimes the good guys win...
Wait
The Nationalists won
No pasaran!
This is epic
This is pure shit... You, f***ng commies got what deserved...
@@ofgb1975 so far Fascist started a war in Europe and killed millions.
@Luka Knoery ikr
¡Arriba España!
Division Azul
Viva España con honra
Ya hemos pasao!
"¡No pasarán!"
@@zavi13
“Bueno, ellos ya pasaron” ☺️
Who won the war?
Rudy Tahang the nationalists. Mainly because if outside support and an undivided republican front.
@@namelessidiot667 The nationalists did not have much support from foreign nations, the nationalists won because they were more organized, all had the same leader and the same ideas for what Spain should become. The republican army was very disorganized and beliefs varied widely.
No one won.
Communist propaganda
lol the good guys arent dying its unrealistic
This is so historically inaccurate
🇪🇦⚔🇪🇦
Only a dead communist is a good communist :-)
No se rick parece falso
All criminals. All.
Who? The P.O.U.M or Nationalists?
Plotarmor
¡Arriba España! ¡Viva Cristo Rey!
¡España, mañana, será republicana! ¡No pasarán! Y ¡muerte al fascismo!
¡Que Viva!
@@facuuu2809 fascismo zzzz, Nacionalismo God. Una tercera República? Jajajajajaj una tercera guerra civil que perderán