Добро пожаловать в Открытый Тест от Clarinet Hack! Здесь у нас ученические (студенческие) кларнеты от компании Буффе Крампон - E11, E12f и E13. Также я записал различные музыкальные фрагменты на моем RC Prestige из начала 2000-х, чтобы сравнить ученические инструменты для начинающих с профессиональным кларнетом. Поделитесь вашими мыслями об этих инструментах в комментариях! И голосуйте за ваш любимый инструмент во время прослушивания теста! Чтобы голосовать, нажмите на кнопку Подсказка в правом верхнем углу. Проходите по ссылке, чтобы посмотреть детальный обзор Буффе E11, E12 и E13 - ua-cam.com/video/A2jL2RsWs1k/v-deo.html Подписывайтесь на мой канал, чтобы увидеть больше кларнетовых видео! Кларнеты были любезно предоставлены Ателье Гончарова! Особая благодарность Владиславу Гончарову! www.atelier-goncharov.com
Очень Креативно! Увлекательно! Профессионально! Режиссура на высшем уровне!!! Очень Профессиональная и Скурпулезная оценка всех инструментов! Такого объективно теста я ещё не видел! Поздравляю!!!
I've only been playing for six months, so it's still difficult for me to be certain if the sound of a clarinet is good or not. I watched your videos with the best headphones I could find and I decided that I really prefer the sound of the E13. I discussed this with my teacher and with my friend who's been playing clarinet for years and they both agree that the E13 is a great choice. So today I ordered the E13 online and will hopefully get it next week. I am super excited, and I wanted to thank you because your videos were such an in-depth analysis and they really helped me make a decision. Thank you so much, Anton!!!
@@AntonMoiseyenko Just am update to say I am LOVING my E13. The sound is so beautiful. Maybe in these 6 months of learning I have developed a more discerning ear because I really can tell the difference between this clarinet and my Yamaha ABS resin instrument. This instrument sounds so pretty I wish I could play all day! Also it sounds so loud. It's like I only need to blow 50% as hard as I did before, which really helps with breath control and expression and even articulation. Also, the keys are much more responsive and playing is easier. Again, thank you for taking the time to make these amazing videos!
I have played a clarinet 14 keys B flat since 1991 and I love it. In a nutshell, I was 11 when my dad gave me my first clarinet. Well, I have considered the idea of buying a new one.
Best comparison video ever! In previous video I thought the order: 12f, 11, 13 and RC. Sincerely, I prefer the E11 instead of E12f. Summarizing, in first place I vote RC, after E13 which sounds great, then E11 and finally E12f which I don’t say it is bad. Regards
The Prestige tunes a little higher. Allso the sound a bit less compact - the E13 seem to be the one that has most projection and sweetest sound ( in this room !) but will happen in a larger venue?
I like the E13 very much, the sound quality is really great for its price! I didn’t feel any discomfort playing it. The mouthpiece here is Nick Puccini Tosca - highly recommended to try 😉
Out of the student clarinets the E13 shines through, but interestingly I could hear hardly any difference going to the RC Prestige. Might be more obvious in real life, or better quality playback than UA-cam!
Excellent test! I have already decided: E13! Could I ask you please regarding instruments? Were these "out of the box" or were these instruments first checked by the technician ( corrected leakages / pads, regulation etc. and then subjected to test)?
Interesting question! These clarinets were kindly provided by Atelier Goncharov and usually they fix the instruments before selling so I think they were lightly checked by technicians before. Usually there’s no big problems with Buffet instruments out of the box but to be sure if you decide to buy an instrument it’s better to ask a repairman to check if everything works fine and if it needs some fixing.
hi, may i ask what the percent number at the center of analysis screen refers to? it seems to be RC prestige has the poorest tune quality, am i right?? quite stunning result.
The percents are showing the tuning rate, how often you get clear 442 in my case. The main problem with my set up is that my mouthpiece is around 443, and the clarinet has got sharper within 15 years. But the overall tuning is more even especially if you compare it with e11 and e12.
E13 still wins! Much more even intonation between registers... The E12 was a little flat on the lower register for my taste. Great playing :-) (ps. I could only afford the E11 :'-D) the prestige sounds a bit too cold for my taste.
Да, Престиж, по моим ощущениям, самый красочный из них. Хотя по количеству темной краски е13 мне тоже очень понравился. Если бы покупал вот таким образом инструмент, точно купил бы е13 :)
Добро пожаловать в Открытый Тест от Clarinet Hack!
Здесь у нас ученические (студенческие) кларнеты от компании Буффе Крампон - E11, E12f и E13.
Также я записал различные музыкальные фрагменты на моем RC Prestige из начала 2000-х, чтобы сравнить ученические инструменты для начинающих с профессиональным кларнетом.
Поделитесь вашими мыслями об этих инструментах в комментариях!
И голосуйте за ваш любимый инструмент во время прослушивания теста!
Чтобы голосовать, нажмите на кнопку Подсказка в правом верхнем углу.
Проходите по ссылке, чтобы посмотреть детальный обзор Буффе E11, E12 и E13 - ua-cam.com/video/A2jL2RsWs1k/v-deo.html
Подписывайтесь на мой канал, чтобы увидеть больше кларнетовых видео!
Кларнеты были любезно предоставлены Ателье Гончарова! Особая благодарность Владиславу Гончарову!
www.atelier-goncharov.com
00:05 - Tchaikovsky - E11
01:19 - Tchaikovsky - E12F
02:39 - Tchaikovsky - E13
03:57 - Tchaikovsky - RC Prestige
05:15 - Weber - E11
07:19 - Weber - E12F
09:19 - Weber - E13
11:23 - Weber - RC Prestige
13:23 - Saint-Saëns - E11
13:56 - Saint-Saëns - E12F
14:31 - Saint-Saëns - E13
15:04 - Saint-Saëns - RC Prestige
15:36 - Pierné - E11
16:42 - Pierné - E12F
17:49 - Pierné - E13
18:55 - Pierné - RC Prestige
Очень Креативно! Увлекательно! Профессионально! Режиссура на высшем уровне!!! Очень Профессиональная и Скурпулезная оценка всех инструментов! Такого объективно теста я ещё не видел! Поздравляю!!!
Valeriy Moiseenko спасибо! Надеюсь, что это многим поможет сделать правильный выбор!
I've only been playing for six months, so it's still difficult for me to be certain if the sound of a clarinet is good or not. I watched your videos with the best headphones I could find and I decided that I really prefer the sound of the E13. I discussed this with my teacher and with my friend who's been playing clarinet for years and they both agree that the E13 is a great choice. So today I ordered the E13 online and will hopefully get it next week. I am super excited, and I wanted to thank you because your videos were such an in-depth analysis and they really helped me make a decision. Thank you so much, Anton!!!
Thank you for your comment! I’m really glad that this video could help you to decide! Hope that the new e13 will suit your expectations!
@@AntonMoiseyenko Just am update to say I am LOVING my E13. The sound is so beautiful. Maybe in these 6 months of learning I have developed a more discerning ear because I really can tell the difference between this clarinet and my Yamaha ABS resin instrument. This instrument sounds so pretty I wish I could play all day! Also it sounds so loud. It's like I only need to blow 50% as hard as I did before, which really helps with breath control and expression and even articulation. Also, the keys are much more responsive and playing is easier. Again, thank you for taking the time to make these amazing videos!
It's very interesting! I like the E12F. Because it was good for price and beautiful sound.I should buy it too. Thank you.
I hope you'll enjoy playing it!
That made my day when you played Piernè- probably one of favorite clarinet pieces ever. :)
Thank you! I love this piece too, especially when I play it with my wife :)
I have played a clarinet 14 keys B flat since 1991 and I love it. In a nutshell, I was 11 when my dad gave me my first clarinet. Well, I have considered the idea of buying a new one.
Best comparison video ever! In previous video I thought the order: 12f, 11, 13 and RC. Sincerely, I prefer the E11 instead of E12f. Summarizing, in first place I vote RC, after E13 which sounds great, then E11 and finally E12f which I don’t say it is bad. Regards
Thank you for your comment! I agree with your opinion!
The Prestige tunes a little higher. Allso the sound a bit less compact - the E13 seem to be the one that has most projection and sweetest sound ( in this room !) but will happen in a larger venue?
Hi, for me the most interesting between student's clarinet is the E13. I'd like to know which mouthpiece do you use. Thank you!
I like the E13 very much, the sound quality is really great for its price! I didn’t feel any discomfort playing it. The mouthpiece here is Nick Puccini Tosca - highly recommended to try 😉
@@AntonMoiseyenko Thank you!
Out of the student clarinets the E13 shines through, but interestingly I could hear hardly any difference going to the RC Prestige. Might be more obvious in real life, or better quality playback than UA-cam!
I think it would be more fair to compare both new e13 and Prestige, but in my case, after the blind test, I’ve found that I like e13 even more :)
Thank you for the video. What is the application that is overlaid onscreen?
Тюнер - n-Track Tuner - n-Track S.r.l.
Ты молодец продолжай снимать все получится удачи
Спасибо! Надеюсь быть полезным!
Excellent test!
I have already decided: E13!
Could I ask you please regarding instruments? Were these "out of the box" or were these instruments first checked by the technician ( corrected leakages / pads, regulation etc. and then subjected to test)?
Interesting question! These clarinets were kindly provided by Atelier Goncharov and usually they fix the instruments before selling so I think they were lightly checked by technicians before. Usually there’s no big problems with Buffet instruments out of the box but to be sure if you decide to buy an instrument it’s better to ask a repairman to check if everything works fine and if it needs some fixing.
@@AntonMoiseyenko Thank you!
hi, may i ask what the percent number at the center of analysis screen refers to? it seems to be RC prestige has the poorest tune quality, am i right?? quite stunning result.
The percents are showing the tuning rate, how often you get clear 442 in my case. The main problem with my set up is that my mouthpiece is around 443, and the clarinet has got sharper within 15 years. But the overall tuning is more even especially if you compare it with e11 and e12.
I have e12f .it is really nice
This is a very nice instrument for its price!
@@AntonMoiseyenko Why the "f"? Could you explain, please?
Beautiful playing! May I ask what is the excerpt?
Thank you!
The excerpts are:
Tchaikovsky - Clarinet solo from Sleeping Beauty (ua-cam.com/video/cJLUZeQhHts/v-deo.html),
Weber - Concertino Op.26 (ua-cam.com/video/rgOd5ftKz9M/v-deo.html),
Saint-Saens - Clarinet Sonata, II movement (ua-cam.com/video/7Cb1XaLqPGw/v-deo.html),
Pierne - Canzonetta (ua-cam.com/video/Dpmck4CEa28/v-deo.html).
E13 still wins! Much more even intonation between registers... The E12 was a little flat on the lower register for my taste. Great playing :-) (ps. I could only afford the E11 :'-D) the prestige sounds a bit too cold for my taste.
After this test I've started respecting e13 even more! Fantastic instrument, great price-quality ratio!
I have an E13 but really would like to buy an RC...what do you think? Worth the upgrade? :)
They are quite different instruments, depends on what you’re searching for.
@@AntonMoiseyenko play in an orchestra and duets
😁 i dont like to play solo. 🙈
Из студенческих моделей больше всего понравились - Е11 и Е13 , но всё же Престиж есть Престиж)
Да, Престиж, по моим ощущениям, самый красочный из них. Хотя по количеству темной краски е13 мне тоже очень понравился. Если бы покупал вот таким образом инструмент, точно купил бы е13 :)
@@AntonMoiseyenko было бы интересно также услышать Ваше сравнение Buffet с Selmer. Я думаю, это было бы многим интересно.
Согласен! А какие именно инструменты были бы интересны?
@@AntonMoiseyenko я думаю , что самые ходовые модели - Престиж, Фестиваль, Тоска и Сельмер Привиледж
Интересно! Надо попробовать ;)
I like E-13.
Me too, I enjoyed it really much!
Все кларнеты нравятся, кроме E12F
Интересно! Что понравилось в понравившихся и не понравилось в Е12? :)
Подскажите пожалуйста, что это за приложение?
Какое именно?
#3 prestige?)
Не знаю, не знаю ))))
Toco uma yamaha 650🇧🇷
I’d love to compare buffet with yamaha.