@@georgesbinetter2416 You're both right. ABSOLUTELY TRUE! This (meaning THE ORIGINAL "DAS BOOT") was - hands down! - the BEST movie about WW2 submarine warfare ever done - and the actors (in cluding the Captain) just nailed their respective roles!
Ich stimme vollkommen zu, mein Freund. Dieses Remake wirkt für den US-Markt „amerikanisiert“, und die Charaktere wirken „hohl“ oder oberflächlich, wie junge College-Studenten, die Theater spielen oder „Cosplay“ spielen. Ich kannte einen U-Boot-Besatzungsangehörigen, einen Torpedomann, der wegen Krankheit auf ein anderes Boot versetzt worden war und später erfuhr, dass „Seine GESAMTE Besatzung“ auf SEINEM Boot durch Wasserbomben umgekommen war. Frank wollte sich „Das Boot“ nie ansehen, als es herauskam, und als er später in seinem Leben eine Szene sah, war er wegen ihres Realismus wirklich traurig. „Meine Jungs!“ mit Tränen in den Augen. Möge Herr Frank Mayer in ewigem Frieden ruhen, ein LIEBESMANN. Das Original „Das Boot“ ist meiner bescheidenen Meinung nach VIEL besser als dieses Remake
I watched the original series the first time when I was a child in German TV and was sooo fascinated. Have watched it so many times since then that I can speak literally every single text line which makes my wife go crazy…To watch this remake which they dare to call „Das Boot“ was like waiting about 15 years after Return of the Jedi for the next part of Star Wars - and seeing Jar Jar Binks…
@@juannieves8642 Учту,спасибо. Кстати ещё хороший фильм с морской тематикой и Второй Мировой Войной: Sink the Bismarck!(1960).Хоть и старый,но мне понравился.
Have to Agree with most of these comments The Original Das Boot would have to be one of the Greatest War Films ever Made!!! If you could ever imagine what it would have been like to be in a U Boat in the middle of the Atlantic Ocean! Then the Writers and Producers and actor's of the original Created as close as you could ever imagine what these Brave Men went through!! 🙏❤️🙏
I really enjoyed the new series. Utterly hated the side characters on land. But the Uboat crew was largely A+ performance. (though Im unsure if I liked the Captain being somewhat insane) Shame they did the typical stretch out a tv series from a few scenes thing here. Otherwise it may have been a contender of the original. As the original Das Boat far surpassed the tv series. Which all of the highlights were shown in this video.
@@geronimo5537 i saw the original series when it first came out and i dont think that anyone has managed to show a submarine in such a dramatic way as this series. especially when even though you feel you should not be on their side, you end up doing just that.
@@seanseanuk as someone who was born in 91; has played many videos games and seen many movies. I have learned that in media. The camera's center focus always paints the center person as most sympathetic to the viewer. As we see the moment more from their point of view giving us their perspective. Be that good or bad. It is probably the biggest flaw and strength of media consumption. So I largely did not see the original series when it aired. But I have to entirely agree that no other has come close to being as accurate to real life.
@@geronimo5537 i think more because the "nazi" era, becomes an individual and the "nazi" part is forgotton. but i never worked out if that was because of the casting, the camera work. or maybe because the original was filmed in german, with subtitles.
Boat crew look like Korean pop star 👍 Herr Kaleun made many absurd decision, he needs more whiskey to think straight. I believe they had laundry machine on the boat, their uniform is impeccable.
I’m afraid it doesn’t hold a candle to the original version. With that you could almost smell the sweat , old farts , fuel and fear as well as the crews rough jokes and humour brought a real gritty reality this version just doesn’t have.
Hi.......why Das Boot music ??....by far the best and most realistic movie WWII u-boat...I visited U-995 in Laboe....It was really being in that U-96. Unforgottable !! DE from Argentina.
Why is stuff like this made. Its like looking at the mona lisa and thinking "I can do that. I don't care if i can do it even half as well but ill use the name and dont care if i give it any respect or justice" Just watch the ORIGINAL Das Boot. The 6 hour, subtitled version, the only version. Its a masterpiece and cannot be copied or bettered.
I didn't even go beyond a quick overview. A happy youth memory has been fouled up completely by this"remake". What indeed is the point of this? I have no clue, except rewriting history? They did the same last year with All Quiet on the Western Front, a cannon of a movie from 1930 and it's 70s version was OK too. But the 2022 version? I left absolute shocked after 20 minutes. There was nothing, but truly, nothing left of the original movie nor the book. In other words: they cut out the living parts in both cases, since both books were written by veteran who'd actually been there. Indeed, very good advice!
Having watched a bit if this I felt calling it "Das Boot" was nothing but an insult to the previous version. The authors of this latest one should feel ashamed of themselves.
Yes the original Das Boot the best insofar boats are involved. But the best of all yet or still Apacolapse Now. Now come on guys.....Andrew of South Africa, yeah South Africa.
7:40 - Completely miscalculation here. 1700 meters distance to US corvette, torpedo speed 30 knots (55 kph = 15 m/sec) means 113 seconds. In fact no real chance to hit small ship as WW2 corvette.
Der Film ist der beste WW2-Film, der je gedreht wurde, und die Serie ist wahnsinnig gut und realistisch. Wir sind stolz auf die Kriegsmarine für immer.
Haven't seen this version. The original is best watched in the series (fullest) format. The main grumble for me is the sub seems immune to depth charges, only air-dropped bombs seem to touch it.
If the original hadn't been made, this would be a good film. But the original was made and was one of the 2 best naval war films ever (the other being The Cruel Sea). That makes this something of a let down.
Ah man! This actually has a lot of potential, but sadly it is not realized. For starters, a U-boat refueling on the surface in daytime? Not likely, no U-boat commander would be dumb enough to do that. Or if they were, they would not survive their first patrol. Secondy, no U-boat commander would attack a Corvette with torpedoes. TWO torpedoes at that. The Type VIIC U-boat carried 14 torpedoes, and out of those 4 were for the aft tube. Every single torpedo was prescious, and a Corvette was a small escort ship. Third, no U-boat commander would reload torpedoes with enemy escorts around. Reloading torpedoes makes a lot of noise!
refueling on the surface not in the shipping lanes, routes travelled by ships across the atlantic. weather is overcast depends on the position in the atlantic if a plane can get that far. one plane must search, thousands of miles of ocean to find one ship/uboat. corvettes fire back at you, so safer to attack with torpedos as it was really hard to find a submerged uboat. a reloaded torpedo can be fired, an unloaded torpedo can not be fired. if a ship has a torpedo coming towards it, then the ship deals with the torpedo first, not so interested in attacking a uboat. sebastijanglozinic8630 no idea
A similar point is made in the original when Prochnow attacks the destroyer; the 2nd watch officer (Semmelrogge's character) considered it madness to do so (albeit in rough seas to boot).
I am not that familiar with ships silhouettes, but in my opinion they falsely identified merchant ship as corvette, to be able to sink it without breaking the order "not to engage unless necessary". Only a handful of sailors knew that ship isn't a corvette.
The original Das Boot is a film that should be nearly 11 hours long from what I remember as a T.V series instead. One thing you may or may not know about the original film. They actually had original staff on set who built them for making every part of the set real as it was for the real crews. Even the training for the cast was so strict in the movements on diving while another ran through the open hatch by grabbing bulkhead swinging over the man on the ground. This type of man is something special knowing only they are the rescuers if they needed rescued! Still the same today no matter which navy it is. This is life and death for each and everyone if they are required to fire nuclear weapons then they will! They are some of the most watched people by their retrospective nations on the secrets they hold, as there is no secrets in such a confined area with mass destruction in the rear end. This could kill you too if they ruptured.
The series with all 4 seasons is brilliant in that it reveals a lot more about the war than just the dumb heroism. Many facts are covered that didn't find place in the 80s movie like drugs, conflicts, commercial interests in war etc.
For someone who is familiar with the subject matter, this is simply an embarrassment. At 12:19, it's impossible for the Horchmaat to suddenly hear the entire convoy only after a freighter has been hit. Convoys never stopped but always had to keep moving. The convoy had to be heard from the beginning. At 6:17 it is obvious that the enemy's position is not right 30, but rather left 60. At 11:19 it is said that a shot at 300 meters is too risky, but they shoot anyway. In fact, this should not actually be successful because the torpedo is only armed after a distance of 300 meters. It is also strange that no one ever gives, repeats or executes commands to increase or decrease the boat's speed, even though the boat is clearly changing speed. Even when the boat dives in alarm at 14:13, nobody seems to be interested in the speed. At 11:13, even inexperienced commanders can see that the opponent's heading is not 80 degrees, but rather 60 degrees. An enemy speed of 17 knots is far too high for a large freighter in a convoy (probably 1942), 8-10 knots would be realistic. Only a small proportion of freighters can even manage such a speed, and then only for a short time, because far too much fuel is consumed. It becomes completely absurd at 12:42, when the Kaleun announces enemy position 0 degrees and targets a freighter that is clearly showing its broadside (probably enemy position left approx. 90 degrees). 0 degrees would mean that the freighter is heading directly towards the submarine. At 13:34, the submarine is also clearly not on a collision course with the destroyer. It is also unrealistic that even when attacking a convoy while submerged, nobody is interested in how loud it is in the submarine.
@@Ganttura1 The angle at which the submarine was positioned in relation to the bow of the target ship had to be entered on the TDC. This is the position angle that is announced in the communication between the kaleun and the weapons officer. This can be clearly recognized by the fact that before the announcement of the attitude angle, the submarine is told whether it is to the left or right of the bow of the target ship.
@@JohnMarrington The submarine is told whether it is left or right? I am so confused. I thought it just meant the angle at which when looking from the target ship towards the bow is in relation with the submarine. I am not a native English speaker so I apologize if I did not understand and my own explanation was total bogus.
Why would you remake Das Boot it's never going to be as good as the original film and the 5hr long mini series, that's impossible as especially the series is one of the best most gripping things ever produced.
The TV series was actually really good. Splendid acting, pacing was excellent, uniforms, models, etc. But wow, the story was straight out of a fairy tale, and that ending? Ugh.
It is possible... I guess. Although 16 knots was literally the top speed for the Flower-class corvette. For her to go 16 knots, she would pretty much have to be in the middle of an attack run in perfect seas. Not to mention, why would you try to torpedo a Flower-class corvette in the first place? It is a waste of torpedoes.
Good God, but this is an awful sequel to the original "Das Boot". The "American" corvette was in fact the Canadian HMCS SNOWBERRY. And far from being sunk during WWII, she survived and in fact sank U-536. If the U-boat was concerned about her contacting her fellow escorts, she failed miserably in doing so given how long it took them to eventually fire their torpedoes at them. And if SNOWBERRY had detected the U-boat, why did she then stooge about well in front instead of attacking? In the last scene, if a freighter had already been torpedoed, why wasn't the destroyer that almost hit them pinging with her asdic? What a bloody silly show this is.
Er hatte eine Mission zu erfüllen und hatte dagegen verstoßen und somit unnötigen Aufsehen zu erregen und das ist ein Fehler denn nun nicht machen sollte in solch einer Mission.
Aren't they a bit too hysterical, talky, and well-groomed for a seasoned u-boat crew? And torpedoes being reloaded in combat conditions? Not bloody likely, considering the racket that made! Most subs fired all tubes empty and retreated to reload. The bit about the captain resigning the able sub and crew to its fate was pathetic. What a load of tosh this is. A far cry from the original.
Il y a un Film-Das Boot - avec Jürgen Prochnow. L'histoire d'un sous-marin. Mais en principe, L'histoire des sous-marins allemands dans la Seconde Guerre mondiale. Je ne suis pas sûr que ce Film, c'est un long Film , il y a plus de 2 ou même 3 heures dans d'autres langues que L'Allemand. Un super Film. Sans bave, sans-Nazis -,, sans-Houston we have a problem -. Juste L'histoire. Comme vu du côté Allemand.
Nar, not as believable as the original series, to much pointless drama. And the captain wasn't believable as was the actor who played the original captain.
Nowhere near as good as the original. Let us make a remake and make loads of money but all you get is a shallow imitation of the original one of the finest WW11 movies.
9 von 10 Details falsch am schlimmsten, die Nr 1 stellt die Torpedos für den Unterwasserschuss ein und nicht der 1 WO und der 1 WO muss schon erstmal das Kdo übernehmen
The original Das Boot...one of the best war movies ever made!!!
END OF THE COMMUNICATION
Juergen Prochow as Kaleun, unbeatable!
@@georgesbinetter2416 You're both right. ABSOLUTELY TRUE! This (meaning THE ORIGINAL "DAS BOOT") was - hands down! - the BEST movie about WW2 submarine warfare ever done - and the actors (in cluding the Captain) just nailed their respective roles!
Jawohl, Kapitän
Red October👉.Sean Connery,best of👍
@@laszlohajmasi827 pawraaa, new pawraa
The original was the best war movie ever made.
It was excellent. Sadly the TV series, shamelessly trading on the name, was absolute dross.
I'd say that The Cruel Sea was equally good.
@@MrHistorian123 it sure was. “Snorkers good oh”
@@craigevans6981 Yes - Stanley Baker as the lovable (not) Lt Bennett.
Die alten Das Boot Filme waren und sind meiner Meinung nach immer noch die besten
Agreed!
Ich stimme vollkommen zu, mein Freund. Dieses Remake wirkt für den US-Markt „amerikanisiert“, und die Charaktere wirken „hohl“ oder oberflächlich, wie junge College-Studenten, die Theater spielen oder „Cosplay“ spielen. Ich kannte einen U-Boot-Besatzungsangehörigen, einen Torpedomann, der wegen Krankheit auf ein anderes Boot versetzt worden war und später erfuhr, dass „Seine GESAMTE Besatzung“ auf SEINEM Boot durch Wasserbomben umgekommen war. Frank wollte sich „Das Boot“ nie ansehen, als es herauskam, und als er später in seinem Leben eine Szene sah, war er wegen ihres Realismus wirklich traurig. „Meine Jungs!“ mit Tränen in den Augen. Möge Herr Frank Mayer in ewigem Frieden ruhen, ein LIEBESMANN.
Das Original „Das Boot“ ist meiner bescheidenen Meinung nach VIEL besser als dieses Remake
Richtig.. 👍🇪🇸
Wenn ist das nonstück git und Slotermeyer ? Ja bierhund das oder die flipperwaldt gersput !
I watched the original series the first time when I was a child in German TV and was sooo fascinated. Have watched it so many times since then that I can speak literally every single text line which makes my wife go crazy…To watch this remake which they dare to call „Das Boot“ was like waiting about 15 years after Return of the Jedi for the next part of Star Wars - and seeing Jar Jar Binks…
guter Vergleich..
Ну посмотреть то я всё равно посмотрю.
@@ИванЖилин-э2й just skip all the french resizzzztence moments
@@juannieves8642 Учту,спасибо. Кстати ещё хороший фильм с морской тематикой и Второй Мировой Войной: Sink the Bismarck!(1960).Хоть и старый,но мне понравился.
Have to Agree with most of these comments The Original Das Boot would have to be one of the Greatest War Films ever Made!!! If you could ever imagine what it would have been like to be in a U Boat in the middle of the Atlantic Ocean! Then the Writers and Producers and actor's of the original Created as close as you could ever imagine what these Brave Men went through!! 🙏❤️🙏
some of the best music too
I really enjoyed the new series. Utterly hated the side characters on land. But the Uboat crew was largely A+ performance. (though Im unsure if I liked the Captain being somewhat insane) Shame they did the typical stretch out a tv series from a few scenes thing here. Otherwise it may have been a contender of the original. As the original Das Boat far surpassed the tv series. Which all of the highlights were shown in this video.
@@geronimo5537 i saw the original series when it first came out and i dont think that anyone has managed to show a submarine in such a dramatic way as this series. especially when even though you feel you should not be on their side, you end up doing just that.
@@seanseanuk as someone who was born in 91; has played many videos games and seen many movies. I have learned that in media. The camera's center focus always paints the center person as most sympathetic to the viewer. As we see the moment more from their point of view giving us their perspective. Be that good or bad. It is probably the biggest flaw and strength of media consumption.
So I largely did not see the original series when it aired. But I have to entirely agree that no other has come close to being as accurate to real life.
@@geronimo5537 i think more because the "nazi" era, becomes an individual and the "nazi" part is forgotton.
but i never worked out if that was because of the casting, the camera work. or maybe because the original was filmed in german, with subtitles.
Boat crew look like Korean pop star 👍 Herr Kaleun made many absurd decision, he needs more whiskey to think straight. I believe they had laundry machine on the boat, their uniform is impeccable.
Exellent series one of the best war action in decades
Das Boot is the best German WW2 Movie.....Danke Germany fűr das.....👍🏻❤🇩🇪🥇👏👏
I think they deserve double thanks. We also owe the theme of the film to the Germans... 😉
@@decorolkamm9029 yes that theme is amazing .
Not the best German the best ever
The original series was absolutely superb
I’m afraid it doesn’t hold a candle to the original version. With that you could almost smell the sweat , old farts , fuel and fear as well as the crews rough jokes and humour brought a real gritty reality this version just doesn’t have.
Hi.......why Das Boot music ??....by far the best and most realistic movie WWII u-boat...I visited U-995 in Laboe....It was really being in that U-96. Unforgottable !! DE from Argentina.
These men were exceptionally brave.
The original was outstanding
Why is stuff like this made. Its like looking at the mona lisa and thinking "I can do that. I don't care if i can do it even half as well but ill use the name and dont care if i give it any respect or justice"
Just watch the ORIGINAL Das Boot. The 6 hour, subtitled version, the only version. Its a masterpiece and cannot be copied or bettered.
Well said.
I didn't even go beyond a quick overview. A happy youth memory has been fouled up completely by this"remake". What indeed is the point of this? I have no clue, except rewriting history? They did the same last year with All Quiet on the Western Front, a cannon of a movie from 1930 and it's 70s version was OK too. But the 2022 version? I left absolute shocked after 20 minutes. There was nothing, but truly, nothing left of the original movie nor the book. In other words: they cut out the living parts in both cases, since both books were written by veteran who'd actually been there.
Indeed, very good advice!
Having watched a bit if this I felt calling it "Das Boot" was nothing but an insult to the previous version. The authors of this latest one should feel ashamed of themselves.
This is not bad at all. Thank you for uploading.
If you come to Helsinki, in the harbour is a fortress, and the ”original prototype” of the U-96 is there
The crew looked rather clean.
They also smell Coco Chanel nº5
@@jbg-mnk1457
😂🤣👌👍
Yes the original Das Boot the best insofar boats are involved. But the best of all yet or still Apacolapse Now. Now come on guys.....Andrew of South Africa, yeah South Africa.
7:40 - Completely miscalculation here. 1700 meters distance to US corvette, torpedo speed 30 knots (55 kph = 15 m/sec) means 113 seconds. In fact no real chance to hit small ship as WW2 corvette.
Watched season 1 of this series. Haven't been able to watch anymore series in New Zealand.
no worries, its not worth it
@@Werner4vosshave not watched it, but from a couple clips I’ve seen it doesn’t seem historically accurate or realistic at all
0.50 For some reason there is a modern ball valve on the filling hose!
На заправочном шланге современный шаровый кран почему то !
Come & See & Das Boot, best movies of this subject matter ever made.
Der Film ist der beste WW2-Film, der je gedreht wurde, und die Serie ist wahnsinnig gut und realistisch. Wir sind stolz auf die Kriegsmarine für immer.
SEHR SEHR GUT...
orgoglioso di che? di quella banda di assassini...
Haven't seen this version. The original is best watched in the series (fullest) format. The main grumble for me is the sub seems immune to depth charges, only air-dropped bombs seem to touch it.
Not many U Boat men survived WW2. Unbeleivable brave men.
About 10000, 1 in 4.
just cowards 🤮🤮👎👎
If the original hadn't been made, this would be a good film.
But the original was made and was one of the 2 best naval war films ever (the other being The Cruel Sea). That makes this something of a let down.
That looks like a redo. I don't remember any of this actors playing in Pertesons movie.
Without Jurgen Prochnow + crew, it's not Das Boot. ENDE.
It's Das Ende. ENDE. 😄
well said.
Only the sly and the cowardice hide beneath the waves.
Hahahaha
BRAVO ❤❤❤❤
*What is the name of this particular submarine movie ??*
4:12 That's a pretty low blow. They were taking on fuel as well and did this guy think he was just gonna hide underwater for the whole war?
Lothar-Günther-Buchheim:
Das boot/Buch und Kino(A hajó/Könyv és film)
Absolut reality. :-(
Ajánlom mindenkinek!
Super film . Dziękuje
Co to za film?
Ah man! This actually has a lot of potential, but sadly it is not realized.
For starters, a U-boat refueling on the surface in daytime? Not likely, no U-boat commander would be dumb enough to do that. Or if they were, they would not survive their first patrol.
Secondy, no U-boat commander would attack a Corvette with torpedoes. TWO torpedoes at that. The Type VIIC U-boat carried 14 torpedoes, and out of those 4 were for the aft tube. Every single torpedo was prescious, and a Corvette was a small escort ship.
Third, no U-boat commander would reload torpedoes with enemy escorts around. Reloading torpedoes makes a lot of noise!
refueling on the surface
not in the shipping lanes, routes travelled by ships across the atlantic.
weather is overcast
depends on the position in the atlantic if a plane can get that far.
one plane must search, thousands of miles of ocean to find one ship/uboat.
corvettes fire back at you, so safer to attack with torpedos as it was really hard to find a submerged uboat.
a reloaded torpedo can be fired, an unloaded torpedo can not be fired.
if a ship has a torpedo coming towards it, then the ship deals with the torpedo first, not so interested in attacking a uboat.
sebastijanglozinic8630 no idea
A similar point is made in the original when Prochnow attacks the destroyer; the 2nd watch officer (Semmelrogge's character) considered it madness to do so (albeit in rough seas to boot).
I am not that familiar with ships silhouettes, but in my opinion they falsely identified merchant ship as corvette, to be able to sink it without breaking the order "not to engage unless necessary". Only a handful of sailors knew that ship isn't a corvette.
@@martinnuman1097 i'm ex royal navy
Baciar
Gar nicht schlecht. Gar nicht sooo schlecht. Aber. Das Original ist nicht zu schlagen. Ist so!
Oh dear .....its know we're near as good as the original series /film
In reality a U-boat commander would not want to be on the surface alongside another vessel in daylight.
The name of this movie, please?
What is this? Some leftovers from the original "Das Boot". Like tea brewed for the fifth time from the same bag.
Das U- Modell wackelt in der See wie ein Schuhkarton und bei dem Geschrei brauchten die Engländer kein Radar.
Esta no es la versión original de 1980, con Jurgen Prochnow, que es lejos la mejor: una gran película alemana.
yg mn bukan di jln ku no....pasti ber tahan di tmpt nya masing masing...tak ke mn mn...
Sorry; doesn’t deserve the same title as the original classic series/movie. Poor story, poor cgi, overly padded out with unnecessary ‘stuff’.
The original Das Boot is a film that should be nearly 11 hours long from what I remember as a T.V series instead.
One thing you may or may not know about the original film. They actually had original staff on set who built them for making every part of the set real as it was for the real crews. Even the training for the cast was so strict in the movements on diving while another ran through the open hatch by grabbing bulkhead swinging over the man on the ground.
This type of man is something special knowing only they are the rescuers if they needed rescued! Still the same today no matter which navy it is. This is life and death for each and everyone if they are required to fire nuclear weapons then they will!
They are some of the most watched people by their retrospective nations on the secrets they hold, as there is no secrets in such a confined area with mass destruction in the rear end. This could kill you too if they ruptured.
@@bmcg5296
You are right. I managed to get a dvd copy of the original tv series .
It’s very long, but worth it if you’re a fan.
@@NEMES1-Syour extremely lucky having the full complete version. Must look to see if it’s about anywhere. 👍🏻
It wasn’t bad I enjoyed it I watched Das Boot in 1980 brilliant!
The series with all 4 seasons is brilliant in that it reveals a lot more about the war than just the dumb heroism. Many facts are covered that didn't find place in the 80s movie like drugs, conflicts, commercial interests in war etc.
For someone who is familiar with the subject matter, this is simply an embarrassment. At 12:19, it's impossible for the Horchmaat to suddenly hear the entire convoy only after a freighter has been hit. Convoys never stopped but always had to keep moving. The convoy had to be heard from the beginning. At 6:17 it is obvious that the enemy's position is not right 30, but rather left 60. At 11:19 it is said that a shot at 300 meters is too risky, but they shoot anyway. In fact, this should not actually be successful because the torpedo is only armed after a distance of 300 meters. It is also strange that no one ever gives, repeats or executes commands to increase or decrease the boat's speed, even though the boat is clearly changing speed. Even when the boat dives in alarm at 14:13, nobody seems to be interested in the speed. At 11:13, even inexperienced commanders can see that the opponent's heading is not 80 degrees, but rather 60 degrees. An enemy speed of 17 knots is far too high for a large freighter in a convoy (probably 1942), 8-10 knots would be realistic. Only a small proportion of freighters can even manage such a speed, and then only for a short time, because far too much fuel is consumed. It becomes completely absurd at 12:42, when the Kaleun announces enemy position 0 degrees and targets a freighter that is clearly showing its broadside (probably enemy position left approx. 90 degrees). 0 degrees would mean that the freighter is heading directly towards the submarine. At 13:34, the submarine is also clearly not on a collision course with the destroyer. It is also unrealistic that even when attacking a convoy while submerged, nobody is interested in how loud it is in the submarine.
You mentioned these degrees which I think they mean the angle of bow for the torpedo data computer or TDC
@@Ganttura1 The angle at which the submarine was positioned in relation to the bow of the target ship had to be entered on the TDC. This is the position angle that is announced in the communication between the kaleun and the weapons officer. This can be clearly recognized by the fact that before the announcement of the attitude angle, the submarine is told whether it is to the left or right of the bow of the target ship.
@@JohnMarrington The submarine is told whether it is left or right? I am so confused. I thought it just meant the angle at which when looking from the target ship towards the bow is in relation with the submarine. I am not a native English speaker so I apologize if I did not understand and my own explanation was total bogus.
I think it's nice, the old one was this cross-over between Goethe and Nietsche as in feel
Name of this Movi...??
What's the name of the movie?
Das Boot (serial)
Nice Scenes but far away and no chance! The original is the best!
This has taken digital vids to a new LOW.
Why would you remake Das Boot it's never going to be as good as the original film and the 5hr long mini series, that's impossible as especially the series is one of the best most gripping things ever produced.
piękny film
Movie name, please? 😅
Das boot series
The TV series was actually really good. Splendid acting, pacing was excellent, uniforms, models, etc. But wow, the story was straight out of a fairy tale, and that ending? Ugh.
Thats the guy from mad men
Para acertar o Grêmio tinha que trazer Thiago Maia,,Firmino,Claudinho,Wendell,De la Vega!
Name movie?
As an Englander I am mortified that this show can be classed as das boot. This has nothing on the original. It’s a sham.😢😢😢
J'adore le peuple allemand
Abastecer de dia devia ser um pesadelo,com aviões caçando
Дуже яж
Тяжка служба
It says part 1 to 4 watched 1&2 can’t find 3&4 anybody know where to find them
На Дно Их деньги .
Accursed be the war...
12:38 Gegnerfahrt 16? 16 Knoten? no way!
It is possible... I guess. Although 16 knots was literally the top speed for the Flower-class corvette. For her to go 16 knots, she would pretty much have to be in the middle of an attack run in perfect seas. Not to mention, why would you try to torpedo a Flower-class corvette in the first place? It is a waste of torpedoes.
Good God, but this is an awful sequel to the original "Das Boot".
The "American" corvette was in fact the Canadian HMCS SNOWBERRY. And far from being sunk during WWII, she survived and in fact sank U-536.
If the U-boat was concerned about her contacting her fellow escorts, she failed miserably in doing so given how long it took them to eventually fire their torpedoes at them.
And if SNOWBERRY had detected the U-boat, why did she then stooge about well in front instead of attacking?
In the last scene, if a freighter had already been torpedoed, why wasn't the destroyer that almost hit them pinging with her asdic?
What a bloody silly show this is.
🎉🎉🎉 Hare Krišna 💓🍁🦋🌍🪻🌼🪔
Hallo hau ,bout greuhound an,d diki and pq18 and qp18
It's not ,,Das Boot" movie!🙄
this is not das boot !!!!!
It was sunk by a depth charge attack dropped by an enemy aircraft.
Er hatte eine Mission zu erfüllen und hatte dagegen verstoßen und somit unnötigen Aufsehen zu erregen und das ist ein Fehler denn nun nicht machen sollte in solch einer Mission.
It's a decent series dunno what the fuss is about
this is not DAS BOOT film
Original-*****. This one ?- *.
Not sure why this was made and called the same......
Traduire sous titrage en français les documentaire
This is the lame remake of the original Das Boot. Best thing is you don't watch it and forget about it.
Aren't they a bit too hysterical, talky, and well-groomed for a seasoned u-boat crew? And torpedoes being reloaded in combat conditions? Not bloody likely, considering the racket that made! Most subs fired all tubes empty and retreated to reload. The bit about the captain resigning the able sub and crew to its fate was pathetic.
What a load of tosh this is. A far cry from the original.
C'est tiré de quel film ?
I don't understand your language..
@@muhammads.a.m4727 From what film ?
@@FONT49590 Das boot series.
Il y a un Film-Das Boot - avec Jürgen Prochnow. L'histoire d'un sous-marin. Mais en principe, L'histoire des sous-marins allemands dans la Seconde Guerre mondiale. Je ne suis pas sûr que ce Film, c'est un long Film , il y a plus de 2 ou même 3 heures dans d'autres langues que L'Allemand. Un super Film. Sans bave, sans-Nazis -,, sans-Houston we have a problem -. Juste L'histoire. Comme vu du côté Allemand.
Nar, not as believable as the original series, to much pointless drama. And the captain wasn't believable as was the actor who played the original captain.
Nowhere near as good as the original. Let us make a remake and make loads of money but all you get is a shallow imitation of the original one of the finest WW11 movies.
Brought out as a bit of pro EU propaganda as I recall. Middle class bought it as ever.
Nein nein nein. Zee original pleeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeese.
9 von 10 Details falsch am schlimmsten, die Nr 1 stellt die Torpedos für den Unterwasserschuss ein und nicht der 1 WO und der 1 WO muss schon erstmal das Kdo übernehmen
это что за пародия?😂
Please, legends in portuguese
What a silly remake
Luckily i didn't buy anything of ticket or dvd 😅😅😅
I didn't watch it in a cinema
Traduire sous titrage en français
Nutella Das Boot.
BS of the first degree
as usual the remake is nowhere near as good as the Original
too dark
Das Remake ist Trash, nur das Original von 1981 von Wolfgang Petersen ist "Das Boot"...
Very noisy for a subcrew🥴
The second das boot was a politically correct mess.
What the fuck !!!
Triste copie, l'original est beaucoup mieux 😉
Still exciting
Absolute garbage compared to the original
Was für ein schlechter Film ....