Steely Dan is such precise music - it is flawlessly written, arranged, performed, and produced. The first album 'Can't Buy a Thrill' was loaded with radio friendly but very sophisticated pop. When Aja came out, a lot of us were surprised how mature and refined their sound had become. Black Cow is a perfect example of that, but Peg and Deacon Blues are every bit as impressive.
In this initial class of the semester on mixing, Black Cow is the topic. It will help a novice understand some of what makes Steely Dan recordings sound so dynamic, and some other music that is also older, sound quite flat by comparison. Start at (I think) 14:40. ua-cam.com/video/c7SI86nxI0o/v-deo.html
I have been listening to this song for over 40 years. I know every chord, every break, every melody, every word, and I'm still along for the ride every single time
Personally The Royal Scam is my favourite Steely Dan Album the title track is amazing (Id Request This) , You’ve already Done Kid Charlemagne, and there’s loads of great songs on there. Aja is my second favourite and it’s brilliant The title Track is a little progressive in places but it’s still cool. Great song!
As usual, great analysis Justin. I’m continually impressed at your off the cuff, articulate way of getting into what makes a track work. I’ve been listening to Aja since it came out in 1977. I know it like the back of my hand, it’s deep in my DNA. Aja is the album that every other aspires to be. And now, on the edge of my 55th year, I’m convinced that “Black Cow” is the best song on there.
My first exposure to Steely Dan was in Jazz Band in high school. We played this song and Peg. Went out and bought the album and loved every song on it. Surprisingly, it's not in my digital catalog. I must remedy this soon. I still have the vinyl, though. Maybe I'll just break out the turntable.
This groove was also used completely by Lord Tariq / Peter Gunz for DejaVu ( Uptown Baby ) When it comes to the ‘ Dan , everyone’s got their list of favorites I won’t disagree with any of them probably so I’ll go slightly off the heavily traveled path and recommend King of the World : it’s about living in a post nuclear apocalyptic America - great groove and have the lyrics handy As for Aja - you owe it to yourself to experience the entire recording Calling it a sonic masterpiece is not overstating it.
So many great tunes by Steely Dan. If you're looking for another one with lots of "room, ambiance & space"...may I suggest the epic title track from their album "The Royal Scam".
Hey Justin - loved your thoughts on this one, but as I've said before, you really can't go wrong with Steely Dan. I've seen a few folks recommending I.G.Y., and I'll join in that chorus. It's from Donald Fagen's first solo album - catchy as hell with an infectious groove. One of his best, in my humble opinion. Keep up the great work!
when this came out I went into town and bought the album around 1pm. I thought I would go for a quick drink afterwards, several pubs later and eventually being thrown out at closing time, I still had my album with me and it even survived the taxi ride home as well. I was shocked the following day that I had put such a priceless piece of art in such reckless danger.
Yes, I could hear the rain.Nothing profound to say other than these guys continue to impress me, decades on, with their songwriting abilities. You hit on a couple of my favorite parts.
I love the sound of the rain! The wind through tall trees is another soothing sound, in a large forest it sounds like the ocean. Yes, even when there's no one there to hear it.
@@sevensolaris I think it's a rootbeer float mixed up in a blender ("some kind of frothy drink"). I've been meaning to try one for several years but I wind up eating it before it makes it to the blender!
I was listening to Frank Zappa's RDNZL when this notification came up. Yes, Justin. I stopped Zappa in favor of you. A bigger compliment than you know, chief !! 😎
Black Cow is about a guy, who, in the corner of his eye, sees his high, partied out girlfriend drinking a Black Cow (A cola-Ice cream float). He's not spying on her, but rather she's making such a spectacle of herself that he can't help notice. He say's she goes down to the party district, and changes her name--just like the "pros" = prostitutes--do. He's calling her a wh**e. She goes out and parties, then stumbles home to him, who has to try to deal with it. But he's had enough, and tells her to hit the road. Rudy's is an actual bar in NY. IMO the melody and arrangement compliment the lyrics perfectly. What a delight! As are your reactions, Justin! Thanks for having me along, all the best.
How smoooooth was that?! - Aja is one of my very favourite Steely Dan albums. Perfect for late-night smooth listening after a few drinks!😆 - Absolutely no one else sounded like Steely Dan. They're completely recognisable in an instant. I'd definitely urge you to listen to the whole album. The musicianship is second to none and the whole album has an incredible, chilled vibe.
They didn't do so well on the singles charts here in the UK so didn't get lots of airplay but this album did well and you can hear why. Such a smooth sound, love it.
Oh yeah, really enjoyed this track. I loved the accents throughout the song instrumentally and vocally. The accents, hold and drop really accentuated the groove. I loved the vocal melody in the chorus, really nice. Musically I liked the smooth transitions and instrumentally what's not to like, especially the two solos, really cool. Loved the choice and reaction.
It's funny. I have two reaction channels I follow--yours and one other. On the other channel, these young guys are really getting into Steely Dan, and last night I was thinking they needed to hear Black Cow. I woke up to find it here!
You struck gold here JP! It is our hope you continue to pursue the Dandom music repertoire. Only the second song by Steely Dan? How about "Green Earrings", "King of the World", "FM (No Static at All)", or any other song off Aja for starters. This is definitely hallowed ground for many. Everyone in the Dandom has a different favorite album which says a lot. Mine, well it depends on which day it is. I personally LOVE all of them for separately for different reasons.
This song has been one of my partners since the album was released. I’ll never stop listening to it or finding ways to enjoy it. For you Justin, play it often. It’s unbreakable. Check out the (two) piano/vocal demos ...they’re out there on UA-cam and give you the raw and beautiful harmonies and a very different sounding DF voice.
You made my day today. Work sucks but then the notification comes on my phone that you are doing Black Cow! My day just got a whole lot better. Yes, you MUST do the entire album (pronounced Asia). IMO their best, but every Steely Dandy can make a case for any of their albums as their best. 🎺🎷❤️🔥👍. Have a great weekend young man.
Oh dear, just going through your playlists. Another of my really favourite bands (all the albums are in my collection). I couldn't choose a favourite album but Aja is a great start. The Royal Scam next?
I bought this album on 8-track back before time began. I still play it regularly, it’s part of me now. Probably play it today at work, so good. What’s better is what I learn from you and the other fellow commentators, simply awesome. Aja deserves a full album review when you finish all the songs. Listen to it all from beginning to end. Then do a review... pls. Take care everyone, virus is spiking, be safe please, Peace and Music
I’m new to your channel. I’ll definitely be checking out more. Steely Dan has been my favorite band for the last 30 years. Countdown to Ecstasy is my favorite album of theirs. And Fagen’s The Nightfly is ridiculously good as well.
The lyricism is so damn vivid and specific, I can even see the dark smokiness of the bar where the opening of this song takes place...some cheap dive in Hollywood called Rudy's (it wouldn't surprise me if the place actually existed). It's even telling that the subject of the tune is drinking a Black Cow, which can be either alcoholic or non-, depending on what you're looking for. Maybe if the person was already high, they settled for a sweet, creamy drink with no booze in it, (but it could also be the writer's part of my brain, overthinking it all as usual!)
Niiiiice. I'd been meaning to get back to Steely Dan and check out more of their stuff. So smooth, good feeling. I just need more stuff like this in general.
This whole album is dope! SteelyDan does seem like cruise music as you guys noted in the first reaction, but on repeated listens you discover the subtle musicianship and beauty. I love Steely Dan on evening drives. Check out Deacon Blues. I really love the first album too. All the songs on the first album are superb. While you on the jazz rock fusion exploration, can you react to some more Frank Zappa? Inca roads, Muffin man, cosmic debris, or anything off Zoot Allures or Hot Rats.
Black Cow is easily one of my fave Steely Dan songs. I love their jazzier stuff and even though Walter Becker isn't featured in this track, how can you go wrong when you've got Tom Scott, Joe Sample & Larry Carlton sitting in?!
My god man, don't apologize! You just proved to everyone the kind of mood this song puts you in. It gets you into that cat that ate the canary grin mood of satisfying slow jazz/funk/rock fusion. So much of Steely Dan puts me in that spirit. I ride a recumbent trike (nice and easy going) and this is the music I choose to listen to while riding... it enhances the beauty of the Florida coastline. So many great Steely Dan songs to do. I'm sure I listed them the last time you did them.
@@JustJP It really is. Just on a side note, since I forgot it in my OP, the song is about a masochistic relationship with an unhappily married woman who either cheats a lot OR turns tricks, and how he's had enough.... There are varying accounts on whether or not it was a romantic relationship or he was just a sounding board. Rudy's is a dive bar in Hell's Kitchen. It's famous for having a huge plastic pig outside the door. "They saw your face"--think "walk of shame." Her "book of numbers" is her little telephone book (we old folk used to carry these since we didn't have smart phones) and her "remedies" are just whatever she would take (valium, cocaine, whatever...) to drown out her sorrows from the previous night. Black Cow as a drink refers to a few different things. A root beer float with chocolate ice cream is a black cow (or made with coke). There's an alcoholic version that has kahlua in it, but you get the idea. Greene Street is in Tribecka/Meat Packing district in NYC. It used to be known for 2 things--hookers and clubs, so when she was seen down at Greene Street looking so outrageous, it was either a nod to the club going kids, or to dressing up like a hooker. Take your pick. Today it's posh and you're more likely to see Beyonce there than a hooker, but this was written in the 70s. Let's see... so then she "staggers home to [her] precious one." And then "I'm the one who must make everything right. Talk it out 'til daylight." And that's where the confusion is. Is he doing it because he's a friend who is tired of the one-sided friendship? Or were they lovers and he's tired of that? As someone else put it on another reaction video: "He's sick of it- so tells her to "Drink her big Black Cow" (from Rudy's) and "GetOuttaHere". We all know women like this - screwed up emotional vampires. That's what the song is all about folks." Personally, I've known TOO many women like this, so it kind of adds to my love of the song. It's such a good feeling to tell them "it's over now" and be on your way. As always, enjoy your reactions!
I'm always up for a bit of Steely Dan. Aja is usually said to be their best album but my favourite is Countdown To Ecstasy Also as Mr. Mahone says The Nightfly is well worth checking out. Another tasty video JP!
i haven't listened to this album in a long time. And this is a song that I therefore haven't heard in awhile. So it was nice to hear it. At the time Aja came out there was a faction within music that was mainstreaming jazz/rock/fusion and this song exemplifies that. Its not my favorite song by Steely Dan (Kid Charlemagne or Book of Liars) or from this album (Deacon Blues) but is still a good song. More jazz fusion than funk and soul; but very well done. The one thing about SD that keeps them from being at the top of my listening choices is because they're, to me, a studio band which while smooth; lacks the passion of a live performance. Nice done. A Black Cow when I was a kid was a Root Beer Soda with vanilla ice creme.
Now that's music! Hi Justin. I saw Steely Dan and I had to listen. I hope you and Manny are doing well. I can't comment on the tune because it speaks for itself.
The Dan! Gotta love the Dan. Tricky chord progressions, baroque yet catchy melodies, lyrics that read like movie scripts. Having said that, if it weren't for Fagen's gloriously nasal, nasty, snarky vocals, I probably wouldn't. My tolerance for jazz-funk is limited. Justin, was that a Moscow *Mule* you were sipping? I like a sneaky reference.
Great song from one of the best albums of the twentieth century. They were amazing! Please react to the title tune from this same album, Kid Charlemagne, My Old School
Steely Dan is the shit - so tight; so jazzy; and they grooved HARD. They brought in only the very best session musicians and they didn't sound like anyone else. Love practically everything they ever put out. And yep....Aja is pronounced like Asia. lol
YASSSSSSSSS, JP! SO OUTRAGEOUS! I am a progie fan at heart....Genesis and YES, but love the grooves Steely Dan! Next you gotta do anything from the 1981 Gaucho album!
These classic steely dan records are all great. (The stuff after the comeback, was technicly good, but never realy got me ...) This is one of these songs that ar jazzy and easy th listen at the same time. The Royal Scam, Aja & pretzel logic are my favortis, but like them all...
Dude you could be a DJ for an easy listening station. I enjoy your thoughtful and music savvy reactions. BTW...Aja is my album pick out of the Steely Dan catalogue.
The instrumental section reminded me of English Canterbury bands like Hatfield and the North or National Health, the spacey keyboards and the female background harmonies. It’s not my favorite Steely Dan song, but it’s still nice and smooth.
Funny timing for this upload. I haven't listened to Steely Dan in a while as well but I finally got back into them and listened to this album yesterday. Very strong opener for an album.
If you stay on this album check out Home at Last, which is a hidden gem, it doesn't get the airplay but is as good as anything Steely Dan has ever done.
Justin I can here the rain! Something you rarely here by my house in Phoenix AZ!! Lol. Aja is a classic probably top 100 of all time!! So huge when it came out! Very similar to Boz Scaggs album Silk Degrees released a few months before Aja in 1976. Give the song Peg a listen! Probably the best song off of Aja. Plus react to Lowdown by Box Scaggs! Classic! Totally agree with you about how the space in black cow was beautifully filled! Have you ever heard a Bad song with a sax in it??! I don't think I have!! Funny how your voice did mellow though while you were describing this song!! Funny guy!! Peace to you and yours Justin!! Your biggest fan- Michael😊😊
Steely Dan, always 🔥. Gino Vanelli must have had Steely Dan as his inspiration. Or vice versa :-) Check up Gino’s 6th studio album from 1978 Brother to Brother, very good if you like this genre. Also the trumpeter Maynard Ferguson with his big band can be something for you. Both from Canada. I saw on Twitter that you was asking for metal suggestion. That’s a worm hole to enter as you first need to define Metal and which genre or period you’d like to explore. I dropped some thoughts there. My humble suggestion is that you do a bit of homework of metal first as you will see many “new” viewers in your reaction channel when you add metal band but metal is more divided (or diverse if you want or better pointing in more directions than the spines on a hedgehog 🦔 ) versus prog rock that is very diverse but in comparison still less subgenres. In metal you have the classic metal and heavy metal and then typically five major categories: thrash metal, death metal, black metal, power metal, and the related subgenres of doom and gothic metal. Is Deep Purple, Led Zeppelin and AC/DC the first metal rock or is it Black Sabbath, Judas Priest, Mötley Cruel Iron Maiden, Motörhead, Scorpions, Rainbow, Gillan solo? Slayer, Metallica then? And after that all really heavy metal bands like Sabaton, Satyricon, Gorgoroth, Dissection, Mgla, Draconian, Behemoth, Meleches, Narjahanam just to mention a few. So are you looking for the roots of metal or just metal, whatever metal? en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heavy_metal_music?wprov=sfti1
JustJP cool I was not knowledgeable at all about “other” metal until a few years ago.... just knew the std rock metal like Black Sabbath and Ozzy himself, Iron Maiden, Metallica, Motörhead, Judas Priest etc... Now, on Sundays I’m listening to a metal segment on Digital Revolution Radio where Mother Metal 🤠🤘🏼 is giving a “class” of metal from the world. well, I gave you some bands to dig into...
Lovely reaction and analysis, as usual! I think I've said it before, but I REALLY hope you get around to "Deacon Blues" from this album!!! It is such an emotional song. "Aja" (the entire album) is in a tie with "Close to the Edge" for my favorite album of all time! Every single song is stellar on "Aja". I also wish you would do a "second listen" reaction to the song "Aja". I would really enjoy seeing you react to it on your own. (Not that I didn't enjoy your reaction with your buddy!) ;)
Wake Forest “Demon Deacons” in North Carolina is the reference in this song. It is contrasted with The University of Alabama “Crimson Tide”. One of many East Coast school references in SD’s songs (see also My Old School where William and Mary is referenced)
Reclining in the disco lounge with a sharp suit and a cocktail, waiting for Barry Manilow. I'd only ever heard Reelin' In the Years. Didn't expect this at all.
Good reaction. Love this song. A couple personal perspectives... 1) The horns after the “talk it out til daylight” line, to me, signify the monotony of the discussion, like a musical eye-roll, as this is an ongoing happening. They repeat later, indicating the end of the talk, or the start of another one, leading into another chorus of “I can’t cry anymore...” and 2) “You were high” is putting emphasis on just how messed up this person was, almost in disbelief. “ I saw you at Rudy’s; you were very high. You were HIGH!” I almost imagine it being said a la Chris Walken.
I normally pay very little attention to lyrics, but I recently read someone analyzing these lyrics as referring to the person being talked about in the song having a drug addiction and financing it with prostitution. Thus the person "drowning out your sorrow" sorrow with the "book of numbers" (clients) and "remedies" (drugs), and the line "You should know how all the pros play the game (you change your name). The piece said Rudy's is a real place in a NY neighborhood (when the song came out this was before it was gentrified), and IIRC that Green Street was known for prostitution. The analysis said (and Wikipedia also says) that a black cow is not just a root beer float; there's an alcoholic version that is a fru-fru drink.
Hey man! Just came today. Watched and commented on your Dave Matthews #41 which was great! Just wanted to point out that my name here is after a Steely Dan song Babylon Sister which you should really check out the live version! This was my favorite album, Aja, in '78, I was 20 years old! Yes, I am an OLD white lady and I love all kinds of music! Looking forward to watching more.
Also just as a suggestion anytime you're listening to Dave Matthews Band check out a live video because they are known for their live performances more then radio airplay.
In this initial class of the semester on mixing, Black Cow is the topic. It will help a novice understand some of what makes Steely Dan recordings sound so dynamic, and some other music that is also older, sound quite flat by comparison. Start at (I think) 14:40. ua-cam.com/video/c7SI86nxI0o/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/QfdmEGpQr6s/v-deo.html "Lucretia MacEvil," by Blood Sweat and Tears is one of their hits among many to be excellent music and classifies this group as the pioneers of Jazz/Rock....you are going to like this group if you like Jazz...if not.....well .......sorry...It doesn't change the fact that in 1967 they were the first Rock group to put a full jazz horn section and sell the public on their sound ..way before Steely Dan or Earth Wind and Fire.....critic considered them a Jazz/Rock band.
Aja is a masterwork by Steely Dan..
Easily one of their 2 or 3 best. I put it right there with Time Out of Mind.
Yes, the Aja album is their apogee, but all their albums were great.
Steely Dan is such precise music - it is flawlessly written, arranged, performed, and produced. The first album 'Can't Buy a Thrill' was loaded with radio friendly but very sophisticated pop. When Aja came out, a lot of us were surprised how mature and refined their sound had become. Black Cow is a perfect example of that, but Peg and Deacon Blues are every bit as impressive.
In this initial class of the semester on mixing, Black Cow is the topic. It will help a novice understand some of what makes Steely Dan recordings sound so dynamic, and some other music that is also older, sound quite flat by comparison.
Start at (I think) 14:40.
ua-cam.com/video/c7SI86nxI0o/v-deo.html
I have been listening to this song for over 40 years. I know every chord, every break, every melody, every word, and I'm still along for the ride every single time
Amen!
The outro to "Black Cow" is one of the tastiest damn jams of all time.
Check out Donald Fagen's "I.G.Y." or "New Frontier" from his "The Nightfly" LP.
My first CD ever purchased.
Great Great Album!
Love "New Frontier." Where else can you hear a Tuesday Weld reference.
Agreed. Tom Scott's hauntingly soulful tenor sax solo is nothing short of mesmerizing.
Favorite song on Nightfly is Maxine. Urban nostalgic Jazz. Makes me want to “drive to the coast/and drive right back again “. And, what a sax solo!
More Steely Dan please. The whole of Aja is amazing. Check out Deacon Blues
Any Major Dude Will Tell You. You'll love it.
Absolutely, and Midnight Cruiser
This and Gaucho are my favourite Steely Dan albums. Time Out Of Mind is my favourite song of all time from them.
Same here!!!
Jamel_AKA_Jamal just reacted to that song as well as Bodhisattva (finally).
Personally The Royal Scam is my favourite Steely Dan Album the title track is amazing (Id Request This) , You’ve already Done Kid Charlemagne, and there’s loads of great songs on there. Aja is my second favourite and it’s brilliant The title Track is a little progressive in places but it’s still cool. Great song!
Hands down their best album... I keep posting for someone to review the song "The Royal Scam" but no takers.
Typical Steely Dan song but every time they manage to surprise you. I love them.
Hey no fair, you know any Steely Dan will get an instant like from me, especially from "Aja". There are few bands with this degree of musical quality.
I'm always looking for the insta-like😁
As usual, great analysis Justin. I’m continually impressed at your off the cuff, articulate way of getting into what makes a track work.
I’ve been listening to Aja since it came out in 1977. I know it like the back of my hand, it’s deep in my DNA. Aja is the album that every other aspires to be.
And now, on the edge of my 55th year, I’m convinced that “Black Cow” is the best song on there.
Ty Jim, its definitely a keeper
In my 59th year here, and agree with you 100%. Well said.
Close to perfection..as always...Steely Dan in general👍smooth, sensible,🎺🎸🎹🎧 🎙virtuoso. Walter rest in peace
My first exposure to Steely Dan was in Jazz Band in high school. We played this song and Peg. Went out and bought the album and loved every song on it. Surprisingly, it's not in my digital catalog. I must remedy this soon. I still have the vinyl, though. Maybe I'll just break out the turntable.
This groove was also used completely by Lord Tariq / Peter Gunz for DejaVu ( Uptown Baby )
When it comes to the ‘ Dan , everyone’s got their list of favorites
I won’t disagree with any of them probably so I’ll go slightly off the heavily traveled path and recommend King of the World : it’s about living in a post nuclear apocalyptic America - great groove and have the lyrics handy
As for Aja - you owe it to yourself to experience the entire recording Calling it a sonic masterpiece is not overstating it.
So many great tunes by Steely Dan. If you're looking for another one with lots of "room, ambiance & space"...may I suggest the epic title track from their album "The Royal Scam".
Ty Paul!
And the title track of Pretzel Logic.
Hey Justin - loved your thoughts on this one, but as I've said before, you really can't go wrong with Steely Dan. I've seen a few folks recommending I.G.Y., and I'll join in that chorus. It's from Donald Fagen's first solo album - catchy as hell with an infectious groove. One of his best, in my humble opinion. Keep up the great work!
Yes!
Ty so much Randy! I'll toss it in my bowl!
Steely Dan plays with such precision and a great lyricist with Donald Fagen just fantastic ☝️
I always have to plug in my bass after hearing a Steely Dan song. Steve Dan always have the groove.
Steely Dan Aja.. Musical masterpiece
when this came out I went into town and bought the album around 1pm. I thought I would go for a quick drink afterwards, several pubs later and eventually being thrown out at closing time, I still had my album with me and it even survived the taxi ride home as well. I was shocked the following day that I had put such a priceless piece of art in such reckless danger.
You can never go wrong with Steely Dan. Such varied styles and so tight in every way IMHO
Yes, I could hear the rain.Nothing profound to say other than these guys continue to impress me, decades on, with their songwriting abilities. You hit on a couple of my favorite parts.
A Classic of classic Albums , A jem from start to finish ,one of my favor Albums of all time
You won't ever find a more tastefully produced album, Justin.
This album is one that rises head and shoulders above most others - utter perfection.
I love the sound of the rain! The wind through tall trees is another soothing sound, in a large forest it sounds like the ocean. Yes, even when there's no one there to hear it.
My kind of environment
The great Tom Scott on sax... just so smooth!
Fun fact, Aja is an album frequently used by audiophiles to test their new high end equipment because of how flawlessly it is mixed and mastered.
The production is definitely 👍
Perfect rainy day music.
Very very much so
BTW, a Black Cow is a rootbeer float.
Or...Kahlua and half and half cream.
Ty ty
Root beer float or a coke float.
@@sevensolaris I think it's a rootbeer float mixed up in a blender ("some kind of frothy drink"). I've been meaning to try one for several years but I wind up eating it before it makes it to the blender!
I was listening to Frank Zappa's RDNZL when this notification came up. Yes, Justin. I stopped Zappa in favor of you. A bigger compliment than you know, chief !! 😎
Craig Fazekas
Studio Tan and Sleep Dirt and now, Läther are my favorite Zappa albums.
JustJP react to RDNZL needs to be a thing
Craig Fazekas ... that's some commitment !!
@@thecool9 ... break him in easy with maybe "Village of the Sun" .. or "Uncle Remus" .... or maybe "Blessed Relief" ;)
Haha ty Craig!
Black Cow is about a guy, who, in the corner of his eye, sees his high, partied out girlfriend drinking a Black Cow (A cola-Ice cream float). He's not spying on her, but rather she's making such a spectacle of herself that he can't help notice. He say's she goes down to the party district, and changes her name--just like the "pros" = prostitutes--do. He's calling her a wh**e. She goes out and parties, then stumbles home to him, who has to try to deal with it. But he's had enough, and tells her to hit the road.
Rudy's is an actual bar in NY. IMO the melody and arrangement compliment the lyrics perfectly. What a delight! As are your reactions, Justin! Thanks for having me along, all the best.
How smoooooth was that?! - Aja is one of my very favourite Steely Dan albums. Perfect for late-night smooth listening after a few drinks!😆 - Absolutely no one else sounded like Steely Dan. They're completely recognisable in an instant. I'd definitely urge you to listen to the whole album. The musicianship is second to none and the whole album has an incredible, chilled vibe.
Awesome! You might also try Your Gold Teeth II.
Both of them! The first off "Countdown".
@@mikeloomis687 definitely!
Great choice. The Steely Dan albums do not disappoint.
Yes, do continue with Aja. Every song is a 10.
They didn't do so well on the singles charts here in the UK so didn't get lots of airplay but this album did well and you can hear why. Such a smooth sound, love it.
I don’t always listen to Steely Dan....but when I do, I have a Moscow mule nearby. How relaxing can it get!
The most interesting comment in the world. 😎.
Oh yeah, really enjoyed this track. I loved the accents throughout the song instrumentally and vocally. The accents, hold and drop really accentuated the groove. I loved the vocal melody in the chorus, really nice. Musically I liked the smooth transitions and instrumentally what's not to like, especially the two solos, really cool. Loved the choice and reaction.
It's funny. I have two reaction channels I follow--yours and one other. On the other channel, these young guys are really getting into Steely Dan, and last night I was thinking they needed to hear Black Cow. I woke up to find it here!
Gotta love the timing😄
You struck gold here JP! It is our hope you continue to pursue the Dandom music repertoire. Only the second song by Steely Dan? How about "Green Earrings", "King of the World", "FM (No Static at All)", or any other song off Aja for starters. This is definitely hallowed ground for many. Everyone in the Dandom has a different favorite album which says a lot. Mine, well it depends on which day it is. I personally LOVE all of them for separately for different reasons.
Thanks Mike, I'll definitely get more going with them!
This entire album, @JustJP. It's Steely Dan's Masterpiece.
This song has been one of my partners since the album was released. I’ll never stop listening to it or finding ways to enjoy it.
For you Justin, play it often. It’s unbreakable. Check out the (two) piano/vocal demos ...they’re out there on UA-cam and give you the raw and beautiful harmonies and a very different sounding DF voice.
Ty! I've been listening on repeat 😃
You made my day today. Work sucks but then the notification comes on my phone that you are doing Black Cow! My day just got a whole lot better. Yes, you MUST do the entire album (pronounced Asia). IMO their best, but every Steely Dandy can make a case for any of their albums as their best. 🎺🎷❤️🔥👍. Have a great weekend young man.
Thanks so much Barry, I hope you have an amazing and much better day today😁
Oh dear, just going through your playlists. Another of my really favourite bands (all the albums are in my collection). I couldn't choose a favourite album but Aja is a great start. The Royal Scam next?
I bought this album on 8-track back before time began. I still play it regularly, it’s part of me now. Probably play it today at work, so good.
What’s better is what I learn from you and the other fellow commentators, simply awesome.
Aja deserves a full album review when you finish all the songs. Listen to it all from beginning to end. Then do a review... pls.
Take care everyone, virus is spiking, be safe please,
Peace and Music
I’m new to your channel. I’ll definitely be checking out more. Steely Dan has been my favorite band for the last 30 years. Countdown to Ecstasy is my favorite album of theirs. And Fagen’s The Nightfly is ridiculously good as well.
Ty so much Adam!
The lyricism is so damn vivid and specific, I can even see the dark smokiness of the bar where the opening of this song takes place...some cheap dive in Hollywood called Rudy's (it wouldn't surprise me if the place actually existed). It's even telling that the subject of the tune is drinking a Black Cow, which can be either alcoholic or non-, depending on what you're looking for. Maybe if the person was already high, they settled for a sweet, creamy drink with no booze in it, (but it could also be the writer's part of my brain, overthinking it all as usual!)
Niiiiice. I'd been meaning to get back to Steely Dan and check out more of their stuff. So smooth, good feeling. I just need more stuff like this in general.
This whole album is dope! SteelyDan does seem like cruise music as you guys noted in the first reaction, but on repeated listens you discover the subtle musicianship and beauty. I love Steely Dan on evening drives. Check out Deacon Blues. I really love the first album too. All the songs on the first album are superb.
While you on the jazz rock fusion exploration, can you react to some more Frank Zappa? Inca roads, Muffin man, cosmic debris, or anything off Zoot Allures or Hot Rats.
My favorite part is the little Fender Rhodes solo. Everything else is so perfectly interwoven, in a casual way.
That solo is laid back into last week. Reminds me in some way of Greg Philinganes playing the solo on Ruby Baby.
@@hklinker Donald Fagen's "Snowbound" is another really laid back track! ua-cam.com/video/96GCrZec5u8/v-deo.html
Yes, and a great solo on it by WB, who co-wrote the song.
My "go to" song when checking out audio equipment. Excellent choice today.
Ty squidly!
Black Cow is easily one of my fave Steely Dan songs. I love their jazzier stuff and even though Walter Becker isn't featured in this track, how can you go wrong when you've got Tom Scott, Joe Sample & Larry Carlton sitting in?!
Hey Justin, great as always! Aja is a Fat album, all winners, Aja and Deacon Blues are two more great tracks. Peg also for sure! Keep 'em coming!
Thanks Ray!
My god man, don't apologize! You just proved to everyone the kind of mood this song puts you in. It gets you into that cat that ate the canary grin mood of satisfying slow jazz/funk/rock fusion. So much of Steely Dan puts me in that spirit.
I ride a recumbent trike (nice and easy going) and this is the music I choose to listen to while riding... it enhances the beauty of the Florida coastline.
So many great Steely Dan songs to do. I'm sure I listed them the last time you did them.
Perfect music for a ride down the coast!
@@JustJP It really is.
Just on a side note, since I forgot it in my OP, the song is about a masochistic relationship with an unhappily married woman who either cheats a lot OR turns tricks, and how he's had enough.... There are varying accounts on whether or not it was a romantic relationship or he was just a sounding board.
Rudy's is a dive bar in Hell's Kitchen.
It's famous for having a huge plastic pig outside the door. "They saw your face"--think "walk of shame."
Her "book of numbers" is her little telephone book (we old folk used to carry these since we didn't have smart phones) and her "remedies" are just whatever she would take (valium, cocaine, whatever...) to drown out her sorrows from the previous night.
Black Cow as a drink refers to a few different things. A root beer float with chocolate ice cream is a black cow (or made with coke). There's an alcoholic version that has kahlua in it, but you get the idea.
Greene Street is in Tribecka/Meat Packing district in NYC. It used to be known for 2 things--hookers and clubs, so when she was seen down at Greene Street looking so outrageous, it was either a nod to the club going kids, or to dressing up like a hooker. Take your pick. Today it's posh and you're more likely to see Beyonce there than a hooker, but this was written in the 70s.
Let's see... so then she "staggers home to [her] precious one." And then "I'm the one who must make everything right. Talk it out 'til daylight." And that's where the confusion is. Is he doing it because he's a friend who is tired of the one-sided friendship? Or were they lovers and he's tired of that?
As someone else put it on another reaction video: "He's sick of it- so tells her to "Drink her big Black Cow" (from Rudy's) and "GetOuttaHere". We all know women like this - screwed up emotional vampires. That's what the song is all about folks."
Personally, I've known TOO many women like this, so it kind of adds to my love of the song. It's such a good feeling to tell them "it's over now" and be on your way.
As always, enjoy your reactions!
I'm always up for a bit of Steely Dan. Aja is usually said to be their best album but my favourite is Countdown To Ecstasy Also as Mr. Mahone says The Nightfly is well worth checking out. Another tasty video JP!
Thx Mark!
i haven't listened to this album in a long time. And this is a song that I therefore haven't heard in awhile. So it was nice to hear it. At the time Aja came out there was a faction within music that was mainstreaming jazz/rock/fusion and this song exemplifies that. Its not my favorite song by Steely Dan (Kid Charlemagne or Book of Liars) or from this album (Deacon Blues) but is still a good song. More jazz fusion than funk and soul; but very well done. The one thing about SD that keeps them from being at the top of my listening choices is because they're, to me, a studio band which while smooth; lacks the passion of a live performance. Nice done. A Black Cow when I was a kid was a Root Beer Soda with vanilla ice creme.
I like the sound of rain. Steely Dan are a super groove. Thanks for your reaction.
Ty Mary!
Now that's music! Hi Justin. I saw Steely Dan and I had to listen. I hope you and Manny are doing well. I can't comment on the tune because it speaks for itself.
Thanks Ed!
This was sample by Lord Tariq and Peter Gunz for "uptown baby"
Dude just found this one my favorite Steely Dan song I know you love it love you goose plus
The Dan! Gotta love the Dan. Tricky chord progressions, baroque yet catchy melodies, lyrics that read like movie scripts. Having said that, if it weren't for Fagen's gloriously nasal, nasty, snarky vocals, I probably wouldn't. My tolerance for jazz-funk is limited.
Justin, was that a Moscow *Mule* you were sipping? I like a sneaky reference.
I'd love to say it was, but it was water🙃
a near perfect album
Deacon Blues is my favorite on an album of first rate songs. What more needs to be said.
I’m in the Sarasota area and this is the first sunny day in two weeks. This is a classic musician centric tune.
Haha, all clouds and rain in Orlando, I feel you😃🌧
Solid work from a great band
Great song from one of the best albums of the twentieth century. They were amazing! Please react to the title tune from this same album, Kid Charlemagne, My Old School
Steely Dan is the shit - so tight; so jazzy; and they grooved HARD. They brought in only the very best session musicians and they didn't sound like anyone else. Love practically everything they ever put out. And yep....Aja is pronounced like Asia. lol
YASSSSSSSSS, JP! SO OUTRAGEOUS! I am a progie fan at heart....Genesis and YES, but love the grooves Steely Dan! Next you gotta do anything from the 1981 Gaucho album!
Haha glad you enjoyed it!
These classic steely dan records are all great. (The stuff after the comeback, was technicly good, but never realy got me ...) This is one of these songs that ar jazzy and easy th listen at the same time. The Royal Scam, Aja & pretzel logic are my favortis, but like them all...
Dude you could be a DJ for an
easy listening station. I enjoy
your thoughtful and music savvy
reactions. BTW...Aja is my album pick out of the Steely Dan catalogue.
Haha ty so much!💿
The instrumental section reminded me of English Canterbury bands like Hatfield and the North or National Health, the spacey keyboards and the female background harmonies. It’s not my favorite Steely Dan song, but it’s still nice and smooth.
Perfect album!
Funny timing for this upload. I haven't listened to Steely Dan in a while as well but I finally got back into them and listened to this album yesterday. Very strong opener for an album.
Always a good time for the Dan!😃
Do continue with that album. Its a great album.
If you stay on this album check out Home at Last, which is a hidden gem, it doesn't get the airplay but is as good as anything Steely Dan has ever done.
Justin I can here the rain! Something you rarely here by my house in Phoenix AZ!! Lol. Aja is a classic probably top 100 of all time!! So huge when it came out! Very similar to Boz Scaggs album Silk Degrees released a few months before Aja in 1976. Give the song Peg a listen! Probably the best song off of Aja. Plus react to Lowdown by Box Scaggs! Classic! Totally agree with you about how the space in black cow was beautifully filled! Have you ever heard a Bad song with a sax in it??! I don't think I have!! Funny how your voice did mellow though while you were describing this song!! Funny guy!! Peace to you and yours Justin!! Your biggest fan- Michael😊😊
Haha ty Michael!
Not a bad track on the album, one of my favorites. The title track is the best.
Steely Dan, always 🔥. Gino Vanelli must have had Steely Dan as his inspiration. Or vice versa :-) Check up Gino’s 6th studio album from 1978 Brother to Brother, very good if you like this genre. Also the trumpeter Maynard Ferguson with his big band can be something for you. Both from Canada.
I saw on Twitter that you was asking for metal suggestion. That’s a worm hole to enter as you first need to define Metal and which genre or period you’d like to explore. I dropped some thoughts there. My humble suggestion is that you do a bit of homework of metal first as you will see many “new” viewers in your reaction channel when you add metal band but metal is more divided (or diverse if you want or better pointing in more directions than the spines on a hedgehog 🦔 ) versus prog rock that is very diverse but in comparison still less subgenres. In metal you have the classic metal and heavy metal and then typically five major categories: thrash metal, death metal, black metal, power metal, and the related subgenres of doom and gothic metal.
Is Deep Purple, Led Zeppelin and AC/DC the first metal rock or is it Black Sabbath, Judas Priest, Mötley Cruel Iron Maiden, Motörhead, Scorpions, Rainbow, Gillan solo? Slayer, Metallica then? And after that all really heavy metal bands like Sabaton, Satyricon, Gorgoroth, Dissection, Mgla, Draconian, Behemoth, Meleches, Narjahanam just to mention a few. So are you looking for the roots of metal or just metal, whatever metal?
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heavy_metal_music?wprov=sfti1
Ty Dive! I'm familiar on a surface level with pretty much every type of metal, just wanted to choose a few for deeper dives
JustJP cool I was not knowledgeable at all about “other” metal until a few years ago.... just knew the std rock metal like Black Sabbath and Ozzy himself, Iron Maiden, Metallica, Motörhead, Judas Priest etc... Now, on Sundays I’m listening to a metal segment on Digital Revolution Radio where Mother Metal 🤠🤘🏼 is giving a “class” of metal from the world. well, I gave you some bands to dig into...
Oh yes Brother to Brother from Gino Vannelli. In top 10 of my favorite albums of all time. I'm a drummer...it's silk to your ears (Dutch expression)
Lovely reaction and analysis, as usual!
I think I've said it before, but I REALLY hope you get around to "Deacon Blues" from this album!!! It is such an emotional song. "Aja" (the entire album) is in a tie with "Close to the Edge" for my favorite album of all time!
Every single song is stellar on "Aja".
I also wish you would do a "second listen" reaction to the song "Aja". I would really enjoy seeing you react to it on your own. (Not that I didn't enjoy your reaction with your buddy!)
;)
MissAstorDancer
I could hear Ali shouting “... of all tam...”
@@-davidolivares ????
Wake Forest “Demon Deacons” in North Carolina is the reference in this song. It is contrasted with The University of Alabama “Crimson Tide”. One of many East Coast school references in SD’s songs (see also My Old School where William and Mary is referenced)
Smooth as a cold drink on a hot day!
Now I'm thirsty 🥃
Great reaction as usual....you have to check out AJA, the song....so jazzy and unusual. This was sampled by a rapper.
Again! Nice review covering every facet of the tune!
Ty!
This album is my favorite record of all time.
I saw the continuation band (as I call it since Walter died) in NYC back in 2018 the night they played Aja (pronounced Asia) and it was stellar.
Title track off of the Royal Scam album has some fantastic horns on it.
Reclining in the disco lounge with a sharp suit and a cocktail, waiting for Barry Manilow. I'd only ever heard Reelin' In the Years. Didn't expect this at all.
Good reaction. Love this song. A couple personal perspectives...
1) The horns after the “talk it out til daylight” line, to me, signify the monotony of the discussion, like a musical eye-roll, as this is an ongoing happening. They repeat later, indicating the end of the talk, or the start of another one, leading into another chorus of “I can’t cry anymore...” and 2) “You were high” is putting emphasis on just how messed up this person was, almost in disbelief. “ I saw you at Rudy’s; you were very high. You were HIGH!” I almost imagine it being said a la Chris Walken.
I normally pay very little attention to lyrics, but I recently read someone analyzing these lyrics as referring to the person being talked about in the song having a drug addiction and financing it with prostitution. Thus the person "drowning out your sorrow" sorrow with the "book of numbers" (clients) and "remedies" (drugs), and the line "You should know how all the pros play the game (you change your name). The piece said Rudy's is a real place in a NY neighborhood (when the song came out this was before it was gentrified), and IIRC that Green Street was known for prostitution. The analysis said (and Wikipedia also says) that a black cow is not just a root beer float; there's an alcoholic version that is a fru-fru drink.
Interesting...ty Rich!
Hey man! Just came today. Watched and commented on your Dave Matthews #41 which was great! Just wanted to point out that my name here is after a Steely Dan song Babylon Sister which you should really check out the live version! This was my favorite album, Aja, in '78, I was 20 years old! Yes, I am an OLD white lady and I love all kinds of music! Looking forward to watching more.
Thanks for the suggestion Babylonsis, and for enjoying the channel!
@@JustJP i will get greedy now and say chevk out "Hex Nineteen" also!
Also just as a suggestion anytime you're listening to Dave Matthews Band check out a live video because they are known for their live performances more then radio airplay.
While you're working your way through Crime of the Century and Aqualung, it's definitely worth going through all of Aja too, great record!
I may I may😁
This had the best chorus parts on any SD song in my opinion.
Please add Razor Boy to your list. Great song; very smooth.
The Black Cow changes regionally how you make it in the country... around here it's basically a root beer milkshake
The drummer on this track was from the Lawrence Welk Show... and a one-a, and a two-a...
"Wunnerful wunnerful Guy and-a Rawlna"
If you dig Steve Gadd's drumming on Aja then listen to Billy Cobham's Spectrum and Crosswinds albums.
Title track is a must!!!! Called Asia
In this initial class of the semester on mixing, Black Cow is the topic. It will help a novice understand some of what makes Steely Dan recordings sound so dynamic, and some other music that is also older, sound quite flat by comparison.
Start at (I think) 14:40.
ua-cam.com/video/c7SI86nxI0o/v-deo.html
Nice!
Thanks for the sample of the sample !
Black Cow is A root Beer Float with liquor in it....a drink of the 70's
ua-cam.com/video/QfdmEGpQr6s/v-deo.html "Lucretia MacEvil," by Blood Sweat and Tears is one of their hits among many to be excellent music and classifies this group as the pioneers of Jazz/Rock....you are going to like this group if you like Jazz...if not.....well .......sorry...It doesn't change the fact that in 1967 they were the first Rock group to put a full jazz horn section and sell the public on their sound ..way before Steely Dan or Earth Wind and Fire.....critic considered them a Jazz/Rock band.