*the most shocking thing is that no one from this group debuted tonight but they slayed the hardest:( these girls really deserve to debut TT* *p.s. my haein and natty:(*
since foreigners don't vote natty isn't gonna win if she wasn't top 9 the last few weeks already, it was obvious, and she hasn't that type of beauty that koreans like like tzuyu for example... but she did good and show that she improve her singing!
Tbh this group have it all Lee haein : main vocal Lee si an : variety queen, visual Bae eunyeong: lead vocal Bin ha neul: rapper Natty: main dancer Kim eunseo: lead dancer It's just my opinion and imagination, it's okay if other people have different opinion. I just feel so sad that not even one of them make it into debut members 😭😭😭
For me if this group debut together: 1. HAEIN : MAIN VOCAL, LEADER, OLDEST OF THE GROUP 2. EUNYEONG: LEAD VOCALIST, FACE OF THE GROUP , LEAD RAPPER/ RAPPER (maybe) 3. EUNSUH: LEAD DANCER, VOCALIST 4. SIAN: VISUAL, VOCALIST, CENTER 5. HANEUL: MAIN RAPPER , DANCER, VOCALIST 6. NATTY: MAIN DANCER, VOCALIST, MAKNAE, CENTER
I look up a good Samaritan who gives us a good audio of this idk if this cover or they edit but its helpful atleast we got a clean audio ua-cam.com/video/lSBMEwC02Lk/v-deo.html They deserve more credit
You know this performance is “Magical” when Heechul cried at 2:59. Is it because he knew that their efforts won’t be paid off as none of them were gonna be in the group? Cuz I still think Mnet already knew who they want. Anw the song, the dance, their charms, how the teachers got up and dance with them and all of it really is “something magical” indeed.
@@flyandhigh Now it's basically proved that the manipulate the results, lol. Not only the final but all the competition. It's not being dramatic, it's common sense.
damn you were ahead of time with this theory, this actually is true and is showed cause 8 out of the 9 girls in fromis have been signed with the agency already so had guaranteed spots
And this is the Lee Sian who couldn't even dance in the first Episode. Even though you didn't make it, I'll still support you, OUR BABY GIANT! 😭😭😭 Natty, Eunyeong, Haein, Haneul HWAITING!
Yes. I remember it when the teacher compliment her voice when she sang Catalena. Then she surprise us in STEP which is suprisingly really suit her. I think in STEP stage she shines the most. I wish this MAGICAL team will debut together.
There was probably some sort of dispute with the producers, either that or mnet decided it didn’t fit with fromis so they scrapped it completely. Either way we are missing a gem (I’m also convinced this song was meant to be the theme song for produce 48. Even the demo says “pick me up pick me up” in the original lyrics
Natty's voice is so unique, and distinct! Haein is really talented but she have had it tough for her since pd101 so i hope she debuts. Sad, this group didn't make it to top 9
this group's vocals and choreo is just amazing, look at the audience dancing to it after the dance break and the stage presence tho 😍 this group needs to debut
#Natty !!! if you see our message that we write for you, don’t give up. we’ll always beside you forever. Look !!! many people from many countries love you. keep going. We love you so so so much ♥️♥️♥️
Haein, please start a group with Tasha, Eunyoung, Haneul, Sian, Sia and maybe Nayeon. Natty and Eunseo, please return to JYP! You guys are JYP-grade talents!
I am so upset that Lee Haein didnt make it in the final line-up. This girl has been already rejected before in produce 101. I am so proud of her that she still tried for the 2nd time but still got rejected again. Dear Haein, i hope you could read this comment. Youre a pure talent, we fans hope that you will not give up your dream. Fighting. We are always here for you. ❤❤
In episode 10, i wasn't attracted by this song at all. However, I was so overwhelmed by the performance and i almost cried... And the most ironic thing is that NONE OF THE GIRLS FROM TEAM MAGICAL GOT DEBUTED! Dang it Mnet! It's not just a pity, it's a grave mistake and a heavy loss!
Second time,haein cant debut. I've been a fan of her since 101. She is already 24. I dont know what is she going to do after idol school but i really hope she can solo or form a grp with natty and 4step. Support you forever my Haein❤
NATTY is so beautiful and sexy here! Please let her debut! EDIT: Okay, now i know that NATTY didn't make it a debut. But its never mind! Natty is still young and she still can debut in another better group after some time. Maybe 1 month, 3 months, 1 year, 3 years or longer time. But we can wait patiently, wait for her to grow up, become a grown up woman. And NATTY, if you are reading this comment, i would like to tell you never give up! Just be yourself and we are waiting here for you! FIGHTING NATTY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Natty and Haein very beauty and their voice so soft and sweet. Their ability's so perfect. I always support you, and don't give up. Your ability will prove urself. ❤❤❤
I feel sorry for Natty and Haein. They deserve to debut. But I believe that they deserve better than this idol school group. Hope they dont give up. It'd be great if they can go back to JYP or PD101 ss3.
@@Twinkle-cs8qt That’s because this performance was from the final episode and there was none of the magical girls made it to fromis_9 hence they basically got all disqualified
Natty please don't give up !! ❤️❤️❤️ you did it so well we love you ! ❤️❤️ i hope you will finally debut ❤️ and girl, you are so beautiful, i've never see a girl beautiful like you ❤️💕💕
Came back to realize how these entertainments wasted the talents of these girls! And as a Sian bias, realizing how popular she was during idol school, u can clearly hear all the loud cheers whenever it's her part. She could've retained the popularity if mnet produce 48 give equal screentime! I'm still mad 'cause sian is nowhere to be found in the k-pop industry! With all that visual and skills
Natty😢 You did your best..and I wouldn't be interested in K-pop if I didn't meet you.. Today, you are not the one, but you are already the only one for me☺️ Save your tears and be shine in your own way😊
Eunyeong, Natty, are the two girl I like in this show. Eunyeong is a leader and I like her personality. She cares about others. Natty is a dancing queen. Please keep on fighting🙏🏻🙏🏻I hope that you two can be debut with better groupmates in a better company.
I really love Natty's dance. At 1:46 when she's the center, I can feel the shining power from her movement. I love this team, too. Hope every member will have colorful future.
I miss Natty so much 💔💔😭Natty真的進步很多.......從16到現在一直在突破自己.....但卻一次一次受到挫折....都快沒自信了😭😭😭 Please support Natty more ❤❤❤🙏🙏 She's really good at dance&sing and she loves it very much Wish she can debut one day I will wait that day
I hope all the girls from this group can debut. They are sooo qualified as an idol. Natty, Haein, Eunsuh been through survival show before. I want them to be proud of themselves. inter fan love you. I don't want them to give up.
This is my jam!!! I really love this song!! Also the choreography was well executed. Each member fit perfectly in the song! The stage was awesome! And the fireworks(?) definitely added to the already amazing performance!
because the group is korean, the vote is from koreans and they weren't popular in korea, this views are 60% natty stans that are only international and others who liked the song. Why do you think views on youtube means popularity? You must haven't watched the show as 90% os the people who are hating on the final group.
and in Korea alone, most name that is mentioned in this team is Haein, Sian and Haneul. Haneul is my bias with Tasha but no one here mentioned her while Haneul is mentioned many times at Naver
Andreas Widjaja yes, actually now saying that this girls weren't popular may be a lie, because haein was really popular, even for me was shocking that she didn't debut, and haneul and sian were too, but nothing really big
This is the best song for me out of the three. I even let my kpop friends hear the three performances and they also like this out of the three. It’s so sad how no one from this group debuted 😭 im crying right now
![Idol School [8회]카라 골반댄스 완벽 재현! ′STEP′이시안,신시아,타샤,빈하늘 @학기말고사 170908 EP.8](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/3OO6KZbRcwM/mqdefault.jpg)
![Idol School [8회]카라 골반댄스 완벽 재현! ′STEP′이시안,신시아,타샤,빈하늘 @학기말고사 170908 EP.8](/img/tr.png)
![Idol School [최종회]어머머 넌 피노키오 못말려♥ ′피노키오′ 박지원,이나경,이채영,박소명,백지헌,유지나@최종 데뷔멤버 선발전 170929 EP.11](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/oVnTLMFUHP8/mqdefault.jpg)
![Idol School [최종회]혜성처럼 반짝 하고 나타난 ′환상속의 그대′ 이새롬,이서연,노지선,조유리,송하영,장규리@최종 데뷔멤버 선발전 170929 EP.11](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/jRHilAiU78g/mqdefault.jpg)
![Idol School [6회]반전 드라마! 아름다운 하모니'꿈을 모아서'김나연,신시아,이다희 @학업성취도평가(보컬) 170824 EP.6](/img/n.gif)
You can't deny the charisma of sian
Natty is a real performer
Transgender Thai Natty
@@se-binjang2342 wtf?
@@se-binjang2342 why would she be trangender?
1. NATTY - MAIN DANCER
2. HAEIN - MAIN VOCAL
3. HANEUL - MAIN RAPPER
4. EUNYOUNG - LEADER
5. EUNSUH - LEAD DANCER
6. SIAN - VISUAL
still FIGHTING!
Who is Sian
Prettiest one
For me Haein is the prettiest
I love this team. And I hope they can debut together.
Người Việt à :)))
And now we know that lee haein was the most voted trainee in the final ranking but mnet...
Ikr the truth revealed that Haein should be on Fromis_9 but Msnake rigged her out of the group.😡
this is the only song i actually repeat listen from idol school. just came back again after checking out kiof. proud of natty and haein 🥹
*the most shocking thing is that no one from this group debuted tonight but they slayed the hardest:( these girls really deserve to debut TT*
*p.s. my haein and natty:(*
Queenie CCP what? so who in top 9? poor hae in and natty 😭😭
Ongniel Jaehwan debut ASAP Gyuri steals Haein's spot :'((((((
Haneul too :(
So sad, this group did the best.
since foreigners don't vote natty isn't gonna win if she wasn't top 9 the last few weeks already, it was obvious, and she hasn't that type of beauty that koreans like like tzuyu for example... but she did good and show that she improve her singing!
Tbh this group have it all
Lee haein : main vocal
Lee si an : variety queen, visual
Bae eunyeong: lead vocal
Bin ha neul: rapper
Natty: main dancer
Kim eunseo: lead dancer
It's just my opinion and imagination, it's okay if other people have different opinion. I just feel so sad that not even one of them make it into debut members 😭😭😭
Omg yasss!! All in one package 🙌🏼🙌🏼
Zuellene Casela ikr!!! They slay this performance too
For me if this group debut together:
1. HAEIN : MAIN VOCAL, LEADER, OLDEST OF THE GROUP
2. EUNYEONG: LEAD VOCALIST, FACE OF THE GROUP , LEAD RAPPER/ RAPPER (maybe)
3. EUNSUH: LEAD DANCER, VOCALIST
4. SIAN: VISUAL, VOCALIST, CENTER
5. HANEUL: MAIN RAPPER , DANCER, VOCALIST
6. NATTY: MAIN DANCER, VOCALIST, MAKNAE, CENTER
THIS TEAM READY TO DEBUT
@@rahelalexandra3335 SO true!!!!!!! I miss them.. i hope they'll debut someday.
this group deserves better..
I don’t understand on how the team behind this that made them not officially released the studio version of this song like we need this bop already?
Ikrrr
I look up a good Samaritan who gives us a good audio of this idk if this cover or they edit but its helpful atleast we got a clean audio
ua-cam.com/video/lSBMEwC02Lk/v-deo.html
They deserve more credit
You know this performance is “Magical” when Heechul cried at 2:59. Is it because he knew that their efforts won’t be paid off as none of them were gonna be in the group? Cuz I still think Mnet already knew who they want. Anw the song, the dance, their charms, how the teachers got up and dance with them and all of it really is “something magical” indeed.
lmao he wasnt even crying
Malay mo napuwing
Youre dramatic lol
@@flyandhigh
Now it's basically proved that the manipulate the results, lol. Not only the final but all the competition. It's not being dramatic, it's common sense.
damn you were ahead of time with this theory, this actually is true and is showed cause 8 out of the 9 girls in fromis have been signed with the agency already so had guaranteed spots
And this is the Lee Sian who couldn't even dance in the first Episode. Even though you didn't make it, I'll still support you, OUR BABY GIANT! 😭😭😭 Natty, Eunyeong, Haein, Haneul HWAITING!
John Eres she improves a loooott. Love her so much 😍
Ovi Gayatri Yass! Been rooting for her since first ep, and I'm so happy she improved so much! 😍😍
I hope lee sian join pd101 s3. She really improved a lott. Her voice is more better than member of fromis. And she can dancing welll
Yes. I remember it when the teacher compliment her voice when she sang Catalena. Then she surprise us in STEP which is suprisingly really suit her. I think in STEP stage she shines the most. I wish this MAGICAL team will debut together.
Probably the most improved student on the show but like most of the team here sadly underrated.
Natty 👍👍👍👍👍👍
S. Sunisa I love natty forever ❤️❤️❤️❤️support ❤️❤️❤️❤️
natty & hanuen 💓💓
Lesbian Thai Natty
@@marielgomez6430 If it's not true. Her company is going to sue you soon.
The way this song has been stuck in my head for years but an official audio was never released… ICONIC QUEEN THINGS ONLY
Not only that, but the fact that if you look for "Idol School" on UA-cam Music, two songs come out mixed with a J-POP group's discography lmao
There was probably some sort of dispute with the producers, either that or mnet decided it didn’t fit with fromis so they scrapped it completely. Either way we are missing a gem (I’m also convinced this song was meant to be the theme song for produce 48. Even the demo says “pick me up pick me up” in the original lyrics
i didn't like natty's voice on sixteen but on this stage it's so cute it's my favorite part
her voice is so much more improved :( lol i am going to love her voice so much...
Transgender Thai NATTY
I love natty she's so amazing I really want her to debut in a group 💜💜💜
That’s because she was 14
@@regulardog8728 actually, 13 on sixteen
Natty's voice is so unique, and distinct! Haein is really talented but she have had it tough for her since pd101 so i hope she debuts. Sad, this group didn't make it to top 9
Yeah I'm now wondering about Haein's future.
the girl at 4:10 is haein? she was in p101 too? in don't matter performance group?
+mahsa.19 s Yes, it's her!
I've just watched ep 10. I couldn't beleive all scenes of Natty in ep 10 were cut! Fuck Mnet!
I love this song and this grp so so so much i wanna die you know💔
Nattyyyyy please get her debutttt
Still mad no one from this group debuted and that this song never got released, freaking Mnet 👁️👄👁️
定期的に戻ってきちゃうよね、そしていつ見ても泣ける
Natty slayed the stage 😍😙
Natty ,You are NO.1 in my heart. สู้ต่อไปลูกกกก
this group's vocals and choreo is just amazing, look at the audience dancing to it after the dance break and the stage presence tho 😍 this group needs to debut
Natty's voice is so cute.
Let's debut soon !!!
which one is she?
Natty ・0:38~
・1:43~
・2:12
・2:42
#Natty !!! if you see our message that we write for you, don’t give up. we’ll always beside you forever.
Look !!! many people from many countries love you. keep going.
We love you so so so much ♥️♥️♥️
grace sterz Im so sad too. hope she won’t giving up on her dream and her country 🇹🇭
Yeah you’re right! Natty keep fighting💕💕💕
Meggy Myu ☺️☺️☺️
I support you. I really love her.
I hope she never give up.
Natty is my one pick forever.
deeft L thanwalaokhon did she get eliminated?
none of the girls in this group made it to the top 9 as a final group member.. :'( #brokenheart
Miftah Luthfie im crying
Miftah Luthfie WHAT THE FLOWER?! ARE THEY CRAZY?! Then which group of members debuted?
jiwon disputed the last place with Hae-in, jiwon won, the rest were fine but 2 girls are there just for being pretty lol #3 and #9
Thats kpop. Always 1 or 2 members in the group solely for visuals.
Andres Guerrero 9 who you mean 8?
まじで伝説のステージ
もう一生見られないメンツだろうしこのステージを生で見れた人本当に羨ましい、、、
Came back to appreciate Lee Haein as the Creative Director of Kiss of Life. Had no idea. Also happy she is working with Natty.
Haein, please start a group with Tasha, Eunyoung, Haneul, Sian, Sia and maybe Nayeon.
Natty and Eunseo, please return to JYP! You guys are JYP-grade talents!
Adrian Robles - BEST COMMENT 🔥 Yes go back to JYP girls and patience is the key to success 💪🏻💖
Adrian Robles agree
Adrian Robles jyp might not accept people who left... they should try going to BIGHIT
If i were them i would totally go for BIG HIT, but sadly they only recruit male trainees at the moment
Haein tasha haneul plss. Thoose 3 are so good together
NATTY FIGHTING!!!
✌✌✌✌✌✌✌✌✌✌✌✌✌✌✌✌
i will literally never forgive mnet for not releasing a studio version of this
True :(
THIS IS MASTERPIECE
I can’t agree with you anymore.
@@user-yt8fj3yb5r 4 years still waiting lol
@@crystyles Mnet🤬🤬🤬
@@crystyles I’m still waiting either
I am so upset that Lee Haein didnt make it in the final line-up. This girl has been already rejected before in produce 101. I am so proud of her that she still tried for the 2nd time but still got rejected again.
Dear Haein, i hope you could read this comment. Youre a pure talent, we fans hope that you will not give up your dream. Fighting. We are always here for you. ❤❤
In episode 10, i wasn't attracted by this song at all. However, I was so overwhelmed by the performance and i almost cried...
And the most ironic thing is that NONE OF THE GIRLS FROM TEAM MAGICAL GOT DEBUTED!
Dang it Mnet! It's not just a pity, it's a grave mistake and a heavy loss!
Me too, but is not mnet's falt is voters falt , not allowing international fans to vote is a mistake
Carlos Silva they want the group to appeal to Korea first and foremost
Criss 小樹 - cough - reminds me of the IKYK team from pd101 ( s2 )
Ru L. Yes, that's what they say, but later they will try to bring them to other countries, just as they did with Wanna One
The thing is if you look at Knetz comments , they are mainly who disagree or dont comprehend the result too
Haein, Natty please debut please please please, help them K-fan 😭😭This's the best performance, love all of them
Celine Yuyu knetz standard is.so weird.so we cant make a wish with them
r r yeh finally haein and natty are eliminated 😑
この歌アイドル学校で発表した歌の中でトップ5に入るんですけど！！！
まじで好き
No one is gonna talk about this song being so catchy , its not just me right????
This perform is better that the debut group
r r ikr
Sad but true
Natty 😭
This team should debut with Tasha, Shin Sia and Seo Herin. A wonderful new 9 members girl group. Heain, love you thousand times.
my19002001 AGREE!!!! Those 9 are my favourites 😭😭😭😭
my19002001 Dont forget Kim Nayeon
It's a crime MNET never released an album of these singles like they do with Produce. This song is SO GOOD
Second time,haein cant debut.
I've been a fan of her since 101.
She is already 24.
I dont know what is she going to do after idol school but i really hope she can solo or form a grp with natty and 4step. Support you forever my Haein❤
If chanmi is still trying to be an idol, Haein can do it too. But I fear she'll lose confidence in her self.
Maybe her former company will offer her to rejoin with Suhyun and others or find a good company and will debut as a gg member in 2019 or 2020.
HaeIn can be a Solo singer. Her voice (and visual too) has SNSD's TaeYeon color, but with weaker and softer tone.
NATTY is so beautiful and sexy here! Please let her debut!
EDIT: Okay, now i know that NATTY didn't make it a debut. But its never mind! Natty is still young and she still can debut in another better group after some time. Maybe 1 month, 3 months, 1 year, 3 years or longer time. But we can wait patiently, wait for her to grow up, become a grown up woman.
And NATTY, if you are reading this comment, i would like to tell you never give up! Just be yourself and we are waiting here for you! FIGHTING NATTY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
teh gilvert Spoiler
Nop
you were right she will finally debut in a group this july
Natty and Haein works so hard congrats to them Kiss of Life Stan
I still can't understand why none of them got debuted ???? They are so perfect and talented
Most of people (korean) vote for visual like nakyung..
Natty and Haein very beauty and their voice so soft and sweet. Their ability's so perfect. I always support you, and don't give up. Your ability will prove urself. ❤❤❤
I feel sorry for Natty and Haein. They deserve to debut. But I believe that they deserve better than this idol school group. Hope they dont give up. It'd be great if they can go back to JYP or PD101 ss3.
1:44-1:52 OMG NATTY DID SUCH A GREAT JOB!!!! IT'S SO SAD HOW ALL OF THE GIRLS FROM MAGICAL GOT DISQUALIFIED T_T
Kiki Guanwhyyy
why?
@@Twinkle-cs8qt That’s because this performance was from the final episode and there was none of the magical girls made it to fromis_9 hence they basically got all disqualified
毎回聴く度にこの曲売って欲しいって思う
Natty please don't give up !! ❤️❤️❤️ you did it so well we love you ! ❤️❤️ i hope you will finally debut ❤️ and girl, you are so beautiful, i've never see a girl beautiful like you ❤️💕💕
I hope these girls find a great company quickly and debut soon, they're all so talented (still upset with haein 😭😭)
that guy from the moon I hope Haein will debut with Hyeri in a same company because they are both free agent and longtime friends.
I hope Haein and Suhyun find their way back to each other 😶
Came back to realize how these entertainments wasted the talents of these girls!
And as a Sian bias, realizing how popular she was during idol school, u can clearly hear all the loud cheers whenever it's her part. She could've retained the popularity if mnet produce 48 give equal screentime! I'm still mad 'cause sian is nowhere to be found in the k-pop industry! With all that visual and skills
2021 I still watch this stage "The best stage"
for me this is the best group and performance
visual on point
dance on point
vocals on point
but no one from this group will debut
😭😭😭
Sad... 😢 i wondering when will i got to see the talented one debuted.
Yes, this group is very good. But why surprise? No one has made a debut.
Natty.. 😭😭
Finally they got spotlight nowadays 😭 2023 here 😢
wanted a studio version of this :(((
This really looked like a real debut stage 😢😔
Natty😢
You did your best..and I wouldn't be interested in K-pop if I didn't meet you..
Today, you are not the one, but you are already the only one for me☺️
Save your tears and be shine in your own way😊
watching this makes me wonder what it would be like if haein recruited sian for kiss of life... she would really fit their concept i think
i wish there was official audio of this, or at least the full demo, we were robbed of magical
True :(
natty deserves to debut
beautiful voice Natty😍
もうMagical組でデビューしよう…
脱落するにはもったいなさすぎる…
I like this team sound. Together as one Because so much and amazing.
Natty have so many international fans. Natty keep fighting
I watch this program because of Natty, and this video the highest number of viewer but no one's from this group being a debut member. It's a big false
Loris Tan Wait but Pinocchio is still the most...
TwiceAndBTSshouldDate 3 weeks ago
DahMin-BangTwice is Real but truth is they have the most dislikes
I watched this video because of haein hehehe she is my crush since produce 101
Natty will finally debut
1:45 obsessed with that part omg
also this song is so good i wish they released it :(
the highlight of the song. i kept on repeating it
また見に来てしまった
何度見ても心動かされる
Natty😭
정은 😭😭😭
정은 ✋✋✋✋✌✌✌✌
😭😭😭😭
정은 so cute :D
Eunyeong, Natty, are the two girl I like in this show. Eunyeong is a leader and I like her personality. She cares about others. Natty is a dancing queen. Please keep on fighting🙏🏻🙏🏻I hope that you two can be debut with better groupmates in a better company.
I really love Natty's dance. At 1:46 when she's the center, I can feel the shining power from her movement. I love this team, too. Hope every member will have colorful future.
this is, lowkey, the best of the three songs from that day
and I love the other two songs!
Team Magical The best for me 💕
I love this one the most. I'm kind of dissapointed with the other one- not well executed. And this song sounds like a very good debut song.
I think this song is quite good but it sound familiar with the song Suncatcher in Aikatsu ,a japanese song ,just personal idea😂
I watch aikatsu too!
I watch aikatsu too!
I watch aikatsu too!
Natty😍😍
love you
I miss Natty so much 💔💔😭Natty真的進步很多.......從16到現在一直在突破自己.....但卻一次一次受到挫折....都快沒自信了😭😭😭
Please support Natty more ❤❤❤🙏🙏
She's really good at dance&sing and she loves it very much
Wish she can debut one day I will wait that day
LETS CONTACT OR EMAIL MNET or make petition on twitter for official audio of this
nattyyyy
NOOOO MY HAEIN UNNIEEEE AND NATTYYYYYYY 😭😭😭😭😭
wanna cry so bad....... life is so cruel.....
they're awesome right 😢 I feel so motivated watching these two talented girls. But Knet just don't let them make it, twice!!! 😭😭😭😭😭
Still mad we didn't get a studio version of this 😢 wasting a perfectly good song like that
Natty perfect voice 1:45
Natty fighting!!!
ไม่ได้เดก็ไม่เป็นไร อย่าเพิ่งยอมแพ้นะลูก สู้ต่อไป กำลังใจมีให้หนูเสมอ 😭✌
#Natty #Haein #Eunseo Forever
Haneul is so perfect and professional no one noticed her in ear headphone dropped. CAN'T WAIT FOR YOUR DEBUT HANEUL FIGHTING!
This group looks professional.
The performance is high complete.
Natty her voice's very sweet!!! Good job.
no way
Sen Li Why?
Sen Li เรื่องของมรึงงง
Sen Li เปนรัยมากป่ะมรึง
Natty haein eunsuh don't give up!!
I hope all the girls from this group can debut. They are sooo qualified as an idol. Natty, Haein, Eunsuh been through survival show before. I want them to be proud of themselves. inter fan love you. I don't want them to give up.
Yu Minaya I think I will wait year 2019 for them to debut in gg.
2024?
Me
🙋♂️
This is my jam!!! I really love this song!! Also the choreography was well executed. Each member fit perfectly in the song! The stage was awesome! And the fireworks(?) definitely added to the already amazing performance!
even the teachers like this group performance so much
I Luvv thiis
The Musician Me actually them can debut in one group!!😍😍
thaank u sooooo much for appreciating all the members without leaving one behind
The Musician Me from my opinion, magical is the best wellmade song+choreo from the others..
THE BEST TEAM AND YET NONE OF THEM GOT TO DEBUT :')
thanks a fucking lot mnet
ย้อนมาชม HaeIn & Natty
ตอนนั้นเป็นเพื่อนเด็กฝึกและเพื่อนร่วมกลุ่ม..
(ตอนนี้เป็น PD HaeIn & Natty + 3 members => #KissOfLife 💋 เพิ่งเดบิวท์Gen5? และโปรโมทอย่างต่อเนื่อง..หลังจากผ่านประสบการณ์ดีร้ายมาหลายปี..คงถึงเวลาเปล่งประกายแล้ว💫💫💫💫💫)
このメンツでデビューしてほしい。。
あの時を思い出してしまう😭
I love this Sound&Song. It feel like staying in Galaxy.
สักวันมันต้องเป็นของหนู นัตตี้ ✌✌ อย่าท้อ นะ #idolschool #natty
To Jae หมายความว่ายังไงคับ
To Jae ประกาศผลยังคับ
I'm pmart ประกาศ แล้วจ้า นัตตี้ได้ที่13 ยังไม่ได้เด นะ 😭😭
To Jae เสียใจมาก นี้ร้องไห้เลยอ่ะ😭😭
ศักยภาพเรื่องเต้นก็เยี่ยม เรื่องร้องก็ไม่ได้ด้อย เด็กไทยเก่งกว่าเห็นๆ นัตตี้อย่าท้อเหมือนตอนนั้น
even though this is just a generic EDM song why do I feel so sentimental when I watched and listen to this? there's so much emotion in this :')
This is the most viewed video among the three videos in episode 10. So, why no one debut from this group? WEIRD
sadly in naver this is the lowest
because the group is korean, the vote is from koreans and they weren't popular in korea, this views are 60% natty stans that are only international and others who liked the song. Why do you think views on youtube means popularity? You must haven't watched the show as 90% os the people who are hating on the final group.
and in Korea alone, most name that is mentioned in this team is Haein, Sian and Haneul. Haneul is my bias with Tasha but no one here mentioned her while Haneul is mentioned many times at Naver
Andreas Widjaja yes, actually now saying that this girls weren't popular may be a lie, because haein was really popular, even for me was shocking that she didn't debut, and haneul and sian were too, but nothing really big
I'm thinking there was a foul play. I hope not...
Natty is the BEST! Stay strong Natty~ You deserves more
shut uppp fucking nutty fans everywhere
Sen Li we're not talking shits about you so stop. If you hate her then go, we have our opinions and we respect yours and please do the same.
Keziah Nyca Ybanez leave that poor loser alone. They just can’t accept the fact that Natty has a lot of recognition
Sen Li army's always rude. Immature army everywhere
I'm Hungry And I'm not ashamed! whatttt!!! you are the loser dear always supporting a stupid nuttella lol
วันนี้นัตตี้ทำได้ดีมาก วันนี้ไม่ได้เด วันหน้าต้องได้เด ต้องมีสักวันที่เป็นวันของหนู ขอแค่อย่ายอมแพ้ สู้ต่อไปนะนัตตี้ ❤
Chareearn P อยากให้ jyp ดึงนัตตี้กลับไปจังเลย😭
Teerattchaya Sae-Be จริงค่ะ ถ้าเป็นไปได้อยากให้น้องได้กลับไปjyp 😭
ภาวนาให้ดึงกลับไป jyp
อันนี้ไม่รู้จิงรึป่าวน่ะ เห็นทางแม่นัตตี้ได้ฟอลโล่วค่าย WM ent. แบบเค้าอาจจะเอานัตตี้ไปร่วมวงป่าวแล้วเห็นว่ากำลังจะเดเกริล์กรุ๊ปด้วย ถ้าน้องได้ร่วมเดค่ายนี้จิงจะดีใจมากเพราะสุดท้ายน้องก้อได้เด และขอให้วงน้องปังๆมากๆ ปล.ข่าวอันนี้ไม่แน่ชัดน่ะอาจจะจริงไม่จริงก้อได้
นี่รอบไหนเเล้วคะ พอดีดูเเบบ งงๆ เเต่เชียร์น้องมาก
I admit this was the best performances of ep 10. Its so perfect.
I came wacth this video everyday. Waitting for thay are debut.
I hope magical team debut together and get to the top because they are freaking gorgeous and talented! Mnet....
This stage is very good, it is surprising that this team has no debut 😭
เสตจนี้ดีมากๆ งงว่าทำไมทีมนี้ไม่ได้เดบิว 😔
I love this team💕I love you all, Please don't give up!✌🏻💗 (I want fancam😭😖)
This is the best song for me out of the three. I even let my kpop friends hear the three performances and they also like this out of the three. It’s so sad how no one from this group debuted 😭 im crying right now