Discussion | RAF's new draft Bill proposes excluding foreign nationals from lodging claims

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 2 лют 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 195

  • @lindiwesoko7876
    @lindiwesoko7876 Рік тому +42

    The entitlement and arrogance from this Sibanda guy is disgusting. I applaud the spokesperson, he stood his ground

  • @Mbali5726
    @Mbali5726 Рік тому +58

    I like the RAF spokesperson, SA has really created an entitlement problem

    • @dimodaddly4952
      @dimodaddly4952 Рік тому

      Yes that's the problem, now these foreign nationals they have the audacity to challenge SA in every decision SA makes against them.

    • @mtttttttttttte6205
      @mtttttttttttte6205 Рік тому +4

      U correct an accident is not a right😀😀😀 so the bill will fail.

    • @Bahrain-kv7uk
      @Bahrain-kv7uk Рік тому +5

      @@mtttttttttttte6205those illegal foreign nationals should have insurance like how it’s done in other countries not burden SA …ur too entitled

    • @pearcekanyoka2453
      @pearcekanyoka2453 10 місяців тому

      RAF lost the case with cost

  • @Paperscissor183
    @Paperscissor183 Рік тому +65

    It is quite strange that they want what they don't have in their country.

    • @DuduzileZwane-i4q
      @DuduzileZwane-i4q Рік тому +7

      It’s amazing

    • @Bahrain-kv7uk
      @Bahrain-kv7uk Рік тому +4

      Imagine

    • @keleohilebonyanaleahdithej7486
      @keleohilebonyanaleahdithej7486 Рік тому

      That’s why they flee their countries to come Cruze here … while we don’t enjoy the same in their countries

    • @nthabibotsi9855
      @nthabibotsi9855 Рік тому

      I think most of the Zims came to South Africa, studied the laws of South Africa and now they are attacking the South African government with their own laws. 1st ZEP, 2nd both Zim parents giving birth in South Africa want their children born in SA to be given SA birth certificate, 3rdly now fighting the RAF‼️Their entitlement demands is at another level but yet they failed to fight for those demands in their own country hence they fled to SA. What is the next thing that they are intending to fight for ⁉️

    • @pearcekanyoka2453
      @pearcekanyoka2453 10 місяців тому

      RAF lost the case with cost

  • @Unplugged_Bits
    @Unplugged_Bits Рік тому +13

    On behalf of all South Africans, I vote for this Bill.

  • @nosisantsele4987
    @nosisantsele4987 Рік тому +30

    Foreign nationals entitled to free health care free education free everything sis maan they have no shame

    • @pakisoramatlo5556
      @pakisoramatlo5556 Рік тому

      Not at all. These are the people who claim to be more educated than South Africans

  • @musandasikhwivhilu
    @musandasikhwivhilu Рік тому +48

    All countries compels foreigners entering their country to purchase insurance for the duration. Why should South Africa be an exception?

  • @raymulaudzi6086
    @raymulaudzi6086 Рік тому +3

    Mr Polela handled Sibanda very well and with intellect. Thank you SA for standing up

  • @TheRoshuma
    @TheRoshuma Рік тому +16

    South Africa is too kind. This does not happen anywhere in the world. In Europe you insure yourself before you land. This is too much for a developing country like South Africa.

  • @mecharamorula4660
    @mecharamorula4660 Рік тому +15

    Most South Africans will vote in favour of this bill.

    • @keleohilebonyanaleahdithej7486
      @keleohilebonyanaleahdithej7486 Рік тому

      Yes why not… I don’t think their claims were legitimate… the way they scam! Especially Ghanaians & Nigerians

  • @Mpongz
    @Mpongz Рік тому +29

    Thank RaF make sure that foreign nationals stop this entitlement nonsense

  • @wazha1000
    @wazha1000 Рік тому +18

    Just across the border in Botswana your car pays for insurance etc as a RSA person visiting and its not cheap either. RSA please get your house in order.

  • @zodwagumede5700
    @zodwagumede5700 Рік тому +17

    Why when we as SA making our laws excluding foreigners Zimbabweans are always the ones come out fighting our government for that

    • @keleohilebonyanaleahdithej7486
      @keleohilebonyanaleahdithej7486 Рік тому

      Funny not fighting their own goverment … they came to destroy our country that’s all… you’re a visitor shut up & learn

  • @Siya_mini
    @Siya_mini Рік тому +26

    South Africa can't discuss they problem with out inviting foreigner😂

  • @thembimaseko9600
    @thembimaseko9600 Рік тому +25

    Sibanda is used to lecture South Africans he claims to know what we should do very tired of him.

  • @zodwagumede5700
    @zodwagumede5700 Рік тому +13

    We can not be told by ama foreigners what to do

  • @FREENETWORLD
    @FREENETWORLD Рік тому +11

    Why there where even included?

  • @SA_CrimeWatch
    @SA_CrimeWatch Рік тому +26

    After this we want the department of health to do the same… let foreigners take health insurance wether they use private or public we cant we just cant take care of the entire continent

  • @shangewinter-ko1of
    @shangewinter-ko1of Рік тому +14

    This is what happens when you are too kind to everyone so now they behave like we owe them...

  • @thabangtladi8057
    @thabangtladi8057 Рік тому +26

    what do foreigners know about RAF, free health care, free education etc and when did they started thinking that they deserves all those social services? So why should we even discuss this issues with such poor hungry desperate failed nations??

  • @mmgamersblock4017
    @mmgamersblock4017 Рік тому +23

    this bill is long overdue

  • @cecilajonas6196
    @cecilajonas6196 Рік тому +13

    Long overdue

  • @philgasa6161
    @philgasa6161 Рік тому +17

    Banks are also responsible for the destruction of South Africa

    • @fozia1301
      @fozia1301 Рік тому

      100!

    • @as3r274
      @as3r274 Рік тому

      Blame every and any one but yourself

  • @philgasa6161
    @philgasa6161 Рік тому +18

    Might be challenged? how do you challenge foreign laws while failing to address and challenge laws at home? 😂 These are the so-called most educated Zimbabweans? a joke 🤣🤣🤣

  • @khuluvusokaziprecious7096
    @khuluvusokaziprecious7096 Рік тому +9

    The entitlement from Zimbabweans is sickening... may this bill go through court and pass

  • @siyabonganxumalo4574
    @siyabonganxumalo4574 Рік тому +16

    Foreigners will run us dry.

  • @thembimaseko9600
    @thembimaseko9600 Рік тому +27

    Helen Suzman foundation please for once leave black government alone. Your eyes must focus on Palestine and Israel.

    • @Tinker8531
      @Tinker8531 Рік тому +4

      This has nothing to do with cheap labour so they will be quiet.

    • @WNdaba
      @WNdaba Рік тому

      Helen Suzman is a Jewish foundation and therefore they will push any agenda that makes what they do in Palestine seem legal and moral. Jews were refugees in Palestine and later took the land bit by bit. HSF know Zimbabweans will eventually do the same in SA in 50yrs hence they support them.

  • @noreenm5018
    @noreenm5018 Рік тому +12

    Dr Sibanda, which country you from and does your country have Road Accident? If they do, please let us know if they cover foreign Nationals, Basically I know that is not the fact in your country and go a d start to fight there. Once you win in your own country may be we can listen.
    We've also lived in other country, but we as SAns we don't dictate to other countries, we live, we work or study and be jolly. That how we do things, give SA some respect please.

    • @Bahrain-kv7uk
      @Bahrain-kv7uk Рік тому +1

      He’s from Zimbabwe

    • @nkelemogono4746
      @nkelemogono4746 Рік тому

      Zimbabweans are so entitled...

    • @pakisoramatlo5556
      @pakisoramatlo5556 Рік тому +1

      Amen to that. He think he knows to much about SA. He won't even tell Mnangagwa what to do.

    • @keleohilebonyanaleahdithej7486
      @keleohilebonyanaleahdithej7486 Рік тому

      @@pakisoramatlo5556very true… that’s what I don’t understand about Zimbabweans they like to sound brilliant … and sadly they can’t help themselves… many Zimbabweans says the ones like this Dr Sibanda are Shonas… know it all’s

  • @BrainWashed-ww
    @BrainWashed-ww Рік тому +14

    South Africa has been compromised😂😂😂

  • @JAYLEEvanSLOAN
    @JAYLEEvanSLOAN Рік тому +7

    Do they have RAF in Zimbabwe

    • @pakisoramatlo5556
      @pakisoramatlo5556 Рік тому +2

      I don't think so.

    • @keleohilebonyanaleahdithej7486
      @keleohilebonyanaleahdithej7486 Рік тому +1

      Nope… S Zimbabwean women said she’s cursed to have been born in Zim … she said it’s bad she doesn’t like it… I felt sorry for her sham… but the ones like sibanda are going to make South Africans very angry with their wide opened big mouths

  • @senzelweokuhle8803
    @senzelweokuhle8803 Рік тому +4

    Aaaah this man ❤❤❤is putting this annoying Sibanda in his place 😂😂😂❣️❣️❣️❣️

  • @BrainWashed-ww
    @BrainWashed-ww Рік тому +9

    Beautiful 💗

  • @ThatoPhukuntsi
    @ThatoPhukuntsi Рік тому +5

    Mmmmm we have a hero here 🙌🏻

  • @Samkele_Mbusi
    @Samkele_Mbusi Рік тому +17

    I hope and pray this means Petrol prices will be decreased extensively for us South African motorists

    • @tawandazvakavapano404
      @tawandazvakavapano404 Рік тому

      Yes...I think it must....coz the huge amount was going to idiots foreigners....so once that is stopped then the advantage must be felt by the south Africans....

  • @mokone4758
    @mokone4758 Рік тому +7

    This zimbo guys is really sure that he knows everything about our laws inside out😂😂😂

  • @nkosanangobese6048
    @nkosanangobese6048 Рік тому +6

    But really South Africa is dump serious we citizens are on the receiving end of the stick we pay tax every month...how has this been happening??the foreign nationals have been receiving RAF while most of them have been not paying tax....they receive Sasa grant aswell 😢they should be a insurance that covers for people using the roads like its happening in other countries....

    • @pakisoramatlo5556
      @pakisoramatlo5556 Рік тому

      You can say that again.

    • @keleohilebonyanaleahdithej7486
      @keleohilebonyanaleahdithej7486 Рік тому

      Is it sass’s or asylum… and asylum is way more than sass’s grant… that’s why they won’t leave ever… they are in paradise… I think they eish to swap places … because one said to me one day why don’t you South Africans go to zim and take out mnsngwagwa… I said we have our own

  • @MatlakalaMolefe-i2d
    @MatlakalaMolefe-i2d Рік тому +2

    Thank you mr pHolela

  • @nosisantsele4987
    @nosisantsele4987 Рік тому +7

    SABC is a foreign object

  • @sibusisokavelaphikunene3916
    @sibusisokavelaphikunene3916 Рік тому +13

    Sibanda must request that from Munangagwa

  • @hlayisanibrianmahosi1906
    @hlayisanibrianmahosi1906 Рік тому +8

    They must have travel insurance just like other countries.

    • @keleohilebonyanaleahdithej7486
      @keleohilebonyanaleahdithej7486 Рік тому

      Remember they came in disguise asking the permits for a year … after year it was another year … now they are in courts even won the case… fortunately with what they won … they won’t ever get citizenship…

  • @mecharamorula4660
    @mecharamorula4660 Рік тому +5

    Thank you Mr Pholela. This fool Sibanda must go ask for Raf from Mnangagwa.

    • @pearcekanyoka2453
      @pearcekanyoka2453 10 місяців тому

      RAF lost the case with cost

    • @pearcekanyoka2453
      @pearcekanyoka2453 10 місяців тому

      Mr Pholela & RAF lost the case with cost at HIGH COURT , CONSTITUTION 🥲

  • @leonardmabunda69
    @leonardmabunda69 Рік тому +4

    Sbanda must tell mnangagwa what 2 do not us

  • @Champ_Samaritan
    @Champ_Samaritan Рік тому +11

    They have been stealing that money in the name of foreigners😂

    • @tawandazvakavapano404
      @tawandazvakavapano404 Рік тому +2

      Agree... how do you pay someone without a bank account. Doesn't make sense at all.

    • @Bahrain-kv7uk
      @Bahrain-kv7uk Рік тому

      I know some Zimbabwean guy who wouldn’t stop saying he’s waiting for his payout and he had fraudulent papers so they do open bank accounts

    • @keleohilebonyanaleahdithej7486
      @keleohilebonyanaleahdithej7486 Рік тому

      @@Bahrain-kv7ukI knew they scamming… yooh! How will we progress…

    • @pearcekanyoka2453
      @pearcekanyoka2453 10 місяців тому

      Mr Pholela & RAF lost the case with cost at HIGH COURT , CONSTITUTION 🥲

  • @windy4049
    @windy4049 Рік тому +5

    Tsek to the Dr.

  • @louisaringani3333
    @louisaringani3333 Рік тому +6

    Sibanda s argument is empty and STUPID. He is talking about fuel levy ? So he is ONLY considering those who are driving. What about PEDESTRIANS????. Is time for sibanda to GO. WE ARE DONE WITH FOREIGHNERS. VERY EXCELLENT ANSWER USING WORDS LIKE CAN'T.

    • @pearcekanyoka2453
      @pearcekanyoka2453 10 місяців тому

      Mr Pholela & RAF lost the case with cost at HIGH COURT , CONSTITUTION 🥲

  • @TshephoMorapama
    @TshephoMorapama Рік тому

    Thanks spoke person we will have our money without delay

  • @evertonbouwer4038
    @evertonbouwer4038 Рік тому +3

    The Minister of Entitlement has spoken folks.he knows South Africa better than South Africans.Hail the brilliant Mr.Sibanda.

    • @pakisoramatlo5556
      @pakisoramatlo5556 Рік тому +4

      If you can ask him about Zimbabwe, I am pretty sure there is less that he can say about it, but no, when it is South Africa, he has a lot to tell. Shame on him.

    • @keleohilebonyanaleahdithej7486
      @keleohilebonyanaleahdithej7486 Рік тому +4

      Why can’t he start the same in his country … to compensate them if they get involved in accidents in SA… since he knows it all

    • @pearcekanyoka2453
      @pearcekanyoka2453 10 місяців тому

      Mr Pholela & RAF lost the case with cost at HIGH COURT , CONSTITUTION 🥲

  • @tatendawilson3057
    @tatendawilson3057 Рік тому +4

    If they pay only to foreign nations with bank it means they are pay foreign nationals are legal. To obtain bank account you must have valid permit to work and study. All Raf needs to request Home Affairs ability to verify.

    • @Bbbbee-lolo
      @Bbbbee-lolo Рік тому +3

      You pay your insurance in Canada, Europe and USA so this got nothing do with legal or illegal, same way you are working illegal in SA and manage to win cases in CCMA it's same way you have been claiming

    • @Bahrain-kv7uk
      @Bahrain-kv7uk Рік тому

      Nope we know a lot of your country people…they are able to get fraudulent papers easily and are able to gain and suck the country try very easily

    • @Bahrain-kv7uk
      @Bahrain-kv7uk Рік тому

      *dry

  • @ModjadeepSA
    @ModjadeepSA Рік тому +1

    Stop interviewing foreigners about the affairs of our country

  • @nomasikisiki607
    @nomasikisiki607 Рік тому +1

    Kick them out the bill... its absurd that they've been getting many billions already!

  • @DevenPillay-xf6zy
    @DevenPillay-xf6zy Рік тому +1

    Dr Sibanda much appreciated....I'm pride of you as African and more intelligent than RAF Official infact he saying you want lecture them lol while u giving him a clear picture....thanks again Dr Sibanda u are far from them....

    • @pearcekanyoka2453
      @pearcekanyoka2453 10 місяців тому

      Mr Pholela & RAF lost the case with cost at HIGH COURT , CONSTITUTION 🥲

  • @BeverleyMoses
    @BeverleyMoses 10 місяців тому +1

    CAN I PLS GET THE NO FOR THE CEO OF RAF

  • @nkelemogono4746
    @nkelemogono4746 Рік тому +7

    Can we claim in Zimbabwe? You are so entitled.

  • @dianasekatane6045
    @dianasekatane6045 Рік тому +6

    What's happening when SAns are going to other countries?

    • @cecilajonas6196
      @cecilajonas6196 Рік тому +11

      Travel Insurance is a must have.

    • @nosisantsele4987
      @nosisantsele4987 Рік тому +3

      They fend for themselves or their families bring them home

    • @Bbbbee-lolo
      @Bbbbee-lolo Рік тому +7

      We buy private insurances

    • @dianasekatane6045
      @dianasekatane6045 Рік тому +7

      @Bbb-ml4gb Therefore the same thing must prevail in this country. We aren't going to be a nanny state of the world.

    • @Bahrain-kv7uk
      @Bahrain-kv7uk Рік тому +2

      They pay insurance….meaning you should do the same.

  • @sentsolebatla2512
    @sentsolebatla2512 Рік тому

    We need this kind of leadership, in this hijacked country,. I salute you you sir

  • @katenkosi1389
    @katenkosi1389 Рік тому +1

    How long to take someone to get paid because my brother's son he was involved in the road ecident 2016 till today he doesn't head from the lawyers nothing

  • @chippandenga6722
    @chippandenga6722 Рік тому +5

    As an undocumented foreigner, how do you even grt paid yhst money. How do they receive the funds because I assume they do not have a bank account? 😢 He is basically agreeing that they have been LAZY do the minimum due diligence. Ridiculous😢

    • @sibusisokhumalo3013
      @sibusisokhumalo3013 Рік тому +2

      Do we comment on your country of origin???,do we feel untitled to your countries interests and policies??do we comment on governmental changes and legal amendments????

  • @hlayisanibrianmahosi1906
    @hlayisanibrianmahosi1906 Рік тому +9

    Can the Sibanda guy be declared undesirable immigrant according to immigration act and be deported

  • @thembimaseko9600
    @thembimaseko9600 Рік тому +2

    Our government play big in these countries they should pay until they close down.

  • @Ayanda846
    @Ayanda846 Рік тому +1

    Yes this is not bad at all

  • @paulusemaloke2751
    @paulusemaloke2751 Рік тому +1

    Polela doesn't make sense, how do you pay someone before verifying the documents?

    • @Bahrain-kv7uk
      @Bahrain-kv7uk Рік тому

      They have bank accounts so the bank is at fault of the docs are fraudulent

    • @thembimaseko9600
      @thembimaseko9600 Рік тому

      Fake documents are working in South Africa. They have r d p houses. Fake degrees are working in South Africa. Bogus doctors are working in South Africa. R A F is working for them. Most Spaza shops owners are driving cars on the road ask yourself.

  • @BeverleyMoses
    @BeverleyMoses 10 місяців тому

    You are CORRECT MR SISBANDA

  • @sibusisokhumalo3013
    @sibusisokhumalo3013 Рік тому +2

    one thing i support bout this bill

    • @vjchabane9795
      @vjchabane9795 Рік тому

      Be careful, that’s not the only thing the bill say. It also says that if Sibusiso gets involved in an accident and have his leg amputated, he cannot be paid for those injuries anymore.

  • @richardmonareng4315
    @richardmonareng4315 Рік тому +1

    The foreigners rule Sou Africa a lot no road eccident Fund claim for foreigners like other Countries do so.

  • @mpucukonxumalo7802
    @mpucukonxumalo7802 Рік тому

    This is unbelievable.

  • @phetosindi5008
    @phetosindi5008 Рік тому

    Undocumented ? 2:20

  • @vjchabane9795
    @vjchabane9795 Рік тому

    I agree with Dr. Sibanda. I agree with RAF too., but will poor foreigners afford insurance

  • @11Kumz
    @11Kumz Рік тому +1

    It gets paid into the lawyers, account?

  • @FREENETWORLD
    @FREENETWORLD Рік тому +3

    Road African accident Fund 😢

  • @vjchabane9795
    @vjchabane9795 Рік тому

    Polela is at RAF. Hebana

  • @sivuyilehendrickralarala4409
    @sivuyilehendrickralarala4409 Рік тому +2

    Yep .. .. We truly an Oprah state.. ..

  • @keleohilebonyanaleahdithej7486

    I love his accent

  • @stanleynkosikamthembu168
    @stanleynkosikamthembu168 Рік тому

    The authorities has made a joke of our people and our country. This has to be changed, with vigour without mercy.

  • @kenosimodiakgotla5844
    @kenosimodiakgotla5844 Рік тому

    South African Govt is really reactive, leaders are old and don't have an idea how to govern. Imagine billions

  • @keleohilebonyanaleahdithej7486

    Don’t just pay… nothing will happen … it will take years like senso meyiwas case

    • @pearcekanyoka2453
      @pearcekanyoka2453 10 місяців тому

      Mr Pholela & RAF lost the case with cost at HIGH COURT , CONSTITUTION 🥲

  • @Alexandrelaurent1
    @Alexandrelaurent1 Рік тому +3

    This bill will probably not pass because of the legality of it , if you contribute towards something and there's payment or coverage that is meant for you incase of an accident I think fair play should come in this context and the person or whatever the system is supposed to cover must come in play , yes South Africans feel like they are carrying the entire continent but in this instance the individual actually contributes towards the cause thus deserves his fair share of the pie , I didn't know that you could claim outside of your insurance provider but in this case the state is actually at fault why is a public institution dealing with issues concerning insurance , first how do you know how much an individual has contributed regardless of their status in the country insurance should be left to private entities and fuel levies should be used to maintain roads not be kept in fund to pay people South Africans or foreigners , now we have an issue that just stares up hate while it a faulty system .

    • @pearcekanyoka2453
      @pearcekanyoka2453 Рік тому +2

      Correct & very excellent, l give you a big up, Minister is using force and discrimination 😢😢😢

    • @bhekimathabela6300
      @bhekimathabela6300 Рік тому

      I go to England 🇬🇧 I buy food, petrol ⛽️, pay rent etc does that mean I qualify for their road accident insurance policy 😅 😳 😐 😬 🤔, it's like you doing RSA a favor by coming then you'll tell them how they should do things and cover you by force. It's unfair and a wrong mentality 😢

    • @pearcekanyoka2453
      @pearcekanyoka2453 10 місяців тому

      Mr Pholela & RAF lost the case with cost at HIGH COURT , CONSTITUTION 🥲

    • @pearcekanyoka2453
      @pearcekanyoka2453 10 місяців тому

      @@bhekimathabela6300 Mr Pholela & RAF lost the case with cost at HIGH COURT , CONSTITUTION 🥲

  • @thembimaseko9600
    @thembimaseko9600 Рік тому

    A N C and E F F will rule come 2024

    • @RicksPhatPharm-vw2lb
      @RicksPhatPharm-vw2lb Рік тому

      Black South Africa will regret this immensely... If you not prepared to back the IFP or VF this election you going to find that whites will no longer comply. You never won any war, arms we downed and Julius Malemas threats and arrogance doesn't scare whites on the contrary if forces whites to act! Someone better stop lying to black youth and explain to them what will happen. Not one minority will accept this, this election will not be overlooked many are ready and ethno states is the only way forward now

    • @wahwah7701
      @wahwah7701 Рік тому

      @amandamalunga716 Who's gonna stop them?

  • @JuniorTlake-uv5ij
    @JuniorTlake-uv5ij 6 місяців тому

    No action just big mouth

  • @tshabzin2709
    @tshabzin2709 Рік тому

    Sibanda go make those demands in Zimbabwe mahn 🚮

    • @pearcekanyoka2453
      @pearcekanyoka2453 10 місяців тому

      Mr Pholela & RAF lost the case with cost at HIGH COURT , CONSTITUTION 🥲

  • @matome7301
    @matome7301 Рік тому

    Spokesperson is misleading himself by saying they don't cover the driver.

    • @thembimaseko9600
      @thembimaseko9600 Рік тому

      Whatever you must go and fight in your country.

    • @pearcekanyoka2453
      @pearcekanyoka2453 10 місяців тому

      Mr Pholela & RAF lost the case with cost at HIGH COURT , CONSTITUTION 🥲

  • @jeremiahmasole3170
    @jeremiahmasole3170 Рік тому

    Haai haaai haaai

  • @RoselineMokgwabone
    @RoselineMokgwabone Рік тому

    SA e tlwaetswe sleg.

  • @GwabiniMfwethu
    @GwabiniMfwethu Рік тому +5

    So we’re paying high levies for people SA doesn’t even know they’re here?🥲

    • @pearcekanyoka2453
      @pearcekanyoka2453 10 місяців тому

      Mr Pholela & RAF lost the case with cost at HIGH COURT , CONSTITUTION 🥲