Now watching A.Mi.Go MV all I can think about is Minho complaining about having to run through the crowd in broad daylight as they all looked at him like he was crazy while the rest slept in the van in A/C. Good times.
SHINee is a group of vocals for sure, but Jonghyun is SHINee’s main MAIN Vocals. He is also SHINee’s Center in all ways. Stands in the center in interviews, center in many formations and choreo and the like. And he still is. 🥰
With the choreo, because of Jonghyun's height is more short than others (oops, but is true 😂🙏). Fun fact: Jonghyun is one of the best singer in kpop! So I think he's in the middle too when he sing the climax part in SHINee's song. Basically the center for choreo is Taemin. Can't wait to see next long journey SHINee's reaction!! ❤❤
Jonghyun’s voice was one of a kind for sure. It is still my favorite voice in Kpop. He was able to put so much emotion into each word he sung, that you could really feel it even if you couldn’t understand the language. His falsettos were just beautiful and he could belt like no one else. I miss hearing his voice. Thanks for this deep dive into SHINee. I can’t wait to see more reactions!
I'm glad you are learning about Jonghyun because he was early on the Main Vocalist with Onew. That is why w/o him now the other 4 members have really just all strengthened vocally to bring Jonghyun's essence within their current music. SHINee will always be 5 members. They always incorporate Jonghyun in all that they do. He is their inspiration ie. "The Feeling". If you follow their journey including their live stages you'll witness how each member started to stand out on their own and have their own individual colors. JOnghyun is my bias in this group, it is because he is the most amazing artist...a legend in the Kpop world for sure.
Jonghyun voice is actually very distinct you can pick that voice ...but as you go in this journey you guys able you pick everyone's voice just by listening it...all the members have sub different vocal tone....
I loooove when people go to SHINee's early discography, discover and be blown away by the one in a million Kim Jonghyun 😎. As his new fan i can guarantee you will never escape his charm. And i really appreciate u guys with ur reaction, many reactors out there just act on pity towards him, or don't care at all. Also you're right about him styling his vocal, you will never hear the same in 2 different songs that he sings, he's so expressive thru his voice and he'll adjust his voice to which way he thinks will fit in the song and ofc it works incredibly perfect. Sorry i rant a lot, once talking about Jjong i'll never stop 😂. Anw tysm your reaction made my day 🤗 looking forward to the next video
Watching your reaction to the three earlier Shinee releases make me emotional. Especially so when you appreciate Jonghyun. He's my ult bias since their debut, and he still is and will always be. I've not found any other singer that can touch my feels so deep the way he did. Wait till you hear his solo songs like Heya (Ysi Fuera Ella), Diphylleia Grayi, End of the Day, Deja Boo, Crazy (Guilty Pleasure), Hellelujah, Mono-Drama and so much more. I don't have to understand the lyrics. His emotive delivery is enough to hit the feels. Anyway, the reason why he has the MJ flair is coz MJ is one of his biggest inspiration. Before Taemin got the Korean MJ tag, fans gave that nickname to Jonghyun. He sings like the King of Pop, while Taemin dance to the King's likeness. It is funny when you both try to imitate Jonghyun's first few lines from Love Like Oxygen, coz the members did make fun of him for that. It reminded me of Onew imitating him on a variety show. It's so hilarious! I look forward to your Shinee journey.
Key is actually SHINee’s Lead Dancer, Lead Rapper, and Vocals upon debut. Minho is Main Rapper. Both of them rap in SHINee songs, though ofc later they don’t if not necessary to the song.
Oh boy amigo.. what a time in shinees history haha Also, yes. Jonghyuns passing was a devastating emotional shock to everyone, and people also have to remember that logistically it was also hard for shinee to continue because he is their main vocal and has the most lines and ad libs in shinees songs. His voice is a main part of shinees sound pre-2018. Fortunately all shinee members can hold their own in all aspects. Key also mentioned this in an I live alone with taeyeon.
I am so happy to see you guys do this! I was so lucky that I was there to witness they debut and their pre debut. When it comes to SHINee, I TRUST. I am abit younger than Taemin, so its like we grow up all together. They always delivered no matter what. They worked so hard, they are passionate, they are well mannered, everyone respect them even just for they are and they never stop giving us more. 5HINee 💎💎💎💎💎
So excited to see you guys officially start your Shinee journey, especially starting from the very beginning. You really get to see their own musical journey this way, from the different styles and genres to the improvement in skills of each of the members. Believe it or not, they all go through a massive improvement, whether that be in vocals, dance, or even rap. We always like to say that Shinee doesn’t have distinct positions, because they’re a group made of 5 vocalists, 5 dancers, 5 rappers, and 5 visuals.
SHINee yesss! Subscribing so I don't miss anything. And so happy you finally get to meet Jonghyun. Excited for you to check out more and hopefully you get to react to their live stages too.
You ain't seen nothing yet as far as Jonghyun goes :-). (And the other members too; they're all crazy talented.) Jjong has an extraordinary range of what he can do with his voice and you've barely begun to scratch the surface. (His solo work is very different from his work with Shinee, btw, and it's extraordinary and very well-worth exploring.) As others have said, Jonghyun deliberately chose an MJ-inspired delivery for Love Like Oxygen (Onew liked to tease him about it :-)), and you can go to his solo work "Moon" for gorgeous Prince vibes. I found Jonghyun first, a year and a half ago, and Shinee through him, and the reason I'm a Shawol isn't because of Shinee's music and talent (as much as I love and respect that), it's because of the class and the character of the group, and because of how much they clearly loved and continue to love and honor Jonghyun.
SHINee is the most famous and loved debut song of any group. This is why it's almost a requirement for newer groups to cover it. Also, this MV started a storyline that continued through 2021 with SHINee's song "Marry You". This is the first installment where they are attracted to a girl and compete to try to court her. "Lovesick", which debuted in 2015, continues the story reaffirming their love (btwn the girl and one of the guys who she chose) after being together for years and how happy her man is. It's like a love letter. "Marry You" is the guy actually proposing to his girl. Taemin joked and said the next installment was going to involve children. Taemin was only 14 when "Replay" debuted so he couldn't actually sing due to immature vocal cords. As you now know, Jonghyun was THE vocal powerhouse of Kpop, and (still is IMHO) that was just the very small tip of the iceberg. He was their main vocal and his loss left a huge void within their brotherhood. When the guys decided to continue on and honor Jonghyun's dream of SHINee forever, they knew they would have to step it up to fill in at least some of that void, but it would never be completely healed. Jonghyun, along with Onew helped to teach Taemin how to sing. So even today, when Taemin sings in his falsetto during a ballad, you can hear whispers of Jonghyun's voice -- especially when he sang "Already" (a gift from Jonghyun) with Jonghyun's backing vocals. It was sometimes hard to distinguish between them. When and if you decide to react to some live stages (which are the best to react to for SHINee) you will see how insane Jonghyun can get with the adlibs, especially with "Sherlock": ua-cam.com/video/M4pINahBoRY/v-deo.html ; "Stranger": ua-cam.com/video/J-cQSFe4JA0/v-deo.html ; "Excuse Me Miss": ua-cam.com/video/T0MAL3hVwoE/v-deo.html and "Ring, Ding, Dong" + "Lucifer": ua-cam.com/video/mtFK7FxKdLs/v-deo.html ; of course then there's "Romeo & Juliet" where Jonghyun shows us why he was considered the King of Adlibs: ua-cam.com/video/I3Jrvf-O6w4/v-deo.html SHINee came out of the gate with phenomenal footwork. Taemin was already a master at it, but the others followed suit. SHINee is the group that uses their legs, feet, and arms the most with very intricate movements. Other groups use mostly the torso and hips to drive their choreos with very large arm movements. When you look at these very old MVs, you can instantly think, well that choreo isn't that difficult. However, it was back then. The footwork along with the extreme synchronicity was totally new for Kpop groups, that's why IU stated that whenever SHINee was having a dry-run rehearsal, she and the other groups would run to go see it because it was so unique and new, especially coupled with live singing. IU further stated that one of the reasons why SHINee was special was because of that. ("IU's Palette" with SHINee as guests) BTW: SHINee also has the most beautiful harmonies in Kpop. You'll hear them when you get to "Lucifer". Many have said they could be an acapella group. AMIGO: The title of the song is actually is an Korean acronym for A.MI.Go = "Your heart hurts when you fall in love with a beauty". Just three weeks ago SHINee were guests on MMTG and it was hilarious because in the first episode, Jaejae, the host, decided that AMIGO needed to be updated. During the second episode they went to a JYP studio and Jaejae provided them with new lyrics, and they recorded the song.....OMG, seriously it really was hilarious. Episode 1: ua-cam.com/video/3aBvbIftZH4/v-deo.html Episode 2: ua-cam.com/video/U3STSw1RLrk/v-deo.html
Hi, i am back. Good reaction, ty. To my surprise i liked Replay. R&B vibes. It was sweet and had good harmonies. New Taemin biased. Love his dancing. I will check out ur other reactions to Shinee. Hopefully I will find more songs to love. =0} Hugs. -NY USA 2019 Army💟 SHINee fun facts : They were the first ones to start doing dance practice videos :) Aileen DeMong said 1/13/22 SHINee was SM's experimental group. When they debuted they didn't even get any promos beforehand like what usually happens with new groups, just a few days before their television debut there was a news story about this new group with the song called Replay from SM and then they had their debut on Inkigayo (very unheard of) a few days later and then they grew from there. They are known as the Idol of Idol's and a lot of groups, even their seniors in the industry, look up to them and love them. And despite them debuting in 2008 they were all 15-18 years old at the time and they often teased other idol groups about that as they were often younger than them but had more seniority in the industry lol. Charitha Venkatesh.B said on 2/20/2022 "Marry you" is the latest one of the 3-part sequel that SHINee is doing since debut... The sequence goes like 💙"Replay" (liking & confessing to an older girl - debut 2008) 💙"Love sick" (how their relationship is still going on - 2015, the dance choreo for love sick mirrors choreo of replay and at one time during the performance when the lyrics say 'how long has it been' they show 7 in their fingers indicating the years from 2008 to 2015, meaning they have been in love for the whole time & in relationship with the same girl) 💙"Marry you" (proposing to that girl - 2021) This is the whole relationship arc, they joked that the next song in a few years might be either about their child or about a divorce 😆😆🤣 The lyrics also show the continuation here, 💕Replay: "You are too pretty" 💕Love sick: "You were too pretty, do you know" 💕Marry you: "You are still too pretty, u take my breath away everytime I see you" 💕Replay: "You are everything to my life" 💕Love sick: "You are still everything to my life" 💕Marry you: "Still everything to my life" Sakura said on 4/16/23 Thanks for your reaction 😊 For SHINee, here a little warning so you know: "Replay", "Love", "Diamond sky" and "From now on" from their concert of the same title "From now on", are very emotional (first concert after). There are also others lives performances of their others concerts that are very moving but I think the most difficult one to watch for the first time remains "Y se fuera ella" by Jonghyun (There is a version with Eng Sub). And even if someone request it, "Our page" is a mv to watch later in your journey (song written by the members for Jonghyun, the lyrics are a must). I prefer to warn in case, at least you can prepare a little mentally and bring some tissues 😕 Nice reaction(Love Like Oxygen), ty. Like this one too. Catchy. They slayed. Good vocals and harmonies. Some of the hair styles were cute. =0p Nice reaction(Amigo), ty. This one is not bad. More modern to me. I like the others more.
Just watched almost all of your series- shiny discovery of SHINee, and it warmed my heart to see other people enjoy and love SHINee. I went back specifically to this one and hoping that you’ll be able to react to more LIVE PERFORMANCES/CONCERTS of SHINee. Since you both liked Replay, their live performance SHINee World IV SWIV in Seoul was not only phenomenal but so emotional. Thank you!
1:45 “Everybody just looks like Bruce Lee at some point” okay this should not have made me laugh as hard as it did But like that’s so true, the hairstyles of the late 2000’s were very questionable at best. Shinee goes through so many unique hair transformations, especially around Lucifer/Sherlock era.
Can't wait for your Lucifer reaction ❤ My teenage self tried to learn the Lucifer choreography with my sister and suffered miserably 😂😂😂 Good old times 🤗💃🏻
I never made the connection but omg you're totally right - LLO is very reminiscent of Mandy Moore's first single "Candy"! Although by LLO's release, MM's music had already moved far away from its bubblegum pop debut and she was also several years into a decent acting career. LLO is actually a remake; the original version, written by a Danish team and with a different title, was sung by Martin/Saveus (who I believe was the first Danish X Factor winner). I've never listenened to his music but read that apparently his singing style is very similar to Michael Jackson and Justin Timberlake, which could explain Jonghyun's MJ-esque singing in that song. Martin has since written several kpop singles for SM, Shinee's label. Fun fact: Onew has hilariously poked fun at Jonghyun's singing in LLO later on in a game show and eventually Key Minho and Taemin joined in on the teasing too... during a LIVE CONCERT, much to the fans delight. 😂
OMG I'm so excited for your Shinee journey 😅❤ After like few MVs, reactors usually become Full time Shawols and rant about them nonstop ❤ Lots of surprises are waiting for you guys 💃🏻💃🏻💃🏻 Reply means noona (older woman in Korean language) you're so pretty and I want to see you again and again (reply). At the time I was little bit older than them, their debut song strategically targated older woman 😂 It worked like a charm and I was whipped immediately 🤣😂 Going strong fan for 15 years ❤
I hope you can watch or react to this 2015 live performance of Love Like Oxygen ua-cam.com/video/qeESEkNHVdQ/v-deo.html They did harmonies and everything live for this one because they said the original backtrack doesn't sound like them anymore. Edit: You don't have to do a video on it. I don't know how kpop copywrite stuff works on tv broadcasts these days.
SM buys a lot of songs from western song writers. Kesha, Bebe Rexha, Bruno Mars, Corbin Blu, Alejandro Sanz, 112 Cupid just to name a few off the top of my head.
At debut Onew was 18 years old. Jonghyun had just turned 18. Key and Minho were 16 and Taemin was 14 years old going on 15. If you have any questions feel free to ask
Now watching A.Mi.Go MV all I can think about is Minho complaining about having to run through the crowd in broad daylight as they all looked at him like he was crazy while the rest slept in the van in A/C. Good times.
SHINee is a group of vocals for sure, but Jonghyun is SHINee’s main MAIN Vocals. He is also SHINee’s Center in all ways. Stands in the center in interviews, center in many formations and choreo and the like. And he still is. 🥰
welllll said. he's the BASE of SHINee afterall
@ TrangNguyen-mp9it 😄
With the choreo, because of Jonghyun's height is more short than others (oops, but is true 😂🙏). Fun fact: Jonghyun is one of the best singer in kpop! So I think he's in the middle too when he sing the climax part in SHINee's song.
Basically the center for choreo is Taemin.
Can't wait to see next long journey SHINee's reaction!! ❤❤
yesss 🔥🔥
Jonghyun’s voice was one of a kind for sure. It is still my favorite voice in Kpop. He was able to put so much emotion into each word he sung, that you could really feel it even if you couldn’t understand the language. His falsettos were just beautiful and he could belt like no one else. I miss hearing his voice. Thanks for this deep dive into SHINee. I can’t wait to see more reactions!
I'm glad you are learning about Jonghyun because he was early on the Main Vocalist with Onew. That is why w/o him now the other 4 members have really just all strengthened vocally to bring Jonghyun's essence within their current music. SHINee will always be 5 members. They always incorporate Jonghyun in all that they do. He is their inspiration ie. "The Feeling". If you follow their journey including their live stages you'll witness how each member started to stand out on their own and have their own individual colors. JOnghyun is my bias in this group, it is because he is the most amazing artist...a legend in the Kpop world for sure.
Jonghyun voice is actually very distinct you can pick that voice ...but as you go in this journey you guys able you pick everyone's voice just by listening it...all the members have sub different vocal tone....
I loooove when people go to SHINee's early discography, discover and be blown away by the one in a million Kim Jonghyun 😎. As his new fan i can guarantee you will never escape his charm. And i really appreciate u guys with ur reaction, many reactors out there just act on pity towards him, or don't care at all. Also you're right about him styling his vocal, you will never hear the same in 2 different songs that he sings, he's so expressive thru his voice and he'll adjust his voice to which way he thinks will fit in the song and ofc it works incredibly perfect. Sorry i rant a lot, once talking about Jjong i'll never stop 😂. Anw tysm your reaction made my day 🤗 looking forward to the next video
Jonghyun is the most amazing vocalist!! Replay is the best debut song ever 🎉
Watching your reaction to the three earlier Shinee releases make me emotional. Especially so when you appreciate Jonghyun. He's my ult bias since their debut, and he still is and will always be. I've not found any other singer that can touch my feels so deep the way he did. Wait till you hear his solo songs like Heya (Ysi Fuera Ella), Diphylleia Grayi, End of the Day, Deja Boo, Crazy (Guilty Pleasure), Hellelujah, Mono-Drama and so much more. I don't have to understand the lyrics. His emotive delivery is enough to hit the feels. Anyway, the reason why he has the MJ flair is coz MJ is one of his biggest inspiration. Before Taemin got the Korean MJ tag, fans gave that nickname to Jonghyun. He sings like the King of Pop, while Taemin dance to the King's likeness. It is funny when you both try to imitate Jonghyun's first few lines from Love Like Oxygen, coz the members did make fun of him for that. It reminded me of Onew imitating him on a variety show. It's so hilarious! I look forward to your Shinee journey.
He was definitely a huge standout and it's our first time hearing him!! 🔥
vocal king for sure.
Key is actually SHINee’s Lead Dancer, Lead Rapper, and Vocals upon debut. Minho is Main Rapper. Both of them rap in SHINee songs, though ofc later they don’t if not necessary to the song.
Legendary group
Oh boy amigo.. what a time in shinees history haha
Also, yes. Jonghyuns passing was a devastating emotional shock to everyone, and people also have to remember that logistically it was also hard for shinee to continue because he is their main vocal and has the most lines and ad libs in shinees songs. His voice is a main part of shinees sound pre-2018. Fortunately all shinee members can hold their own in all aspects. Key also mentioned this in an I live alone with taeyeon.
Yeah you have to watch SHINee Live Concert Ring Ding Dong + Lucifer at SWC V, you’ll see the incredible Jonghyun ❤
Heard “journey with SHINee”
Me: Subscribe
Okay let’s go!
*Love like oxygen is ART*
I am so happy to see you guys do this! I was so lucky that I was there to witness they debut and their pre debut. When it comes to SHINee, I TRUST. I am abit younger than Taemin, so its like we grow up all together. They always delivered no matter what. They worked so hard, they are passionate, they are well mannered, everyone respect them even just for they are and they never stop giving us more. 5HINee 💎💎💎💎💎
SHINee
their debut song even now is considered the best and honestly i don't think that will change. I'm waiting for the next one
Yeeaay SHINee.. Thanks sooo muchhh.. Will waiting for the next video reaction
Hope you enjoyed it!
There are old variety show episodes where Jonghyun brags about how he likes to imitate MJ. lol It was always his thing.
ohmygod YES!!!! I'm so happy 😂😂😂
Another shinee❤❤Love it.. Thank you so much
Thank you! 😊
So excited to see you guys officially start your Shinee journey, especially starting from the very beginning. You really get to see their own musical journey this way, from the different styles and genres to the improvement in skills of each of the members. Believe it or not, they all go through a massive improvement, whether that be in vocals, dance, or even rap. We always like to say that Shinee doesn’t have distinct positions, because they’re a group made of 5 vocalists, 5 dancers, 5 rappers, and 5 visuals.
SHINee yesss! Subscribing so I don't miss anything. And so happy you finally get to meet Jonghyun. Excited for you to check out more and hopefully you get to react to their live stages too.
Subscribed for SHINee!!! Looking forward to your next reaction 😊
Welcome!!
I feel like Shinee's mom I saw them born, grow and develop...
Aww thanks for the SHINee content, really appreciate it!
Our pleasure!
Replay is considered the greatest KPop debut ever.
Ahhh I luv SHINee so much
I love how you said... stole your heart 😂😂 first time I watched it I said... stole his wallet!!! Lmao
You ain't seen nothing yet as far as Jonghyun goes :-). (And the other members too; they're all crazy talented.) Jjong has an extraordinary range of what he can do with his voice and you've barely begun to scratch the surface. (His solo work is very different from his work with Shinee, btw, and it's extraordinary and very well-worth exploring.)
As others have said, Jonghyun deliberately chose an MJ-inspired delivery for Love Like Oxygen (Onew liked to tease him about it :-)), and you can go to his solo work "Moon" for gorgeous Prince vibes.
I found Jonghyun first, a year and a half ago, and Shinee through him, and the reason I'm a Shawol isn't because of Shinee's music and talent (as much as I love and respect that), it's because of the class and the character of the group, and because of how much they clearly loved and continue to love and honor Jonghyun.
Thank you for starting this SHINee journey. Subscribed for more SHINee and solo member's video reactions.
SHINee is the most famous and loved debut song of any group. This is why it's almost a requirement for newer groups to cover it. Also, this MV started a storyline that continued through 2021 with SHINee's song "Marry You". This is the first installment where they are attracted to a girl and compete to try to court her. "Lovesick", which debuted in 2015, continues the story reaffirming their love (btwn the girl and one of the guys who she chose) after being together for years and how happy her man is. It's like a love letter. "Marry You" is the guy actually proposing to his girl. Taemin joked and said the next installment was going to involve children. Taemin was only 14 when "Replay" debuted so he couldn't actually sing due to immature vocal cords.
As you now know, Jonghyun was THE vocal powerhouse of Kpop, and (still is IMHO) that was just the very small tip of the iceberg. He was their main vocal and his loss left a huge void within their brotherhood. When the guys decided to continue on and honor Jonghyun's dream of SHINee forever, they knew they would have to step it up to fill in at least some of that void, but it would never be completely healed. Jonghyun, along with Onew helped to teach Taemin how to sing. So even today, when Taemin sings in his falsetto during a ballad, you can hear whispers of Jonghyun's voice -- especially when he sang "Already" (a gift from Jonghyun) with Jonghyun's backing vocals. It was sometimes hard to distinguish between them. When and if you decide to react to some live stages (which are the best to react to for SHINee) you will see how insane Jonghyun can get with the adlibs, especially with "Sherlock": ua-cam.com/video/M4pINahBoRY/v-deo.html ; "Stranger": ua-cam.com/video/J-cQSFe4JA0/v-deo.html ; "Excuse Me Miss": ua-cam.com/video/T0MAL3hVwoE/v-deo.html and "Ring, Ding, Dong" + "Lucifer": ua-cam.com/video/mtFK7FxKdLs/v-deo.html ; of course then there's "Romeo & Juliet" where Jonghyun shows us why he was considered the King of Adlibs: ua-cam.com/video/I3Jrvf-O6w4/v-deo.html
SHINee came out of the gate with phenomenal footwork. Taemin was already a master at it, but the others followed suit. SHINee is the group that uses their legs, feet, and arms the most with very intricate movements. Other groups use mostly the torso and hips to drive their choreos with very large arm movements. When you look at these very old MVs, you can instantly think, well that choreo isn't that difficult. However, it was back then. The footwork along with the extreme synchronicity was totally new for Kpop groups, that's why IU stated that whenever SHINee was having a dry-run rehearsal, she and the other groups would run to go see it because it was so unique and new, especially coupled with live singing. IU further stated that one of the reasons why SHINee was special was because of that. ("IU's Palette" with SHINee as guests)
BTW: SHINee also has the most beautiful harmonies in Kpop. You'll hear them when you get to "Lucifer". Many have said they could be an acapella group.
AMIGO: The title of the song is actually is an Korean acronym for A.MI.Go = "Your heart hurts when you fall in love with a beauty". Just three weeks ago SHINee were guests on MMTG and it was hilarious because in the first episode, Jaejae, the host, decided that AMIGO needed to be updated. During the second episode they went to a JYP studio and Jaejae provided them with new lyrics, and they recorded the song.....OMG, seriously it really was hilarious.
Episode 1: ua-cam.com/video/3aBvbIftZH4/v-deo.html
Episode 2: ua-cam.com/video/U3STSw1RLrk/v-deo.html
That Romeo & Juliet SWC 5 performance is killer...
Hi, i am back. Good reaction, ty. To my surprise i liked Replay. R&B vibes. It was sweet and had good harmonies. New Taemin biased. Love his dancing. I will check out ur other reactions to Shinee. Hopefully I will find more songs to love. =0} Hugs. -NY USA 2019 Army💟
SHINee fun facts : They were the first ones to start doing dance practice videos :)
Aileen DeMong said 1/13/22
SHINee was SM's experimental group. When they debuted they didn't even get any promos beforehand like what usually happens with new groups, just a few days before their television debut there was a news story about this new group with the song called Replay from SM and then they had their debut on Inkigayo (very unheard of) a few days later and then they grew from there. They are known as the Idol of Idol's and a lot of groups, even their seniors in the industry, look up to them and love them. And despite them debuting in 2008 they were all 15-18 years old at the time and they often teased other idol groups about that as they were often younger than them but had more seniority in the industry lol.
Charitha Venkatesh.B said on 2/20/2022
"Marry you" is the latest one of the 3-part sequel that SHINee is doing since debut... The sequence goes like
💙"Replay" (liking & confessing to an older girl - debut 2008)
💙"Love sick" (how their relationship is still going on - 2015, the dance choreo for love sick mirrors choreo of replay and at one time during the performance when the lyrics say 'how long has it been' they show 7 in their fingers indicating the years from 2008 to 2015, meaning they have been in love for the whole time & in relationship with the same girl)
💙"Marry you" (proposing to that girl - 2021)
This is the whole relationship arc, they joked that the next song in a few years might be either about their child or about a divorce 😆😆🤣
The lyrics also show the continuation here,
💕Replay:
"You are too pretty"
💕Love sick:
"You were too pretty, do you know"
💕Marry you:
"You are still too pretty, u take my breath away everytime I see you"
💕Replay:
"You are everything to my life"
💕Love sick:
"You are still everything to my life"
💕Marry you:
"Still everything to my life"
Sakura said on 4/16/23
Thanks for your reaction 😊
For SHINee, here a little warning so you know: "Replay", "Love", "Diamond sky" and "From now on" from their concert of the same title "From now on", are very emotional (first concert after). There are also others lives performances of their others concerts that are very moving but I think the most difficult one to watch for the first time remains "Y se fuera ella" by Jonghyun (There is a version with Eng Sub). And even if someone request it, "Our page" is a mv to watch later in your journey (song written by the members for Jonghyun, the lyrics are a must).
I prefer to warn in case, at least you can prepare a little mentally and bring some tissues 😕
Nice reaction(Love Like Oxygen), ty. Like this one too. Catchy. They slayed. Good vocals and harmonies. Some of the hair styles were cute. =0p
Nice reaction(Amigo), ty. This one is not bad. More modern to me. I like the others more.
Thank youuuuuu
Just watched almost all of your series- shiny discovery of SHINee, and it warmed my heart to see other people enjoy and love SHINee. I went back specifically to this one and hoping that you’ll be able to react to more LIVE PERFORMANCES/CONCERTS of SHINee. Since you both liked Replay, their live performance SHINee World IV SWIV in Seoul was not only phenomenal but so emotional. Thank you!
Thank you for your reaction! I really enjoyed it and will be waiting for your next SHINee reactions!
So happy to follow you both on your SHINee journey!
And I peeped the Fairy Tail necklace, love that!!
Some of the early Shinee song used to be American pop songs and SM ent. bought the rights to remake the music. So you will find similarity
Thanks for the reaction ❤️
Thank you too!
1:45 “Everybody just looks like Bruce Lee at some point” okay this should not have made me laugh as hard as it did
But like that’s so true, the hairstyles of the late 2000’s were very questionable at best. Shinee goes through so many unique hair transformations, especially around Lucifer/Sherlock era.
I really miss JONGHYUN's voice
Can't wait for your Lucifer reaction ❤ My teenage self tried to learn the Lucifer choreography with my sister and suffered miserably 😂😂😂 Good old times 🤗💃🏻
I never made the connection but omg you're totally right - LLO is very reminiscent of Mandy Moore's first single "Candy"! Although by LLO's release, MM's music had already moved far away from its bubblegum pop debut and she was also several years into a decent acting career.
LLO is actually a remake; the original version, written by a Danish team and with a different title, was sung by Martin/Saveus (who I believe was the first Danish X Factor winner). I've never listenened to his music but read that apparently his singing style is very similar to Michael Jackson and Justin Timberlake, which could explain Jonghyun's MJ-esque singing in that song. Martin has since written several kpop singles for SM, Shinee's label.
Fun fact: Onew has hilariously poked fun at Jonghyun's singing in LLO later on in a game show and eventually Key Minho and Taemin joined in on the teasing too... during a LIVE CONCERT, much to the fans delight. 😂
you guys really should see SHINee - Hitchhiking Live concert!!!! thats gonna blow your mind
Ok FIY ring ding dong & lucifer has autotune effects as that was going on at that time in kpop....
Must react to their live singing
JONGHYUN will be missed forever
ONEW's voice 🔥🔥
Yesss ......🎉🎉
i'm binge watching your shinee's reactions! absolutely will love it if you react to their downtown baby and diamond sky live
More SHINee please ❤❤
SHINee lagi❤
Terimakasih❤
Baby taemin is only 14 when debuted😂thx again for another SHINee reaction, and look forward to more 🎉
OMG I'm so excited for your Shinee journey 😅❤ After like few MVs, reactors usually become Full time Shawols and rant about them nonstop ❤ Lots of surprises are waiting for you guys 💃🏻💃🏻💃🏻
Reply means noona (older woman in Korean language) you're so pretty and I want to see you again and again (reply). At the time I was little bit older than them, their debut song strategically targated older woman 😂 It worked like a charm and I was whipped immediately 🤣😂 Going strong fan for 15 years ❤
It sounds like Mandy Moore’s Candy I think. I think that’s the one
Also please please react to their solo MVs and albums ❤❤❤ Much like Taemin each members have amazing solo careers 😉😁
To think they were told that they couldnt sing.....
ua-cam.com/video/r1IFH8BzggA/v-deo.html
여행하시고 레전드 리허설 보세요 라이브라 너무 좋아요
I hope you can watch or react to this 2015 live performance of Love Like Oxygen ua-cam.com/video/qeESEkNHVdQ/v-deo.html
They did harmonies and everything live for this one because they said the original backtrack doesn't sound like them anymore.
Edit: You don't have to do a video on it. I don't know how kpop copywrite stuff works on tv broadcasts these days.
SM buys a lot of songs from western song writers. Kesha, Bebe Rexha, Bruno Mars, Corbin Blu, Alejandro Sanz, 112 Cupid just to name a few off the top of my head.
Wow!!
First time I looked them up 3 yrs ago, found this MV and I thought for sure they looked dated so yeah, I get “weird” 😅
At debut Onew was 18 years old. Jonghyun had just turned 18. Key and Minho were 16 and Taemin was 14 years old going on 15.
If you have any questions feel free to ask