Does a Falling Tree Make Sound in an "Empty" Forest? (Ronald Knox Knew).

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 25 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 8

  • @channe11-manager
    @channe11-manager  3 місяці тому

    Timestamps:
    00:00 - Channe11 Intro
    00:06 - Posing The Question
    00:17 - Introducing: Ronald Knox
    00:28 - Knox's Limerick(s), Illustrated
    00:45 - The Implication of Knox's Verses
    01:05 - Props to Alan Watts
    01:11 - The Need to Go Beyond Science for Answers
    01:44 - Spirituality/God as a Transcendent Tool
    02:06 - Confessing the Process, and Considering a Philosophical View of God
    02:35 - Knox Rejects the Premise of the Question
    03:15 - The Inextricable Link Between Being and Awareness
    03:42 - ( The "Oh Face" and the Three Os Prelude )
    03:52 - The Necessity of a Spiritual Perspective
    04:30 - The Self-Limiting Nature of Strict Materialism
    05:26 - The Three Os, Their Characteristics, and the One Most Applicable
    06:25 - A universal placeholder is required. The "Name" is secondary - just ask the Rock.
    07:19 - Chopping down misconceptions of God / "Axed" KRS-One.
    07:27 - Perception-Model Slides (Reality Requires Consciousness)
    08:28 - Minecraft/Mindcraft, Quantum Nuggets and the MC-YOU
    08:35 - Solipsism or Sloppyism?
    09:04 - Rappin' Up - The Real Good News
    09:32 - It's Just Vibes, Man
    10:53 - Air-Quotes Hearing
    11:16 - The Reality-Now Minigame (You Buddha Believe It)
    11:48 - God as Omnipresent Consciousness / The Razor's Edge(s)
    12:19 - The Green Field Forever Listens
    12:33 - The Greatest Gift of All
    12:52 - Knox Outro, and Thanks

  • @rethinkingjesus
    @rethinkingjesus 2 місяці тому

    I really enjoyed your video. You did a great job of putting into words what is beyond words or minds ability to comprehend . 🙌

  • @channe11-manager
    @channe11-manager  3 місяці тому

    Typo @2:30 - Schopenhauer's name is misspelled.

  • @channe11-manager
    @channe11-manager  3 місяці тому

    This is a link to a very good video on Schopenhauer: ua-cam.com/video/f-djIdl8WO4/v-deo.html.
    I saw it after completing this piece, but was impressed with it's breadth and depth. It's worth a view.

  • @my3rs307
    @my3rs307 3 місяці тому +1

    It doesn't

    • @channe11-manager
      @channe11-manager  3 місяці тому

      That's fair - and that was my take for a long time. I think it depends on how sound is considered @10:54 and whether anything happens, or even exists in a consciousness void, which is impossible to test. Can objects exist without a subject? It's fascinating, and the answer changes depending on how we look at it, our presuppositions, and how we define our terms - which is why I still retain some respect for the opposing argument from a certain perspective. I appreciate the feedback.

    • @dfunk1866
      @dfunk1866 3 місяці тому +1

      ​​@@channe11-manager it makes a vibration.
      Ear drums convert vibration to sound.
      So technically, even if someone is around to hear it... It still has only made a vibration.
      Watching your video made me lose some brain cells.
      Please stop using religion to make yourself and others dumb.
      We need smarter people on earth, not dumber 1s.