I have to say, a lot of the 1988 effects hold up very well against their 2024 replacements. Just shows how the production team were still cutting-edge right to the end.
@@ptonpc agreed. I mean, the hand of omega floating when the doctor beckons, the flying Dalek, and the Dalek blaster effects are all just as good in the 1988 version. Sure you can remake them but I didn’t really see anything that needed fixing. It’s not exactly an “invasion of the dinosaurs” level problem that needs fixing 🤪
KINDA and LOGOPOLIS are still the most impressive for the updated effects option, imo. I do like the replacement laser beams used in EARTHSHOCK. The original reminds me of a striped candy cane, or pole, you’d find outside a barbershop.
@GreatHealer. Obviously, just to make a comparison and say where I think effects are going in the future. I watched the first episode of Dr. Who in 1963, so I feel I am qualified to make this remark, as I have seen the developments in special effects, as they happened. Where you alive in 1963?
@ewaf88 we don't have to be there in 1963 to see the comparison. We can all look back easily these days. Again in 1988 (IMO) in my opinion! These were impressive effects. Watched this one on broadcast thankyou.
@@pferreira1983 it was an effect that was good then, still holds up today. it was the first time they did the x-ray zapper. Don't replace a historic first, just add a small layer of polish to make it shine
That mother ship explosion is AMAZING!!! In fact all the mothership shots are fantastic. The only place that I feel was a let down was the casket of Omega. It was way too clean and lacking in details and textures. The original looks better. So F. But having worked on the DVDs before I know that almost no time or money is given to these enhancements. But I'd give everything else an A++. Also classic Daleks can not aim worth a damn!!
I agree about the casket. The original looks like a very real, very old artefact, with barely perceptible imperfections in the way it's overlaid. The new version looks like CGI from 20 or even 30 years ago. But I think all the other new effects stand up well, and just as important, they haven't gone overboard with gratuitious changes.
@@tulliusexmisc2191 To be fair, it's a Gallifreyan piece of technology and they really did build those things to last...? I mean, plunging into the heart of a sun? The novelisation explains the aiming - as well as the gun combat, there was a lot of cyberwarfare and signals warfare with jamming signals going on in inter-Dalek combats.
@@watcherzero5256 well you could barely miss it, harumph. Eh, these things happen, not exactly a deal breaker, maybe it’ll be looked into in later releases?
2:03 Worst of all is the floating casket, which actually looks less fake in the original! Admittedly, the original is slightly oversized in the wide-shot but at leas the relative dimensions are right. There's better shadows but an awful untextured model is used in the 2024 version and it looks squished along its length in the wide-shot! It reminds of the 'dead' looking Red Dwarf 3D models that they used when they dropped the plastic models for external shots of the mining ship!
Remember watching this live when I was 8. It’s nice they’ve bothered to update some special effects. I did rather like the original mothership explosion where you had a pay attention to see that Davros’ escape pod had got away in time, rather than it being obvious. I remember rewinding the VHS to check!
I'm just gonna say it as it was mentioned on Twitter: The CGI Daleks were kind of pointless and very jarring. I think it takes away from the impact of seeing an actual Dalek prop go up the stairs for the first time. I'm unsure what it is but this one didn't gel with me when I saw that all four stories would have this special edition. I'm more looking forward to Silver Nemesis' effects as that was the story I'd wanted to see redone.
Got to say as a child growing up in the 80's with the sheer weird and wacky sort of 80's eccentricities Doctor Who involved and the sort of sound effects they used with the Dalek voices and laser shots alone, it really was a special time watching Doctor Who.
Even the soft blur on the end credits is of nostalgic value. Not everything has to be sharp and clean especially when you've got Daleks on wheels taking corners on uneven roads! The more slick they make everything the else, the more jarring the actual practical effects are, which were very good for the time. This is the era of the Amiga 500 in our homes and the special edition should pay homage to that era and the tech available (Video Toaster, Lightwave, Deluxe Paint and Scala etc) with upscaling and period accurate tech tweaks only in my view. Hopefully the original version is included as well?
I adore the remastered version, but I have to say, using After Effects for a lot of my UA-cam stuff, I can spot a LOT of the tricks used in the 2D side of these edits.
The Emperor not losing his eye light before the Davros reveal is a definite improvement. The suicide of the black Dalek is an interesting alternative. But otherwise, in every way, the original is best in my opinion.
Interesting they corrected the text on the gate as the truck moves in at 8:06, but missed it as the truck leaves the screen at 8:08. We now have a magical disappearing (and reappearing) E. If you're on desktop UA-cam you can use , and . keys to play back and forward frame by frame.
Tracking the second part of the shot didn't look satisfactory, so it was excluded with the rationale that it was only sad nerds like us that would be looking for it lol
Is it just me or does the floating coffin look way better in the original. Not saying it's not janky, but the 2024 version looks out of place in a lot of shots.
7:47 You can easily tell thats not the same Dalek, and its clearly CGI, and I'm pretty sure they just Photoshoped the Dalek out of the original, as when the Dalek moves, you can see some distortion where the Dalek originally was.
A much better explosion at the climax and we see davros jetterston more clearly,not just a spec in space,thanks for the video ,I have the collection arriving Shorty,not going to be disappointed.
Great video! Thanks Dan! I’ve not long watched the special edition; I thought there was something different about the end titles but I couldn’t put my finger on it! The new ones look far better!
Besides the production mat in the road the only thing I think they could have improved was the LMG, even if adding recoil would be too much work they could have added some muzzle flashes and smoke.
Would have liked some muzzle flashes from the army machine guns and possibly some bullet holes in the wall behind the Daleks. I just feel it would have made that more dynamic
I was looking forward to this on on Blu-ray the most, but honestly I prefer the original effects. Even the rainbow particles at 3:00, a visual that I love, why couldn't the smooth new one be multi-coloured?
I'm not really against the idea of updating special effects, but I think you're right - I don't think the new ones are really an improvement on the originals. The black Dalek's death, maybe, but everything else is....well, it's OK. But so was the original.
The newer effects in most areas are an improvement, especially Ace’s Omega charged bat, the only downside was the coffin, it’s supposed to be old, but it looks like it’s just been purchased at Wilko, and the Dalek self destruct was worse than 1988, 8/10
I must say I was disappointed - the CGI Daleks especially (hate the one on the bridge) - I love Imperial Daleks and the shape of these is just wrong. It's such a shame that after going to effort of creat physical models, the ships end up looking like CGI. They're well composed images though. Nothing technically wrong with them. It's just aesthetic issues for me. The best effects for me was giving a view to the shuttle roof hatch and the light on the Dalek Emperor's Eye staying before Davros reveals himself. Oh and the I M Foreman sign! Thanks as always for the comparison video, Dan.
@@Darren79 always a pleasure to hear your thoughts Darren although I do disagree with you for the most part, only effect that really bothered me here was the Supreme at the end. Hoping to try and blitz through the remaining 3 stories over the next few weeks.
Alright, we have a choice. Either we can take out the impressive and historical practical Dalek going up the stairs for the first time, or we can take out the blatantly obvious tarp that we laid down on that road like 40 years ago. Which do we go with?
The outer space shots are a substantial improvement but thoseset on Earth were not that different to make much difference to the viewer - just the usual extend lightening dalek lasers rather than the fuzzier shorter ones. Simply changing the colour of the out the effects really doesn;t do anything. In fact many I prefer the original. So yes to the spacehsip and earth visuals but everything else I can't see what much of the point was.
Some good, some not so good. Love the story although there’s one thing which really gets me, it’s The Doctor’s conversation with ACE. “The Daleks have a ship up there capable of cracking open this planet like an egg, but even they, ruthless though they are would think twice before making such a radical alteration to the time line.” Also The Doctor, he programs “The Hand Of Omega to fly into Skaro’s sun and turn it supernova.” No qualms about that.
The Daleks are a time-active species at this point. Eliminating them is only going to reduce alterations to history. The Daleks interact with the Earth repeatedly in the next couple of hundred years, undoing all of those may end up far too chaotic for Daleks to track.
I still maintain that New Who has over-powered the Daleks. 'Dalek' was a great story and I understand that in order to sell the threat that the lone Dalek posed and to explain the level of the Doctor's anger/guilt then it needed to be formidable. Dramatically for that story it makes sense, and this is now a post-Time War Dalek so I understand the upgrades. But now Daleks can absorb the internet, shield themselves, rotate their mid sections, fly etc. then all of Classic Who just would not work. You couldn't hollow one out and climb inside, you couldn't throw mud at the eye stalk or cover it with a coat, you couldn't push one out of a window or down a lift shaft and Ace and her bat wouldn't get close. I miss the old days!!
i think i prefer the OG effects in pretty much every instance. maybe it's just because i've seen the old ones so many times, but all the new ones really look like they're stuck on top of the footage rather than actually a part of it.
Thanks for putting this together. I'd say the mothership explosion is the only new effect that is significantly better than the original (it always bothered me it wasn't shot on high speed looking straight up to simulate a zero-g explosion). Given they have tinkered with some of the backgrounds I am baffled why they didn't erase the 1980s buildings that were clearly in shot in the cemetery...
I'd say most of the new VFX were better, but they should have either kept the 1988 Dalek blaster bolts the same, or only altered one faction and not the other.
I lot of these effects suffer from being too crisp for the footage they're placed on. The dalek on the stairs and the hand of omega especially, would look perfect if they de-focussed the cgi a little more.
I remember the visceral fear of the dalek's suddenly being able to go up stairs! in the playground the next day ALL the talk (going on for days) was about the Dalek's going up stairs and chasing us!! lots of re-enacments going on with plungers and whisks and the playground steps!!!
Did anyone else notice they cut the line on the tv broadcast that was about to introduce the first episode of Doctor Who when Ace leaves to go find the Doctor? I was waiting for the scene to come on but was disapointed they had cut it from the special edition.
I love the new dalek lasers and other weapon effects, as well as most of the new spaceship sequences, but the original opening scene still beats the new one for me. I also prefer the colours on the original Hand of Omega; while the new one is more textured and 3D and real (and has a better shadow), it looks a bit too new and shiny, whereas the old one looked quite old and worn, as might be expected of an artefact from the dawn of Time Lord civilisation. Best new effect: dalek floating up the stairs, the old one really needed changing Worst new effect: Hand of Omega Impressed by: I. M. Foreman sign fix, basically all the spaceship stuff Left to be desired: The ring around Skaro when it is destroyed is conspicuously absent in the new one, Special Weapons Dalek's beam should've been thicker Completely new effects: the TARDIS in the end titles, I mean COME ON
I know a lot of it is to fit in with Nu Who (Dalek weapons etc) but I DO HAVE A BIAS TO THE ORIGINAL (it's one of the few 1980s stories where I actually love the Optical FX and find they don't jar with the story; they're of their time but oddly timeless as well - The Leisure Hive and Time And The Rani being other obvious likes). The exception is probably the linking shots of the Dalek shuttle prior to landing which is a Paintbox matte and is deeply unimpressive and should've been left out. Battlefield needs this remake a lot more without doubt - especially the dodgy Model photography and 'Snake Guard'.
There's a huge amount of irony in a lot of the space shots. They explicitly say the ship is in geostationary orbit, and when we see the shots of earth from the position of the mothership, the size of earth makes logical sense for the required distance. Now, in violation of the onscreen dialogue, the mothership is now in low earth orbit, which doesn't make sense.
This is my favorite feature on the DVD / Blu-rays. I've seen these episodes so many times over and over again over the years and the new effects manage to breathe new life into them for me.
My opinion upon hearing this had been done was that Remembrance was already perfect with great modelwork, and that any additions would be at best pointless and at worst distracting. Thanks for the confirmation.
@ACtheLegend You been keeping up.with the news? You don't need .e to tell you that there's nothing you can do to prevent the catharsis of spurious morality.
I'll confess I was low key hoping a Dub with Nicolas Briggs daleks were available but that doesn't mean however I like the current voices any less. I can't wait to jump into the Season 25 collection.
Tbh I think these are 50/50 some of the effects are an improvement such as the laser effects for the Daleks. And some better transitions of the scenes and certain details are better on the updated version such as, the Dalek Mothership being seen in its entirety. The visuals in space look better and the firing of the omega device looks gorgeous on the update. However, I think certain VFX actually look better on the original version such as the Dalek flying up the stairs for the first time and the Dalek fight scenes, the CGI Daleks feel unnecessary. I also think the visuals of the ship flying looks better on the original and the hand of omega floating on its casket is better on the original. Xc
Side not I don't like how the 5.1 surround mix for this and on the DVD, replaced Mr Ratcliff's yell when he gets zapped by the lighting 5:39 with what sounds like a random stock yell sound. In fact that's one of many changes in the 5.1 surround mix I don't like, hen why I tend to stick with the original stereo mix. Also ironically this was the first ever Dr who story with a Stereo sound mix
Some of these changes are definitely unnessisarry (the shot of the escape pod, namely) and a lot of it feels too 'clean' against the 80s era TV camera shots - but I do like some of the editing changes and insert shots
So glad the Dalek now overheats rather than goes all trippy. annoyed me when I watched it when it was first aired. Davros's escape pod is a good addition. Shame the Special Weapons Dalek still wobbles like hell!
The BBC was at the cutting edge of squeezing what could be done out of VFX by 1988. I was at the BBC during this season run and visited the Visual Effects department. They had all the latest Quantel Paintbox stack and loads of custom gear including a mainframe Vax to do heavy graphic number crunching for intensive effects.
Most of the effects are pretty fine and I much prefer the new laser effects, but god that CGI Supreme is absolute wank (also I actually prefer the Emperor losing its eye earlier as the voice transitions from Dalek to Davros)
The 2024 SFX aren't really that much better and, in some case, they are worse. In some cases there is some minor improvement but overall, kind of a wasted effort. The Hand of Omega crate looked much better in the original. Dalek blaster fire seems to be an improvement; except possibly the special weapons Dalek.
The next generation of BBC 3D animators and effects department are technical efficient but the soul of their craft is missing in my opinion. Thank goodness for Aardman and Pixar (prior to Lasseter leaving) who showed that it is possible to produce new IP with soul in the 21st century. The BBC however beside a few exceptions like the sci-fi drama Outcasts and Humans don't show it often. Therefore, if they can't do it for Remembrance of the Daleks (a classic), they should leave it alone and just upscale it. This is just my view but I am entitled to hold it.
But they are obviously computer models. None of the textures match the practical effects used elsewhere! You detract from the actual action and produce an uncanny valley effect by brushing up the spaceships and energy blasts etc and leaving the rocking Daleks alone! Better to leave it all alone and let the story speak for itself. There's no stories like this in the modern series post "the Dr was a little girl" nonsense!
@@bigd5090 I think CGI does well when spaceships and objects cross each other. The real weakness as you say was wobbly daleks that had far more screentime than spaceships. Most 'who shows had daleks on smooth studio floors. A shame such efforts are undermined by the latest high-budget show, and I don't mean in effects.
@@bigd5090 "But they are obviously computer models" - except they aren't. All of the spaceships in this story are practical models. In fact all of the spaceships in Season 25 are practical models except for the Cyber Scout Ship in Silver Nemesis.
Nice to get a better look at the Destiny of Stars (Imperial mothership), although the cloaked in shadows look really suited the gritty aesthetic of this story.
@@HiveFleetOni I clearly have memory problems. Eret-mensaiki Ska, the flagship of the Imperial Fleet. Excellent, thank you. I just couldn't imagine who other than Davros would've been throwing around fancy names.
The updated dalek blasts are better The added and updated Space segs are great The insertion of deleted content is ace A lot of the new stuff is brilliant, but with the good comes the bad, but overall I liked it, are the original unchanged episodes also included in the set?
![Doctor Who: The Five Doctors Effects Comparison [Redux]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Ke0l1yX9imU/mqdefault.jpg)
![Doctor Who: The Five Doctors Effects Comparison [Redux]](/img/tr.png)
I have to say, a lot of the 1988 effects hold up very well against their 2024 replacements. Just shows how the production team were still cutting-edge right to the end.
I agree.
I was thinking the same thing. A lot of the new effects don't really add anything.
If it ain't broke....
@@ptonpc agreed. I mean, the hand of omega floating when the doctor beckons, the flying Dalek, and the Dalek blaster effects are all just as good in the 1988 version. Sure you can remake them but I didn’t really see anything that needed fixing.
It’s not exactly an “invasion of the dinosaurs” level problem that needs fixing 🤪
@@richardmattocks fixing is the wrong word here. They offer a new alternative way to view the classic story in an exciting manner.
Honestly these might be my favorite new effects
KINDA and LOGOPOLIS are still the most impressive for the updated effects option, imo.
I do like the replacement laser beams used in EARTHSHOCK. The original reminds me of a striped candy cane, or pole, you’d find outside a barbershop.
My favourite classic Dalek story. Nice to see some of those rough edges being smoothed over with restraint and respect.
Quite impressive in 1988 imo.
For that budget, to be precise.
@@GreatHealer. We weren't in a bearskin and a zinc plated vacuum culture back then
@ewaf88 what is the point of this comment really..
@GreatHealer. Obviously, just to make a comparison and say where I think effects are going in the future.
I watched the first episode of Dr. Who in 1963, so I feel I am qualified to make this remark, as I have seen the developments in special effects, as they happened.
Where you alive in 1963?
@ewaf88 we don't have to be there in 1963 to see the comparison. We can all look back easily these days. Again in 1988 (IMO) in my opinion! These were impressive effects. Watched this one on broadcast thankyou.
I love how the extermination at 0:49 is basically untouched. That’s how good it is.
I didn't even notice any difference.
They just changed the colour from green to blue for continuity. The effect itself is... Well, it was one of the very best of Classic Who.
@@DomWeasel Ah okay.
@@pferreira1983 it was an effect that was good then, still holds up today. it was the first time they did the x-ray zapper. Don't replace a historic first, just add a small layer of polish to make it shine
@@steveg5122 Agreed.
That mother ship explosion is AMAZING!!! In fact all the mothership shots are fantastic. The only place that I feel was a let down was the casket of Omega. It was way too clean and lacking in details and textures. The original looks better. So F. But having worked on the DVDs before I know that almost no time or money is given to these enhancements. But I'd give everything else an A++. Also classic Daleks can not aim worth a damn!!
Same thoughts
I agree about the casket. The original looks like a very real, very old artefact, with barely perceptible imperfections in the way it's overlaid. The new version looks like CGI from 20 or even 30 years ago.
But I think all the other new effects stand up well, and just as important, they haven't gone overboard with gratuitious changes.
@@tulliusexmisc2191 To be fair, it's a Gallifreyan piece of technology and they really did build those things to last...? I mean, plunging into the heart of a sun?
The novelisation explains the aiming - as well as the gun combat, there was a lot of cyberwarfare and signals warfare with jamming signals going on in inter-Dalek combats.
11:21 they couldn’t have digitally erased that carpet?
Other than that, pretty darned good, overall. I particularly like the revamped space shots.
Lol, I noticed that too.
@@watcherzero5256 well you could barely miss it, harumph.
Eh, these things happen, not exactly a deal breaker, maybe it’ll be looked into in later releases?
Even stranger is how they couldn't be bothered to add muzzle flashes to machine guns. 8I
Amazing comparison always look forward to these videos once the collection sets come out! So exciting to see lots of new cgi Daleks & shots
These are so awesome, I wish every story could get this treatment
This story wasn't on my top ten as a kid. Now it's one of my favorites, and this update just made it better.
2:03 Worst of all is the floating casket, which actually looks less fake in the original! Admittedly, the original is slightly oversized in the wide-shot but at leas the relative dimensions are right. There's better shadows but an awful untextured model is used in the 2024 version and it looks squished along its length in the wide-shot! It reminds of the 'dead' looking Red Dwarf 3D models that they used when they dropped the plastic models for external shots of the mining ship!
The shadow looks worse in the newer effect I think. It wouldn't be that defined in daylight.
The moment I saw Ace beating up that Dalek with her high-tech baseball bat, I fell in love with her.
Floating casket looked better in 1988.
Remember watching this live when I was 8. It’s nice they’ve bothered to update some special effects. I did rather like the original mothership explosion where you had a pay attention to see that Davros’ escape pod had got away in time, rather than it being obvious. I remember rewinding the VHS to check!
You can still see it leaving on the new one :D i went back to look :D
@ yeah I meant later in this video they’ve added a completely new shot of the escape pod ejecting.
@@Jimbatron ... the lost art of subtlety.
There’s just something special about out Remembrance of the Daleks. It’s this wonderful sweet spot between classic and new Who.
I'm just gonna say it as it was mentioned on Twitter: The CGI Daleks were kind of pointless and very jarring. I think it takes away from the impact of seeing an actual Dalek prop go up the stairs for the first time. I'm unsure what it is but this one didn't gel with me when I saw that all four stories would have this special edition. I'm more looking forward to Silver Nemesis' effects as that was the story I'd wanted to see redone.
7:47 shame that the new model for the renegade supreme doesn't use the necros style casing.
Got to say as a child growing up in the 80's with the sheer weird and wacky sort of 80's eccentricities Doctor Who involved and the sort of sound effects they used with the Dalek voices and laser shots alone, it really was a special time watching Doctor Who.
Even the soft blur on the end credits is of nostalgic value. Not everything has to be sharp and clean especially when you've got Daleks on wheels taking corners on uneven roads! The more slick they make everything the else, the more jarring the actual practical effects are, which were very good for the time. This is the era of the Amiga 500 in our homes and the special edition should pay homage to that era and the tech available (Video Toaster, Lightwave, Deluxe Paint and Scala etc) with upscaling and period accurate tech tweaks only in my view. Hopefully the original version is included as well?
I liked the late 80s special effects of alot of the Mccoy Doctor Who episodes. You should do all of season 25.
I adore the remastered version, but I have to say, using After Effects for a lot of my UA-cam stuff, I can spot a LOT of the tricks used in the 2D side of these edits.
The Emperor not losing his eye light before the Davros reveal is a definite improvement. The suicide of the black Dalek is an interesting alternative. But otherwise, in every way, the original is best in my opinion.
That's the problem. They tend to go overboard with the new effects and they usually stick out like a sore thumb.
Interesting they corrected the text on the gate as the truck moves in at 8:06, but missed it as the truck leaves the screen at 8:08. We now have a magical disappearing (and reappearing) E. If you're on desktop UA-cam you can use , and . keys to play back and forward frame by frame.
I noticed that when I watched it too.
Tracking the second part of the shot didn't look satisfactory, so it was excluded with the rationale that it was only sad nerds like us that would be looking for it lol
Thanks so much for this
Is it just me or does the floating coffin look way better in the original. Not saying it's not janky, but the 2024 version looks out of place in a lot of shots.
You're right.
( 8:05 ) Nice touch! 😱
7:47 You can easily tell thats not the same Dalek, and its clearly CGI, and I'm pretty sure they just Photoshoped the Dalek out of the original, as when the Dalek moves, you can see some distortion where the Dalek originally was.
A much better explosion at the climax and we see davros jetterston more clearly,not just a spec in space,thanks for the video ,I have the collection arriving Shorty,not going to be disappointed.
Great video! Thanks Dan! I’ve not long watched the special edition; I thought there was something different about the end titles but I couldn’t put my finger on it! The new ones look far better!
Besides the production mat in the road the only thing I think they could have improved was the LMG, even if adding recoil would be too much work they could have added some muzzle flashes and smoke.
Personally I prefer the original effects as they blend in with the rest of the production
Would have liked some muzzle flashes from the army machine guns and possibly some bullet holes in the wall behind the Daleks. I just feel it would have made that more dynamic
Absolutley fantastic work on these effects!
Watched the updated version last week.
Bloody marvellous!!
where can yo uwatch them?
Best but us is at 07:27 where you can see Davros's escape ship in both versions if you pay really close attention...
I was looking forward to this on on Blu-ray the most, but honestly I prefer the original effects. Even the rainbow particles at 3:00, a visual that I love, why couldn't the smooth new one be multi-coloured?
They are multi-coloured. The colours just aren’t as vibrant as the original effect.
Agreed though, I also think the original looks better.
I'm not really against the idea of updating special effects, but I think you're right - I don't think the new ones are really an improvement on the originals. The black Dalek's death, maybe, but everything else is....well, it's OK. But so was the original.
I honestly prefer all the classic Who effects over any of the "remastered" versions, you get the whole Doctor Who charm that way.
Modern CGI will never be as visceral as old school/practical effects.
@@jaysmith2858 except when these new effects have used practical effects and people still can’t tell the difference 😂
Goddamn they did this story justice
The newer effects in most areas are an improvement, especially Ace’s Omega charged bat, the only downside was the coffin, it’s supposed to be old, but it looks like it’s just been purchased at Wilko, and the Dalek self destruct was worse than 1988, 8/10
YES!!!! IVE WANTED A SPECIAL EDTION SO BADLY AND THIS IS PERFECT!!!!
I must say I was disappointed - the CGI Daleks especially (hate the one on the bridge) - I love Imperial Daleks and the shape of these is just wrong.
It's such a shame that after going to effort of creat physical models, the ships end up looking like CGI. They're well composed images though. Nothing technically wrong with them. It's just aesthetic issues for me.
The best effects for me was giving a view to the shuttle roof hatch and the light on the Dalek Emperor's Eye staying before Davros reveals himself. Oh and the I M Foreman sign!
Thanks as always for the comparison video, Dan.
@@Darren79 always a pleasure to hear your thoughts Darren although I do disagree with you for the most part, only effect that really bothered me here was the Supreme at the end. Hoping to try and blitz through the remaining 3 stories over the next few weeks.
Love the new effects, but it’s reminded me that the 1988 originals were also very good for the time.
I've been looking forward to this video, some of the subtle changes I didn't even notice.
Alright, we have a choice. Either we can take out the impressive and historical practical Dalek going up the stairs for the first time, or we can take out the blatantly obvious tarp that we laid down on that road like 40 years ago. Which do we go with?
I found the Hand of Omega graphics to be a bit jarring as the floating casket just didn't appear detailed enough
Is it me or do the 1988 effects look better?
The new transmat effect is just hilarious.
They should have left that well alone! The original has charm.
6:35 The only effects shot that ever bothered me to be honest. The new one is perfect.
All around some exceptional enhancements and additions.
The outer space shots are a substantial improvement but thoseset on Earth were not that different to make much difference to the viewer - just the usual extend lightening dalek lasers rather than the fuzzier shorter ones. Simply changing the colour of the out the effects really doesn;t do anything. In fact many I prefer the original. So yes to the spacehsip and earth visuals but everything else I can't see what much of the point was.
Awesome comparison
80’s Doctor who has a pulpy vibe. It’s weird seeing Doctor who without early 2000’s CGI special effects.
FANTASTIC!! 😁
Some good, some not so good. Love the story although there’s one thing which really gets me, it’s The Doctor’s conversation with ACE.
“The Daleks have a ship up there capable of cracking open this planet like an egg, but even they, ruthless though they are would think twice before making such a radical alteration to the time line.”
Also The Doctor, he programs “The Hand Of Omega to fly into Skaro’s sun and turn it supernova.” No qualms about that.
The Daleks are a time-active species at this point. Eliminating them is only going to reduce alterations to history. The Daleks interact with the Earth repeatedly in the next couple of hundred years, undoing all of those may end up far too chaotic for Daleks to track.
My favourite story ever, I am so pumped for this!!!!
I still maintain that New Who has over-powered the Daleks. 'Dalek' was a great story and I understand that in order to sell the threat that the lone Dalek posed and to explain the level of the Doctor's anger/guilt then it needed to be formidable. Dramatically for that story it makes sense, and this is now a post-Time War Dalek so I understand the upgrades. But now Daleks can absorb the internet, shield themselves, rotate their mid sections, fly etc. then all of Classic Who just would not work. You couldn't hollow one out and climb inside, you couldn't throw mud at the eye stalk or cover it with a coat, you couldn't push one out of a window or down a lift shaft and Ace and her bat wouldn't get close. I miss the old days!!
i think i prefer the OG effects in pretty much every instance. maybe it's just because i've seen the old ones so many times, but all the new ones really look like they're stuck on top of the footage rather than actually a part of it.
Thanks for putting this together. I'd say the mothership explosion is the only new effect that is significantly better than the original (it always bothered me it wasn't shot on high speed looking straight up to simulate a zero-g explosion). Given they have tinkered with some of the backgrounds I am baffled why they didn't erase the 1980s buildings that were clearly in shot in the cemetery...
The tracking was near impossible to make it look right.
I'd say most of the new VFX were better, but they should have either kept the 1988 Dalek blaster bolts the same, or only altered one faction and not the other.
The Hand of Omega looked better in the original I'd say
I lot of these effects suffer from being too crisp for the footage they're placed on. The dalek on the stairs and the hand of omega especially, would look perfect if they de-focussed the cgi a little more.
There's a mistake at 8:09. The E is still missing in the new version as the truck passes the gate
It goes by so quickly, I'm not too fussed.
@jeremyjasiak it kind of spoils it slightly. But the new sfx is much better
even better than the last Nu Who series
I remember the visceral fear of the dalek's suddenly being able to go up stairs! in the playground the next day ALL the talk (going on for days) was about the Dalek's going up stairs and chasing us!! lots of re-enacments going on with plungers and whisks and the playground steps!!!
I like the new effects, they still feel 80s but higher budget. Respectful enough, I'd say.
The updated special effects make 1988 & 2005 feel like the gap in time was much less than 17 years.
In the extended version, do they have the scene where The Doctor says “I’m far more than just another Timelord.”?
@@project_boredom2940 yes
tbh, the shuttle docking shot didn't really need updating. original is so good
Did anyone else notice they cut the line on the tv broadcast that was about to introduce the first episode of Doctor Who when Ace leaves to go find the Doctor? I was waiting for the scene to come on but was disapointed they had cut it from the special edition.
I love the new dalek lasers and other weapon effects, as well as most of the new spaceship sequences, but the original opening scene still beats the new one for me. I also prefer the colours on the original Hand of Omega; while the new one is more textured and 3D and real (and has a better shadow), it looks a bit too new and shiny, whereas the old one looked quite old and worn, as might be expected of an artefact from the dawn of Time Lord civilisation.
Best new effect: dalek floating up the stairs, the old one really needed changing
Worst new effect: Hand of Omega
Impressed by: I. M. Foreman sign fix, basically all the spaceship stuff
Left to be desired: The ring around Skaro when it is destroyed is conspicuously absent in the new one, Special Weapons Dalek's beam should've been thicker
Completely new effects: the TARDIS in the end titles, I mean COME ON
Aside from the Hand of Omega burial CGI, I cant really say that I feel these new effects have added anything or improved anything.
I know a lot of it is to fit in with Nu Who (Dalek weapons etc) but I DO HAVE A BIAS TO THE ORIGINAL (it's one of the few 1980s stories where I actually love the Optical FX and find they don't jar with the story; they're of their time but oddly timeless as well - The Leisure Hive and Time And The Rani being other obvious likes).
The exception is probably the linking shots of the Dalek shuttle prior to landing which is a Paintbox matte and is deeply unimpressive and should've been left out.
Battlefield needs this remake a lot more without doubt - especially the dodgy Model photography and 'Snake Guard'.
There's a huge amount of irony in a lot of the space shots. They explicitly say the ship is in geostationary orbit, and when we see the shots of earth from the position of the mothership, the size of earth makes logical sense for the required distance. Now, in violation of the onscreen dialogue, the mothership is now in low earth orbit, which doesn't make sense.
This is my favorite feature on the DVD / Blu-rays. I've seen these episodes so many times over and over again over the years and the new effects manage to breathe new life into them for me.
Oh dear. No.
Good job with the effects. Petty you could make the daleks less wobbly .
My opinion upon hearing this had been done was that Remembrance was already perfect with great modelwork, and that any additions would be at best pointless and at worst distracting.
Thanks for the confirmation.
Haven't you got some kind of catharsis of spurious morality to go and moan about, Scrapyard?
There was a couple of tiny things they could improve. Out of all the stories I agree there wasn't much that could be improved.
@ACtheLegend You been keeping up.with the news? You don't need .e to tell you that there's nothing you can do to prevent the catharsis of spurious morality.
I kind of feel this story really didn't need it's effects updated and from the look of it my feelings remain the same
Same here.
It's subtle, it's not a lucas. Good stuff.
Blimey you don’t hang about!
I'll confess I was low key hoping a Dub with Nicolas Briggs daleks were available but that doesn't mean however I like the current voices any less.
I can't wait to jump into the Season 25 collection.
Tbh I think these are 50/50 some of the effects are an improvement such as the laser effects for the Daleks. And some better transitions of the scenes and certain details are better on the updated version such as, the Dalek Mothership being seen in its entirety. The visuals in space look better and the firing of the omega device looks gorgeous on the update.
However, I think certain VFX actually look better on the original version such as the Dalek flying up the stairs for the first time and the Dalek fight scenes, the CGI Daleks feel unnecessary. I also think the visuals of the ship flying looks better on the original and the hand of omega floating on its casket is better on the original. Xc
Side not I don't like how the 5.1 surround mix for this and on the DVD, replaced Mr Ratcliff's yell when he gets zapped by the lighting 5:39 with what sounds like a random stock yell sound. In fact that's one of many changes in the 5.1 surround mix I don't like, hen why I tend to stick with the original stereo mix. Also ironically this was the first ever Dr who story with a Stereo sound mix
@@silverdaleks1 not really, the first story with a Stereo sound mix was actually Frontios.
@@DanTheMan2150AD oh well the info and facts subs on the DVD said Remembrance was the first to be stereo..
Brilliant dalek story
Some of these changes are definitely unnessisarry (the shot of the escape pod, namely) and a lot of it feels too 'clean' against the 80s era TV camera shots - but I do like some of the editing changes and insert shots
Do you plan to do the rest of Season 25 updated effects?
The floating coffin is better in the 80s
So glad the Dalek now overheats rather than goes all trippy. annoyed me when I watched it when it was first aired. Davros's escape pod is a good addition. Shame the Special Weapons Dalek still wobbles like hell!
"It works... it works...!"
The BBC was at the cutting edge of squeezing what could be done out of VFX by 1988. I was at the BBC during this season run and visited the Visual Effects department. They had all the latest Quantel Paintbox stack and loads of custom gear including a mainframe Vax to do heavy graphic number crunching for intensive effects.
Most of the effects are pretty fine and I much prefer the new laser effects, but god that CGI Supreme is absolute wank (also I actually prefer the Emperor losing its eye earlier as the voice transitions from Dalek to Davros)
I prefer the original but good job
The 2024 SFX aren't really that much better and, in some case, they are worse. In some cases there is some minor improvement but overall, kind of a wasted effort. The Hand of Omega crate looked much better in the original. Dalek blaster fire seems to be an improvement; except possibly the special weapons Dalek.
Not sure I see the point of most of the changes
Shame they didn't spend the effort on updating the horrid synths instead :P
To give folks a choice 😊
Will you do videos for the other stories of Season 25?? 😊
@@calumbrown9790 yes
@@DanTheMan2150AD awesome! Can't wait to see them!
The next generation of BBC 3D animators and effects department are technical efficient but the soul of their craft is missing in my opinion. Thank goodness for Aardman and Pixar (prior to Lasseter leaving) who showed that it is possible to produce new IP with soul in the 21st century. The BBC however beside a few exceptions like the sci-fi drama Outcasts and Humans don't show it often. Therefore, if they can't do it for Remembrance of the Daleks (a classic), they should leave it alone and just upscale it. This is just my view but I am entitled to hold it.
Wonder why they cut the Doctor Who in TV meta reference.
This was probably the peak of effects the old show had. Everything can be improved though, the CGI spaceships are better than the models.
But they are obviously computer models. None of the textures match the practical effects used elsewhere! You detract from the actual action and produce an uncanny valley effect by brushing up the spaceships and energy blasts etc and leaving the rocking Daleks alone! Better to leave it all alone and let the story speak for itself. There's no stories like this in the modern series post "the Dr was a little girl" nonsense!
@@bigd5090 I think CGI does well when spaceships and objects cross each other. The real weakness as you say was wobbly daleks that had far more screentime than spaceships. Most 'who shows had daleks on smooth studio floors. A shame such efforts are undermined by the latest high-budget show, and I don't mean in effects.
@@bigd5090 "But they are obviously computer models" - except they aren't. All of the spaceships in this story are practical models. In fact all of the spaceships in Season 25 are practical models except for the Cyber Scout Ship in Silver Nemesis.
@@ACtheLegendThe point was they've REPLACED some practical effects with CGI e.g. 0:43.
@@bigd5090 0:43 is the mothership, and it's practical.
Nice to get a better look at the Destiny of Stars (Imperial mothership), although the cloaked in shadows look really suited the gritty aesthetic of this story.
Where did that name come from?
@ The very, very excellent novelisation of Remembrance 😊
@@HiveFleetOni I clearly have memory problems. Eret-mensaiki Ska, the flagship of the Imperial Fleet. Excellent, thank you.
I just couldn't imagine who other than Davros would've been throwing around fancy names.
How have they managed to make some of the shots worse 🥴
Such as?
The updated dalek blasts are better
The added and updated Space segs are great
The insertion of deleted content is ace
A lot of the new stuff is brilliant, but with the good comes the bad, but overall I liked it, are the original unchanged episodes also included in the set?
@@RicStorm616 the originals are always included as standard, otherwise there wouldn’t be a point to these updated effects being included.