Jewish Youths From India on a Visit to Israel
Вставка
- Опубліковано 10 чер 2015
- Birthright Israel is celebrating its 15th anniversary with a half a million participants, including 22 youngsters from the Jewish community of India. A dwindling minority in their country, they see Israel as their possible home. Shahar Peled reports i24news is an international 24-hour news and current affairs television channel based in Jaffa Port.
For more from our news teams www.i24news.tv
Facebook: / i24newsen
Twitter: / i24news_en - Комедії
Jews are not declining in India they are migrating to Israel they don't have any problems here in India
After living for 2000yrs in india... and u have the audacity to say u don't feel like indian..
Probably thinking they be rich in Israel in no time
@@charlesbronson9402 yes, its abt money.
Our problem is, we are too humble towards people. Look at what mslims have done to the country (we'll see more of them).
You wouldn't understand. It's a feeling. I was born in africa but I'm still tied to india. But I'm also tied to the middle east from where my ancestors came from.
@@arieswoman824 you're correct.
I would say Jews are more safe in India then any other country.
long live India n israel friendship.
shehroz Irani mate it's not about how many Jews living in other country. We are talking about a peaceful life they perusing. And history is biggest evidence that when Jews were slaughtered throughout the middle east only India gave them asylum and welcomed them with open heart. In for Jews living Israel they have India favourite destination for holiday.
shehroz Irani and whole world knows about the conflict bw Iran and Israel.
And compare it with the relations of India and Israel
+shehroz Irani who is this pervert from the beautiful country of Iran.
shehroz Irani hahahahha what a moron u r ... seems lyk u have no idea what happening in my and ur country. ur preassumed and self proclaimed thoughts tellling the whole story about ur knowledge. 1st of all go and google how india and current govt bjp govt helped iran by buying there oil even after the so many sanction imposed by america go moron google it. 2nd history is evidence when in medieval era jews where getting slautered indian king were the only one who gave asylum not only jews same thing in zorastrians and shias as well.
3rd no one in unhappy in my country i dont know what ur source is, as there is no so called bhramin rule after independence we had three bhramin presidents from 13 and 3 prime ministers bhramin from 14 pms ,who became the pm of my country after that no pm in from bhramin caste , and as according to u current bhramin ruling govt bjp have a obc pm.
4th we give scholarships , reservations, quotas and subsidies to all minority and low caste people do ur country do any of that, we even subsidies the hajj travel for muslims. so think twice before saying anything against my nation. u people have misunderstood us, u think our politeness is our weakness.
shehroz irani sorry brother but u dont know anything about hindus your comments are saying this but leave all that i will tell u my personal belief that INDIA AND ISRAEL are natural friends but we Indians have very good relation with IRAN we indian love Iran we have historical ties n no u r misguided here in India All are equal n minority have even more advanages than majority hindus ..brother pls google it whenever it comes between India or Pakistan ...Iran always choose INDIA n we respect that n example u can see when whole european union and America was saying to India not to buy Oils from Iran INDIA refuses n said we will not do this n stands by IRAN PEOPLE so pls brother we Indian love Iranians n u can see lot of actresses of Iran are working in BOLLYWOOD n we love them we think Iran is a beutiful country and India's friend n will always .....
what is wrong with this people... They cant live Jewish in india?? Someone cant pronounce your name?? is that the reason?? i just want to ask that girl... How many Jewish are in india?? i guess 5k... is it indians mistake? If someone doesnt know about your religion teach them rather than criticize.... India never hated Jewish community... You guys go to israel we got no problem with that but you talk as if you were humiliated in india that hurts us.... I just wanna say... India is your birth place dont forget it for gods sake...
sanjay s yup ...their are hundreds of religion...I m jain,but it is familiar to North East India ..that doesn't mean I should criticize
***** thanks..
sanjay s they really disappointed me, can i call them (the indian Jewish traitors) 😏, i have a Jewish indian, & he never feels what these traitors feelings, we hang out eat play study together, so stop critisizing you fools, "thaali ke baigan" aka diplomats😡
They are not traitors. They are migrating to their original homeland. It is their choice. Stop calling them traitors.
Dipika Dil look at the tone of the girl (wearing glasses), & remember India is the country who protected them, despite of having a lot of muslim citizens, so they should be thankful, but instead of that what they are showing to the world??, deaf & dumb people will never understand this little thing, don't be soo tolerant
The report is a bit pessimistic for India. The word "diminishing" sounds like a forced exodus of Jews from India was underway. Indians, Hindus/Muslims/Sikhs migrate to many countries, but this report makes it sound as if there was anti-Jewish environment in India. The migration I am sure is because of better opportunities available in Israel and not some other reason. India has literally NO anti-Semitic history. India has always been a multi-religion society with tolerance for minorities. India-Israel friendship will go a long way. I hope the "stereotypes" about India are not created for better people to people contact.
Zionist controlled media can't and won't say that other countries are not anti semitic, this does not fit well in their propaganda in how Jews are victims when in fact they are the most dispiciable people known throughout history, they cry when they say they were thrown out of most countries over the centuries.....We just forgot to ask why they were pushed out .
+Ricky Bell Hi ..Just for your Information ...Only country where Jews lived peacefully for 2000 years is in INDIA , in Kerala they(Jews) also crowned as Prince also and ruled some parts(This kerala jews are some what more older then Mumbai jews) ....Might be due to Bad economy some people are moved/migrated but still India is great place and second place for Jewish to Live after Israel ..
+KC Bamania you are right the jews left india for better future not for anti semitism ,in kolkata very few jews remaining.
Well, even though there are billions of Hindus, these people are hale and hearty. What an atrocious way of addressing a country in which you were born and accepted.
What???
Don't say even though. We Hindus are way pluralistic, civilized & Secular than all Abrahamics. All Hindu countries are secular but all Abrahamic countries are not secular.
just saw that indian origin jews were discriminated in Israel. It's sad to hear
They still feel it like home though,not India😂
@@mohmmadnabeehasan4672atleast we treat them like humans not kaafirs and behead then idiot muslim
@@mohmmadnabeehasan4672
Dear...come to Ahmedabad... they're a notable community here...
Maybe you need some eye opening visuals...😅
@@mohmmadnabeehasan4672so do pak people living in west
Yes they are so blinded by their religion... They can't see what's good for them... When you identify yourself with a specific religion as your sole identity, you tend to be blind to other good people around you..
India is an interesting place ! 80% Hindus and 20% Muslims and other minorities ! the Muslims majority of the nation always stand with Palestinian cause and Hindu majority of the nation 50% with Israel and 50% with Palestine ! but in general they have nothing against Israeli people themselves.
1 billion hindus stands with israel.
Bother not 50% hindus stand with israel n the other with palestine... Allmost all hindus , 100% stands with israel n you said right for muslims . If you see some one from social media with a hindu name speaks supporting palastine cause most probably he is a jihadi with a malicious intent .
We have supported Israel in UNSC tho
@@odin3433 except sikulars and librandus
The whole world with Palestine , the barbaric images of babies slaughtered lined everyone with Palestine
Arab world always stand against india when it comes to kashmir issue.
India helped arab countries to get independence from Britain. India was the first non- Arab country to support palestine in UN resolution. India continued supporting palestine.
But what it got in return.
Continuos backstabbing from muslim countries.
There is a limit for everything.
bahoot sahi !
Ridiculous it's only India where they never faced discrimination.
Their population is very miniscule
Difference occurs if only you think from the perspective of culture
Proud to serve in Israeli military but a step they wouldn't have considered in Indian military?????.........why?????.........Indians don't recognize Indian jewish people coz we don't see Indian jewish people as separate identities, you guys r a proud part of us..........don't know why but I felt little hurt when some of our brothers and sisters displayed such perspective about native Indians in Israel........please don't do that, it hurts a lot.
@@gc-rm1ez Infact they should, nobody is stopping them to participate, it's their birth right........ BUT, The media spokes person used a statement on behalf of Indian origin jewish youngsters "Proud to serve in Israeli military (till now everything is fine), but a step they wouldn't have considered in Indian Military (this didn't sound well, may be the media spokesperson quoted it wrong? )........ Just to add...... The video is 8 yrs old and there was no war to fight for.
@@explore39come on that's a 15 year old naive teen.
Kids her age will consider pizza without double cheese as discrimination too.
they consider Israel as their country because of persecution their ancestors came to India but they brought up like that Israel their won nation for their family work or other things they live here but when they cross 18 years they mostly move to Israel for army service then some live their some go to other country like America
1:30 - 1:40 - As an Indian, I feel a little sad (not hurt) to hear that they felt like 'strangers' in India. Perhaps, they were so busy being Jewish, that they did not try to understand India. Perhaps, we did not do a good job of making them feel at home. Perhaps, they were expecting some special treatment that were never aware of. Perhaps...whatever could be the reason. But, I can say for sure, that Jewish people were never treated as refugees, or even guests. They were only seen as one of us. As Indians.
There are so many different religions and cultures here that even we Indians have not heard so far. As a south Indian, Hindu, I keep discovering new Hindu gods everyday. North Indian Hindus aren't able to pronounce my South Indian Hindu name. And I can't pronounce their Hindu, or Islamic, or Zoroastrian, names correctly. So, it is not surprising that most of their friends have never heard of Judaism in India, let alone pronounce their names correctly. 30,000 Jews among 1.4 Billion ! What's the probability?
India is the only country where antisemitism practically doesn't exist. The Bene Israel people have lived here safely, and happily for over 2000 years (following a shipwreck). Baghdad Jews, and Zoroastrians came here to escape persecution. None were forced to convert.
India has always been a melting pot or all religions and cultures. An ancient United States. India only opposed those who came with an army to conquer us. Not refugees and guests who came seeking safe haven. None was asked to leave. None were treated differently. A Jew in India can become anything he/she wants to be, including the President or Prime Minister of India. Absolutely no stopping them.
But despite all this, if they feel at home only in Israel, we only wish them all happiness, peace and prosperity. If ever they want to return in the future, India's doors will always be open.
Well said man ❤
India committed a genocide against the Sikhs. Your excessive pride blinds you to other people's POV. If someone has a problem listen to them rather than suggesting they don't understand India or whatever.
Eloquently said....
#Hitler already told that jews are betrayer. Hence proved again 😏
I agree
India has classic unique prestigious Jewish history, I hope they tried to learn first. They're just youths as noted. I'm sure they love both.
well felt really hurt when the student and the reporter mentioned that they are like aliens, India was the only country you were not persecuted, you forefathers lived peacefully all these years in mighty India, sorry lady your comments struck of a line of my love for Israel and Jews.
+תומר שאשא sorry Ms. Jew you trying to sell oranges as apples.
i luvindia merabharatmahan What do you mean?
+תומר שאשא those kids say they feel alien in India, what does that mean, they have never stepped out and pass remarks of the country they were born and grew up, accept the fact that using the world alien is not right after spending 2000 years in India, and you are supporting them with your irrational statements.
i luvindia merabharatmahan I don't know how those kids feel and I can't speak for them. But you have to accept the fact that they see themselves part of the Jewish people first, and want to live among their people and not in a foreign place, and that does not mean anything bad against India or the Indian people.
right
i m Jewish-indian ☺
To Indians who are criticising them for leaving india, try to understand that it's in their religion that they have to return. bdw,
They are Marathi Jews also called Bene Israelis in Konkan. They are from Alibag, Maharashtra.
Ohh great. India is like vacation stop than huh? When in need come over here and when things are good you leave? fck that. You NEED to understand INDIA always comes FIRST! you are unpatriotic liberal piece of shit!
unfortunately INDIA became like a refugee center ,muslims came,jews came,Christians came,parsi came .Hindus got fucked by their own government .look in the video that girl hate india just because we didn't pronounce her name properly ?WTF is that ?
The way that girl showcase India that was shameful even after to know that only India was country which provided shelter to Jews when they were prosecuted in different part of the world. Nothing against Jews or Israelis we love them and I wish there could be more jews in India it could be better if we had 20 crore Jews rather then these muslims
Nitin Ramola why have more than 200 countries kicked Jews out??? Look into it. They are money loving hungry leach..Dont say you love them---you Love India and thats it. Fck the other people. India First. Dont be a love hugging bitch to everyone, be a patriot of YOUR country
root Who said Islam is pain and who said Hindus are suffering? Jaha dekho vaha. We are victim, we are victim act karte ho. Grow some balls- suffering/ pain? Bullcrap. Mard ban mard. Kabhi Shivaji aur Maharana Pratap ko esi batee karta suna hey? Stop playing victim card and grab a talwar. Understood. Stop all thses non-sense about Israel is my friend and jews r my friend. Fck that shit. Koi Indian ko to kabhi friend ki tarah treat karte nahi ho chale dusre desh ki juuti chatne.
The JEWS lives in COCHIN, MUMBAI, AHMEDABAD & in other parts of INDIA.
Identity of citizen of India is Indian. It's awkward if someone call you Aryan Indian, Dhraviran Indian, Sanatan Indian, Muslim Indian, Jews Indian, Sikh Indian. 1 Country 1 religion Indian.
Please note that Jews in India have never faced the anti semitism seen in other countries. Even if their names are Hebrew they are a welcome part of India’s unity in diversity. Can people not acknowledge this?
long live Israel long live india
india is always with jews and Israel people's
To all those saying i have no respect for my nation: I am a proud Indian and I am a proud jew. The video was taken when we had visited Israel on a trip. fyi I have no plans to leave India nor in the entire video did i ever say that i am planning to. i never in the entire video mentioned I hate India.
So whatever you people wanna interpret go ahead.. your views and opinions won't change the reality and my love for India.
@eilanit gadkar...it is very nice to see jews as part of india.
i know the concept of " returning to homeland". but trust me it is your choice where ever you want to go and live...
you will always be indian...there are so many nris. if there are american indians why cannot be israeli indian...
but i feel as indian i know nothing about jew people or jewish culture...because even in school-textbooks there is nothing about jew religion.
your comments on India has caused comment war between israelis and Indians (though not as bad as india pakistan ) .
My views are clear... Not my problem if people misinterpret.
It is ok. It is just the news outlet that picks and edits in a way that would trigger people and make them comment. Negative coverage helps them with algorithm and engagement
@@eilanitgadkar8871 yes..we are proud indian..our religion can be different but we are one nation❤❤..
India welcomed them 2000 years ago and they stayed here for all these years and the young indian jews joining the israel military, very sad. Y couldnt they serve in indian army and give something back to the country.
hahahah lol u even didn't know that mossad and raw have joint programs and institutions in India and israel
we already have crores of hindu sikh jain boudh people for our country but Israel have only jews soo we dont need them but Israel need them soo i dont think your comment have any logic jew and Israel have connection like hindu and bharat (india) have connection
Israel Indian friendship is unbreakable & uncompromising. Though you consider yourself a Jew, but we always consider you our brother. Love from Kerala BHARAT.
❤da mera😂
*The way she says I N D I A gives the perfect example of superiority complex of the West..*
The thing is. Israel is literally in the middle East , not west. But since Israel is a vassal of USA, so it seems it is kinda ok to call it "west" 😂.
By that logic, even Japan and S Korea are "west". 😂
as an indian hindu I say that we give them a citizenship from both countries india and Israel no matter where they want to live
Bhavesh Bhanushali Indian law prohibits dual citizenship. Something I'd like to change
@@daakudaddy5453 so that people can commit crime in one country and flee to another country? I am sure u r some super rich person who feels india in diffrnt way. Dual citizenhsip, never!
Born in India to Indian parents, look brown and feel discriminated when people around fail to pronounce your arabic name😂.Not to forget that some idiots feel Israel as their first country.Felt good that they ain't here anymore.
Motherfucker muhammad 😂😂😂
Like muslim who love Pakistan more than indian
C'mon dude I'm pretty sure the way you saying this you would prefer any islam majority state over anything
BHARAT DESH KI SANSKRITI SABSE BEST HAI YAHAN FLAT EARTH WAALE LOG ARYABHATT JAISO KO GYAAN NA PELE
Love to all my brothers
What kind of ridiculous reason is this that their economic condition is a fault of India and therefore they had to migrate ? There are economically weaker Hindus and a lots of them living in India,where do you suppose they should migrate to?
Indians cannot spell our names right,Indians can't do this..Indians can't do that..I mean this is ingratitude at its peak.There are many complex names among the very hindu community as well,If I were to ask a Jew to pronounce "Krishnamachari Srikanth" would he be able to pronounce it as fluently as a Hindu?The answer is plain NO and the reason is pretty obvious too.
There is one and only one reason they are bashing India,which is,Hindus aren't rich "Caucasians".Since they themselves aren't Whites and they have found their new home among much whiter Israelis,they cannot hold back the tendency of a Dull Complexioned person to bash their very own race in front of Caucasians.
Its better they left India.
I respect jews and israel. But dear indian jews do not spit on the plate that feeds you. that's all i have to say and VD Savarkar's theory was right. The land where the religion was born matters the most...secondary is the country you are born to.
i love israel🇮🇱 people
lomg live india israel friendship...
Nice to see this, but honestly I hope not all of India's Jews go to Israel permanently. It would be incredibly sad when there are no more Jews left in India. I wish they would go and live there for a few years maybe and then come back to India; It is incumbent on the rest of us Indians to make India even more attractive for jews to live and work so they are happy.
that girl say i cant live in india becoz they cant pronounce my name correctly
Indians in the comment should not get offended. The Indian people were good for the Jews and we are grateful for this. We have only good words to say about the Indians. But you must to understand that Jews still see the Jews as their people and want to live among them, not in the diaspora.
+תומר שאשא i like israel But you should know... india is a majorty Hindu.. But we also have many muslims and christian community here... if all Muslims say we dont belong to india and Christians say we dont belong to india... Its not cool... You born in india suddenly bcoz of religious reasons you wanna go... its like you ignore your own mom for some reason.. All country should embrace all religion... this world is for everyone... Religion is ur belief... we indians dont know much about Jewish religion im sure... Everyone in india will love to know about jewish community... Peace!!!
We are proud of all the Indian jews, and we have best wishes for them no matter where they live. You're always welcome back.
sanjay s There's a BIG difference between Christianity/ Islam and Judaism, that many non Jews don't understand.
Being a Jew isn't a religion. It's first and before all a nationality. Christianity and Islam are universal religions: they are open to everyone, and many people from different nationalities believe in them. Why is being a Jew different? to understand that we need to go back 1,900 years ago.
for more than 1,000 years, until 1900 years ago, all the Jews lived in the area of today Israel, in a Kingdom called Judah (or Israel). Jesus was a Jew who was born in that era. Than, 1,900 years ago, the Roman Empire destroyed the kingdom of Judah and exiled all it's people (the Jews) all over the Roman Empire. That's why there are Jews all over the world. The Jews all over the world, during all the 1,900 years until today, always saw themselves as Jews, people who are exiled from their home in Israel, and wanted to return. Jews in exile always kept their tradition, married usually other Jews, and had connections with other Jewish communities (even from far places.. for example in the 17th century there were many marriages between Jews in England and in Iraq).
All the Jews in the world prayed every year "for the next year in Jerusalem". Jews tried to return to Israel many times in the last 1,900 years, but usually in small numbers. But in the end of the 19th century the modern Zionist movement emerged, and it gave hope for all the Jews in the world to finally return to their home - so they returned in huge numbers.
Now that's what you must understand about the Jews who live in India - the Christians and Muslims of India are usually people native to India who just converted to Islam/ Christianity.
The Jews are refugees from the destroyed kingdom of Judah in Israel who found home in India (just like the Jews who found home in Germany and in Iraq and in Russia and in Iran), but are still part of the Jewish people and want to return to their home and people, in Israel. Judaism, unlike Christianity and Islam, isn't a missionary religion - we don't try to convert people to our religion. And Jews during history tried to marry with other Jews to keep their nation. That's why the people who are Jews are, unlike in Christianity and Islam, usually not native to the place they live. And as I said being a Jew isn't a religion at all - I am an atheist and I'm a Jew, Albert Einstein was an atheist Jew, and the father of Zionism, Hertzel, was an atheist Jew.. It's first a nationality, than a religion (that almost only people from the Jewish nationality believe in).
I hope you understand now the difference.
We Jews are grateful to your people that you were good to our people while they found home and safety in your country - but you must understand that they see themselves as part of the Jewish people (and they really are) and want to live with their people just like you want to live with your people.. and that's ok.
i respect the Jewish community i wish someday i visit Israel but i didn't like the way that girl said... like no one pronounced her name properly etc... im a hindu and if someone from Israel didn't pronounce my name properly i cant go complain... Anyway we indians love Jewish people... :) +תומר שאשא
+תומר שאשא thanks for taking your time to explain about Jewish religion and its history...
This is a very old posting 😮
Can i24 news interview Cochin Jews staying in Israel?
Why are so many people so hurt in the comments? These people are ethnically Jewish, although they share cultural ties to india. Their blood runs through Israel and their ancient customs and traditions are celebrated there. It's like meeting a part of your family you were never able to meet.
They finally got to visit a place where they don't feel like the odd one out and it was a nice experience for them being able to get in touch with that part of their identity. Yet there are Indians in the comments calling them traitors for being excited and expressing the way they felt about coming to Israel. That seems very uncalled for
common enemies make stronger friends
proud to be an *insert nationality here*
Indian Jewish community is always welcome along with the Israeli Jewish people... come, explore India... you are always welcome.. with open arms, love, and respect. Long live the State of Israel, with peace and prosperity... India is always on your side.
we love you too.amd we allways will.
Israel love with India will be like America and england of the east
love from india😙
My PM even not knowingly, how many Jews are in India.. shook hands with ...Many were from N.E. India!!
love Israel from India ... I really want to travel Israel once .
it's an humiliation to us we don't expect that from an indian jew.. i mean they look more indian than an Israeli
So long "strangers" stay there, don't look back.
Long live india long live israel sholem israel people very good people long live huminisam no vepon no war only peace humanity man's of the world's unity girish kumar huminist I frome india man's of the world's unity girish kumar huminist
Hindus from India always support🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱💪💪💪❤❤❤🇮🇳🇮🇳
Only andhbakts
I'm Indian and I didn't even know india had Jewish people
so its good that now you know. travel to kerela and see foir yourself all the history in fort cochin. still there are so many sighns in Hebrew and still there is the well knowen eria called "the jew town" and a well knowen sinagouge. there was a very old jewish comunity there. most of them left and came ti israel or ather countries
wooww amazing to India
What non sense! I'm an Indian Muslim 🇮🇳 and how can these people insult our country like this?? They shouldn't forget that they are Indians , look like Indians and talk like Indians doesn't matter if they Jewish!
Arre tu mad*rch*d m*slim, Pakistan nhi gaya? Chal nikal l*vde, Aat@nkwadi
We shouldn't care about them anymore because they consider themselves as isrealis
Sad to know..
Is there any Jews from Gujarat
It's high time we as Indians recognised the Hindus all across the world as a rightful Indian citizens of the country! Many Islamic republics nobody cares! One Hindu country, everybody looses their minds! Jai Hind...... Jai Karnataka!
they are not fully grown ups , when they will read whole history, they will know the value. Anyways sorry my Jewish friends for mispronouncing ur names
respecting your sentiments is more important than pronouncing your name correct...feel bad that as a indiAn we respect Jews but indian Jews seem to be unhappy here...
Indian and Israel are true friend
I even don't know about Jews in India and Indian Jews. why they are migrating to Israel from india. but I'm learning about that
They are Marathis man!
I'm a Malaysian Indian... My grandfather was from India Tamil Nadu. And how do I get to know if I'm a Jew? I just love Israel, the Hebrew language & I started not to eat pork according to the Old Testament. I'm a born again Christian but the church I attend follows almost like the Jewish procession. We have a Shofar mostly... How do I find out if I'm a Jew?
Thank u.
Are you in TPM Church ?
To find out if you have jewish ethnicity there are different DNA tests; tests like ancestry DNA go back about 10 generations.
Ask you mum!
😂😂😂 you are tamilian hindu you are from chola Kingdom
@@metasploit5660 no I'm not 🤣🤣🤣 I'm a Naidu, Pather & Pillai mix from both sides of my parents family 🤣 I'm a Christian baptized the moment I was born. I'm not a Hindu & I am a child of God!
Indians should be proud that they never persecuted Jews...
Love, Care and Peace between Peoples of Hinduism and Judaism.
Victory for Zions!. Jai Hind!
why Jews wants to leave India ? its their land too ..what difference he see in Indian army ?
taking religion first= civil war.
nation first=world war
humanity first=family discord
what to do..............................
all Israeli are my brother's and sister
ISRAEL ARMY ZINDABAD
INDIAN ARMY ZINDABAD
Same to you
She is Marathi, her pronounciation say that 😊😘
You fucking idiots, India has given you a place for everything - freedom of expression, freedom of religion, right to live, right to education, a place to build your shelter...and what not? You grew up breathing Indian air, developed your brain/knowledge by Indian intellectuals, fed on Indian sweats by hard-working leaders...and what not? HOW DARE BETRAY YOUR OWN MOTHERLAND??? India never force you & your family to become Jew/Hindu/Christian. You only chose that. HOW CAN YOU TURN YOUR BACK TO YOUR OWN MOTHERLAND just for your religion? Fuck your religion. Please don't mind my language cos you deserve worst than that.
Info Bank Never judge people, you haven't been in their shoes. You know nothing of Judaism and the Jewish homeland. Didn't you see the full video? The talk about feeling of not belonging to India. It's possible. Jews from all over the world (including US and western Europe) migrate to Israel because it's a part of their religion to get back to the 'Homeland'. Their generations did chose to stay in India during the rough times of colonialism, famines, partition and wars, despite creation of Israel at about the same time as India.
Though I am sad about this that some would like to migrate, but I can understand it the pleasure of being among people of your kind, who understand your way and culture.
Side note: They are all things evil, but Sundar Pichai, Satya Nadela and Indra Nooyi make us proud? We have double standards, don't we?
Ashish Zexx, now don't tell me you're one among them. First of all, you should not have judged me - what if I'm a jew? You hypocrits... Go away from India if you don't belong to this country. None stops you!!! Why do you have to SHOUT OUT LOUD that you don't belong to India? Thanks for being a critic, but I clearly do not appreciate your brainless, irrational comments.
Info Bank Of course you're not Jewish and don't know even one tiny bit about the importance of Jerusalem for people of Jewish faith... that much is clear from the tone you take. This is not judging, this is simple deduction.
You completely lack perspective or even the ability to think about complex matters with that hollow cerebrum of yours that is barely capable of one dimensional hysterical thinking. Let alone understand them.
I've been nothing but polite, but you take the offensive and insult to make up for lack of argument. You're so small a person, you can't even handle a simple difference of opinion with composure.
Enjoy life with your lens of small thinking, you'll amount to much of a person.
Info Bank Who the hell are you to judge people who's life you don't understand? Have you ever met one of these people? I know you haven't.. You don't know their life, how they feel, the challenges and prospects they have, and out of nowhere you come here dictating what they should do? Who the hell died and made you a Rabbi (that's equivalent to a Priest for Jews, in case you don't know, which actually is the case)
So keep your mindless opinions to yourself and thanks for being active on the internet. You don't have anything to contribute to humanity anyway...
Go to Jerusalem! You don't have to teach me your patriotism here in India, you emotional fool. Keep your politeness with yourself - I've read your comments to others, you've been very rude to everyone for nothing.
You assume yourself that everyone is a fool to you. When I was three, my granny taught me: Rabbi means Teacher, simply meaning present days' Priest. Mind your words and lets stop personalizing because nobody's hell died for me and your hell didn't made me a Rabbi.
I am citizen of that country to where I belong - India is my Motherland and I will serve for my country.
Genral JFR jacob was a true patriot he lived his entire life in india he took the surrender of pakistani genral in 1971 war
Who gives a shit what anybody thinks of us. We just do whatever the hell we need to do, and there ain't nothing anybody can do about it. If they come as friends, they're welcome and if not, then it proved to be their last destination. So many came and went. History testifies everything....
let me tell you 1 think jews people !!! hindus never hate jew ..... !! we love you sooo much
We will be in Support to our Jewish community and Israel.....
🇮🇳❤🇮🇱
It's ok man even we Hindus when we go to another countries we also start comparing our own India and other country.
We always talk maybe India could have been more developed maybe it could have been more cleaner like that.
But the one thing stands out is that we Hindus feels ONLY AND ONLY INDIA AS our home. No matter how much we complaint about India in other countries but finally we advocate for the country where Hindus are majority...
So the Jews are doing same inside they love India but in Israel they are feeling like home as Jewish are majority there. Just like we Hindus we feel more home in India Hindustan Bharat !!!
*Jews from other countries- Exodus, attrocities
*Jews from India- mispronounciation of their names
thanx for remarks on India
Oooohh hooo So that's what they think of us and I was 'falling in love' with jews people for no reason well great for you.it's Shameful wht she said but thanks for living here on our land for 2000 years without being persecuted she could only criticize us cuz she is alive not like other countries were Jews were not even alive today to 'criticize' them
"establishment of the Israel in 1984.." - try 1948... fail....
why dont they look like israeli jews, are they mixed with locals or wheather changed them
+shivayogi hanchanal They don't have original Jewish genes.. They are mixed..
I admire too much Israel, a little country of big energy, braverty, intelligence and much more, Like me too much to compare Israel with Chile my own country. like a history teacher in my school named Republic of Israel i job heavy for what my students learn all the possible of Israel. Shalom!!!!
Shalom!
I live in UK, people they just wonder seeing me , your Indian Jew, never met any indisn jew before lol.
Bro please Jews are most welcome , don’t say diminish , we never want you to leave
the news reporter is so pretty , just sayin :D
y Jewish leaving india sad to know that Jewish are always welcome in india. I request my Jewish brother not to leave india
Common guys, india is for those people who consider themselves as indian first 🇮🇳. Its good they went to their beloved country isreal🇮🇱 and they might face racism there but we indians should mind our own business 😌.
I think if they r proud in being jews, they shud also say proudly they r Indians.
I knw israel is the land of Jews jst lyk India is d land of hindus. bt they r gonna hv to stay in india if they wanna grow nd gain respect. it's not India's fault that they r so less in population.
incredibly stupid girl trying to feel important by showing herself different .comes with her age.hopes she outgrows it.
Getting ignored and discriminated are 2 different things, if not for social media many doesn't even know that Jews live in India and they came to India like 2000 yrs ago, they're filled up with their own daily issues, 99% of Indians will never get chance to meet Jew in a first place.
Jewish r India from 1000 years of time..and dear pls try to pronounce Jewish properly..
This is OUR DEMOCRATIC INDIA. But on the other side Pakistan the Jews have disappeared. All that remains r just graves n a handful of Jews who call themselves Qureshis to save their lives.
But bro I'm muslim and Qureshi to
they should live in INDIA ANY RELIGION CAN LIVE WITH US
Any Indian Jews here
these are jank of india
bettar to let tham go
scrap not allowed in india
indian government should give jews parsi and jain community special minority status with some extra privilage
why jain
parsis and Jews acceptable but why jains?
i luvindia merabharatmahan yeah why jains they are part of hinduism.
Y
Who care Jewish or lauda lahsun this is totally myth Jewish are very intelligent so what happened in India they gave nothing to India also same they ignored by Israeli Jewish
India love Israel. every Israelian r my brother's and sisters
To be frank most of the bene Israeli had forgotten many of its religious practices it's because of immigration of Bagdadi jews in 19 and 20th centuries they could revive them.
The children talking bad about India owe their present existence to India. Don't forget that..
But such jews must negligible.
Why none of them look like JEWS? They look very Indian, have they not read Torah?
Do you think the original Hebrews looked European with white skin and blonde hair 😂😂😂😂 They look more like the biblical Jews than the European Jews who are not even genetically related to the ancient Hebrews. The original Jews are brown skinned people like other people from the Middle East, they are Middle Eastern, not from Poland or Germany or Ukraine.
I want to marry the anchor :)
Indians are discriminated in Israel so are Ethiopians, Eritreans and Palestinian Jews. Israel is a colonial state.