It sounds great! I came across this while searching for other versions, and this is one of the best German ones And after this i checked out your other song called "grandpa died at Christmas" and that was great as well!
Glory To The Working Class, For The Socialist Future . Слава Рабочему Классу , За Социалистическое Будущее . Lob an die Arbeiterklasse , Für die sozialistische Zukunft . You performed the song perfectly . Вы отлично исполнили песню . Sie haben das Lied perfekt gespielt .
i really find it fascinating how many differnet versions of this song exist, its a bit like drunken sailor with its many different lyrics.. oh and verry well sung btw it sounds amazing :)
Sembles un autèntic alemany!!! I'm sure that people who speaks more of two languages have a privileged brain and if above play ukulele like you do then... "és per treure's el barret" ;-) Congrats
No, I am from Ireland, but I did have a German girlfriend in my University days. And I first sang this song in a theatre show called: "An Evening with Berthold Brecht".
Great rendition!! If I may ask, where are you from? I see you replying in English, Russian and German so I'm a bit confused. Again, great rendition! Glad it got recommended to me!!
Thanks a lot. So many people never relate the word "beautiful" with the German language. As for socialism, the totalitarian farces that claimed that title in the 20th century gave it a bad name. But the basic premise of a fair society for all is something every decent human being would surely wish for. And when you view it's opponents, like Trump, Bolsonaro, etc you see they are anything but decent people. ❤
@@berniarmstrongI love this song and other socialist music, but I can't agree with communism being something good even in theory. I think it's repulsive and absolutely evil from it's roots, a classless society where the hard working and the lazy are forced into the same class, the talented and the useless are treated the same, that discourages hard work and promotes laziness. It's morally wrong to wish for a classless society, even if you ignore the difficulties I applying it in real life.
@@Aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa-i8y You haven't understood the basics of Marxist ideology (neither did most of the leaders of the USSR 😉). It was never about bringing everyone down to a certain level, it was about fairness, justice and bringing the best out of people. The fact that certain states in the 20th Century (and a couple today) claimed themselves to be "communist" is easily shown to be a false claim. A totalitarian state can never be socialist, let alone communist. I agree with you there are difficulties in creating a fairer society, but that is no reason to dismiss the idea out of hand.
@berniarmstrong I'm talking about communism because most socialists defend communism. My problem is with communism rather than socialism because in socialism you still can have more than others. I agree that a totalitarian state can never be communist because communism itself is stateless (and because communism can't possibly exist because it's a contradiction in and on itself), but a classless society will never be fair and it will never bring the best out of people, because classless implies bringing everyone down to the same level.
@@Aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa-i8y So what is the advantage of a class based society, then? Obviously there is a benefit for the exploiter, but not for the exploited, surely?
Pretty good German pronunciation. My only critique would be that you make the last line in the chorus sound like "kein Arbeiter" (No worker) and not "ein Arbeiter" (a worker)
Не должно быть никаких причин, по которым вы не можете сделать версию на акустической гитаре. Удачи в изучении инструмента. практика делает совершенным.
It's a six string ukulele. The first and third strings are doubled. The first has a lower octave string on it and the third a higher octave one. You can certainly play this song on a normal uke, because the tuning is the same. But you won't get the fuller sound that a six string ukulele has. By the way, don't confuse a six string ukulele with a Guitalele, which also has six strings, but they are tuned and set up quite differently.
If you are taken in by the Milton Friedman doctrine that has had forty years to prove its case and failed utterly, then I am guessing that you are alone here. The gap between rich and poor has never been wider since the 17th century; the middle classes have been decimated, their children will have less opportunities than they did; the climate crisis threatens to leave large areas of the planet uninhabitable causing mass movements of people into already crowded areas, etc. I could go on. Is that what you call success? As for communism, please don't confuse that with the Totalitarian farce that had the cheek to call itself that under Stalin and his heirs.
@@berniarmstrong and why is communism and its brother, fascism always start in the same place: a poor country. Such as Russia, which was poor in 1917 due to the Tsar’s poor decisions in World War I. Germany, also had the rise of fascism because of hyper inflation of the German mark and poverty. Poverty, which was increasing not because of capitalism, but because of poor government decisions. You cannot blame capitalism, but the government itself.
@@berniarmstrong now, I am not a full on capitalist, I just believe that capitalism is a good system for the people. There is an equal opportunity for all, if you go to school and use experience, while communism just means the economy will collapse. How? Well, in simple terms, if everyone is “rich” and have more money or wealth to buy more things, thus creating a situation where More is Bought than Produced, then the producers and retail will increase prices, making inflation. Inflation will mean that people will have the burden of bringing more money TO buy basic products, just like how it is in America thanks to Joe Biden and his leftist policies.
![German Soldier Sings - Die Grenzwacht hielt im Osten [LIVE][+ English Translation]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/T-Vr5lIshXo/mqdefault.jpg)
It took UA-cam 6 whole years to reccommend this, I love your rendition of this classic! :)
Wow, thank you! Please feel free to check out my playlist of Spanish Civil War related songs I have written.
@@berniarmstrong I certainly will! :)
same lol
his voice sound so good
Same
yo cortex I know you
Long live the revolution! ☭
Visca la classe obrera!
Wunderschön gesungen Genosse! ❤
Danke schon
German has never been a beautiful language to me, but i just adore your singing.
Thank you Nico. German can sound lovely. It depends who is speaking / singing it.
It depends. South and north german is very different.
Viva la Commune! 🎉
So glad I got recommended this! Kinda helped me with studies.
As a retired teacher, I am so glad to hear that!
A wonderful performance of the song! I wish you further success and good luck!
Glory to the Workers' Front!
Слава Рабочему Фронту!
Spasiva!
WEIL DU AUCH EIN ARBEITER BIST! Sehr schön 🚩✊🏻
This might be the best version ive heard so far. Definitely compares to the Hannes Wader version!
Thanks so much!
It sounds great! I came across this while searching for other versions, and this is one of the best German ones
And after this i checked out your other song called "grandpa died at Christmas" and that was great as well!
Thanks for the listens.
Вдохновенно!!!
Спасибо
Glory To The Working Class, For The Socialist Future . Слава Рабочему Классу , За Социалистическое Будущее . Lob an die Arbeiterklasse , Für die sozialistische Zukunft . You performed the song perfectly . Вы отлично исполнили песню . Sie haben das Lied perfekt gespielt .
Kraft der Arbeiter!
Хорошо играете, привет из России! Да здравствует Революция!!🚩✊
This is really rather good - and it introduced me to all of your other songs, and so many of them are beautiful.
Thank you very much oh humped backed one 😁
Check out my Playlist of songs related to the Spanish Civil War.
Such a great performance, huge respect from Vietnam ❤
Thanks a lot!
I saw the title and thought that it was saying that the workers United front lied about something
@@jownadel1526 Ha ha ha!
Excellent performance Genosse, and thanks for chords)
I’ve been looking for a different version of this song since 2016.. took you long enough algorithm
@@zeldius3397 I thank the algorithm that you found my version.
vielen dank. gern mehr solcher lieder
Danke.
Kamerad! Ausgezeichnet!!
Powerful stuff, Berni ... and your German sounds very authentic (not that I really speak it!)
most english speakers struggle with the german ch and r sound but he pronounces them in a very authentic way
Wow, really good pronounciation and i love the rhythm! Well done
Thanks so much. I am especially pleased because I barely speak German. But I love Brecht.
So happy that I found this version. It's great! Greatings from Magdeburg :)
Thanks so much. I was worried about German speakers feeling I was destroying their language.
Meine deutsch ist feuchbar :-)
No way 7 years ago was 2017????
i really find it fascinating how many differnet versions of this song exist, its a bit like drunken sailor with its many different lyrics.. oh and verry well sung btw it sounds amazing :)
Thanks very much.
beautiful playing
Superklasse! Strict rhythm and strong language, perfect!
Moltes mercès :)
日本からこんにちは！
同志の演奏に励まされ感激しています❤🎉
Sembles un autèntic alemany!!! I'm sure that people who speaks more of two languages have a privileged brain and if above play ukulele like you do then... "és per treure's el barret" ;-) Congrats
Musik der Leute soll von der Leute besingen
Sie singen sehr gut 🙏
Danke schön!
@@berniarmstrong Bitte sehr 🙏
Are you from Germany? Because your pronounciation is great! Stay splendid o7
No, I am from Ireland, but I did have a German girlfriend in my University days. And I first sang this song in a theatre show called: "An Evening with Berthold Brecht".
KLASSE! Roth front;❤❤❤
Danke!
Wow. Different to hear you sing in German. Cool.
Thanks, Gina.
Arbeiter voran❤❤
Moltes Mercès
Viva aos camponeses Alemães! GREETINGS FROM BRAZIL!!! ☭ 🇧🇷🚩
Great rendition!! If I may ask, where are you from? I see you replying in English, Russian and German so I'm a bit confused. Again, great rendition! Glad it got recommended to me!!
I am Irish
Glad you liked it
Привет из России!
Привет, вернулся!
Здравствуй!
Cool singing
Danke schön!
@@berniarmstrong bitte mein freund
Рабочим - винтовки
Буржуям - верёвки
Убейте систему, а не людей
greetings from a brazilian comrade ❤
Obrigado
Дед ты лучший
Spasiva!
No pasaran!!
I’m not a Socialist or any of its other forms but that is very beautiful singing:)
Thanks a lot. So many people never relate the word "beautiful" with the German language. As for socialism, the totalitarian farces that claimed that title in the 20th century gave it a bad name. But the basic premise of a fair society for all is something every decent human being would surely wish for. And when you view it's opponents, like Trump, Bolsonaro, etc you see they are anything but decent people. ❤
@@berniarmstrongI love this song and other socialist music, but I can't agree with communism being something good even in theory. I think it's repulsive and absolutely evil from it's roots, a classless society where the hard working and the lazy are forced into the same class, the talented and the useless are treated the same, that discourages hard work and promotes laziness. It's morally wrong to wish for a classless society, even if you ignore the difficulties I applying it in real life.
@@Aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa-i8y You haven't understood the basics of Marxist ideology (neither did most of the leaders of the USSR 😉). It was never about bringing everyone down to a certain level, it was about fairness, justice and bringing the best out of people.
The fact that certain states in the 20th Century (and a couple today) claimed themselves to be "communist" is easily shown to be a false claim. A totalitarian state can never be socialist, let alone communist. I agree with you there are difficulties in creating a fairer society, but that is no reason to dismiss the idea out of hand.
@berniarmstrong I'm talking about communism because most socialists defend communism. My problem is with communism rather than socialism because in socialism you still can have more than others. I agree that a totalitarian state can never be communist because communism itself is stateless (and because communism can't possibly exist because it's a contradiction in and on itself), but a classless society will never be fair and it will never bring the best out of people, because classless implies bringing everyone down to the same level.
@@Aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa-i8y So what is the advantage of a class based society, then?
Obviously there is a benefit for the exploiter, but not for the exploited, surely?
wow
Glad you were wowed! 😉
Pretty good German pronunciation. My only critique would be that you make the last line in the chorus sound like "kein Arbeiter" (No worker) and not "ein Arbeiter" (a worker)
Thanks, I will remember that next time I sing it.
got this beautiful reccomendation just now smh
Thanks so much!
¡No pasarán!
Привет из России!
✊🏽
привет товарищ, скажи пожалуйста, на акустической гитаре можно сыграть эту песню?
Не должно быть никаких причин, по которым вы не можете сделать версию на акустической гитаре. Удачи в изучении инструмента. практика делает совершенным.
@@berniarmstrong спасибо за ответ товарищ
Lenin would be proud.
Spasiva!
bro when he sees loot from a player I killed:
A cada canço em sorprens més 😂
Mercès. Es part de la meva intenció ;)
Gute Aussprache
Vielen dank
what type of ukulele is that sir? can I do it in a normal ukulele
It's a six string ukulele. The first and third strings are doubled. The first has a lower octave string on it and the third a higher octave one.
You can certainly play this song on a normal uke, because the tuning is the same. But you won't get the fuller sound that a six string ukulele has.
By the way, don't confuse a six string ukulele with a Guitalele, which also has six strings, but they are tuned and set up quite differently.
@@berniarmstrong thx for the answer sir
Қызыл Революцияның Даңқы!
Кыһыл Революция Албан Аата!
Слава Красной Революции!
Саясаткерлерге емес, халыққа даңқ!
@@berniarmstrong Жұмысшыларға және шаруаларға
o7
☭
Новый привет из России
Spasiva!
Rotfront!
Ja, danke!
Rotfront verrecke!
@@derlinksfaschist8136 Dieser Moment wenn man Kommunist und Nationalist gleichzeitig ist. Vollidiot.
@@nasenturke7482 Wieso bin ich Kommunist?
@@derlinksfaschist8136 Sozialistische/Kommunistische Lieder uploaden und in seiner Kanalbeschreibung vom Prolet reden.
Dein Deutsch ist sehr leicht zu verstehen!
Danke schön.
Wow I am the only one here who has common sense about modern economics and how communism is a bunch of lies.
How so is communism a bunch of lies?
If you are taken in by the Milton Friedman doctrine that has had forty years to prove its case and failed utterly, then I am guessing that you are alone here. The gap between rich and poor has never been wider since the 17th century; the middle classes have been decimated, their children will have less opportunities than they did; the climate crisis threatens to leave large areas of the planet uninhabitable causing mass movements of people into already crowded areas, etc. I could go on. Is that what you call success?
As for communism, please don't confuse that with the Totalitarian farce that had the cheek to call itself that under Stalin and his heirs.
@@berniarmstrong communism makes people become “rich” and have everything in life, am I correct?
@@berniarmstrong and why is communism and its brother, fascism always start in the same place: a poor country. Such as Russia, which was poor in 1917 due to the Tsar’s poor decisions in World War I. Germany, also had the rise of fascism because of hyper inflation of the German mark and poverty. Poverty, which was increasing not because of capitalism, but because of poor government decisions. You cannot blame capitalism, but the government itself.
@@berniarmstrong now, I am not a full on capitalist, I just believe that capitalism is a good system for the people. There is an equal opportunity for all, if you go to school and use experience, while communism just means the economy will collapse. How? Well, in simple terms, if everyone is “rich” and have more money or wealth to buy more things, thus creating a situation where More is Bought than Produced, then the producers and retail will increase prices, making inflation. Inflation will mean that people will have the burden of bringing more money TO buy basic products, just like how it is in America thanks to Joe Biden and his leftist policies.