If Israel doesn’t want a ceasefire, what does it want? | The Bottom Line
Вставка
- Опубліковано 5 чер 2024
- Israeli leaders insist on an open-ended war in Gaza until the Palestinian group Hamas is defeated, but this goal is a “fantasy”, argues former Israeli government adviser Daniel Levy.
Levy, president of the US/Middle East Project, tells host Steve Clemons that the biggest problem is the Joe Biden administration’s refusal to act as a superpower and stop bankrolling Israel’s war.
Levy also explains how the war on Gaza has put the ideology of Zionism “under the microscope”, and how Israel and the West have prevented the Palestinians from rebuilding a robust national liberation movement.
Subscribe to our channel bit.ly/AJSubscribe
Follow us on Twitter / ajenglish
Find us on Facebook / aljazeera
Check our website: www.aljazeera.com/
Check out our Instagram page: / aljazeeraenglish
Download AJE Mobile App: aje.io/AJEMobile
#Israel #Palestine #Hamas #AlJazeera #Netanyahu #Zionism #MiddleEast #Gaza #israelhamaswar
Netanyahu wants ALL of the land that Palestinians have & had.
and he wants to deport or kill everyone
Even south Libanon 🇱🇧 , Irak 🇮🇶, Jordania 🇯🇴, Sinaï ! They want apocalyps for ther fals Messiah !
Why is Egypt not taking in the Palestinian mothers, children & babies?
@Petal4822 that's helping ethnic cleansing .. how disingenuous are you
He has it already :)
Israel want all Palestinian lands
Why is Egypt not taking in the Palestinian mothers, children & babies?
Palestine never existed.
@jil9019 your fake BRO ffs
@@Petal4822you again .. just copying and pasting yeh .. bot
Without the Palestinians.👌
The answer is simple it wants Gaza.
But without the Gazans. 💔
The people of Gaza need to hoof it into Egypt….most Gazans are Egyptian Arabs anyway.
Lebanon and syria also part of 🇮🇱
They already had Gaza in 2005, but they returned it. Clearly, the correct answer is that they want Hmas, not Gza.
@@Petal4822 Egypt is irrelevant to this situation. Egypt is its own sovereign entity. Israel cannot expect for other nations to simply do what is convenient and expedient for Israel. Egypt has every right to lock its own border from refugees from this conflict.
The word “Pause” is a joke! He sent billions worth of weapons already. It’s a complete insult to common intelligence.
& you don't need long line nets to go fishing in a bowl!
Israel's actions for the last 80 years have made it quite clear what they want. The US and Britain's actions are also clearly saying that they know what Israel wants and that they support it. All of these parties, Britain for about 100 years now, have been very consistent with their actions as it relates to this land and the people who live there. There is no need for any of them to verbalize what their intentions are. Actions speak louder than words.
Don't west time netanyahu must arrest
If the British are so generous why don't they give zionists a piece of their own land ?
Why did the US and UK refuse to supply weapons to Israel in 1948. Israel had to purchase most of the weapons used in war of independence from Czechoslovakia under control of Stalin in Russia.
@@michaelw2288 Why did Israel attack the USS Liberty? I could care less about that country after all they have done that is against the interests of the US and theyre supposed to be an ally. Laughable
Maybe you're thinking wrong just maybe,
No america and no england wants to see Hamas-isis in their countries.
Just a thought.
It is making me feel deep shame for being Jewish and sadness and anger toward family members who support Israel. Never again, means never again for everyone. Feel for the Palestinian plight.
Do not be ashamed of being Jewish! Many Christians are zionists, but most are not. Many Jews are not zionists either. Peace be with you. Luke 19: 41-44.
Don't be.
You have humanity, and you are on the right side.
Keep the love. Keep it up✊🏼❤️
You are the one with the plight!
Do not feel this way. Help them with social media and walks xxx
😂😂😂😂
"If Israelis don't want to be accused of being like the Nazis, they simply need to stop behaving like Nazis." - Norman Finkelstein
The Nazis were those that genocided Jews. And Gaza looks just like Berlin in '45. And for the same reason. They genocided Jews.
son of hamas co-founder: hamas is evil"
Pretty lame quote, who the f cares what Israelis want?
Actually Palestinians are the Semite ,all the Isrealis are European converts,no one talks about the real semites.
Most Israelis are Mizrahi, so you can flush your argument down the toilet.
Not true at all..
@@lukazupie7220it is very true you dumbass! ask your self how does one set of people look like ALL the europeans but they are “jew” and look nothing like the rest of the middle eastwrn countries surrounding them? second are you denying the holocaust? where dis jews leave from if they are native to palestinian land?😂😂😂😂😂😂
Israel DOESN'T care what Arabic Islam says...
Arabs with the Koran, even Allah Himself, have no certificate or right to judge the identity of Israeli residents
Everytime I mention the fact that these people are from Poland 🇵🇱 the Ukraine 🇺🇦 Russia and Germany 🇩🇪 UA-cam bans me for 24 hours calling the truth hate speech
Thank you Al Jazzera and Daniel for trying to bring peace to the world.
The hole land without the population oil and gas industry
Where's the oil??? Lol. How stupid.
@@marielouisenilsson3766 under the soil of gazza
@@marielouisenilsson3766 dont you follow the news why build a seaport while so many aid trucks waiting on the border
@@marielouisenilsson3766 It's offshore in Gaza's water and on land. The oldest motive of colonialism in the book..resources. Other people's.
@@marielouisenilsson3766 lol hasbra failure. the rights to drill have already been sold. too bad bots have no intelligence to look it up
One thing must be changed in the Israeli society to offer equality for the Palestinian people who are still refugees with a continual reduction of their land by illegal settlements. The shipping people in from other countries and nations that will hold dual citizenship as "settlers" must be stopped immediately. Many of these land thieves are bad actors, who see an opportunity to steal, kill and destroy with impunity. Others see an opportunity to glean the benefits from where they come from and from low cost housing, free medical and other opportunities from moving to a land their ancestors from the time of Babylonian captivity, never lived in or even wanted to return to, once they were free to do so, and they were.
I've found it difficult to stomach seeing so many people who are walking around with such pride and arrogance, enjoying all the benefits of this regime who are obviously not from the region due to not only their appearance, but also how they speak. As an American veteran I resent our tax dollars of billions upon billions going to support them. I'm not alone in this sentiment. Americans are sick of it and those who've just been made aware of it are outraged by it.
The Israeli apartheid military regime is not a democracy. Just as the Palestinian Authority needs to be changed, so does this regime.
yes they are really. A lot of settlers are there with ill intentions, probably people who never worked, amounted to anything before, go there to feel superior and enjoy the lawlessness land and wealth grab of natives.
NO Biden nor Trump
That means Trump will win. His supporters worship him. He can’t do no wrong in their view.
@@cyrusparsa1724 Hi Joebama!
@cyrusparsa1724 they believe trump is the chosen one
@@cyrusparsa1724 yeah must suck to be an American Democratic voter right now. The ones with consistent morals at least. Between a rock and a hard place.
This has all been very hard to watch from the sidelines (New Zealand)
@@coreyjblakey Yes, seems like the U.S. is at an inflection point, so many are disgusted with the hand wringing, and bulllshit coming out of all the administration's agents mouths, I cannot vote for anyone that isn't totally against the war mongering, and allowing this horrific genocide proceed with our tax dollars. Jill Stein is the Green Party's candidate, it will be interesting to see what path the Americans take, I am one.
1948. NEVER FORGET
10 countries attacking Israel? Or just consequences?
Nakba
@@nom_chompsky ?
Israhell is the squatters on the Palestinians land. It’s was always Palestine 🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🍉🍉🍉🫒🫒🫒
Also dont forget Oct 7th...........
Not only does it want Gaza as its own territory it is banking on the idea that they will be able to secure the offshore gas that is off the Gaza border. They have explicitly told BPN on that they had interest in the area, and they wanted to sell the rights to dig multiple gas companies in the region.
It is sheer, greed, and capitalistic resource bargaining. That is causing this.
Yes, Gaza marine has Gas, Lebanon and Cyprus have has, West bank has oil.
In 1948 after Israel declared independence (end of british rule), Jordan army crossed the Jordan river into Judea & Samaria (known as the west bank by MSM) and east Jerusalem. The Jordan army killed or drove away the Jewish people. The Jordan army then destroyed Jewish property or took it over. Jordan then encouraged Jordanian settlement in the occupied land. Jewish property not destroyed became occupied by Jordanians. After the Israeli victory in 1967 and Jordnian disillusionment with their expansion effort (1988), Jordan revoked the Jordanian citizenship of "palestinians" in Judea & Samaria (known as the west bank by MSM) and east Jerusalem. For the most part "palestinians" are leftover Jordanian colonist (Gaza residents more closely tied to Egypt). The homeland of the majority of "palestinians" is Jordan.
As an American I have noticed for some time most middle eastern policy is directed out of Jerusalem with only minor deviations tolerated. AIPAC and JDL are very powerful here full of vengeance and victimhood towards any one who dares to speak against Israel. Very sad experience for those of us who pay attention to Gaza horrors.
DOES ANYBODY REMEMBER THE KILLING FIELDS OF CAMBODIA
Another pet project of the USA
Or the nightly treat on TV showing the hacked dead bodies floating down a river by the tens of thousands night after night in Rwanda while Clinton sat on his hands?!
Yes, never thought any country would ever want to follow in pol pots footsteps gaza is a killing field at the hands of Netanyahu and all the rhetoric has not bought forward any action to stop the ethnic cleansing.
I have read about those, horrifying. This case is so similar. And we are watching it happen in real time whilst being gaslit by the mainstream media that “It’s not happening, it’s not a genocide, it’s ‘human shields’”. We are not stupid.
Look! A deed to a cattle ranch!
Free Palestine
OK !! TOMORROW....
at last yr promise is heartening.
Hamas won’t let palastine be free
Israel won't let hamas be
Zionists won't let Israel be
Land. Land for free. Access to oil reserves. And so on...
Oil reserves? Explain.
@@MIKEENBAR sure, check the UN trade and development (UNCTAD study) about the sizable oil and natural gas reserves that West Bank sits on and the Mediterranean coast off Gaza strip.
This must be updated because the 1 billion in weapons went there!!
so far $2.3 Billion in wepons and $7.2 Billion financial AID
Why is Egypt not taking in the Palestinian mothers, children & babies?
Stop funding UNRAW !!
@@Petal4822 Why are you defending Israel as they massacre many Palestinian mothers and children, and make refugees of the rest?
@@Petal4822 Because they don't want to break international law? Israel might consider that route someday.
Netanyahu has already said that he plans to build settlements in Gaza, so obviously he wants g-cide. What are you even asking, AJ?
Arabs have wanted to g-cide the Israelis since the UN created the state
It's strange how nobody is calling Russia's invasion of Ukraine a genocide, although far more Ukrainians have been dispersed than Gazans.
I suppose it's because Ukrainians are a more mature society.
genocide accusation is false. gaza population is 2 million. assume 40 thousand palestinians dead (a high estimate). 40 thousand/ 2million means 2% of gaza population dead due to war. Don't forget war started by hamas on oct 7.
@@T0MapleLaughs ZioDrivel.
I love Palestine, I'm from Bangladesh, free Palestine
Are you an Arab from Bangladesh or a convert from Bangladesh
@@miloslavski6149 Brilliant, the whole truth.
who
blessed souls. Bangladeshis
u two can scratch each others back s
I like how the guest calls the Israeli PM 'Nut'-anyahu , about right.
Death, Death for Lebensraum.
Well said Daniel
Don't be daft.
Land and resources obviously.
There's lots on that side of the Atlantic to take yet.
Thats the problem with greedy people its want want want want
It is more than greed and envy. It is a pychopathic, self absorbed sense of entitlement at any cost. God complex. It will be the downfall of the wicked.
The devil in action
I think everyone knows what Israel wants. Israel is simply an extension of British colonial power. British was responsible for over 165 million death under its colonialism. But Israel is not UK empire. So it can only start small for land grab. And it doesn't have enough troop to colonize. So it is easier to get rid of people on the land and take them. Then they can build hotels and resorts to make money. Eventually if successful, it will expand to Egypt or Jordan.
Planet earth is calling you.
simple ...
Israel wants to eliminate terrorists, and 82% of GAZAN support Hamas terrorists
@@JackFieldBand The US government needs to stop military funding for these israeli psychopaths.
Correction it's not united kingdom (UK) it's a tiny kingdom (TK) 😂
Lol
Israel wants a pureblood ethnostate and lebensraum. How terribly familiar.
Most settlers are European
@@gordonaliasme1104 it's in there DNA to brutally conquer and colonize
LAND.........LAND..........LAND.......LAND.....
Lebanon and syria also part of 🇮🇱
@@uttaranboruah9475my a****** too
@@uttaranboruah9475my *ss* too.
Yes, this was never about the hostages for the Israeli government
@@uttaranboruah9475Indeed.....why not? Ain't Israelis occupiers?
Land....Land.....Land......Land......Land...
What a mess. What a catastrophe. What a tragedy. No stop to it?
Steal land and more land for settlements.
Land
Great honest man Mr Levy. Much respect
Biden, all words and no action. Period!
Biden is a Zionist on the payroll of Israel. He is an American Traitor. Just like Trump!
@@miloslavski6149what sort of a dumb answer is that
@@bluedragon13063 What was your question?
It's going to plan.
@@miloslavski6149 no idea it must have been to a comment deleted
Just look at the continuous settlements, the number of killings, the destruction of almost all Gaza, ignoring the international laws, the UN resolutions and so on,my answer is they want the whole land of Gaza, end of the debates
A very partial list of massacres by Arabs against Jews: Safed massacre 1834 Battle of Tel Hai 1920. Palestine riots of 1929. Tiberias pogrom 1938. Haifa Oil Refinery massacre 1947. Convoy of 35 massacre 1948. Ben Yehuda Street bombing 1948. Jewish Agency bombing 1948. Hadassah medical convoy massacre 1948. Kfar Etzion massacre 1948. Ma'ale Akrabim massacre 1954. Avivim school bus massacre 1970. Lod Airport massacre 1972. Kiryat Shmona massacre 1974. Ma'alot massacre 1974. Zion Square massacre 1975. Coastal Road massacre 1978. Dizengoff Street bus bombing 1994. Beit Lid massacre 1995. Sbarro restaurant massacre 2001. Dolphinarium discotheque massacre 2001. Hebrew University bombing 2002. Bat Mitzvah massacre 2002. Yeshivat Beit Yisrael massacre 2002. Café Moment bombing 2002. Passover massacre 2002. Kiryat Menachem massacre 2002. Shmuel HaNavi bus bombing 2002. Maxim restaurant bombing 2003. Mercaz HaRav massacre 2008. Jerusalem bulldozer attack 2008. Jerusalem synagogue massacre 2014. Tel Aviv shooting 2016. Beersheba attack 2022. Bnei Brak shootings 2022. october 7 massacre 2023.
It was the whole land that’s what. Action speak louder than words.
Land, and the gas reserves that Israel swiped from the Palestinian Authority.
Gas reserves?! 😂😂😂 What are you on?
If you lesser thans are nice we might offer you a chance to stay one night in one of our new beach front resorts. Subject to availability. Israel has spoken. Bless you.
@@JackFieldBand Look up "Gaza Marine."
@@JackFieldBand too mentally feeble to use google eh? no worries your cell mate will pound it into you
@@JackFieldBand You need an education badly, please don't embarrass yourself.
Well targeted questions and impassioned and informative answers. Thank you both.
Israel want the whole land how ever they can acquire it!
Ok👌
Real estate.
Their stated goal is to be a welcoming home for every desiring member of their ethnic group around the world. To meet that goal they need ever expanding borders.
That has to be one of the most inane comments in this section.
Spot on. Too many Zionist across the world are ready to come home after 2000 years and unfortunately the Palestinians are set to be displaced and the US are fully onboard with this plan.
@@jeffrp8388don’t cry about the truth Jeff
Netanyahu saving himself by blood of others
Thank you so much Mr. Levi and Mr. Steve for the great analysis. ❤❤❤❤❤
Let’s remember Israel was created on stolen Palestinian land and start there with 1948⁉️
What about the Palestinian prisoners taken hostage that if alive amount to more than 10 thousand in Israeli concentration camps?
Tell me...who ruled this fake so called "palestine"? What king? What president? Who???
Since this is called a "war" they are prisoners of war and the red cross should demand to inspect and international law applies.
There was no Palestine
There was no stolen land. In 1948 the arabs started a war and lost. That’s the nature of war. If you start one you might lose. You can’t start a war and when you lose say “sorry, didn’t mean to try to wipe you off the face of the earth … now give me back the land I lost trying to obliterate you”.
And there are prisons exclusively holding Palestinian children. Why are they imprisoning children?
They told the world exactly what they were going to do and they are doing it.
It wants real estate. Money.
Peace is when there is an agreement that respects both sides needs .
Great interview
These ghouls want that beach front property and the 1 trillion cubic feet of natural gas just off shore of Gaza
And what about palestinian hostages? There is public that cares very deeply about the thousands of palestinian Internet.
Palestinian hostages? Explain.
Its all about money, except that part which is about making Israel a one nation state. "Human animals"??? What are they on?
Can you understand why they want it as a one nation state?
@@MIKEENBAR Yes, because they're violent terrorists and don't want any Palestinians left to oppose them.
i know what they want they want all
Can we come to an agreement on the definition of anti Zionism as apposed to anti sémitismes, it may help clarify this conflict
Shame on people's that can sell their conscience for petroleum peanut.
Land land land All the Warfare and War is about Land that will be our Survival and also the Graveyard
Where do you want us to live, on the moon? Of course we fight for the land here, we need a place to live! They will not take our land, We conquered it, its ours now.
a ceasefire after so much of destruction. israel lacks humanness.
No ceasefire until they release the hostages without prisoners exchange.
This was really good and reality based.
Lies, slavery and genocide are baked into Judaic/Zionist ideology.
Deuteronomy 20:
"10 When you march up to attack a city, make its people an offer of peace. 11 If they accept and open their gates, all the people in it shall be subject to forced labor and shall work for you. 12 If they refuse to make peace and they engage you in battle, lay siege to that city. 13 When the Lord your God delivers it into your hand, put to the sword all the men in it. 14 As for the women, the children, the livestock and everything else in the city, you may take these as plunder for yourselves. And you may use the plunder the Lord your God gives you from your enemies. 15 This is how you are to treat all the cities that are at a distance from you and do not belong to the nations nearby.
16 However, in the cities of the nations the Lord your God is giving you as an inheritance, do not leave alive anything that breathes."
I am appalled.
And Christianity and Islam too
World domination 😮
Land.
You speak truth. Thank you.
What else if not land?
what else arabs want?
Colonial empire building of a theocratic and fascist nature.
Land land land
Dont they make use of a war situation to dig the Ben Gurion channel?
This dude is asking GREAT questions! He knows what’s what, amirite?
They want the land for real estate and the oil that's under the gaza strip that's wat thay want .
Gaza don't have that much natural resources. So, I really don't understand what you're talking about...
Israel gave the Arab Palestinians Gaza in the first place.
@@JackFieldBandThis area has somehow located at intersection of the three continents of Asia, Europe and Africa, and this adds to it's highly remarkable financial, economical and cultural importance at the global level. This land has always been geographically noticeable. Anyway war is a waste & the worst choice for problem solving in this allegedly modern era. The universe doesn't need it.
@@Petal4822
they gave it just to siege them by blockage from the outside without loosing resources and manpower. nice try smart***.
so practically they never gave Gaza to Palestinians.
They said without shame what they wanted, earlier if not most recently.
I’m not sure that the US wants this war to end.
Neither does Netanyahu and his wanna built Third Temple government
god bless palestine !
They won’t stop as they think they are unstoppable thanks to his father America
Since its birth,
Israel wants as much of Palestine as possible with as few Palestinians as possible 🇵🇸
My indigenous grandmother
said something quite interesting.
Look to the Israeli
Palestinian map. Which is the body? Which is the shadow.
She understands what’s happening. It happened to our ancestor and we’re still here.
🇺🇸❤️🇵🇸
They don’t want Palestine to exist, that was the plan since Ben Gurion. Netanyahu and Yitzhak Rabin’s Assassin have both confessed this.
Well said. Hope your message gets around the world.
Criticizing Israel is not anti-semitic
😂
I seen some UA-cam videos in which the Israelis think west Jordan is also Israel.
It wants a non jew Israel. No... Blinkin sent weapons...😢
Sadly, it does seem like this war will go on for a while, I still get irritated every time someone calls those campus protests anti semitic. Being against Israel’s actions is not being against Jewish people. End this crisis NOW, PERMANENT CEASEFIRE NOW. To all those who have died, may you rest in peace and power. As a non Muslim, I pray that you will someday reunite with your family and friends in Jannah. I also pray that one day, Palestine and Israel’s children will live together in peace.
Land and natural gas - duh
There is no international court of justice
🫡🇮🇱
They want the land for them only,,
They want the land so they can build a canal through it
Yes, Daniel Levy!! In every interview I've seen him, he's incredibly insightful, knowledgeable and precise, understanding the tetonic cultural shift towards learning about the Palestinian's plight and remind's me so much of the movement in the 80's to stop the Apartheid in South Africa. The curtain has been pulled back on Israel's myth of democracy, military supremacy and the 'most moral army' narrative and their neighbors have seen this...
All of Palestinian for themselves
Israel is finished
Nitenyahoo (sic) is a great Gampler, keep losing all the way. Still looking for a win…!
We often talk about the accountability of Israelis but what about the US and UK? Who would do,, if US and UK stop supporting Israel, then Israelis doesn't have the courage to maintain war and its hegemony,
The want the oil and gas off the coast of Gaza/Rafah.
Safety from Savages surrounding it
Great interview -- thanks Steve, Dean Baker
I love how Daniel Levy calls him NutAndYahoo 😂
Land's
Messiah had already come.
Jewish couples in Brooklyn are planning to retire in Gaza after their kids finished college!! They've had plans for the land for years already!
What 😳😳 so this planned year's ago
The quiet fart @ 11:15......gold.
Um. Maybe world domination.
They didn't hide their supremacist ideology.
They look down on others, and they never respected others. They're a blood thirsty colonial entity.
Yup. Lies, slavery and genocide are baked into the DNA of Judaic/Zionist ideology. Deuteronomy 20 -
"10 When you march up to attack a city, make its people an offer of peace. 11 If they accept and open their gates, all the people in it shall be subject to forced labor and shall work for you. 12 If they refuse to make peace and they engage you in battle, lay siege to that city. 13 When the Lord your God delivers it into your hand, put to the sword all the men in it. 14 As for the women, the children, the livestock and everything else in the city, you may take these as plunder for yourselves. And you may use the plunder the Lord your God gives you from your enemies. 15 This is how you are to treat all the cities that are at a distance from you and do not belong to the nations nearby.
16 However, in the cities of the nations the Lord your God is giving you as an inheritance, do not leave alive anything that breathes."
This pre-dates the Hamas Charter by thousands of years.
No good solutions for either side and many with vested interests in continuing conflict = endless conflict
thanks for sharing
I always like to hear anything Daniel Levy has to say. A truly intelligent man with an excellent grasp of the issue. What Daniel might not see, is that he himself, brings hope to the world with his acknowledgement of what Israel has done and his humanity as a Jewish man. Many of the people we are looking to these days for answers, are in fact Jewish. They are not running away.. they have become a voice for the voiceless. A strong voice for the Palestinian people! They amplify the voices of the great Palestinian scholars, whose voices are so often ignored. These people are in fact, the voices that are the saving grace of the world Jewish community. Honestly, if I believed all the Jews in the world supported what Israel has done and is doing and supported nationalistic Zionism, I would have to say that I would become anti-Semitic… something I would not ever want to be. The huge numbers of Jewish people opposing Israel right now, despite Israel practically having become their cultural and ideological identity over the decades, is breathtakingly beautiful. They are breaking free and standing with humanity. Gideon Levy, Ilan Pappe, Naomi Klein, Norman Finklestein, Noam Chomsky, all the Jewish students, Jewish voices for peace, code pink, breaking the silence and all the children, grandchildren and great grandchildren of victims of the holocaust that are speaking out and protesting.
That man talks a lot of sense.