@@travisinkster4234 I purchased it at Menard's (similar to a Home Depot or Lowe's). If you don't live nearby one, menards.com may offer shipping. You could probably find something similar at a kitchen remodeling store. My top was listed as a countertop for a kitchen island/bar.
I have bought a bekant for this purpose - to put a butcher block top on it - but my use case is for a sit/stand kitchen table/counter .. now that i see your weight calculations for this ikea one .. well.. assuming the bekant is similar.. im starting to have doubts about using the surface for chopping and a stand mixer and other vigourous and or heavy kitchen things .. if you have a moment curious to hear what you think 🙂
At full height, with weight on it, it will wobble a little, but very stable if you don’t load everything on one edge. Weight isn’t an issue for the motor except for raising it. It goes up slower when heavy.
Where I live only teak wood is available, so should I go with ½ inch , ¾ inch or 1 inch thick block ? Even the ½ thick teak wood block with 63" x 31" size is pretty solid. But I am very concerned about the weight of the block and load on the motors. That's the reason should I get default ikeas fiberboard or is it okay to go with solid wood desk. Thanks for the video. You are a torch bearer
You can use solid wood. I would consider 1 inch thick if the weight isn't too much. Mine weighs 92 pounds and is 1.5 inches thick. I chose the extra thickness due to the extra width (mine is 72 inches wide, so it overhangs the edges of the legs). I can set items near the edge of the desktop without concern for the load near the sides. I found an online calculator that estimated your size with teak would weigh about 60 pounds. If that is the case, it is definitely lighter than mine and I don't have any issues with the motors (just slower going up than down).
Hi John, great video. I'm looking to do something similar and am drawn to the Idasen due to it being one of the most stable bases. My biggest concern is the motors since the weight capacity is lower than a lot of competitors. How are the motors holding up with the heavy butcher block top?
Very well. It is slower going up than down, But I read that from other reviews before I did it so I expected that to be the case. I keep the total weight under 165 pounds. That includes the 92 pound butcher block top. Never had any issues.
@@JohnVanDeVoort John the reason for slowness is the power adapter. If that's a problem, you can buy Linak SMPS006 power adapter. According to the datasheet this will provide 38 mm/s speed until 800N which makes 180 lbs.
Great video ! I've purchased this desk (but with Ikea's own table top) in 2020 just as the pandemic hit us, and it's a great buy. The only thing I regret is that I haven't researched the option of getting the wheels for it. There are no Ikea made ones and the support claims that the desk was designed to be without wheels - it's only then it's guaranteed to be stable 100%.. Oh well...
Hi John - thanks for sharing. I'm considering doing the same thing. I have this already with the black desktop, but I want to swap it out for the IKEA Karlby walnut countertop. It's 74x42. Do you think the Idasen base will support that?
I believe so. If my math is accurate, it's 20% larger (so: 110 lbs vs 92 lbs of my 72"x36" countertop). Just keep the weight of what you place on top at or less than total rated weight for the lift base. You'll notice that the speed of lifting is slower than going down. That is normal with my base, which supports about 140 lbs of total weight (with butcherblock, plus computer/camera gear on top).
You might also be able to find a smaller top than the Karlby, if you don't need that large of a top. I purchased mine at Menards.com (stores in the upper midwest of the US, SKU: 4857015), but you could probably find options at any home improvement store that sells kitchen cabinets/countertops.
Hi Everyone! It's been almost two years since I made this desk and it is still going strong! Since this channel has become more Tesla/EV focused, I'm starting up a new channel to focus on home DIY things, such as this desk build. It’s called ‘Make Things Do Things.’ If you like this type of content, feel free to check it out here: www.youtube.com/@makestuffdostuffdiy
Great job on the desk! I'm planning on doing the same very soon as I find that the IKEA base is one of the sturdiest on the market and available to me here in Canada. How's the desk treating you after two years? Have you had an issues with it? My main and only concern is the weight capacity IKEA lists for the IDASEN base.
I've had zero issues with it and I love it. The only issue with weight is that the motor goes slower up than down. But it handles the weight well. Desk is super sturdy.
Hi John, do you think where the 3 cross braces join you could extend the width by moving the slider out one position and only using 2 bolts a side? Any chance you have the max distance between the legs so inside leg to inside leg? Thanks
I'm at the max width for the adjustable base. I would not recommend extending further as it would affect lateral stability. The legs are 53 inches apart (on center of leg). Distance of inside of leg to inside of other leg is 49.5 inches.
How heavy was the butcherblock top you put on. I'd be concerned having too much weight on the legs depending on how much more you have on the desktop. The advertised weight limit is 75kg / 165 lbs.
+xNajTalonx it is 92 lbs. The desk has another 55 lbs of weight on top. Mostly my 32 in curved monitor and Canon EOS R camera, that I use to make videos. The motors go slower up then down, but it has worked fine.
Not at all. The weight is well distributed on the base. When standing, I usually keep my desk at 43 inches high. I can lean on it to work without any problems. If I grab it and try to make it wobble when standing, it will move a little, but not bad for having more than 100 pounds at 43 inches.
It'd be better to use a countertop (like for a kitchen counter) since you can put the screw holes where you need them. I think the uppspel (Ikea) is manufactured, not solid wood, with screw holes prepositioned. I haven't tested, but they may not line up with the Idasen base.
Your desk top is 100% solid wood?. Where did you purchase your desk top?? And you mentioned particular desk top measurements. Did you have it personally professionally cut at buying location before you brought it home??
It is solid wood. I purchased it at the size it is (36x72 inches) at Menard’s (menards.com). It’s a countertop - so, I found it in the kitchen area of the store. Most lumber/home improvement stores will have countertops for kitchens if you want to check in your area.
Really informative video! The butcher block top you used 72" is 10" longer than the tabletop length that Ikea supplies with the Idasen (~62"). This left quite abit of overhang on the sides (from the frame). a) Does the Idasen frame allow you to extend it lengthwise to reduce this overhang? b) Will it tip/wobble if you put too much weight on the sides? Thanks!
That was a concern of mine as well when I was researching & planning. I have the Idasen frame extended to the max width that IKEA designed it for - no frame modifications. Given the thickness of the top (1.5 inches), there is no bending or sagging on the overhang (which is about 7-3/4 inches from the outer edge of the metal bracket to edge of top). The trade-off in thickness is in the weight of the top. It is 92 lbs, which makes raising the desk slower than if using a lighter load, but it works just fine. I enjoy using it everyday and would definitely build it again. It's one of the best desks that I've owned for workspace and function.
Hi, John.nice job. will this frame hold a 72'' x 30'' x 1 1/2 '' top and 70 lbs monitors(dual 49 inch and arm )? I check ikea website, the max load is 165 lb.
It absolutely will. My top is 92 lbs. I have about 50 pounds of computer and video gear on top. Stability is not an issue. Only thing I’ve noticed is that is lifts slower with more weight on it.
That's a weak motor regardless. The less stress the better for longevity, this is why Jarvis or flexispot flagships have motors which handle up to 165kg.
Nice video already did same thing but nice to see someone being helpful. The Ikea one is made with very good components and is very stable with these dimensions, unlike others which are generally unstable and wobble when the desk is not at the lowest point. As you already know, the Ikea component only supports about 100 lbs or so and it slows the motor system down with each weight increase, never going to be a problem unless someone is putting a heavy water-cooled PC system on their desktop. Putting a water-cooled PC on the desktop TBH is not IMO ideal, risking it falling by accidentally bumping against it at the max height would surely cost plenty in my case probably, £12000 (and my own system weighs over 100lbs, 45KG +). Anyway nice video 👋 good luck with your channel
+Paul Pham I’m not aware of A different controller with memory presets. But the phone app has three presets and I’ve heard there’s a computer app for the Mac OS that will Bluetooth control the desk height. I haven’t tried it out though.
Awesome video John! Great cinematography, editing and overall quality. I have ordered an Ikea Idasen earlier this evening, with an Ikea top, and look forward to build my own setup. I'd like to support your channel so I subscribed. Best of luck with your next videos!
Thank you for your support and checking it out! Best wishes with your desk setup. I love mine - space, function, look. It checks all the boxes I had for a studio desk.
Great video. I like the style of the desk legs. I was thinking about an adjustable desk but didn't like the standard designs. I think I just found mine. Lol
Hi John, does it wobble a lot when in the standing height? I have read some reviews online and they say its a good desk and doesn't wobble much. What's your take on that? I am looking to purchase it, just curious to find out how stable it is?
I was concerned about that too before the build. It feels very solid. Desk height for me working is 43 inches. It is on a carpeted floor and will move if I intentionally grab the edge and push/pull it. However, when resting my hands to type and do other work, I don't feel any movement. I can lean against the desk or rest my elbows on not feel much movement either. The butcher block top I have weighs 92 pounds. With the 32" curved monitor and other equipment, the stand is supporting about 110-115 lbs. Feel free to reply if other questions.
@@6Sloth9 I haven't done an update video, but just letting you know that I've been using this desk solidly for the last 2 years. I haven't had a single issue with it.
@@Barry981 Yes. You can get it to rock on carpet a little when it is at standing height. But deflection is not significant enough to be a safety concern (at least for the weight that I keep on top of the desk). I am still using it after 2 years. The only issue I've noticed is that the motor is slower going up than down, which is attributed to the weight being close to the base's limit.
I used 1.25 inch length on my 1.5 inch thick butcher block. I don't recall the diameter size - I had them left over from another project. I tried to find the thickest diameter wood screw that would fit in the Idasen holes, to make sure they held the top down well (in case I wanted to put a heavier load near the edge of the desk top). I hope that helps. Best wishes on your project!
Great video! I picked up the IDASEN base, and was considering whether to use the native desktops or to use my own. Good to know how to put it together with a 3rd party desktop.
Thank you! I've been using the new desk for a few weeks now and have really been enjoying it. If you decide to build and have questions, feel free to reach out.
@@JohnVanDeVoort Great to hear. After this video I ended up purchasing the Idasen base and pairing it with the IKEA Tommaryd tabletop. Absolutely love it, the desk is super solid. Cheers!
@@JohnVanDeVoort yes, maybe in the future you can make that little enhance :) so, how's overall stability? I'm also thinking on acquire same base but wondering if will it be a solid enough assemble, means, it won't bend if I unconsciously lay down my arms and some body dead weight on one spot of the desk
Hey John. This is an extremely helpful video for me. I was contemplating on going for this base as well but with two differences: 1. A relatively thinner marble/granite tabletop. It will be both glued and drilled. (It's gonna be around the same weight as yours) 2. I'm getting the non motorized version as I only need a sitting table but this was the most stable base of all in Ikea India. My question is, I have a habit of taking a quick nap on my table from time to time 😅 I'd like to know your thoughts on whether it is strong enough to hold my weight. I am around 195 lbs. Thanks for the video. Liked and subbed
Awesome - thank you! For the question - I can only speak to my table / base combination. It is super sturdy and could easily support 600 lbs in down position, and if the weight is placed in the center of the desk, from front-to-back. I'm not concerned about it collapsing, but more concerned about it tipping over if placing a heavy weight near the front or back, or if placing weight on it while it is in a standing height position. The other factor to consider is strength of the mounts (for top to base). I used the longest screws that I could for the wood, so it wouldn't poke through the top of the wood. You would want to do a little research on fixing marble/granite. You could also consider mounting a 1-inch thick solid wood (not plywood) sub-board in between the marble/granite top and the base, then use adhesive to attach the marble granite to wood support. You could recess this in from the edges so you don't see the board when sitting at the desk. This would also make attaching cable management brackets easier underneath the desk. Good luck with your build and have fun!
@@estefc6771 I used 1.25 inch long screws. For a solid wood top (not MDF or fiberboard), this length provides great support to hold typical desktop loads (100 lbs or less).
There are third party apps that connect to that desk, so you can just click with mouse on your computer instead having to open app in phone. And also some of these do show reminders (like stand for 15 minutes every hour). Desk Remote Control on mac (gui), idasen-controller (cmdline tool) on linux, mac, windows. Probably there are other, too.
@@panpanww The top is a butcher block countertop, usually used for a kitchen counter. I bought it at Menard's. It is a large home improvement store in the United States, similar to Home Depot or Lowes. You may be able to find one at a home building supply store. Good luck!
hi, a couple of questions 1. Where did you source the Butcher Block from ? 2. What is the thickness of the block ? I was not able to locate a 36x72 block, most I saw are 39x72
Hello! I purchased it from Menards (similar to Home Depot or Lowe's, located in the upper midwest of the United States). Here is a link to the product on their website, if you'd like to view it for info: www.menards.com/main/kitchen/countertops-laminate/all-countertops-laminate/butcher-block-birch-countertop/birchbblock36x72/p-1444430610433.htm It is 1.5" thick and weighs about 92 lbs. I hope you find one and enjoy the build. Let me know if you have other questions!
@@JohnVanDeVoort Thanks, I know Menards has great products, relative to HD/Lowes, The ones available in HD/Lowes seem to be 110# or more, I was able to locate some in a store called floor&decor, which are 90# but currently out of stock. I plan to put 3 or may be 4 monitors and the IDASEN is rated at only 165# so I am worried, but thanks for your response, and a great informational video.
Weight is a valid concern. I was hesitant about that too. My desk goes up slower than down, but definitely handles the weight. This video was helpful in my research (5min in they talk about the IKEA base): ua-cam.com/video/H6tpHac6r3Y/v-deo.html
@@JohnVanDeVoort Thanks, I went ahead and got the uplift-commercial frame, which is rated for a lot of weight. I personally would not trust BTOD alone as their analysis of the desks seem to have been a source of a lot of controversy. I got the Butcher Block from HD (not that great quality), its drying the 3rd poly-coat as I write. I am going to do this mod ua-cam.com/video/RXHiheIDAi4/v-deo.html to the desk (flip up lid/storage for laptops and stuff) sometime in the near future, right now its just gonna be like yours. I am also planing a seat mod, so its possible to sit in crosslegged/yoga postures while working as well as standing. I also feel the uplift saddle is good but not invested in it yet. Thanks for the informative video...
But I don't believe that the EMF radiation emitted from the electric motors is ionizing radiation (like X-rays) and wouldn't be any more harmful than other electrical fields from motors, Wi-Fi routers, etc. Let me know if you have data regarding levels and type of radiation - I'd like to research that more.
@@JohnVanDeVoort it's coming from the chip inside the compartment, there's a bluetooth chip which emits constant EMF, no matter if the button is pressed or not on the table controller. I measured it with acoustimeter 2, it shows around 5 V/m. Something to note for people who prefers to live EMF free.
amazing work. May I ask what exact screws/washers you used to mount the desktop to the frame? Thank you so much
What screws diameter and washers did you use? Please let me know as i messed up my installation and need to re-do it all over again.
also to create the pilot holes for the screws what size drill bit(?) did you use? (i am very new to this)
Very good and detailed video. If i purchase a 32x75 inch block countertop will it fit or will have adjustment problems (e.x. on the edges)????
Awesome video! I wish I had seen this a year ago before I bought my Fully.. I love the look of this!
Glad you like it!
Great video, where did you get such a deep butcher block?
@@travisinkster4234 I purchased it at Menard's (similar to a Home Depot or Lowe's). If you don't live nearby one, menards.com may offer shipping. You could probably find something similar at a kitchen remodeling store. My top was listed as a countertop for a kitchen island/bar.
I have bought a bekant for this purpose - to put a butcher block top on it - but my use case is for a sit/stand kitchen table/counter .. now that i see your weight calculations for this ikea one .. well.. assuming the bekant is similar.. im starting to have doubts about using the surface for chopping and a stand mixer and other vigourous and or heavy kitchen things .. if you have a moment curious to hear what you think 🙂
At full height, with weight on it, it will wobble a little, but very stable if you don’t load everything on one edge. Weight isn’t an issue for the motor except for raising it. It goes up slower when heavy.
Very nice production, John! Enjoy seeing your cinematography.
Thank you! I’m still learning and working to refine over the next few planned videos.
Where I live only teak wood is available, so should I go with ½ inch , ¾ inch or 1 inch thick block ? Even the ½ thick teak wood block with 63" x 31" size is pretty solid. But I am very concerned about the weight of the block and load on the motors. That's the reason should I get default ikeas fiberboard or is it okay to go with solid wood desk. Thanks for the video. You are a torch bearer
You can use solid wood. I would consider 1 inch thick if the weight isn't too much. Mine weighs 92 pounds and is 1.5 inches thick. I chose the extra thickness due to the extra width (mine is 72 inches wide, so it overhangs the edges of the legs). I can set items near the edge of the desktop without concern for the load near the sides. I found an online calculator that estimated your size with teak would weigh about 60 pounds. If that is the case, it is definitely lighter than mine and I don't have any issues with the motors (just slower going up than down).
@@JohnVanDeVoort thanks a lot for the quick reply. Really helpful information. Thank you.
@@V0LKSJAGER You're welcome! Best of luck with your build.
Hi John, great video. I'm looking to do something similar and am drawn to the Idasen due to it being one of the most stable bases. My biggest concern is the motors since the weight capacity is lower than a lot of competitors. How are the motors holding up with the heavy butcher block top?
Very well. It is slower going up than down, But I read that from other reviews before I did it so I expected that to be the case. I keep the total weight under 165 pounds. That includes the 92 pound butcher block top. Never had any issues.
@@JohnVanDeVoort John the reason for slowness is the power adapter. If that's a problem, you can buy Linak SMPS006 power adapter. According to the datasheet this will provide 38 mm/s speed until 800N which makes 180 lbs.
Great video ! I've purchased this desk (but with Ikea's own table top) in 2020 just as the pandemic hit us, and it's a great buy. The only thing I regret is that I haven't researched the option of getting the wheels for it. There are no Ikea made ones and the support claims that the desk was designed to be without wheels - it's only then it's guaranteed to be stable 100%.. Oh well...
Hi John - thanks for sharing. I'm considering doing the same thing. I have this already with the black desktop, but I want to swap it out for the IKEA Karlby walnut countertop. It's 74x42. Do you think the Idasen base will support that?
I believe so. If my math is accurate, it's 20% larger (so: 110 lbs vs 92 lbs of my 72"x36" countertop). Just keep the weight of what you place on top at or less than total rated weight for the lift base. You'll notice that the speed of lifting is slower than going down. That is normal with my base, which supports about 140 lbs of total weight (with butcherblock, plus computer/camera gear on top).
You might also be able to find a smaller top than the Karlby, if you don't need that large of a top. I purchased mine at Menards.com (stores in the upper midwest of the US, SKU: 4857015), but you could probably find options at any home improvement store that sells kitchen cabinets/countertops.
Hi Everyone! It's been almost two years since I made this desk and it is still going strong! Since this channel has become more Tesla/EV focused, I'm starting up a new channel to focus on home DIY things, such as this desk build. It’s called ‘Make Things Do Things.’ If you like this type of content, feel free to check it out here: www.youtube.com/@makestuffdostuffdiy
Great job on the desk! I'm planning on doing the same very soon as I find that the IKEA base is one of the sturdiest on the market and available to me here in Canada. How's the desk treating you after two years? Have you had an issues with it? My main and only concern is the weight capacity IKEA lists for the IDASEN base.
I've had zero issues with it and I love it. The only issue with weight is that the motor goes slower up than down. But it handles the weight well. Desk is super sturdy.
Hi John, do you think where the 3 cross braces join you could extend the width by moving the slider out one position and only using 2 bolts a side? Any chance you have the max distance between the legs so inside leg to inside leg? Thanks
I'm at the max width for the adjustable base. I would not recommend extending further as it would affect lateral stability. The legs are 53 inches apart (on center of leg). Distance of inside of leg to inside of other leg is 49.5 inches.
How heavy was the butcherblock top you put on. I'd be concerned having too much weight on the legs depending on how much more you have on the desktop. The advertised weight limit is 75kg / 165 lbs.
+xNajTalonx it is 92 lbs. The desk has another 55 lbs of weight on top. Mostly my 32 in curved monitor and Canon EOS R camera, that I use to make videos. The motors go slower up then down, but it has worked fine.
One question , how is the wobbling at the stand position ?
It’s pretty solid. I use it on a carpet floor with padding. It hasn’t caused me any worries for tipping.
Great video..we plan to use this for a conference table..about 36" x 84"
Perfect!
Awesome video John. I got some inspiration from watching this :D
Awesome! Thank you!
Does the carpet make the desk wobbly?
Not at all. The weight is well distributed on the base. When standing, I usually keep my desk at 43 inches high. I can lean on it to work without any problems. If I grab it and try to make it wobble when standing, it will move a little, but not bad for having more than 100 pounds at 43 inches.
Do you think Its possible to use a uppspel tabletop and a idasen frame..theyre both different brands but do you think i could use them
It'd be better to use a countertop (like for a kitchen counter) since you can put the screw holes where you need them. I think the uppspel (Ikea) is manufactured, not solid wood, with screw holes prepositioned. I haven't tested, but they may not line up with the Idasen base.
@@JohnVanDeVoort thank you very much
Your desk top is 100% solid wood?. Where did you purchase your desk top?? And you mentioned particular desk top measurements. Did you have it personally professionally cut at buying location before you brought it home??
It is solid wood. I purchased it at the size it is (36x72 inches) at Menard’s (menards.com). It’s a countertop - so, I found it in the kitchen area of the store. Most lumber/home improvement stores will have countertops for kitchens if you want to check in your area.
Really informative video!
The butcher block top you used 72" is 10" longer than the tabletop length that Ikea supplies with the Idasen (~62"). This left quite abit of overhang on the sides (from the frame).
a) Does the Idasen frame allow you to extend it lengthwise to reduce this overhang?
b) Will it tip/wobble if you put too much weight on the sides?
Thanks!
That was a concern of mine as well when I was researching & planning. I have the Idasen frame extended to the max width that IKEA designed it for - no frame modifications. Given the thickness of the top (1.5 inches), there is no bending or sagging on the overhang (which is about 7-3/4 inches from the outer edge of the metal bracket to edge of top). The trade-off in thickness is in the weight of the top. It is 92 lbs, which makes raising the desk slower than if using a lighter load, but it works just fine. I enjoy using it everyday and would definitely build it again. It's one of the best desks that I've owned for workspace and function.
what's your main light there? the one with all the grid pattern
Aputure 100x, with Light Dome SE softbix. I have 3 of them on ceiling mounts.
awesome video! Thanks
Glad you liked it! This was one of the first videos I ever made for UA-cam. I had no idea if people would find it helpful.
Hi, John.nice job. will this frame hold a 72'' x 30'' x 1 1/2 '' top and 70 lbs monitors(dual 49 inch and arm )? I check ikea website, the max load is 165 lb.
It absolutely will. My top is 92 lbs. I have about 50 pounds of computer and video gear on top. Stability is not an issue. Only thing I’ve noticed is that is lifts slower with more weight on it.
That's a weak motor regardless. The less stress the better for longevity, this is why Jarvis or flexispot flagships have motors which handle up to 165kg.
Nice video already did same thing but nice to see someone being helpful. The Ikea one is made with very good components and is very stable with these dimensions, unlike others which are generally unstable and wobble when the desk is not at the lowest point. As you already know, the Ikea component only supports about 100 lbs or so and it slows the motor system down with each weight increase, never going to be a problem unless someone is putting a heavy water-cooled PC system on their desktop. Putting a water-cooled PC on the desktop TBH is not IMO ideal, risking it falling by accidentally bumping against it at the max height would surely cost plenty in my case probably, £12000 (and my own system weighs over 100lbs, 45KG +). Anyway nice video 👋 good luck with your channel
Thank you. That is very kind and good feedback.
Sir, Is it possible to change the distance between the two legs of this idasen underframe ?
+Most_Inflamed_Man yes- the video shows it at the maximum width. It does have ability to be narrower when you assemble the legs.
Where did you find the countertop? Or how did you look for it?
I'm only finding ones that are either 26" or 42" deep
I bought it at Menards. SKU 4857015. You can look it up on their website too if you don’t have a store nearby.
A big thanks for the video, I was thinking about building the exact same desk!
You are very welcome. It was a fun project to do and I still love the desk.
@@JohnVanDeVoort do you know if we can replace the controller with something with memory selection?
+Paul Pham I’m not aware of A different controller with memory presets. But the phone app has three presets and I’ve heard there’s a computer app for the Mac OS that will Bluetooth control the desk height. I haven’t tried it out though.
Awesome video John! Great cinematography, editing and overall quality. I have ordered an Ikea Idasen earlier this evening, with an Ikea top, and look forward to build my own setup. I'd like to support your channel so I subscribed. Best of luck with your next videos!
Thank you for your support and checking it out! Best wishes with your desk setup. I love mine - space, function, look. It checks all the boxes I had for a studio desk.
Great video. I like the style of the desk legs. I was thinking about an adjustable desk but didn't like the standard designs. I think I just found mine. Lol
Glad it was helpful!
Can you adjust the length of the underframe? The website confuses me, it looks like you either have to go for 63 inches or 47. There's no in between.
There are several stops in between. I don’t have exact measurements for each stop, but remember the different screw holes for various settings.
Do you think the Ikea Idåsen base would work with a 200cm (about 79 inches) table top?
Hi John, does it wobble a lot when in the standing height? I have read some reviews online and they say its a good desk and doesn't wobble much. What's your take on that? I am looking to purchase it, just curious to find out how stable it is?
I was concerned about that too before the build. It feels very solid. Desk height for me working is 43 inches. It is on a carpeted floor and will move if I intentionally grab the edge and push/pull it. However, when resting my hands to type and do other work, I don't feel any movement. I can lean against the desk or rest my elbows on not feel much movement either. The butcher block top I have weighs 92 pounds. With the 32" curved monitor and other equipment, the stand is supporting about 110-115 lbs. Feel free to reply if other questions.
@@JohnVanDeVoort I guess i am gonna go for it. Thanks for a very detailed reply, it really helps and much appreciated.
This video was so much fun to make and I still love this desk! Let me know if you'd like to see an update now that I've been using it for over a year.
Hey. Did you get around to make the update video? I'm thinking of buying the desk but I'm hearing conflicting reviews
@@6Sloth9 I haven't done an update video, but just letting you know that I've been using this desk solidly for the last 2 years. I haven't had a single issue with it.
@@JohnVanDeVoortstill sturdy ?
@@Barry981 Yes. You can get it to rock on carpet a little when it is at standing height. But deflection is not significant enough to be a safety concern (at least for the weight that I keep on top of the desk). I am still using it after 2 years. The only issue I've noticed is that the motor is slower going up than down, which is attributed to the weight being close to the base's limit.
@@JohnVanDeVoort thank you!
Hey John, Nice video! What are the dimensions of the screws you are using? I have a 1.5 inch thick butcher block.
I used 1.25 inch length on my 1.5 inch thick butcher block. I don't recall the diameter size - I had them left over from another project. I tried to find the thickest diameter wood screw that would fit in the Idasen holes, to make sure they held the top down well (in case I wanted to put a heavier load near the edge of the desk top). I hope that helps. Best wishes on your project!
thanks a lot man.
Great video! I picked up the IDASEN base, and was considering whether to use the native desktops or to use my own. Good to know how to put it together with a 3rd party desktop.
Thank you! I've been using the new desk for a few weeks now and have really been enjoying it. If you decide to build and have questions, feel free to reach out.
@@JohnVanDeVoort Great to hear. After this video I ended up purchasing the Idasen base and pairing it with the IKEA Tommaryd tabletop. Absolutely love it, the desk is super solid. Cheers!
Nicely done, but I think a better solution to attach the wood panel to the base would have been using threaded inserts instead of standard lag screws
Thanks for adding that suggestion. I've been using my desk for over a year now - it's held up and has been very good to work on.
@@JohnVanDeVoort yes, maybe in the future you can make that little enhance :) so, how's overall stability? I'm also thinking on acquire same base but wondering if will it be a solid enough assemble, means, it won't bend if I unconsciously lay down my arms and some body dead weight on one spot of the desk
how long are the 2 feet that touch the floor in cm? thanks!
They are 70 cm from front-to-back and 141 cm from side-to-side of the base.
@@JohnVanDeVoort thank you so much!
Hey John. This is an extremely helpful video for me. I was contemplating on going for this base as well but with two differences:
1. A relatively thinner marble/granite tabletop. It will be both glued and drilled. (It's gonna be around the same weight as yours)
2. I'm getting the non motorized version as I only need a sitting table but this was the most stable base of all in Ikea India.
My question is, I have a habit of taking a quick nap on my table from time to time 😅 I'd like to know your thoughts on whether it is strong enough to hold my weight. I am around 195 lbs.
Thanks for the video. Liked and subbed
Awesome - thank you! For the question - I can only speak to my table / base combination. It is super sturdy and could easily support 600 lbs in down position, and if the weight is placed in the center of the desk, from front-to-back. I'm not concerned about it collapsing, but more concerned about it tipping over if placing a heavy weight near the front or back, or if placing weight on it while it is in a standing height position. The other factor to consider is strength of the mounts (for top to base). I used the longest screws that I could for the wood, so it wouldn't poke through the top of the wood. You would want to do a little research on fixing marble/granite. You could also consider mounting a 1-inch thick solid wood (not plywood) sub-board in between the marble/granite top and the base, then use adhesive to attach the marble granite to wood support. You could recess this in from the edges so you don't see the board when sitting at the desk. This would also make attaching cable management brackets easier underneath the desk.
Good luck with your build and have fun!
@@JohnVanDeVoort Thank you so much for this. You've made a lot of things easier. 👍🏼
I'm doing this same thing as well.
Awesome! You’ll love it.
Açıklayıcı anlatım için teşekkürler
where did you purchase the butcher block from.
Menard’s. But you can buy similar from another home improvement store that sells kitchen cabinets and countertops.
How thick was the table top?
It is 1.5 inches thick. Let me know if you have any other questions. Good luck if you decide to build it!
@@JohnVanDeVoort yes that is the goal! Your video was awesome and motivated me to tackle this.
What size screws do you recommend for that thickness?
@@estefc6771 I used 1.25 inch long screws. For a solid wood top (not MDF or fiberboard), this length provides great support to hold typical desktop loads (100 lbs or less).
Hey John, after watching your video 20x I now achieved it exactly like yours and it works perfectly 🥰
Thank you and subscribed 😍💪
+BrownSugarDynamite that is awesome! I hope you enjoy it. I still love mine. Glad that I could help!
There are third party apps that connect to that desk, so you can just click with mouse on your computer instead having to open app in phone. And also some of these do show reminders (like stand for 15 minutes every hour). Desk Remote Control on mac (gui), idasen-controller (cmdline tool) on linux, mac, windows. Probably there are other, too.
That's awesome! Thanks for the tip. I'll be sure to check it out.
What is the width of the table? It doesnt look like a 600mm
It is 36 inches (914mm). You have a good eye!
@@JohnVanDeVoort Thanks John, Where you got the table top? It is very hard to get 914mm width table.
@@panpanww The top is a butcher block countertop, usually used for a kitchen counter. I bought it at Menard's. It is a large home improvement store in the United States, similar to Home Depot or Lowes. You may be able to find one at a home building supply store. Good luck!
Why not just buy the IDASEN top? Its of excellent quality plywood. Had mine for 6 years now and its still good as new
Hi I'm Korean and I'd like some help making a desk! can I know the size of the side that comes out at 4:08
The desk extends beyond the top brace by 7 1/4 inches or about 190 mm
hi, a couple of questions
1. Where did you source the Butcher Block from ?
2. What is the thickness of the block ?
I was not able to locate a 36x72 block, most I saw are 39x72
Hello! I purchased it from Menards (similar to Home Depot or Lowe's, located in the upper midwest of the United States). Here is a link to the product on their website, if you'd like to view it for info: www.menards.com/main/kitchen/countertops-laminate/all-countertops-laminate/butcher-block-birch-countertop/birchbblock36x72/p-1444430610433.htm
It is 1.5" thick and weighs about 92 lbs. I hope you find one and enjoy the build. Let me know if you have other questions!
@@JohnVanDeVoort Thanks, I know Menards has great products, relative to HD/Lowes, The ones available in HD/Lowes seem to be 110# or more, I was able to locate some in a store called floor&decor, which are 90# but currently out of stock. I plan to put 3 or may be 4 monitors and the IDASEN is rated at only 165# so I am worried, but thanks for your response, and a great informational video.
Weight is a valid concern. I was hesitant about that too. My desk goes up slower than down, but definitely handles the weight. This video was helpful in my research (5min in they talk about the IKEA base): ua-cam.com/video/H6tpHac6r3Y/v-deo.html
@@JohnVanDeVoort Thanks, I went ahead and got the uplift-commercial frame, which is rated for a lot of weight. I personally would not trust BTOD alone as their analysis of the desks seem to have been a source of a lot of controversy. I got the Butcher Block from HD (not that great quality), its drying the 3rd poly-coat as I write. I am going to do this mod ua-cam.com/video/RXHiheIDAi4/v-deo.html to the desk (flip up lid/storage for laptops and stuff) sometime in the near future, right now its just gonna be like yours. I am also planing a seat mod, so its possible to sit in crosslegged/yoga postures while working as well as standing. I also feel the uplift saddle is good but not invested in it yet. Thanks for the informative video...
With idasen I did find the selection of tops a bit lacking. especially compared to older models.
How is this a "hack"? They sell the frame separate for exactly this purpose. LOL.
I find the leg design ugly though! Decisions!
+T T the style isn’t for everyone. If honest, I preferred other leg styles too, as I was researching. The plus to this is it is very stable.
I've heard this is one of the most sturdy, stable, and reliable sit/stand legs you can get. Especially for the price.
ikea idasen emits constant EMF radiation from the master motor compartment.
But I don't believe that the EMF radiation emitted from the electric motors is ionizing radiation (like X-rays) and wouldn't be any more harmful than other electrical fields from motors, Wi-Fi routers, etc. Let me know if you have data regarding levels and type of radiation - I'd like to research that more.
@@JohnVanDeVoort it's coming from the chip inside the compartment, there's a bluetooth chip which emits constant EMF, no matter if the button is pressed or not on the table controller. I measured it with acoustimeter 2, it shows around 5 V/m. Something to note for people who prefers to live EMF free.