'What's The Use Of Our Constitution Without Liberal Judges': Fali Nariman
Вставка
- Опубліковано 19 лип 2024
- Advocate Karuna Nundy speaks to veteran Indian jurist Fali Nariman to discuss issues plaguing the Supreme Court, the recent composition of benches, reservation for women lawyers in India, Nariman's representation in the Bhopal gas tragedy case and more.
Note: This interview was recorded on December 19, 2017, some three weeks before the January 12, 2018 press conference by four Supreme Court judges.
A grand old man from a different era speaking the truth and only plain truth. A rare species to be found these. God bless him good health and sharp wit !!
Excellent interview. Pl also watch this and share. ua-cam.com/video/PRR9EPNUUJw/v-deo.html. My father, Professor Shanti Swarup, a freedom fighter died at 96 in March 2020. He made two videos before his death. Pl also see comments by my husband Jim Howland which further delineate my father's views. This will be useful material I believe for our struggle. ua-cam.com/video/OMjEzJ1JgZ0/v-deo.html. I also suggest an interview with Prof Rajmohan Gandhi ( Gandhi's grandson) and Mr Karan Singh who are still alive and can tell the truth about so many things pertaining to the correct moral choices about our social contract and so on. Btw, both my husband and I are also political scientists. Thanks for your time.
Very natural and truthful interview...Great Fali sir...
What a splendid chat, this lady is singularly outstanding to conduct this exceptional interview , wonderful
Discussion is admirable. Both the interviewer and interviewee get five out of five. Line to remember: "Do The Right Thing".
@arjun rai go away troll, educated people don't want your kind here
1 second ago
Please also see this video of Prof Shanti Swarup, former Prof and freedom fighter. Passed away in march at age of 96. ua-cam.com/video/PRR9EPNUUJw/v-deo.html
This is the classic instance of how an interview should happen . Karuna is brilliant , very sensible and trying to bring out the gem out of a very senior practioner of law in India. They both are scripting history . It is insightful and educative .
What a fantastic discourse!! So refreshing to see the level of intellect, and free flowing discussion. Karuna Nundy is just amazing!!
Ur best commitment towards news story surely flourished us as individual and as a nation at large, helping us generating a deeper rational thinking for the betterment for our nation is deeply appreciate. Happy Republic Day TEAM WIRE🎟🖋
No
omg Karuna is such a great interviewer! Love her.
Every young lawyer should listen this interview. Everyone wants to earn maximum by specialising. Thus some people become famous criminal lawyers. Vaidyas and Vakils know how to take. They dont know how to give.
It's a delight to watch my inspiration Karuna Nandy speak with legend Fali Nariman... so much to learn from both of them. Strength, humility and clarity of thoughts. Thank you Wire for bringing such interesting pieces.
Such debate is more required during this era
@arjun rai But he never supported secularism.
@arjun rai Without secularism, our country would be a bloody mess.
Withiut Secularism , perhaps we will be in the bunch of PAK like anarchy.
1 second ago
Please also see this video of Prof Shanti Swarup, former Prof and freedom fighter. Passed away in march at age of 96. ua-cam.com/video/PRR9EPNUUJw/v-deo.html
@@ramachandrannarayanan2402 i
It is the best honour on earth to get a chance to even listen to the likes of eminent and seniormost lawyer Fali Sam Nariman! My deepest gratitude for this enlightening experience of listening to none other than Fali Sam Nariman. My deepest gratitude and best regards, Sanjeev Sirohi, Advocate
This is an interview that I have enjoyed thoroughly in the recent past. It's so natural, expressive, edifying, and relevant. Listening to one of the finest legal minds of India expressing is so enriching. It's pleasure and privilege indeed.
Thank you Fali sir and Karuna Ji. God bless you. I thank God that India is blessed with such a great personalities like Fali sir. Feeling proud!
A judge does not have to be conservative or liberal. He has to be rational and free from all kinds of ideologies. He should have very basic traits of compassion towards the citizens of the country.
More of this kind of interviews please.
One of the most graceful lady I have seen on TV. I wish my daughter takes her as a role model.
A blessing to see Fali ji
Those who are watching this conversation with age of under 25 and science technical background they are really something beyond and special open minded 🙏❤️
Enjoy hearing both personalities....
Thanks for this session..
Jurist Fali Nariman is outspoken, with a great sense of Humour.
Life is a continuous Process of Learning.
My question of to him is " Whether Common Man can afford the Fees of lawyers like Fali Nariman.
I fully agree what this great man said, "the constitution, the civil procedure code, the criminal procedure code and the evidence act are the basics".
Simply astounding and Enlightening.
All of must study such interviews.
Really amazing and rare deep understanding of the constitution of India. He could have avoided the word ' HARIJAN' which is unparlimentary, bad and humiliating for the SCs of India.
Fine inspiring interview. Moral fibre, reading habits, introspective judges..... truly commendable. Where has this gone? Do we see any signs of hope?
@arjun rai if basic intellectuality makes one leftist, I would love to be a leftist someday.
@@maanyashukla326 but fali have due process of law in his thought
@arjun rai Go away troll
Very good interview. Must watch for every Indian and certainly for Judges and Lawyers
This interview has made my day. Love it. Need more interviews like this.
pop pop pop pop pop pop pop pop pop pop pop op ppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppopppppppppppppppppp ppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppppp
Highly intellectual personality...
Great achievement in life.
Happy man..
Lot to learn from HIM..
GOD BLESS him with good health and happiness...
The grand old man in this interview is way more open minded, liberal and truthful than most chaps in the current generation. And Karuna Nundy as usual asking all the right questions, putting forth the commendable arguments.
Civil Law is key to sucessful legal profession.....Thankyou ....learning is process and it is continous
Damn! What a person, what a personality, mind-blowing!! No more words.
" a test for Civilisation ". Well said Sir, so basic and moral.
Most interviews will give you knowledge but it's very rare when you learn something beyond the realms of accumulating knowledge. A spiritual man always have good sense of humour and understanding of themselves. A learned man only says he don't know. Things doesn't happen according to them. Law is the bare minimum ethics that is required for a civilization to be stable. Yes as a human being you must know what is right and wrong. We do know. Sometimes we do wrong because we are human but one must strive to be the civilized one. What a man !!!!! Thank you The Wire.
Brilliant interview....brilliant mind......learned soooo much......grt job guys......👏👏👏
Those wise words!! "Stand Up and be counted....Do the right thing."
Such a lovely, admirable and informative talk. Enjoyed it thoroughly :)
Thank you, very informative and relevant. It is inspiring to see the level of discourse, wisdom and humility.
Great interview of fali sir by karuna ma'am wire team please conduct these interviews with other great lawyers.
Huge reverence to acumen and astute of Mr Fali S Nariman
Great interview and very insightful especially because the intewviewer is herself a renowned lawyer having indepth knowledge of the field.It is always amazing to hear sir share is extensive knowledge and experience.A must watch for every law student aspiring to go into litigation.
Most of the INDIA is still living in MEDIEVAL times.
And
Nicely put it by Mr Nariman
" Test of the civilisation "
very informative, please do more interview so we can learn and understand our constitution basics.
Thank you The Wire
waquar usmani read some material interview nhi help karega.. lodu
yash vijayvergiya THEN,what are you doing here.( I will not use any bad word because The Wire is my favorite channel and my parent taught me to react with polite words. Your words reflects your learning, keep it up).
Come to the answer
Go and read books , why u r wasting your time here. see,
Theory and practical is two thing. when a senior person share his experience and thought, it gives us a different angle to think and act.
suggestions for you:-
Think before act and act after you think properly
waquar usmani bro my whole point was that u read then u will learn, listening to experience won't change anything. they have done their part of work, you do your. everyone has different experiences in life, so you cannot apply his experience into your life coz its different... each one of us has different experiences and life... so conversation between us will be your of part of youtube experience??
Two very pleasant and intelligent personalities. Good job WIRE.
A really enriching discourse and a great contribution to the idea of justice and law.
First ...Thank You "The Wire".Such great exchange of ideas.It's treat...
Wonderful interview... Thanks for this. Can you please arrange a similar one with CJI Ramanna or Justice D.Y.Chandrachud
Only educated Indians can understand meaning of constitution
Sushanto Banerjee u r very true I m really worried about educated youth r job less and illiterate bumpkins r enjoing preveledge and ruling us
close all universities and start vocational training in odd jobs such as making pakoda dhokla khakda papdi itly dosa etc
not necessarily.
@giri kotte ask the question why they are least educated
Its a toilet paper.
What is brilliant mind Shri Nariman Sir
I feel ...Fali Nariman is Don Bradman of Indian Judiciary.
Nanipalkhiwala......
Educational man. Might be just 30-35k views, but unbiased, learned and earned viewership which the wire should be proud of.
This was such an awesome discussion! More such vids please!!!
Really Thankful☺️ Listening from a Remote Village Katheel Hoon of Tehsil Kahuta, District Rawalpindi, Pakistan 🇵🇰🌼🏵️🎁
Very helpful and informative. Thank you The Wire
Very insightful interview,kudos
Wow..... It's raw and pure.
Nani palkhiwala and Fali Nariman a most notable lawyer in our indian judiciary...as a student you lot to know from fali Nariman..he did practice in criminal and civil case....I m very enthusiasticaly about thier knowledge and their work in judiciary.
Unfortunately, many have forgotten the contribution of the legendary, Nani Palkhivala.
Nani Palkhivala should be given the Bharat Ratna, he deserved it.
A very good interview. There was a tune between the interviewer and the interview. Probing questions and insightful answers.
Advocate Fali S. Nariman is indeed a man of integrity with profound knowledge and expertise in Law but what is interesting is that he still manages to laugh. This gives me hope that we still have people who are able to balance both their professional and personal life.
Such an insightful interview. Learnt a lot of things.
I agree totally if Nehru wouldnt have been there for the first 10 to 15 yrs after independence .....India would have been very different...may b
I mean his contributions were great to build up the secular diverse country we are proud of today
One of the best interviews. Great job @the_Wire
Wonderful thoughts
It would have been brilliant if this interview had occured after the press conference by the four senior judges.
Meaningful debate 👌👌👌
Nice ending and an valuable advice 🙏
Best interview on Republic Day
I am so sorry that he has lost his image when he fought for union carbide after Bhopal gas tragedy
Well all said and done......all nice things said.....who Judges the Judges...are there any checks and balances for Judiciary.......I am not sure
Please do the another interview of sir nd mam.wonderfull
The pre independence generation in India is of a different quality.. unfortunately we are losing so many of these gems to age and we are left with whatsapp uncles 😢
Interesting and learning experience too
The mainstream media should take a cue from the interview and hold civilized interviews
Karuna Nandi pls join in Politics...we need educated ppl like you making policies
But good people are not appreciated.
Take the case of Kanyahia Kumar. He is only one example.
Excellent Interview.
There should be more discussions on India's greatest Jurist Nani Palkhivala.
Thanks to #Wire for bringing this to us .
Great interview.
Freedom of Expression is the most important topic because it is misused in the Indian Democracy.
Proof that brilliant minds still thrive in this great nation of ours! Such a pity that we elect the senseless to govern us!! Wonderful discussion and so enlighting to hear ! Bravo!
Scenario changed over the 175 years since Chartered High Courts were established with State's role changing with Police State transforming to Welfare State.
With the advent of Administrative Law, some of the State's actions which needed to be examined as to validity did not fall in the domain of Civil Court requiring procedure ordained by CPC but simple one to examine legality.
Similarly certain types of disputes of standard nature like dispute between Borrower and Banks did not require Civil Court following CPC to decide when the dispute is of routine nature.
Tribunals emerged in the above background.
Tribunals' role and utility cannot be assessed from the perspective of Civil Court and it's functioning.
Very Nice
Enlightening. In a way humbling.
Moral fiber is most important
Dope Man !!
Here we have two men Fali Nariman and Kalvi from kayar Sena both near about same age...One is giving constructive information to the younger generation while the other one is destroying the future of the younger rajput generation ..
Destroying future need elaboration brother
times are tough...but we are the nation which overturned the emergency... so stay strong this too shall pass
A inspiring interview . Karuna tried to push her agenda but Soli stood firm.Dharma is distinguishing between right and wrong and all Indians should lead a Dharmic life regardless of their religion which should be deeply respected .
Knowledgeable debate. 👏👏👏
Excellent presentation !
A MAULANA NAMED ABUL KALAM AZAAD BECAME 1st EDUCATION MINISTER OF INDIA, BUT NOBODY CALLED INDIA AS MUSLIM STATE
Brilliant interview...
He is very good. It is almost rude not to view his interview.
Republic Day treat..
WHICH STABILITY DID NEHRU PROVIDE P.O.K, AKSAI CHIN IN 1962 DEFEAT?
Keep learning.
Knowledge is like ocean, deep & Vast.
Everyone can have their opinion, but the truth shall prevail.
Good interview.
very nice
“ This Chap” , that is what the man deserves!
Excellent
Wire is reflecting people opinions... tqu
Jai Bheem
It is due to mentality of the judges which is well influenced and inspiring them against the Muslims.
Very nice presentation, like the easy style of the anchor. Godi media Zchhee and Notime Now anchors should learn.
Absolutely brilliant Sir Fall N
Simply legend.