It's the same phenomenon with an expected voice we anticipate in leaders at all, two more examples are Ulbricht and Honecker, leaders of the socialistic East-Germany. They sound like eunuchs.
...and it also helped him to talk himself out when he was asked to support the resistance. "this is unsoldierly" not "i would like to help, but im afraid".
@@mauricekeip6303 I don't think he was afraid - he was simply psychologically unable to support the resistance, because of his upbringing and his character.
The questions are fair and polite, in clear German. The accused are given time to explain their actions. I am impressed with the clarity of the spoken German. Beautiful! Manstein does not blame anyone. He describes the historical context of the time, including the effects and ongoing legacy of the WW1 context. In fact, he often alludes to WW1. The lesson we can all learn is that war is bad and we should avoid it. Had I been round at the time, and a German, I would have been proud to have Manstein as my leader. I am sure that the court would have respected him also.
@@Petal4822 weren't a lot of people a fan of Hitler, just cuz your a fan of someone doesn't mean you neccesarily have the same mind as them, I mean his dismissal was cuz of arguments, which is not really something a fan would do
@@Petal4822 Manstein was one of the few generals that dared to stand up against Hitler too. He was not as vocal as Guderian but he also got into some heated arguments with him.
@@manfredkleist7966 Der Verlierer wird am Ende immer der Verbrecher sein. Ich sehe dies anders. General von Manstein hatte auf den Sieg gesetzt und immerhin die Schlacht um Sewastopol auf der Krim gewonnen. Es ist ein Präventivschlag gewesen, leider ist es gescheitert.
My country has a proverb “ You win, you become a king. You lose, you turn yourselves into enemy”. The one who win the war will decide how the history is written.
@@paulminh3525 Yes of course, that is true. My country then had to blame themselves solely for both World Wars. It is a historical truth that these wars had many fathers. It is like a song from ABBA. The Winner takes it all, the loser standing small.
“When this war is over we will be accused of an infinity of murder as if all men at war everywhere hadn’t behaved in the same way” The Forgotten Soldier
No, not for his role as a general during the war, but because on October 10, 1941 he issued an order to all soldiers under him that practically made the "Wehrmacht" an accomplice in the murder of Jewish civilians by the "SS" and "SD Einsatzgruppen" as he made an explicit promise of support from ordinary soldiers in these war crimes. In fact, the trial in Nuremberg saved him from being extradited to Poland or the Soviet Union, where he would have faced execution. According to the Yalta Declaration, the Allies agreed that war criminals should be tried at the place where the crimes took place. The British in particular did not want to extradite Manstein and have him executed by Stalin's regime because they simply considered his military knowledge to be far too valuable, so that he later became an advisor to the now allied German army in the Cold War.
@@MachiaveIIi25 In Nürnberg wurde von Manstein als Zeuge der Anklage im Verfahren gegen den Generalstab des Heeres verhört. Der Vorwurf der Anklage lautete: Der Generalstab sei eine verbrecherische Organisation gewesen. Im Gegensatz zur "SS" wurde die Anklage vom Ankläger in Nürnberg zurück gezogen oder das Gericht hat den Generalstab freigesprochen. Die "SS" wurde als "verbrecherische Organisation" verurteilt, was auch aus deutscher Sicht richtig war und ist. Die Kriegerwitwen bekamen allerdings keine Witwenrente nach dem Krieg von den beiden neuen Staaten.
@@inpersonaDK What does your comment have to do with mine, and even if so, how would those circumstances refute anything i wrote? Do you even understand the topic or did you just randomly pick a comment in which to indulge in your cheap revisionism
Bei Interviews mit Generalen/Admiralen der Wehrmacht ist festzustellen, dass sie alle mehr oder weniger die gleiche Art zu reden haben. Auch der Tonfall ist bi allen sehr ähnlich.
Da enden aber schon die Gemeinsamkeiten. So hat man damals eben gesprochen. Hör dir mal Klaus Kinski aus den 60er Jahren an. Suche nach die Lästerzungen
Not questionable. It was totally bias. Never happened in history before and an intentionally to humiliate and stigmatize the Germans by the Zionists and Loxists
?? ein nicht geringer Teil der Offiziere, vor allem in der Luftwaffe konnten fließend englisch...die meisten es verstehen; es gehörte auch teilweise zur AUsbildung !
Strange how the caption and description is in English, but they provide no English subtitles. What's the purpose of that? They lure in English speaking people...due to the English caption, then they throw German at us. What the heck is that about?
It is actually an excellent idea when you remember that the trials were a total travesty of truth and of history itself. The mass murderer, Stalin, responsible for ten to thirty times the deaths caused by Germans and Japanese together, used the trials to cover his own attrocities, like the mass graves of Katyn Forrest. The english and american attrocities were also off limits. It was a rigged show trial from the start. So, yes, it is right that a sham trial should be as obscured as possible.
@@jackmeskill2539 , thing is the Nazis started a total World war . If you are responsible for putting children in ovens you get everything you deserve.
@@goijehudim5798 , I started work in 1983 . One of the old boys I used to worked with helped liberate Belsen . I’ve heard first hand what them bastard nazis done from someone that was there. Make no mistake the Nazis where evil & got what they deserved .
@@johnnymlad8472 He was a rabid Anti Semite, who watched the Murder of Women and Children, he did not have to do it, but he did, it is well documented, Prisoner exchange , what damn planet are you on, the Russians had little hope with the Germans and the Germans knew that the Russians would kill them for all the Filthy atrocities committed in Russia against its civilian population, you do realise that when anti partisan operations were going on, they may have killed Partisans but they also killed everybody in the Villages at the same time, Herman Fegelein was very cruel in that respect, 18000 Villages Thousands of Towns erased with the populations murdered, that was Russia under the Germans 27 Million Civilians, and you talk of Von Manstein wanting Prisoner exchanges, if they had given him to the Russians they would have had Millions to watch the cruel bastard hang. His stance compared to Guderian was stark, Russian Commanders admired Guderian, they hated to the core Von Manstein, Dietl in the Balkans was a cruel Bastard as well.
Er war ein Verbrecher, der einem Verbrecher folgte. Wieviele Tote gab es seinetwegen in Belarus, der Ukraine und Polen? Er hätte Hitler bei einer Unterredung mit einer Gabel in den Hals stechen können, dann wäre er womöglich ein Held der in Treue zum Volk stünde. Aber so war er ein kleiner Wicht, ein Mörder und Antisemit, trainiert auf Befehl und Gehorsam, verehrt von Wichten bis heute.
Perhaps it would have been better in Russian they should have hold of him, it was Politics that stopped that, he would have paid the ultimate price for his Brutality and Murder.
Los sovieticos le tenian la celda lista en sus famosos campos de reeducacion ,pero nunca se imaginaron que Manstein terminaria como uno de los principales asesores de la Otan en la Guerra Fria .Si no me equivoco ,en la foto donde sale fumando se alcanza a distinguir en su uniforme el escudo de los vencedores de Sebastopol .
Manstein nunca fué "uno de los principales asesores de la Otan en la Guerra Fria". Su actividad profesional en el período de posguerra se limitaba a la de consejero inoficial del Ministerio de Defensa alemán durante la reorganización del ejército alemán occidental: "Bundeswehr".
3 роки тому+2
Antes lo ingleses tuvieron que jusgarle y condenarle a 18 años de prisión. El que haya terminado en la OTAN tiene que ver más con la guerra fría
Manstein manipulates the evidence and blames Paulus for the events that happen at Stalingrad. But the reality is, his version of events is wrong. ua-cam.com/video/uzAzpIdDNcI/v-deo.html
The German is very clear (klar). I can understand every word. Not like these days when you hear them speaking now, for example, Timo Werner and Joshua Kimmins.
En 1939, en una sola fábrica de tanques rusa producían más tanques que en todas las fábricas alemanas. En la primer arremetida, los alemanes destruyeron 35.000 tanques y carros blindados estacionados al Oeste para... invadir Europa.
Diese leicht Berlinerisch gefärbte Mäuschenstimme. Ich hatte mir einen Manstein immer anders vorgestellt. Jedoch sehr geschickt in seinen Formulierungen.
@@bigbadladnamedalasad7071 Not at all, his defensive Manouver at Kuban in 1943 was brilliant and Against Hitlers orders. He was prussian General in first place.
@@ItsYoBoyBryce00 And what do those two wars have in common? they fought on multiple fronts, the 2nd time of course they simply could not reproduce the things they needed fast enough and in the 1st war, they could not import food to feed their people, as they weren't taking Culturable grounds, hence why in the 2nd war, food wasnt a problem at all, They definitely did learn from their mistakes, forsept one, over extending, trying to take a Nation the size of Europe and a population so high you could stack all those people together and have the empire state building. Just mistakes, and idiotic leadership, not listening to your Generals is not very wise. Not all Generals are right of course, but most of the time theyre generals for a reason.
In what regard, exactly? If Hitler never came to power, invaded countries without provocation, killed millions because of his fanaticism, do you think these leaders would have involved their countries in war? No. Hitler and his regime, complicit with many of the German population, were solely to blame for war crimes.
Rommel is overrated, certainly a very good divisional or corps commander, but unsuited for higher command due to lack of knowledge of supply/logistics/organizational ability. Manstein is probably the best overall (I mean, he could literally excell at anything, be it moving tanks or destroying fortresses), while late-war generals like Model or Heinrici were the best at organizing a good defense against a numerically superior enemy with depleted units. From what I know, Manstein was quite popular with his subordinate commanders, and worked very effectively together with them, like Manteuffel, Hoth, Hollidt,...
The story goes that at the Berlin Victory Banquet in 1945, after Russian troops performed their gruelling "Soldier's Dance" with military precision, Patton - not wishing to be upstaged - immediately launched into "Dixie" with a fine, soaring falsetto, gracefully conducting himself with his own gold-plated General's Swagger Stick. His high-pitched canteen opera naturally stole the whole show with broken champagne glasses and raucous applause. Unfortunately, Stalin and Zhukov were so unnerved by Patton's singing, they were forced to evacuate the minstrel's tribute with Explosive Vibratory Flatulence (EVB}. A condition, by the way, the State Department uses to this day for diplomatic leverage at all high-level talks.
'It was nothing to do with me, guv!' Please, you only need to read through the KTBs of various units on the eastern front to know what a pile of BS this is. The whole gang should have faced the firing squad.
and not guilty of anything other than being the best tactician and overall military genius of WW2. He was a most honourable and respected military leader. I recommend any of his books, but especially "Lost Victories". A marvelous man at any level.
The russians later apologised to Von Manstein, stating publicly, after his release, that he had in fact been falsely accused and had not been guilty of any of the charges levelled against him.
@@robertdipaola3447 I am afraid that that totally discredited farce of a tribunal were not interested in truth or facts, but essentially in covering up russian, american, british and other allied war crimes and crimes against humanity. years later, the Russians admitted to the Katyn Forrest murders and many more, perpetrated on Stalin's direct orders. The Russian military also belatedly admitted that Field Marshal Eric Von Manstein was innocent of all charges put against him and had been jailed in a travesty of justice. Now, years later, we have the proof of facts denied by the victors . It is an old story, of course. The german Army, far from perpetrating attrocities on the Eastern Front, distinguished themselves in their attempts to protect local populations from the Communist retaliations and war crimes visited on them by advancing soviet troops, as the german armies retreated. It is sad that utter lies and falsehoods as presented in so many videos by this ignorant propagandist are still to be found on Utube. The author is an attention-seeking liar who may have some psychiatric issues. He is certainly not a historian, not even a very bad one.
A Great Prussian Style Commander. A great military leader and cultivated man .These were a class of military leaders like of which will never come again Their memory must be preserved. Indian Military Veterans salute then .
Manstein manipulates the evidence and blames Paulus for the events that happen at Stalingrad. But the reality is, his version of events is wrong. ua-cam.com/video/uzAzpIdDNcI/v-deo.html
As the accusations of war crimes and the validity of their innocence gets pointed in the comments, lest not forget that these men just like our honored servicemen and woman are all soldiers. Warriors who fought to the very end for their countries. Call it blind loyalty, but I see it as honorable valor to ones country. Each country played their role in terms of war crimes during WWII. At least they learned to be at least somewhat better in our modern society.
@@davidlynch9049 I'm saying at the end of the day soldiers fight wars for their countries as a duty to serve. And yes the Nazis had a radical and violent solution to their own problems but so did the Soviets who hailed as victors after the fact.
The German army lost its honor in WW2. The mass killings cant be excused away because of battlefield performance or their personal beliefs in military tradition. They were jackbooted thugs wantonly killing civilians and waging aggressive wars against peaceful nations. Read about German militarism and their culture and you can see how they slowly lost their minds over the centuries, culminating in WW2. Its not really rocket science.
I Have footage farm Die Deutshe Wocensch videos which Gobbels team was broadcasting in theatres across Germany and Wermacht units, you can see in Baltic state Invasion that Jewish civilians are being stripped and shot, similarly when the Germans were sure of Soviet Union surrendering till Oct -1941, 2 million Soviet POW's were starved to death, only after when the realised they needed the POW labour did these POW have better survival rates, even Polish civilians trying to give some milk to Soviet POW's were shot by the Wermacht. The biggest post world war 2 myth was that of a clean Wermacht, most Wermacht leaders were for the Invasion of Soviet Union, belived in Utermenchen concept and performed the war of Anhilation on the Soviets, it was only at the Wars end they all pretended to be innocent.
Manstein manipulates the evidence and blames Paulus for the events that happen at Stalingrad. But the reality is, his version of events is wrong. ua-cam.com/video/uzAzpIdDNcI/v-deo.html
Firstly I recommend ro improve your spelling. Secondly those Jews in the Baltic states were beaten to death by indigenous Baltic inmates who were liberated by the Germans. Last but not least: v. Mansteins original name was v. Lewinski and he had jewish ancestry from Warsaw/ Poland To be continued...
Fair justice of the victorious Allies! They never disarmed their military forces after WW 1, no on the contrary they were deploying more and more military. France: 724.000 Belgium:113.000 Germany:100.00 Poland: 275.000 Sowjets:885.000 This a ratio of about.....a bloody lot. They elegantly broke their promises! And the so called Polish victims tried to force the French at about 3x to start a two-frontline -war against Germany between the years of 1919 to 1933. Years before Hitler came to power. They also circulated maps depicting the new borders to their West, for instance, in the vicinity of our capital Berlin. Not to mention their policy about treating their minorities in the most cruel and apalling way. Hence killing, rapeing and ransacking about 58.000 Germans living in Poland due to the stupid and severing borders fullfilling the Versailles Dictate. While declaring war on Germany on the 3rd of September, they never declared war on Russia although they invaded Eastern Poland on 17.9.1939! And which conclusions do we draw about the Jewish DECLARATION of war on Germany on the 24.3.1933? Was that just a joke? Welll we will never learn, because documentnare willneverHitler was in office for about 53 days only.Strange but evident....and I could go on and on about Roosevelt and Churchill etc. If you have further questions it would be my pleasure to enlight you about the historical events taking place in this period of time.
Alles richtig. Die Wahrheit wird das Deutsche Volk nie erfahren Die Frage stellt sich was das Deutsche Volk verbrochen hat um so hinterhältig belogen zu werden.
Manstein manipulates the evidence and blames Paulus for the events that happen at Stalingrad. But the reality is, his version of events is wrong. ua-cam.com/video/uzAzpIdDNcI/v-deo.html
@paulrimmer391 Perhaps yes perhaps not. Even if Moscow had fallen the war wasn't over Stalin had a big war industry behind Ural, not attackable for the tiny german bombers. With Hitlers war Deklaration against US the war was 100% lost
14 днів тому
They're all smoking. Ugh Hitler never taught them how bad smoking is? Terrible!
Manstein manipulates the evidence and blames Paulus for the events that happen at Stalingrad. But the reality is, his version of events is wrong. ua-cam.com/video/uzAzpIdDNcI/v-deo.html
Rudol Hess wird am wenigsten vermisst und erwähnt, schon komisch RUDOLF HESS hat gelebt bis 1987 . Ich habe das Gefühl das Rudolf Hess einen Großen Teil zum Ost Block System und DDR Politik dazu beigetragen hat. Meine persönliche Meinung als alter West Deutscher Bürger und christ. Klaus - Dieter Scheffel geb. BURGET
Danke fürs hochladen. :)
Thanks for this upload. :)
I'm amazed how Donitz, Mannstein, Jodl et al spoke with this high tone.
Perhaps the microphone
I expected a deeper tone of voice from Field Marshall Von Manstein.
It's the same phenomenon with an expected voice we anticipate in leaders at all, two more examples are Ulbricht and Honecker, leaders of the socialistic East-Germany.
They sound like eunuchs.
@@EJStormful these bastards were....
@@kubanskiloewe ...or should have been.
Typischer Casinoton Preussischer Offiziere. Vorwitziger Klassenbester.
You might say the same of George. Patton, that is; General George Patton.
He expresses himself clearly, succinctly and logically. Very typical of someone brought up in a Prussian/German environment.
...and it also helped him to talk himself out when he was asked to support the resistance. "this is unsoldierly" not "i would like to help, but im afraid".
@@mauricekeip6303 I don't think he was afraid - he was simply psychologically unable to support the resistance, because of his upbringing and his character.
@@myfilm18 Sometimes i think the same about Hitler.
@@mauricekeip6303 Sind Sie aus Deutschland?
@@myfilm18 Nein. Sie?
These Nuremberg Trial videos are historically quite significant, but they would be much better with either a voiceover translation or subtitles.
The questions are fair and polite, in clear German. The accused are given time to explain their actions. I am impressed with the clarity of the spoken German. Beautiful!
Manstein does not blame anyone. He describes the historical context of the time, including the effects and ongoing legacy of the WW1 context. In fact, he often alludes to WW1.
The lesson we can all learn is that war is bad and we should avoid it. Had I been round at the time, and a German, I would have been proud to have Manstein as my leader. I am sure that the court would have respected him also.
Manstein was a devoted fan of Hitler....nothing to be proud about.
@@Petal4822 Churchill was a fan of Hitler's also in the mid 1930s.
@@peace-now Not true. Churchill wrote books condemning Hitler in the early 1930’s. Churchill loathed Hitler.
@@Petal4822 weren't a lot of people a fan of Hitler, just cuz your a fan of someone doesn't mean you neccesarily have the same mind as them, I mean his dismissal was cuz of arguments, which is not really something a fan would do
@@Petal4822 Manstein was one of the few generals that dared to stand up against Hitler too. He was not as vocal as Guderian but he also got into some heated arguments with him.
I miss the other war criminals in this round: Churchill Roosevelt and their colleagues
Stalin being #1!
@@GeorgeTel100 Stop whinging
General von Manstein ist ein Held gewesen, den Hitler nicht leiden konnte.
Ja, ein guter General aber er hat Krieg für einen Verbrecher geführt!
@@manfredkleist7966 Der Verlierer wird am Ende immer der Verbrecher sein. Ich sehe dies anders. General von Manstein hatte auf den Sieg gesetzt und immerhin die Schlacht um Sewastopol auf der Krim gewonnen. Es ist ein Präventivschlag gewesen, leider ist es gescheitert.
von Manstein war einer der größten Verbrecher der Wehrmacht. Ein brillianter General aber ein schlechter Mensch.
My country has a proverb “ You win, you become a king. You lose, you turn yourselves into enemy”. The one who win the war will decide how the history is written.
@@paulminh3525 Yes of course, that is true. My country then had to blame themselves solely for both World Wars. It is a historical truth that these wars had many fathers. It is like a song from ABBA. The Winner takes it all, the loser standing small.
“When this war is over we will be accused of an infinity of murder as if all men at war everywhere hadn’t behaved in the same way” The Forgotten Soldier
WAITE A MINUTE; VON MANSTEIN WENT ON TRIAL FOR BEING A GENERAL ON THE LOSING SIDE?
No, not for his role as a general during the war, but because on October 10, 1941 he issued an order to all soldiers under him that practically made the "Wehrmacht" an accomplice in the murder of Jewish civilians by the "SS" and "SD Einsatzgruppen" as he made an explicit promise of support from ordinary soldiers in these war crimes. In fact, the trial in Nuremberg saved him from being extradited to Poland or the Soviet Union, where he would have faced execution. According to the Yalta Declaration, the Allies agreed that war criminals should be tried at the place where the crimes took place. The British in particular did not want to extradite Manstein and have him executed by Stalin's regime because they simply considered his military knowledge to be far too valuable, so that he later became an advisor to the now allied German army in the Cold War.
@@MachiaveIIi25 In Nürnberg wurde von Manstein als Zeuge der Anklage im Verfahren gegen den Generalstab des Heeres verhört. Der Vorwurf der Anklage lautete: Der Generalstab sei eine verbrecherische Organisation gewesen. Im Gegensatz zur "SS" wurde die Anklage vom Ankläger in Nürnberg zurück gezogen oder das Gericht hat den Generalstab freigesprochen. Die "SS" wurde als "verbrecherische Organisation" verurteilt, was auch aus deutscher Sicht richtig war und ist. Die Kriegerwitwen bekamen allerdings keine Witwenrente nach dem Krieg von den beiden neuen Staaten.
@@MachiaveIIi25BS. The whole court from the US representation was Jewish and Loxists. Look it up.
@@inpersonaDK What does your comment have to do with mine, and even if so, how would those circumstances refute anything i wrote? Do you even understand the topic or did you just randomly pick a comment in which to indulge in your cheap revisionism
Is this testimony available in English translation?
No you noob you must learn german to understand the history
Die Stimme ähnelt sehr der von Karl Dönitz.
Bei Interviews mit Generalen/Admiralen der Wehrmacht ist festzustellen, dass sie alle mehr oder weniger die gleiche Art zu reden haben. Auch der Tonfall ist bi allen sehr ähnlich.
Da enden aber schon die Gemeinsamkeiten. So hat man damals eben gesprochen. Hör dir mal Klaus Kinski aus den 60er Jahren an. Suche nach die Lästerzungen
Interessant zu hören, was die Angeklagten gesagt haben. Ohne Zensur und ohne Kommentar. Sehr schön. Das damalige Gericht ist anzuzweifeln.
und heute bist du ein covidiot und putin freund
@@quikzome6973 Lass dich wegimpfen!
Erich von Manstein war aber kein Angeklagter, sondern Zeuge.
Not questionable. It was totally bias. Never happened in history before and an intentionally to humiliate and stigmatize the Germans by the Zionists and Loxists
3:05 "Als outsider" dass ein Wehrmachtsgeneral schon Anglizismen benutzt, das ist bemerkenswert.
?? ein nicht geringer Teil der Offiziere, vor allem in der Luftwaffe konnten fließend englisch...die meisten es verstehen; es gehörte auch teilweise zur AUsbildung !
Ja habe mich auch gewundert.
Hat nur noch gefehlt das er sagt ... "unsere Truppen waren leider nicht up to date"
@@Zeta_Reticulum ....:-)
Glaubst du ein General ist ungebildet?
Strange how the caption and description is in English, but they provide no English subtitles. What's the purpose of that? They lure in English speaking people...due to the English caption, then they throw German at us. What the heck is that about?
It is actually an excellent idea when you remember that the trials were a total travesty of truth and of history itself. The mass murderer, Stalin, responsible for ten to thirty times the deaths caused by Germans and Japanese together, used the trials to cover his own attrocities, like the mass graves of Katyn Forrest. The english and american attrocities were also off limits. It was a rigged show trial from the start. So, yes, it is right that a sham trial should be as obscured as possible.
I can get it in English if I turn the CC on and move the auto-generate from German to English.
@@jackmeskill2539 , thing is the Nazis started a total World war .
If you are responsible for putting children in ovens you get everything you deserve.
@@jameshodgkins559 any proof?
@@goijehudim5798 , I started work in 1983 .
One of the old boys I used to worked with helped liberate Belsen .
I’ve heard first hand what them bastard nazis done from someone that was there.
Make no mistake the Nazis where evil & got what they deserved .
Von Manstein was a great officer
He was also involved in the murder of Soviet POW's and Civilians, and was involved in the Holocaust.
@@johnnymlad8472 He was a rabid Anti Semite, who watched the Murder of Women and Children, he did not have to do it, but he did, it is well documented, Prisoner exchange , what damn planet are you on, the Russians had little hope with the Germans and the Germans knew that the Russians would kill them for all the Filthy atrocities committed in Russia against its civilian population, you do realise that when anti partisan operations were going on, they may have killed Partisans but they also killed everybody in the Villages at the same time, Herman Fegelein was very cruel in that respect, 18000 Villages Thousands of Towns erased with the populations murdered, that was Russia under the Germans 27 Million Civilians, and you talk of Von Manstein wanting Prisoner exchanges, if they had given him to the Russians they would have had Millions to watch the cruel bastard hang.
His stance compared to Guderian was stark, Russian Commanders admired Guderian, they hated to the core Von Manstein, Dietl in the Balkans was a cruel Bastard as well.
He was a fascist and an enemy of all the freedoms we cherish. There were no "Good Germans" in the officer corps.
@@johnnymlad8472 Still a fascist at the end of the day
@@robertevans8010 Bollocks. Are you sure you are not the raving Richard Evans?
Der taktisch und strategisch größte Generalfeldmarschall der damaligen Wehrmacht!!! Treue um Treue.....
🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸
Nichts, auf das man stolz sein könnte.
@@littlejohn5652 auf deine mutter nicht
Er war ein Verbrecher, der einem Verbrecher folgte. Wieviele Tote gab es seinetwegen in Belarus, der Ukraine und Polen? Er hätte Hitler bei einer Unterredung mit einer Gabel in den Hals stechen können, dann wäre er womöglich ein Held der in Treue zum Volk stünde. Aber so war er ein kleiner Wicht, ein Mörder und Antisemit, trainiert auf Befehl und Gehorsam, verehrt von Wichten bis heute.
@@brainpope6660 deine mutter mehr nicht
Sadly there's no English subtitles. The fallen liberators families would have wanted to hear what Manstein had to say.
Perhaps it would have been better in Russian they should have hold of him, it was Politics that stopped that, he would have paid the ultimate price for his Brutality and Murder.
Liberators?
Liberators? /
German is not so difficult.....learn it
@@minimax9452 Jawohl!
Stimme wäre bei der Augsburger Puppenkiste besser aufgehoben gewesen - vor allem unblutiger
Hast du ne Ahnung, wenn da das Krokodil kommt😂
Where are the video?
Ein zackiger preußischer Feldmarschall
Los sovieticos le tenian la celda lista en sus famosos campos de reeducacion ,pero nunca se imaginaron que Manstein terminaria como uno de los principales asesores de la Otan en la Guerra Fria .Si no me equivoco ,en la foto donde sale fumando se alcanza a distinguir en su uniforme el escudo de los vencedores de Sebastopol .
Manstein nunca fué "uno de los principales asesores de la Otan en la Guerra Fria". Su actividad profesional en el período de posguerra se limitaba a la de consejero inoficial del Ministerio de Defensa alemán durante la reorganización del ejército alemán occidental: "Bundeswehr".
Antes lo ingleses tuvieron que jusgarle y condenarle a 18 años de prisión. El que haya terminado en la OTAN tiene que ver más con la guerra fría
"WE DEFEATED THE WRONG ENEMY!" Now we are paying the price
Yes we must destroy the USA all together
@@ChrisTenalach77777 Who will feed you?
@@psilvakimo not you that's for sure
@@ChrisTenalach77777 Damn right I won't. Not you, that's for sure as hell.
Manstein manipulates the evidence and blames Paulus for the events that happen at Stalingrad. But the reality is, his version of events is wrong.
ua-cam.com/video/uzAzpIdDNcI/v-deo.html
I apologise ifI'm being stupid but not speaking German I cannot follow any of this . The Robert h Jackson Centre should surely have a German name .
The German is very clear (klar). I can understand every word. Not like these days when you hear them speaking now, for example, Timo Werner and Joshua Kimmins.
@@peace-now 👍
En 1939, en una sola fábrica de tanques rusa producían más tanques que en todas las fábricas alemanas. En la primer arremetida, los alemanes destruyeron 35.000 tanques y carros blindados estacionados al Oeste para... invadir Europa.
Thanks dir this vid
Diese leicht Berlinerisch gefärbte Mäuschenstimme. Ich hatte mir einen Manstein immer anders vorgestellt. Jedoch sehr geschickt in seinen Formulierungen.
Der Sieger schreibt die Geschichte...
Ja und die aufgeschriebene Siegergeschichte der Deutschen bis zur Niederlage 1945 ist ebenfalls überliefert. Wo ist dein Problem?
Vaya valientes. Tirandole toda la culpa al muerto, a alguien que no puede defenderse.
Greatest Commander of all time in the whole world.
According to himself 😂😂
@@bigbadladnamedalasad7071 Not at all, his defensive Manouver at Kuban in 1943 was brilliant and Against Hitlers orders. He was prussian General in first place.
Good commanders don't lose the only 2 wars they fight in.
@@ItsYoBoyBryce00 And what do those two wars have in common? they fought on multiple fronts, the 2nd time of course they simply could not reproduce the things they needed fast enough and in the 1st war, they could not import food to feed their people, as they weren't taking Culturable grounds, hence why in the 2nd war, food wasnt a problem at all, They definitely did learn from their mistakes, forsept one, over extending, trying to take a Nation the size of Europe and a population so high you could stack all those people together and have the empire state building. Just mistakes, and idiotic leadership, not listening to your Generals is not very wise. Not all Generals are right of course, but most of the time theyre generals for a reason.
Where are Stalin, Churchill, Truman and other criminals to be judged by justice?
They were the liberators ....
@@Petal4822 ok commie
To the victor go the spoils.....
In what regard, exactly? If Hitler never came to power, invaded countries without provocation, killed millions because of his fanaticism, do you think these leaders would have involved their countries in war? No. Hitler and his regime, complicit with many of the German population, were solely to blame for war crimes.
@@davidlynch9049
That's the Anglo-American narration of history & WW2.
Please let's look at what happened through the perspective of others.
🌹
Who is the best german general? Manstein or Rommel?
Manstein
Manstein by talent
@@joachims1499 Rommel
Model
Rommel is overrated, certainly a very good divisional or corps commander, but unsuited for higher command due to lack of knowledge of supply/logistics/organizational ability. Manstein is probably the best overall (I mean, he could literally excell at anything, be it moving tanks or destroying fortresses), while late-war generals like Model or Heinrici were the best at organizing a good defense against a numerically superior enemy with depleted units. From what I know, Manstein was quite popular with his subordinate commanders, and worked very effectively together with them, like Manteuffel, Hoth, Hollidt,...
The story goes that at the Berlin Victory Banquet in 1945, after Russian troops performed their gruelling "Soldier's Dance" with military precision, Patton - not wishing to be upstaged - immediately launched into "Dixie" with a fine, soaring falsetto, gracefully conducting himself with his own gold-plated General's Swagger Stick.
His high-pitched canteen opera naturally stole the whole show with broken champagne glasses and raucous applause.
Unfortunately, Stalin and Zhukov were so unnerved by Patton's singing, they were forced to evacuate the minstrel's tribute with Explosive Vibratory Flatulence (EVB}.
A condition, by the way, the State Department uses to this day for diplomatic leverage at all high-level talks.
Can’t believe that Manstein’s voice sound like a teenager or a young man.
man kann es gar nicht glauben, dass ein mensch mit dieser stimme in solch einer hohen Position gelangt war.
Willkommen in der Realität, Hirn schlägt Stimme!
'It was nothing to do with me, guv!'
Please, you only need to read through the KTBs of various units on the eastern front to know what a pile of BS this is. The whole gang should have faced the firing squad.
Exactly. They were all criminals and allowed illegal acts…
Convicted and sentenced to eighteen (18) years and only served four (4).
and not guilty of anything other than being the best tactician and overall military genius of WW2. He was a most honourable and respected military leader. I recommend any of his books, but especially "Lost Victories". A marvelous man at any level.
Victors justice.
The russians later apologised to Von Manstein, stating publicly, after his release, that he had in fact been falsely accused and had not been guilty of any of the charges levelled against him.
He should have awarded ,praised, by the trails for his integrity and military bearing
@@robertdipaola3447 I am afraid that that totally discredited farce of a tribunal were not interested in truth or facts, but essentially in covering up russian, american, british and other allied war crimes and crimes against humanity. years later, the Russians admitted to the Katyn Forrest murders and many more, perpetrated on Stalin's direct orders. The Russian military also belatedly admitted that Field Marshal Eric Von Manstein was innocent of all charges put against him and had been jailed in a travesty of justice. Now, years later, we have the proof of facts denied by the victors . It is an old story, of course. The german Army, far from perpetrating attrocities on the Eastern Front, distinguished themselves in their attempts to protect local populations from the Communist retaliations and war crimes visited on them by advancing soviet troops, as the german armies retreated. It is sad that utter lies and falsehoods as presented in so many videos by this ignorant propagandist are still to be found on Utube. The author is an attention-seeking liar who may have some psychiatric issues. He is certainly not a historian, not even a very bad one.
My German is so so. Auto translation is bad.
A Great Prussian Style Commander. A great military leader and cultivated man .These were a class of military leaders like of which will never come again Their memory must be preserved.
Indian Military Veterans salute then .
Manstein manipulates the evidence and blames Paulus for the events that happen at Stalingrad. But the reality is, his version of events is wrong.
ua-cam.com/video/uzAzpIdDNcI/v-deo.html
My German's rusty wish it was in English please.
next tribunals will be ;-)
RIP heiliges Deutschland ❤
Stauffenberg Rules ❤ saved our honor somehow
So na ja@@cracksi001
As the accusations of war crimes and the validity of their innocence gets pointed in the comments, lest not forget that these men just like our honored servicemen and woman are all soldiers. Warriors who fought to the very end for their countries. Call it blind loyalty, but I see it as honorable valor to ones country. Each country played their role in terms of war crimes during WWII. At least they learned to be at least somewhat better in our modern society.
Don't equivicate what the Nazis did to what the allies did trying to stop them.
@@davidlynch9049 I'm saying at the end of the day soldiers fight wars for their countries as a duty to serve. And yes the Nazis had a radical and violent solution to their own problems but so did the Soviets who hailed as victors after the fact.
The German army lost its honor in WW2. The mass killings cant be excused away because of battlefield performance or their personal beliefs in military tradition.
They were jackbooted thugs wantonly killing civilians and waging aggressive wars against peaceful nations.
Read about German militarism and their culture and you can see how they slowly lost their minds over the centuries, culminating in WW2. Its not really rocket science.
mein Onkel-Urgroßvater.
I Have footage farm Die Deutshe Wocensch videos which Gobbels team was broadcasting in theatres across Germany and Wermacht units, you can see in Baltic state Invasion that Jewish civilians are being stripped and shot, similarly when the Germans were sure of Soviet Union surrendering till Oct -1941, 2 million Soviet POW's were starved to death, only after when the realised they needed the POW labour did these POW have better survival rates, even Polish civilians trying to give some milk to Soviet POW's were shot by the Wermacht. The biggest post world war 2 myth was that of a clean Wermacht, most Wermacht leaders were for the Invasion of Soviet Union, belived in Utermenchen concept and performed the war of Anhilation on the Soviets, it was only at the Wars end they all pretended to be innocent.
Manstein manipulates the evidence and blames Paulus for the events that happen at Stalingrad. But the reality is, his version of events is wrong.
ua-cam.com/video/uzAzpIdDNcI/v-deo.html
Firstly I recommend ro improve your spelling.
Secondly those Jews in the Baltic states were beaten to death by
indigenous Baltic inmates who were liberated by the Germans.
Last but not least: v. Mansteins original name was v. Lewinski and he had jewish ancestry from Warsaw/ Poland
To be continued...
Best marschall maybe in Europe during WW2
Best General George Patton during WW2
@@Petal4822 crazy best Marshall Fritz Erich von Manstein
Fair justice of the victorious Allies!
They never disarmed their military forces after WW 1, no on the contrary they were deploying more and more military.
France: 724.000
Belgium:113.000 Germany:100.00
Poland: 275.000
Sowjets:885.000
This a ratio of about.....a bloody lot.
They elegantly broke their promises!
And the so called Polish victims tried to force the French at about 3x to start a two-frontline -war against Germany between the years of 1919 to 1933.
Years before Hitler came to power.
They also circulated maps depicting
the new borders to their West, for instance, in the vicinity of our capital
Berlin.
Not to mention their policy about treating their minorities in the most cruel and apalling way.
Hence killing, rapeing and ransacking about 58.000 Germans living in Poland due to the stupid and severing borders fullfilling the Versailles Dictate.
While declaring war on Germany on the 3rd of September, they never declared war
on Russia although they invaded Eastern Poland on 17.9.1939!
And which conclusions do we draw
about the Jewish DECLARATION of war on Germany on the 24.3.1933?
Was that just a joke? Welll we will never learn, because documentnare willneverHitler was in office for about 53 days only.Strange but evident....and I could go on and on about Roosevelt and Churchill etc.
If you have further questions it would be my pleasure to enlight you about the historical events taking place in this period of time.
Alles richtig.
Die Wahrheit wird das Deutsche Volk nie erfahren
Die Frage stellt sich was das Deutsche Volk verbrochen hat um so hinterhältig belogen zu werden.
Talking like a canary...tweeting like a bird... that suits him! That's Manstein
His Balls never dropped still a boy soprano
Vorrei vedere You ,con un cappio al collo:l'Aida au contrarie,gli canti,se richiesto.
Manstein manipulates the evidence and blames Paulus for the events that happen at Stalingrad. But the reality is, his version of events is wrong.
ua-cam.com/video/uzAzpIdDNcI/v-deo.html
Stupid comments.
If only Mannstein had been given supreme command. The Red Army would have been smashed by Christmas. He was a military genius.
No, the german troops had been too weak, few ammuntion, freezed tanks and no winter clothing...
@@Micha-y2c Not in July!
@paulrimmer391
Perhaps yes perhaps not. Even if Moscow had fallen the war wasn't over Stalin had a big war industry behind Ural, not attackable for the tiny german bombers. With Hitlers war Deklaration against US the war was 100% lost
They're all smoking. Ugh Hitler never taught them how bad smoking is? Terrible!
Ich sage nur Jawoll!
Amazing Von Manstein
I don't believe he was a criminal,he was good at his job.
The Nüremberg trials was kangrøø court.
Why the hell were they allowed to smoke cigarettes during the Nuremberg trials …..if it was the other way around, they would be facing a firing squad.
This is older pic, when were still in field and active generals.
Are you kinda stupid, Elaine? This picture isn’t from Nuremberg trial.
@@davidglickstein5169 The Video is titled Nuremberg trial....
@@Petal4822 I see, you‘re stupid. lol
Those generals were fighting for their country, respect them.
videl som Hákový kríž na moste necítil som nič a knihu ktorú som ešte nečítal nevidel môj boj ne prešla by mňe cez srdce mali chlapec 🧒
Manstein manipulates the evidence and blames Paulus for the events that happen at Stalingrad. But the reality is, his version of events is wrong.
ua-cam.com/video/uzAzpIdDNcI/v-deo.html
Miss real men
Don't speak German so this is just jabbering to me
None of this is any good without fucking subtitles. ....
Very soon Iranian generals would be answering in a court too for all their crimes against humanity.
Sounds just like a Kraut _Patton._
Der Feldmarschall mit einer lächerlich hohen Stimme.
Rudol Hess wird am wenigsten vermisst und erwähnt, schon komisch RUDOLF HESS hat gelebt bis 1987 . Ich habe das Gefühl das Rudolf Hess einen Großen Teil zum Ost Block System und DDR Politik dazu beigetragen hat. Meine persönliche Meinung als alter West Deutscher Bürger und christ. Klaus - Dieter Scheffel geb. BURGET
Rudol Hess flew to Scotland for a summer vacation and never returned to Germany.
kompletter Unsinn...als wessi und Atheist
Genius interviewed by non-geniuses.
Useless.