I don’t know why people dislike this recording. It’s faster than other famous recordings but venegrov creates so many colors in his sound, it’s really, really good. The sound quality I think perfectly fits the mood of the piece, the crackles and the constant buzz in the background gives it such a sweet, nostalgic feeling. It’s my favorite recording on UA-cam
@@musicwizardtom There is a famous interview from Arthur Rubinstein where he says "One must be born with talent, that is the most important thing". So I don't know who you're referring to when you say "these people". There are literally thousands of musicians playing 10 hours a day and who will never achieve what Vengerov is showing here.
In my experience the last one they showed (arpeggios with pizz in second to last variation) is the hardest passage tied with the some of the artificial harmonic double stops in the last one. There's literally only 2 bars to "relax" in the entire piece though.
Honestly I like the tempo he sets here. Especially because he managed to retain a lot of the musicality and phrasing even tho he picks up the pace more than other recordings.
@Joshua Thompson Yeah, this video was definitely recorded many years ago, but he doesn't look 15. That's besides the point of the comment though, he makes it look easy because of how good his technique is. Age doesn't matter here.
i wont read any more comments, they are ignorant, sickening negative and just plain dumb... vengerov is totally amazing and can hold his violin any way he pleases, he can interpret any composer again, any way he pleases, he can express his face and body without criticism... you fools... if u cant hear the quality of his soul then don't listen.... don't watch... just go to other sites and listen to technicians wit no expression at all.. please go
Let's all be respectful and not call each other fools. You doing so makes you no better than anyone else that you criticize of. It is true that some people may prefer different interpretations, and if one has a well trained ear, listening to more subtle emotions that is not conveyed in just plain movements alone go a long way.
@@fam-guy26 Around 27375hrs of serious practice needed to play this on a decent professional level(So at least double it for Vengerov).So yeah totally not as hard as it sounds, its much harder.
@@compoeses Saw somone performe it at a well known music uni in my area and I know other students on a similar Level from this uni who told me how much they practice. Of course its just a "educated guess"
The bad recording gives a sense of nostalgia. I like the the distortion, because it the performance feel like a mark in history. Also this is better than Hillary Hahn’s version sorry but it’s the truth.
That pizz arpeggios were even harder so they probably didn't have time to mention that. It is like the easiest parts of the piece are hard in the normal scale and normal parts are insane
1. Why do i have the impression that he's smilling during all the piece as if to say "yeah too easy man "?😅 2. Also like some people walk during their sleep, this guy just play violin while sleeping. It's the only explanation i found to explain that he seems to have his eyes close during all the piece.
@Joshua Thompson Corrected comment: What do you mean? I was just wondering what the point was to go grammar nazi on someone's comment when they're clearly not a native speaker, if the meaning of the comment is still intelligible. xD
@Joshua Thompson It was meant a bit more light-heartedly, so don't get upset please. Just couldn't help but wonder, and sometimes ppl feel bad when they try to interact online but don't have the most polished English. Sorry if I came off as nasty. All the best!
To all the people criticizing him. He is technical as perfect as nobody else. Just watch his Sibelius Vilinconcerto. He plays it without any wrong note(maybe a few that are not 100% in tune) and with so many different colours and emotions, and with perfect technic. After that the ysaye Sonata Nr. 3. again with perfect tune and technic. At the same time so dramatic. In my opinion his Sonata has to played exacly like he does. Back to this piece. He Interpretation is so Gold. I mean compare his ending with Hilary's ending or look at the move he does while playing the left hand Finger pizz.- part...
Harmonicos y pizzicatos a la vez! Oh, DIOS MIO! QUE TERROR! Siempre he considerado que esta pieza es la obra mas difícil de la historia del violín pasando por encima a los caprichos de Paganini, las sonatas y partitas de Dios Bach y las sonatas de Ysaye y Bartok. Una pieza entre deliciosa y encantadora para nuestros oídos, no se que tan infernal para un violinista, en lo personal me atreví a interpretar las anteriores, pero cuando vi la partitura de esta obra, me dio miedo y no me he atrevido a ni ensayarlo.
Tactical_Strike sorry-I know the feeling as a violinist as well. I tried to do the double stopped artifice harmonics - it took about 15 seconds to just sound one of them
Too many people say that the pizzicatos on 6:10 and the later ones are super hard… but the real hard part is the 4:38… it’s the only part when he actually opens his eyes and thinks it through a little to do it correctly, the other ones come on muscle memory but… that thing that is similar to a Bach fugue whit PIZZICATO AND HARMONICS is the real difficulty of this piece…
The recording of this quality kind of ruins the video quite a bit. That's why midoris version is probably the best now if it wasn't for the lack luster recording quality of this track.
This is definitely my second favorite, I'll take Hillary Hahn's version any day, even accounting for audio technology differences I'll take her any day over this.
I give up listening to any other version than Midori’s for this. I love both Vengerov and Hillary but when it comes to this piece they can’t hold a candle out to her in my opinion
Hilary is cleaner and gives more life to each note while having a more robust tone. BUT! This recording leaves much to be desired in terms of audio quality.
As much as I love Vengerov's interpretations... this one is just not right, too fast and furious, this is supposed to be played slowly and calmly, like a lullaby.
I think the title of the piece show give a interpretation of how the piece should feel “last rose of the summer” the last rose trying to keep alive in the fun summer experience these adventures throughout
All I can say… just don’t play like this… He doesn’t breathe, music need to breathe… it’s like swimming and not breathing, you need to take pauses, otherwise it’s horrible, like most parts on this video, we can’t understand what he’s playing..
When he opens his eyes you know that part is hard..
I don’t know why people dislike this recording. It’s faster than other famous recordings but venegrov creates so many colors in his sound, it’s really, really good. The sound quality I think perfectly fits the mood of the piece, the crackles and the constant buzz in the background gives it such a sweet, nostalgic feeling. It’s my favorite recording on UA-cam
Non classical people are obsessed with bumblebee
@@kev5996 Exactly somehow it has become the standard of technical proficiency 😐
wait, so there is someone who didnt like this recording.. why tho? its good
@@kev5996 ah yeah that one piece
I like the more delicate version from midori
those harmonics, those left hand pizz... i-i’m speechless over his talent
little sunny, we dont throw the word talent around these people
@@musicwizardtom yeah, we use skill and hard work and most importantly, PRACTICE
@@musicwizardtom There is a famous interview from Arthur Rubinstein where he says "One must be born with talent, that is the most important thing". So I don't know who you're referring to when you say "these people". There are literally thousands of musicians playing 10 hours a day and who will never achieve what Vengerov is showing here.
Talent, intelligence and industry are all important in becoming a great violinist.
Brett and Eddy didn't even show the actually hard and impressive parts :o
In my experience the last one they showed (arpeggios with pizz in second to last variation) is the hardest passage tied with the some of the artificial harmonic double stops in the last one. There's literally only 2 bars to "relax" in the entire piece though.
right
i love them! didn't know they had a video bout vengerov ^^ where can i find it?
@@avitalalef9947 it’s the most difficult pieces video
So they should show us the whole video instead?
I like the muffled sound, it gives a particular vibe to the recording
I agree, like it makes it sound older somehow
I'm terrified, he's too good
Honestly I like the tempo he sets here. Especially because he managed to retain a lot of the musicality and phrasing even tho he picks up the pace more than other recordings.
he makes it look easy
That’s why he’s a profession 😂
Joshua Thompson He is 46 not 15 lmao. Was that a joke?
@Joshua Thompson Yeah, this video was definitely recorded many years ago, but he doesn't look 15. That's besides the point of the comment though, he makes it look easy because of how good his technique is. Age doesn't matter here.
@Joshua Thompson Oh I see. Have a good day!
@Joshua Thompson bruh the first 2 pages aren't that bad
U gotta love those smug smiles and those perfect string crossings
the left hand pizzicato of Maxim Vengerov its unbelievable
And the glissed octaves stayed in tune all the way up and down
My self esteem before watching this: +10000
My self esteem after watching this: -10000
But i will keep on practicing 40 hours a day!
i wont read any more comments, they are ignorant, sickening negative and just plain dumb... vengerov is totally amazing and can hold his violin any way he pleases, he can interpret any composer again, any way he pleases, he can express his face and body without criticism... you fools... if u cant hear the quality of his soul then don't listen.... don't watch... just go to other sites and listen to technicians wit no expression at all.. please go
Let's all be respectful and not call each other fools. You doing so makes you no better than anyone else that you criticize of. It is true that some people may prefer different interpretations, and if one has a well trained ear, listening to more subtle emotions that is not conveyed in just plain movements alone go a long way.
Piss off wanker
I did not know the violin could do all that! The height of virtuosity! ❤
4:37 excuse me wtf how is he doing that.
Idk he’s a true ling ling
It is not that hard as it Sounds. It is just a thing of long slow Practice. But he is doing it amazing.😉
@@fam-guy26 Around 27375hrs of serious practice needed to play this on a decent professional level(So at least double it for Vengerov).So yeah totally not as hard as it sounds, its much harder.
@@tbrwsWhere'd you get that number from?
@@compoeses Saw somone performe it at a well known music uni in my area and I know other students on a similar Level from this uni who told me how much they practice. Of course its just a "educated guess"
Thank you for the posting!!superb Vengerov!!!
The bad recording gives a sense of nostalgia. I like the the distortion, because it the performance feel like a mark in history. Also this is better than Hillary Hahn’s version sorry but it’s the truth.
Vincent Gomez agree
Yes it is.
Is this recording sped up? It feels like it is slightly sped up
@@robertkim3066 No Vengerov is just a god, but in reality maybe.
@@NoferTadros he talking about why its so distorted
He touches the places that have never been touched before on the violin
I generally thought that my playback speed was 1.5, but it's just his skills
if you can play something slowly, you can play it quickly
that was INSANE PIZZICATO AT 6:10, I'm just terrified :0, Why did brett and eddy did not show this part?
WHAT WAS THAT
I almost fell out my chair that was inhuman
That pizz arpeggios were even harder so they probably didn't have time to mention that. It is like the easiest parts of the piece are hard in the normal scale and normal parts are insane
I think it's sped up. If it isn't, then he's not human.
@@ainhawani5094 Its not sped up, no hes not a human
Funny how this video is ranked as Comedy
Were supposed to be laughing cause well never be a ling ling like him.
I assume comedy refers to the laughably bad audio quality of the recording.
@@ruthsteen6943 I'm inclined to think that his guess is more accurate
@@ruthsteen6943 I think it adds a bit of nostalgia to the piece ,but hey that's my opinion....
Must be because it sounds funny, like something out of Looney Tunes
Hahaha
*cries*
The thought alone of meeting those people who disliked this video makes me feel uncomfortable.
5:20 did he just forgot to breathe lmao
you can hear the audience laughing while he climaxes lmao
He did that intentionally to flex how good he is.
And that smug grin afterwards xDD
1. Why do i have the impression that he's smilling during all the piece as if to say "yeah too easy man "?😅
2. Also like some people walk during their sleep, this guy just play violin while sleeping. It's the only explanation i found to explain that he seems to have his eyes close during all the piece.
4:40 pizz at that speed whaa
Ikr I can’t even tell he’s doing it
absolutely amazing.
Did he just closes his eyes ? He his overly confident, but this is such beautiful.... 😭❤️
Joshua Thompson ... yes i m not english frère
@Joshua Thompson why would you even
@Joshua Thompson Corrected comment:
What do you mean?
I was just wondering what the point was to go grammar nazi on someone's comment when they're clearly not a native speaker, if the meaning of the comment is still intelligible. xD
@Joshua Thompson It was meant a bit more light-heartedly, so don't get upset please. Just couldn't help but wonder, and sometimes ppl feel bad when they try to interact online but don't have the most polished English. Sorry if I came off as nasty. All the best!
@Joshua Thompson "beautifully" would be more correct...
Who else is here from TwoSet ?
Also omg Vengerov!!!
Where does that piece appear in one of their videos?
They ranked it 2nd hardest violin piece
@@meraldlag4336 Send link please.
ua-cam.com/video/awWpqR7yUHM/v-deo.html
me!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Only a few hundred thousand views??? Cmon guys we can do better than this. Let’s share this masterpiece!!!!
This vid is literally an international treasure 👏
To all the people criticizing him. He is technical as perfect as nobody else. Just watch his Sibelius Vilinconcerto. He plays it without any wrong note(maybe a few that are not 100% in tune) and with so many different colours and emotions, and with perfect technic.
After that the ysaye Sonata Nr. 3. again with perfect tune and technic.
At the same time so dramatic. In my opinion his Sonata has to played exacly like he does. Back to this piece. He Interpretation is so Gold. I mean compare his ending with Hilary's ending or look at the move he does while playing the left hand Finger pizz.- part...
I love his ballade he just makes it amazing. Especially towards the end where it goes crazy.
Love the Man and the Violinist Vengerov, can't even imagine how hard is to make this piece alive as he do
Nobody is criticizing him
He is not as good as Heifetz and the rest of the old guys. But in terms of interpretation and sound i often prefer him
Don’t forget Bach before the ballade too!
Speechless. CRAZYYY
Bravo!
IT TAKEN ME HALF AN HOUR TO GIVE ONLY ONE READ TO AN 8 MINUTE PIECE. BELIEVE ME IS THE MOST DIFFICULT PIECE OF ALL TIME !!!!!!!!!
Harmonicos y pizzicatos a la vez! Oh, DIOS MIO! QUE TERROR! Siempre he considerado que esta pieza es la obra mas difícil de la historia del violín pasando por encima a los caprichos de Paganini, las sonatas y partitas de Dios Bach y las sonatas de Ysaye y Bartok. Una pieza entre deliciosa y encantadora para nuestros oídos, no se que tan infernal para un violinista, en lo personal me atreví a interpretar las anteriores, pero cuando vi la partitura de esta obra, me dio miedo y no me he atrevido a ni ensayarlo.
pieces i'll never be able to play, #1
Wauw best vengerov ever!
I like how his face is like "Mmmmm too easy I want to go home and sleep"
I am speechless when he played the variarion when left hand pizz is the melody, its like Ernst trying to be better than Paganini
Me: I might be able to play this
Also me: watching at 0.000000001x speed
Brooo I've been trying bach preludio e major and I hv to transcribe by ear(can't read music)at 0.25x speed 🤣
He really can master that work. Pure class. Shame that it's so bad recording.
God! He's a God!
he's the only one who can compete with LingLing
Vengerov is a real good of the violin
Madre del amor hermoso
excelente version
Damn bro thats quite OP. He is a anime MC
4:37 Where is that pizz. coming from lol
Wtfff ok is a second violin but I don’t see yeh it’s that 😶
He is using the free fingers of his left hand to pluck the string
@@meraldlag4336 ... i know its a joke... im a violinist and it is hard to make pizz. like that so seamless
Tactical_Strike sorry-I know the feeling as a violinist as well. I tried to do the double stopped artifice harmonics - it took about 15 seconds to just sound one of them
All those faces he was making, this was too easy for him. What is this man made of dude
I love the spam of left hand pizz at 3:36
EXZELLENT!!!
3:40 crazy pizz part
Funnily enough the easiest part of the entire piece once you figure out how it works
Oof
how to play sacles
Даже страшно становится!
Why is this labeled into the Comedy Category??
Because it is so difficult its almost comedy and not music
When was this performance?
at 5:20 i love how hes like "AAAA SO HARD- just kidding"
holy shit
6:11 😭😭😭😭😭🤯
Too many people say that the pizzicatos on 6:10 and the later ones are super hard… but the real hard part is the 4:38… it’s the only part when he actually opens his eyes and thinks it through a little to do it correctly, the other ones come on muscle memory but… that thing that is similar to a Bach fugue whit PIZZICATO AND HARMONICS is the real difficulty of this piece…
vengerov makes rush e like twinkle twinkle
Hey ma, look! Eyes closed
3:29 bro he going MAD, with the pinky not stroking. I would bow to Venegrov, and alos the creator of the music [Ernst]..
Is that a Strad?
The pizz is so fast the camera couldn’t quite catch it :’D
who put dislikes???!!! Ling Ling??
...
Twoset violin
5:20 para el realmente parece ser facil
WHAT. IN. THE. EVER. LOVING. HELL. WHAT THE F********* IS THATTTT
6:10 wut
How many of you came from twoset
the sound quality is pretty poor.
The recording of this quality kind of ruins the video quite a bit. That's why midoris version is probably the best now if it wasn't for the lack luster recording quality of this track.
Yeah but in a way it kind of gives a nostalgic feel to it
what
If I have to find one mistake in this magnificent performance, is at 6:25
There was no mistake there pal
Too easy, play it on viola next time
The dynamic range of the recorded sound is compressed and tonalities don’t come through neutrally. A great pity.
He must have sold his soul to Lucifer to be able to play this
This is definitely my second favorite, I'll take Hillary Hahn's version any day, even accounting for audio technology differences I'll take her any day over this.
If you don't know Midori's performance - which towers above Hilary's (and this one) - you are really missing out.
what the f
Wait.....He's using a 5 string violin. So Vengerov is a sacrilegious boi?
What are you taking about?, he's clearly using only 4 strings
@@owdy3973 I think I saw it wrong cuz of the low res
@@thunderbolt2681 it's ok
How's your vision?
I give up listening to any other version than Midori’s for this. I love both Vengerov and Hillary but when it comes to this piece they can’t hold a candle out to her in my opinion
Violinist can play Caprice. No24 : Lol, poor noobs only can play Bach
(BACH:?????)
He : y'all trash
I even can close my eyes to play It
Deserve to be restaured
The music here sounds like the music on an old Caruso recording -- tinny and terrible!
True, but in the olden days that was normal lololol...
N Charles My point was that this is NOT the olden days, so why produce a recording that sounds so terrible? :-)
There is a recording of Madori Playing this piece on UA-cam... Much better sound; just as good as Maxim.
Hilary is cleaner and gives more life to each note while having a more robust tone. BUT! This recording leaves much to be desired in terms of audio quality.
I knew vengerov was good but not this good
As much as I love Vengerov's interpretations... this one is just not right, too fast and furious, this is supposed to be played slowly and calmly, like a lullaby.
+XJohn1996 So says you. As you contradictorily state, it's called an interpretation. Vengerov perfectly has the right to play it as he wants.
I think the opposite is true. Vengerov's performance outperformed the score itself (just my opinion though!).
I personally felt like he was fighting against the piece rather than enjoying it. Others might like this but I just prefer other versions.
John u can't give your opinion saying "is just not right".
I think the title of the piece show give a interpretation of how the piece should feel “last rose of the summer” the last rose trying to keep alive in the fun summer experience these adventures throughout
Horrible sound. What a waste.
What the fuck man,this is amazing.you clearly know nothing about the violin.
Hugo Haag
The recording sound quality...not the performance.
@@hugohaag9878 what? He saying about the recording sound quality
All I can say… just don’t play like this…
He doesn’t breathe, music need to breathe…
it’s like swimming and not breathing, you need to take pauses,
otherwise it’s horrible, like most parts on this video, we can’t understand what he’s playing..