If TWICE was a group chat Jihyo: Start the group chat Jihyo and Nayeon: Fighting together Jeongyeon and Mina: The one who is explaining the homework Sana: The one who is asking about the homework Chaeyoung: The one who is just telling the people who are fighting to stop the fight Tzuyu: The one who is kind of smart and doesn't need too much explanation Dahyun: The one who tries to talk but keeps disconnecting in 10 seconds Momo: The one who has no idea why is she in here and leave
Reaches 1000s 1. 2:53 Jihyo - Someone Like Me 2. 3:10 Nayeon - LIKEY 3. 5:33 Jeongyeon - Pink Lemonade 4. 5:41 Mina - Dance The Night Away [Note 1] 5. 6:14 Sana - Wishing [Note 1] 6. 6:37 Tzuyu - STAY BY MY SIDE 7. 6:44 Chaeyoung - The Best Thing I Ever Did [Note 2] 8. 7:47 Dahyun - TURN IT UP 9. 8:31 Momo - Trick It Reaches 2000s 1. 5:50 Nayeon (+1) - CHILLAX [Note 1] 2. 6:08 Jihyo (-1) - L.O.V.E [Note 1] 3. 11:12 Jeongyeon - Go Hard 4. 11:18 Mina - Shot Clock 5. 12:31 Sana - Scandal 6. 12:50 Chaeyoung (+1) - SOS 7. 13:23 Tzuyu (-1) - Thank You, Family [Note 3] 8. 14:46 Dahyun - Push & Pull [Note 4] 9. 16:06 Momo - Sandcastle Reaches 3000s 1. 8:49 Nayeon - Fake & True 2. 9:17 Jihyo - POLISH 3. 16:20 Mina (+1) - Queen of Hearts 4. 17:29 Jeongyeon (-1) - Hare Hare Reaches 4000s 1. 12:06 Nayeon - Kura Kura 2. 12:41 Jihyo - Baby Blue Love Reaches 5000s 1. 15:21 Nayeon - Wonderful Day 2. 15:51 Jihyo - Flow like waves [Note 5] Notes: - “I WANT YOU BACK” was between “Be as ONE” and “STAY BY MY SIDE”. - “The Best Thing I Ever Did” was before “Yes Or Yes”. - “I Love You More Than Anyone” was after “Promise”. - “Push & Pull”, “Hello”, and “1, 3, 2” were sub-group songs in which all members had to participate in one of these song as a group of three members. - Mute gap between “TICK TOCK” to “That’s all I’m saying” to prevent copyright.
@@momoran_ you do the total amount of lines they have at the end divided by the amount of songs they participated in, the final chart and/or placement totals would help you with that.
1) Lead vocalist (treated as main) 2) Main vocalist 3) Vocalist (treated as lead) 4) Lead vocalist 5) Vocalist 6) Main rapper, vocalist 7) Vocalist 8) Lead rapper, sub vocalist 9) Sub vocalist, sub rapper
@@ainttrynabeniceWhat ok she is freaking all rounder of the group she is the best in rap and 4th best vocalist of the group. She really deserves more lines.
@@BstansforBno nayeons lines are necessary. She’s center on top of lead vocalist, face of the group and Lead dancer. All be positions contribute to her line distribution and as you can see the less she gets the worse their songs do with the general public. Hare hare is flopping and neon got the allot of lines in it💀
@@ElPato8 She needs to get important parts, and she gets a lot of them, she got choruses in Hare Hare and in all of the songs in Ready to Be, for example
Twice was never meant to have fair line distributions, a lot of people seem to not understand that. NMIXX for example was meant to. & if it makes you all feel better, all members actually have a say in who gets what lines. They said it once that they decide in a group chat. Also while all members sound amazing and have improved over the years, Jihyo, Nayeon, and Jeongyeon STILL carry live vocals. One main vocalist and two leads is a lot to compete for, esp in a group of 9 but I assume Jeongyeon just isn’t as hungry for those lines and is happy where she is.
I noticed that before the FOL era, Mina and Jeongyeon were closer in lines, now Jeongyeon and Sana are closer in lines, shows that Jeongyeon lines are kinda decreasing
Tzuyu's lines have been very consistent in 2023 (besides Catch a Wave), a lot around the middle (#4-#6). Meanwhile they were all over the place in 2022 lol, from her first #1 in a song to some last places.
Its not gonna happen. They already have 2 powerful vocals (Nayeon and Jihyo) and also 2 Calm vocals (Mina and Sana) they don't need Jeongyeon anymore. She is just there to get mistreated
@@EvenUA-cam she not gets less 😭 she is 5 in the most album only she is low in taste of love and perfect world but in the rest she is 5/4 so stop complain only jeongyeon get less lines and is the Lead Vocalist
Tzuyu, Dahyun and Momo deserve more lines chaeyoung gets a lot of lines and is mostly 3rd in most of their distributions. Tzuyu is also getting a lot right now, lets hope it stays that way. As of now, Dahyun and Momo have very little lines
I hope JYP gives JiHyo and JeongYeon more lines or promotes Mina to a lead vocalist and NaYeon to a main vocalist so the line distribution can evolve into something like this: 1. JiHyo 2. NaYeon or JeongYeon 3. NaYeon or JeongYeon 4. Sana or Mina 5. Sana or Mina 6. ChaeYoung or Tzuyu 7. ChaeYoung or Tzuyu 8. DaHyun 9. Momo
but why promoting two members to a position they can't reach? it's debatable about nayeon being a main vocalist, but mina has not the same skills as jeongyeon vocally speaking
@@kpopbroughtmehere Ik I’m basing it off of the line distribution besides if JYP is giving most adlibs and notes to NaYeon nowadays and Mina more lines then JeongYeon it would kinda be common sense to promote them if they were to be treated like this.
@@RRRonan even jennie in blackpink is not the main vocalist but has the most lines. even yeji in itzy is not the main vocalist but has the most lines. it's fvcked up i know (my bias in twice is jihyo and i would LOVE for her to be first), i don't know why the agencies keep doing this, but at least let's the main vocalist be the main vocalist, being untouched by the leads. the main is the main for a reason
RIGHT they are just screaming in the background half the lines wich is kind of their job in the group lmfao, maybe they could let jeongyeon highnote a bit too
@@nuggetsplace8273But i think mina have more because of the fact that she is more complete than jeongyeonnie. She only pass her in vocals, in dance and rap, mina win
@@avrilynicolas3247 this is a line distribution. lines require vocals. if you want to use dance habilities then go to a center distribution. That requires dance.
@@avrilynicolas3247jeongyeon's better in open style + why would dance matter this is line distribution and like half of their songs don't have a choreo lmao
Q I like and adore twice but even though jeongyeon doesn't have few lines, the simple fact of being the main vocalist and having less lines than mina leaves a lot to say about her position as Of vocalists since mina is not and jeongyeon is and when you see the great difference between jihyo nayeon and jeongyeon you see the little Interest in her having such a good vocal and so powerful but anyway, despite my discomfort with the matter of the main vocalists, I love twice and they have tremendous songs 😻😻💕💕💕💕
Why tf are some people in the comments putting Tzuyu in the bottom 2 or 3 of their "what it should be rankings" and labeling her mainly as "the visual" first and foremost when she's not even in the weaker third of the members at singing? The real line distribution is already doing her a bit of a disservice as it is.
The top 5 should be: Nayeon - Jihyo (1st or 2nd) Jeongyeon Chaeyoung - Mina Based on Vocal Tier Maybe 6th Tzuyu Dahyun 7th Sana 8th Momo 9th I know that JYPE is giving more lines to Nayeon because she has de the representative Voice of the group, center, Lead Vocalist and FOTG, so it’s okay (that’s why i put to Nayeon in 1st), the difference between Nayeon and Jihyo it’s not that huge compared to Jeongyeon, the Problem is that they still giving more lines to Mina and Sana and even Tzuyu than Jeongyeon, besides in Ready To Be the 1st place was really close between Nayeon and Jihyo SORRY IF I WROTE SOMETHING WRONG, I’M NOT GOOD AT ENGLISH 😂
1000 Jihyo - Someone Like Me (2017) Nayeon - Likey (2017) Jeongyeon - Pink Lemonade (2018) Mina - Dance The Night Away (2018) 2000 Nayeon - CHILLAX (2018) Jihyo - L.O.V.E (2018) 1000 Sana - Wishing (2018) Tzuyu - STAY BY MY SIDE (2018) Chaeyoung - The Best Thing I Ever Did (2018) Dahyun - TURN IT UP (2019) Momo - Trick It (2019) 3000 Nayeon - Fake & True (2019) Jihyo - POLISH (2019) 2000 Jeongyeon - Go Hard (2020) Mina - Shot Clock (2020) 4000 Nayeon - Kura Kura (2021) 2000 Sana - Scandal (2021) 4000 Jihyo - Baby Blue Love (2021) 2000 Chaeyoung - SOS (2021) Tzuyu - Thank you, Family (2021) Dahyun - Push & Pull (2021) 5000 Nayeon - Wonderful Day (2021) Jihyo - Flow like waves (2022) 2000 Momo - Sandcastle (2022) 3000 Mina - Queen of Hearts (2022) Jeongyeon - Hare Hare (2023)
How should be in my opinion 1. Jihyo (she's the main vocal) 2. Nayeon/Jeongyeon (lead vocals) 4. Chaeyoung (main rapper) 5. Dahyun (lead rapper) 6. Mina (the 2nd best sub vocal) 7. Momo (sub-rapper) 8. Sana/Tzuyu (sub vocal)
That's right except I'll change minas and dahyuns place because mina has an angelic voice but try should do this and distribution must be fair every member will get atleast 15+ seconds singing so it could be fair
Can You please do ATEEZ and SKZ album distribution please??? They both just made a cb with a mini and a full album respectively Pleasee haha Im a Big Fan of your work! I think You and Random-K are the best right now, I really respect all your work and love You guys do this 🎉🎉❤😊
Jyp:O que você quer de aniversário? Momo: Um unicornio! Jyp:Momo não é posivel isso, pessa outra coisa Momo:mais linhas! Jyp:OK que unicornio você quer?
Really entertaining to watch Sana, Dahyun and Tzuyu constantly overtake each other. Shame that the first spots are so established though. It would be so much cooler if each (or maybe at least the majority of them) had at least a brief time as the first one.. kind of like a time of attention for them.
all members have a song that they are top 1 Nayeon - I'm gonna be a star Sana - Merry & Happy Jihyo - TT Mina - Dance The Night Away Momo - Signal Tzuyu - Sandcastle Jeongyeon - Up No More Chaeyoung - How U Doin' Dahyun - Shadow
Tzuyu wasn't a good vocalist for a looong time, she started improving a lot since last year and almost reached Chae/Mina's level rn (she's E-, the other 2 are both E, Mina barely, Chae a bit higher) but if she keeps improving at this pace she can definitely surpass them both in like a year or two
Why are you making her compete with Sana? This isn't the first time I've seen you say something negative about Sana. Just say she deserves better and move on,don't target Sana. I hate seeing fans compare members. Also,she is not E-. She's close to supporting but still hasn't supported a single time. Shes a high f+ for now.
How come Jeongyeon a Lead Vocalist so far behind with her co-Lead/Main Vocalists. :( She really need more lines. 🥺🥺 So sad to see a Main Dancer have more lines than the Lead Vocalist.
Can we talk about the fact that Momo always had the least😭 like “give jeongyeon more lines” GIVE MOMO MORE LIKE I KNOW SHE IS LIKE MORE OF A DANCER BUT LIKE SHE STILL NEED LINES😭
Its a different situation, we all know momo is the weakest vocalist of the group and she gets center position in the dance breaks, meanwhile jeongyeon is a lead vocalist
@@Nayeonmy178 Clearly no, chaeyoung has a much better vocal than momo, she is not among twice's weak vocalists, with respect to dahyun, she has a better vocal than momo, and besides that, there are many lines where chae doesn't raps but she does, so nothing to do with chae.
@@Syzygy722 the only one strong vocalist are nayeon, jihyo and jeongyeon the rest have poor vocals but stand out in other aspects Also chaeyoung always has more lines than jeongyeon Jeon>>>>>>>Chaeyoung And Momo get hardly 9-10 seconds this very bad for a member Also dahyun is not very better than Momo She is a F while Momo F- so is not much different because dahyun passing the F#4 strained
1. Vocalist (3) 2. Vocalist (1) 3. Vocalist (5) 4. Vocalist (2) 5. Vocalist (8) 6. Vocalist (4) 7. Vocalist (6) 8. Vocalist (7) 9. Vocalist (9) Lol the gap between Jihyo who is Main Vocalist and Nayeon Lead Vocalist is very huge. I hope Jihyo can back on top and JYPE remember she is MAIN VOCALIST. Also wtf Jeongyeon was totally robbed all the time she is the second vocalist of the group and she get only few lines? She should get more and back atleast top 3 Chae should be 5 atleast she is Rapper and Vocalist i want her to be in 4th but it very impossible so 5th well good to her. 6th Should between Sana or Tzuyu (Tzuyu because she is F+ tier Sana is F only) Both also are fit for twice songs. Unfair for Dahyun and Momo but yes they are not a strong vocalist but they deserve lines. I hope JYPE will stop favoring some members 😢
Twice vocal ranking changed though : 1.Jihyo 2. Nayeon >= jeongyeon (nayeon improved). 4.mina 5.tzuyu 6.chaeyoung (she regressed to the point she can’t support anymore in their latest concert). 7.dahyun 8.sana 9.momo
The distance is so embarrassing 💀 no hate to Nayeon and Jihyo but they don’t need to carry every song behind their backs 😭 we have Jeongyeon, utterly the most underutilized and most stable vocalist in the group and yet y’all give her one chorus?? She should be much much higher, a few hundreds secs behind Jihyo at least. I understand her voice doesn’t suit Twice concepts, but she could do the adlibs instead of Nayeon’s screeching (sorry), and the last chorus with half a pre chorus (like TTT). That’s how simple it is. The rest of them I’m not complaining with tho.
@@gauravnandan8208 cuz they treat jeongyeon like a sub vocalist and every like 10 songs she gets lines and while Mina gets a lot of lines. (no hate to Mina I love both of them)
@iguaranteeigotcha16 I’m not saying that Mina is a better vocalist than jeongyeon?? I’m saying that as a lead vocal she should get more lines, yet she’s treated as a sub vocalist due to the lines that she gets. I’m also not saying that Mina is a bad vocalist. she is a sub vocalist, just that in this case the positions are not respected. we can see it when jeongyeon gets 8th on a title track (set me free). and sure, she doesn’t always have to be 3rd or 2nd in every song but it just feels like her vocals are being wasted.
@iguaranteeigotcha16 yea I also see what you are talking abt and agree with you that even in songs that she doesn’t get much lines she gets the hardest parts
Jeong is lead vocalist because she is better than Mina, Mina lines seems more because she sings more the slower parts which are like 4 words in a lot of seconds like in alcohol free she went from last to 5th with only "I'm in drunk with youuuuuuuuuuyu"
![TWICE ~ All Songs Line Distribution [from LIKE OOH-AHH to ONE SPARK]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/-F0Xok6F_i0/mqdefault.jpg)
![TWICE ~ All Songs Line Distribution [from LIKE OOH-AHH to ONE SPARK]](/img/tr.png)
![SEVENTEEN ~ All Songs Line Distribution [from Adore U to MAESTRO]](/img/n.gif)
If TWICE was a group chat
Jihyo: Start the group chat
Jihyo and Nayeon: Fighting together
Jeongyeon and Mina: The one who is explaining the homework
Sana: The one who is asking about the homework
Chaeyoung: The one who is just telling the people who are fighting to stop the fight
Tzuyu: The one who is kind of smart and doesn't need too much explanation
Dahyun: The one who tries to talk but keeps disconnecting in 10 seconds
Momo: The one who has no idea why is she in here and leave
thats right...everytime dahyun lleaves last palce she is just back in 9th place after like sub 7 songs
Reaches 1000s
1. 2:53 Jihyo - Someone Like Me
2. 3:10 Nayeon - LIKEY
3. 5:33 Jeongyeon - Pink Lemonade
4. 5:41 Mina - Dance The Night Away [Note 1]
5. 6:14 Sana - Wishing [Note 1]
6. 6:37 Tzuyu - STAY BY MY SIDE
7. 6:44 Chaeyoung - The Best Thing I Ever Did [Note 2]
8. 7:47 Dahyun - TURN IT UP
9. 8:31 Momo - Trick It
Reaches 2000s
1. 5:50 Nayeon (+1) - CHILLAX [Note 1]
2. 6:08 Jihyo (-1) - L.O.V.E [Note 1]
3. 11:12 Jeongyeon - Go Hard
4. 11:18 Mina - Shot Clock
5. 12:31 Sana - Scandal
6. 12:50 Chaeyoung (+1) - SOS
7. 13:23 Tzuyu (-1) - Thank You, Family [Note 3]
8. 14:46 Dahyun - Push & Pull [Note 4]
9. 16:06 Momo - Sandcastle
Reaches 3000s
1. 8:49 Nayeon - Fake & True
2. 9:17 Jihyo - POLISH
3. 16:20 Mina (+1) - Queen of Hearts
4. 17:29 Jeongyeon (-1) - Hare Hare
Reaches 4000s
1. 12:06 Nayeon - Kura Kura
2. 12:41 Jihyo - Baby Blue Love
Reaches 5000s
1. 15:21 Nayeon - Wonderful Day
2. 15:51 Jihyo - Flow like waves [Note 5]
Notes:
- “I WANT YOU BACK” was between “Be as ONE” and “STAY BY MY SIDE”.
- “The Best Thing I Ever Did” was before “Yes Or Yes”.
- “I Love You More Than Anyone” was after “Promise”.
- “Push & Pull”, “Hello”, and “1, 3, 2” were sub-group songs in which all members had to participate in one of these song as a group of three members.
- Mute gap between “TICK TOCK” to “That’s all I’m saying” to prevent copyright.
Can I get your ideas?
if only they let Momo sing/rap in her natural register like in the misamo unit... She would shine more in their songs
Average/Line Distribution per song
Nayeon: 33.9 | 19.1%
Jihyo: 32.1 | 18.1%
Mina: 18.8 | 10.6%
Jeongyeon: 17.6 | 9.9%
Sana: 16.9 | 9.5%
Chaeyoung: 16.3 | 9.2%
Tzuyu: 15.4 | 8.7%
Dahyun: 13.9 | 7.8%
Momo: 12.7 | 7.2%
Thats not super bad but its kinda bad
How did you calculate it?
@@momoran_ you do the total amount of lines they have at the end divided by the amount of songs they participated in, the final chart and/or placement totals would help you with that.
@@philip0w0hoang Ooh!! Thank you for telling me^^ This helps alot
@@dvalee i don't think it's bad. just give jeongyeon some lines from nayeon/jihyo and it's perfect.
No one can do it as well as you, you are officially a brand, K-STAT.Ihave fun watching your videos
Totally agree 😁
💯% agree
The fact that
Nayeon beats Jihyo
Mina beats Jungyeon
Sana beats Chaeyong
Are mind blowing
Nayeon beats Jihyo and Jeongyeon
Mina beats Jeongyeon
Sana beats Chaeyoung, Tzuyu, Dahyun
Sana SHOULD beat Dahyun anyway, cause girlie can’t hold a single note in live singing often.
Nayeon and jihyo really we’re fighting hard for that first place 😂
Ik😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Anyone who’s seen them live knows they deserve the most lines. I wish tzuyu had more, she’s sooooo stable these days
yeah lmao
I'M GLAD THAT YOU'RE BACK!!!!!
1) Lead vocalist (treated as main)
2) Main vocalist
3) Vocalist (treated as lead)
4) Lead vocalist
5) Vocalist
6) Main rapper, vocalist
7) Vocalist
8) Lead rapper, sub vocalist
9) Sub vocalist, sub rapper
I know nayeon is most line because her voice fit twice song more a search on google
I luv nayeon
Same she is my bias
best kpop line distribution channel for sure ❤
Cmon give Momo, dahyun, tzuyu and chae more lines…
You're so right 😭 momo barely sing 😭
Chae is good with her lines, if they would rap lines it would be better, but i think she’s ok
@@ainttrynabeniceWhat ok she is freaking all rounder of the group she is the best in rap and 4th best vocalist of the group. She really deserves more lines.
@@Unknown..777no she not she have good lines stop complain
Chaeyoung no 😂 she have good lines
23:11 Nayeon 👁️👄👁️
It’s crazy that Nayeon has 97 MINUTES of lines (1 1/2 hour)
Jeongyeon deserves more lines
I honestly don't think Jeongyeon should get more lines, I just think Nayeon should get a bit less
@@BstansforBJeongyeon needs more lines, thats a fact
Not really. She barely participated in group promotions. She got exactly what she deserved
@@BstansforBno nayeons lines are necessary. She’s center on top of lead vocalist, face of the group and Lead dancer. All be positions contribute to her line distribution and as you can see the less she gets the worse their songs do with the general public. Hare hare is flopping and neon got the allot of lines in it💀
@@ElPato8 She needs to get important parts, and she gets a lot of them, she got choruses in Hare Hare and in all of the songs in Ready to Be, for example
Twice song is always best song in kpop ever ❤️
Nayeon vs Jihyo
Mina vs Jeongyeon
Sana vs Chaeyoung vs Tzuyu vs Dahyun
Momo :)
after eyes wide open it’s
nayeon
jihyo
mina
jeongyeon
sana v chaeyoung
tzuyu
dahyun
momo
I see Tzuyu, I click. She is so beautiful 😍. Look at her eyes 😍,her nose and her mouth
Twice was never meant to have fair line distributions, a lot of people seem to not understand that. NMIXX for example was meant to. & if it makes you all feel better, all members actually have a say in who gets what lines. They said it once that they decide in a group chat. Also while all members sound amazing and have improved over the years, Jihyo, Nayeon, and Jeongyeon STILL carry live vocals. One main vocalist and two leads is a lot to compete for, esp in a group of 9 but I assume Jeongyeon just isn’t as hungry for those lines and is happy where she is.
Nayeon and Jihyo be playing criss-cross 😂😂
I noticed that before the FOL era, Mina and Jeongyeon were closer in lines, now Jeongyeon and Sana are closer in lines, shows that Jeongyeon lines are kinda decreasing
Omggg Finally thankyouuu 😭♥️
Tzuyu's lines have been very consistent in 2023 (besides Catch a Wave), a lot around the middle (#4-#6). Meanwhile they were all over the place in 2022 lol, from her first #1 in a song to some last places.
Twice best group of the world👑
Hope jyp can treat Jeongyeon better in the next 6 years and she can be top 3 again
just let it go bruh …it’s over
No! She will
Its not gonna happen. They already have 2 powerful vocals (Nayeon and Jihyo) and also 2 Calm vocals (Mina and Sana) they don't need Jeongyeon anymore. She is just there to get mistreated
Jeongyeon doesn't fit most of twice songs
But her voice is super super beautiful
Chaeyoung, Tzuyu, Dahyun and Momo need more lines
Chaeyoung have a lot in hare hare and crazy stupid love so stop complain about her the rest is understandable
@@EvenUA-cam she not gets less 😭 she is 5 in the most album only she is low in taste of love and perfect world but in the rest she is 5/4 so stop complain only jeongyeon get less lines and is the Lead Vocalist
I agree except for chae she doesnt deserve to have lines
Tzuyu not bc she’s just a filler member
Tzuyu, Dahyun and Momo deserve more lines chaeyoung gets a lot of lines and is mostly 3rd in most of their distributions. Tzuyu is also getting a lot right now, lets hope it stays that way. As of now, Dahyun and Momo have very little lines
it's so good to see you consistently posting again 🤩
Lo importante es que todas las chicas se lucen en cada una de sus lineas
Love k stat❤
1:21 Nayeon:😱😱💀💀😡😡😡 (im gonna be a star)
1:27 Nayeon:😊😊😍😍😍😘😘 (TT her era)
Momo deserves more lines her voice is great ❤️❤️
yes, but I think that she is the main dancer, so the percentage that JYPE give her more lines is really low
Jihyo's 1st and 2nd place is totally the fairest her being main vocalist
I think Dahyun, Momo and Tzuyu needs more lines too.
You should do a version of this without adlibs, i think it'd be interesting to see
I hope JYP gives JiHyo and JeongYeon more lines or promotes Mina to a lead vocalist and NaYeon to a main vocalist so the line distribution can evolve into something like this:
1. JiHyo
2. NaYeon or JeongYeon
3. NaYeon or JeongYeon
4. Sana or Mina
5. Sana or Mina
6. ChaeYoung or Tzuyu
7. ChaeYoung or Tzuyu
8. DaHyun
9. Momo
but why promoting two members to a position they can't reach? it's debatable about nayeon being a main vocalist, but mina has not the same skills as jeongyeon vocally speaking
@@kpopbroughtmehere Ik I’m basing it off of the line distribution besides if JYP is giving most adlibs and notes to NaYeon nowadays and Mina more lines then JeongYeon it would kinda be common sense to promote them if they were to be treated like this.
nayeon never become a main vocalist. Jihyo can do it better
@@RRRonan even jennie in blackpink is not the main vocalist but has the most lines. even yeji in itzy is not the main vocalist but has the most lines. it's fvcked up i know (my bias in twice is jihyo and i would LOVE for her to be first), i don't know why the agencies keep doing this, but at least let's the main vocalist be the main vocalist, being untouched by the leads. the main is the main for a reason
@@RRRonan same for the lead vocalists btw
Nayeon and jihyo: ↗️↘️↗️↘️↗️↘️↗️
Momo: ↘️➡️➡️➡️➡️
Taking the fact that Nahyo lines are mostly adlibs. The distribution isn't THAT unfair
RIGHT they are just screaming in the background half the lines wich is kind of their job in the group lmfao, maybe they could let jeongyeon highnote a bit too
@@nuggetsplace8273But i think mina have more because of the fact that she is more complete than jeongyeonnie. She only pass her in vocals, in dance and rap, mina win
looking at this, all the members even momo were switching between the top 3 and bottom 3 and it wasnt just jihyo and nayeon at the top all the time
@@avrilynicolas3247 this is a line distribution. lines require vocals. if you want to use dance habilities then go to a center distribution. That requires dance.
@@avrilynicolas3247jeongyeon's better in open style + why would dance matter this is line distribution and like half of their songs don't have a choreo lmao
If we switch Chae with Sana and Jeong with Mina this would be ideal
And swap nayeon with jihyo
Chaeyoung and Sana it's ok
and swap Nayeon and Jihyo it would be totally fair
Lol sana fits the concept more than chaeyoung so she deserves more lines than chaeyoung
@@Nayeonmy178 what concept exactly? lol
不管是怎樣！
希望twice在2024年團體歌詞分配能公平一點！
也希望女孩們聲樂部分能提升！謝謝~~
加油加油~~
希望twice唱歌技巧提升！
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Im happy your back ! Can you make secret number who diss to doxa ?
Q I like and adore twice but even though jeongyeon doesn't have few lines, the simple fact of being the main vocalist and having less lines than mina leaves a lot to say about her position as Of vocalists since mina is not and jeongyeon is and when you see the great difference between jihyo nayeon and jeongyeon you see the little Interest in her having such a good vocal and so powerful but anyway, despite my discomfort with the matter of the main vocalists, I love twice and they have tremendous songs 😻😻💕💕💕💕
I think the order should be…
1. Jihyo (Main Vocal)
2. Nayeon (Lead vocal, fotg, center)
3. Jeongyeon (Lead vocal)
4. Chaeyoung (Main rapper, 4th best vocalist)
5. Mina (Sub vocal, 5th best vocalist)
6. Dahyun (lead rapper, sub vocal, 2nd weakest vocalist)
7. Tzuyu (sub vocal, 4th weakest vocalist)
8. Sana (sub vocal, 3rd weakest vocalist)
9. Momo (sub vocal, sub rapper, weakest vocalist)
You're terrible, who doesn't even know how to sing 😡
chaeyoung is just bouncing from 1 to 9
Why tf are some people in the comments putting Tzuyu in the bottom 2 or 3 of their "what it should be rankings" and labeling her mainly as "the visual" first and foremost when she's not even in the weaker third of the members at singing? The real line distribution is already doing her a bit of a disservice as it is.
Love ❤
The top 5 should be:
Nayeon - Jihyo (1st or 2nd)
Jeongyeon
Chaeyoung - Mina
Based on Vocal Tier
Maybe 6th Tzuyu
Dahyun 7th
Sana 8th
Momo 9th
I know that JYPE is giving more lines to Nayeon because she has de the representative Voice of the group, center, Lead Vocalist and FOTG, so it’s okay (that’s why i put to Nayeon in 1st), the difference between Nayeon and Jihyo it’s not that huge compared to Jeongyeon, the Problem is that they still giving more lines to Mina and Sana and even Tzuyu than Jeongyeon, besides in Ready To Be the 1st place was really close between Nayeon and Jihyo
SORRY IF I WROTE SOMETHING WRONG, I’M NOT GOOD AT ENGLISH 😂
Well if you put Nayeon first in line i hope more center Jihyo will come
I think that Sana is a better vocalist than Dahyun
1000
Jihyo - Someone Like Me (2017)
Nayeon - Likey (2017)
Jeongyeon - Pink Lemonade (2018)
Mina - Dance The Night Away (2018)
2000
Nayeon - CHILLAX (2018)
Jihyo - L.O.V.E (2018)
1000
Sana - Wishing (2018)
Tzuyu - STAY BY MY SIDE (2018)
Chaeyoung - The Best Thing I Ever Did (2018)
Dahyun - TURN IT UP (2019)
Momo - Trick It (2019)
3000
Nayeon - Fake & True (2019)
Jihyo - POLISH (2019)
2000
Jeongyeon - Go Hard (2020)
Mina - Shot Clock (2020)
4000
Nayeon - Kura Kura (2021)
2000
Sana - Scandal (2021)
4000
Jihyo - Baby Blue Love (2021)
2000
Chaeyoung - SOS (2021)
Tzuyu - Thank you, Family (2021)
Dahyun - Push & Pull (2021)
5000
Nayeon - Wonderful Day (2021)
Jihyo - Flow like waves (2022)
2000
Momo - Sandcastle (2022)
3000
Mina - Queen of Hearts (2022)
Jeongyeon - Hare Hare (2023)
tnx❤️
Mina ate
Nayeon definitely no 1
If Jeongyeon still let the line down a bit then Sana would rise to 4th place
How should be in my opinion
1. Jihyo (she's the main vocal)
2. Nayeon/Jeongyeon (lead vocals)
4. Chaeyoung (main rapper)
5. Dahyun (lead rapper)
6. Mina (the 2nd best sub vocal)
7. Momo (sub-rapper)
8. Sana/Tzuyu (sub vocal)
That's right except I'll change minas and dahyuns place because mina has an angelic voice but try should do this and distribution must be fair every member will get atleast 15+ seconds singing so it could be fair
Can You please do ATEEZ and SKZ album distribution please???
They both just made a cb with a mini and a full album respectively
Pleasee haha
Im a Big Fan of your work! I think You and Random-K are the best right now, I really respect all your work and love You guys do this
🎉🎉❤😊
Yes please 😭
TWICE BEST GG
Nayeon jihyo be working hard for the first place, while other members like Beverly are catching up to them
23:10 in which song is Jihyo last?
Do what we like
Next is Nmixx please 🥺🥺🥺
momo 😢 😢 😍 😍
Jyp:O que você quer de aniversário?
Momo: Um unicornio!
Jyp:Momo não é posivel isso, pessa outra coisa
Momo:mais linhas!
Jyp:OK que unicornio você quer?
Really entertaining to watch Sana, Dahyun and Tzuyu constantly overtake each other.
Shame that the first spots are so established though. It would be so much cooler if each (or maybe at least the majority of them) had at least a brief time as the first one.. kind of like a time of attention for them.
What a sickening line distribution
How can fans call this a fair line distribution
A lead vocalist having more lines the main Vocalist (Nayeon
#justice4Dahyun
Last waltz was tzuyu the first in line distribuition
chaeyoung❤❤❤❤❤
all members have a song that they are top 1
Nayeon - I'm gonna be a star
Sana - Merry & Happy
Jihyo - TT
Mina - Dance The Night Away
Momo - Signal
Tzuyu - Sandcastle
Jeongyeon - Up No More
Chaeyoung - How U Doin'
Dahyun - Shadow
sana is not first in merry and happy, mina is not first in dance the night away
Sana, Thank u Fam
Mina, Queen
Dahyun, do what we like
Poor tzuyu, she is a good vocalist and better than sana, she deserves more! But i’m happy for mina❤❤❤
Tzuyu wasn't a good vocalist for a looong time, she started improving a lot since last year and almost reached Chae/Mina's level rn (she's E-, the other 2 are both E, Mina barely, Chae a bit higher)
but if she keeps improving at this pace she can definitely surpass them both in like a year or two
@@arbuz510 yes
But JYPE secretly hates Tzuyu that's why they give Tzuyu few lines and screentime
Why are you making her compete with Sana? This isn't the first time I've seen you say something negative about Sana. Just say she deserves better and move on,don't target Sana. I hate seeing fans compare members. Also,she is not E-. She's close to supporting but still hasn't supported a single time. Shes a high f+ for now.
@@arbuz510Tzuyu is still high f+. She hasn't supported yet but has been very close.
I’m surprised that Mina has way more lines than Jeongyeon ( even tho Mina is a sub and Jeongyeon a main )
Jeongyeon is a lead
a jihyo com a nayeon desde 2015 praticando o distanciamento social
Minas been in the top 5 116 times!
How come Jeongyeon a Lead Vocalist so far behind with her co-Lead/Main Vocalists. :(
She really need more lines. 🥺🥺
So sad to see a Main Dancer have more lines than the Lead Vocalist.
Momo is ranked 9th. Why did she sing more than Jeongyeon?
Leave Mina alone. At least Jeongyeon is in the Top 4. Seriously, this is ridiculous.
@@renjunlv.8606Mina is also the main dancer
@@ibramzz isn't mina a lead dancer?
@@renjunlv.8606no, minas official positions are Main Dancer, Sub Vocalist
Jeongyeon,Jihyo,Dahyun,Chaeyoung really deserve more lines..
Sana deserves more lines
In recent songs, the favoritism to Nayeon has been very noticeable, and something strong.
im gonna be
im im gonna be
im gonna be a...
Cuál es la canción en la que Jihyo quedó de 9th?
Do What We Like del álbum Eyes wide open
Can we talk about the fact that Momo always had the least😭 like “give jeongyeon more lines” GIVE MOMO MORE LIKE I KNOW SHE IS LIKE MORE OF A DANCER BUT LIKE SHE STILL NEED LINES😭
She gets since she’s the weakest vocalist, and I don’t think she actually cares to get a lot of lines
Its a different situation, we all know momo is the weakest vocalist of the group and she gets center position in the dance breaks, meanwhile jeongyeon is a lead vocalist
@@Syzygy722but Momo is always last also dahyun and chaeyoung are a weak vocalist and have good lines
@@Nayeonmy178 Clearly no, chaeyoung has a much better vocal than momo, she is not among twice's weak vocalists, with respect to dahyun, she has a better vocal than momo, and besides that, there are many lines where chae doesn't raps but she does, so nothing to do with chae.
@@Syzygy722 the only one strong vocalist are nayeon, jihyo and jeongyeon the rest have poor vocals but stand out in other aspects
Also chaeyoung always has more lines than jeongyeon
Jeon>>>>>>>Chaeyoung
And Momo get hardly 9-10 seconds this very bad for a member
Also dahyun is not very better than Momo
She is a F while Momo F- so is not much different because dahyun passing the F#4 strained
my fans twice is my
Yo Momo is doing good rap and amazing cool dance she is body is nice and vocal is very cute and little beatiful just not great
Dahyun deserves more real rap parts!!!!
1. Vocalist (3)
2. Vocalist (1)
3. Vocalist (5)
4. Vocalist (2)
5. Vocalist (8)
6. Vocalist (4)
7. Vocalist (6)
8. Vocalist (7)
9. Vocalist (9)
Lol the gap between Jihyo who is Main Vocalist and Nayeon Lead Vocalist is very huge. I hope Jihyo can back on top and JYPE remember she is MAIN VOCALIST. Also wtf Jeongyeon was totally robbed all the time she is the second vocalist of the group and she get only few lines? She should get more and back atleast top 3
Chae should be 5 atleast she is Rapper and Vocalist i want her to be in 4th but it very impossible so 5th well good to her. 6th Should between Sana or Tzuyu (Tzuyu because she is F+ tier Sana is F only) Both also are fit for twice songs. Unfair for Dahyun and Momo but yes they are not a strong vocalist but they deserve lines. I hope JYPE will stop favoring some members 😢
I'm happy k-stat is back again ❤
@@opinionisopinion ikr, it's the fact that there's over a 300 second difference between nayeon and Jihyo 💀
Twice vocal ranking changed though :
1.Jihyo
2. Nayeon >= jeongyeon (nayeon improved).
4.mina
5.tzuyu
6.chaeyoung (she regressed to the point she can’t support anymore in their latest concert).
7.dahyun
8.sana
9.momo
@@opinionisopinion nayeon is also first in like 15 songs more than Jihyo, it's Hella sad
@@Verowinday777
Jeongyeon >= Nayeon still Jeongyeon slightly better period
7:21 Я думаю, что с песни "Fancy" началась новая эра TWICE. Я ощущаю разные атмосферы между 2015-2018 и 2019-наши дни, ведь они уже повзрослели.
YALL MOMO ONLY HAS BEEN IN THE TOP 3 8 TIMES? Istg she’s been in it way more
Momo merece más líneas.
Where did you find the line distribution for pink lemonade? I cannot find any that indicate that chaeyoung is second
Actually chae only sing 2 seconds
She definitely not second
She is last
23:11 does somebody know what song jihyo is last?
Do what we like
@@hollyglimmer3486she is 8th there
@@ryansantos7096 In random_k yes, but in most others no. She has very small difference with Jeongyeon.
Jihyo was on her way to catch Nayeon in 2018 then after moon came and after it was over lmao
All Korean title songs line distribution Please😊
U know one thing i realized is that it not compare to see ALL the member bing first in a kpop group
Jeongyeon bu kadar az alirken Nayeon niye fazla aliyor ikisi de lider vokal degil mi?
I feel that TWICE literally survives on Nayeon and Jihyo
Please do Blackpink all songs line distribution till born pink album please
The distance is so embarrassing 💀 no hate to Nayeon and Jihyo but they don’t need to carry every song behind their backs 😭 we have Jeongyeon, utterly the most underutilized and most stable vocalist in the group and yet y’all give her one chorus?? She should be much much higher, a few hundreds secs behind Jihyo at least. I understand her voice doesn’t suit Twice concepts, but she could do the adlibs instead of Nayeon’s screeching (sorry), and the last chorus with half a pre chorus (like TTT). That’s how simple it is. The rest of them I’m not complaining with tho.
Niziu pls
Jeongyeon kept her 3rd position for 5 years
i think its safe to say any time nayeon doesnt have 1st place its jihyo and vise versa
Can you do , Seventeen too? 😢🙏🙏🙏🙏
Please do this to Seventeen for all of their songs to Super🙏🏼🙏🏼
Can I request Snsd most viewed mv all of the time? Please Please Please ❤
This comment section is filled with solo stans 💀
atp make Mina a lead vocalist and jeongyeon a sub
Why ??
@@gauravnandan8208 cuz they treat jeongyeon like a sub vocalist and every like 10 songs she gets lines and while Mina gets a lot of lines. (no hate to Mina I love both of them)
@iguaranteeigotcha16 I’m not saying that Mina is a better vocalist than jeongyeon?? I’m saying that as a lead vocal she should get more lines, yet she’s treated as a sub vocalist due to the lines that she gets. I’m also not saying that Mina is a bad vocalist. she is a sub vocalist, just that in this case the positions are not respected. we can see it when jeongyeon gets 8th on a title track (set me free). and sure, she doesn’t always have to be 3rd or 2nd in every song but it just feels like her vocals are being wasted.
@iguaranteeigotcha16 yea I also see what you are talking abt and agree with you that even in songs that she doesn’t get much lines she gets the hardest parts
Jeong is lead vocalist because she is better than Mina, Mina lines seems more because she sings more the slower parts which are like 4 words in a lot of seconds like in alcohol free she went from last to 5th with only "I'm in drunk with youuuuuuuuuuyu"