Kindle Paperwhite or Kobo Clara 2E?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 30 лип 2024
- In this video, we compare the Kobo Clara 2E against the Kindle Paperwhite to see which one is best!
My book, Supercharge Your Reading: geni.us/YDMO8T
Kindle Paperwhite: geni.us/5mD72Dh
Kobo Clara 2E: geni.us/aA1ag
00:00 What would I choose?
00:55 Value Per Dollar
02:24 Library Integrations
03:24 Build Quality
06:13 Screen
07:57 Book Availability
08:58 Note-taking Features
Disclosure: Some links in the description may be affiliate links, which earn me a commission for qualifying purchases. I'm also a participant in the Amazon Associates program. To learn more, you can read my affiliate transparency disclaimer here: go.maneetpaul.com/affiliate-d...
------------------
Hi there! My name is Maneetpaul Singh, but my friends call me Maneet (pronounced muh-neet).
I'm based out of NYC and make UA-cam videos about Book Tech and digital reading.
Think of me like the MKBHD of books 😅
I'm also a Sikh with a love for blue turbans. If you want to learn more about Sikhi and why I look the way I do, check out this short documentary I made: • THEY CALLED ME OSAMA (...
Whenever you’re ready, here are a few other ways I can help you:
1. Read a new book with me every month
At the start of every month, I’ll announce a new nonfiction book I’m going to read. Every week after that, I’ll email you one lesson I’ve learned from the book and a discussion question to help us reflect on it. Join me and 1,000+ other bookworms in the Presently Reading community: go.maneetpaul.com/presently-r...
2. Check out the books I’ve written
Outside of UA-cam, I’m also an author. I write short books on topics that relate to digital reading, but also self development. You can find my books here: go.maneetpaul.com/books
If you want to get in touch, you can also email me hello@maneetpaul.com
TL;DR:
💌 Read with me every month: go.maneetpaul.com/presently-r...
📚 Check out the books I've written: go.maneetpaul.com/books
📖 Follow me on Goodreads: / maneetpaul-singh
👳🏽♂️ Learn more about my turban and Sikhi: • THEY CALLED ME OSAMA (...
🥰 Support my work on Patreon / maneetpaul
For Canadians, there is only one choice, Kobo. Amazon has chosen to cripple Canadian Kindles in two ways. First, Bluetooth has been disabled on Canadian Kindles. Therefore, Audible or other Audio books are not available for Canadian Kindles. If that were not upsetting enough, Libby is also not supported on Canadian Kindles. I have both a Kobo and Kindle and find myself using the Kobo Clara far more.
Isn't it more convenient to use your phone eg. for audio books? I don't really see the advantage of having an e-reader for that
@@nulla9601 I, for instance, don’t own a phone…
@@mramosch You are extremely rare.
@Nulla why not use both?
@@factoryofdivisiveopinions because I always have my phone with me and not always my kindle
Just want to put this out there that if you call Amazon and ask they may remove the ads for you at not cost. I called and asked per a comment I saw on another video and they did for me. But you do have to ask out right and say you were told it could be done for free. The first thing they will say is that it costs $20. But in my case they did remove the ads at no cost.
They removed mine for free when I told them that the cover art being advertised when the kindle was sleeping made me uncomfortable. (It was always smutty romance novels which always had people in various degrees of passionate embraces.)
Hey, have you remove ads on your kindle? I’ve heard lot of my friends told that just telling amz you from Vietnam and they will remove ads for free. Lol
I favour the Kobo. I have a Kindle but I want easy access to library books and I don't buy e-books. I mostly use my Kindle for classic works long out of copyright. So much for the Kindle's advantage. I'm not crazy about the personal data that Amazon collects. I also want to DL fave newspapers, web pages, and magazines for an easy, portable read.
You can read the paper on kobo? Using your normal newspaper account or do you have to pay more? Can you get WSJ or NYT?
I have both and I am a recent convert to to Kobo. I prefer the size and user friendliness of the Kobo Clara 2E. Also you should never have to pay to remove the adverts on a Kindle. Thanks for sharing your videos!
Maneetpaul, thank you for another fantastic review, I've been genuinely enjoying them as I've been shopping for my first-ever e-reader. I've chosen the Kindle PW through your reviews and love it!
Great review. Your insights into the note taking capabilities was helpful in my decision making
I got the PW signature last week. My previous Kindle was the original version of the Oasis. I debated waiting for a possible new Oasis. Very happy I went with the PW. Really dig it. Thank you so much for all your reviews. It was a big deciding factor in my choice. Have a great one.
Thank you for a really helpful review! I love how you spoke highly of both of them even though you have a favorite between them.
Maybe an unpopular opinion but I actually much prefer browsing the library and checking out books on my phone or iPad then "sending" it to my Kindle. This is because navigating on eink is significantly slower on Kindle (and from what I can tell from reviews, most e-readers) and would be annoying to browse. I usually even do that when finding Kindle books to read too.
This is the best review between the two. Thanks for including things for consideration for people living outside the USA. Also thanks for keeping filler words to a minimum.
Thanks a bunch, I especially like how you compared the note taking experience on both devices.
Another wonderful video. Thanks for the comparison, it can be difficult to change if you have already invested in one ecosystem over another. Plus having books over multiple platforms can be a little bit of a hassle in my opinion.
The ghosting issue, I wonder if Kindles page turn animation helps alleviate that. It's sort of like having refresh set to every page turn, but without the annoying flashing. Just a guess. If that's what they did, it is very smart.
You do an amazing job. Thank you.
Awesome review! Now my decision is much harder knowing about the highlighting and note taking issue when i was already leaning towards the Clara2E, but now.... 😂😭
Hey lad. I'm a Kobo Clara 2e man. My daily ereader is my new (sealed in box) Sony PRS-350 and I use my Kobo Mini (mint with a new battery installed) out and about with finally using my Clara 2e at night. The one ereader that I don't miss is my old Sony PRS-505 as it was an absolute horror to read on. Thanks for the honest comparison albeit subjective. Peace.
~ 8:00 - I think that book availability is _the_ most important criterion for selecting among many otherwise pretty similar devices. I definitively deep into amazon "ecosystem", but one should also weight Kobo's better integration with public libraries.
Also note that Amazon is discontinuing book lending (to other Kindle account) capability - not that it was particularly useful, because it was once only, for 14 days, and most publishers opted out if it, anyway. (BTW, reselling e-books is not a technical problem - Amazon holds patents on that - but big publishers don't want to even consider it.)
Would love a video comparing the user interface for sideloaded books. I have an original kindle paperwhite that I'm looking to replace and 90% of my books are sideloaded. From what I can gather, the books will look a mess on new kindle with the collections being a nightmare or basically useless.
Hi , I recently bought a Kobo Mini . I reset it to factory default but now I cannot set it up because of network error. Can you help solve the problem? Thanks
Nice presentation, and it is so nice to see an American discuss the whole Amazon library xenophobia. As from many of the comments, there are many who are frustrated by the restrictions imposed by Amazon, whether Bluetooth barring, library blocking, or advertising on screen. I have not read all the comments, but there is also your licence to read on a Kindle. Amazon reserves the right to block or even brick your device if you knowingly or unknowingly 'break' its rules. Your Amazon books are not your own. They are on permanent loans, and Amazon will monitor what you do on your device with their book and those you put on their device. I like that there are more devices coming into the marketplace with Google Play. This will really shake things up
A 6.8" kobo would be perfect
Thanks for your reviews. How can I export the notes and highlights on Kobo?
what about epub that i have on my computer ? Amazon wont allow me to send it to the device right ?
I have kobo libra h20 anyway looking to do Clara 2se I just want to know is there glare to read outside I sometime am taking the train and goes outside and I get glare and I am a fan of Libbys from my library thank you for sharing your video look forward your next !!
I would love to own a Kobo Clare 2R but it's not available where I live. If I try shipping, it'll cost my almost twice the price. I wish Kobo had a branch in Nepal. Even the kindles are pricy here. The new scribe is priced at rupees 1,00,000, which is like 775 dollars. At that point I might as well buy hundreds of actual 2nd hand books. 😅
My Kobo Clara 2E arrived on Oct 31st and I was so happy. 6" size is actually good on my palm. 7" would be the best...I think. But I'll get used to the size in no time. The ghost image is quite obvious to be honest altho I can set the refresh setting. The rest is super smooth
How much it weigh?
@@clip012 it says 171g but I feel it's much lighter. Try hold or carry 3-4 AA batteries on your hand. That's how close the weight is I think
Are you still happy, and using, your Kobo?
@@JAHinHK yes. Super satisfied with it. Still super smooth
@@bomanson Thank you. I'm going to pick one of these up. Cheers.
Do we need to pay for subscription for both? Or just pay per download?
I have a Kindle right now, but after discovering Libby (as a non-US resident) I am seriously considering a Kobo for lending books.
I just wish the Clara came in black-the blue they’ve used makes me think of one of those book-style phone cases grandmas use…
How much of the memory is available to sideloaded books?
Thanks for this comparison. Is the 2E noticeably slower than the Kindle? If so, I wonder if this is a software or hardware difference...
it is slower, yes. The kindle is about twice as fast at times.
I didn't know that ads appear on the screensaver on the Kindles, but now it makes sense why Amazon won't put a customisable sleep timer on the device..
Could you please do a comparison of screen 'whiteness' when the built in lights are turned off? Reading with a lamp, or by a window? For example.
they are both very close without the light. The screen on the kobo looks nicer and sharper with the light on.
Thanks for your reviews, I think I'll go for a Kindle, seems like those are just a tad better of an option that all the competitors for its price. Onyx Booxs where on my radar but are too fragile and too expensive even if it runs on Android, their latest model is one I would have bought if it had more storage space (only a measly 7 gig free even tho they sell it as a 16 !) and all the other readers don't play well with the Kindle bookstore. I'm thinking of delving into indy writers and I don't believe any of the competition is just going to provide what I'm looking for. Amazon just seems like a great place for discovering great up and coming writing talent.
Kobo Clara 2 E and yes I own the Kindle. In Canada you can download Library books and I get to see the Canadian price when I buy a book.
Definitely happy with the Clara. Kindle goes back into the closet until I give away for free to a friend. Yes Clara no advertising. Thank God!!
What is not mentioned is the "Pocket" web service integration with the Kobo. It is nicer to read cleaned web pages on the reader instead of a computer screen.
one video on reading kindle on IPad or any Android tablet please.
New Paperwhite. I love the device and Kindle Unlimited. I've recently found your channel and binged a bunch of content so I'm not sure which video mentioned 8 or 16g's. I have the 8g model and like every other device you don't actually get a full 8g. I have about 30 books on this device and it reads "5.67g".
No audiobooks.
The software of the Kindle takes up a bit of the storage. But if you aren't reading audiobooks are graphic heavy novels, you'll be just fine :)
Do you gonna buy the Kindle Scribe? I will do :D
None of this stuff matters after the power button was put in that place Kobo it is for me thanks for your videos
Awesome video! Is it possible to export highlight via email on personal documents?
That feature only works on books purchased from Amazon. I just checked with a personal document on my Kindle and didn't see that option anywhere :/
this was such a neat comparison to see. would also love to see like the kindle oasis compared to the kobo sage (or whatever the equivalent would be)
I can't agree more on the note function, which is a key function to me: I used for a month a Clara and had to return it and get a Paparwhite. I use those device for study and underlining on the Clara is at best painful, slow, unpredictable. On the Paperwhite you underline fastly and effectively and also taking notes is far better on the Paperwhite. Adding documents without the need of a PC is a plys too. I loved tge ergonomics of Clara but it is simply impossible to take notes on it
I have both. My biggest annoyance with the Kindle is that it has a plastic flush screen. Text on the Kobo is much sharper. I like the Kindle because the software is faster. I dislike the Kobo because it’s only 6”. I would love a kindle paperwhite 5 with an indented screen.
If warm light isn’t important to you then try the new basic kindle that was just launched. It’s faster than the Kobo Clara 2e plus it has the indented screen. Only thing missing is the warm light but it does have dark mode. I’ve had it now for three weeks and I love it.
kobo libra 2!
If there ever was Paperwhite with indented screen, I'd buy it instantly. Nowadays Amazon just doesn't have anything for me in their lineup. I have both Paperwhite 4 and Oasis 3 and ever since I bough Kobo Libra 2, I didn't read on those at all, because of how aweful their screens are.
@@fxaman thanks for the info. I myself am reluctant to buy paperwhite because I hear from few that reading on fused screen feels like reading on a tablet while on indented it feels like reading from a book. Is warm light feature worth it (if i buy cant get my hands on clara and instead get kindle basic)? I dont plan to do any reading in dark room, have very well lit room but I want to get that yellowish book paper feel.
@@Iampilgr1m is it useable with brightness to 0 in a well lit room? I absolutely hate the "blue light"
PDFs take much storage. My Kindle paperwhite 11th is almost full because I've put there all my PDF llibrary.
Hasn't been a full year and the Kobo Clara 2E already up $10 from original price, damn.
What are these lock screen ads I keep hearing about? I've owned many Kindles and never once have I seen ads on my devices. Is this a US-only thing?
Yes I think so too, it must be a US only thing. Or at least prohibited in the EU by law as I never saw it.
@@k2u364 There are devices that are a bit cheaper with ads and more expensive ones without ads. The difference is isnignificant though. I'd recommend to go for the non ad version then. Also it is there in the EU as well.
@@k2u364 No, mine had ads and I bought it in Germany.
Yes, the ads are only in the U.S., I believe. I know that there are no ads available in Canada.
Why does this human have the kindest eyes 😭 🥺
Amazon is slowly getting rid of the possibility to have any side loaded docs in your kindle (even ebooks you bought through other retailers) so for me that’s a deal breaker
Can you sideload mp3 audiobooks on Clara?
My experience is "No".
Hum yes you can but my comment was deleted ??? Search the web for it.
~ 8:40 - A bit of a tangent - many self-publishing authors go through services such as Smashwords, which are not only bookstores themselves, but also offer distributing members' works through a number of stores, including Amazon, Apple, Barnes & Noble and Kobo.
nice review, next time please mention battery life
Is kobo affected at all by the Overdrive to Libby switch?
So far I've been ok borrowing books using Libby on my computer or iPad then clicking "sync" on the Clara. I also download library books directly on the Clara using its built-in Overdrive but wonder what will happen once the Overdrive app is no longer supported.
You don’t need a computer to transfer library books onto kindle. You just borrow from Libby then choose to open with your kindle device. I’ve done it, it’s quite easy. However, I’m considering buying a Kobo just to have it lol. But I do love Kindle Unlimited content.
I think you can do the same thing with the Kobo (Canada).
What country are you in?
kobo wins for me. i’m able to add book files without having to do extra steps and download other programs to add it like with kindle. also dark theme.
Paperwhite is 100$ or less with a cover these days. Are they about to issue a new model and selling the old one out?
En mi país el kobo es más caro que el Kindle, así que prefiero el Kindle, total no hay tantas diferencias, y para descargar libros gratis esta lectulandia y lo transformas con calibre. No entiendo en que los gringos se complican tanto la vida la verdad... Igual opinión mía.
For Canadians there is no question...Kobo is head and shoulders over Kindle...love borrowing from a library 😂😂😂
Oh no, one more choice!!! 🤣
~ 5:30 - Another detail that was better on Voyage than on Paperwhite.
Talking about the plastic, I don't care how much plastic are recyclable in this device, because they both will last very long time. My last kindle works 6 years and still good. If we want to reduce the consumption of plastic, just refuse to use single use plastic products.
This video looks biased towards Kobo
I wish all people of Indian descend could speak clearly like you. This would help me understand half of the Canadian population better 😅
I have a lot of respect for people who learned English as a second language. That is not an easy thing to do. Let alone move across the world to a new country.
That’s such a derogatory comment, borderline racist
Just bought Clara 2E and it's great after coming from Kobo aura.