Investigators Still Hunting for the Idaho Killer

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 16 жов 2024
  • Welcome #STSNation ...
    Are Moscow, Idaho investigators closing in on the killer responsible for four horrific homicides?
    Two more amazing guests weigh in ...
    Jim Van Allen is a Certified Profiler and experienced Threat and Risk Assessment Specialist.
    He has over 31 years of experience in law enforcement and investigations, with the Ontario Provincial Police, 15 of which were spent as the Manager of the OPP Criminal Profiling Unit.
    Peter Massey started his career at the Hamden, CT Department of Police Services rising to the rank of Detective.
    He retired in July 2003 after more than twenty years to become the Training Coordinator for the National Crime Scene Training and Technology Center at the Henry C. Lee Institute of Forensic Science.
    He is currently a Professor of Instruction at the University of South Florida at St. Petersburg.
    Let us never forget those young lives lost way too soon: Madison Mogen, 21, Kaylee Goncalves, 21, Xana Kernodle, 20, and Ethan Chapin, 20.
    #IdahoStudentMurders #TrueCrime #Idaho4 #IdahoStudentsTrueCrime #IdahoLatest #IdahoToday #MoscowMurders #TrueCrime
    For Ad-Free & BTS Content ...
    Support the show ❤️
    / survivingthesurvivor

КОМЕНТАРІ • 428

  • @LKK.
    @LKK. Рік тому +73

    This channel is by far one of the best in terms of quality and quantity of content. The questions asked, the responses by the experienced guests, in a daily podcast, long format (1hr +) is engaging, thought provoking and educational from veritable experts in their own respective fields- this is a valuable resource for any in LE, prosecutors/defense attorneys, students, etc. I am captivated the entire time.

    • @shelbell1279
      @shelbell1279 Рік тому +4

      I agreeeeeeeeee

    • @Vjbc_in_KC_opinionated_grandma
      @Vjbc_in_KC_opinionated_grandma Рік тому +4

      I totally agree!

    • @BTJ10
      @BTJ10 Рік тому +3

      1:09:00 Totally agree 💯, Awesome

    • @daybyday0731
      @daybyday0731 Рік тому +3

      It really is...so happy to see what the channel has grown to be! They both deserve it...

    • @gabinobarrera6048
      @gabinobarrera6048 Рік тому +2

      I agree Head and Shoulders above other so-called legal Minds and investigators those other goofballs I've listened to couldn't catch a cold if they were naked in the Arctic Circle

  • @ericaknesek3266
    @ericaknesek3266 Рік тому +50

    This is by far better than ANY shows on TV !

    • @N2Dressage001
      @N2Dressage001 Рік тому +4

      Agree!

    • @sw9750
      @sw9750 Рік тому +6

      Totally agree. The quality of the guests is incredible, many of them world leaders in their respective areas of expertise.

  • @lonie3100
    @lonie3100 Рік тому +66

    I hope the first responders are okay, I’ve been thinking about them a lot.
    Imagine being called to a residence following a call about someone being unconscious and at the scene you walk into a quadruple murder 😔
    They might have ptsd after this or even quit their jobs 😔
    I wish them strength ❤️

    • @spirit13the1st6
      @spirit13the1st6 Рік тому +10

      I also cant imagine coming upon a scene like that.
      It will probably alter your outlook on life and Human Nature.
      To think someone capable of doing this is walking around out here is frightening.

    • @christyrussell913
      @christyrussell913 Рік тому +14

      Exactly, people are forgetting this PD and EMS is small, they take care of the town of Moscow AND the dang college. It’s ridiculous. LCSO handles the county. These men and women are doing all they can do. Can you imagine being a new recruit and THAT was the first thing you saw ?

    • @daybyday0731
      @daybyday0731 Рік тому +7

      Thank you for thinking about them..I think about them too😮‍💨 they haven't had a murder like this and I'm sure this was their first sadly...Praying everyday the killer gets caught...I pray God gives the investigators exactly who did this..

    • @SurvivingTheSurvivor
      @SurvivingTheSurvivor  Рік тому +5

      It’s one of the toughest jobs. Godspeed.

    • @annemarievanleeuwen9959
      @annemarievanleeuwen9959 Рік тому +1

      First responders are héros I was caught in a house fire and nearly died from 3rd burns if it wasn't for first responders the trauma they go thru on a daily basis is horrific I'm heartbroken for the victims in the Moscow murders 💔💔💔

  • @Anne-py4uj
    @Anne-py4uj Рік тому +29

    All these gentlemen are amazing at what they do

  • @chicosmummy
    @chicosmummy Рік тому +42

    The profiling I'm seeing coming through all more or less seem to agree on rage/revenge, slighted/rebuffed/treated badly in their mind, known to victims in some way, young male. I think the cops are circling in now, even if they say they don't have a suspect publicly.

    • @farkas3131
      @farkas3131 Рік тому +6

      Agreed

    • @cosmiccharlie8294
      @cosmiccharlie8294 Рік тому +2

      There was a roomate in the house who took her own life amidst allegations of bullying. Revenge could figure into that.

    • @whereisyourhumanity7557
      @whereisyourhumanity7557 Рік тому +2

      That sounds like most of the young men I've known.

    • @brettcordes3602
      @brettcordes3602 Рік тому +2

      Not in the house. But, point taken and I agree. People are hung up on lack of proof that bullying occurred, but it’s irrelevant. If someone THOUGHT bullying was a factor in her death…there is a revenge motive present.

    • @Liberty6010and9
      @Liberty6010and9 Рік тому +3

      @@cosmiccharlie8294 no there was not. You are speaking of Hannah Cleire and she never lived in that house. Hannah was Maddie's roomate in the college dorms. Not at that house. And Hannah's Dad came out and basically said there was no evidence of foul play in her case and they want to be left alone.

  • @conradmorin1891
    @conradmorin1891 Рік тому +17

    I sincerely want to "Thank You", as your highly qualified and experience guests, for another great video that truly helps us to understand the complexity of this investigation. >>>Although I am a former cop, and former investigator, a lot has changed since my retirement. >>>I truly believe that the killer will be identified and apprehended, and in the meantime, I hope if anyone who knows who committed such a crime, that they have the courage to let the investigators know. >>>The families need answers, closure and justice, as I can't imagine what these families are living, thinking, and feeling. >>>>So sad!

  • @ericaknesek3266
    @ericaknesek3266 Рік тому +15

    My favorite channel ! Thank you !

  • @QBAN2010
    @QBAN2010 Рік тому +32

    For the love of God, Will some of these experts explain to us how the killer was able to exit the house without leaving a blood trail!!!!!!

    • @inquiringmind2852
      @inquiringmind2852 Рік тому +6

      Don't know who said it as I've watched so many channels but one of the experts said they had a case where the perp wore Walmart bags over their shoes to commit the crime and took them off before exiting. Or suggested shoes could gave been taken off before starting the attack and putting them on afterwards.

    • @captaincrunch1707
      @captaincrunch1707 Рік тому +5

      What does a blood trail matter if the killer walked away unseen. Really, the killer was not standing in blood as he likely didn’t spend much time in the house after the attacks.

    • @christyrussell913
      @christyrussell913 Рік тому +11

      Who says he didn’t leave a blood trail? Of course he did, why do you think there was so much LE activity at night? They know how he got in who he killed first and last and how he got out. We just don’t know, as it should be.

    • @pyrodaddy2854
      @pyrodaddy2854 Рік тому +7

      Most of the house won't have blood. When they say blood everywhere that's exaggerated. The average human has 1.5 gallons of blood. He probably just went into the kitchen and had a new outfit ready to go. They say they were attacked in their rooms so only the rooms will have significant amounts of blood.

    • @mikeengler2645
      @mikeengler2645 Рік тому

      @@inquiringmind2852 I saw that interview

  • @1ACL
    @1ACL Рік тому +16

    You have the best guests! Good job!

  • @DJackson700
    @DJackson700 Рік тому +14

    I believe that if the occupants of the White Elantra were not suspects they would have come forth on their own to help.

  • @annetterhoads3117
    @annetterhoads3117 Рік тому +10

    They truly have the best guests ever!

  • @MareRS357
    @MareRS357 Рік тому +19

    This case is so shocking. So many of us are horrified to hear of these murders. Prayers go out to Families and also Police Officers trying to solve these crimes. ❤🙏🏼

  • @GeoTime402
    @GeoTime402 Рік тому +5

    Joel STS always provides in-depth coverage with relevant guests. Excellent program ....

  • @Kat-qc5kw
    @Kat-qc5kw Рік тому +13

    Excellent guests and interview

  • @artistbrindle
    @artistbrindle Рік тому +16

    This is always a fascinating feed. Loved listening to the guests

  • @BasedTexans
    @BasedTexans Рік тому +16

    You must just be doing interviews 24/7. It's incredible how much new quality content you consistently put out every single day 👏

    • @SurvivingTheSurvivor
      @SurvivingTheSurvivor  Рік тому +5

      It’s exhausting

    • @BasedTexans
      @BasedTexans Рік тому +1

      @Surviving The Survivor I can't even imagine, especially when you are sick. I hope you guys have a much needed break and a merry Christmas 🎅!

  • @timothyyoung902
    @timothyyoung902 Рік тому +7

    Really like ur channel thank you for the info and time ...and your guess are all awesome !!!...merry Xmas and happy holidays

  • @kellywark5149
    @kellywark5149 Рік тому +3

    Shoutout to Jim Van Allen. Small world My late Uncle was a long time Chief with the OPP and My Cousin RCMP. You mention the Case in Toronto of Erin Gilmour and Susan Tice and 39 years later We have an Alleged Suspect in Custody thanks to Tireless work by Investigators and Scientific Advances in Genetic Geneology. I have had the privilege of working a 1998 Cold Case with DS Stephen Smith Head of TPS Cold Case Unit. Great Man and I learned much about the advances in Genetic Geneology from DS Smith. The Case I assisted on was TPS 24 Shades of Blue Cold Case edition. You can listen to this on all streaming Apps. Many Thanks for Your Service. 💙

  • @photina78
    @photina78 Рік тому +2

    Good lordt!!! I've never seen so many ads in my life! This is an excellent channel and you always have fantastic guests, but I couldn't get into this show due to construction interruptions from the ads! I am skipping every single ad!

    • @photina78
      @photina78 Рік тому +1

      @@mischaraine1645 The other videos I've watched on this channel, about the Idaho 4, didn't have nearly as many ads.

  • @mauiswift6391
    @mauiswift6391 Рік тому +4

    Stellar Joel! Outstanding guests with not the repeating of facts.

  • @judyjackson2260
    @judyjackson2260 Рік тому +22

    Inan was a felon so he couldn't legally get a gun, he described himself as an introvert and a loner, he thought it was funny that people thought he was the killer, he met three of the victims, had been to outside of their house, he changed his story, he followed one of the girls on Tik Tok, he said in the past he was like an outsider or oddball. He inserted himself in the investigation, he was in the vicinity at the right time. He gave information on a suspect car pointing away from himself. He cried for hours over the crime when He only met them once. He works with knives. He mentioned knives in his interview. He likes animals and the dog was not harmed. He had a cut right at the right time with a convenient excuse. He looks interesting to me.

    • @Brooke52528
      @Brooke52528 Рік тому +6

      When you put all these points together as you have, it doesn't look good does it?!

    • @factsmatter8667
      @factsmatter8667 Рік тому +3

      Who is this guy? I heard him speak only today but heard his name a lot recently.
      The killer wants to get away with this This guy seems sick but I can't believe he would want to get caught.

    • @factsmatter8667
      @factsmatter8667 Рік тому +1

      What kind of felon? A violent felon?

    • @captaincrunch1707
      @captaincrunch1707 Рік тому +2

      Any person near this crime looks good for it. Unless they have an eye witness alibi that was with them in person between 3-4am.

    • @pyrodaddy2854
      @pyrodaddy2854 Рік тому

      Inan got arrested for drug possession and haveing a stolen gun while assaulting a man during a petty weed robbery. Him being a convicted felon doesn't mean he can't get a gun there fore he must use knives. I live in Chicago and lots of felons have guns most gang bangers out here carry 9mm with 30rd extended mags or 100 round drums.

  • @TUA77
    @TUA77 Рік тому +12

    Excellent commentary! A wealth of knowledge exists in all your guests. Many people underestimate LE and the length of time it takes to even get to the Unsub. I worked with Forensic patients in a Case Manager position and nothing surprised me. Some days I had flight ,fight and freeze all day.. One of my favorite books about how to predict behavior and using Intution is THe Gift of Fear by Gavin DeBecker. I fully recommend that book to all, despite it being published over 20 yes ago. Thanks so much, appreciate all you do and the wealth of knowledge you bring to SM.

  • @lulubelleish
    @lulubelleish Рік тому +11

    It must be agony for the parents and siblings

  • @socialbutterfly4146
    @socialbutterfly4146 Рік тому +3

    These guests are great! Very Insightful panel. Thank you all for this👏

  • @shelbell1279
    @shelbell1279 Рік тому +2

    This is one of The BEST channels by far!!!! Wow!!! Thank you for being youuuuu❤❤❤❤❤

  • @lyndaclodfelter2448
    @lyndaclodfelter2448 Рік тому +4

    These guys are so real

  • @coachkpilates2604
    @coachkpilates2604 Рік тому +2

    Great show. You have the BEST GUESTS

  • @lindatexas5906
    @lindatexas5906 Рік тому +12

    Should the coroner be discussing graphic details with the parents? I find it odd that she is allowed to talk about it publicly

    • @ButtercupAngel
      @ButtercupAngel Рік тому +2

      Me too and she also does other jobs they need new people in there working that only does one job and are experienced

    • @Vjbc_in_KC_opinionated_grandma
      @Vjbc_in_KC_opinionated_grandma Рік тому +7

      In my opinion, she was very unprofessional. She should not have given any crime details. The one thing I can say for the cops there is that they are keeping their mouths shut!

    • @Ruth78620
      @Ruth78620 Рік тому

      @@ButtercupAngel another guest in here said she's a criminal defence attorney in Moscow and she gained her position as coroner by being voted in. I think its grossly disrespectful to the victims and their families to speak in such detail and I'm sure it could hinder the investigation because there's some things only LE and the perpetrator need to know so they are 100% sure they've got the right madman.

  • @pharaohgamma3931
    @pharaohgamma3931 Рік тому +6

    Proximity to the house is key. The intruder was local and not an aimless, homeless, transient. The motive was revenge. What was the male, Ethan Chapin doing inside the 1122 King Rd. home? Was Ethan hiding from someone who he had gotten into a fight that evening? Furthermore, what was Ethan and his girlfriend's Xana's timeline from 9 pm to 1:45 am?

    • @lifeofreilly9943
      @lifeofreilly9943 Рік тому +1

      I totally agree…Has the same revenge feeling of the Wonderland Murders, completely personal for whatever reason. I believe Maddie was involved somehow (another night earlier or through text) and Kallie was wrong place, wrong time

    • @ours1209
      @ours1209 Рік тому

      that timeline is disturbing! do you think LE knows?

  • @mamag4160
    @mamag4160 Рік тому +7

    Best coverage I’ve seen on this case. Thank you for seeking out great experts!!

  • @brendaclauer2307
    @brendaclauer2307 Рік тому +15

    Prayers to families, friends and police officers who had to also be hit hard who walk in on the murder victims for healing, may God heal and bless them all in Jesus name Amen

  • @maritfaye212
    @maritfaye212 Рік тому +3

    Great Channel, excellent panel🙏👍🙏 Greetings from Norway 🇳🇴

  • @kristinm2668
    @kristinm2668 Рік тому +7

    This is my new favorite show. So well done and backing it up with great experts!

  • @marklogan1360
    @marklogan1360 Рік тому +1

    Surviving the ADVERTISEMENTS is the biggest challenge on this channel. Five long ads coming in the first ten minutes renders this great content essentially unwatchable.

  • @jordanrip1515
    @jordanrip1515 Рік тому +3

    This channel turned on the super ad function. Made sure to show us all the ads

  • @kathleenjamieson7550
    @kathleenjamieson7550 Рік тому +5

    I think the descriptions from all of your guests have labeled a couple of people very close to the 4. I have a guess that LE already have an narrowed idea of who committed this crime and are just gathering as much evidence for a conviction. My opinion.

  • @maritfaye212
    @maritfaye212 Рік тому +3

    Thank you gentlemen 🙏💙🙏

  • @kelliebilinski
    @kelliebilinski Рік тому

    The host delivers his questions to both guests in a balanced respectable cmanner. Great job

  • @expensivepink7
    @expensivepink7 Рік тому

    Thank you for all the thoughtful and on track expert answers to these questions

  • @samuelpope7798
    @samuelpope7798 Рік тому +1

    Campers and bushcrafters also sometimes use big knifes. The KA-BAR is often used as a utility knife for those purposes. Processing fire wood making shelters , striking a spark on carbon steel blade etc. UA-cam is full of such videos. Entire channels. Very common knife sold everywhere.

  • @elizabethhealy4544
    @elizabethhealy4544 Рік тому +4

    Your show is great and you ask the best questions! It’s so smart and I learn so much from you and all your talented quests. I was curious about something you brought up. You mentioned that dog that was skinned but there was a dog in the house and nothing happened to it?? We know the killer was cold and heartless. How does that make any sense? I don’t think the dog belonged to the girls on the first floor. Where was the dog found and what about the barking?

  • @shawnwakattu28
    @shawnwakattu28 Рік тому +6

    I doubt this is first time kill for the perpetrator.
    This has many components of a planned, very well calculated kill. To stab to death four people, and flee the home undetected, while on the loose a month later is unlikely the work of a novice killer.

  • @samanthalebron9560
    @samanthalebron9560 Рік тому +2

    I just don't think they're used to having press conferences, hence not having them live. They don't want to compromise the investigation

  • @cwc8979
    @cwc8979 Рік тому +3

    Enjoy your show, any chance you can get John Walsh on your show? I have yet to hear his views on this story 👍

  • @Hugh1966
    @Hugh1966 Рік тому

    Subscribed . Great guests and insights

  • @beautifulrosemary6565
    @beautifulrosemary6565 Рік тому +3

    He keeps having different guests on asking the same questions. Exploiting this story. I swear UA-cam is anything for views content. It's sad.

  • @thewife6466
    @thewife6466 Рік тому

    Just want to say yours has got to be the best analysis of this horrific crime.

  • @MAINECOONLADY
    @MAINECOONLADY Рік тому +1

    Very intelligent & reasonable info, questions & examples given to back up & explain concepts shared. Ty all 3 of you, Gents!+

  • @lauriemadsen3786
    @lauriemadsen3786 Рік тому

    Just discovered and subscribed to your channel today. I've binged watched for hours today. Fantastic guess! ✌️

  • @susan-hp5id
    @susan-hp5id Рік тому +7

    What about the other murders that occurred on the 13th that also involved one or more victims stabbed in their sleep?

    • @captaincrunch1707
      @captaincrunch1707 Рік тому +1

      Agree they seem too similar. Also, many experts aren’t identifying that the perp could have access to a bazooka but prefers the knife. This perp is laser focused on stealth AND not getting caught by making undue noise(gun). He chooses his targets(house) very carefully because he wants to kill and have a clean sneaky unseen getaway. My favorite question is how he came upon this house. He definitely saw it at night to see that there were no floodlights or cameras. If it’s a SK then I think he cruises around in both daylight and nighttime when looking for a target of opportunity. It’s just un fathomable to think this wasn’t his first murder. Until the cops prove otherwise, to me it’s a SK.

    • @pyrodaddy2854
      @pyrodaddy2854 Рік тому +1

      Yes the victim was Travis Juetten his mother reached out with the possibility that it's connected. Almost everything matches from method of entry murder and time. The dates also are weird being the 13th. He lived in Oregon but he wasn't a sexy looking college girl so no outside agency gave a fuck. Travis wife lived after being stabbed 19 times and they also had a friend in the house who woke up and called the police. I would like to think alot of answers to this are in Silverton Oregon.

    • @susan-hp5id
      @susan-hp5id Рік тому

      @@captaincrunch1707 www.camaspostrecord.com/news/2020/oct/29/police-ask-for-help-in-washougal-murder/
      Are you aware of this murder as well?

    • @susan-hp5id
      @susan-hp5id Рік тому +1

      @@captaincrunch1707 it makes me wonder if this is a serial killer? Or did someone or someone's copycat this?

  • @Kimberly_K_
    @Kimberly_K_ Рік тому

    Awesome replay ! Thank you STS 😘

  • @shon88
    @shon88 Рік тому +14

    Do you know if tracking dogs were used to try to pick up the killer's scent and path of escape? I'm not sure if that would even work, but I was wondering if it was attempted? Or if it could've led to a home or where a car was parked.

    • @pyrodaddy2854
      @pyrodaddy2854 Рік тому +6

      I don't think it works that way I assume they would need a scent to follow like a article of clothing or something that's hundred percent from the killer to follow.

    • @brendaclauer2307
      @brendaclauer2307 Рік тому +3

      To use tracking dogs would need something for them to smell like that of a person to follower, so many people there way to much for any one smell to stick out to the dogs, J/S

    • @LourdesGzz
      @LourdesGzz Рік тому +1

      They didn’t use dogs on the scene

    • @susanohnhaus611
      @susanohnhaus611 Рік тому +4

      There are specially trained tracking dogs that would follow a blood scent trail and this killer surely left one. There was a brief clip of LE early on where there was a shot of a dog sniffing along the chainlink fence so I think they may have done some but obviously not any trained tracking dogs

    • @pyrodaddy2854
      @pyrodaddy2854 Рік тому +3

      @@susanohnhaus611 your probably right I highly doubt a small department has those kind of dogs ready to go at any moment though.

  • @1ACL
    @1ACL Рік тому +6

    If you, as the content creator on UA-cam, sees suspicious comments, do you have a protocol to follow to coordinate with or report to LE? I suppose you cant answer this here, but I sure hope there is a way, because its a good bet the perp is watching UA-cam, etc., and perhaps commenting.

  • @joanaubry6395
    @joanaubry6395 Рік тому +4

    Wow, I totally agree....you and your guests are the most professional! I have been following this horrible tragedy. You guys are awesome!

  • @mamag4160
    @mamag4160 Рік тому +3

    I watched an interview with a neighbor who delivers for grub hub. He said that there are “many” doorbell ring cameras in that area around the house. Maybe they already have footage of the car in the immediate area. So the gas station video may just be “more” video

    • @MareRS357
      @MareRS357 Рік тому +2

      Hi Mama G. Many people went out and got ring installed after this horrendous crime. One next door neighbor had a surveillance camera. There are no safe places anymore.

    • @libertyna933
      @libertyna933 Рік тому +1

      Yes , exactly right and the gas station video may not even be the Hyundai Elantra .

  • @susanray975
    @susanray975 Рік тому +1

    Love y show.. u have best guests and u are great interviewer...

  • @farkas3131
    @farkas3131 Рік тому +4

    Some of you have thought way too hard into this ... smh

  • @rhondacooper4667
    @rhondacooper4667 Рік тому +4

    Once again the Goncalves are constantly speaking of nature of the crimes, I have been listening to a lot of the interviews One really stood out that was on Fox shortly after the incident, The inconsistent of how the mother was talking very very fast said they were going to see their daughter next week for her birthday, funny just prior to that statement they were all together that week and rambling on about the new car that was just purchased. That is very interesting 🤔🤔

    • @tomd1434
      @tomd1434 Рік тому +2

      A mother who lost her daughter talking very very fast as you say, soon after the incident, and that makes your antennas go up? Saying one thing then another you noticed? Her daughter was just murdered. Do you think you would be calm and level headed if you were in her shoes? No disrespect intended towards you. I’m asking you so perhaps you can think about it from another point of view.

  • @CDV99
    @CDV99 Рік тому +1

    Good panel. So to the one guest' comment, police departments are above criticism or scrutiny? Tell that to the residents of Uvalde , TX.

  • @mjay3734
    @mjay3734 Рік тому +2

    Telling you it’s Inan Harsh. He’s a chef (familiar with knives) also a felon (can’t own firearm) has changed his statement, loner, also lives very nearby. Look into him.

    • @samuelpope7798
      @samuelpope7798 Рік тому

      He's sketchy a f. I don't know if he did it but I'd bet major jack that junkie's dealing again.

    • @darlenevoigt1457
      @darlenevoigt1457 Рік тому

      I don’t know. It’s Jack Showalter, then it’s Jack Duclos, now it’s Elan? Changes every week

  • @totallydomestic433
    @totallydomestic433 Рік тому

    Great questioning & Great guest. Thanks

  • @bobbifeazell7827
    @bobbifeazell7827 Рік тому +1

    Great show and panel.

  • @lulubells930
    @lulubells930 Рік тому +1

    I’m really glad you don’t keep rolling with negativity and doubt. !!

  • @donnielynn4096
    @donnielynn4096 Рік тому +3

    The killer has changed the way he lives his life, look for those changes

  • @emilyk565
    @emilyk565 Рік тому +4

    Joel- You are a very talented journalist and I just found your channel because of the Idaho murders. I got my BA in Interdisciplinary Studies- Psychology, Sociology and Social Work. While I attribute all of that understanding and interest to making me a top performer in sales/management for many years, I am going back to college to get my Masters in Psych or possibly Social Work because helping others is my true passion. I cannot wait to see your mother on here as well as she has many years of experience and an MSW in the field. You have the most amazing, experienced guests on your channel. I think college professors should recommend students on an academic, learning level subscribe to your channel/Patreon!

  • @jessicallewelynfoster7593
    @jessicallewelynfoster7593 Рік тому +1

    As an avid true crime sleuth I really appreciate your channel and coverage of current true crime events including this horrific quadruple murder in Idaho, however out of all the UA-cam content makers I find your channel to be flooded with adverts every 2 to 3 minutes, quite excessive, I normally allow the ads to run so as to support the channels, however in your case the excessive amount of ads has really put me off watching your content. I understand that’s one of the ways the make money, but this is truly excessive on your channel.

  • @Dragonfly657
    @Dragonfly657 Рік тому +2

    My father was a Holocaust Survivor ❤
    Love your show and great guests.
    This is buy far the saddest case because we are seeing these parents grieve. It’s horrible pain to overcome I don’t think you can ever heal from such sadness.

  • @mschmidt9150
    @mschmidt9150 Рік тому +1

    Hunters don't prefer K-BAR knives, it would be someone who couldn't get a permit for a gun.

  • @tomd1434
    @tomd1434 Рік тому +1

    But there are two cases that are very similar from the same general region since 2020. One murder in June 2020 of a middle aged woman who was sleeping and stabbed to death around 3am while she slept. No one ever caught. Then a year later a couple attacked at around 3am while they slept. The man was stabbed to death and the woman miraculously survived approximately 19 stab wounds. The middle aged woman I believe lived in Washington and the couple was from Oregon. Not far apart. Now this. Yes a bit further but same region. Seems to be a rare MO and they’re very similar. Cops said no evidence but doesn’t mean they’re not linked. That to me needs to be looked into which I’m sure it is. Why isn’t that being talked about more? Strange to me.

  • @Liberty6010and9
    @Liberty6010and9 Рік тому +5

    Thank you so much for having these 2 men on. It has literally taken all the strength that I have to not just scream because of all of these ppl throwing all of this pressure on these Police. It's been relentless, and it's been absolutely ridiculous and uncalled for. Ppl sitting in their living rooms online bashing these Police when they have no clue as to the massive amount of evidence, leads, tips, information that they have to go through. This is not some easy task where they can wave a wand and everything is done and sewn up in a day. The media has been so stupid in their coverage of this case. Just wanting to bash the police, as if any of these media ppl have a clue on what a quadruple homicide investigation entails. These men are telling the truth here and ppl need to listen and stop pressuring and bad mouthing these Police. They are working their butts off on this case! They are not magicians and ppl expecting them to be need to sit down and zip it! It's going to take time! That's just reality and it should have been common sense! But it seems we have an entire very spoiled entitled population who just cannot handle reality. Sucks to be them. Because this case is going to take as long as it takes.

  • @fuquaysteve271
    @fuquaysteve271 Рік тому +1

    It is despicable to question the father of a victim especially when he obviously was not even in the same county. He is grieving and in the anger stage. Period ....the public servant that suggested that should be ignored and shamed for calling himself a servant of the nation when he is really a public servant...nothing more.

    • @feralLove
      @feralLove Рік тому +1

      Do you know the father personally and if so were you with him 24/7 during the timeframe of the murder?? If not then your opinion is based on assumptions and not fact. Think a lot of folks find the fathers comments about Moscow law enforcement to be highly offensive and outta line.
      The father needs to show respect to receive respect and from his news interviews he's not.

  • @kellycregeen1393
    @kellycregeen1393 Рік тому +2

    THIS CASE IS SO TWISTED.ALOT OF EVIDENCE,DNA,BODILY WENT OVER BY FORENSIC PATHOLOGISTS &DETECTIVES.THERE HAD TO BE CLOSE TO A BREAK IN THE CASE.EITHER HE WILL STRIKE AGAIN OR STUMBLE AND BE CAUGHT

  • @JDBluedevil
    @JDBluedevil Рік тому +9

    I think they are to quickly discounting the serial killer option here. It very well could be the first murders of a budding serial killer. BTK's first attack he only planned to kill one person but planned poorly and ended up killing multiple because there were more in the house than he expected. All of these girls were all over social media and Instagram so someone could have been digitally stalking one or more for months.

    • @factsmatter8667
      @factsmatter8667 Рік тому +1

      Is is true that one or more had _Only Fans_ accounts? They certainly took a lot of photos of themselves pressing up against other females.

    • @QBAN2010
      @QBAN2010 Рік тому +1

      Your comments will make more sense when you learn the difference between to and too!

  • @sunnymoondog
    @sunnymoondog Рік тому +1

    Excellent guests!

  • @samanthalebron9560
    @samanthalebron9560 Рік тому +1

    That shows how much this was thought out prior....how is there no bloody footprints leading outside ?

    • @krissykrupski4973
      @krissykrupski4973 Рік тому +1

      Change of shoes, wore shoe covers, or never left the house.

    • @krissykrupski4973
      @krissykrupski4973 Рік тому +1

      Detective Ken Mains explains so many things, I think he is great, you should check him out.

    • @melbelle2049
      @melbelle2049 Рік тому

      Most likely but that would not be divulged

    • @angelarich8455
      @angelarich8455 Рік тому

      Same question I have

  • @christyrussell913
    @christyrussell913 Рік тому +3

    Start looking for the quiet helpful guy that learned how to “fake” emotions and sincerity, For god sakes you are in Idaho it’s 13 degrees EVERYBODY is wearing gloves he could have also wore butcher gloves. Unless you noticed him right after the killing he has calmed down and assimilated BACK into his community, he lives there always has.

  • @zee-lz3en
    @zee-lz3en Рік тому +2

    John Jack Showalter fits the profile he apparently took a 5 hour drive afterwards who would do that unless you had to get out of area he had a place down the road he should have stayed there but was worried cops would find these kids sooner than they did he wanted to get to family camp where there's knives and blood already he could blend it all in and if cops come up there his clothes could seem like he killed a deer or whatever

  • @davidgonzales2274
    @davidgonzales2274 Рік тому +2

    I was surprized how very chipper, almost a matter of fact xena's mother was, a vlog dedicated to the street stated that i believe zena's mom had been arrested for drug possession before the killings., how unbelievable.

  • @TheCatquillen
    @TheCatquillen Рік тому +1

    Please don’t start blaming the Dad!! If my child was murdered like his, I would be hell to deal with!

  • @rossydv
    @rossydv Рік тому

    I have trouble getting past the name of the show. What hell does it mean?

  • @zee-lz3en
    @zee-lz3en Рік тому +2

    I think he wanted to kill the two girls and Ethan heard noise on way out then he had to get those two

  • @Ammo08
    @Ammo08 Рік тому +1

    One reason people might have a large hunting knife could be, as ya'll mentioned, hunting, fishing, police, or trades people, but I think you also need to look at ex-military. Lot's of us kept the knives we were issued; they are keepsakes from a time that was important to us...just a thought.

  • @1ACL
    @1ACL Рік тому +4

    LE need to look into the skinned dog and bunnie. If true, it could be very significant seeing how it happend so close to town. Its def an act thats at least psychologically related to the murders. How many psychis like that live in a couple mike radius? I mean, it really is pissible to be tge same person.

  • @Vjbc_in_KC_opinionated_grandma

    The average time turn around for DNA evidence in Idaho is 89 days. Ancestral DNA takes a lot of work!

  • @steverockwell5074
    @steverockwell5074 Рік тому +1

    After I heard how the girls had bullied and harrased their former roommate. Yeah. Be nice folks...never know who youre pissing off. That girl has family, friends, exbfs, etc. Just be nice.

  • @samuelpope7798
    @samuelpope7798 Рік тому +1

    Hunting and video games? hard to take this very seriously.

  • @LV_Potter
    @LV_Potter Рік тому +2

    In this case the gamer discussion is misplaced. The level of effort needed to pull a virtual trigger is pretty close to that needed to pull an actual trigger, but the level of effort to kill with a knife is so vastly different that simply being desensitized just isn't enough.

    • @browngreen933
      @browngreen933 Рік тому

      Exactly. This guy is a Jack the Ripper type. I'm thinking some sort of rural loner who came into town to kill for sport.

    • @LV_Potter
      @LV_Potter Рік тому

      @@browngreen933 My money's on someone spun on mdma or meth.

  • @donnielynn4096
    @donnielynn4096 Рік тому +1

    Awesome show, dude.your experts satisfy my curiosity

  • @hlowrylong
    @hlowrylong Рік тому +2

    Any chance Ethan or one of the girls actually owned the knife (murder weapon) used in their murder? Has that been ruled out?
    What if the murderer stopped by to see one of them, then things turned sour, and the murderer grabbed the knife to attack?
    It has just seems as though the four were unlikely murder victims. I’m having a hard time thinking this was well planned, or planned for a while. This is especially true if the white Hyundai Elantra was ‘the getaway vehicle’.
    Probably very unlikely, but it struck me.

    • @sioux6365
      @sioux6365 Рік тому +1

      Ethan is a triplet, so you'd think his brothers would know, huh?

  • @mrsr003
    @mrsr003 Рік тому +1

    I really wish people would stop sort of accusing Kaylee’s Dad! He didn’t have anything to do with it! Sheesh!

  • @robhdez5048
    @robhdez5048 Рік тому +2

    More good guests. Thanks for not bringing on more generic "former FBI agents" with little homicide or forensic experience. The vast majority of G-men have never seen a dead body or investigated one leading to speculation.
    Anyhow, these are two solid guys with real LEO and forensic experience. Not terribly intellectual like PhD Gary who is in another world with incredible insights as well, but more nuts & bolts types with practical & reasonable conclusions which is needed to cut through the fog.
    As for the video collection task, the older gentlemen had it right. That task force (TF) stumbled in not identifying and collecting ALL surveillance/CCTV video to freeze that moment in time & get as much historic video as possible as well. Yes, it's a big task that requires its own team of specialized members, but needed to get done as one of the priorities. The town is not that big. At this point, much of the video being pursued will have purged, or will soon purge due to overwriting.
    MPD should have created a sworn/civilian (10 bodies minimum) video retrieval team with prioritized areas to ID & collect video to span out from the crime scene epicenter focusing on main ingress/egress routes. Where able, get as much historic video as possible. The goal is preservation initially & reviewing later unless you have a distinct person/vehicle you have IDed. If the TF is not using BriefCam Forensic or similar software to compress the review process, they are wasting time. It's a bit concerning that the cops did not locate/request this video before it was offered to them.

  • @PoohBear0774
    @PoohBear0774 Рік тому +1

    Xana Kerdoodle’s mother stated she thinks Xana and Ethan went to a bar after the short time at the frat party. Also, Xana’s father had been to the house a couple of weeks before the murders to ‘fix, change’ the locks on the doors. I do believe it’s a 20s guy who has had some kind of contact w/ victims(s) has experience killing animals… a loner w/ small circle of friends. Weird, strange an oddball. I also believe he is right there in sight and is reliving the killings by watching, listening to everything that is televised about the murders. He is really proud of himself to have ‘gotten away’ w/ this. The longer this goes on w/o a suspect( or so he believes) the more excited it gets. This was very well planned and he has never felt more important in his life!

  • @Lo-fi_Hi-brow
    @Lo-fi_Hi-brow Рік тому

    (Constructive criticism: You could really use a better mic.)

  • @Kat-qc5kw
    @Kat-qc5kw Рік тому +6

    With the strength required to stab to death 4 people, is it possible the killer was high on meth or a similar drug that gives a person super high strength? I cannot imagine the fortitude it would take to kill 4 people in this manner.

    • @JDBluedevil
      @JDBluedevil Рік тому +4

      No need for drugs, adrenaline would probably be enough

    • @Brooke52528
      @Brooke52528 Рік тому +1

      That makes a lot of sense.

    • @LourdesGzz
      @LourdesGzz Рік тому +4

      Psychopaths don't need drugs, Ted Bundy, Chandler Halderson, many more never used drugs to commit their crimes

    • @pyrodaddy2854
      @pyrodaddy2854 Рік тому +1

      Strength is irrelevant women stab stronger males to death all the time the most recent example being Courtney clenney so you don't have to be a male or in a drug craze. You also have to remember as blood loss begins to flow your victim it's literally losing strength and the closer they get to hypovolemic shock their mental status begins to decrease . You can probably stab someone 4 times while their asleep before they even get a chance to fight back.

    • @feralLove
      @feralLove Рік тому +2

      A chronic meth addict who is high is capable of such savagery. From living in an area where, in recent years, its use has become widespread and not just contained to more rural areas anymore, its become a serious issue and makes the user feel invincible like superman while under the influence. I have lived in a college town for 42 years and even college graduates have done the unthinkable under its influence.

  • @kathiehirsch6922
    @kathiehirsch6922 Рік тому +1

    No one has said how the murderer exited without a shred of blood or footprints with blood anywhere…this seems unbelievable……

    • @Ruth78620
      @Ruth78620 Рік тому

      He could have taken a change of clothes with him, he seems to be a very organised killer. There's also been talk that he may have been in the house before they returned home. He's a watcher so I hope they've thoroughly checked that tree line.

  • @samanthalebron9560
    @samanthalebron9560 Рік тому +1

    Why would the killer park rt in front of the house if committing something like this..?? Wouldn't make sense

  • @lulubells930
    @lulubells930 Рік тому

    Thank you

  • @patriciakoch5789
    @patriciakoch5789 Рік тому

    “New York”, this is me at my job lol

  • @daybyday0731
    @daybyday0731 Рік тому +2

    Joel I didn't realize how handsome you were lol...and of course our beautiful Carmella 😍...Just wanted to say what an amazing job you have been doing...Your guest have been great! Glad to see your channel growing...Two cases that have my attention the markel and the Idaho 4 so thank you for your hard work.

    • @pyrodaddy2854
      @pyrodaddy2854 Рік тому

      True crime reporter groupie

    • @daybyday0731
      @daybyday0731 Рік тому +2

      @@pyrodaddy2854 lol no that's not it at all ...thank you for making me laugh though

    • @pyrodaddy2854
      @pyrodaddy2854 Рік тому +1

      @@daybyday0731 that's what they all say

    • @daybyday0731
      @daybyday0731 Рік тому +2

      @@pyrodaddy2854 your profile speaks volumes lol ...I have been here since they both had 1 thousand subs and I'm just really happy to see the channel grow...in his previous videos he was never this close to the screen but now you can really see what he looks like...nothing more nothing less...I'm a happily married woman.Have a good Day

  • @madelinemahajan2808
    @madelinemahajan2808 Рік тому +6

    In regard to the evolution of crime in the modern age... Someone needs to do a show where they explore the contribution of INCEL sub-culture in incubating sadist misogynists and the potential for INCELS to increasingly play a role in crimes such as this one.

    • @spoonypoon7998
      @spoonypoon7998 Рік тому

      Yes with video games playing a major part in the evolution of crimes and the age at which they are committed