Tagore was a true nationalist. When Brigadier Dyer ordered killing of thousands of unarmed Indians in Amritsar massacre, he, as a strong protest, returned the knighthood back to the British Empire. Let me also quote from his immortal Gitanjali which won him the coveted Noble prize for literature: "Where the mind is without fear and the head is held high, Where knowledge is free, Where the world has not been broken up into fragments by narrow domestic walls, Where words come out from the depth of truth, Where tireless striving stretches its arms towards perfection, Where the clear stream of reason has not lost its way into the dreary desert sand of dead habit, Where the mind is led forward by thee into ever widening thought and action, Into that heaven of freedom, my Father, let my country awake."
Read his book ghar bair in English home & world you will understand he hate nationalism concept even before Hitler arrive. He was in love with this country . He doesn't want to forced other.
Rabindranath Thakur detested blind adherence to nationalism. Genius Bengali poet was a humanist and an Internationalist. Kabi guru Robindra apni geno juge juge ganmo nen ...because your words are eternally true and still relevant today. “ I will never allow nationalism triumph over humanity.” Tagore
Nationalism is needed, but too much of everything is bad. Nationalism gave rise to Azad Hind Fauz, but extreme nationalism gave rise to Nazism or Maoism
I would humbly like to add that; Rabindranath Tagore took active part in nationalist activities; amongst which the movement against Partition of Bengal for the first time in 1905 was remarkable. Due to his intervention along with other nationlist leaders this became one of the successful campaigns against the British Rule. He also addressed the Indian Nation Congress many times alike other Nationlist leaders like Tilak, Lala Lajpat Rai. However he questioned and opposed ruthlessness in the name of nationalism which he saw in his time and thus advocated humanism. But he was a true Patriot and Nationalist by heart and his thoughts. Please do not spread misconceptions about a Great man like him who represents India throughout the world like other Great men of our country. People outside India knows 'India' as the 'Land of Tagore and Vivekananda' and many others who are the framers of modern India.
Tagore detested nationalism, he was a humanist. He said,”I will never allow patriotism triumph over humanity.” Non Bengali people have hard time distinguishing between humanism and nationalism : He was against blind adherence to nationalism.
Thanks for Strong and open discussion...... Nationalism is inversely proportional to the Humanism . But reality from last few centuries is you can't survive (live) without Nationalism . Note : Nationalism has many siblings like Casteism,Statism .....etc.
My dear friend there is long story behind this name. initially tagore is known as thakur. but once its happen that some myth sprout that smell of meat has been sprout from near their home so thakure community refuse to accept them as thakur after that their surname is changed as tagore forever
@@satyajeetsinhkumpavat4166 What? In Bengali it is spelt as 'Thakur'. In those days the English pronounced our names wrong and spelt it wrong! It's as simple as that. For example, 'Moti' was spelt 'Mutty', 'Kanthi' was 'Contai', 'Bardhaman' was 'Burdwan', 'Chuchura' was Chinsurah' etc.
@@satyajeetsinhkumpavat4166 His family is not "Thakur" similar to north Indians... So, there is no truth in yoru story. Are you aware his grand father aborted Hinduism and took Brahma religion?
very very true. Nothing is bigger than humanity. No nationalism can be more pious than compassion for fellow human beings and other natural creatures on this planet.
3:30 The national anthem was adopted from his poem Bharato Bhagyo Bidhata and it was written when the George x came to India but it was an act of valor to let them know they are not the Bharato Bhagyo Bidhata
Today we are going through one of the darkest periods of Indian civilisation where we have seen during last six years thousands of innocent people are killed followed by armed violence of one against our fellow brothers and sisters and there have been protest movements against such sectarian politics in the name of religion and hardcore nationalism. Tagore has always been an iconic figure who introduced not only India's culture to the West but also very critical of ultra-nationalist and ultra-rightist powers, He was critical of Hitler, Mussolini and the undemocratic and authoritarian rules in Russia in the name of Socialism especially under the leadership of Stalin. If Tagore is live today, he must have raised his voice against inhuman treatment against a section of people to call for a global movement against such autocratic dictatorship. Tagore always spoke about humanism, global society in which all people across caste, class, religion should live in harmony and peace. This is high time that Indians should wake up to the calls and teachings of Tagore and protect and promote thousands of years of rich India's history, culture, traditions, ideas, thoughts, philosophy, integrity as a nation !
The problem is with our education system. We are not motivated to think critically. Just read, memorize and reproduce. Our debates are not about learning and enriching our thoughts. They are about winning over the opponents and earning a trophy or an award to feel good about ourselves. Education is not an end in itself in our education system. It is a means to an end. That end being material gains.
“The time has come when badges of honour make our shame glaring in their incongruous context of humiliation, and I for my part wish to stand, shorn of all special distinctions, by the side of my country men.” So wrote Rabindranath Tagore in 1919 to Lord Chelmsford, Viceroy of India, as he explained his reasons for renouncing the knighthood that had been awarded him by Britain some 4 years earlier.
@@AsadAli-jc5tg unhone 100 sal pehle hi rashtravad ke khatro se duniya ko agah kar diya tha. This pre dates rise of Nazism in Germany and India was still under British rule. This is very relavant.
Humanitarianism 》》》》》》》》》》》Nationalism ..... this is damn TRUE . If you don't agree with Tagore .....mind you BHAGAT SINGH'S view were quite same like TAGORE.....now what ?would you agree with BHAGAT now ?
National anthem shud not be a matter of debate at all. You have to think why this issue has become debatable and a court verdict is sought about it? The root cause is suspecting the Patriotism of a targetted minority by those whose own claims to patriotism are sham,based on perverted ideologies which promote divisiveness,and hatred in our essentially and unavoidable pluralistic society of india?WHO IS ANY ONE (UNLESS THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA IS AMENDED TO THAT EFFECT) TO DICTATE WHAT SOME CITIZENS SHUD DO OR NOT DO TO PROVE THEIR PATRIOTISM AND TELL ME IS IT WRITTEN ON ANYBODY"S FOREHEAD THAT HE IS A SAINT OR SINNER?TO WHICH COMMUNITY RAM RAHEEM,ASA RAM .......... BELONGED?"BARBADIYE KHAROKHAS KE LIYE KYU BARQ KO DAAWAT DETE HO,KYA LALA-O GUL BACH JAYENGE JAB AAG LAGEGI GULSHAN KO? E HIND KE MUHAFIZ WAQT KI DAUR MEIN HUM KAHA JA RAHE HAI? Show less REPLY
Arey Bhai..., if I trample down Humanity n just worship Allah Do u think Allah will Accept my worship.. the Answer is No.. which ever country , family or job.. we need to be honest ... bhai.. Samjhe.. ? Worship is easy Black n white.. Insaniyath sey Namaz padho Roza rakho zakath do.. Ye sab cheezen Ek Insaan ko insaniyath sikhati hai.. bhaichara.. brother hood sikhati hai.. Hope this Answers ur Question... Basically After Eman the first this is Righteousness.. is His Command.. written in Quraan Surah 105.. Hope this Answers ur Question.. (Eman means Belive )
Bhai I think ur Waasta with religious people is not Good.. why will God ask to Choose bwt him and the Land of birth? There Question itself is Irrelevent... Give me one practical example if u have come accross.? Do u know the difference bwt Farma bardari and zimedari? Worship is Personal connection soul to the creator ... Its a spiritual journey and experience...
In our country there is no freedom of speech, still, its illegal for the minority to get married, just recently LGBT get legal rights. People are arrested for criticising Ideology like Religion and Nationalism. There are no equal rights for women and especially women from the minority community. People are killing, dividing themselves based on religion ( even I have a problem as my girlfriend is from a Muslim family, we both are Atheist). Nothing good going to happen in India in social aspect until we give Humanity and Human Rights more important than Religion or Nationalism. We attack and kill humanist writers like M. M. Kalburgi, Taslima Nasreen. People are hacked to death for declaring they are Atheist in India like H Farook from Tamil Nadu and countless killings for eating beef.
Nationalism is being used in negative and by many Politicians especially the current regime but personally I believe nationalism is necessary, it's a feeling and should never be defined.
Nationalism is needed, but too much of everything is bad. Nationalism gave rise to Azad Hind Fauz, but extreme nationalism gave rise to Nazism or Maoism
I am a bengali .And I think you are misinterpreting this .I am saying bengali because during translation many words can be putted by translator himself ...😕😕😕
He opposed british nationalism . If he was opposed to Indian revolutionaries why the hell did he lecture the British. The misappropriation of robi thakur has long outlived its lies
@@arjunsinha212 he wasnt a commie revolutionary 😁. He was a nationalist. Our nationalist movement had two funding options. Till first world war it was through US , Italy, even Germans, the carbonaris , the Mazzini etc . Although the Gaddar movement was more on the socialist side it still operated from US soil . After the October revolution and end of first world war the funds from the above mentioned countries dried up. By 1930s as soviet union came into reckoning and their influence in Afghanistan increased indian revolutionaries got more funds from USSR . So the revolutionary got a commie tinge. Tagore made it very clear he hated commie old farts 🙂the kind who targeted his affluence. He was a staunch nationalist alright. And this very statement that you say makes you quite misinformed about him.
If humanism is not above nationalism to q hr murder ki saza fansi nhi h aur q prisoners of war (PoW) ko wapas Kiya jata h :and why terrorists were released after 1999 airline hijack for safety of our passengers But when it comes to poor citizens they are denied their Basic rights : we aren't OK if people die with corona but we are very much OK if people die of Malnutrition, Hunger, denied to hospitalization.,
Tagore ji was poet , and poet has to have human approach, but nationality has to be imposed up to level to develop national character after all we all have to be in boundaries , we can't disown this , because world doesn't think in line of human concept. Global citizenship is grt idea but there will be one or many always to differ from idea, till then we have to satisfy with concept of nationality
the very way Ravishji presents his vocabulary , I really have difficulty in understanding his point of view ....making vocabulary complicated doesnt make it interesting...as far as my understanding goes he has not at all understood Tagore...actually he is misleading people and confusing ppl ...his main problem is with the rise of hindu nationalism ...as these ppl only want to enslave and misdirect hindus and r afraid of a day when hindus stand united...
I dont understand why ndtv has such a callous anchor who does have enough quality to understand and analyse tagore's views . He speaks like an uneducated fellow
ہندوستان دی سن سنتالی وچ دو حصیاں یعنی مغربی ہندوستان (عرف الباکستان) تے مغربی ہندوستان (عرف انڈیا) وچ ونڈ دے ذمےدار سرخ (روسی) سامراج ، سفید (برطانوی) سامراج تے اوناں دے مقامی سہولت کاراں مثلا مسلم لیگ، کانگریس، تے کیمونسٹ پارٹی وغیرہ سن-
Half baked understanding spread for pet agenda! Tagore called togatherness as a better nationalism, questioning the anti- other sentiment emerging from any sectarianism what ever may be the source - be it regional, religious, linguistic, geographic, race, or historical chavunism. That means he refined nationalism, mahatma Gandhi adopted that nationalism as his philosophy.
thakur sahab ki lino me swantrata ki bhawan umadati h, lekin woh duniya ko apne hisab se dekh rhe h ....unhe ye nhi pta ki log sath rhte rhte annatanqwad faila dete h
If this r tagors views abt nation then I dubt he wrote jan gan man for nation. And this anchor is very appologetic white accepting that it was written for King George.
Tagore was way ahead of his time. His thoughts are even ahead of our time.
Tagore was a true nationalist. When Brigadier Dyer ordered killing of thousands of unarmed Indians in Amritsar massacre, he, as a strong protest, returned the knighthood back to the British Empire.
Let me also quote from his immortal
Gitanjali which won him the coveted Noble prize for literature:
"Where the mind is without fear and the head is held high,
Where knowledge is free,
Where the world has not been broken up into fragments by narrow domestic walls,
Where words come out from the depth of truth,
Where tireless striving stretches its arms towards perfection,
Where the clear stream of reason has not lost its way into the dreary desert sand of dead habit,
Where the mind is led forward by thee into ever widening thought and action,
Into that heaven of freedom, my Father, let my country awake."
Read his book ghar bair in English home & world you will understand he hate nationalism concept even before Hitler arrive. He was in love with this country . He doesn't want to forced other.
He is internationalist
Do more research
He didn't reject knighthood because they killed unarmed Indians he did it because they killed unarmed people.
You don't know anything about Rabindranath.
Tagore was a true patriot. Not a nationalist.
Rabindranath Tagore's eyes say it all.....
Rabindranath Thakur detested blind adherence to nationalism. Genius Bengali poet was a humanist and an Internationalist. Kabi guru Robindra apni geno juge juge ganmo nen ...because your words are eternally true and still relevant today. “ I will never allow nationalism triumph over humanity.” Tagore
Nationalism is needed, but too much of everything is bad. Nationalism gave rise to Azad Hind Fauz, but extreme nationalism gave rise to Nazism or Maoism
Maoists aren't nationalists but ok
@@shreyanghosh758 dafuq?I AM NOT A LEFTIST
@@shreyanghosh758 right wing is hyper nationalists and you are accusing a left winger. WOW
I would humbly like to add that; Rabindranath Tagore took active part in nationalist activities; amongst which the movement against Partition of Bengal for the first time in 1905 was remarkable. Due to his intervention along with other nationlist leaders this became one of the successful campaigns against the British Rule. He also addressed the Indian Nation Congress many times alike other Nationlist leaders like Tilak, Lala Lajpat Rai. However he questioned and opposed ruthlessness in the name of nationalism which he saw in his time and thus advocated humanism. But he was a true Patriot and Nationalist by heart and his thoughts. Please do not spread misconceptions about a Great man like him who represents India throughout the world like other Great men of our country. People outside India knows 'India' as the 'Land of Tagore and Vivekananda' and many others who are the framers of modern India.
Tagore was patriot, not Nationalist. There are lot of differences. Internationalist... would be a near suitable word.
Read three books of Tagore 'Nationalism, 'Towards Universal Man' and Crises Of Civilisation'.
People like who fail to distinguish bw nationalism and patriotism.
Tagore detested nationalism, he was a humanist. He said,”I will never allow patriotism triumph over humanity.” Non Bengali people have hard time distinguishing between humanism and nationalism : He was against blind adherence to nationalism.
He was a socialist
Joy bangla,Joy Rabindranath ; from Bangladesh
❤️ For Bangladesh
Ravish Kumar, you are the best person. A true enlighted and courageous man .
I do agree with the humanitarianism aspect though .
Thanks for Strong and open discussion...... Nationalism is inversely proportional to the Humanism .
But reality from last few centuries is you can't survive (live) without Nationalism .
Note : Nationalism has many siblings like Casteism,Statism .....etc.
According to today's standards he would be ,"anti-national" 🙃
Jana gana mana adhinayaka can't be king George or any George whatsoever. - Tagore
Why Tagore is called Tagore like the Europeans, why don't we say Thakur?
Bcs,she was little over rated
You should know y Gandhi hated Tagore.
My dear friend there is long story behind this name. initially tagore is known as thakur. but once its happen that some myth sprout that smell of meat has been sprout from near their home so thakure community refuse to accept them as thakur after that their surname is changed as tagore forever
@@satyajeetsinhkumpavat4166 What? In Bengali it is spelt as 'Thakur'. In those days the English pronounced our names wrong and spelt it wrong! It's as simple as that. For example, 'Moti' was spelt 'Mutty', 'Kanthi' was 'Contai', 'Bardhaman' was 'Burdwan', 'Chuchura' was Chinsurah' etc.
@@satyajeetsinhkumpavat4166 His family is not "Thakur" similar to north Indians... So, there is no truth in yoru story. Are you aware his grand father aborted Hinduism and took Brahma religion?
Bjb aur RSS walo ke liye ab Tagore bhi Anti national ho gaye
very very true. Nothing is bigger than humanity. No nationalism can be more pious than compassion for fellow human beings and other natural creatures on this planet.
3:30 The national anthem was adopted from his poem Bharato Bhagyo Bidhata and it was written when the George x came to India but it was an act of valor to let them know they are not the Bharato Bhagyo Bidhata
Today we are going through one of the darkest periods of Indian civilisation where we have seen during last six years thousands of innocent people are killed followed by armed violence of one against our fellow brothers and sisters and there have been protest movements against such sectarian politics in the name of religion and hardcore nationalism. Tagore has always been an iconic figure who introduced not only India's culture to the West but also very critical of ultra-nationalist and ultra-rightist powers, He was critical of Hitler, Mussolini and the undemocratic and authoritarian rules in Russia in the name of Socialism especially under the leadership of Stalin. If Tagore is live today, he must have raised his voice against inhuman treatment against a section of people to call for a global movement against such autocratic dictatorship. Tagore always spoke about humanism, global society in which all people across caste, class, religion should live in harmony and peace. This is high time that Indians should wake up to the calls and teachings of Tagore and protect and promote thousands of years of rich India's history, culture, traditions, ideas, thoughts, philosophy, integrity as a nation !
The problem is with our education system. We are not motivated to think critically. Just read, memorize and reproduce. Our debates are not about learning and enriching our thoughts. They are about winning over the opponents and earning a trophy or an award to feel good about ourselves. Education is not an end in itself in our education system. It is a means to an end. That end being material gains.
I appreciate your valued words..
Tagore was a free mind unlike Gandhi
10:53 to 11:06
Deserves more than million views
Rabindranatha thakur is great philosopher past time and present time
even in 2019 it is as relevant as it was may be in 1917 when the book Nationalism released....!!!1
Now I am going to write my practical file on Nationalism
I need higher level brain to take it.
7:08
Ravish Kumar ft. Rabindranath Tagore ❤
We should expect someone to be human when everyone around are human... But the world doesn't work this way...
He make this type of phrase because to trape his enemy through controlling there mind he is a wise man ever alive
“The time has come when badges of honour make our shame glaring in their incongruous context of humiliation, and I for my part wish to stand, shorn of all special distinctions, by the side of my country men.”
So wrote Rabindranath Tagore in 1919 to Lord Chelmsford, Viceroy of India, as he explained his reasons for renouncing the knighthood that had been awarded him by Britain some 4 years earlier.
This is timeless, Tagore is relevant even to this day.
Woh kaise Gulati ji?
@@AsadAli-jc5tg unhone 100 sal pehle hi rashtravad ke khatro se duniya ko agah kar diya tha. This pre dates rise of Nazism in Germany and India was still under British rule. This is very relavant.
Marx already did that even before him.
@@AsadAli-jc5tg marx resembles on only one point with him
From Pak🕊Always interesting & insightful to watch your programmes Ravish Kumar Ji. I m a great fan of R. Tagore Ji. How can I access that book.
See and search from sources, Also available in the nation or not
These clips will be taught in journalism lectures after 100 years
10:50 everything happened after only 2 years
Rabindranath Tagore was a Socialist.
Communism is a extreme level of socialism..
Wow I never hoped mainstream media can publish anything good
Kaviguru is the emotion of every single bengali all over the world
I m glad Ravish is with us n NDTV.
Excellence explained by rabish sir
6:00
Humanitarianism 》》》》》》》》》》》Nationalism ..... this is damn TRUE .
If you don't agree with Tagore .....mind you BHAGAT SINGH'S view were quite same like TAGORE.....now what ?would you agree with BHAGAT now ?
There is a difference between Nationalism & Patriotism!
In nationalism we think our country is on top...
But patriotism is a feeling ...
Defined borders have to exist
Anyone in 2025
upsc history optional question ka source
Ravishji you're really Adorable 💕
jai ho
बहुत सुन्दर पेशकश
Can you translate in English?
National anthem shud not be a matter of debate at all. You have to think why this issue has become debatable and a court verdict is sought about it? The root cause is suspecting the Patriotism of a targetted minority by those whose own claims to patriotism are sham,based on perverted ideologies which promote divisiveness,and hatred in our essentially and unavoidable pluralistic society of india?WHO IS ANY ONE (UNLESS THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA IS AMENDED TO THAT EFFECT) TO DICTATE WHAT SOME CITIZENS SHUD DO OR NOT DO TO PROVE THEIR PATRIOTISM AND TELL ME IS IT WRITTEN ON ANYBODY"S FOREHEAD THAT HE IS A SAINT OR SINNER?TO WHICH COMMUNITY RAM RAHEEM,ASA RAM .......... BELONGED?"BARBADIYE KHAROKHAS KE LIYE KYU BARQ KO DAAWAT DETE HO,KYA LALA-O GUL BACH JAYENGE JAB AAG LAGEGI GULSHAN KO? E HIND KE MUHAFIZ WAQT KI DAUR MEIN HUM KAHA JA RAHE HAI?
Show less
REPLY
You forgot that Tagore's India was destroyed in 1947 when Gandhi-Nehru accepted the British proposal to divide India.
Desh Prem Hamara Aakhari Adhyath'mic Sahara Nahi
Bansak ta. Mera Ashray Manavta hai. Main heerey ke daam mein Glass nahi Khareedoonga .. Aur Jab tak main zinda hoon Manavta key upar Desh prem ki Jeeth nahi hooney doonga.. -
"Ravindhranath Tagore"
Book - " Rashtra vaad "
Thank you for ur comment :).. U know what.. Worship Righteousness is not contradicting .. its contradistintive.. I hope this answers Ur Question..
Arey Bhai..., if I trample down Humanity n just worship Allah Do u think Allah will Accept my worship.. the Answer is No.. which ever country , family or job.. we need to be honest ... bhai.. Samjhe.. ? Worship is easy Black n white.. Insaniyath sey Namaz padho Roza rakho zakath do.. Ye sab cheezen Ek Insaan ko insaniyath sikhati hai.. bhaichara.. brother hood sikhati hai.. Hope this Answers ur Question... Basically After Eman the first this is Righteousness.. is His Command.. written in Quraan Surah 105.. Hope this Answers ur Question.. (Eman means Belive )
Yaar Jab tum Job pey Jate ho.. ur collegue will ask job will come first or parents? Kya boleyge tum.. ?
Bhai I think ur Waasta with religious people is not Good.. why will God ask to Choose bwt him and the Land of birth? There Question itself is Irrelevent... Give me one practical example if u have come accross.? Do u know the difference bwt Farma bardari and zimedari? Worship is Personal connection soul to the creator ... Its a spiritual journey and experience...
In our country there is no freedom of speech, still, its illegal for the minority to get married, just recently LGBT get legal rights. People are arrested for criticising Ideology like Religion and Nationalism. There are no equal rights for women and especially women from the minority community. People are killing, dividing themselves based on religion ( even I have a problem as my girlfriend is from a Muslim family, we both are Atheist). Nothing good going to happen in India in social aspect until we give Humanity and Human Rights more important than Religion or Nationalism. We attack and kill humanist writers like M. M. Kalburgi, Taslima Nasreen. People are hacked to death for declaring they are Atheist in India like H Farook from Tamil Nadu and countless killings for eating beef.
Nationalism is being used in negative and by many Politicians especially the current regime but personally I believe nationalism is necessary, it's a feeling and should never be defined.
Nationalism is needed, but too much of everything is bad. Nationalism gave rise to Azad Hind Fauz, but extreme nationalism gave rise to Nazism or Maoism
Everything should be questionable. It should be defined.
The intro is gold, like the anchor.
I am a bengali .And I think you are misinterpreting this .I am saying bengali because during translation many words can be putted by translator himself ...😕😕😕
Don't mislead people. Please read KALANTAR
Very nice video . Very usefull.
We don't need nationalism from west,
He opposed british nationalism . If he was opposed to Indian revolutionaries why the hell did he lecture the British.
The misappropriation of robi thakur has long outlived its lies
Thakur was a patriot, not a nationalist.
@@arjunsinha212 he wasnt a commie revolutionary 😁. He was a nationalist. Our nationalist movement had two funding options. Till first world war it was through US , Italy, even Germans, the carbonaris , the Mazzini etc . Although the Gaddar movement was more on the socialist side it still operated from US soil .
After the October revolution and end of first world war the funds from the above mentioned countries dried up.
By 1930s as soviet union came into reckoning and their influence in Afghanistan increased indian revolutionaries got more funds from USSR .
So the revolutionary got a commie tinge.
Tagore made it very clear he hated commie old farts 🙂the kind who targeted his affluence.
He was a staunch nationalist alright. And this very statement that you say makes you quite misinformed about him.
gurudev humari desh ki garv hai.
Positive......
Gurudev
If humanism is not above nationalism to q hr murder ki saza fansi nhi h aur q prisoners of war (PoW) ko wapas Kiya jata h :and why terrorists were released after 1999 airline hijack for safety of our passengers
But when it comes to poor citizens they are denied their Basic rights : we aren't OK if people die with corona but we are very much OK if people die of Malnutrition, Hunger, denied to hospitalization.,
NDTV India hindi Live UA-cam channel hona Chahye
He was like a Greek god google say 6ft2 if not more in Bengal they say he was 6ft4 he would do wrestling in Aswell
Socialism better of nationalism
Tagore ji was poet , and poet has to have human approach, but nationality has to be imposed up to level to develop national character after all we all have to be in boundaries , we can't disown this , because world doesn't think in line of human concept. Global citizenship is grt idea but there will be one or many always to differ from idea, till then we have to satisfy with concept of nationality
great TV show ..
Rabindranath world No1 kabi hen । Unone jivan ke har chis ke ware me likha hen
its really a great concern. we the people should conisder it very seriously. 😷
the very way Ravishji presents his vocabulary , I really have difficulty in understanding his point of view ....making vocabulary complicated doesnt make it interesting...as far as my understanding goes he has not at all understood Tagore...actually he is misleading people and confusing ppl ...his main problem is with the rise of hindu nationalism ...as these ppl only want to enslave and misdirect hindus and r afraid of a day when hindus stand united...
classic...
"Gora" aache se poriye Ravish ji ........
Gora is not of nationalism it is about humanism
Today mob lynching representing this
Bc kalakaar kavita likhega kya
Saaf saaf bola kar
I dont understand why ndtv has such a callous anchor who does have enough quality to understand and analyse tagore's views . He speaks like an uneducated fellow
पाकिस्तान के सापेक्ष में आपका बात बकवास है
ہندوستان دی سن سنتالی وچ دو حصیاں یعنی مغربی ہندوستان (عرف الباکستان) تے مغربی ہندوستان (عرف انڈیا) وچ ونڈ دے ذمےدار سرخ (روسی) سامراج ، سفید (برطانوی) سامراج تے اوناں دے مقامی سہولت کاراں مثلا مسلم لیگ، کانگریس، تے کیمونسٹ پارٹی وغیرہ سن-
Bangladesh..now can be counted if we see from indo-aryan viewpoint
Being a bengali,I have huge respect to Rabindranth Thakur.But Rabish kumar tum kahena kaya chate ho...??!😂
M bengali and free thinker and fan of Ravish
@@mixedtube2591 free thinker,i mean blind fan of Rubbish Kumar's propaganda.Good....👍🏻🤯😆.
Half baked understanding spread for pet agenda! Tagore called togatherness as a better nationalism, questioning the anti- other sentiment emerging from any sectarianism what ever may be the source - be it regional, religious, linguistic, geographic, race, or historical chavunism. That means he refined nationalism, mahatma Gandhi adopted that nationalism as his philosophy.
Classic NDTV, no english subtitles but the title is in english, haha you guys got the best jokes
thakur sahab ki lino me swantrata ki bhawan umadati h, lekin woh duniya ko apne hisab se dekh rhe h ....unhe ye nhi pta ki log sath rhte rhte annatanqwad faila dete h
If this r tagors views abt nation then I dubt he wrote jan gan man for nation. And this anchor is very appologetic white accepting that it was written for King George.
daliya verenker it was not written for King George and he only wrote our national anthem. Try to think and understand the things in other way also
just u dont know the full history he didnt written for any george at all. but for our nation as connecting all the state in a single song only.
Tagore was British agent
you are chinese agent
Islamic dogs must learn from ravindranath Tagore.