EA Secretly Made Changes to Recruits and Player Archetypes in College Football 25 Dynasty

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 3 лют 2025
  • Ігри

КОМЕНТАРІ • 142

  • @PoodleGaming
    @PoodleGaming  Місяць тому

    Use code Poodle at Raycon - buyraycon.com/Poodle

  • @y-townsking1599
    @y-townsking1599 Місяць тому +76

    They need to make Physical WR’s traits useful. I’m tired of them losing the high point balls and not bullying CB’s in the run game

    • @moneymanhussein8445
      @moneymanhussein8445 Місяць тому +19

      I swear bruh 6’4 wr have no advantage they dont even catch jump balls they need to fix that for next year, only way you catch a deep ball is if they burn the corner

    • @Keno-ss6ht
      @Keno-ss6ht Місяць тому +3

      @@y-townsking1599 man edit them when you play dynasty mode & they graduate you make them like u want 6’6 99 every player I mean it’s cheesy but fun I mean the game is yours play how you want but try and see hell I won 9 tiles with bama lol 😂

    • @dr.mo7773
      @dr.mo7773 Місяць тому +5

      Move em to TE

    • @omogiant40
      @omogiant40 Місяць тому +3

      @@dr.mo7773 or try aiming down left or right when running go's/fades

    • @conehed1138
      @conehed1138 Місяць тому +3

      ​@@omogiant40that's risky tho, if the corner is in trail or is too far on top of the receiver, they break on it for an easy pick. Just so annoying how the defense attacks the ball way better than the offense

  • @jahdadon5989
    @jahdadon5989 Місяць тому +13

    They need to make physical wideouts actually physical

  • @Underfly1
    @Underfly1 Місяць тому +15

    I just hope they make it to where transfers actually develop.

    • @andrewoberg
      @andrewoberg Місяць тому +2

      yep, whole transfer portal needs a rework too

    • @phillip4buckeyes4life
      @phillip4buckeyes4life Місяць тому

      I had a transfer 90 develop into a 92 by seasons end idk if that counts

    • @andrewoberg
      @andrewoberg Місяць тому +1

      @@phillip4buckeyes4life they don’t get offseason training the year they transfer, they get pushed down the depth chart in most cases & them transferring was useless. especially if their dealbreaker was pro potential their ass ain’t getting drafted with no development

    • @Underfly1
      @Underfly1 Місяць тому +2

      @@phillip4buckeyes4life i think they develop throughout the season but I meant the offseason. Transfers don’t develop in the offseason you sign them so you have to wait until the next offseason to get that training boost. Which is obviously unhelpful when it comes to senior transfers😂

    • @phillip4buckeyes4life
      @phillip4buckeyes4life Місяць тому

      @Underfly1 good good point. I agree their off season Devo is terrible

  • @danieldbeavers
    @danieldbeavers Місяць тому +11

    That RB progression cost is how it always was. Quickness is most expensive and power is second most regardless of archetype. IQ and Route Running are the cheapest. What's really annoying about it is that power backs won't upgrade their power traits (and thus any of their physicals) until they've become elite receivers, and by that time they're probably so high overall that they declare for the draft.
    It looks like maybe EA's hotfix for that was to put more caps on power backs' bars for route running, hands, and elusiveness. I couldn't say for sure, that's just how the 2 power RBs on my roster are currently.

    • @CAPAE
      @CAPAE Місяць тому +2

      It is the same across All players among the same Archetype. The only differences are stat caps and Dev Traits.
      The biggest difference is that Receiving Backs actually gain Route Running ratings group slower. Why? No idea, but Power Backs Overall ratings are skewed towards Power ratings, which are harder to grow, which makes them appear lower in Overall rating most of the time.

    • @Eibarwoman
      @Eibarwoman Місяць тому +4

      What is worse is the power backs is usually right up against the power cap, without architect so they won't develop much either.

    • @benwatson222
      @benwatson222 Місяць тому

      @@Eibarwomandoes architect and limitless actually work now? I know it was based on the player buying the skill upgrade instead of it being a level up

    • @Eibarwoman
      @Eibarwoman Місяць тому

      @@benwatson222 I haven't gotten a coach build with that yet for the HC. Usually my rebuilds don't involve playing enough rivalry games to unlock Architect.

    • @benwatson222
      @benwatson222 Місяць тому

      @ gotcha from everything I have read it’s a total sham of an ability which really sucks

  • @CKBowling1
    @CKBowling1 Місяць тому +34

    I have quite a few players who take an extensive amount of time to commit. They stay at Top 10 or 8 until week 5-6 even if I have full hours on them.

    • @RyanPatridge
      @RyanPatridge Місяць тому +9

      I have 1-2 early commits and almost none until after the conference championships while the AI have. 25+ commits..

    • @CKBowling1
      @CKBowling1 Місяць тому +1

      @@RyanPatridge I will say I got a quarterback commit pretty early this time right after I unlocked elite recruiter

    • @KALICOE
      @KALICOE Місяць тому +3

      Honestly it depends on school and location if you fsu or mia in the state of Florida your class should be filled by week 8

    • @dicemaniii
      @dicemaniii Місяць тому +1

      Coach attributes are a key role. Especially recruiting coach and elite. Found out that not CEO but the one right under that def helps in the recruiting commits

    • @KALICOE
      @KALICOE Місяць тому +1

      @dicemaniii ceo is the top coach I have yet to use points except for oline play and getting 65 hours and I still pull what I want

  • @SplashAdjusts
    @SplashAdjusts Місяць тому +1

    Them giving us more coach points could fix a lot of this. Like i could actually buy the one where persuades are more effective and players are less likely to go pro. If I could just do more as a coach i think itll balance out a lot of this

  • @benwatson222
    @benwatson222 Місяць тому +1

    I have noticed that sometimes the physical skills they have when you recruit them will get downgraded now. I have noticed this mainly with athletes

    • @williamthomas4125
      @williamthomas4125 24 дні тому

      Try letting the cpu auto change their position. When you position change, it adjusts physical badges based on rating. Takes away badges where the rating isn't high enough.

  • @BrandonWafer8
    @BrandonWafer8 Місяць тому +3

    They should do something like madden with freshman, they should let freshman devolp depending on snaps

    • @PoodleGaming
      @PoodleGaming  Місяць тому +1

      I agree. Maybe even a training camp mode or something to develop certain guys a bit.

  • @dantaeking3523
    @dantaeking3523 Місяць тому +23

    Wish their was more Improvisor QBs in recruiting instead of so many scrambling QBs

    • @Jake.E75
      @Jake.E75 Місяць тому

      What's the difference between the two?

    • @underrated38
      @underrated38 Місяць тому +5

      I always dig the looking for field generals. Hella rare and somehow hard af to sign

    • @dantaeking3523
      @dantaeking3523 Місяць тому +11

      @@Jake.E75 Improvisors develop better throwing than scramblers

    • @jaronmcelhaney212
      @jaronmcelhaney212 Місяць тому +1

      Hard to find

    • @jaronmcelhaney212
      @jaronmcelhaney212 Місяць тому +2

      Sometimes we you need a QB hard not to take a scrambler

  • @kinetik615
    @kinetik615 Місяць тому +19

    Where can we see this chart in full for all positions?

    • @frogalex8915
      @frogalex8915 Місяць тому +1

      yeah thats what i wanna know

    • @PoodleGaming
      @PoodleGaming  Місяць тому +12

      I’m working on a website.

    • @epicdroneimages1128
      @epicdroneimages1128 Місяць тому

      @@PoodleGaming looking forward to that

    • @asippel05
      @asippel05 Місяць тому +4

      @@PoodleGamingdefinitely looking forward to that! For now, any way we could get it shared with a link on google sheets/drive or something similar?

  • @kristopherbrown8276
    @kristopherbrown8276 Місяць тому +6

    They got rid of speed rusher at outside linebacker

    • @blakeluker1425
      @blakeluker1425 Місяць тому +1

      Speed rusher at OLB was never a thing. It's a bug in the game that if you change a player to OLB and their archetype changes to Speed Rusher you can't see their caps and they don't progress. Same with Slot archetype WRs and Strong Arm QBs

  • @brandoncreighton5000
    @brandoncreighton5000 Місяць тому

    One observation you made about how you can’t keep the elite players past their 3rd year…I think they may be doing this to encourage people to build out CEO coaches getting those abilities to try to keep projected draftees from leaving.

    • @PoodleGaming
      @PoodleGaming  Місяць тому +1

      Yeah it’s possible, but the path to get there is too expensive for my taste

  • @Jay-dh5vx
    @Jay-dh5vx Місяць тому

    Great vid keep up the good work

  • @bigjoe1009
    @bigjoe1009 Місяць тому

    I like it, I wish it showed what was upgraded from the start, that would be sweet

    • @PoodleGaming
      @PoodleGaming  Місяць тому +1

      I 100% agree. I would love a “progression” screen that shows a chart of where they started and how they progress along the way

  • @HotboyGaming81
    @HotboyGaming81 Місяць тому

    Bro where can we can the spreadsheet for all positions or do you plan on making videos for all positions and tendencies!? Come on man you can’t tease us like that…you straight cooking in this video!!

    • @PoodleGaming
      @PoodleGaming  Місяць тому

      lol, I plan to put it all together on a website but I do reference it in my videos.

  • @justins4873
    @justins4873 Місяць тому

    It's effing sick that they are doing updates!

    • @PoodleGaming
      @PoodleGaming  Місяць тому +1

      Is that a good sick or a bad sick lol?

    • @justins4873
      @justins4873 Місяць тому

      @PoodleGaming good sick haha

  • @Je-Razor
    @Je-Razor Місяць тому +4

    I think they should remove abilities to be upgraded with points and only be the attributes that improve through them.
    Instead I think that there should be a certain level in a stat that guarantees that the player get that ability instantly. But there should also be a lower level in the same stat that allows for the same ability but the player needs to obtain a certain amount of XP by playing in games for upgrading early but it won't use points.
    So you can get a player to upgrade the abilities early by playing them or you can wait and hope they get good enough in that stat to obtain it automatically.
    Doing it this way they can easier balance development with attributes and players not feeling there is a lack of development because they used all points on abilities. And you get an extra bonus for playing players instead of sitting them by getting abilities early if they have met the minimum threshold.

    • @PoodleGaming
      @PoodleGaming  Місяць тому +1

      I said this in a video this week. I feel like the ability point spending aspect needs to be retooled a bit. Great concept, but you just don’t earn enough points to ever truly upgrade a player and their abilities at some positions

  • @SWB_mike
    @SWB_mike Місяць тому +13

    All of the athletes have been nerfed I think they started with them and I hate that there is 5 star gems with impact

    • @PoodleGaming
      @PoodleGaming  Місяць тому +9

      I feel like 5 stars have been very inconsistent lately

    • @Jake.E75
      @Jake.E75 Місяць тому +5

      Dude, I recently signed a 5 star athlete QB. He was a 75 impact with so many stat caps!

    • @adrianbelgrave4123
      @adrianbelgrave4123 Місяць тому +2

      ​@PoodleGaming EXACTLY...going on year 20 on dynasty I got 5 stars with 15 skill caps and even had a normal dev 5 star... and it seems 4 star gems are really what you should be looking for currently... THANKS for these recruiting updates... which is the ONLY reason why I keep coming back year after year is because of recruiting...

    • @moneymanhussein8445
      @moneymanhussein8445 Місяць тому +1

      I noticed this too 5 stars have been so trash, my 4 stars are better, my 5 stars dont even start wit good abilities now

    • @adrianbelgrave4123
      @adrianbelgrave4123 Місяць тому

      @@Jake.E75 Thats exactly what one of recent middle Linebackers were.... A 5 star Impact with 16 skill caps

  • @omogiant40
    @omogiant40 Місяць тому +7

    I just dislike how I can't manually upgrade like Madden & there's no practice mode. Only in ultimate team & no spring game, which would be training camp in Madden. Hopefully, ncaa 26 has this & put encouraging transfers as the transfer portal is open.

    • @Frequencyshoots
      @Frequencyshoots Місяць тому +4

      Bro wdym there's no practice mode there is practice mode in dynasty

    • @AlphonsoTerrell
      @AlphonsoTerrell Місяць тому +1

      @@FrequencyshootsHe’s talking about practice mode that would allow you to develop players like in madden, before you play the game for the week. It allows you to get extra points to help develop focus players faster. I’m pretty sure he knows there’s a free play practice mode in dynasty. It just doesn’t provide any benefit.

    • @omogiant40
      @omogiant40 Місяць тому

      @@AlphonsoTerrell facts idky they Made it like that

  • @lloyddillon4537
    @lloyddillon4537 Місяць тому

    Do you upgrade it yourself?How does it work

  • @smjr11
    @smjr11 Місяць тому

    How do i fix strong arm qb bug!?

  • @badalada1461
    @badalada1461 Місяць тому

    Do I need to start a new dynasty for the new updates?

  • @JonRitter-j8m
    @JonRitter-j8m Місяць тому

    I am in online dynasty and Tennessee won first two chips and I won last one as Aggies. He still is winning more 5 stars than me. Is this a championship thing or potential stats thing? I will be leading or tied on guys and he gets a big boost after scouting and offering week. Love your videos and I’m lost here.

  • @epicdroneimages1128
    @epicdroneimages1128 Місяць тому

    Question:
    If i have 60 hours to use on a player, is it better to use Hard sell, DM, and social media (55 hours) or
    Hard sell and a soft sell with 2 of 3 ✅ (60 hours)?

    • @rdoran85
      @rdoran85 Місяць тому +1

      The first option is the better choice. The penalty is heavier as of a few updates ago for a “wrong” hard or soft sell. I used to use the second option before they nerfed it.

    • @epicdroneimages1128
      @epicdroneimages1128 Місяць тому

      @ ah ok. I was unsure because i know the wrong soft sell penalty isn’t AS severe as hard sell, but didn’t know how severe vs using 15 hours instead

  • @PoodleGaming
    @PoodleGaming  Місяць тому

    Sign up now and get started using promo code [Poodle] to get up to $1,000 in bonus cash and to claim your free pick! t.co/OTigs6k4DW
    Follow me on Twitter for dynasty advice! x.com/poodle_yt?lang=

  • @adrianbelgrave4123
    @adrianbelgrave4123 Місяць тому

    I agree wholeheartedly on how quick the elite players go to the draft... I had alot of SO RBs leave early a few season ago... Great content 👊🏿

    • @PoodleGaming
      @PoodleGaming  Місяць тому +1

      Right, it’s awful lol. They build slow, then they aren’t useful. They build fast, then they leave.

  • @jackhealy5687
    @jackhealy5687 Місяць тому

    Is there still an issue with getting the most recently updated rosters in new dynasties?

    • @CKGolf77
      @CKGolf77 Місяць тому

      My shit messes up with that too

    • @moneymanhussein8445
      @moneymanhussein8445 Місяць тому

      Yea been a problem, if the abilities they gave a player doesn’t match their archetype they dont work in dynasty, ashton jeanty doesnt have any good abilities in dynasty they are so trash, they have him with receivers abilities not rb abilities

    • @CKGolf77
      @CKGolf77 Місяць тому

      @ oh shit that’s even worse than what’s going on for me. Even if I hit active roster it still uploads the default one when the game came out.

  • @Extendinq
    @Extendinq Місяць тому

    how can I get this excel spreadsheet I feel like i’m wasting my time with half of these recruits sometimes

  • @trillazzaj
    @trillazzaj Місяць тому +1

    Aye P, it’s some lost archetypes in the system too. I had a ATH Scramber turn into a Strong Arm QB, couldn’t see ratings & he didn’t upgrade over the years. They’re changing something fahsho

  • @OmgItsRickyy
    @OmgItsRickyy Місяць тому

    Oh yeah I meant to tell you I love the reycons bro thanks

  • @taylorbaker47
    @taylorbaker47 Місяць тому +1

    Damn uploaded 30 seconds ago gang gang

  • @mitchellreece9820
    @mitchellreece9820 Місяць тому +3

    Ea can't stop getting in its own way. Always messing something up.

  • @Jake.E75
    @Jake.E75 Місяць тому +2

    So with this update, its more worth it to re roll perks. Is there any players we shouldn't re roll besides QBs and NIL players?
    Something ive also noticed is that when the game first came out, players you forced to transfer would show up on other teams, has that changed as well?
    Thanks for the video! Very helpful.

    • @adrianbelgrave4123
      @adrianbelgrave4123 Місяць тому

      @@Jake.E75 I haven't noticed that lately... But in the couple seasons I have

  • @KaiWolfe-l6b
    @KaiWolfe-l6b Місяць тому

    Love the spreadsheet. This is all just from research you and your couple of subs have compiled then? EA never released this information right?

    • @PoodleGaming
      @PoodleGaming  Місяць тому

      This is information that subs have shared with me. Doing their own independent testing.

  • @Keno-ss6ht
    @Keno-ss6ht Місяць тому +2

    Is it me or all the top players are caucasian I’m just saying I mean 5 ⭐️top rb white I’m not sayin it’s not unrealistic but cb all top 10 wr just curious

    • @moneymanhussein8445
      @moneymanhussein8445 Місяць тому +3

      😂i dont even recruit them for realism, im not about to have team full of white rb and wr at LSU

    • @Keno-ss6ht
      @Keno-ss6ht Місяць тому

      @ man I’m glad someone see it too thank you fam !! I mean I’m not saying …. But bro it looks funny I’m not saying there aren’t top white rb or corners or wr but if you go look pro and college keep it 100 unless you BYU NORTH IDAHO STATE IDK

  • @hafestos
    @hafestos Місяць тому +2

    Did they or did you just want to make a vid? Without watching, but basing off past videos, you’re making assumptions with no actual proof right?

    • @CAPAE
      @CAPAE Місяць тому +1

      I can confirm this is the case. The charting goes back to before the update with the change.

  • @willfordham7180
    @willfordham7180 Місяць тому

    What's the name of the sing in the background

    • @PoodleGaming
      @PoodleGaming  Місяць тому +1

      Drunk face - machine gun Kelly

  • @wrkid2
    @wrkid2 Місяць тому

    #1 overall recruits should be better and in real life there are always freshmen who come in ready to go day 1

    • @PoodleGaming
      @PoodleGaming  Місяць тому

      I agree, there should be more elite players day 1

  • @JayWallEnt
    @JayWallEnt Місяць тому

    I’m new to dynasty.. so wait a second, can I go to that screen you were on in the beginning in to my players stats and upgrade them manually? Or does it just do it by xp earned with the player?

    • @PoodleGaming
      @PoodleGaming  Місяць тому

      They upgrade themselves on their own using the XP they accrue.

  • @homestarrunner919
    @homestarrunner919 Місяць тому

    I'm pretty sure you can put this on manual but it would be a lot to do each week if you wanted to do that.

  • @Thump411
    @Thump411 Місяць тому +1

    I can’t believe it took 10 plus years for a new game and some how NCAA 14 is way better

  • @johnnymo350
    @johnnymo350 Місяць тому +1

    The other issue is that elite prospects don’t feel elite. EVERYONE gets redshirted. That just doesn’t happen in today’s college football. The best prospects play right from the jump, or they transfer. Can’t wait for dynamic transfer dealbreakers. They should all develop multiple of these so you can’t just redshirt everyone.

    • @PoodleGaming
      @PoodleGaming  Місяць тому

      I agree with this, I was saying this in my video this week. I think they need make deal breakers more impactful, make some freshman day 1 starter types

  • @moneymanhussein8445
    @moneymanhussein8445 Місяць тому

    They keep ruining the game since release, gameplay was better in july

    • @PoodleGaming
      @PoodleGaming  Місяць тому

      I do appreciate that they are making changes though

  • @JoeySmith101
    @JoeySmith101 Місяць тому

    Sup Poodle?

  • @biggross75
    @biggross75 Місяць тому +1

    Game has gotten way worse as they tweaked it.

  • @xTBrown13x
    @xTBrown13x Місяць тому

    Recruiting is so bad i hope they totally revamp that crap before next game

    • @Fortnite-jx8de
      @Fortnite-jx8de Місяць тому +1

      I like the concept a lot, but the system just seems too buggy and inconsistent

    • @xTBrown13x
      @xTBrown13x Місяць тому +1

      @ I just want more straightforwardness. If I’m on a 20 game win streak I should have the interest of almost every top level recruit. If I’m winning natty after natty, I should have the pick of the litter. Like you said, it’s just too buggy

  • @louballs77
    @louballs77 Місяць тому +3

    hard disagree with you, you want it to be easier? game is way too easy to recruit and build

    • @andrewoberg
      @andrewoberg Місяць тому

      needs to be harder absolutely, but it also needs to make more sense
      edit: why is this clown talking about the meta? mf wants all 99s i disagree too🤣🤣