Hi gentlemen, I have been watching your videos for quite some time. They are really worth watching. Of course I have been reading the Qur'an too, but what I understand from that is total violence, hatred, sex and so on as against the good deeds of Muhammad told by my muslim friends. What actually astonishes me is that even the self proclaimed islamic scholars in India don't try to go through those records or watch videos of people like you. Hats off to you both
I'm rather surprised to learn that Bedouin dialects were spoken so far north. I thought they came from the central Arabian area. I'm particularly interested in the linguistic study of the Qur'an because my speciality is in textual analysis (Greek, Latin, etc). I hope we are going to get more information later on this topic. Best wishes to all involved in this research.
This is nothing new what Jay is saying.. he just making into drama. Quran means Recitation.. means you listen then read... The book form is called Mushaf.. even now I can write Quran in Roman Arabic form..the main thing is its original meaning is never changed.
Sabaic Arabic is a writing form, But Arab of that time were good at Oral communication and with very good meomry very few can write... Most of the Quran was recited at the time of Muhammad PBUH and it was at the time of Abu Bakr RA the first Khalifa it was decided to write it down as a book form as Islam was spreading outside Arab too and many people who memorize the Quran was killed in wars...
@@sower9973 if you saying that because of watching others then there is no point, you need to do your own research. But it is your opinion so everyone have right to have their opinion.
What a delightful presentation! Brilliant. The northern origins idea is getting stronger by the day. It is my understanding (and I stand corrected as I haven't read Durie's book yet) that the Sabaic script has unique letters, very much like the Ethiopic script, and doesn't need diacritical marks at all to distinguish letter or sounds. Is that right or did it have a dotting system too?
The markings were added later on in the Ethiopic script. I'm not sure if the same happened with the Sabaic script; wikipedia says they didn't have a way of marking vowels Edit: looks like they had a matres lectionis system, so he might be referring to that
I find it very odd that on every every Christian apologetic UA-cam channel before you can watch a video an Islamic infomercial comes on. I go to Islamic apologist channel and this never happens. I wonder if David, Sam, Christian prince or CIRA know this is going on. It’s definitely something to look into.
How to respond to muslims who say that Jesus is not the son of God and that Muhammad is greater than HIM. Here are the answers from the koran and Islamic sources itself proving that Jesus is not only greater than Muhammad but also the Son of God. Jesus was born of a virgin-koran 3:47 and 66:12- Surah Maryam Muhammad was not Jesus performed miracles- koran 2:87 Muhammad did not Jesus was taken up to heaven - koran 4:157-158 Muhammad was not Jesus will return at the end of time- Surat al-imran Muhammad will not
Like CP shares...it had lots of contradiction so its not the word of God, cut and paste book. Q.An Nissa 4:157-158 confirm the BIBLE (taurat and Injil).
Didn't you earlier claim Islam's beginning were in Petra? It seems like the stuff you're referring to now as being not Mecca is around the Petra area you mentioned in a previous video
If all men are born with sin because of Adam and Eve. Then why would Jesus be sinless, yet he was "son of man". These are his exact words. What you call him is immaterial! Next, the bible says no child will carry the sins of his parents. Isn't it a contradiction? Why do you want us to carry Adam's? There's nothing like an original sin. This was a philosophy that was being made to justify the crucifixion of Jesus. But, was Jesus crucified? Nope. Unless you don't believe that Jesus was the messiah prophesied in psalms. Read these: Quoting Jesus himself: "For these are the words which were written in the prophets (psalms and Isaiah) that must be fulfilled - "I will not die but live, for in the time of trouble, God will hide me, for you have not required sin offering"! Psalms 118:17-25, Psalms 71:2-4, psalms 40:6, psalms 138:7, psalms 20:6, psalms 28:8, psalms 27:5-6, psalms 41:1-2, Luke 24:44, and the Qur'an 4:157-158. Now, if you want to continue believing that the "Roman Jesus" died for you, that's your problem. Even in Luke 24:44, Jesus is affirming want is in the Torah, that God will hide him and that he will not die! So this guy left Islam to go worship idols! Was it poverty or the devil is also working very hard? Bro. Islam will remain a true religion of God. Read these bible verses: Deuteronomy 21:22-23, Exodus 20:3, Matthew 4:10, Luke 4:8, Leviticus 26:1, Ezekiel 23:30, 38:18, 33:25, Ezekiel 14:3, Ezekiel 14:4, Jeremiah 1:16, Isaiah 2:8. Even though Catholics deny that they don't worship the idols, but they are often seen kneeling before them - taking them to be earthly representation of Mary and Jesus. Now, i believe this guy is sick! He once claimed he was Muslim, but wants nothing to do with Islam. But, he is forever adorning Muslim attires! The brain was corrupted to leave Islam, but the heart/soul still admires Islam. Brother run away very fast! Christianity was not even the religion of christ. It is a corrupted version of Judaism, tailoredbto meet the needs of Romans. The reason Romans were prepared to kill early Christians, and eyewitness disciples of Jesus so that that they overhaul Jesus' teachings! Ask yourself these questions: 1. Was Jesus unaware of what he was teaching when he was on earth? Why would he teach different things while on earth, then go away and send Paul to come contradict all his (Jesus') teachings? 2. In view of 1. Which "Jesus" appeared to Paul? You and i know that the world is waiting for Jesus ' "second coming", not "third coming"! 3. Why would Jesus make Paul blind in order to talk to him? In order to give him instructions? Jesus never made anyone blind when he was on earth, and even when he appeared to his disciples after the alleged crucifixion. Who exactly appeared to Paul? Is it possible that Satan assumed Jesus' appearance and then made him blind in order not to be recognised? How comes Paul's teachings are contradicting Christ, if it's Christ who sent him? 4. How comes those who accompanied Paul never saw Jesus when he allegedly appeared to Paul? They only heard the voice. The bible is even contradicting itself on this. Read these verses, and decide for yourself which is "more" manmade! The bible is replete with cases of killings, rape, mass murders, forced slavery - allegedly under the instructions of the "Jewish God". Read these verses: Numbers 31:7-18, Chronicles 21:14-15, Isaiah 13:16, Zachariah 14:2, Lamentations 5:11. In the case of Numbers 31:7-18; How do you (as a man), tell that a 3 year or a 9 year old girl is a virgin? By sleeping with her, against her will - right? If this is not rape, what is it? And the worst bit is, the instruction came from the "Hebrew God". The same God allegedly ordered them to kill infants as young as 1 month. Think about it! And this is how you portray God - as a vengeful, irrational, merciless, etc or the bible was intentionally manipulated to be used to commit genocide against other races! In the bible, there are over 1,000 contradictions. Here are some of them: 1. What did Judas iscariot do with the money he was paid after betraying Jesus? There are two different accounts in the bible! Logically, one is not true! 2. How was Jesus crucified? Definitely, not on a cross. The Jews never used to crucify people on a cross. It was not known to them then. Then, where did the cross come from? Or how many times was Jesus crucified? Read Deuteronomy 21:22-23. 3. How old was Jesus when he died? The bible is deliberately scanty on Jesus life and lifestyle while on earth. Despite having lived on earth for 33 years, he is being portrayed as having lived for 1 month. During the 33 years period, Jesus did everything any mortal did, including sleeping and waking up regularly, playing as a kid on a regular basis. And when he reached maturity, he was circumcised according to Jewish culture- and by a man! Early Christianity did not regard Jesus as God. It was in 400 AD when a Roman empiror (Constantine), who was not in the list of prophets/was not an appostle of God comanded that Jesus must be regarded as a God/Son of God. The Ebionites and nazarenes objected, but were killed in large numbers till the narative stuck. In fact, prior to that, trinity was not even known. 4. According to God's plan, He only intended to use Mary as the one who will bring Jesus on earth. Thereafter, Mary was to go on with her life. She was later married by Joseph and together they were blessed wiyh other children (daughters and sons). Now Mary was mother of Christ/God! Why are you embarrassed to say, "brothers and sisters of "God"? Why are you embarrassed to call Joseph, step father of "God"? You're even shy to recognize Jesus' dibblings in the bible. They too, played their part. 5. The bible portrayed Jesus kneeling down severally and praying to God! Which God was he worshipping? Was he worshipping himself? If he was worshipping himself, how comes at calvary he prayed till "his sweat turned to blood", and still he refused to honour his own prayer? Was her merely acting? I mean, he sent himself to come and die for humanity. Why was he praying asking "himself " to have "mercy on himself" and remove the cup? 6. If Jesus was God, how comes at calvary he asked Peter and another disciple (must be Andrew), to keep vigil as he prayed? You mean your God is not omnipresent? You have a lot to deal with! Stop misinterpreting the hadiths, and Quran to misinform "some muslims" and to exite fellow christians!
Thanks guys for educating all of us on Islam things that Muslims don’t even know.. God bless you guys and the sacrifices that you make everyday exposing Islam.. Glory to God 🙏🏼
Lol they are hilarious they aren’t educating anyone, I learned this from the past! Obviously the quran is in Arabic. Just wish Joseph smith would not about saying Muslims never knew this 🤣
@@marriannawhaleymartin5929 really ? Lol. What do you mean why I don’t tell anyone! Everyone knows this. Obviously fadi and his buddies want to make it seem something else! Then why don’t you tell your people that Jesus real language was Aramaic and that you don’t have the original gospels like the quran! Why are the gospels translated in Greek. It’s that simple love
@@marriannawhaleymartin5929 everyone knows that the Arabic quran is obviously sabaean Arabic which is the quraish Arabic dialect! The vowels you see in the quran is so those who don’t understand Arabic without its vowels can read it properly. No problemo . God bless you
Very very serious question about Quran ? In this video!! All dawa gang are hiding!! Watch this video !!! Where is your Quran came!! By who!!!? Which language original Quran? Muslims you cannot scape!! Must answer!!
At 5:17, saying "ha theos" makes no sense. That is using the Hebrew article with the Greek word for "God". But I know what he means. He means "ho theos" which is the Greek article and the Greek word for "God". I think he meant to say "ho logos" which is "the word" in John 1:1. Bringing up the article (or lack thereof) in relation to "theos" in John 1:1 actually opens up a can of worms.
Ho theos is Greek, not Hebrew....I get what you meant, that just bugged me lol. Really interesting video though, especially since many Muslims place a heavy emphasis on "the original language and dialect" of the Quran. I'm curious to see what their take on this is.
I wish you all would write a book on all this, expounding on some of the terms you use. The basic terms ( readers etc). I’m sure there is much you all had to leave out because of time. Thanks for sharing what you have learned.
so yesus did not died in crucifixion IS A WRONG STATEMENT Jesus said it ahead of time that He is going to be KILLED AND HIS BURIAL IN ADVANCED .. Luke 9:22 "The Son of Man must suffer many things," He said. "He must be rejected by the elders, chief priests, and scribes, and He must be KILLED and on the third day be raised to life." John 12:7 "Leave her alone," Jesus replied. "It was intended that she should save this perfume for the day of my burial. JESUS DIED OF LOSS OF BLOOD AND WATER DEHYDRATION John 19:34 Instead, one of the soldiers pierced His side with a spear, and immediately blood and water flowed out. John 19:33 33But when they came to Jesus and saw that He was already DEAD, they did not break His legs. JESUS COMING FROM HIS MOUTH SAID THAT HE DIED.. REVELATION 1:17,18 ....“Do not be afraid; I am the First and the Last. 18 I am He who lives, and was DEAD, and behold, I am alive forevermore. Amen. And I have the keys of Hades and of Death. Hebrews 2:9 But we do see Jesus, who was made lower than the angels for a little while, now crowned with glory and honor because he suffered DEATH, so that by the grace of God he might taste DEATH for everyone. Yes, it was God the Father who ultimately brought His Son to Calvary, but His Son went their voluntarily. The Son of God willingly agreed to die on the cross for the salvation of those whom God had chosen from eternity past (Eph. 1:4-5). “Greater love has no one than this, that someone lay down his life for his friends” (John 15:13). Oh, what a love! Jesus lay down his life for us, so that we might live with Him forever. My fellow believers in Christ, if you ever doubt whether Jesus loves you or not, look back to Calvary and survey the wondrous cross, and don’t stop surveying it until you exclaim, He spread His arms from right to left, that's how much He loves you.,... Romans 8:9 But you are not controlled by your sinful nature. You are controlled by the Spirit if you have the Spirit of God living in you. (And remember that those who do not have the Spirit of Christ living in them do not belong to him at all.)
@@9999rosebud There are many books from 1st untill 3rd century wrote Jesus did not die on the cross found in AG Hamadi library in 1948 The revelation of Peter The Act of John The chronicle of Great Second Seth Gospel of Judas
@@MrXucinxgaronx Jesus said that He is going to get killed coming from His mouth and He also said that He DIED coming from His mouth.. Jesus said,.. “I am the good shepherd…and I lay down my life for the sheep…I lay down my life that I may take it up again. No one takes it from me, but I lay it down of my own accord. I have authority to lay it down, and I have authority to take it up again” (John 10:14-18). Jesus said that He is the TRUTH John 14:6 Jesus answered, "I am the way and the TRUTH and the life. No one comes to the Father except through me. So, who crucified Jesus? Who crushed him to death? His Father did! Listen to Prophet Isaiah, Surely he has borne our griefs and carried our sorrows; yet we esteemed him stricken, smitten by God, and afflicted. But he was pierced for our transgressions; he was crushed for our iniquities…. Yet it was the will of the Lord [Father] to crush him (Isa. 53:4-5, 10). “Do you really believe that it was God who killed His own Son?” “Yes”. “Why would God do that to His Son?” “He did not spare His Son, so that He could spare you. God loves you more than His Son it is because God don't want you to die a second death which is separation from Him for 'ETERNITY' received His free gift which is His Son and you will have Eternal Life with Him”.. That is the message of the cross..
@@ownpetard8379 U r right. Even today we have Jew leaders in Iran ,Afghanistan ,Pakistan and Islam karimov former president of Uzbekstan. Imran Khan (pak),Mahmoud Ahmadi nejad (iran) and Ashraf Ghani (Afghanistan) are exapls to be Jew. Even khamaini I guess.
8:50...actually its "Where's Waldo?"..🤷🏻♂️ ..Dr. Jay seems to deeply knowledgable and authoritative at times....but I keep getting thrown off when he keeps making confusing minor errors- i.e. 5:18 John1:1 "ho Theon"/"ηο Θεον" is Greek- not Hebrew (but yes it is an example of definite article).... 6:28 Originally "Nabatean Aramaic" was not even an Arabic dialect...it did apparently "evolve" into Nabatean Arabic when native Arab speakers began utilizing it about 2 centuries before Mahomet, it eventually merged into Arabic from the replacing the original Aramaic vocabulary with Arabic words...apparently it is now called "Nabatean Arabic"...apparently it is believed Arabic script evolved not from Sabaic Script, but rather Nabatean Aramaic script....🗣👳🏾♂️🐪🌴🏝🏜...
In the 2nd minute, Jay Smith mentions a book by Ahmad Al-Jallad, a scholar researching the history of the Arabic language, strongly implying that Al-Jallad's book supports the comments that he subsequently makes about northern version of Arabic in which the Qur'an in written. I have a few questions which would provide a considerable amount of clarity to the claims being made in the video, which I am not disputing. What is the name of this book by Al-Jallad? Does this author make any comments in the book that explicitly support Smith's claim that the Qur'an was written in the northern I'rab Arabic rather than the Sabaic Arabic which one would expect that Qur'an to have been written? If the answer is No, which is what I expect, can either of the speakers in this video reply to this comment and give a citation and quotation from the book which they believe supports the comments they make about the northern origin of the Qur'anic text? Peter Clemerson
Fascinating. Have you seen these 2 presentations ? "Did the Early Muslim Empire have a Language Policy?" by Dr. Petra Sijpesteijn ua-cam.com/video/Da9D1BwJMgY/v-deo.html and Dr. Ahmad Al-Jallad The Rise of Arabic: From an epic past to an evidence-based history “ua-cam.com/video/dHRbuu8c8nw/v-deo.html
Christianity Is Not The Religion Of Jesus , Jesus And His Mother Were Nasara Muslim , Jesus And His Mother Mary Worship The Only One True God , Jesus Was 2nd Adam And A Prophet Of God . God Bless All Of Us . Amin .
What watch, there are lying to you, they want to change the history of Islam, language of Quran, they want to erase everything about Islam, but the only one listening and believe is you Christians audience 😂😂😂😂
Explained and showed: Dear Dr. Jay Smith, thank you very much for the clearification, which was told the same by Professor to me to change last name to have better future in 2016 in New Zealand. It opened new doors, changed my personality. I changed my last name from DADAMUKHAMEDOV (GRANDFATHER MUKHAMMAD) to AZIMOV. It impacted my acceptance to the western world with good intention.
"What’s more, he suggests that many of the Qur’ānic variants coexisted during the time of the prophet just as variants in ancient poetry coex-isted during the lifetime of the poets and rawī-s who lived in an oral-transmission environment (p. 232). Nasser concludes that the mysterious tradition of sab`at aḥruf (in its broader sense encompassing the Qur’ānic qirā’āt) was probably a consequence of the failure of the codification process by ‘Uthmān, which was not able to produce a single unified Reading of the Qur’ān. Thus, the variant readings kept multi-plying exponentially until Ibn Mujāhid, when their number became limited again." Marcin Grodzki on Shady Nasser's critique of the variant qiraats of the Quran Jay Smith name drops Shady Nasser a lot but blows the discussion out or proportion just to prove his ridiculous claims. The Arabs were an oral people and only a select few could read and write. Therefore there are multitude of pronouciations. You travel anywhere in a specific country and its people will have their own dialects to the SAME language. This is the reason Uthman codified the Quranic text and scholars such as Ibn Mujahid set the pronunciations later on after Prophet Muhammad. To PRESERVE the Quran and its intended meaning as Islam was expanding outside the Arab lands and reaching non Arabs. The meaning of the Quran is unchanged and the book we have today is preserved as how it was revealed. Fun fact: Qur'an in Arabic comes from the root word qara'a yaqra'u (verb: reading or recitation). It is recited and spoken. Its not a "Book". Even the Qur'an that we hold today is actually not the Quran and rather more accurate called Mushaf (compiled texts/scripture)
With respect Mr. Sabri: you make some very valid points which I agree poke some holes in Smith's view. However, so much research seems to be coming to light indicating that Muhammed may actually have been from Petra in Jordan and that seems compelling to me. Wouldn't that be important to know? Many native people maintain traditional stories from much, much farther back than a couple hundred years, with sacred storytellers who have been charged with passing down these stories with the utmost reverence. So I have little doubt there is much truth in the Qur'an. I'm just less sure of it's origin. Similar arguments are made about the Christian Bible by Muslims that I also think miss this point. May we people of the book debate these questions earnestly, as indeed the nature of God is vital to understand. But may we do this as brothers and sisters, not enemies sneering at one another. I'm convinced that the problem is much less the differences between how truth seekers understand God and those who don't even acknowledge God exists or care about the impact of their actions on others.) May you be blessed today.
@@aedaldaniel - as are you. And so thoughtful. I sincerely apologize for the rudeness and arrogance of too many Americans (like Jay Smith.) He fails to mention that the exact same criticisms he levels against the Q'uran have also been made against the Christian Bible. Seems to me that what's important is what these holy books teach is about how to live our lives in a way that honors our Creator. I have much to learn from Islam. As - salumu alaikum my brother.
Hebrew was the language of the scholars and the scriptures. But Prophet Jesus's (peace be upon him) "everyday" spoken language would have been Aramaic. And it is Aramaic that most biblical scholars say he spoke in the Bible. What is the Aramaic term that Jesus (peace be upon him) used for God? The Aramaic word for God is "Alaha"/"Aloho", which is related to the Hebrew word "elohim". In the version of Jesus's (peace be upon him) last words found in gMark and gMatt this word is transliterated into a Greek form as "Eloi", so Jesus (peace be upon him) is depicted as using this word for God in his native language in his last cry before dying. Jesus (peace be upon him) was praying not crying. Just put yourself in Jesus's (peace be upon him) place and think logically NOT emotionally. I bet you would've prayed as well NOT cried. Now does Allah like Muhammad (peace be upon him) said and Alaha"/"Aloho like Jesus (peace be upon him) said when he was praying to God as he was about to be crucified not sound the same? They're praying to the same God because there is only one God and Jesus, Moses, Ibraham, Joseph, Solomon, David, and Mohammed (peace be upon all of them) are His Prophets to humans and they all came with same message from the same One and only God! I'm only asking everyone to take the extra mile and fact check these 2 ignorant men! Peace and love to all of y'all ✌🏿
About the Holy Quran, what's wrong is only in terms of english translation and syntax in writing of the one who wrote the messages dictateed by Jibreel...please reflect and pray...
Languages of pre-Islamic Arabia To show how at loss the Islamic-era Arabic literary evidence can sometimes be, one needs only to consider the linguistic situation of pre-Islamic Arabia (on which see Macdonald 2000 and Al-Jallad 2015: 1-25). The Muslim authors did not have an understanding of the variety of languages in the pre-Islamic era, claiming that most of the inhabitants of Arabia were Arabic-speaking (Rabin 1951), whereas in historical reality Arabia was home to speakers and writers of forms of North Arabian (including but not restricted to Arabic), South Arabian, Aramaic (Nabataean, Syriac) and, to lesser extent, Hebrew, Ge’ez, Persian, Greek, and Latin.4 In the Islamic tradition, not only Arabians but also major characters of the monotheist tradition such as Ismail speak Arabic (al-Masʿūdī, Murūj: II, 162). Furthermore, later Arabic writers had little grasp that the South Arabians did not see themselves as and could not be called Arabs in the pre-Islamic era. The Muslim authors see Yemen as the original home of the Arabs and Arabic language - an idea of which we do not have much evidence and that is most likely incorrect. To this is connected another myth, namely that the Arab tribes are divided to two section: al-ʿarab al-ʿāriba, ”True Arabic-speaking Arabs,” and al-ʿarab al-mustaʿriba, “Arabized Arabs.” The ʿarab al-ʿāriba are deemed to be the Southern tribes and the ʿarab al-mustaʿriba Northern. But this is incorrect insofar that the Arabic language actually spread from the north to the south in the course of late antiquity, and not the other way around. The Islamic tradition pushes the importance of Yemen even further, for example claiming that the eponym of the Greeks, Yūnān, came from Yemen (al-Masʿūdī, Murūj: II, 5-6). All of this probably reflects Islamic-era, post-conquest tendency of Yemenite Muslims to emphasize their significance but this needs further research (for some notes see Bashear 1989). In the Muslim sources, the development and rise of the Arabic script is said to have happened in the Ḥijāz, al-Anbār, or al-Ḥīra (e.g., al-Hamdānī, Iklīl: I, 77-79). The suggestion of al-Ḥīra is interesting, since it was the capital of the Lakhmids (see below) and, indeed, the first text that is written completely in Arabic is the Namara inscription dated to 328 CE; it is a funerary text for Marʾ al-Qays ibn ʿAmr, who is usually identified with a Lakhmid king of that name (Bellamy 1985). The script is a late variant of Nabataean, of which the Arabic script developed during the following centuries (Gruendler 1993). However, the Namara inscription is the only testimony for the Lakhmids’ ostensible written use of Arabic. As for the Ḥijāz, there is actually more evidence that the Arabic script evolved there. Based on epigraphy, the rise of the Arabic script seems to be more directly related with the longevity of Nabataean Aramaic that was, according to new finds (Nehmé 2010), used in the western parts of the peninsula until the fifth century. The script of these inscriptions is Nabataean and the language is often a mixture of Aramaic and Arabic. In 2014, Frédéric Imbert and a French-Saudi team found a new Nabataean Aramaic- Arabic inscription dated 469-470 CE as south as Najrān, which sparked scholarly and media interest.4 The Old Arabic inscriptions of the sixth century (Zebed, Jabal Usays, Harran; see Macdonald 2008) seem to be continuation of this epigraphic habit of late Nabataean inscriptions, even if they have been found to the north of the Ḥijāz, in Syria. Writing on perishable material, if it existed, has not been preserved. reference: helda.helsinki.fi//bitstream/handle/10138/307521/Lindstedt_Early_Muslims_Pre_Islamic_Arabia_and_Pagans_.pdf?sequence=1
How these guy is broadcasting and evaluating openly..... Don't he got a threat from radical hardcore Islamist like dead threat of him and his family's.... Bravo.....with full dedication in jesus work...MGBU
This new evidence would place the prophet figure, if he existed, in northern Arabia, and the Quran as being created from users of that Arab lingual sub-area. (Sadly the warner/prophet of the Quran is unidentified as to his location and background in the Quran itself, an omission that is very fishy, as when giving such as account one would be keen to provide this, to prove that the message was genuine.) Mecca down on the western edge of the Arabian peninsula never made much sense. In one's studies of History and Geography even back at school age one knew that great empires are founded upon a large demographic bases, and that such population pools don't live in remote rocky and sandy desert locations - those are sparsely populated before modern times. The account of Islam spreading according to the SIN would require a massive and impressive conquest in less than 50 years after the death of the prophet figure, it simply couldn't be done from a small base. Pilgrims on Hajj and umra are actually visiting a "Mohammedland Hejaz".
Some one send the message here said where is Jesus said I'm equal with God worshiping me here is the verse, read the book of proverbs chapter 8 verses 22- 31 then tell poeple your stupidity of not understanding of the bible, bible is not Newspaper.
But you who are criticizing the language of the Quran do not understand the language yourself, and so on what basis is your criticism?? There are some of the vowels that you don't understand yourself unless it is explain to you by someone and yet you are shamefully criticizing the Arabic language.
The problem is that the Arabic words you claim are similar to Aramaic are more Hebrew rather than Aramaic words. Hebrew predates Aramaic and is from the period of the Akkadian and Sumerian languages. We learn this from the names of the Hebrew letters that symbolize pictures and not sounds. And only because the first linguists were antisemitic did not want to give Hebrew the proper credit.
I was told once that the original Arabic the Angel recited to Mohammud was like the Fire from Heaven! No book before or since was like that!I I was also told that attempts have been made to write artifical Korans but no human source has bee able to duplicate the Divine Fire of the Koran!
The Corpus of the 114 Surats informs us that there is a Tradition which claims to be an Apostolic Tradition yet rejects circumcision while the Apostles were all circumcised, didn't believe in Trinity, and had prescribed a dietary Law in Acts 15:22-34 which the said Tradition rejects. Is it not ironic! On the basis of those clues we can say for sure that: Qur'an is a codeword for Torah. The Reminder should be the proper Title for the corpus of 114 Surats. Islam means an Evangelical Party supposed to enforce the Torah as the Law of the land. Muhammad euphemism for Messiah Abu Quasim as an Arabian Evangelist who later became a Sovereign Ruler, Legislator...and took up Muhammad as a reign name. Unfortunately the "Muhammad" of the Palace and the "Mohammad" of the Shahada in the Mosque got blended together in the Tradition. If it is true that Abu Quasim signed off his formal treaties and official decrees as Muhammad as reported by Ibn Hisham, then this might explain how this present OPTICAL ILLUSION was perpetuated by those who were eager to capitalize on the Pilgrimage to Macca. It' s high time to differentiate the palace and the Mosque under the Messianic title Muhammad.
Oh man your critics are really not helping an Arabic speaker you are focusing in writing... Its really a theory that don't make any sense. Pleas go ask any arabic from Yemen or any arabic speaker "janah" will stay "janah"😅 you have to learn arabic to make the critic worthy. Don't look to writing the silab its always the same hope my point is clear
Keep digging, probably will misguide a few ignorant "muslims", however, those with knowledge and insight will find this video amusing.....everyone knows Arabs didn't write with vowels nor would have the companions, may God be pleased with them, used them while writing down the revelation, they were added in later to assist the non-native readers with their recitation. Side note: I was looking for the Bible of Jesus's companions (not the hearsay of some Greeks 60 years later but from those who walked with Jesus, peace be upon him) who wrote down his teachings as they happened in their original language, can anyone point me to that book? Maybe these scholars in the video can give me one.
hmmm...this set me thinking: Jesus spoke Aramaic, the original bible is in orthodox Greek, a majority of bible printed is in English, can you do a similar approach, linguistically speaking?
BHAGAVAD GITA is the worlds best scripture to date.Better by far than the Bible. I was a Reborn Christian converted to the honoring of Lord Krishna. See UA-cam CAESAR'S MESSIAH why Jesus is a farce.
The reason we are watching is because we searched for you. Now if you really want authorities to adhere to freedom of religion, you need to advertise the truth to all nations via other direct media to reach out to those whom are unaware of the truth.
FROM THE NEW TESTAMENT BOOK, IT IS EVIDENT THAT JESUS IS NOT GOD OF CHRISTIANS. JESUS DIDN'T KNOW ANYTHING ABOUT CHRISTIAN. THERE IS NO VERSE IN THE NEW TESTAMENT THAT PROVES THAT JESUS IS GOD OF CHRISTIANS. JESUS WAS NEVER SENT TO CHRISTIANS. THERE IS NO RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN JESUS AND CHRISTIANS. JESUS ONLY HAS A VERY CLEAR RELATIONSHIP WITH THE PEOPLE OF ISRAEL. MATTHEW 15: 24 But he answered and said, I am not sent but unto the lost sheep of the house of ISRAEL. JESUS WAS BORN TO BE A LEADER WHO WILL SHEPHERD THE PEOPLE OF ISRAEL, NOT SHEPHERD CHRISTIANS. MATTHEW 2: 6 And thou Bethlehem, in the land of Juda, art not the least among the princes of Juda: for out of thee shall come a Governor, that shall rule my people ISRAEL. JESUS ONLY INTERACTED WITH ISRAELITES, JESUS NEVER INTERACTED WITH CHRISTIANS. MARK 12: 29 And Jesus answered him, The first of all the commandments, Hear, O ISRAEL, The Lord our God is one Lord. JESUS IS THE SAVIOUR OF THE PEOPLE OF ISRAEL. JESUS IS NOT THE SAVIOUR OF CHRISTIANS. THERE IS NO VERSE IN THE NEW TESTAMENT THAT STATES THAT JESUS IS THE SAVIOUR OF CHRISTIANS. ACTS 13: 23 Of this man's seed hath God according to his promise raised unto ISRAEL A SAVIOUR, JESUS JESUS BE PRAYED AS KING OF ISRAEL, NOT AS KING OF CHRISTIANS. JOHN 12: 13 Took branches of palm trees, and went forth to meet him, and cried, Hosanna: Blessed is the King of ISRAEL that cometh in the name of the Lord. JESUS COMMANDED THE WORSHIP OF GOD, JESUS NEVER COMMANDED WORSHIP OF JESUS. MATTHEW 4: 10 Then saith Jesus unto him, Get thee hence, Satan: for it is written, Thou shalt worship the Lord thy God, and him only shalt thou serve. JESUS COMMANDED TO THE FOLLOW JESUS, JESUS NEVER COMMANDED WORSHIP OF JESUS. JOHN 8: 12 Then spake Jesus again unto them, saying, I am the light of the world: he that FOLLOWETH me shall not walk in darkness, but shall have the light of life. IN THE NEW TESTAMENT BOOK, JESUS ONLY INTERACTED WITH ISRAELITES. JESUS NEVER INTERACTED WITH CHRISTIANS. THERE ARE NO STORIES ABOUT CHRISTIANITY IN THE NEW TESTAMENT. SO, IT IS IMPOSSIBLE FOR JESUS IS THE GOD OF CHRISTIANS. THIS IS A FACT, NOT HOAX. TO PROVE IT, READ THE NEW TESTAMENT BOOKS FROM MATTHEW TO REVELATION WITH COMMON SENSE.
Growing up as muslim in Muscat Oman, the hardest thing for me was to accept everything without asking any questions.
They just t3lk lies and mistaken informations
I hope you have left that life.
This has been an exciting series, keep going guys!
i thank God I left Islam last year 😔😔😔😔 I had feeling about that half moon and star symbol of Islam ,and it turns out to be hubaal religion
look at this fool thinking the moon and star are the symbol for islam i have never ever in my life heard such a dumb thing
Alhamdulillah I accepted Islam and left the polytheism of Christianity. Islam has no symbol the moon and the star is a Seljuk innovation.
Hi gentlemen, I have been watching your videos for quite some time. They are really worth watching. Of course I have been reading the Qur'an too, but what I understand from that is total violence, hatred, sex and so on as against the good deeds of Muhammad told by my muslim friends. What actually astonishes me is that even the self proclaimed islamic scholars in India don't try to go through those records or watch videos of people like you. Hats off to you both
Hi Fadi ,it's always a pleasure to have you,♥️👍♥️
Before Becoming A Hindu, Muslim, Christian, Sikhi Or Buddhist, Be Human First! There Will Be Peace!
I'm rather surprised to learn that Bedouin dialects were spoken so far north. I thought they came from the central Arabian area. I'm particularly interested in the linguistic study of the Qur'an because my speciality is in textual analysis (Greek, Latin, etc). I hope we are going to get more information later on this topic. Best wishes to all involved in this research.
Thank you Fadi n Jay for your discoveries and analysis. Lot to learn from you.🙏
This isn’t any discovery! Nothing new. Muslims knew this but Joseph smith is making it into something else
This is nothing new what Jay is saying.. he just making into drama.
Quran means Recitation.. means you listen then read...
The book form is called Mushaf.. even now I can write Quran in Roman Arabic form..the main thing is its original meaning is never changed.
Sabaic Arabic is a writing form, But Arab of that time were good at Oral communication and with very good meomry very few can write...
Most of the Quran was recited at the time of Muhammad PBUH and it was at the time of Abu Bakr RA the first Khalifa it was decided to write it down as a book form as Islam was spreading outside Arab too and many people who memorize the Quran was killed in wars...
Quran and Islam = deception by satan.👹👿
@@sower9973 if you saying that because of watching others then there is no point, you need to do your own research.
But it is your opinion so everyone have right to have their opinion.
The God of Israel is a God of perfection not chaos!!!!!!! Amen!
God Bless guys!!!
From the Philippines
- Great work on Qur'an language's origen.
Presented shade of light on the side of truth.God bless both of You.
Another great video gentleman 😉
What a delightful presentation! Brilliant. The northern origins idea is getting stronger by the day. It is my understanding (and I stand corrected as I haven't read Durie's book yet) that the Sabaic script has unique letters, very much like the Ethiopic script, and doesn't need diacritical marks at all to distinguish letter or sounds. Is that right or did it have a dotting system too?
Go to UA-cam f'or a real bombshell: See CAESAR'S MESSIAH. SPREAD THE WORD TO EVERY CHRISTIAN AND MUSLIM ALIKE.
The markings were added later on in the Ethiopic script. I'm not sure if the same happened with the Sabaic script; wikipedia says they didn't have a way of marking vowels
Edit: looks like they had a matres lectionis system, so he might be referring to that
Gr8 insight or Truth and good information. Thanks
The print is too small to read. I think I would 'enjoy' reading 2or3 of your books.
There is absolutely no surprise guys. As a rule of thumb every right thing is misappropriated in the wrong hands. Keep it up !
@@cp-christianporn5848
Sheik Wasim Yousef; "Imams are hiding Muhammad's dark history from Muslims so they don't leave Islam."
Have big respect for you Fadi. God bless you both 🙏🇦🇺
Jay misspoke about halfway through when he spoke in Greek from John and called it Hebrew, in case anyone was confused.
I find it very odd that on every every Christian apologetic UA-cam channel before you can watch a video an Islamic infomercial comes on. I go to Islamic apologist channel and this never happens. I wonder if David, Sam, Christian prince or CIRA know this is going on. It’s definitely something to look into.
I GET Hebrew Israel adverts
The ADS are customised to your views, so probs you watch a lot of stuff with Islam in
@H K Phooey thanks
@@GedaliahAR thank you for your input but I watch more sports and preachers than I do anything and I don’t get any adversitment for them.
How to respond to muslims who say that Jesus is not the son of God and that Muhammad is greater than HIM. Here are the answers from the koran and Islamic sources itself proving that Jesus is not only greater than Muhammad but also the Son of God.
Jesus was born of a virgin-koran 3:47 and 66:12- Surah Maryam
Muhammad was not
Jesus performed miracles- koran 2:87
Muhammad did not
Jesus was taken up to heaven - koran 4:157-158
Muhammad was not
Jesus will return at the end of time- Surat al-imran
Muhammad will not
Jesus(PBUH) is the greatest of all prophets and messengers.Followers of Jesus(PBUH) and Christians are saved from Hell 🔥
yup, and dont forget this verses too.
QS 5:72-73
QS 5:166-117
QS 19:30-36
Like CP shares...it had lots of contradiction so its not the word of God, cut and paste book.
Q.An Nissa 4:157-158 confirm the BIBLE (taurat and Injil).
Didn't you earlier claim Islam's beginning were in Petra? It seems like the stuff you're referring to now as being not Mecca is around the Petra area you mentioned in a previous video
This proves that maybe the Romans did help create the Quran ....the Romans were in the North and not in Mecca...love from an ex Muslim
They were around at that time.
@Isaac59 Are you a muslim?
@Isaac59 So you are a Muslim? Question, Does allah love You?
ua-cam.com/video/qpIaMYPmafA/v-deo.html
@Isaac59 That last thing is unknown to me.
Al Fadi we keep praying for you not to be afraid with the word and to keep going!
5:18 Oh dear what a howler! 'Ho' is the *Hebrew* definite article like 'ho theos' in John?!!
If all men are born with sin because of Adam and Eve. Then why would Jesus be sinless, yet he was "son of man". These are his exact words. What you call him is immaterial!
Next, the bible says no child will carry the sins of his parents. Isn't it a contradiction? Why do you want us to carry Adam's?
There's nothing like an original sin. This was a philosophy that was being made to justify the crucifixion of Jesus.
But, was Jesus crucified? Nope. Unless you don't believe that Jesus was the messiah prophesied in psalms.
Read these:
Quoting Jesus himself:
"For these are the words which were written in the prophets (psalms and Isaiah) that must be fulfilled - "I will not die but live, for in the time of trouble, God will hide me, for you have not required sin offering"!
Psalms 118:17-25, Psalms 71:2-4, psalms 40:6, psalms 138:7, psalms 20:6, psalms 28:8, psalms 27:5-6, psalms 41:1-2, Luke 24:44, and the Qur'an 4:157-158.
Now, if you want to continue believing that the "Roman Jesus" died for you, that's your problem.
Even in Luke 24:44, Jesus is affirming want is in the Torah, that God will hide him and that he will not die!
So this guy left Islam to go worship idols! Was it poverty or the devil is also working very hard?
Bro. Islam will remain a true religion of God.
Read these bible verses:
Deuteronomy 21:22-23, Exodus 20:3, Matthew 4:10, Luke 4:8, Leviticus 26:1, Ezekiel 23:30, 38:18, 33:25, Ezekiel 14:3, Ezekiel 14:4, Jeremiah 1:16, Isaiah 2:8.
Even though Catholics deny that they don't worship the idols, but they are often seen kneeling before them - taking them to be earthly representation of Mary and Jesus.
Now, i believe this guy is sick!
He once claimed he was Muslim, but wants nothing to do with Islam. But, he is forever adorning Muslim attires!
The brain was corrupted to leave Islam, but the heart/soul still admires Islam.
Brother run away very fast!
Christianity was not even the religion of christ. It is a corrupted version of Judaism, tailoredbto meet the needs of Romans. The reason Romans were prepared to kill early Christians, and eyewitness disciples of Jesus so that that they overhaul Jesus' teachings! Ask yourself these questions:
1. Was Jesus unaware of what he was teaching when he was on earth? Why would he teach different things while on earth, then go away and send Paul to come contradict all his (Jesus') teachings?
2. In view of 1. Which "Jesus" appeared to Paul? You and i know that the world is waiting for Jesus ' "second coming", not "third coming"!
3. Why would Jesus make Paul blind in order to talk to him? In order to give him instructions? Jesus never made anyone blind when he was on earth, and even when he appeared to his disciples after the alleged crucifixion. Who exactly appeared to Paul? Is it possible that Satan assumed Jesus' appearance and then made him blind in order not to be recognised? How comes Paul's teachings are contradicting Christ, if it's Christ who sent him?
4. How comes those who accompanied Paul never saw Jesus when he allegedly appeared to Paul? They only heard the voice. The bible is even contradicting itself on this.
Read these verses, and decide for yourself which is "more" manmade!
The bible is replete with cases of killings, rape, mass murders, forced slavery - allegedly under the instructions of the "Jewish God". Read these verses: Numbers 31:7-18, Chronicles 21:14-15, Isaiah 13:16, Zachariah 14:2, Lamentations 5:11.
In the case of Numbers 31:7-18; How do you (as a man), tell that a 3 year or a 9 year old girl is a virgin? By sleeping with her, against her will - right? If this is not rape, what is it?
And the worst bit is, the instruction came from the "Hebrew God". The same God allegedly ordered them to kill infants as young as 1 month. Think about it! And this is how you portray God - as a vengeful, irrational, merciless, etc or the bible was intentionally manipulated to be used to commit genocide against other races!
In the bible, there are over 1,000 contradictions. Here are some of them:
1. What did Judas iscariot do with the money he was paid after betraying Jesus? There are two different accounts in the bible! Logically, one is not true!
2. How was Jesus crucified? Definitely, not on a cross. The Jews never used to crucify people on a cross. It was not known to them then. Then, where did the cross come from? Or how many times was Jesus crucified? Read Deuteronomy 21:22-23.
3. How old was Jesus when he died? The bible is deliberately scanty on Jesus life and lifestyle while on earth. Despite having lived on earth for 33 years, he is being portrayed as having lived for 1 month. During the 33 years period, Jesus did everything any mortal did, including sleeping and waking up regularly, playing as a kid on a regular basis. And when he reached maturity, he was circumcised according to Jewish culture- and by a man!
Early Christianity did not regard Jesus as God. It was in 400 AD when a Roman empiror (Constantine), who was not in the list of prophets/was not an appostle of God comanded that Jesus must be regarded as a God/Son of God. The Ebionites and nazarenes objected, but were killed in large numbers till the narative stuck. In fact, prior to that, trinity was not even known.
4. According to God's plan, He only intended to use Mary as the one who will bring Jesus on earth. Thereafter, Mary was to go on with her life. She was later married by Joseph and together they were blessed wiyh other children (daughters and sons). Now Mary was mother of Christ/God! Why are you embarrassed to say, "brothers and sisters of "God"? Why are you embarrassed to call Joseph, step father of "God"?
You're even shy to recognize Jesus' dibblings in the bible. They too, played their part.
5. The bible portrayed Jesus kneeling down severally and praying to God! Which God was he worshipping? Was he worshipping himself? If he was worshipping himself, how comes at calvary he prayed till "his sweat turned to blood", and still he refused to honour his own prayer? Was her merely acting? I mean, he sent himself to come and die for humanity. Why was he praying asking "himself " to have "mercy on himself" and remove the cup?
6. If Jesus was God, how comes at calvary he asked Peter and another disciple (must be Andrew), to keep vigil as he prayed? You mean your God is not omnipresent?
You have a lot to deal with! Stop misinterpreting the hadiths, and Quran to misinform "some muslims" and to exite fellow christians!
Thanks guys for educating all of us on Islam things that Muslims don’t even know.. God bless you guys and the sacrifices that you make everyday exposing Islam.. Glory to God 🙏🏼
Lol they are hilarious they aren’t educating anyone, I learned this from the past! Obviously the quran is in Arabic. Just wish Joseph smith would not about saying Muslims never knew this 🤣
@@ajajjjaj9233 If you knew this, why didn't you tell anyone?
@@marriannawhaleymartin5929 really ? Lol. What do you mean why I don’t tell anyone! Everyone knows this. Obviously fadi and his buddies want to make it seem something else! Then why don’t you tell your people that Jesus real language was Aramaic and that you don’t have the original gospels like the quran! Why are the gospels translated in Greek. It’s that simple love
@@marriannawhaleymartin5929 everyone knows that the Arabic quran is obviously sabaean Arabic which is the quraish Arabic dialect! The vowels you see in the quran is so those who don’t understand Arabic without its vowels can read it properly. No problemo . God bless you
@@ajajjjaj9233 we do have the original Gospel
Very very serious question about Quran ? In this video!!
All dawa gang are hiding!!
Watch this video !!!
Where is your Quran came!!
By who!!!?
Which language original Quran?
Muslims you cannot scape!!
Must answer!!
At 5:17, saying "ha theos" makes no sense. That is using the Hebrew article with the Greek word for "God". But I know what he means. He means "ho theos" which is the Greek article and the Greek word for "God". I think he meant to say "ho logos" which is "the word" in John 1:1. Bringing up the article (or lack thereof) in relation to "theos" in John 1:1 actually opens up a can of worms.
Drinking arabica, brain boost arabic
Ho theos is Greek, not Hebrew....I get what you meant, that just bugged me lol.
Really interesting video though, especially since many Muslims place a heavy emphasis on "the original language and dialect" of the Quran. I'm curious to see what their take on this is.
YEAH! Let every Muslim confront the raw facts. The FACTS!!!!
Nice serie!
I wish you all would write a book on all this, expounding on some of the terms you use. The basic terms ( readers etc). I’m sure there is much you all had to leave out because of time. Thanks for sharing what you have learned.
Its amazing and unbelievable that a language existed and a "holey" book was also written without even inventing vowels.
Indeed stupid will believe qutham ibn kilab is a prophet.
Still fascinating that people are memorising it even though they dont spaek the languages
so yesus did not died in crucifixion
IS A WRONG STATEMENT
Jesus said it ahead of time that He is going to be KILLED AND HIS BURIAL IN ADVANCED ..
Luke 9:22
"The Son of Man must suffer many things," He said. "He must be rejected by the elders, chief priests, and scribes, and He must be KILLED and on the third day be raised to life."
John 12:7
"Leave her alone," Jesus replied. "It was intended that she should save this perfume for the day of my burial.
JESUS DIED OF LOSS OF BLOOD AND WATER DEHYDRATION
John 19:34
Instead, one of the soldiers pierced His side with a spear, and immediately blood and water flowed out.
John 19:33
33But when they came to Jesus and saw that He was already DEAD, they did not break His legs.
JESUS COMING FROM HIS MOUTH SAID THAT HE DIED..
REVELATION 1:17,18
....“Do not be afraid; I am the First and the Last. 18 I am He who lives, and was DEAD, and behold, I am alive forevermore. Amen. And I have the keys of Hades and of Death.
Hebrews 2:9
But we do see Jesus, who was made lower than the angels for a little while, now crowned with glory and honor because he suffered DEATH, so that by the grace of God he might taste DEATH for everyone.
Yes, it was God the Father who ultimately brought His Son to Calvary, but His Son went their voluntarily. The Son of God willingly agreed to die on the cross for the salvation of those whom God had chosen from eternity past (Eph. 1:4-5).
“Greater love has no one than this, that someone lay down his life for his friends” (John 15:13).
Oh, what a love! Jesus lay down his life for us, so that we might live with Him forever. My fellow believers in Christ, if you ever doubt whether Jesus loves you or not, look back to Calvary and survey the wondrous cross, and don’t stop surveying it until you exclaim, He spread His arms from right to left, that's how much He loves you.,...
Romans 8:9
But you are not controlled by your sinful nature. You are controlled by the Spirit if you have the Spirit of God living in you. (And remember that those who do not have the Spirit of Christ living in them do not belong to him at all.)
@@9999rosebud
There are many books from 1st untill 3rd century wrote Jesus did not die on the cross found in AG Hamadi library in 1948
The revelation of Peter
The Act of John
The chronicle of Great Second Seth
Gospel of Judas
@@MrXucinxgaronx
Jesus said that He is going to get killed coming from His mouth and He also said that He DIED coming from His mouth..
Jesus said,..
“I am the good shepherd…and I lay down my life for the sheep…I lay down my life that I may take it up again. No one takes it from me, but I lay it down of my own accord. I have authority to lay it down, and I have authority to take it up again” (John 10:14-18).
Jesus said that He is the TRUTH
John 14:6
Jesus answered, "I am the way and the TRUTH and the life. No one comes to the Father except through me.
So, who crucified Jesus? Who crushed him to death? His Father did! Listen to Prophet Isaiah,
Surely he has borne our griefs and carried our sorrows; yet we esteemed him stricken, smitten by God, and afflicted. But he was pierced for our transgressions; he was crushed for our iniquities…. Yet it was the will of the Lord [Father] to crush him (Isa. 53:4-5, 10).
“Do you really believe that it was God who killed His own Son?” “Yes”. “Why would God do that to His Son?” “He did not spare His Son, so that He could spare you. God loves you more than His Son it is because God don't want you to die a second death which is separation from Him for 'ETERNITY' received His free gift which is His Son and you will have Eternal Life with Him”.. That is the message of the cross..
We are all praying for you everyday keep up the good work🙏
From Afghanistan, kindly regaurds.
Is the checked headscarf an Islamic gown or arabic traditions?
Pashtuns should be Christian. Spread the word (safely).
@@ownpetard8379
They have a lot of Jewish names.
@@abdhaigardez5680 The first Christians were Jews.
@@ownpetard8379
U r right. Even today we have Jew leaders in Iran ,Afghanistan ,Pakistan and Islam karimov former president of Uzbekstan.
Imran Khan (pak),Mahmoud Ahmadi nejad (iran) and Ashraf Ghani (Afghanistan) are exapls to be Jew. Even khamaini I guess.
This is inline with Dan Gibson research about Mecca is in Petra area and Muhammad was actually from up there.
8:50...actually its "Where's Waldo?"..🤷🏻♂️ ..Dr. Jay seems to deeply knowledgable and authoritative at times....but I keep getting thrown off when he keeps making confusing minor errors-
i.e. 5:18 John1:1 "ho Theon"/"ηο Θεον" is Greek- not Hebrew (but yes it is an example of definite article)....
6:28 Originally "Nabatean Aramaic" was not even an Arabic dialect...it did apparently "evolve" into Nabatean Arabic when native Arab speakers began utilizing it about 2 centuries before Mahomet, it eventually merged into Arabic from the replacing the original Aramaic vocabulary with Arabic words...apparently it is now called "Nabatean Arabic"...apparently it is believed Arabic script evolved not from Sabaic Script, but rather Nabatean Aramaic script....🗣👳🏾♂️🐪🌴🏝🏜...
Please list in your video description the title and author of books you reference in the videos.
This gave me a good laugh! May Allah guide you
Thanks for the great revelation God bless you Mr Al Al Fadi ive learned a lot !
They shoud have used the Nabatean script
Do you want to read it in binary code?
Is Sabaic Arabic or Semitic?
at 5:18 John 1:1 in greek ho logos, the word. ho is letter omicron.
In Hebrew the is the letter hey
I haven't heard from David Woods, is all well?
@tom todd
He hasn't been out of action , you must not be watching the correct channels
HE HAS BEEN WITH
AP
vOCABE
ALFADI
@@GedaliahAR thanks
JESUS CHRIST (YESHUA) ❤️ The LIVING GOD (Isaiah 9 : 6-7) !
the phrase "Where's Wally" was almost the same as the phrase "Where's Waldo".
We are learning about Wally World. 😁
In the 2nd minute, Jay Smith mentions a book by Ahmad Al-Jallad, a scholar researching the history of the Arabic language, strongly implying that Al-Jallad's book supports the comments that he subsequently makes about northern version of Arabic in which the Qur'an in written.
I have a few questions which would provide a considerable amount of clarity to the claims being made in the video, which I am not disputing.
What is the name of this book by Al-Jallad?
Does this author make any comments in the book that explicitly support Smith's claim that the Qur'an was written in the northern I'rab Arabic rather than the Sabaic Arabic which one would expect that Qur'an to have been written?
If the answer is No, which is what I expect, can either of the speakers in this video reply to this comment and give a citation and quotation from the book which they believe supports the comments they make about the northern origin of the Qur'anic text?
Peter Clemerson
Fascinating. Have you seen these 2 presentations ?
"Did the Early Muslim Empire have a Language Policy?"
by Dr. Petra Sijpesteijn
ua-cam.com/video/Da9D1BwJMgY/v-deo.html
and
Dr. Ahmad Al-Jallad The Rise of Arabic: From an epic past to an evidence-based history “ua-cam.com/video/dHRbuu8c8nw/v-deo.html
I heard deep dive hahaha! Dr Holes in the narrative immediately comes to mind!
Quran written hundreds years too late from the Muhamad time ?? Then how it supposed to be God revelation ...????
Thank you
Christianity Is Not The Religion Of Jesus , Jesus And His Mother Were Nasara Muslim , Jesus And His Mother Mary Worship The Only One True God , Jesus Was 2nd Adam And A Prophet Of God . God Bless All Of Us . Amin .
REALLY INSPIRING SERIES. I AM WATCHING ALL YOUR VIDEOS. GREAT JOB TO BRING TRUTH AT FINGERTIPS.
See UA-cam: CAESAR'S MESSIAH. EVERY MUSLIM MUST WATCH THIS!!!!
What watch, there are lying to you, they want to change the history of Islam, language of Quran, they want to erase everything about Islam, but the only one listening and believe is you Christians audience 😂😂😂😂
An eye opener and truth reveler. you would be a great contributer for world peace and humanity
I love this channel
Hello, they say Mohammad received the Quran from Salman Farsi, is Salman Farsi a myth?
Explained and showed: Dear Dr. Jay Smith, thank you very much for the clearification, which was told the same by Professor to me to change last name to have better future in 2016 in New Zealand. It opened new doors, changed my personality. I changed my last name from DADAMUKHAMEDOV (GRANDFATHER MUKHAMMAD) to AZIMOV. It impacted my acceptance to the western world with good intention.
"What’s more, he suggests that many
of the Qur’ānic variants coexisted during the time of the prophet just as variants in ancient poetry coex-isted during the lifetime of the poets and rawī-s who lived in an oral-transmission environment (p. 232). Nasser concludes that the mysterious tradition of sab`at aḥruf (in its broader sense encompassing the Qur’ānic qirā’āt) was probably a consequence of the failure of the codification process by ‘Uthmān, which was not able to produce a single unified Reading of the Qur’ān. Thus, the variant readings kept multi-plying exponentially until Ibn Mujāhid, when their number became limited again." Marcin Grodzki on Shady Nasser's critique of the variant qiraats of the Quran
Jay Smith name drops Shady Nasser a lot but blows the discussion out or proportion just to prove his ridiculous claims. The Arabs were an oral people and only a select few could read and write. Therefore there are multitude of pronouciations. You travel anywhere in a specific country and its people will have their own dialects to the SAME language. This is the reason Uthman codified the Quranic text and scholars such as Ibn Mujahid set the pronunciations later on after Prophet Muhammad. To PRESERVE the Quran and its intended meaning as Islam was expanding outside the Arab lands and reaching non Arabs.
The meaning of the Quran is unchanged and the book we have today is preserved as how it was revealed.
Fun fact: Qur'an in Arabic comes from the root word qara'a yaqra'u (verb: reading or recitation). It is recited and spoken. Its not a "Book". Even the Qur'an that we hold today is actually not the Quran and rather more accurate called Mushaf (compiled texts/scripture)
With respect Mr. Sabri: you make some very valid points which I agree poke some holes in Smith's view. However, so much research seems to be coming to light indicating that Muhammed may actually have been from Petra in Jordan and that seems compelling to me. Wouldn't that be important to know?
Many native people maintain traditional stories from much, much farther back than a couple hundred years, with sacred storytellers who have been charged with passing down these stories with the utmost reverence. So I have little doubt there is much truth in the Qur'an. I'm just less sure of it's origin. Similar arguments are made about the Christian Bible by Muslims that I also think miss this point.
May we people of the book debate these questions earnestly, as indeed the nature of God is vital to understand. But may we do this as brothers and sisters, not enemies sneering at one another. I'm convinced that the problem is much less the differences between how truth seekers understand God and those who don't even acknowledge God exists or care about the impact of their actions on others.) May you be blessed today.
@@suetrublu You are intelligent I can see unlike others in this comments
@@aedaldaniel - as are you. And so thoughtful. I sincerely apologize for the rudeness and arrogance of too many Americans (like Jay Smith.) He fails to mention that the exact same criticisms he levels against the Q'uran have also been made against the Christian Bible. Seems to me that what's important is what these holy books teach is about how to live our lives in a way that honors our Creator. I have much to learn from Islam.
As - salumu alaikum my brother.
Great facts guys.
I challenge u do debate with any scholar instead of hiding behind ur channel ,am sure that u cant defend ur accusations in public
Why dont both of you try to write another Qur'an, and show it to the world. Then let the scholar do the grading. See how you stand against it
Halleluijah Amen, Love you pastor, from Bangladesh,
Praise the Lord Jesus Christ. 🇮🇳
See UA-cam: CAESAR'S MESSIAH. Enjoy. Perhaps you should change your Christianity?
Hebrew was the language of the scholars and the scriptures. But Prophet Jesus's (peace be upon him) "everyday" spoken language would have been Aramaic. And it is Aramaic that most biblical scholars say he spoke in the Bible.
What is the Aramaic term that Jesus (peace be upon him) used for God?
The Aramaic word for God is "Alaha"/"Aloho", which is related to the Hebrew word "elohim". In the version of Jesus's (peace be upon him) last words found in gMark and gMatt this word is transliterated into a Greek form as "Eloi", so Jesus (peace be upon him) is depicted as using this word for God in his native language in his last cry before dying. Jesus (peace be upon him) was praying not crying. Just put yourself in Jesus's (peace be upon him) place and think logically NOT emotionally. I bet you would've prayed as well NOT cried.
Now does Allah like Muhammad (peace be upon him) said and Alaha"/"Aloho like Jesus (peace be upon him) said when he was praying to God as he was about to be crucified not sound the same? They're praying to the same God because there is only one God and Jesus, Moses, Ibraham, Joseph, Solomon, David, and Mohammed (peace be upon all of them) are His Prophets to humans and they all came with same message from the same One and only God!
I'm only asking everyone to take the extra mile and fact check these 2 ignorant men!
Peace and love to all of y'all ✌🏿
About the Holy Quran, what's wrong is only in terms of english translation and syntax in writing of the one who wrote the messages dictateed by Jibreel...please reflect and pray...
Languages of pre-Islamic Arabia
To show how at loss the Islamic-era Arabic literary evidence can sometimes be, one needs only to consider
the linguistic situation of pre-Islamic Arabia (on which see Macdonald 2000 and Al-Jallad 2015: 1-25). The
Muslim authors did not have an understanding of the variety of languages in the pre-Islamic era, claiming
that most of the inhabitants of Arabia were Arabic-speaking (Rabin 1951), whereas in historical reality
Arabia was home to speakers and writers of forms of North Arabian (including but not restricted to Arabic),
South Arabian, Aramaic (Nabataean, Syriac) and, to lesser extent, Hebrew, Ge’ez, Persian, Greek, and Latin.4
In the Islamic tradition, not only Arabians but also major characters of the monotheist tradition such as
Ismail speak Arabic (al-Masʿūdī, Murūj: II, 162). Furthermore, later Arabic writers had little grasp that the
South Arabians did not see themselves as and could not be called Arabs in the pre-Islamic era. The Muslim
authors see Yemen as the original home of the Arabs and Arabic language - an idea of which we do not
have much evidence and that is most likely incorrect.
To this is connected another myth, namely that the Arab tribes are divided to two section: al-ʿarab
al-ʿāriba, ”True Arabic-speaking Arabs,” and al-ʿarab al-mustaʿriba, “Arabized Arabs.” The ʿarab al-ʿāriba are
deemed to be the Southern tribes and the ʿarab al-mustaʿriba Northern. But this is incorrect insofar that
the Arabic language actually spread from the north to the south in the course of late antiquity, and not the
other way around. The Islamic tradition pushes the importance of Yemen even further, for example
claiming that the eponym of the Greeks, Yūnān, came from Yemen (al-Masʿūdī, Murūj: II, 5-6). All of this
probably reflects Islamic-era, post-conquest tendency of Yemenite Muslims to emphasize their significance
but this needs further research (for some notes see Bashear 1989).
In the Muslim sources, the development and rise of the Arabic script is said to have happened in the
Ḥijāz, al-Anbār, or al-Ḥīra (e.g., al-Hamdānī, Iklīl: I, 77-79). The suggestion of al-Ḥīra is interesting, since it
was the capital of the Lakhmids (see below) and, indeed, the first text that is written completely in Arabic is
the Namara inscription dated to 328 CE; it is a funerary text for Marʾ al-Qays ibn ʿAmr, who is usually
identified with a Lakhmid king of that name (Bellamy 1985). The script is a late variant of Nabataean, of
which the Arabic script developed during the following centuries (Gruendler 1993). However, the Namara
inscription is the only testimony for the Lakhmids’ ostensible written use of Arabic.
As for the Ḥijāz, there is actually more evidence that the Arabic script evolved there. Based on
epigraphy, the rise of the Arabic script seems to be more directly related with the longevity of Nabataean
Aramaic that was, according to new finds (Nehmé 2010), used in the western parts of the peninsula until
the fifth century. The script of these inscriptions is Nabataean and the language is often a mixture of
Aramaic and Arabic. In 2014, Frédéric Imbert and a French-Saudi team found a new Nabataean Aramaic-
Arabic inscription dated 469-470 CE as south as Najrān, which sparked scholarly and media interest.4
The
Old Arabic inscriptions of the sixth century (Zebed, Jabal Usays, Harran; see Macdonald 2008) seem to be
continuation of this epigraphic habit of late Nabataean inscriptions, even if they have been found to the
north of the Ḥijāz, in Syria. Writing on perishable material, if it existed, has not been preserved.
reference:
helda.helsinki.fi//bitstream/handle/10138/307521/Lindstedt_Early_Muslims_Pre_Islamic_Arabia_and_Pagans_.pdf?sequence=1
God bless you and your family Always
How these guy is broadcasting and evaluating openly.....
Don't he got a threat from radical hardcore Islamist like dead threat of him and his family's....
Bravo.....with full dedication in jesus work...MGBU
This new evidence would place the prophet figure, if he existed, in northern Arabia, and the Quran as being created from users of that Arab lingual sub-area. (Sadly the warner/prophet of the Quran is unidentified as to his location and background in the Quran itself, an omission that is very fishy, as when giving such as account one would be keen to provide this, to prove that the message was genuine.)
Mecca down on the western edge of the Arabian peninsula never made much sense. In one's studies of History and Geography even back at school age one knew that great empires are founded upon a large demographic bases, and that such population pools don't live in remote rocky and sandy desert locations - those are sparsely populated before modern times. The account of Islam spreading according to the SIN would require a massive and impressive conquest in less than 50 years after the death of the prophet figure, it simply couldn't be done from a small base. Pilgrims on Hajj and umra are actually visiting a "Mohammedland Hejaz".
You're Wrong Not Qur'an.
Lies upon lies just declaring your ignorance..
The most interesting show about the coran an islam, its very interesting!
Some one send the message here said where is Jesus said I'm equal with God worshiping me here is the verse, read the book of proverbs chapter 8 verses 22- 31 then tell poeple your stupidity of not understanding of the bible, bible is not Newspaper.
🙏🙏🙏PRAY FOR 🙏🙏🙏PAKISTANI CHRISTIANS AND HINDU
Hallelujah praise the lord sir
yes i beleive in you brother both of you
Is there a different Arabic in the hadiths and the Arabic of the Qur'an
Basically is the Qur'an ummayid and the hadiths are Abbasid
Does anyone else find it ironic that it’s videos like these that have Islamic ads? Lmaooo
But you who are criticizing the language of the Quran do not understand the language yourself, and so on what basis is your criticism?? There are some of the vowels that you don't understand yourself unless it is explain to you by someone and yet you are shamefully criticizing the Arabic language.
Claims & assumption , no evidence. No scientific proof...Quran is perfect coz Allah said so. It's competes us.
I love Al Fartdi...
And I'm Muslim I'm new to this channel..
Please anybody tell is this uncle Muslim or Christian?
Christian
@@randomiumolica how bro
The problem is that the Arabic words you claim are similar to Aramaic are more Hebrew rather than Aramaic words.
Hebrew predates Aramaic and is from the period of the Akkadian and Sumerian languages. We learn this from the names of the Hebrew letters that symbolize pictures and not sounds.
And only because the first linguists were antisemitic did not want to give Hebrew the proper credit.
thnks
I was told once that the original Arabic the Angel recited to Mohammud was like the Fire from Heaven! No book before or since was like that!I I was also told that attempts have been made to write artifical Korans but no human source has bee able to duplicate the Divine Fire of the Koran!
The Corpus of the 114 Surats informs us that there is a Tradition which claims to be an Apostolic Tradition yet rejects circumcision while the Apostles were all circumcised, didn't believe in Trinity, and had prescribed a dietary Law in Acts 15:22-34 which the said Tradition rejects. Is it not ironic!
On the basis of those clues we can say for sure that:
Qur'an is a codeword for Torah.
The Reminder should be the proper Title for the corpus of 114 Surats.
Islam means an Evangelical Party supposed to enforce the Torah as the Law of the land.
Muhammad euphemism for Messiah
Abu Quasim as an Arabian Evangelist who later became a Sovereign Ruler,
Legislator...and took up Muhammad as a reign name.
Unfortunately the "Muhammad" of the Palace and the "Mohammad" of the Shahada in the Mosque got blended together in the Tradition.
If it is true that Abu Quasim signed off his formal treaties and official decrees as Muhammad as reported by Ibn Hisham, then this might explain how this present OPTICAL ILLUSION was perpetuated by those who were eager to capitalize on the Pilgrimage to Macca.
It' s high time to differentiate the palace and the Mosque under the Messianic title Muhammad.
Uthman chose the wrong Quaran to preserve.
Allah chose the wrong man, wrong language and wrong people to collect his supposed words
Oh man your critics are really not helping an Arabic speaker you are focusing in writing... Its really a theory that don't make any sense. Pleas go ask any arabic from Yemen or any arabic speaker "janah" will stay "janah"😅 you have to learn arabic to make the critic worthy. Don't look to writing the silab its always the same hope my point is clear
Adam And Eve Was The First Creation Of God All Mighty , They Was Created In The Paradise Please See The Evidence In The Quran , God Bless .
Keep digging, probably will misguide a few ignorant "muslims", however, those with knowledge and insight will find this video amusing.....everyone knows Arabs didn't write with vowels nor would have the companions, may God be pleased with them, used them while writing down the revelation, they were added in later to assist the non-native readers with their recitation. Side note: I was looking for the Bible of Jesus's companions (not the hearsay of some Greeks 60 years later but from those who walked with Jesus, peace be upon him) who wrote down his teachings as they happened in their original language, can anyone point me to that book? Maybe these scholars in the video can give me one.
hmmm...this set me thinking: Jesus spoke Aramaic, the original bible is in orthodox Greek, a majority of bible printed is in English, can you do a similar approach, linguistically speaking?
Genesis was written in cueniform. King James edited a lot of the Bible ,
@Majo Flinterman Jesus spoke Aramaic.
See UA-cam CAESAR'S MESSIAH, Mohd! Enjoy.
Islam is a false religion
As an atheist it's good to know how that peopled are reavezling the falsehoods of religions.
Great research May father son and holyghost bless you abundantly.
Ibam a Hindu convert
BHAGAVAD GITA is the worlds best scripture to date.Better by far than the Bible. I was a Reborn Christian converted to the honoring of Lord Krishna. See UA-cam CAESAR'S MESSIAH why Jesus is a farce.
The reason we are watching is because we searched for you. Now if you really want authorities to adhere to freedom of religion, you need to advertise the truth to all nations via other direct media to reach out to those whom are unaware of the truth.
I think Al Fadi should be an alien 👽👽...wrong placement 😜
FROM THE NEW TESTAMENT BOOK, IT IS EVIDENT THAT JESUS IS NOT GOD OF CHRISTIANS.
JESUS DIDN'T KNOW ANYTHING ABOUT CHRISTIAN.
THERE IS NO VERSE IN THE NEW TESTAMENT THAT PROVES THAT JESUS IS GOD OF CHRISTIANS.
JESUS WAS NEVER SENT TO CHRISTIANS.
THERE IS NO RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN JESUS AND CHRISTIANS.
JESUS ONLY HAS A VERY CLEAR RELATIONSHIP WITH THE PEOPLE OF ISRAEL.
MATTHEW 15: 24
But he answered and said, I am not sent but unto the lost sheep of the house of ISRAEL.
JESUS WAS BORN TO BE A LEADER WHO WILL SHEPHERD THE PEOPLE OF ISRAEL, NOT SHEPHERD CHRISTIANS.
MATTHEW 2: 6
And thou Bethlehem, in the land of Juda, art not the least among the princes of Juda: for out of thee shall come a Governor, that shall rule my people ISRAEL.
JESUS ONLY INTERACTED WITH ISRAELITES, JESUS NEVER INTERACTED WITH CHRISTIANS.
MARK 12: 29
And Jesus answered him, The first of all the commandments, Hear, O ISRAEL, The Lord our God is one Lord.
JESUS IS THE SAVIOUR OF THE PEOPLE OF ISRAEL.
JESUS IS NOT THE SAVIOUR OF CHRISTIANS.
THERE IS NO VERSE IN THE NEW TESTAMENT THAT STATES THAT JESUS IS THE SAVIOUR OF CHRISTIANS.
ACTS 13: 23
Of this man's seed hath God according to his promise raised unto ISRAEL A SAVIOUR, JESUS
JESUS BE PRAYED AS KING OF ISRAEL, NOT AS KING OF CHRISTIANS.
JOHN 12: 13
Took branches of palm trees, and went forth to meet him, and cried, Hosanna: Blessed is the King of ISRAEL that cometh in the name of the Lord.
JESUS COMMANDED THE WORSHIP OF GOD, JESUS NEVER COMMANDED WORSHIP OF JESUS.
MATTHEW 4: 10
Then saith Jesus unto him, Get thee hence, Satan: for it is written, Thou shalt worship the Lord thy God, and him only shalt thou serve.
JESUS COMMANDED TO THE FOLLOW JESUS, JESUS NEVER COMMANDED WORSHIP OF JESUS.
JOHN 8: 12
Then spake Jesus again unto them, saying, I am the light of the world: he that FOLLOWETH me shall not walk in darkness, but shall have the light of life.
IN THE NEW TESTAMENT BOOK, JESUS ONLY INTERACTED WITH ISRAELITES.
JESUS NEVER INTERACTED WITH CHRISTIANS.
THERE ARE NO STORIES ABOUT CHRISTIANITY IN THE NEW TESTAMENT.
SO, IT IS IMPOSSIBLE FOR JESUS IS THE GOD OF CHRISTIANS.
THIS IS A FACT, NOT HOAX.
TO PROVE IT, READ THE NEW TESTAMENT BOOKS FROM MATTHEW TO REVELATION WITH COMMON SENSE.
Interesting