"We ought to shift from simply toxic power met by toxic power and focus rather on the virtue, the love, the compassion, the nonviolence, that ought to inform our use of power". Bishop Robert Barron
This is a tenet of stable power politics that goes back at least as far as Confucius. That we still haven't learned that is a sign that the human race is irreparably stupid. This is why I put no faith in politics and all faith in God.
Without a review and commentary like this I wonder what message from the Movie will be received by the millions who shall watch it for entertainment. *Big Thanks Bishop Barron for the 'one of a kind' review of the Film.*
Bishop Barron, thank you for this beautiful reflection! You’re ability to bring us back into focusing on what Our Sweet Generous Lord is teaching us is truly a gift from Him. Thank you for teaching us NOT to get caught up in those things that Our Lord showed us not to get caught up in. Your words express Christ’s clarity, wisdom and Mercy. Thank you for your reference and teaching on Psalm 22. May you continue to be blessed.
Your approach is so refreshing and invigorating. Moreover, your interpretation of Scripture is so recontextualised, it makes sense to those without a theological background. It speaks to most and makes perfect sense. Thank you Bishop Rob.
I recently decided to watch this movie and it was intriguing and disturbing. Thank you Bishop Barron for this commentary on something that was a bit confusing for me. When movies include cringe worthy subjects and situations, I find it hard to want to continue watching. I couldn't decide how I felt at the end of the movie because I was glad the "bad cowboy" was gone but disturbed by how the other "bad guy" did the deed all in the name of protecting his mother. Then showing this verse in the Bible.
the "bad power" character was also portrayed in "american beauty" by chris cooper, with, spoiler alert, same ending. just hollywood congratulating itself again.
@@carlosgaspar8447 Exactly. With Hollywood this woke, we can be almost sure the truly best movie of the year will be virtually ignored by the Oscars. Maybe there should be a Catholic Oscars...?
@@tripp8833 I'm sorry but I couldn't figure out a better way to word it in order to explain my dilemma. It's still a very good movie to watch and wonder about the times and the beautiful scenery. Again, sorry.
I do think that's how you're SUPPOSED to feel. That was the filmmaker's intentions. Sometimes things are not cut and dried. That's why I think it's brilliant.
I haven't even seen the movie and I probably won't, but the points made in this review stand on their own. Thank you Bishop - truly something to ponder.
So freeing to do an examination of conscience and more importantly accept the the reality of my actions, to own them . It took my 62 years to come to this and to understand why I behaved the way I did. I have a wonderful feeling as a result. Feelings of utter joy and peace as I get closer and closer to Jesus. There is just nothing like it. Not sure why I have randomly posted this …. Just thinking, feeling ,and acting …. Bless your heart Bishop Barron.
It always amazes me Bishop Barron how you can derive powerful reflections from movies. I was so intrigued since it’s been a time since your last commentary in a film; I watched it before listening to your video once this was brought to my awareness via an email from the Word on Fire Institute. Thanks!
"Two negatives don't make a positive. Double negatives turn positive only in math and formal logic. *In life things get worse and worse and worse."* - Robert McKee
Great review. It's interesting how many movies now are about someone asserting their power and truth over someone else without questioning if doing so if fair or good in any way. I do think there are some movies that take an opposite approach like "Only Gor Forgives", "Gone, Baby, Gone" or "In Bruges" but it's definitely not a very mainstream take.
I'm just on my way out to morning mass on the day before Ash Wednesday and the second week of all that is going on in Eastern Europe, what an insight with which to ponder during mass, brilliant, thank you.
You may be in a season of struggle, a season of hardship, where you’re working long hours, doing your best to provide, but nothing is improving. You don’t see how it will ever change. But God is watching you. He sees your sacrifice. He sees you going the extra mile. You’re going to come into these turnaround moments where God is going to turn the struggle into ease, turn the lack into abundance, turn the sorrow into joy, turn the injustice, what you didn’t get, what wasn’t fair, into fulfillment, into purpose, into a blessed and satisfied life. I hope this comment has uplifted and blessed you, we are praying for you. We are a new and growing channel, and every encouragement/support is always a blessing. God bless you. Amen
This was sooooo good. I want to see this movie. And thanks for a great explanation of power and how using it to punish bad, is not very Christian......using power to forgive and to show mercy is required of us as Christians. Very Thought Provoking Bishop!
I watched this movie two nights ago. The entire thing gave me the creeps. It was so... ominous. Even in the quiet, thoughtful moments. I think you're right, Bishop, the power was displaced from morally corrupt person to a young person with questionable morals. Not because he was effeminate or "unmanly", but because what he planned and did, didn't seem to phase him. Thank you for your review.
@@TheMDelima it isn't about human hearts hearts that don't listen to the image of God in their hearts. Remorse or no remorse doesn't alter God is Spirit truth and justice. Scary Einstein ? was atheist
I don't see anything Christlike about Christians these days. You prove my point. Christianity is a man made social club based on myths and superstitions.
Bishop Barron, Thank you very much for watching "Power of the Dog" and commenting beautifully, creatively. I've enjoyed your books too, as did our parish men's group.
Love how that parallel of psalm 22 was what Jesus exemplified when he died on the cross for us. When toxicity is met with more toxicity, there is no progress but when toxicity is met with love, there is progress towards peace.
Thank you Bishop Barron for your insights into this film. I would like you to watch and review the film MASS, about 2 couples coming to forgiveness. I would be interested in your thoughts.
Tku so much Dear Fr! I just loved the ending so much.....'The Divine Mercy and compassion swallow up the power of the dog.....! God bless you always. This phrase will remain at the back of my mind for the rest of my day.
Thanks so much for this.. Our culture gets so caught up in the cinemática & dramatic suspense in hopes of just being entertained, w/o ever caring the affects these things has on how they see th world. & amazingly & sadly we also take lessons from the movies w/o realizing it. We miss th boat of what we expose our subconscious to for th simple sake of “entertainment “ & “fine acting”. & wildly, movies w/ scriptural lines tend to press in incorrect lessons for dramatic effect.
It reminds me, in contrast, of the movie The Scarlet and The Black, which also displays two powerful men, but one acting on vice to destroy lives and the other on virtue to save them; I think it reflects well what you've tried to say, Bishop Barron about virtue swallowing vice and braking the chain of "Meet the new Boss; same as the old Boss"!
It seems that many people interpreted the ending of The Power of the Dog to be positive and uplifting. I felt it was intended to be very mixed. The deed at the end was ultimately a “positive”, but it was only necessary because of a very tragic character who descended into becoming a typical western cowboy trope instead of embracing his true self. Phil appears to be on the path toward redemption, but that path is cut short. Its an incredibly sad ending to me that everyone essentially celebrates the demise of this man who had the potential to be saved from his own “toxicity”. I felt that was at least a portion of the intent of the film, but that may have just been me reading too deeply.
Without having seen this particular film, I can't say whether or not you're reading too much into it specifically, but it's certainly been a common theme in cinema - over the past couple of decades at least - for there to be a dearth of portrayals of a genuinely redemptive character arc. Especially so in critically acclaimed fare, the industry excells in providing the audience what it ostensibly desires - power "dynamics" bereft of a moral center, or, as Bp Barron and The Who put it, displays of the new boss, same as the old boss.
What they could have done is in the last scene Peter is shown to have signs of remorse, but only for a split second, then returns to his smile. So, it's like his conscience is trying to get to him but he is still rationalizing his act by telling himself he did it for his mom. That way he's not absolutely immoral and there is still hope for him. But, no, given that this is a Netflix film, they probably think Peter isn't evil at all.
Interesting. Similar for me was how Wolf of Wall Street is easily enjoyed thinking its glorifying it's antiheros, but really if there is a moral to the story its that greed will destroy your soul and everything you hold dear.
The film never uses the term "toxic," this has been mapped onto it by alt-right types. The boy is never meant to be sympathetic, in my opinion-- he is highly intelligent but also cold, as when he dissects the bunny to better understand it. I see this as a story about queer life, which includes queer suffering in periods when queer lives cannot be lived freely. Phil has escaped to a homosocial wilderness, forever in thrall to a former lover (and possible rapist). He is closeted and hates women because of his inability to join heterosexual life-- so in many ways he's a poor example of "toxic masculinity," which includes objectifying women sexually. The boy kills him to save his mother-- a horrible act justified by love. I'll take that complexity over the Bishop's "turn the other cheek" stuff. Look at what Putin's doing right now. Sometimes that's not an option.
I’d love to see another movie review on The Batman, even though its a comic book character, I think the movie really gets to how his mission is one of selflessness, virtue, and steadfastness in difficult situations. Something which a lot of people lack today. (It’s a standalone film so you can go into it without needing any prior context)
This is a powerful movie. Saw it twice. It shows man’s cruelty and how what may appears to be a weaker man has strength to not be destroyed by evil power. The meek being delivered from wicked power. There is a line in
Jesus defined human evil behavior often. Instead we need Acts of love. Phil’s cruelty while psychological and not physical is still evil. Sorry if the Bishop and I disagree in how we see evil. Not the first time either
There are two tools of power; first is individual or personal prowess, either physical or intellectual, and the other is institutional prowess or authority.
Thanks again for thought filled insights. It seems like the Ghandi & MLKjr movements were virtuous demonstrations of change in power. That type of leadership is necessary; however, needless to say no matter our efforts we'll never recreate the garden of Eden here.
Thank you, Bishop, for your commentary. I love Benedict Cumberbatch, but I don't think I want to see him in this role. Your comments about power are spot on, especially with what is happening in Ukraine.
I remember watching a pair of Noir series on Netflix a few years back. They left me in a sense of spiritual discomfort for days. After watching those two series, I said "done with that, no more NOIR movies or series." And by Noir, I mean there was just a cynicism, a darkness and meanness about the characters that was too much to take in. This movie has been characterized as a "neo noir" western. "Toxic masculinity" is not a real personality disorder, it's a modern term used to describe a combination of other personality disorders. The personalities described in the movie exhibit symptoms of malignant narcissism (if they have some conscience) or anti-social personality disorder (if they have no conscience). Both malignant narcissists and sociopaths are good at reading and exploiting the weaknesses of others, so the writer hit the personality profile accurately. If you want film noir, then yes, by all means build your characters around the dozens of unhealthy expressions of narcissism and sociopathy that exist in the real world. The cast of characters is infinite. As clergy, we have the responsibility to edify others. The cynicism embodied in the screen play is simply something to be avoided to be maintain a good spiritual life. I appreciate the reference to "We won't get fooled again." Great observation, too. But this cinematic garbage? Not worth the time.
Just a thought, as an eternal student, I look toward those who look at outward & inward facets of educational possibilities! I think it's important that great teachers always look at the many affectations of what they are teaching. In this case, what are current movies saying. Otherwise, we will become very narrow, without foundation. Isn't it more important to become narrow as a result of our moral findings, rather than the fact that we didn't look!
@@babecarla I think Bishop, in his usual diplomatic way, made his position on the movie pretty clear. However, the good spiritual life does not envision taking in literature, music or entertainment that causes harm to the soul. The saints are clear on that. Not only do they avoid the near occasion of sin, they avoid situations that could cause one to think or imagine things that are uncharitable, like a movie that senselessly indulges not only cruelty but pre-meditated cruelty for the sake of cruelty. I am not perfect, but I cannot consume movies or literature that exhibit not only cruelty but explore the pointless exercise of it, and then leave you wondering whether the director approves, and whether the outcome justified the cruelty. That's film noir. The viewer is challenged to ask "was what I just saw immoral or not?" That's why several people have said on this board the movie made them feel uncomfortable. By the way, a lot of action movies have moved away from delineating clear distinctions between good and evil to screenplays where it's not clear who is good and who is not. They leave the viewer uncomfortable (that's the point), and they can carry the messaging to a point where you don't know who is good and who is not. I think some of the later Batman movies and spin-offs fit into that category. Much of the series production on Netflix is noir. A friend of mine recommended "Occupied," which after two seasons became so noir and cynical that it was unpleasant to watch. You can leave the innocent thinking that there is no distinction between good and evil, or that evil is justifiable under certain circumstances. That's the essential problem. Finally, when we make good moral decisions, we minimize the Faustian bargains that no one wants to make. When we make dumb and careless decisions, we end up making Faustian bargains that cause harm to others. Much film noir is devoted to this ethical catch-22.
@@parishvicar7612 I understand your position and it's laudable. Therefore I guess the world is left to make determinations based on Clips or reviews they read on any particular movie. I'm not a big fan of movies anymore. Hollywood has ruined that for me. However I do find it credit-worthy that Bishop Barron does take a stand on movies and books. I miss that aspect at the Catholic Church that my parents supported. I do, however, for the younger generation's sake, believe that some of our stellar Ministry must particularize with honest reviews - the movies, books, online videos and other online genres for the sake of "Beware". Before the mind is well-formed and because families values are not so stable anymore, we have erring ways among us. Teaching the young to think is a moral imperative to me. Seeking truth and explaining good and bad it's really important. I think Bishop Barron does an amazing job at looking at our era and all of its trappings. He's certainly not afraid to speak out in almost any forum. I like that he's fearless. We need fearlessness for Jesus Christ. 👌 🌈✝️❣
@@parishvicar7612 well if that's true that's wonderful news to me. My mother was a great lover of old Hollywood. Our movies were very restricted when I was growing up so like my parents I became a great reader. Now of course we have many varietals of video opportunities. I still find it difficult to choose sometimes because the leaders in commercials for any given series are always designed to capture your interest. I appreciate your thorough explanation for your point of view. I don't use common colloquialisms in my speech patterns because I have family members who are rigidly elocutionist using only proper English. Even when I've tried to adapt certain terms in to my spectrum of the American/ English, I sometimes find it uncomfortable but I do understand it. I always make sure to do that otherwise you're reading or current events is muddy & becomes difficult. My parents taught me to read with a huge dictionary and thesaurus nearby. God bless you Vicar in your work and I will keep you in my prayers. When I came back to the Catholic Church after a number of years of searching other avenues, I found absolutely everything is here. So it's joyful to interact with our leaders of faith. 🌈✝️❣😎
Thanks for the commentary. Note to self: don't rent 'Power of the Dog'. I think we lost that virtuous power back in the 60s. Think this movie vs. Bonanza. The theme always was: good always prevails. These were strong, powerful men but never killed out of revenge. Now it seems we have modified 'revenge' into 'justification'. It just feels good - for some bizarre reason - to watch someone terrorize others to be destroyed by their victims: and the more ruthless their demise, the better. Does no one see the evil in this picture? Yet someone can enjoy this type of film yet think of themselves as righteous...under the cloak of 'it's not real'. They still enjoyed it though, right? Yet they can watch a movie that implies an animal is being hurt, and scream 'abuse!!' - yet that could never happen in today's world on a movie; but somehow that is real?
Enjoying a movie doesn't mean condoning all of the characters or actions in the movie. That's a bit silly. They may just enjoy the movie because it makes them think and question.
What you have brilliantly exposed here is sophism, or the idea that reality is only a matter of my perspective, and that anything I can do to sell my perspective or make it overcome your opposing perspective is valid. (Modern day sophists are called "lawyers.") Not so much "toxic masculinity" as toxic subjectivism. I haven't seen the film, but your analysis makes me want to see it.
Jordan Peterson had a good line, in ancient times there was the idea of a great power chosing not to exercise that power - the great warrior that: "keeps the sword sheathed", so to speak.
yes you are right if a very toxic power meets another toxic power there's no moral progress and society, people are stuck in their malice and so we are having no christianity alive.thank you for your deep commentary
Bishop Robert Barron Why don't you go to the debate of Sheikh Othman bin Al-Farouq so that Muslims can convert to Christianity instead of the other way around
One thing I’ll never understand: why “Hollywood” (at least in shows/movies that I’ve seen) portrays couples that, after getting married, move in with in laws that don’t like the new addition to the family. And since the new husband is a wealthy one and can afford it, can’t the newly wedded couple move out into their own house?? This movie echoes that old night soap Dallas on that point. I always thought “Bobby, why can’t you and Pam move out of Southfork and get your own mansion??!!” I mean, come on!!!
Poor Dog has to bear the stigma of toxic power. When in fact they are more likely by us to overcome it with their strength and loyalty. I guess I missed this one as i will the movie which by his description is Hollywood pushing an agenda.
Sounds like an interesting movie to go see given the title. Some working dogs who start costing their owner too much in veterinarian costs after becoming homeless are never going to get hired on as mental health working dogs only because they don't have the right pedigreed piece of paper and because they don't have any fancy enough way of jumping over barriers and skating on thin ice too well enough to impress any potential master with enough disposable money to follow through on buying some dogs to properly care for yet another individual creature in their home. And so most homeless dogs then have to learn instead on how to get along with mother nature again instead while being wary of strangers in general. Unless for example it looks a certain way like some new breed of dog like what is now called an American Staffordshire terrier. Not everyone can recognize every sign of power. Like the power of a dog too. What about a different kind of sign power exists other than flesh? Only the sign of a gourd in the sky to the Ninevites was enough for them to believe without often doubting both Job and Jesus Christ in their human weaknesses allowed father in heaven to reveal in them his real power among humankind. Jesus Christ on the day of Pentecost offered his message to everyone present including those after his resurrection who continued to doubt some of his words. Yes it is true that to do all that Jesus Christ must have been consubstantial with our heavenly father.
I hope Bishop Robert Barron To debate Sheikh Othman bin Al-Farouq, because many Christians have begun to leave Christianity and embrace Islam I am also curious that he responds to Ibn al-Qayyim al-Jawziyya’s poem on the denial of Christianit
Great commentary on a disturbing movie. The revenge that plays out in the film felt like a shallow consolation in a harsh world. Certainly not enough to sustain the soul.
POTENTIAL SPOILER ALERT: I was creeped out yet a little satisfied by how the son handled the situation and the climax. BUT the last scene was chilling. Son looks out at his mother kissing her husband, and I got a definite vibe of “watch out, man, don’t mess with her,” and I concluded that he had actually killed his own father (review his description to Phil of his father and how he was great until he started drinking too much.)
Power... a powerful mind... is to me the ability to influence... regardless of physical apperance, with knowledge and conviction. Jesus on the cross ... a message that changed the world. (I did not see the The Power of the Dog).
Bishop Barron's description of one toxic force working against another seems to describe too much of the poles of our media & leaders who too often settle for spin and sound bites to cast the other in as bad a light as possible rather than relying on relaying the truth of a situation in its most full form possible and let people use that truth, abd ultimately Trust God to use that Truth with our prayers to work out the salvation of souls even when the world isn't what we think it should be.
Good to see another movie commentary from the good Bishop. It’s been a while, and they’re always thought-provoking.
great to see the flame of film analysis still burns brightly at word on fire...
I would like to see more but I understand that he is busy
I feel the same way. I was missing those comments and almost wrote it about when I readed yours.
"We ought to shift from simply toxic power met by toxic power and focus rather on the virtue, the love, the compassion, the nonviolence, that ought to inform our use of power". Bishop Robert Barron
This is a tenet of stable power politics that goes back at least as far as Confucius. That we still haven't learned that is a sign that the human race is irreparably stupid. This is why I put no faith in politics and all faith in God.
@@HolyKhaaaaan
Are you Cain?and the sonshine band
this is a tenet of stable power
Without a review and commentary like this I wonder what message from the Movie will be received by the millions who shall watch it for entertainment. *Big Thanks Bishop Barron for the 'one of a kind' review of the Film.*
Bishop Barron, thank you for this beautiful reflection! You’re ability to bring us back into focusing on what Our Sweet Generous Lord is teaching us is truly a gift from Him. Thank you for teaching us NOT to get caught up in those things that Our Lord showed us not to get caught up in. Your words express Christ’s clarity, wisdom and Mercy. Thank you for your reference and teaching on Psalm 22. May you continue to be blessed.
Mrs. PCI agree and
your writing is the best
thank you
Desperada - song
The Eagles - artist
lol
Your approach is so refreshing and invigorating. Moreover, your interpretation of Scripture is so recontextualised, it makes sense to those without a theological background. It speaks to most and makes perfect sense. Thank you Bishop Rob.
Fantastic, Bishop Barron. I wish they would play it at the Oscars. Hollywood needs to hear you.
Love listening to Bishop Barron…always so thought provoking and makes one reflect. Issues become clearer and just make sense! Thank you.
I missed your movie reviews Father! God bless
I recently decided to watch this movie and it was intriguing and disturbing. Thank you Bishop Barron for this commentary on something that was a bit confusing for me. When movies include cringe worthy subjects and situations, I find it hard to want to continue watching. I couldn't decide how I felt at the end of the movie because I was glad the "bad cowboy" was gone but disturbed by how the other "bad guy" did the deed all in the name of protecting his mother. Then showing this verse in the Bible.
the "bad power" character was also portrayed in "american beauty" by chris cooper, with, spoiler alert, same ending. just hollywood congratulating itself again.
@@carlosgaspar8447 Exactly. With Hollywood this woke, we can be almost sure the truly best movie of the year will be virtually ignored by the Oscars. Maybe there should be a Catholic Oscars...?
@@tripp8833 I'm sorry but I couldn't figure out a better way to word it in order to explain my dilemma. It's still a very good movie to watch and wonder about the times and the beautiful scenery. Again, sorry.
I do think that's how you're SUPPOSED to feel. That was the filmmaker's intentions. Sometimes things are not cut and dried. That's why I think it's brilliant.
I haven't even seen the movie and I probably won't, but the points made in this review stand on their own. Thank you Bishop - truly something to ponder.
Power is extremely needed to affect the good and protect against the bad. You have it exactly right: Does virtue or vice drive power. Thank you!
Brilliant commentary as always...such a good way to see things.....
A profound message and analysis, Bishop. God bless and keep up the good work.
So freeing to do an examination of conscience and more importantly accept the the reality of my actions, to own them . It took my 62 years to come to this and to understand why I behaved the way I did. I have a wonderful feeling as a result. Feelings of utter joy and peace as I get closer and closer to Jesus. There is just nothing like it. Not sure why I have randomly posted this …. Just thinking, feeling ,and acting …. Bless your heart Bishop Barron.
Quoting classic rock! Love it! You da Man, Your Excellency!
What can say dear Bishop Barron always thought provoking. Love it. Keep up the good work.
So refreshing! Thank you, Bishop.
This was terrific, thanks Bishop Barron as always.
It always amazes me Bishop Barron how you can derive powerful reflections from movies. I was so intrigued since it’s been a time since your last commentary in a film; I watched it before listening to your video once this was brought to my awareness via an email from the Word on Fire Institute. Thanks!
"Two negatives don't make a positive. Double negatives turn positive only in math and formal logic. *In life things get worse and worse and worse."* - Robert McKee
Thank you so much,Bishop Barron.
Good review. Underscoring that cruelty begets cruelty and that to break that cycle you must love your enemy. Love is powerful beyond everything else.
Excellent. Keep up the good work in Christ and may God bless you and your family ✝✝✝
Great review. It's interesting how many movies now are about someone asserting their power and truth over someone else without questioning if doing so if fair or good in any way.
I do think there are some movies that take an opposite approach like "Only Gor Forgives", "Gone, Baby, Gone" or "In Bruges" but it's definitely not a very mainstream take.
I was just thinking today how long it's been since a movie commentary - LOVE them - DO MORE PLZ
I look forward for the review about the upcoming movie 'Father Stu' 🙏
I'm just on my way out to morning mass on the day before Ash Wednesday and the second week of all that is going on in Eastern Europe, what an insight with which to ponder during mass, brilliant, thank you.
You may be in a season of struggle, a season of hardship, where you’re working long hours, doing your best to provide, but nothing is improving. You don’t see how it will ever change. But God is watching you. He sees your sacrifice. He sees you going the extra mile. You’re going to come into these turnaround moments where God is going to turn the struggle into ease, turn the lack into abundance, turn the sorrow into joy, turn the injustice, what you didn’t get, what wasn’t fair, into fulfillment, into purpose, into a blessed and satisfied life. I hope this comment has uplifted and blessed you, we are praying for you. We are a new and growing channel, and every encouragement/support is always a blessing. God bless you. Amen
Amen
Amen
This was sooooo good. I want to see this movie. And thanks for a great explanation of power and how using it to punish bad, is not very Christian......using power to forgive and to show mercy is required of us as Christians. Very Thought Provoking Bishop!
Quite insightful and brilliant Bishop Barron. Thanks so much!!!
Praise the Lord Jesus Christ 🙏 Mother Mary Pray For Us 🙏Abba Father Bless us and we Adore You 🙏Holy Spirit Guide us and direct our paths 🙏
I watched this movie two nights ago. The entire thing gave me the creeps. It was so... ominous. Even in the quiet, thoughtful moments. I think you're right, Bishop, the power was displaced from morally corrupt person to a young person with questionable morals. Not because he was effeminate or "unmanly", but because what he planned and did, didn't seem to phase him. Thank you for your review.
You're right. I haven't seen the movie, but it seems to be the norm in reality these days. People do evil things without remorse. Scary!
@@TheMDelima
it isn't about human hearts
hearts that don't listen
to the image of God
in their hearts.
Remorse or no remorse
doesn't alter
God is Spirit
truth
and
justice.
Scary Einstein ? was atheist
I agree, did not like this movie at all. Creepy & weird were the words I used. I didn’t even know what the storyline was after watching it
Is vengeance and retribution the main theme of the movie?
I don't see anything Christlike about Christians these days. You prove my point. Christianity is a man made social club based on myths and superstitions.
Bishop Barron, Thank you very much for watching "Power of the Dog" and commenting beautifully, creatively. I've enjoyed your books too, as did our parish men's group.
God Bless Bishop Barron!
Bishop Barron referencing The Who… pretty awesome!
Looking 4ward to watching this movie. Thank u Bishop Barron. XO
Bp be safe in your mission,God bless...
Thank you.
omg, I cant believe our Bishop is talking about this movie. So so cool.
Bishop Barron, you can publish all the spoiler alerts you wish! Thank you for this analysis.
I’ve missed your movie talks :)
Listening to Bishop Baron discuss how power is a neutral reality made me realize that virtue is power used for God!
God Bless Bishop Barron 🙏
Love how that parallel of psalm 22 was what Jesus exemplified when he died on the cross for us. When toxicity is met with more toxicity, there is no progress but when toxicity is met with love, there is progress towards peace.
A perspective on power struggles that I needed to hear right now, so thank you for the context.
I enjoyed this very much Bishop Barron! Thanks.
"If one form of toxicity is replaced by another...," spot on.
Bishop Barron...What a Legend!
Thank you
Nailed it. Thanks Bishop Barron!!
Excellent. I think Phil got a little bit of an inkling in one scene where he is with Peter. There was a look on his face of shock or surprise.
Inspiring analysis
Thank you Bishop Barron for your insights into this film. I would like you to watch and review the film MASS, about 2 couples coming to forgiveness. I would be interested in your thoughts.
Tku so much Dear Fr!
I just loved the ending so much.....'The Divine Mercy and compassion swallow up the power of the dog.....!
God bless you always.
This phrase will remain at the back of my mind for the rest of my day.
At last the Bishop is back reviewing movies! It's been way too long
Thanks so much for this.. Our culture gets so caught up in the cinemática & dramatic suspense in hopes of just being entertained, w/o ever caring the affects these things has on how they see th world. & amazingly & sadly we also take lessons from the movies w/o realizing it. We miss th boat of what we expose our subconscious to for th simple sake of “entertainment “ & “fine acting”. & wildly, movies w/ scriptural lines tend to press in incorrect lessons for dramatic effect.
Well said.
It reminds me, in contrast, of the movie The Scarlet and The Black, which also displays two powerful men, but one acting on vice to destroy lives and the other on virtue to save them; I think it reflects well what you've tried to say, Bishop Barron about virtue swallowing vice and braking the chain of "Meet the new Boss; same as the old Boss"!
Thank you so much, I think you might be the first public figure I've ever heard get Palsm 22 right.
It seems that many people interpreted the ending of The Power of the Dog to be positive and uplifting. I felt it was intended to be very mixed. The deed at the end was ultimately a “positive”, but it was only necessary because of a very tragic character who descended into becoming a typical western cowboy trope instead of embracing his true self. Phil appears to be on the path toward redemption, but that path is cut short. Its an incredibly sad ending to me that everyone essentially celebrates the demise of this man who had the potential to be saved from his own “toxicity”. I felt that was at least a portion of the intent of the film, but that may have just been me reading too deeply.
Without having seen this particular film, I can't say whether or not you're reading too much into it specifically, but it's certainly been a common theme in cinema - over the past couple of decades at least - for there to be a dearth of portrayals of a genuinely redemptive character arc.
Especially so in critically acclaimed fare, the industry excells in providing the audience what it ostensibly desires - power "dynamics" bereft of a moral center, or, as Bp Barron and The Who put it, displays of the new boss, same as the old boss.
What they could have done is in the last scene Peter is shown to have signs of remorse, but only for a split second, then returns to his smile. So, it's like his conscience is trying to get to him but he is still rationalizing his act by telling himself he did it for his mom. That way he's not absolutely immoral and there is still hope for him. But, no, given that this is a Netflix film, they probably think Peter isn't evil at all.
@@krdiaz8026 I hope the filmmakers didn’t intend for him to be the hero, he’s clearly not
Interesting. Similar for me was how Wolf of Wall Street is easily enjoyed thinking its glorifying it's antiheros, but really if there is a moral to the story its that greed will destroy your soul and everything you hold dear.
The film never uses the term "toxic," this has been mapped onto it by alt-right types. The boy is never meant to be sympathetic, in my opinion-- he is highly intelligent but also cold, as when he dissects the bunny to better understand it. I see this as a story about queer life, which includes queer suffering in periods when queer lives cannot be lived freely. Phil has escaped to a homosocial wilderness, forever in thrall to a former lover (and possible rapist). He is closeted and hates women because of his inability to join heterosexual life-- so in many ways he's a poor example of "toxic masculinity," which includes objectifying women sexually. The boy kills him to save his mother-- a horrible act justified by love. I'll take that complexity over the Bishop's "turn the other cheek" stuff. Look at what Putin's doing right now. Sometimes that's not an option.
I’d love to see another movie review on The Batman, even though its a comic book character, I think the movie really gets to how his mission is one of selflessness, virtue, and steadfastness in difficult situations. Something which a lot of people lack today. (It’s a standalone film so you can go into it without needing any prior context)
This is a powerful movie. Saw it twice. It shows man’s cruelty and how what may appears to be a weaker man has strength to not be destroyed by evil power. The meek being delivered from wicked power. There is a line in
But Phil despite his outward terrible behavior, was not an evil man. That's the thing - how do we define bad and good, like the Bishop discusses.
Jesus defined human evil behavior often. Instead we need Acts of love. Phil’s cruelty while psychological and not physical is still evil. Sorry if the Bishop and I disagree in how we see evil. Not the first time either
Thoughtful.
Thank you for this review. While I wanted to know what the movie was about I knew I couldn’t watch it.
Great analysis
There are two tools of power; first is individual or personal prowess, either physical or intellectual, and the other is institutional prowess or authority.
Thanks for helping me get something out of that horrific movie. It is not good to remove a toxic powerful person with another toxic person.
Did the movie say that it was a good thing? I don't think that was the message at all.
Thanks again for thought filled insights. It seems like the Ghandi & MLKjr movements were virtuous demonstrations of change in power. That type of leadership is necessary; however, needless to say no matter our efforts we'll never recreate the garden of Eden here.
Thank you, Bishop, for your commentary. I love Benedict Cumberbatch, but I don't think I want to see him in this role. Your comments about power are spot on, especially with what is happening in Ukraine.
PRAY FOR EUROPE
I remember watching a pair of Noir series on Netflix a few years back. They left me in a sense of spiritual discomfort for days. After watching those two series, I said "done with that, no more NOIR movies or series." And by Noir, I mean there was just a cynicism, a darkness and meanness about the characters that was too much to take in.
This movie has been characterized as a "neo noir" western.
"Toxic masculinity" is not a real personality disorder, it's a modern term used to describe a combination of other personality disorders. The personalities described in the movie exhibit symptoms of malignant narcissism (if they have some conscience) or anti-social personality disorder (if they have no conscience). Both malignant narcissists and sociopaths are good at reading and exploiting the weaknesses of others, so the writer hit the personality profile accurately.
If you want film noir, then yes, by all means build your characters around the dozens of unhealthy expressions of narcissism and sociopathy that exist in the real world.
The cast of characters is infinite.
As clergy, we have the responsibility to edify others. The cynicism embodied in the screen play is simply something to be avoided to be maintain a good spiritual life. I appreciate the reference to "We won't get fooled again." Great observation, too.
But this cinematic garbage? Not worth the time.
Just a thought, as an eternal student, I look toward those who look at outward & inward facets of educational possibilities! I think it's important that great teachers always look at the many affectations of what they are teaching. In this case, what are current movies saying. Otherwise, we will become very narrow, without foundation. Isn't it more important to become narrow as a result of our moral findings, rather than the fact that we didn't look!
@@babecarla I think Bishop, in his usual diplomatic way, made his position on the movie pretty clear. However, the good spiritual life does not envision taking in literature, music or entertainment that causes harm to the soul. The saints are clear on that. Not only do they avoid the near occasion of sin, they avoid situations that could cause one to think or imagine things that are uncharitable, like a movie that senselessly indulges not only cruelty but pre-meditated cruelty for the sake of cruelty.
I am not perfect, but I cannot consume movies or literature that exhibit not only cruelty but explore the pointless exercise of it, and then leave you wondering whether the director approves, and whether the outcome justified the cruelty. That's film noir. The viewer is challenged to ask "was what I just saw immoral or not?" That's why several people have said on this board the movie made them feel uncomfortable.
By the way, a lot of action movies have moved away from delineating clear distinctions between good and evil to screenplays where it's not clear who is good and who is not. They leave the viewer uncomfortable (that's the point), and they can carry the messaging to a point where you don't know who is good and who is not. I think some of the later Batman movies and spin-offs fit into that category. Much of the series production on Netflix is noir. A friend of mine recommended "Occupied," which after two seasons became so noir and cynical that it was unpleasant to watch.
You can leave the innocent thinking that there is no distinction between good and evil, or that evil is justifiable under certain circumstances. That's the essential problem.
Finally, when we make good moral decisions, we minimize the Faustian bargains that no one wants to make. When we make dumb and careless decisions, we end up making Faustian bargains that cause harm to others. Much film noir is devoted to this ethical catch-22.
@@parishvicar7612 I understand your position and it's laudable. Therefore I guess the world is left to make determinations based on Clips or reviews they read on any particular movie. I'm not a big fan of movies anymore. Hollywood has ruined that for me. However I do find it credit-worthy that Bishop Barron does take a stand on movies and books. I miss that aspect at the Catholic Church that my parents supported. I do, however, for the younger generation's sake, believe that some of our stellar Ministry must particularize with honest reviews - the movies, books, online videos and other online genres for the sake of "Beware". Before the mind is well-formed and because families values are not so stable anymore, we have erring ways among us. Teaching the young to think is a moral imperative to me. Seeking truth and explaining good and bad it's really important. I think Bishop Barron does an amazing job at looking at our era and all of its trappings. He's certainly not afraid to speak out in almost any forum. I like that he's fearless. We need fearlessness for Jesus Christ. 👌 🌈✝️❣
@@babecarla I think some directors are trying to recapture a golden age of Hollywood with uplifting movies. Let's hope they do more.
@@parishvicar7612 well if that's true that's wonderful news to me. My mother was a great lover of old Hollywood. Our movies were very restricted when I was growing up so like my parents I became a great reader. Now of course we have many varietals of video opportunities. I still find it difficult to choose sometimes because the leaders in commercials for any given series are always designed to capture your interest. I appreciate your thorough explanation for your point of view. I don't use common colloquialisms in my speech patterns because I have family members who are rigidly elocutionist using only proper English. Even when I've tried to adapt certain terms in to my spectrum of the American/ English, I sometimes find it uncomfortable but I do understand it. I always make sure to do that otherwise you're reading or current events is muddy & becomes difficult. My parents taught me to read with a huge dictionary and thesaurus nearby. God bless you Vicar in your work and I will keep you in my prayers. When I came back to the Catholic Church after a number of years of searching other avenues, I found absolutely everything is here. So it's joyful to interact with our leaders of faith. 🌈✝️❣😎
Quadraphenia one of the great albums of all time
so cool. I want to see it
Depressing movie...but great commentary on it.
Wish youd do more film reviews
Good stuff!
Interesting
Btw, what camera do you use? The image comes through really nice and crispy
Thanks for the commentary. Note to self: don't rent 'Power of the Dog'. I think we lost that virtuous power back in the 60s. Think this movie vs. Bonanza. The theme always was: good always prevails. These were strong, powerful men but never killed out of revenge. Now it seems we have modified 'revenge' into 'justification'. It just feels good - for some bizarre reason - to watch someone terrorize others to be destroyed by their victims: and the more ruthless their demise, the better. Does no one see the evil in this picture? Yet someone can enjoy this type of film yet think of themselves as righteous...under the cloak of 'it's not real'. They still enjoyed it though, right? Yet they can watch a movie that implies an animal is being hurt, and scream 'abuse!!' - yet that could never happen in today's world on a movie; but somehow that is real?
Enjoying a movie doesn't mean condoning all of the characters or actions in the movie. That's a bit silly. They may just enjoy the movie because it makes them think and question.
I miss that jingle u used to put before the videos
So why does Actor Sam Elliot state “this movie is a piece of Shit”. Does it pertain to homosexuality?
Monsignore Eccellenza, sia lodato Gesù Cristo , avete già visto il film Father Stu ?
Sempre complimenti!
What you have brilliantly exposed here is sophism, or the idea that reality is only a matter of my perspective, and that anything I can do to sell my perspective or make it overcome your opposing perspective is valid. (Modern day sophists are called "lawyers.") Not so much "toxic masculinity" as toxic subjectivism. I haven't seen the film, but your analysis makes me want to see it.
Jordan Peterson had a good line, in ancient times there was the idea of a great power chosing not to exercise that power - the great warrior that: "keeps the sword sheathed", so to speak.
yes you are right if a very toxic power meets another toxic power there's no moral progress and society, people are stuck in their malice and so we are having no christianity alive.thank you for your deep commentary
sorry I watched this movie. Appreciate your review.
Bishop Robert Barron
Why don't you go to the debate of Sheikh Othman bin Al-Farouq so that Muslims can convert to Christianity instead of the other way around
One thing I’ll never understand: why “Hollywood” (at least in shows/movies that I’ve seen) portrays couples that, after getting married, move in with in laws that don’t like the new addition to the family. And since the new husband is a wealthy one and can afford it, can’t the newly wedded couple move out into their own house?? This movie echoes that old night soap Dallas on that point. I always thought “Bobby, why can’t you and Pam move out of Southfork and get your own mansion??!!” I mean, come on!!!
Poor Dog has to bear the stigma of toxic power. When in fact they are more likely by us to overcome it with their strength and loyalty. I guess I missed this one as i will the movie which by his description is Hollywood pushing an agenda.
🙏🏼
Not a movie that I would be interested in
Sounds a bit dreary
Sounds like an interesting movie to go see given the title. Some working dogs who start costing their owner too much in veterinarian costs after becoming homeless are never going to get hired on as mental health working dogs only because they don't have the right pedigreed piece of paper and because they don't have any fancy enough way of jumping over barriers and skating on thin ice too well enough to impress any potential master with enough disposable money to follow through on buying some dogs to properly care for yet another individual creature in their home. And so most homeless dogs then have to learn instead on how to get along with mother nature again instead while being wary of strangers in general. Unless for example it looks a certain way like some new breed of dog like what is now called an American Staffordshire terrier. Not everyone can recognize every sign of power. Like the power of a dog too. What about a different kind of sign power exists other than flesh? Only the sign of a gourd in the sky to the Ninevites was enough for them to believe without often doubting both Job and Jesus Christ in their human weaknesses allowed father in heaven to reveal in them his real power among humankind. Jesus Christ on the day of Pentecost offered his message to everyone present including those after his resurrection who continued to doubt some of his words. Yes it is true that to do all that Jesus Christ must have been consubstantial with our heavenly father.
Only the names change....
Thanks for watching this movie for me, cause im not watching that crap.
PRAISE THE LORD GOD JESUS CHRIST AMEN
I hope Bishop Robert Barron
To debate Sheikh Othman bin Al-Farouq, because many Christians have begun to leave Christianity and embrace Islam
I am also curious that he responds to Ibn al-Qayyim al-Jawziyya’s poem on the denial of Christianit
Great commentary on a disturbing movie. The revenge that plays out in the film felt like a shallow consolation in a harsh world. Certainly not enough to sustain the soul.
POTENTIAL SPOILER ALERT:
I was creeped out yet a little satisfied by how the son handled the situation and the climax. BUT the last scene was chilling. Son looks out at his mother kissing her husband, and I got a definite vibe of “watch out, man, don’t mess with her,” and I concluded that he had actually killed his own father (review his description to Phil of his father and how he was great until he started drinking too much.)
Power... a powerful mind... is to me the ability to influence... regardless of physical apperance, with knowledge and conviction. Jesus on the cross ... a message that changed the world. (I did not see the The Power of the Dog).
Bishop Barron's description of one toxic force working against another seems to describe too much of the poles of our media & leaders who too often settle for spin and sound bites to cast the other in as bad a light as possible rather than relying on relaying the truth of a situation in its most full form possible and let people use that truth, abd ultimately Trust God to use that Truth with our prayers to work out the salvation of souls even when the world isn't what we think it should be.
Dog versus shepard would be a more impacting theme
Interesting. Not a Tarantino film fan at all. Not sure I'd watch this movie either. But I was a Who fan.