Wow superb singing by both singers. Perfect notes and perfect on tune. The best thing I like is both are very sober singers. God bless both of you and your Team too !
A beautiful and wonderful song of the past but still fresh as it was before ! Both the singers sang this song beautifully and wonderfully ! Originally this beautiful song of the past was sung by Great Muhammad Rafi and Suman Kalayanpur ! Comments from Shahid Rasheed Khan from Islamabad, PAKISTAN. Comments posted on 24th August, 2020.🌻🌻💖💖💖💖🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰
Both the singers are well known keeping the control over their own part of singing. The female singers ustadi gayan is so sweet...... Oye re... Hay re.... God bless them both. Jay Jaganath.. ....................... .
I fully agree with the sentiments of the learners commentators on this forum. The relaxed but perfect rendition of this otherwise difficult song underscores their command of Hindustani classical music. Superb, indeed!
OMG.. This is simply Singing Par Excellence....Such beautiful voices and music that at times, sounds better than the original...Both have mastered the art, no doubt...And they make it look so easy, too.. Enjoyed every single note, soor and taal...Thank you so much..
This magnificent song is set in raag Sindh Bhairav...and the way Ali Hussein and Madhura Datar have rendered it is superb singing by masters...What voices they possess...truly a gift of the Gods !! And the composition..wahh!!! Just listen to the endless variations given to the single word " Balma "...Genius !!!
i heard the original song and immediatly tried to hear this pair ....ali and madhura..... both of them are suberb...well sang .... keep it up.... enjoyed...
I have been a fan of Ali Hussain ever since I saw him on Saregama many years ago. He sings all those Rafi songs that have been the center of my world for as many years as I have been listening to them. I wish he had been more widely recognized. His talent is obvious. Jeeyo!
Mr Ali keeps it simple without too many vocal acrobatics, unlike Rafi sahab, while Madhura does indulge in them with good impact. Well rendered by both.
Both are good singers.... but very mechanically sung.... Ali was technically correct and Madhura to me missed at couple of places. But both failed hugely on Bhava. This song has been made immortal by Rafi and Suman not just due to the classical quality but due to the exact replication of the naughtiness in screen, the surprise, the smile and many many other things that Mehmood and Shobha showed on screeen. This rendition was totally flat on the emotion side. When you close your eyes and try to link it to the scene the song falls flat. While i have seen many of the performances by both these two guys and have likes them..... this was hugely disappointing.
Kim Chin, Md. Rafi's voice and singing were extraordinary and unparalleled--to this day! If he used ornamentation, it was because the music director wanted them.
Phir ek baar sunne ko mila zabardast identical voice with original singers on this song by Ms. Madhura ji & Ali Hussain Sahab. Music lover (Star Maker) VK Sharma, Retd. Inspr. (DP).
So haunting, especially the words, “Meri Umar Guzarti Jaye”. I remember the Japanese concept of “Mono No Aware”, the Pathos of Things. The best way of appreciating beauty is to focus on its fleeting, transient, fragile nature.
This is a very difficult song to sing and I think both Ali Hussain and Madhura Datar not only did their job very well but surpassed the expectations of the listeners. Great future awaits these two young promising artits.
Fantastic clasicalsong Ali Hussain and madhuradatar Excellent singing and Bestperformens Beautiful ❣️💖💞❣️🥰💝🌷 🌹 thanks Allteam From Rasoolshaik MMEngineers Alinagar GUNTURTOWN AP South INDIA
Wahhhhh RAFI SAHEB v SUMAN KALYANPUR JI ka Prasidh Geet Mind-blowing Singing and Voice 🙏🙏💐💐👌👌👏👏 ATI sundar Uttam Prastuti. 14/6/2023 Rakesh Kumar Rajput in UA-cam channel and Star Maker v SAMULE aps.
Both singers are thorough with raga's technicalities and have done full justice to the musical aspects of the raga rather than simply imitating Rafi and Suman Kalyanpur. Capable of contributing much more to classical music. Great...
Aap log Bharat ke Anmol ratan ho
❤God bless both ❤
Wow superb singing by both singers. Perfect notes and perfect on tune.
The best thing I like is both are very sober singers. God bless you!
Wow superb singing by both singers. Perfect notes and perfect on tune.
The best thing I like is both are very sober singers. God bless both of you and your Team too !
Wow! Superb singing. Very close to the original. Both have mastry in classical singing. Hats off to the entire team.
Superb melodious from Ali Hussain ji and Msdhura madam. This may be 30 th time I'm hearing to the song in last one month. Really fabulous.
अली हुसेन और उनकी सहयोगी ने बहोत खूब गाया है ये गीत. रफी साहब के बाद इतना अच्छा , मेरी नजर मे, सिर्फ हुसेन जी ने गाया है
Simply fabulous..! 👏👏👏❤️
The rendition reflects the level of training the singers have undergone..!
Salute to the charm of raag based songs 🙏
Wow what a lovely classical performance awesome voice lovely modulations perfect rendition mind blowing execution waah waaaah fabulous flawless presentation 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Superb performance by both singers. Madhuraji's voice is absolutely mind-blowing. Great voice control with this classic raga. 🎯💯🙌
A beautiful and wonderful song of the past but still fresh as it was before ! Both the singers sang this song beautifully and wonderfully ! Originally this beautiful song of the past was sung by Great Muhammad Rafi and Suman Kalayanpur ! Comments from Shahid Rasheed Khan from Islamabad, PAKISTAN. Comments posted on 24th August, 2020.🌻🌻💖💖💖💖🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰
Who are these beautiful people. Hats off to their singing. They sung this masterpiece perfectly.
The musicians, the singers, aik se behtar aik, amazing talent in Maharashtra..
The song is wonderful. Original, sharayu-parakh and ali-madhura, all three renditions are soothing!
great voice god bless you both o you.....jai hind.....
Ati Sundar! Mashaallah Kya gaya hai dono ne! Ali & Madura God Bless!!
Superb, both your voice as well as looks. I loved your singing ❤
सुंदर अप्रतिम अविस्मरणीय संस्मरण और बेहतरीन तरीके से गाया है आप दोनों ने ईश्वर करे आपकी आवाज और गायकी और निखरे और महकें 🌹👌🌹
Both the singers are well known keeping the control over their own part of singing.
The female singers ustadi gayan is so sweet...... Oye re... Hay re....
God bless them both.
Jay Jaganath.. .......................
.
Ek se badkar ek. Koi kisise kam nahin. God bless all.
Mera Bharat Mahan.
Wah Ali bhai... wah Madhura ji.... Bahot khoob !
Just Amazing!Feel like listening it again &again ....so well sung both👌👌
❤❤❤😂🎉😢😮😅😊
Perfect duet of this classical song ❤❤❤
God bless you both . Sing more songs like this . All the best ....
Aise git music aawaz performance ke liye dil se bs Dua niklti h..saprem aabhar...🎉
Very well sung 👌🏻👌🏻 wonderful song
The lady also sung too good
khair.... Rafi sahab aur suman ji to magnificient hain unka koi jod nahi magar in dono ne bhi achcha gaya bahot khub...
Superb wah ...jitni tareef ho utni kam singers aur musicians dono ki ..👏👏👏👏
बहोत ही लाजवाब परफॉर्म किया हैं...बहोत मधुर
Bhai kya gaya aap dono ne speechless....sama bandh diya.
Awesome singing by both the singers congratulations to both of you
I fully agree with the sentiments of the learners commentators on this forum. The relaxed but perfect rendition of this otherwise difficult song underscores their command of Hindustani classical music. Superb, indeed!
learned,
It's amazing...... heart touching ❤
Alaap just pierced and scratched the heart. Throughout murkhiya were very very very ohhh trained voices. Hats off
Alphabetical Deepti
❤ excellent singing by both
Wahhhhh buhut hee khoob ali and mathura -KAMAL kar diya
Fantastic singing by both Ali and Madhura....God bless!
Wah kya bat kanhi kami nahi hai.khan sahib aapne rafi saheb. And madhura datar ji. Aapne suman klyaan ji ko hu b hu gaya hai jeete raho .
OMG.. This is simply Singing Par Excellence....Such beautiful voices and music that at times, sounds better than the original...Both have mastered the art, no doubt...And they make it look so easy, too.. Enjoyed every single note, soor and taal...Thank you so much..
खूप सुंदर आवाज. specially female voice and singing is superb
Unbelievable
BOTH SINGERS NICE SINGING 🙏🙏🙏
ALSO GREAT MUSICIANS 🙏🙏🙏
AAP SABNE
BHARAT RATTAN RAFI SAHAB AUR SUMAN KALYAN PUR JI KI YAD TAJA KAR DI
This magnificent song is set in raag Sindh Bhairav...and the way Ali Hussein and Madhura Datar have rendered it is superb singing by masters...What voices they possess...truly a gift of the Gods !! And the composition..wahh!!! Just listen to the endless variations given to the single word " Balma "...Genius !!!
Rajaram S .....shudh NI is used in this song.....not part of Sindh Bhairavi
I see...then which ragaa is the song based on please .
Superb both of you singer I like this song
बहोत बढ़िया। सुनकर मज़ा आ गया।
i heard the original song and immediatly tried to hear this pair ....ali and madhura..... both of them are suberb...well sang .... keep it up.... enjoyed...
Madhura and Hasan Ali both are excellent classical singers . Madhura looks very beautiful as well as innocent . I enjoyed the song many times
👍👍👍
Ohh! Excellent, both were singing beautifully and like originally.
I have been a fan of Ali Hussain ever since I saw him on Saregama many years ago. He sings all those Rafi songs that have been the center of my world for as many years as I have been listening to them.
I wish he had been more widely recognized. His talent is obvious.
Jeeyo!
He is a natural singer
Wah Ali bhai and Madhura ! Suppa !
Ati sundar 👍Bahut achi koshish,,,,, jiyo 👌
Great performance by both of you.
It's Amazaing all Time for me listening frequently.Good luck for more and more singing 🌷
I would like dying by hearing your song
Mr Ali keeps it simple without too many vocal acrobatics, unlike Rafi sahab, while Madhura does indulge in them with good impact. Well rendered by both.
Both are good singers.... but very mechanically sung.... Ali was technically correct and Madhura to me missed at couple of places. But both failed hugely on Bhava. This song has been made immortal by Rafi and Suman not just due to the classical quality but due to the exact replication of the naughtiness in screen, the surprise, the smile and many many other things that Mehmood and Shobha showed on screeen.
This rendition was totally flat on the emotion side. When you close your eyes and try to link it to the scene the song falls flat.
While i have seen many of the performances by both these two guys and have likes them..... this was hugely disappointing.
Best performance of both on classical Salam. Thanks.
Kim Chin, Md. Rafi's voice and singing were extraordinary and unparalleled--to this day! If he used ornamentation, it was because the music director wanted them.
Excellent performance byboth singers and perfect combination of.music.god blrss to all of you
Phir ek baar sunne ko mila zabardast identical voice with original singers on this song by Ms. Madhura ji & Ali Hussain Sahab. Music lover (Star Maker) VK Sharma, Retd. Inspr. (DP).
"Aj hun na aaye Baalma". Thanks.
Very well sung by both Ali Hasan and Madhura . They both deserve appreciation
Simply superb
Kya baat hai kya baat .... aha bohot achha
Waah waah waah gajab voice and gajab music
Excellent 👌👌 singing by both of you
Excellent singing👌👌
Masha Allah keep it up luv frm kolkata
अली हुसेनजी ने बहोत सहजता से गाया l बहोत खूब !
good ali ji, very nice madhura
So haunting, especially the words, “Meri Umar Guzarti Jaye”. I remember the Japanese concept of “Mono No Aware”, the Pathos of Things. The best way of appreciating beauty is to focus on its fleeting, transient, fragile nature.
Very nicely sung.. Just like the original of Rafi and Suman Kalyanpur... All the best Aliji and madhura datar.
Vinod Pillai great
well sung
Aahhhhaaa......😑 bahot khoob
Excellent singing your voice is amazing your notes is perfect
Excellent and perfect singing
This is a very difficult song to sing and I think both
Ali Hussain and Madhura Datar not only did their
job very well but surpassed the expectations of the
listeners. Great future awaits these two young
promising artits.
Not an easy song to sing, but very well sung!
अप्रतिम अप्रतिम अप्रतिम शब्द अपुरे पडत आहेत सर्व मुजिशियन धन्यवाद तसेच गायकांना सुद्धा
वाह वाह लाजवाब प्रस्तुति ....
Bahut acha ! Wonder full instrumentaliats!
Ali Bhaijaan............ Bahut shukriya.Behtereen
Nice nice
Perfect singing. Notes are to the perfect tune. Thanks for the artists.
very nicely sung by both of them esp. madhura.
this song is based on raag madhuvanti
Dono ne bahut khub gaaya gai..
Beautiful,full marks ,well done both of you
Beautiful music and superb voice 👍
Wah!! Perfect Jodi... Both singers sang very well!!! Enjoyed the jugalbandi...
अतिशय अवघड गाणं गायलं दोघांना भरपूर आशिर्वाद
Beautifully sang by both the singers. Khoob nibhaya hai...
What a sweet combination I regards all the artists with folding hands
Bahut khub bahut khub 👌👌👌👌👌💐💐💐💐💐❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹
Beautiful song sung wonderfully ❤️
Fantastic clasicalsong
Ali Hussain and madhuradatar
Excellent singing and Bestperformens Beautiful ❣️💖💞❣️🥰💝🌷 🌹 thanks Allteam
From Rasoolshaik MMEngineers Alinagar GUNTURTOWN AP South INDIA
Kya baat hai sunke dimaag cool ho gaya
Both singing tremendously... What a rendering... True justice with composition.👍👍👍👍
Very well sung !!!!!!!!Truly wonderful !!!!
Wahhhhh RAFI SAHEB v SUMAN KALYANPUR JI ka Prasidh Geet Mind-blowing Singing and Voice 🙏🙏💐💐👌👌👏👏 ATI sundar Uttam Prastuti. 14/6/2023
Rakesh Kumar Rajput in UA-cam channel and Star Maker v SAMULE aps.
भाई वा,जान भर दीया.
Just love All kind of Indian classical music....filmi or non filmi ...rooh ki khuraak!!
No words, just ,"EXTREMELY SUPERB"
Both singers are thorough with raga's technicalities and have done full justice to the musical aspects of the raga rather than simply imitating Rafi and Suman Kalyanpur. Capable of contributing much more to classical music. Great...
Venkat Krishnan Rafi nahin Rafi sahab
Well written
Dono singer ko bahot bahot badhai 👍🏼🌹👏🏼
Just superb!i I love to watch it again &again so well sung great !👍🏼👍🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
Well complemented each other, and look at them appreciate each other as they go about doing their vocal histrionics...
Wow ... Voice soothing to ears ...
technically fit and touching to heart 💓 ...
God bless ...🤔🤔🔥🔥😍😍😘😘😘😘😘😘
Wonderful performance, true tribute to Rafi Saab.Good wishes from Canada
वाह,मां सरस्वती का.आशीर्वाद है दोनों को, लड़की ने तो कमाल ही कर दिया।
Excellent performance 🙏❤🙏❤🙏