Battle of Quebec | Animated History
Вставка
- Опубліковано 12 вер 2024
- Sign up for The Armchair Historian website today using promo code: REVOLUTION, and receive a 50% discount for your first month:
www.thearmchai...
Ironside Computers - Click here to customize your own PC: ironsidecomput... *USE DISCOUNT CODE "History" FOR 5% OFF!*
Sources:
1775: A Good Year for Revolution
Book by Kevin Phillips
100 Decisive Battles: From Ancient Times to the Present
Book by Paul K. Davis
Warfare In The Ninteenth Century
Book by David Gates
Battles of The Revolutionary War 1775-1781
Book by W.J. Wood
A Guide to the Battles of the American Revolution
Book by Theodore P. Savas & J. David Dameron
Cracking the AP U. S. History Exam, 2018 Edition
Book by Princeton Review
Music:
Epic Battle Speech by Wayne Jones
Elegy by Wayne Jones
All This - Scoring Action by Kevin MacLeod is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution license (creativecommon...)
Source: incompetech.com...
Artist: incompetech.com/
Hero's Theme by Twin Musicom is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution license (creativecommon...)
Source: www.twinmusicom...
Artist: www.twinmusicom...
And Awaken - Stings by Kevin MacLeod is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution license (creativecommon...)
Source: incompetech.com...
Artist: incompetech.com/
Big Horns Intro 2 by Audionautix is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution license (creativecommon...)
Artist: audionautix.com/
Faceoff by Kevin MacLeod is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution license (creativecommon...)
Source: incompetech.com...
Artist: incompetech.com/
Long Note Two by Kevin MacLeod is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution license (creativecommon...)
Source: incompetech.com...
Artist: incompetech.com/
Cortosis - Scoring Action by Kevin MacLeod is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution license (creativecommon...)
Source: incompetech.com...
Artist: incompetech.com/
Long Note Three by Kevin MacLeod is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution license (creativecommon...)
Source: incompetech.com...
Artist: incompetech.com/
Victoria II. Copyright © 2018 Paradox Interactive AB. www.paradoxplaza.com
Antonio Salieri, Twenty six variations on La Folia de Spagna
London Mozart Players
Matthias Bamert, as conductor
Thanks for watching guys, if you want to support my channel then sign up for The Armchair Historian website today using promo code: REVOLUTION, and receive a 50% discount for your first month:
thearmchairhistorian.com/
You can also sign up for our newsletter on the website by scrolling to the bottom of the home page.
Just imagine what a great country it could be if revolution spread to Canada and it would become a part of USA.
I know that you probobly dont knowe much about the finnish front during ww2 but i would love if you made a video about things like the battle of Tali-Ihantala or Raatentie
History Time I doubt it he only reason Canada flourished was because of Her Majesty’s Empire and your incompetence in battle before you bring up the revolutionary war the only reason you won good sir was because the French bankrupted themselves and their empire helping you and nearly did the Spanish so rethink your statement old chap . Yours sincerely , Papa Britain
Don't worry, fuzion. Now we have fiat money backed by thin air, so the next war can go on forever, just as you wish
If you want to take British/Canadian land and want the help of the Frrnch near by, If the French live In one part of their land, Like a province, Agian If you want their help, Don't take the one French province that they have......
Holy shit one of the history channels actually discovered Canada exists
Jen Lucille
Well, ever since the US started using its own oil Canada isn’t exactly important.
@@matthew8153 Uh huh... It's not like we're the US's biggest trade partner, that we helped build the Manhattan Project, that we are the world's 11th largest economy, that we are one of the world's biggest and most important tech hubs, that the 4th largest city in North America after Mexico City, New York and Los Angeles is in Canada, that we have more global diplomatic clout these days than Trumpland, that we developed crucial medical advances like insulin, invented the telephone, played major roles in both World Wars and the Cold War or solved the Suez Crisis... right?
@@K1ddkanuck As Much as I like all that you're Saying, Alexander Gram Bell had Dual Citizenship between Canadian and American and Worked on the Telephone in BOTH Countries, so Technically the Phone is the Product of BOTH Canada AND the US... a Distinction I Prefer to saying it was just one country or the other, as it shows what can Be Achieved When Allied Countries Cooperate (so to speak)
@@matthew8153 What do oil politics have to do with the fact Canada gets constantly ignoring or lied about? Oh nothing
KG Motte
And that’s why both use the same country code “1”.
Invade Canada in the winter they said. It’ll be easy, they said...
at times Canada's even colder than russia
When the snow spoke tabarnark
lol should have gotten toronto
@@Rage_Quiting yeah but toronto didnt exist yet.
Rage gamer it was called York
When you're invading Quebec but the snow starts saying "Tabernac!"
We say: tabarnak!
Your welcome 😉
Attaquer means fire in english.
Artur212222 Attaquer means attack, feu means fire.
Bein oui criss!
@Anton Boludo where the river narrows
Lol i guess Canada is like Russia
NEVER ATTACK IT IN WINTER!
Here's how a invasion of Canada would be. Begin in spring, Capture all key cities. Canada has fallen. Now you have to deal with Guerilla in a HUGE country. Canada would easily fall, not the population.
TriEdgedPrism Let’s just leave that to your imagination shall we?
It regularly gets to -40 in places like Sudbury, where plenty of people still live . Definitely not a good idea to invade in winter, the cold also lasts virtually 9 months a year.
@@Original_Dalvik He said the country would fall, but the nationalism is unbreakable.
TriEdgedPrism No, begin in mid-late winter so then you have spring, summer, and fall to win.
“How did America lose in Canada?”
They mistook kindness for weakness.
*AMERICA 🌎 = NORTH AMERICA + CENTRAL AMERICA + SOUTH AMERICA.*
The U.S. is not America. America is the name of our Continent, from Canada to Argentina. They called themselves America without consulting North, Central, and South America. That group of united states in our American continent, who wants to own the World, never had a country name like us.
Latin Americans are happy to be part of America since 1492. Some since 14,000 years ago.
U.S citizens are US Americans, Unitedstatesians, USANIANS, or USONIANS.
They are from North America. We are from South America. *WE ARE ALL AMERICANS!*
Please, people of the world, respect us and share this.
Please call them USONIANS.
Yola Montalvan thankyou Capt Literal... the “United States of America”, commonly referred to as “The States”, its inhabitants commonly refer to themselves as “Americans”... Im pretty sure most intelligent people know all this, but good for you for wanting to prove your superior intelligence...
Hal Kael - You mean, learning English and finding out I am not American, they even told me on my face I was never American even though I’m from South America? How can that give me superior intelligence? Now I’m in the process of learning French, will that make me Super Duper Intelligent? I give you credit for using the word “themselves”, well I’m still doing research on this subject so that we can correct this bigly mistake. Only 10% of Latin Americans know English, can you imagine if 90% learn English and find out they are not Americans a we were taught in School?
@@halkael2317 I think they refer to themselves as "Mericans"...
The use of that Monty Python sketch to illustrate the fact the American (which speak English) couldn't get through Québec's walls (built by the French) was spot on.
But the Citadel was built by the English.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Citadelle_of_Quebec
snnwstt the french already had defenses,the city was already impenetrable before the english conquered quebec back in 1759
@@snnwstt no in 1759 the citadel was already built by the french..that why the british were shooting over the walls with mortier and cannons in 1759!
@@Linguiniqc The actual citadel was built in the early 1800, to protect the city against a possible invasion by Americans.
It's not that the French were "loyal" to the british. It's mostly because we had a way better guarantee that our religion and language would be respected with the crown. That's all I wanted to say.
The british didn't really keep their promises either but we kept our culture despite their attempts to subjugate us
You see what the US did to Louisiana. Got rid of their French Creole language and made them speak English.
In the end francophones are still proud and managed to preserve their culture whereas look at Louisiana they can't even speak French anymore I would say Canada did honour the promise to the french and now Canada is a official bilingual state.
I think it was more like a Fight or Die situation
French Canadians were Catholics (still are) and spoke French. The British loyalist were scared the French Canadians would turn against them (by joining France Catholics, the Pope State, America)
Spent a few days in an airbnb on the Plains of Abraham. If you ever have a chance, Quebec City is a wonderful city to visit.
Except in March, smelting gray snow (snow covered with calcium salt) almost everywhere...
@@snnwstt Slush?
Ryuko T-72 nah In Quebec they leave the snow in the street which mean there is an incredibly high about of it.... Which mean even in spring when its hot, there is still snow but its black instead of a pure white
snnwstt , right.
Guys, I grew up and still live in Québec city, winter is long (and I have no problem with it), but when comes the melting weeks... all this snow mixed with salt becomes a dirty water and the streets are gray... And then arrives May, everything turns green and everyone turns on seeing legs! Come and visit us, you should have a good time!
Really? I had servers in restaurants walk away from our table and not serve us because we didn't speak French. And that's just one Instance I've seen personally when I was last in Montreal. Not one good thing to say about the people I encountered lol
Catholic French Canadians knew that they would be assimilated in an English Protestant US. They used the revolutionary war to ensure concessions from the British. In particular the French language and the Catholic religion were protected. This is one of the reasons why Canada is officially bilingual and you can go to a public catholic school
There's an awful lot of Catholics in the US, though
+LoneLittleJerry There weren't many Catholics in the U.S. at the time. They didn't arrive until much later, when the Irish, Italians, and Eastern Europeans such as Poles began moving to the U.S. in large numbers. Before then and for quite a while since there was very strong anti-Catholic sentiment. Even JFK had to deal with some amount of anti-Catholicism during his presidential run, and that was in 1960, not too far from today.
Collin Hicks Yeah exactly. They knew they would get a better deal from the British.
Oh, I didn't know that. I just assumed that there were always lots of Catholics in the US. Thanks for informing me
@@lonelittlejerry917 im the son of a catholic german family and polish catholic. I think eastern Europe lost alot of good farmers back then. Our motto should be we take the best because were the US.
We have a sign that reads ''This is where the Americans were repelled'' in the old part of Québec city :3
Didn't know that, that's cool
Salutations de Montréal
America did take a beating back then, it did teach us something.
When I visit again I will have to keep my eye out. Best Fortifications ive seen in the entire continent. Weaving streets, tall walls, beautiful architecture.
@@Ryuko-T72 Id suggest visiting the ''Musée Des Plaines D'Abraham'' they have a bunch of high quality replicas of 7 year war era uniforms and even some stuff you can touch, like muskets and a coat :3
Doesn’t everyone hate Quebec?
"Your mother was a hamster and your father smelled of elderberries!" ;)
I fart in ur General directions
Use the Holy Hand grenade!
Oh sir ;) 😂😂😂
How dare you sir
You speak with an "Outrageous Accent"
And 40 years later the americans tried and failed agian.
And we burned the White House
It’s Almost Like the Americans didn’t learn from their last defeat
@@Flour5665 *You* burned nothing, British regulars directly from Europe raided the city and burned it, after *we* burned your parliament building.
@@tremedar you burnt down a temporary outpost not the current parlement . Canada was part of Britain so the distinction at this time was zero really .
We burned the parlement by ourself!
We had super soldiers , injected maple syrup into there veins and we still have it now
In Greece we inject the soldiers with our famous yogurt-garlic sauce.Unstopable!
@Alex Vlaxos nai and zevana
Canada has the most peaceful neighbour in the world!... Greenland!
Pity about the one on the other side though.
Yep, and we love ya, too.
Yeah we are on pretty good terms with all 15 people that live there
As you no doubt typed your response using your American Apple or Android powered phone responding to a video you watched on American UA-cam owned by American Google. My aren't you just beaming with pride of your bigotry and hatred.
@@Simonsvids alaska? Or America, I know Alaska is America.
Canadian: have some bacon
American: that's not bacon it's just thickly sliced ham!
Canadian: THIS MEANS WAR!!!
The term 'Canadian Bacon' is actually an American term, not a Canadian one.
@@bluesteel8376 shut up american america is full of terrorist attacks
I congratulate you for this very thorough and excellent video about this battle. The question of the degree of support from French Canadians to the Americans at this time is a very interesting one. I understand it couldn't be within the scope of your video, but the British adopted the Quebec Act in 1774, which not only enlarged the territory of the colony (against the wishes of Americans, who were understandably angry about this) but also gave some degree of recognition to the French Canadians. Catholic church was officially tolerated in the colony and French Canadians were no longer in the obligation to abjure their faith to get a position in political or public service. The catholic church paid back this official recognition by actively promoting British loyalty to their new French Canadians' subjects. We must also understand that the British in Quebec were at that time largely outnumbered by French Canadians, who were for the most part farmers as their economical and political elite went back to France after 1760. I would resume by saying that French Canadians of this period were ''encouraged'' to support British rule. The British knew what they were doing.
I'm gonna be honest here,seeing the americans failling to take my hometown is oddly satisfying.
Becoz They only like to roll the tales of their victory !
grosbrun17 It's the hometown of my French Canadian g-g-g grandmother.
grosbrun17 bitch, you’re probably the great-great-great-great grandson of one American soldier, so it wasn’t completely unsuccessful.
@@kyktj1283 loool
you're from Quebec?
Wait. THIS ISN'T A HOI4 VIDEO!
more like a victoria 2
@@evanmedi6144 or Total War Empire
The English damn well knew of the planes of Abraham! It was how they took it from the french. Hell as a young Canadian school child we went to Quebec to see the location of the battle between the French and English, and the US invasion was not even mentioned.
Most Americans don't know about it. I had someone arguing with me yesterday that the Americans had never attacked us before the War of 1812. I brought up the attack on Quebec during their Revolution.
Quebeckers born and raise here, Quebec city is a huge fortress and the only reason why the brits could take it was because the frenchs just stopped to provide food and reinforcement. good video thank you pal
Well, usually, the victorious side in Europe was traditionally taking back whatever colonies having been lost at the conclusion of the treaty ending the war. At least, French were relaying on that. But they lose it, in Europe. So. Yes, there is even the mention: "We don't care for the stables" that is, New France, " when the house ", France, " is burning."
Also note that at Quebec, English were able to fire across the St-Lawrence river from the south shore of Levis, with their canons, while the French were unable to shoot back because the river was too wide, not because they were out of ammo. Technology was part of the game too. And While the British were inside the wall, they were besieged by the French, for all winter (British losing their sortie, at the battle of Ste-Foy). In short, Quebec felt to the first … ship... reaching it early next year. And it was an English one.
@Antoine Gauthier the frwnch had more men than the brits in the battle plains of Abraham
Antoine Gauthier one tiny detail: the Citadel did not exist at the moment of the British invasion. It was just an incomplete fortification system. The Brits actually built the citadel as it stand now, but only after the war of 1812.
@@PG-sq5pt
French side:
-1900 regulars
-1500 others
British side:
-4400 regulars
Losses were nearly the same on both sides.
Wrong, you are a Quebecois
Outstanding Series!!! Being an amateur historian myself, I can’t tell you enough how much I am enjoying the armchair historian. Thank you for all your time and hard work gentlemen! My hat is off to you. May God bless you in continuing your great success with this channel.
This is spooky. I had just watched OverSimplified's videos on the American revolution. I also was in Montreal last month for the first time so I was really curious to learn more about this part of history. Amazing timing!
Si vous cherchez un commentaire français(québécois), nous somme ici.
Sans faute, on percevrait une moins grande assimilation vers le monde anglo...
Bonjour
Cool
The war of independence was about British people, not happy about taxation without representation, fighting British people. It was only then the inhabitants of America became American. Years later when these American people tried to fight the British people in Montreal and Quebec they lost. There was no notion of being Canadian just the land being called Canada. These people then became Canadian. Therefore Britain has never lost a war to America.
So the war of 1812 didn't happen?
Yes the war of 1812 did happen but it was America against Britain. Most of the French fought along side the British as they liked the Americans less than they liked the British and as soon as Americans crossed the border they were the invading force as the British/Canadian people were at least from there.
LIES!
The truth is that maple syrup is like a super soldier serum! Those Canadians are invincible.
What about someone from Vermont?
@@a_random_person2230 those aren’t real Canadians
@@nathandutton2860 yeah they are its just that they lost a war to Britain
What we see in this video is a British victory won by British troops. But that was not the case. Most of the British regulars from Québec City were sent to the area of Montreal at the time of the battle. Defence was mostly done by the few British artillery crews left who joined with old French veterans of 1759 to fire canon. The fights in the streets were mostly done by local militia and sailors whose boats were trapped in ice around the city. It's true that few British regulars were there too, but the defence of Québec City and the capture of the invaders was a success because of the collaboration of all those different groups who united and worked together.
By the way, I walk each day where Benedict Arnold was shot when going to work.
Arnold's passage up the Kennebec and Chaudiere Rivers in Maine, portaging through swamps and and across streams, is gruelling even by today's standards. The over 1/3 of his men whom he lost on the journey didn't die, they simply turned back due to the insanity.
At least by that time of year the bugs were dead :P
The Americans got poutined
Today they are being Putin-ed.
@@Slymel22 Canadians are still being Putin-ed. Fuggit 'bout it
No le sirop d'érable bouilli 😆😆😆😆🇲🇶⚜️
Thats hot
I live in Montreal and I definitely learned this at school.
This is why you don't fight in the winter in a northern environment
During the war of 1812, the Americans still couldn't win in summer.
todd reaker It’s because in the summer, you get eaten alive by hordes of mosquitos 😅
todd reaker we won the war dumbass
@@Alexander79080 America lost to Britain and the Canadian colonies get a history book uneducated hillbilly
Kenny Twd The goal of the U.S. was to stop Britain from kidnapping men from America to work for the British Navy. America achieved its goal, Britain did not. Maybe you should get an education my friend
The American patriots never really thought-through how they could appeal to the French Canadians. The Declaration of Independence complains about the loss of "English" freedom in Canada, without mention of the French. In fact, the British law cited actually gave MORE recognition to the French. So from the French Canadian perspective, it was very unclear if English Americans would give them more or less freedom than the British. And let's also remember that it was largely American colonial troops, not British redcoats, that the French Canadians had fought against in the French and Indian War (with George Washington playing a big role).
While the execution may have been terrible, the strategy was very sound. Taking Quebec City could have got France into the war early, while giving them an easily defendable base for operations (while simultaneously denying it to the British).
The Declaration wasn't published yet, though. But you're right, it was pretty uncertain; meanwhile, the British had re-established the rights to speak French and practice the catholic religion in 1774.
@@Mercure250 The Quebec Act, it actually pissed off the americans and was one of the "Intolerable Acts" cited to declare the war. So, I dont think they had the interest of Quebecers in mind, more like territory grab.
@@samsix4340 Yeah
FreedomFox1 ,
Yes, George Washington is not very often cited for his defeat in 1754 where he signed a French paper he couldn't read and took the responsibility for the death of an innocent. Does this tells something to anyone?
Brits to French Canadians: Stay with us we won't respect you!
Americans to French Canadians: Join us, we won't respect you!
France to French Canadians: We'll give up on you because we don't respect you!
Did I mention where I'm from?
Great video! It is also interesting how the French Canadians were one of the main reasons for the United States' failure in seizing Canada. Though some French Canadians did aid the Americans, forming units that would later become two Continental Army regiments, the majority remained neutral. This neutrality could be argued as being caused not only by the confirmed power the British Empire had since the French and Indian War versus the United States' seemingly weak position, but also by the fact that word must have reached the French Canadians as to the great amount of hostility from the majority of the colonists that was directed at Catholics. Furthermore, Governor and General Guy Carleton's Canada Act of 1774 gave the French Canadians surer benefits than if they sided with the Americans. And though Guy Carleton overestimated the loyalty of the British during this conflict (He would not be proven right until the War of 1812), the French Canadian majority's neutrality meant that the United States' depleted contingents could not receive adequate reinforcements and recruits from amongst the Canadian populace.
Most important reason was religion.. Quebecois were Catholics and they were allowed to have their Civil Laws. If Revolutionaries will take control, they should have lost all their benefits and their Catholic Religion that was most important for them.
Great video, always enjoy seeing discussion on often overlooked battles. Through to that end a video on The Siege of Detroit/Battle of Fort Detroit would be great to see.
Thanks again for the great work.
As a side note, Ethan Allen took a splinter group of men and attacked Montreal where he was defeated and captured by the local garrison just down the street from where I lived for 19 years. That was at the Picard house where St. Catherine and Notre Dame streets meet. The city dedicated a gazeebo in one of the parks to him in the east end of the island. He was kept prisoner for a couple of years before being exchanged (and presumedly opening some furniture stores in Maine)
Damn so what we learned in school is actually known by the rest of world... Americans would love cities like Québec, there is literally canons and battlefield remnants everywhere
My Man Uploaded 2 Video's in 3 Day My Dude On A Time Crunch. I Respect the Hustle!
Starting on the 11th, I'll be doing my first ever 100 work week marathon. Looking forward to keeping the momentum going!
@@TheArmchairHistorian Well i hope you do keep doing these amazing video's! they are always enjoyable to watch.
I have a 15 year old ancestor and his 17 year old brother, who were both at Quebec, both had contracted smallpox. They were abandoned on the Isle d'Orléans. They were approached by the British solders later on and told that they would come back in a month and if they were still alive, they would be taken prisoners. They were both taken to the prison ships in Elizabeth N.J. At the age of 15 and 17 they were both veterans of Ticonderoga and Bunker Hill.
I had never heard of that war before. You tube IS still a useful place. Thanks for your channel !
French-Canadians didn't co-operate because they weren't fools. They didn't like the British BUT the British had agreed to protect their right to their language and their religion after they took over. I'd say they knew full well that they would get no such guarantee if they joined the Americans. Although not perfect, obviously even today, circa 250 years or so later, these rights are still taken seriously and afforded legislative protection in Canada so they made a smart decision.
Canadians are just tougher than Americans in every way... And the good guy always wins in the end! Pure hearts, Open eyes... !
@Idk Idk how can you explain Canadians are really nice
The ISorrows Historian™
He knows nothing
Many of you reading this probably don't know much about Quebec City. The old city is the closest thing to Europe in North America, a walled city with great old buildings and character. When you see the it from the river you begin to understand how daunting an objective it was. And the Plains of Abraham are definitely haunted.
"...And the Plains of Abraham are definitely haunted." I live in Québec city. Nowadays, Plaines of Abraham is much more a playground for the city residents than a symbol of commemoration. Really.
Vive le Québec libre!
This video was pretty interesting :)
Vive le canada
Viva le Canada as the previous referendum has proved more people in beautiful Quebec love the rest of Canada then you haters. and the little animosity which is left is going to fade away as the great white north grows older. Quebec is Canada. 🇨🇦
As René Lévesque, the founder of the modern separatist mouvement said: « Quebec nationalism isn’t about hating something, it’s about loving something » and we don’t hate Canada per say, we hate our forced relationship and the history we had with Canada…
We barely survived as a nation and we are not ready to die out just yet..
@@ryanhuntrajput474lol, idk how what you take but you are high on copium bro
I live in Montgomery County, NY, which is named after Richard Montgomery. Awesome video!
Most French Canadian Catholics probably did not see the point of exchanging one set of English Protestants for another, or get involved in their family quarrel.
Also the canadien catholic church threatened to excommunicate any Canadien who joined the americans because the British were the ones who restored their powers. There are some accounts of Canadiens militating for their people to join the Americans but fear of british retaliation and the domination of the church made Canadiens stay on the British side.
Merci pour la leçon! 🇨🇦🤘
Craig Kilborn while interviewing Mike Myers on the Daily Show, "Canada, 1867...what went wrong???..." *shakes his head and shrugs. audience erupts in laughter* one of my funniest memories from television
Dude!! I'm from Montreal and I had no idea that it had been occupied.... Totally blown away...
America to Canada: u are opressed , u are been liberated, do not resist!
I'm surprised you didn't mentioned the french-canadian siding with the british at the battle of quebec. There was french militia engaged.
Engage at the point of the guns, yeah.
@@Emrod82
No they joined due to the concessions that were promised to them. The British didn't want them on their backs while fighting the colonials.
Actually the according to all of the sources from the time, the average Canadian supported the Americans. Read “documents relating to Canada” and “Baby’s journal” both show this.
@@doswheelsouges359 only the Elite supported the British. The Average Canadian supported the rebels
@@nicholasmckenna8614 I'm sorry to tell you that this is wrong. The Brits granted the free practice of catholicisme, the American would not. A minority of French Canadian supported the Americans, but most didn't.
Can you do a video about the 1837 French-Canadian rebellion? Good video by the way, I never thought someone would do a video about this. Nobody knows about it in Quebec except me and the ones who watched this video.
pour ton info -> pierre falardeau a fait un film sur l'insurrection des patriotes de 1837. le film s'appelle: 15 février 1839
Super, merci beaucoup pour ca. Je ne pensais voir quelqun faire une vidéo sur cette guerre. Carley Price
What are you saying? It is taught in every school! There is even a big commemorative plaque on Rue de la Barricade in the Old Town...
which battle? The one with 100 angry drunk bargoers that were stopped by a police barricade? or the time they tried to set up a republic on the niagara river
The one where they wanted to make Downer-Canada an independent country.@@Ryuko-T72
'Highly inaccurate maps' is an understatement. The maps the British military surveyors released to the public hid isolated harbors that could be used as staging grounds, and underestimated distances through uninhabited territory. Accurate maps were a closely held secret of the navy and army. Arnolds map underestimated the distance from the Dead River in Maine to Quebec City by over 300 miles.
See, Marquis de Montcalm ?. When you hold a fortified city with fewer men than the enemy, you don't command a suicidal sortie, you hide behind your walls.
And Americans say "we kicked your ass"
When,
in reality, it was the other way round.
They still won the war so that doesn't matter
@@jijorassad709 no they didn’t
@@sumrandumguy7177The battle was part of the Revolutionary war.
Nice video! Always enjoyable
How come I have absolutely no memory of learning this in history class
We need to try again.
WOAH! AN UPLOAD ON A SUNDAY?! GRIFFIN. WHAT IS THIS MADNESS?
Québec (kebec) .... where the river narrowed ...c'est cela mes amis ⚜️🇲🇶t
The North remembers.
Ah lovely. I love seeing videos where the good guys win :)
Good guys and bad guys are opinionated. But I guess America did attack.
Theres no such thing as good guys.
Theres Winners And losers.If you Win you are a good Guy,If you lose you are evil
History in a nutshell
You're saying the British were good? Boy, the naivety is real.
@@Commanderhurtz1 Objectively speaking, yes. :)
@@Lord_Lambert Do I need to mention the Opium wars? Do I need to mention the British basically did the same to the native Canadians? Do I need to mention how the British treated the Irish and the Scots? No, they were not objectively better. And worse off, Britain has LOST almost all of their territory. All of the territories they got basically became brother states instead of being controlled by the Crown, which said Crown is ruled by the Parliment now. And NOW their populations being replaced by less inteligent and murderous zealots...That are being invited in with welcome arms, while being 'black washed' out of their own history.
I'm a 9th generation of SON'S OF THE AMERICAN REVOLUTION in the State of Maine, CHAPTER B. Arnold which at that time was part of Massachusetts. Maine didn't enter State-hood until 1820.
I've crossed the Benedict Arnold trail while hunting hunting deer in the middle of Nov, this was a rough hunt never mind a march for any Army,, He'd been better to started this trek in May instead of Oct.. His men had to build boats to cross the Kennebeck river, as you can;t imagine how heavy the green boats were, they had no food nor shelter, allot of his men had to turn back because of illness.
In short they weren't much of a force to take on the Brits, The ST Lawrence stood in between them and Canada was safe. I wish The ARMCHAIR HISTORIAN WOULD HAVE MENTIONED SOME OF THIS ARMY'S MISFORTUNES. thank you
Nicely done video, makes it easy to understand and entertaining as well.
*Sips maple syrup in undefeated in any war entered attitude*
I love how Americans and Canadians have totally different views on this lol
That was the moment the Americans learned that under Canada’s nice warm wooly mitten of friendship and politeness is a solid tungsten hockey glove of military skill and pure hate and Arnold was unlucky because he had the puck.
They fought the British, not the Canadians.
@@dmeads5663 well they were canadian's seeing as A all the troops were recruited form upper and lower Canada, and b all Britain did was sense a bunch of generals officers and a few hundred crates of red uniforms so the Americans were fighting Canadian's.
RedFox jack many Canadians fought along side the Americans, especially those in New Brunswick, the nationality of “American” and “Canadian” didn’t exist back then. The US fought against trained British soldiers, not Canadian militias.
Correct me (Canadian), if I am wrong: The USA has not had great success when starting wars (unless you consider Grenada), only finishing them. On the other hand, Canadians are nice and peaceful, until they are not ...
By winning the Battle of Quebec, the English won Canada but ultimately
lost the 13 Colonies. I don't know if they won on the exchange. What is
certain, that the British government lacked common sense and foresight,
but they were blinded by an anti Catholicism and an exacerbated
nationalism, they wanted at all costs to do battle with France. In the
mid-eighteenth century from the English point of view, remaining at
peace with France was out of the question, as English superiority was
evident in America, whether in demographic, military or naval terms.
Remained in peace, was equated with treason. The reality was that the
French were not a serious threat to the English colonies because Canada,
unlike the 13 colonies, was sparsely populated, and the royal navy,
which dominated the sea, could at any time isolated Canada by blocking
it. help that France could send. On the contrary, the French had their
uses in America, they were like a scarecrow! In so much war, by isolated
raids, (which had no influence on the course of the war) in the company
of Indian auxiliaries, they put pressure on the colonists by spreading
death and terror, constantly reminding the colonists that they needed
the crown. This terror allowed the unity of the settlers behind the
king. As long as the French were there, the settlers depended on the
king for their protection, the fear they inspired and the military
dependence of the settlers ensured the complete loyalty of the settlers.
You make this fear disappear, you also make their dependence and their
loyalty disappear. Because no longer having a French threat, the king
and his soldiers were no longer useful to the colonists, on the contrary
even by prohibiting the colonists from settling beyond the Appalachians
(royal proclamation of 1763), by attributing the valley of the 'ohio to
the French of Canada (Intolerable Act 1774) and by claiming taxes to cover the expenses of the
war, the crown had become an obstacle and an unnecessary burden that
they no longer needed to bear. If the British had not gone to war
against France or if Wolf had lost the Battle of Quebec it is almost
certain that there would not have been American independence and the
thirteen colonies would have remained English colonies like Canada or
Australia until the beginning of the 20th century.
Great point. The 7 year war against France came with great cost for Britain. After the victory, Britain demanded the american colonials to finance the cost of war by saying : since we saved you from the french. Rest is history.
Now talk about the battle of the Chateauguay during the 1812 war and how Lieutenant Colonel Charles-Michel de Salaberry sent the Americans packing.
Nothing like taking a quick drive over to the site of that battle to breathe in the sweet smell of Canadian Victory.
Hey I did I project on that in grade 10!
One of the nicer parts about it was that the casualties on both sides were really low about 22 for Britain/Canada/Mohawks and 85 for America (only 23 of which were deaths)
Then talk about the Battle of York
Then he can talk about in the War of 1812, The Battle Of New Orleans, when Colonel Jackson sent the British packing!
If there's one thing we Americans and Canadians have in common, it's our license to gloat!
Lol
Dillon Crowe ah battle of New Orleans a battle that shouldn’t have happened because the war had already ended damn you technology god damn you not being advanced enough
Quebec is like Asterix the Gaul's village against the Romans...you can control the territory but you never gonna get rid of us...:-)
"The maple leaf forever!"
@Caped Crusader soon sadly Venezuela will no longer be an independent country most likely
Venezuela wishea
There will come a grave day for Canada known as the day of the rake where a great number shall be swept away
Same
josh77577 wait why?
For those of you interested in historical fiction, there's a really good book about this by Kenneth Roberts. It's called Arundel.
Follow these principles:
-Wither: Advance through terrain which reduces your manpower and equipment - check
-Hurry: Start the campaign in a hurry so the enlisted men's service time is about to be expired - check
-Expose: Pick the late of the year, so winter hampers your forces - check
-Go blind: Don't scout the enemy fortress before the campaign, to know its strength and required guns - check
-Gung-ho! Attack a fortess with smaller forces than the defender has - check
-Drag: Move around with prisoners during an attack.
-Be visible: Wait in the sight and reach of the enemy.
... and what could possibly go wrong?
Contrary to some commentaries. this is NOT why Canada is bilingual. 1)Because Canada IS NOT bilingual. Only the French speaking population is bilingual.
This battle is why Canada exist. Not why it’s bilingual.
2)Canadian bilingualism is a ploy to give a legal platform to oppose the provincial language law in Quebec, therefore enabling the tsunami of Anglos coming to Quebec
To simply say: “Montreal is in Canada, therefore If I want to speak English only, it’s my right…. “.
There’s not a statement more wrong and misleading that stating Canada is bilingual because of this battle. Reference to bilingualism appeared right after Rene Lesveque founded the P.Q.
Bilingualism is one of the tactics to undermine Quebec nationalism. How’s French doing in Saskatchewan?
The law on Bilingualism SOLE OBJECTIVE IS MEANT TO NEUTRALISE QUEBEC’S LAWS. How’s French doing in Saskatoon? In Regina? about Red Deer? Cause you can be served breakfast in english virtually anywhere in Quebec.
The Official Languages Act / Historica Canada
ua-cam.com/video/lIVMh97mHxw/v-deo.html
Religion was quite important for the french Canadians of the time.
The patriots (the US ones, not the Canadian party of around 1830s) where painted as both staunchly anti-french and staunchly anti-Catholic. I do think that if those 2 where not the case, or if the British did not just pass the act giving BACK to the french their rights to have churches and own property (among other things like having the right to work in the administration of the colony), history would be perhaps different and Québec might be a US state instead of a Canadian province.
Regardless interesting video, it did cover something history class glossed over.
Saying ''French canadian'' for that time period is also innacurate. Back then, the only Canadians were french.
@@SirGenderon that is true all anglos living in that territory of that time period where British loyalists.
Hooray for Quebec! Je me souviens! Best city in North America. Safe. Clean. Historic.
Thank You For Sharing 🇺🇸
Interesting. Canada, Vietnam and Cuba share similar historical experiences, having repelled American invasions.
We would have maintained the 13 colonies but for the greater value of the Caribbean sugar trade and the opportunism of the Good old neighbours of ours France.
Finally someone said Quebec right
"Captain Morgan did exactly what you'd expect: " make rhum.
Sorry. Wrong Captain Morgan!
the bullet hole in the hat was more amusing than it should have been, nice touch.
I very much enjoy your channel already. But by god I’ll be damned if you did you not win my subscription at *roughly* 3:50 with the “Quest for the Holy Grail” reference.
“Your mother was a hamster!
And your father smelt, of elderberries!”
I find it interesting how this video really downplays the role of local Canadian militias. As well the comments...
" In November 1775, Governor Carleton organized the defenders of Quebec City to face a siege by the American rebels. British regular troops were few in number. Canadian militia, from both the anglophone and francophone communities, made up the majority of the defenders. The militia of Quebec City was divided into two sections in 1775-'Canadian Militia' drawn from the francophone population, and 'British Militia' made up of anglophones."
en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Colonial_militia_in_Canada
They never mention this in US schools!
Maybe because it's too embarassing
@@Mercure250 Because it was a minor engagement in the grand scheme of things. We learned about losing battles that assured Canada didn't join the conflict. We didn't learn about the individual battles because they were tiny and the strategic shift, no revolutionary Canada, is what matters.
They do. It might have helped if you had actually gone to school
US schools barely mention history at all, besides the Holocaust or the history of Wakanda
they used to, but now they teach about more important things like, feelings.
1700 man invasion force? Yeah, thats more like a hiking trip...
What a victory!
I clicked on this without looking at the thumbnail. I was expecting the 1759 battle of Quebec. The best battle of Quebec.
Canadians are better at fighting wars, americans just like it more.
The difference between Canada and America Canadians enter wars at the start not two thirds way through
@@keithlordofalbascotland3371 it's the smart way..
You get them at the weakest point..
@@peterlakers1 no it's just being a retarded country coming to the war at the end,fighting least and then claiming they saved eveyone at the war.
@@biliminsrlar5752 What was the Korean War? Or Gulf War? Or Vietnam War?
Not true
Great video as always! Maybe the battle(s) of the isonzo river from the first world war?
We'll consider it!
Which one?, the 1st, 2nd or 538th?
Harry Morris only the 11th please! Thats where things got interesting!
Later:
*Arnold left the Continental Army
*Arnold joined the British Army
There is a nice little plaque in my hometown dedicated to Arnold's expedition all because they thought the Sebasticook river went all the way to Canada
I am American and never learned about this in school. I paid attention and loved history class. This was a losing strategy from the beginning. Just like today, no plan for maintaining the position after you win.
Great tactics....Zero Strategy.
For the Quebecois, (Canadiens at the time) it wasn't a big deal to pass from an anglosphere to another one
For a second I thought I was watching isorrowproductions at the beginning.
My great grandfather died in this invasion.
RIP your great grandfather
I’m sorry about that RIP
Cringe Archive Was your great grandfather like 100 when your grandfather was born? And then your grandfather must've been really old when your father was born.
@@dogestranding5047 I mean like time 6 great. Wasn't going to type great great great great great great great.
@@xxxbigboomerxxxShould have said one of your forefathers then, as I thought the same thing as the other guy wondering about his age.
Congress: " Here's Your Battle-Plan! "
Montgomery: " Right! " (opens envelope with plan)
Plan: " Keel Moose and Squirrel "
Montgomery: "...right then... I shall see to it! "
Congress: " Off you go then! Good Luck! :) "
I've watched most of your videos. I let it play in the background while I work.
Was hoping you might be open to constructive criticism....
The order the videos are in make no sense.
How can I let them play passively while going
from part one to part two on its own if
there's no proper order? idc I love your channel but
for the sake of someone less seasoned in history
order might help make more sense and therefore bring you
more people. Had the thought pop into my head so
many times I just had to share it with you.
Keep up the amazing work, can't wait for the finishing video
of "Siege of Boston" . Thanks for listening Boss!