Our Most Overrated Metal Albums | Feat. The Metal Meltdown

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 29 вер 2024
  • Metal Meltdowns channel: / @themetalmeltdownofficial
    Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use.
    Feel free to leave a comment if you enjoyed the video and any recommendations for future videos. All support helps :)

КОМЕНТАРІ • 279

  • @themetalmeltdownofficial
    @themetalmeltdownofficial 4 роки тому +95

    Yo that Metal Meltdown dude is handsome as hell 😍

    • @martinpazdera3904
      @martinpazdera3904 4 роки тому +2

      Hate his drunk snoby ass

    • @themetalmeltdownofficial
      @themetalmeltdownofficial 4 роки тому +14

      @@martinpazdera3904 Hey! I may be drunk, and I may be snobby but.... um.... what was the third thing you said?

    • @martinpazdera3904
      @martinpazdera3904 4 роки тому +6

      @@themetalmeltdownofficial jk, love you Robert. But seriously dude, give out some more 5s, tired of hearing "This is a great fucking record, 3/5"

    • @themetalmeltdownofficial
      @themetalmeltdownofficial 4 роки тому +12

      @@martinpazdera3904 respectfully thats exactly why i don't give out 5's very often - calling something perfect or a masterpiece loses meaning when you say it every week. But I hear ya, and if helps, I'm about to update the scores of 2 particular albums to a 5/5. More on that another time...

    • @djrbdbdndjwjk5039
      @djrbdbdndjwjk5039 3 роки тому +3

      if something is overrated it is worse than we thought i hate overrated and underrated term. Can we say too popular or too unpopular instead?

  • @joeyuzwa891
    @joeyuzwa891 4 роки тому +34

    as soon as you said “considered the best concept album of all time, considered one of the best prog bands of all time,” i said to myself “no way, he better not pick mindcrime”, and then i nearly flipped my shit when you said operation mindcrime 😂 i am definitely one if those people who LOVE operation mindcrime

  • @martinpazdera3904
    @martinpazdera3904 4 роки тому +34

    I don't think death magnetic is overrated. It's not that good, but I would actually put Black Album on this list

    • @davetorres3906
      @davetorres3906 3 роки тому +5

      Agree, Black Album has aged like milk

    • @realenglishman580
      @realenglishman580 3 роки тому +5

      Nope I think the overrated Metallica album is Hardwired to Self Destruct.

    • @realenglishman580
      @realenglishman580 3 роки тому +5

      Stop that! The Black Album is a classic album.

    • @P3rm4frost
      @P3rm4frost 2 роки тому +3

      Black album has many well thought out songs with a lot of character and hooks and still hits hard. Great big sounds and still raw edge of metal. Hwtsd is far worse but dm just got the freaking praise because it came after st anger. But it's like 1000 riffs in one song going nowhere and a cluster fuck of people pleasing songs.

    • @WFly101
      @WFly101 Рік тому +1

      ​@@P3rm4frostnot true

  • @wahtdookie
    @wahtdookie 2 роки тому +25

    Slipknot self titled is my favourite debut album

    • @AkumaClaps
      @AkumaClaps Рік тому

      He proved to be a POSER and a soyboy, nu metal hater for what he said of self-titled, true slipknot fans have iowa and self-titled on the top 2 ranking... he must love snuff and all of those weak melodic "Stone slipknot sour" 💩..

    • @stantorren4400
      @stantorren4400 Рік тому

      @@AkumaClapsYou’re more entitled than the fucking parasites that is the royal fucking family

  • @RÅNÇIÐ
    @RÅNÇIР4 роки тому +48

    Death Magnetic is actually underrated (the remaster at least)

    • @realenglishman580
      @realenglishman580 3 роки тому +5

      Stop it! The Black Album is a great album so stop it!

    • @realenglishman580
      @realenglishman580 3 роки тому +7

      The Back Album deserves all of the appreciation that it gets, it's not overrated, it's a fantastic album!

    • @realenglishman580
      @realenglishman580 3 роки тому +5

      Your opinion sucks. The Black Album is one of Metallica's best albums, it's a very good record. Death Magnetic is not that good, it's just more tolerable than Load, Reload, St Anger and Hardwired. Black Album is a fantastic album it's beats Death Magnetic any day!

    • @RockyRaccoon1122
      @RockyRaccoon1122 2 роки тому

      Exactly.

    • @TheBeardedNemophilist
      @TheBeardedNemophilist 2 роки тому +4

      Death Magnetic is criminally underrated, much agreed. I hated it when it first came out, but over the last few years it has become one of my favorites

  • @octavia458
    @octavia458 2 роки тому +2

    Haunted is bad as hell. The riffs are simple, but you can sing along to it! "I took an axe to your head, chopping rotted flesh, brain is seeping from the cracks in your skull. Blood drains from holes in your torso, I took your life from you!" I haven't heard the album in a year or so, and yet I remember those lyrics and many others with somewhere around 90% accuracy. You can sing em clean, growl em, whatever you want and they’re awesome! It's not great death metal, but it's full of great songs. I'll fight ya if need be.

  • @metalchiva1
    @metalchiva1 4 роки тому +4

    I think Metal Meltdown is not objective. Death magnetic is far from being a masterpiece, it had production problems. I don't think its overrated, it is a good record, period. I think his analysis approach and comments are lame and that tactic of critism being a jerk or trying to be cool bashing something is waaaaaaaay overrated and really not my cup of tea. Everyone can shit on something, I preffer some different kind of analysis

    • @Transilvanian90
      @Transilvanian90 Рік тому

      His criticism takes something that one may argue is overrated and just shits on it 100%, to a level that's kind of a caricature. I guess it's just theatrics. Like, you can argue that Time I isn't a masterpiece if you want, I personally like it, but the argument that if you remove every element from the music you're left with nothing... wtf is that lol?! That's an absolute truth for literally all music.
      "Muh if you remove the guitars and the vocals and the drums and the bass from Rust in Peace you're left with nothing" Yeah no shit Sherlock.

  • @MetalThrashingMan13
    @MetalThrashingMan13 Рік тому

    With Six Feet Under-Haunted I will say it’s not an album I consistently go back to but it is the album that scratches an itch for mEEEEEE when I get it and that’s why I like it.

  • @TheRealJoeNathan
    @TheRealJoeNathan 2 роки тому +1

    Wintersun - Time I might be in my top 50 favorite albums of all time

  • @metalhead3002
    @metalhead3002 3 роки тому +3

    I know I’m one of the few to say this. But I love all Six Feet Under’s new shit

  • @exploringformetal6072
    @exploringformetal6072 4 роки тому +4

    agree on, see you on the other side. its one of korns worst albums.
    but when this album was released, head ( guitarist ) had left the band and korn seemed to be running out of ideas and they started to struggle a bit
    but overall, this album to me is border line average.

    • @deanlangley4003
      @deanlangley4003 4 роки тому

      I don’t think it’s overrated at all, To me
      It’s underrated

    • @exploringformetal6072
      @exploringformetal6072 4 роки тому

      @@deanlangley4003 i used to say the same thing but ive listened to this album countless times so it has slipped down for me

  • @Manectric7
    @Manectric7 2 роки тому +1

    "weird, spacey, super professional" kinda like what Tool tries on every fuckin album of theirs.

  • @DanAddison
    @DanAddison Рік тому +2

    For me it's anything by Metallica. They are partly responsible for me taking 40 odd years to start getting into metal, because they are arguably the most celebrated metal band in the wider world AND within metal itself, so I stupidly assumed they were roughly as good as it gets, and thus closed my ears to metal because I personally find Metallica so lame and cringe. So their albums are the most overrated, for me.

    • @johnran6015
      @johnran6015 2 місяці тому

      Your position is every Metallica fan that still thinks they make good music, you escaped the matrix, congratulations.

  • @rcurl44
    @rcurl44 2 роки тому +1

    Posthumous Humiliation is barely heard of to be an overrated album.

  • @kostaspanopoulos3233
    @kostaspanopoulos3233 3 роки тому +2

    On a scale of 1 to 10, how American are you?
    Metal Meltdown: Nukiller Blast Records...😛

    • @Transilvanian90
      @Transilvanian90 Рік тому

      "Nucular. It's pronounced nucular"
      -Homer Simpson :))))

  • @ccomega929
    @ccomega929 2 роки тому +1

    i have never liked 6 Ft.
    i enjoy middle erra disturbed, when they went straight hard rock, as i go back to the sickness, it has not aged well.
    i enjoyed death magnetic, and believe it is actually underated now a days, when it first came out, it was definitely a return to form for the band, the songs definitely feel bloated at times.
    Iowa, Iowa, Iowa, fuck the first Slipknot album, it's up there with the sickness
    i feel the same about Dr. Feel good, Too Fast for Love rips, but im more in to Ratt, never been glam fan
    I got bored with See You On the Other Side really quick, i feel like they stoped trying on this album
    i cant Stand Wintersun at all, fuck that band
    i have yet to get in to Dragonforce, i dont mind listening to them, but im just not a power metal guy
    i have never heard of Pissgrave lol
    i used to like Queensryche, they're meh to me

  • @shanetsung3558
    @shanetsung3558 2 роки тому

    7:36 ..my answer when people ask me "how can u call EVERY opeth and the last 3 trivium albums overrated as fuck?!?!!!?????" 🙄

  • @daryl4841
    @daryl4841 2 роки тому

    I can't view any Six Feet Under album as overrated. They have enough fans to continue on but overall they seem very looked down upon by most of the metal community. Most reviewers think they're trash and I never see their material on any kind of top rankings lists of must have music. Its like one of the least elitist and pretentious bands.

  • @Transilvanian90
    @Transilvanian90 Рік тому

    Good video for the most part, although I 100% disagree with Metal Meltdown's stance on Time I; it's an amazing album, sure it's a bit pretentious but it's still super fun to listen to. And his argument of "if you remove everything from the album, what's left?!" Well... nothing. Duh. That's the case for literally 100% of all music ever made. You can not like it but that's a shit argument lol.
    As for Questy, you put Operation Mindcrime as #1 most overrated, which I tend to agree with fully, I got it due to its reputation, listened to it and never fucking listened to it again it was so dull. But why would you also put it on your 100 albums to listen to before you die list, lol. Don't put shit you hate on an essential albums list...

  • @Meshuggapeth
    @Meshuggapeth 4 роки тому +9

    Self titled is my favorite Slipknot sound

    • @AkumaClaps
      @AkumaClaps Рік тому

      He proved to be a POSER a soyboy, nu metal hater for what he said of self-titled, true slipknot fans have iowa and self-titled on the top 2 ranking... he must love snuff and all of those weak melodic "Stone slipknot sour" songs 💩.. the dude even said gray chapter is the worst album(wich I agree) but then says self-titled is the worst one after the gray chapter...what a POSER.

  • @nevermindyouropinion4235
    @nevermindyouropinion4235 10 місяців тому

    One thing I can say that I dont enjoy about this channel is its jus so fn preachy. Lol. I know " then dont watch it " . But i do every once and a while when they pop up . But does anyone listen to music they actually like anymore lol

  • @cornpopsrevenge1891
    @cornpopsrevenge1891 Рік тому +1

    Loved death magnetic! Hated hardwired. And not getting into 72 seasons very much. DM was their last heavy album in my opinion.

  • @MikeMcFarland37
    @MikeMcFarland37 2 місяці тому

    Fuck yeah. Mindcrime is lame. Though I liked empire

  • @joshtaylor6242
    @joshtaylor6242 4 роки тому

    I like the idea of these rants but some of these went to over the top, could of at least talked more sense in the rants

  • @rahbeat9785
    @rahbeat9785 2 роки тому

    f**k Death magnetic

  • @moch3194
    @moch3194 4 роки тому +1

    First

  • @toddwilliams8128
    @toddwilliams8128 2 роки тому +34

    Obituary plays a brand of sludgy, grooving death metal that Six Feet Under can only dream about approaching. Oh, and John Tardy still sounds awesome in the 21st century.
    PS, were you lip-syncing that Chris Barnes impression? It was too perfect.

    • @Intermentor
      @Intermentor Рік тому

      Yes. Obituary rules. Was listening to their new album with a friend while drinking beers. And also a lot of newer death metal bands. I think it was only Gatecreeper that kept my head banging the same way as listening to the old masters.

  • @deathstruggle4136
    @deathstruggle4136 4 роки тому +36

    How is korn „see you on the other side“ overrated? I had the impression that everybody hates this album and the band only played a few songs live when it was released but then never again. I like this album

    • @FoxCunt
      @FoxCunt 3 роки тому +13

      Yeah I agree with you he didn't even give it any actual criticisms or anything just "it's annoying and trash because I said so" lmao

    • @AkumaClaps
      @AkumaClaps Рік тому

      @@FoxCunt He proved to be a POSER, nu metal hater and a soyboy, for what he said of self-titled slipknot albums too, true slipknot fans have iowa and self-titled on the top 2 ranking... he must love snuff and all of those weak melodic "Stone slipknot sour" 💩..

    • @WFly101
      @WFly101 Рік тому

      RIGHT?!!!!?!

  • @jaakko14
    @jaakko14 3 роки тому +28

    Queensryche Operation Mindcrime is held in high regard because it is an awesone album. Every single song is a banger. I can understand if you dont like it becuse of the singing but it doesnt make it a bad album.

  • @goingefishingteam6741
    @goingefishingteam6741 3 роки тому +61

    Slipknot’s debut album is so f@cking good

    • @AkumaClaps
      @AkumaClaps Рік тому

      He proved to be a POSER and a soyboy, for what he said of self-titled, true slipknot fans have iowa and self-titled on the top 2 ranking... he must love snuff and all of those weak melodic "Stone slipknot sour" 💩..

    • @Xeroforte
      @Xeroforte Рік тому +6

      @NoOne_477 It is though, sorry kid.

    • @slammetalgirl
      @slammetalgirl Рік тому +2

      @No One it’s not alt rock ☠️☠️☠️

    • @hansoharrigen6958
      @hansoharrigen6958 Рік тому

      ​@@Xeroforte Ok boomer

    • @sizarix
      @sizarix Рік тому

      @MilkyLore May God burn down your steed.

  • @datguy9408
    @datguy9408 4 роки тому +34

    I still like Slipknots’ debut album regardless, but I do have to agree that Iowa is far superior.

    • @AkumaClaps
      @AkumaClaps Рік тому

      He proved to be a POSER a soyboy, nu metal hater for what he said of self-titled, true slipknot fans have iowa and self-titled on the top 2 ranking... he must love snuff and all of those weak melodic "Stone slipknot sour" songs 💩.. the dude even said gray chapter is the worst album(wich I agree) but then says self-titled is the worst one after the gray chapter...what a POSER.

    • @i_want_my_shuggah
      @i_want_my_shuggah Рік тому +1

      Yeah. I love both.
      I feel like the "Iowa" song is the counterpart for the "Scissors" song. At first I hated them, but after a few listens, I started liking them.
      I wish I could watch Slipknot playing "Scissors" live, that experience would be so memorable.

  • @seakermac5800
    @seakermac5800 10 місяців тому +5

    Death Magnetic is fine. I was surprised when I listened to it last year that I liked abt 60% of it. I’d honestly say it’s underrated

  • @ryangioia2358
    @ryangioia2358 3 роки тому +11

    Metal Meltdown: “Without You is one of the most BORING power ballads ever”
    Every Rose Has It’s Thorn: Hold my beer
    Miles Away: Step aside, kid
    Love Bites (Def Leppard): No, YOU step aside
    I Can’t Live Without Your Love and Affection: Out of my way fools
    Patience: HERE COMES TROUBLE!!

  • @MetalTrenches
    @MetalTrenches 4 роки тому +29

    Dude I get people defending the NEW SFU album in the comments of my review to a degree that makes me embarrassed for humanity. Hot take: there are NO good SFU albums.

    • @themetalmeltdownofficial
      @themetalmeltdownofficial 4 роки тому +7

      Shame on those people

    • @blackwaterrust476
      @blackwaterrust476 4 роки тому +5

      There are people that love SFU? Those poor Souls hate themselves

    • @waycnf7229
      @waycnf7229 4 роки тому

      it's funny because i'm listening to barnes era cannibal corpse

    • @metalmansionrecords5840
      @metalmansionrecords5840 3 роки тому

      Idk they are standouts in the genre along with obituary, monstrosity, morbid angel and deicide, last time I was on bandcamp I counted at least 30 morbid angel clones, it’s very difficult to find your own style and voice in death metal, so much modern death is very bland, nothing different, I’m constantly searching for bands that stand alone in this genre, my search continues

    • @sefisyara5961
      @sefisyara5961 3 роки тому

      Idk SFU has only like 3 decent albums to me - 13, Unborn, Undead

  • @goatmoonwarmaster4641
    @goatmoonwarmaster4641 4 роки тому +7

    Slipknot after Iowa is cheesy and boring, omg you hate queensryche vocals I don't know what to tell you.

  • @realenglishman580
    @realenglishman580 3 роки тому +21

    Death Magnetic is not overrated at all, a lot of people hate it.

  • @davetorres3906
    @davetorres3906 3 роки тому +6

    Slipknot's selft titled it's when i disagree, that album still amazing, but yeah, i also prefer Iowa more at the end but just by a midget

    • @AkumaClaps
      @AkumaClaps Рік тому

      He proved to be a POSER a soyboy, nu metal hater for what he said of self-titled, true slipknot fans have iowa and self-titled on the top 2 ranking... he must love snuff and all of those weak melodic "Stone slipknot sour" songs 💩.. the dude even said gray chapter is the worst album(wich I agree) but then says self-titled is the worst one after the gray chapter...what a POSER.

  • @markpalavosvrahotes5575
    @markpalavosvrahotes5575 4 роки тому +18

    Disturbed sucks period.

    • @datguy9408
      @datguy9408 4 роки тому +3

      Butt rock at it’s finest.

    • @deanlangley4003
      @deanlangley4003 4 роки тому +1

      I disagree but I respect your opinion

    • @markpalavosvrahotes5575
      @markpalavosvrahotes5575 4 роки тому +1

      @@deanlangley4003 Thats alright a lot of people love them. I should have put it sucks to me because music is subjective.

    • @realenglishman580
      @realenglishman580 3 роки тому +1

      Disturbed is a good band.

    • @realenglishman580
      @realenglishman580 3 роки тому +1

      Your opinion sucks.

  • @pmorris1916
    @pmorris1916 4 роки тому +9

    Just want to get out here and rep for glam metal...as an old metal head, I love that stuff! Yes, I listen to death and black Metal mainly now, but I still love me some Skid Row, Crue, Poison, and all the other guys! It’s understandable why all the young guys and girls hate it, but seriously, it was a great time for music in the 80s!

  • @dekapitatorr
    @dekapitatorr 3 роки тому +5

    what times we live in...metalheads complaining about loud production....Death Magnetic rules.

    • @fclefjefff4041
      @fclefjefff4041 2 роки тому +1

      There's "loud" that sounds good and "loud" that sounds like garbage. Sorry you're not able to tell the difference

  • @bloodnthuner
    @bloodnthuner 2 роки тому +9

    As far as Operation Mindcrime goes, its one of the albums that needs to be taken into context from the time period it was released. Yes the production and Geoff's vocal arrangements are very dated but at time it was new and groundbreaking. And its more of a theatrical rock album definitely not as heavy as their earlier stuff. As far as the story goes I think it takes on way more than it can handle with drug addiction, prostitution, politics, religion etc. But for what it is its some great music imo. Saw them play it live back in the day.

  • @alexistaylor9092
    @alexistaylor9092 2 роки тому +7

    As you say, I love how frantic and crazy Slipknot's self titled album is, along with the DJ scratches. But also, my favorite Slipknot album is probably WANYK lol so whatever.

  • @SinisterIcon
    @SinisterIcon 27 днів тому +2

    17:00 Haha, Time II just dropped this week. Bon appetit!

  • @HammeredReactions
    @HammeredReactions Рік тому +3

    Stupify is one of the greatest songs ever written

  • @Triiplesiix
    @Triiplesiix 2 роки тому +4

    😮😮😮 I can’t agree with Slipknot. Maybe bc it was one of my first metal albums? But it’s perfect to me. Self titled and then Iowa..are the only 2 I can really listen to. I hold them is such high reguards. Your crazy to me lol but still love the channel.

    • @AkumaClaps
      @AkumaClaps Рік тому +1

      He proved to be a POSER a soyboy, nu metal hater for what he said of self-titled, true slipknot fans have iowa and self-titled on the top 2 ranking... he must love snuff and all of those weak melodic "Stone slipknot sour" songs 💩.. the dude even said gray chapter is the worst album(wich I agree) but then says self-titled is the worst one after the gray chapter...what a POSER.

  • @rodrigoreyes1209
    @rodrigoreyes1209 11 місяців тому +2

    Disagree with the guy with the seventh crap of the seventh crap poster and the appetite for garbage t-shirt

  • @WFly101
    @WFly101 Рік тому +2

    How tf is Death Magnetic overrated???

  • @redinthesky1
    @redinthesky1 4 роки тому +6

    Six Feet Under - Haunted wasnt terrible, boring at times maybe, but when the last album you were on was The Bleeding... *Sigh*

    • @spongebitchbobface
      @spongebitchbobface 4 роки тому +1

      Not if you count the excellent demo- Created To Kill.

  • @kittykat13ization
    @kittykat13ization 4 роки тому +5

    Shout is a cover song it's a oringal by tears for fears

  • @metalgamer82093
    @metalgamer82093 3 роки тому +5

    Chris Barnes now sounds like strong bad from those old flash animation cartoons or like that dude from the beast man vs skeletor song. Kinda makes me glad now that cannibal corpse replaced him with corpse grinder years ago. Corpsegrinder is much more proficient doing vocals than Chris Barnes is anyways

  • @forgemastermetal
    @forgemastermetal 4 роки тому +5

    This is great guys! We should do an epic collab sometime. Also....I still don't get how SFU is still a thing....

  • @blackwaterrust476
    @blackwaterrust476 4 роки тому +6

    2 legends
    SFU always Sucked
    There is way better Disturbed albums
    I can’t stand Death Magnetic
    Motley Crue in general is overrated
    Again much better Korn albums out there
    Love self Titled Slipknot Self Titled is still my favorite of theirs.
    Not my favorite Wintersun record for sure
    Fuck Dragonforce
    Pissgrave I have never heard of
    You are gonna be Triggered but Operation Mindcrime>>>>Metropolis Pt2

  • @waterdive122productions6
    @waterdive122productions6 3 роки тому +7

    When you were about to mention Operation: Mindcrime, I thought you were going to say Clockwork Angels by Rush. No offense, but I would have thrown my freaking phone off of my porch if you did. If you want a great concept album, go to Clockwork Angels. By the way, it's one of Rush's heaviest albums, and it's their final album. Came out in 2012, and I saw them on that tour.

    • @Transilvanian90
      @Transilvanian90 Рік тому +1

      I had the hardest time getting into Clockwork Angels. It wasn't helped by the fact that I first heard it live, in whole, it bored me then and they cancelled the second half of their show, where they were going to play their actual classics, due to an incoming thunderstorm. So it left a sour taste in my mouth and on multiple listens of the album itself it just... bored me. I'll have to see if after a few years I like it more.

    • @waterdive122productions6
      @waterdive122productions6 Рік тому +1

      @@Transilvanian90 Oh dear. I'm so sorry about that. Sounds to me as if you had a bad introduction to the record. Clockwork Angels is a very special album to me, and as a fan of Rush, it was rather easy for me to get into. Also, coupled with the fact that this is their last album ever makes it very bittersweet. The Garden all on its own is a very emotional song given the situations that would follow the record. I would maybe suggest you try and give it another go if you haven't already, and if you still don't like it, I understand. Clockwork Angels isn't a concept album that is frequently talked about outside of us Rush fans. Good luck my dude!

    • @Transilvanian90
      @Transilvanian90 Рік тому +1

      @@waterdive122productions6 Thanks, that's a good perspective! I'll give it a go one of these days. Oddly enough, Snakes and Arrows, which is generally a bit less liked, got me right at the start and I've loved that album since hearing it, still do now.

    • @waterdive122productions6
      @waterdive122productions6 Рік тому +1

      @@Transilvanian90 I agree with you. Snakes and Arrows is a really good album. I love every song from Far Cry up to The Way the Wind Blows. The songs on the second side, aside from Faithless, Malignant Narcissism, and Hope kind of lost me a little bit, but they're still pretty good songs. I do prefer Clockwork Angels, but Snakes and Arrows is, in my opinion, one of the best albums from the late 2000s.

  • @coreycrossman3447
    @coreycrossman3447 Рік тому +1

    Dude yes the first Slipknot album is one of their worst, couple bangers but it's mostly just noise and chaos in a bad way

  • @csbaucu7761
    @csbaucu7761 4 роки тому +19

    I remember my cousin complaining about Six Feet Under in the 90's. He said it was just rehashed Obituary riffs.

  • @markpalavosvrahotes5575
    @markpalavosvrahotes5575 4 роки тому +6

    Mindcrime is my number 6 album of all time. It is kind of like a play I agree. But I love it Im sorry. It is extremely nostalgic for me. But I have no dislike toward you. We all have different tastes and likes. Great video dude you are one of the best.

    • @integrity101
      @integrity101 4 роки тому

      #6 all time? Cool. What are your top ten?

    • @markpalavosvrahotes5575
      @markpalavosvrahotes5575 4 роки тому +1

      @@integrity101 10. Morbid Angel Covanent. 9. Dont Break The Oath Mercyful Fate 8. Sabotage Black Sabbath. 7. Alice in Chains Dirt. 6 Mindcrime. 5. Opeth Ghost Reveries 4. Judas Priest Stained Class. 3. Agalloch The Mantle. 2. King Diamond Them/Conspiracy 1. My Dying Bride Turn Loose The Swans.

  • @hvitekristesdod
    @hvitekristesdod 3 роки тому +3

    I’m gonna go with
    Behemoth - Envangelion
    Mayhem - Des Mysteriis Dom Sathanas
    Watain - Lawless Darkness
    Septic Flesh - Codex Omega

    • @dickthehead1145
      @dickthehead1145 5 місяців тому +1

      Fat agree on mayhem. Never ever been able to get into them, all the other 2nd gen bands are so much better.

  • @JoshieMadhatt
    @JoshieMadhatt 7 місяців тому +1

    You have to eat your shirt live on UA-cam on August 30th LMAO

  • @bluesrock88
    @bluesrock88 2 роки тому +3

    Operation mind crime is a masterpiece. I am sorry you don´t enjoy it

  • @jeremiahpapa7868
    @jeremiahpapa7868 4 роки тому +3

    How about over hyped people. Ruminating I thought of Wes Borland. Big Dumb Face has two releases both half filled with joke song filler and three our four KILLERZ👹 I picked up Black Light Burns Lotus Island. First three songs total 7 minutes and its one drunk piano diddle broken up. Limp Bizkit were hype machine day one. Sorry Wes but no John 5.

  • @pmorris1916
    @pmorris1916 4 роки тому +4

    That Wintersun album is banging! I am pissed about their business practices, but I hope to see Metal meltdown eating a shirt one day! That album is nowhere close to a turd in my opinion....

    • @Transilvanian90
      @Transilvanian90 Рік тому

      Agreed 100%. Sure Jari has the work ethic of a Turkish gangster but his music is almost always excellent. I love Time I, although I prefer the Self-titled debut. Also, you can't really call Time I overrated since a lot of people shit on it, often due to hating on Jari instead of the music. Which is kinda shitty.

  • @PatrickWDunne
    @PatrickWDunne 2 роки тому +3

    Pissgrave's Posthumous Humiliation is overrated? I've never even heard of it 🤣

  • @lordtrigon1733
    @lordtrigon1733 3 роки тому +5

    Jonathan Davis says “boomamagghgffgghvcdd!” and everyone is fine but David Draiman goes “Ooh-wa-ah-ah-ah!” and people lose their minds 😂
    I still chuck Death Magnetic on I still really enjoy most of it. I like Slipknot’s S/T but it’s one of the most front-loaded albums I’ve ever heard. The one song on See You on the Other Side I will stand by is Seen It All, it should’ve closed the album.
    When I think of overrated albums I can’t help but choose British Steel and Number of the Beast, they are both held up as pinnacles of Metal but both are only held up by a couple of songs and neither does their band justice.

  • @joethomas6255
    @joethomas6255 Рік тому +2

    Bruh slipknot debut is iconic and stands the test of time. Every song is at least a 8/10 overall a near perfect album imo.

  • @johnran6015
    @johnran6015 2 місяці тому

    There is no such thing as a good numetal album, much less song. It was the cockrock (not glam metal, there is no metal in glam metal) of the 90s and 00s, music for the mindless masses. Haha Pissgrave, Disgorge of Mexico buried them in previous decades. I hung out with them at a fest in Chicago, they don't seem to care about their band that much.

  • @coletrain3599
    @coletrain3599 2 роки тому +4

    Slipknot self titled is the best nu metal album

    • @AkumaClaps
      @AkumaClaps Рік тому

      He proved to be a POSER a soyboy, nu metal hater for what he said of self-titled, true slipknot fans have iowa and self-titled on the top 2 ranking... he must love snuff and all of those weak melodic "Stone slipknot sour" songs 💩.. the dude even said gray chapter is the worst album(wich I agree) but then says self-titled is the worst one after the gray chapter...what a POSER.

  • @warrickjohnson1185
    @warrickjohnson1185 3 роки тому +2

    Understand the hate for graveyard classics and nightmares of the decomposed.But personally I love torment musicians are awesome great lyrics.Disturbed sounds like apes at the zoo. Death magnetic is o.k. Obviously they have better. Just because it's no st.anger don't make it good,I agree

  • @joeyuzwa891
    @joeyuzwa891 4 роки тому +3

    i used to LOVE Korn as a kid. elementary through middle school and into my freshman year of highschool, I lived bands like System of a Down, Korn, and Slipknot. since then I’ve started listening to ACTUALLY good music, and I cannot stand ANY of them anymore (admittedly I still like blind and freak on a leash, though that’s probably also because of nostalgia). TRASSHHHHH in my opinion. Jonathan Davis’ voice is so annoying, and his lyrics are horrible. and their riffs aren’t even any good the vast majority of the time. amd their choruses SUCK

    • @robertburdinie1151
      @robertburdinie1151 4 роки тому +1

      I'm the opposite, I thought they all sucked back in the day (except SOAD, always liked them) but have grown to appreciate Korn, Slipknot and Deftones in the last year or so.

    • @joeyuzwa891
      @joeyuzwa891 3 роки тому

      @@robertburdinie1151 see now Deftones I can get behind. I like early Deftones (as well as their new record)

    • @Transilvanian90
      @Transilvanian90 Рік тому

      Agreed 100%, nu-metal is utter crap. Pure teenage cringe that I'm glad I got over.

  • @philthyF80
    @philthyF80 3 роки тому +2

    110% agree about SFU. Seen them on tour for this album. Immolation and Internal Bleeding opened and killed it!!! SFU didn't even come close!!! Immolation and Internal Bleeding killed it!!!!! SFU didn't stand a chance!!!! Their debut was weak.

  • @docvader82
    @docvader82 Рік тому

    Oh my word, what did you say about Cyanide? That song is sooooo middle of the road.
    Yes, it's too loud(I do have a nicer mix on cd).
    But Cyanide is the first track I'd trade for any of the Beyond Magnetic tunes.
    The instrumental is boring and long. If you cut cyanide and S&R, you'd fit the four Beyond songs. (If you need a pinch more space, then End of the Line goes).
    Anyways, Death Magnetic is still my favorite Metallica album since Justice.

  • @VampireJack10
    @VampireJack10 2 місяці тому

    The problem with Death Magnetic is that it doesn't feel genuine.
    Metallica were told to listen to their first 4 albums to see what made them so good - and they just painted by numbers with the album.
    The songs don't have soul.

  • @PeterNorvaisas
    @PeterNorvaisas 4 роки тому +2

    I have no problems with any of these at all. I never heard that Wintersun album or the Pissgrave albums so I'll have to check those out. What was up with the Metal Meltdown parts? The audio wasn't matching. It was like watching a 70s dubbed kung fu movie. But still I'll check out his channel. Thank you for all your videos.

  • @EnemyKnown
    @EnemyKnown 2 роки тому +2

    Sorry mate but Operation Mindcrime is a stone cold classic the story is a little ambitious but it's an overall great album & what do you mean not heavy?

  • @AnonymousAnonposter
    @AnonymousAnonposter Рік тому +1

    Mate. Feed. Kill. Repeat. by Slipknot is better than the debut album imo.
    And I get why people hate The Sickness, but I can't hate it, I actually love it. Even aspects that might be considered cringe or silly.
    But I have nothing to disagree with the rest of the list, especially the takes about Inhuman Rampage and Time I

  • @metalmansionrecords5840
    @metalmansionrecords5840 4 роки тому +2

    Ahhh, I disagree with Haunted, at the time of its release death metal was really stagnant, blast beats and noodling riffs, guttural vocals and who can put out the sickest album cover, with haunted shure Allen west brought the obituary groove, Barnes vocal hooks and lyrics made it unique, to say there are no memorable songs and that this band isn’t a standout in the genre is crazy, Sfu have kinda done everything in the extreme spectrum, tech death to stoner doom and death n roll

  • @docvader82
    @docvader82 Рік тому

    I don't hate Mindcrime, but I don't worship it either.
    Musically I like it, but when Taint overdoes it(which is all too often on their early stuff), it takes me out of the song. The story is cool enough, but I roll my eyes when people call it the best concept album.
    This is probably Sacrilege to say, but Promised Land is my favorite QR album. I like a lot of tunes on Empire. Yes, it's more radio friendly, but they are some well written tunes.
    I like the LaTorre albums more than a lot of Taint ones

  • @tomasjonsson7141
    @tomasjonsson7141 Рік тому +2

    Damn alot of good albums you hate =)

  • @RebbleRabb
    @RebbleRabb 4 роки тому +4

    Oh man, time 1, thank you. I thought it was just me.

  • @slipknotmfkrlocust8843
    @slipknotmfkrlocust8843 3 роки тому +8

    Ok so apparently laugh cry emoji's glitch comments, but I was saying that the Chris Barnes impression is SPOT ON, and hilarious.

  • @lutfimakarim8258
    @lutfimakarim8258 10 місяців тому +2

    Quest for Metal Meltdown

  • @simondavies109
    @simondavies109 4 місяці тому

    Now if you'd have put Iowa on the list I'd agree but Slipknot self titled album is briiant.

  • @LongLiveRockAnRoll
    @LongLiveRockAnRoll 2 місяці тому

    17:00 can't wait for the live shirt eating by Metal Meltdown on August 30 2024 😅

  • @robertburdinie1151
    @robertburdinie1151 4 роки тому +2

    I'll agree that Operation Mindcrime is overrated but more in a Rage For Order is their best album than Operation Mindcrime being bad.

    • @realenglishman580
      @realenglishman580 3 роки тому +1

      I think both Operation Mindcrime and Rage For Order are highly overrated.

    • @robertburdinie1151
      @robertburdinie1151 3 роки тому +1

      @@realenglishman580 what queensryche do you like then? The EP and Warning or do you just dislike them in general?

    • @realenglishman580
      @realenglishman580 3 роки тому +1

      @@robertburdinie1151 I like the Ep and I like Condition Human, other than those I am not really fan of them, that's the truth.

  • @rampantgnaw4289
    @rampantgnaw4289 4 роки тому +2

    Listen to the new dominion album. Starting to think it's better that. Anaal nathrack sorry can't spell

  • @juliengoguen17
    @juliengoguen17 Рік тому

    Death Magnetic is by far Metallica's worst album I'd rather sit and a listen to the full St. Anger album on repeat for a week, than listen to Death Magnetic.

  • @jeremiahpapa7868
    @jeremiahpapa7868 4 роки тому +2

    Beating a dead white horse but White Pony. Deftones get better as they go but my eyes don't light up like others when people say White Pony.

    • @pmorris1916
      @pmorris1916 4 роки тому

      Digital Bath is always going to be my favorite Deftones song, but I can see why a lot of people think this album is overrated...

  • @realenglishman580
    @realenglishman580 3 роки тому +1

    Overrated metal albums I dislike:
    Black Sabbath- Heaven and Hell, Mob Rules, 13
    Helloween- Walls of Jericho
    Helloween- Keeper of the Seven Keys Part 1 and 2
    Judas Priest- Painkiller
    Judas Priest- Defenders of the Fate
    Judas Priest- Screaming For Vengeance
    Megadeth- Rust In Peace, Youthanasia, Dystopia, Un
    Queenscryche- Operation Mindcrime
    Slayer- Reign In Blood
    Queenscryche- The Warning
    Metallica- Hardwired to Self Destruct
    Queenscryche- The Verdict

  • @mattw4461
    @mattw4461 2 роки тому +1

    Queensryche has some songs I think are ok and they're not talentless hacks. I don't hate them but they never appealed to me a whole lot either. Operation Mind is boring as shit and I don't like the sound of the album. I much prefer Promised Land and I don't think that is a very popular album among core Queensryche fans. Just a matter of taste I guess

  • @docvader82
    @docvader82 Рік тому

    Ohhh, Dr. Feelgood? I love the title track. Kickstart is good fun. And fuck the rest of it.

  • @XaoFakeNick
    @XaoFakeNick Рік тому +1

    Geoff Tate should be on the vocals job in Dream Theater. It's my wet dream.

  • @jeremiahpapa7868
    @jeremiahpapa7868 4 роки тому +1

    This may get me hachet or two to the face but how about just about everybody on Psychopathic Records? I have 14 ICP cds as well as Dark Lotus, DJ Clay and Twiztid. Boondox is an artist I do enjoy but come on.

  • @hellbubblez
    @hellbubblez 2 роки тому +1

    IMO I think children of bodom's hate breeder, no matter how much chance I give it I turn it off

  • @jeremiahpapa7868
    @jeremiahpapa7868 4 роки тому +1

    14:25 Hey. Stop weeping your woes over Hypocrites ok. I personally really dig that one. 🙄

  • @warrickjohnson6940
    @warrickjohnson6940 3 роки тому +1

    I defend torment. Music is great maybe shitty vocals,but torment is better than nightmares of the decomposed and I love it.

  • @TrippaC4939
    @TrippaC4939 2 роки тому +2

    I love how for him Disturbed- The Sickness is just "cringe" and nothing else. Sound like a redditor. Why is it cringe? "Just is mate, its cringe".

    • @Questformetal
      @Questformetal  2 роки тому +1

      Your comment is cringe, “why is it cringe” just is mate 🍺 let’s ave a pint down the pub then

    • @TrippaC4939
      @TrippaC4939 2 роки тому

      @@Questformetal I mean thats what you said in the video, you gave other criticism to other albums but you just brushed The Sickness off as cringe and no ther critiques.

    • @Questformetal
      @Questformetal  2 роки тому

      @@TrippaC4939 I mean it makes me wince when I think about the albums lyrics and and his ooh ah ahs so yeah I’d say past questy was correct and so is present but future questy might enjoy it again who knows 👽

    • @Transilvanian90
      @Transilvanian90 Рік тому

      @@Questformetal I'm with you dude, Disturbed is pure cringe. But then again so is their entire catalog as far as I'm concerned, I don't care for alt/nu metal whatsoever.

  • @Idyliss
    @Idyliss 2 роки тому +2

    9:53 he's (sic) of these songs

  • @raquelyoung8840
    @raquelyoung8840 2 роки тому +1

    Dr. Feel Good is the worst poc in hard rock history

  • @realenglishman580
    @realenglishman580 3 роки тому +2

    I agree with most of these except for The Sickness.

    • @i_want_my_shuggah
      @i_want_my_shuggah Рік тому

      Then you need to listen to the other albums a little bit more.

  • @zacharysmart6794
    @zacharysmart6794 Рік тому

    Slipknots debut GOES CRAZY love it my favorite slipknot album still however I AGREE W EVERYTHING about “Dr Feelgood” that shit is awful and so overproduced and “Without You” and “Time For Change” in particular 🤢🤢🤢 but “Slice of Your Pie” and “Rattlesnake Shake” are also just absolutely awful as well! Or “Sticky Sweet” riff rips but like gross or “She Goes Down” wow someone’s objectifying huh? but yes you’re right “Too Fast For Love” is severely UNDERRATED RIFFS GALORE however “Girls, Girls, Girls” although yes very objectifying is the cream of the crop record wise riffage on top!