Putin and the Presidents (full documentary) | FRONTLINE
Вставка
- Опубліковано 2 тра 2024
- FRONTLINE investigates Russian President Vladimir Putin’s clashes with five American presidents as he’s tried to rebuild the Russian empire.
This journalism is made possible by viewers like you. Support your local PBS station here: www.pbs.org/donate.
Drawing on in-depth conversations with insiders from five U.S. presidential administrations, former U.S. intelligence leaders, diplomats, Russian politicians, authors and journalists, “Putin and the Presidents” reveals how the miscalculations and missteps of multiple American presidents over two decades paved the way for Putin’s attack on Ukraine - as seen through the eyes of people who were in the room.
The documentary traces how, prior to launching the war on Ukraine, Putin tested the waters by defying American presidents for 20 years - including by invading Georgia, seizing Crimea, and interfering in a U.S. presidential election. The documentary provides unique insight into the icy relationship between Putin and current U.S. President Joe Biden, both of whom were shaped by the Cold War, and into the evolution of Putin’s grievances with the U.S. and the West.
As Russia’s war on Ukraine continues, “Putin and the Presidents” gives essential context for this historic moment.
“Putin and the Presidents” is a FRONTLINE production with the Kirk Documentary Group. The director is Michael Kirk. The producers are Michael Kirk, Mike Wiser and Vanessa Fica. The writers are Michael Kirk and Mike Wiser. The reporter is Vanessa Fica. The editor-in-chief and executive producer of FRONTLINE is Raney Aronson-Rath.
Explore additional reporting on "Putin and the Presidents" on our website: www.pbs.org/wgbh/frontline/do...
#Documentary #Putin #Russia #Ukraine
Subscribe on UA-cam: bit.ly/1BycsJW
Instagram: / frontlinepbs
Twitter: / frontlinepbs
Facebook: / frontline
FRONTLINE is produced at GBH in Boston and is broadcast nationwide on PBS. Funding for FRONTLINE is provided through the support of PBS viewers and by the Corporation for Public Broadcasting. Additional support for FRONTLINE is provided by the Abrams Foundation, the John D. and Catherine T. MacArthur Foundation, Park Foundation, the Heising-Simons Foundation, and the FRONTLINE Journalism Fund, with major support from Jon and Jo Ann Hagler on behalf of the Jon L. Hagler Foundation, and additional support from Koo and Patricia Yuen.
CHAPTERS:
Putin and the Fall of the Soviet Union - 2:21
President Clinton Meets Russia’s New President: Vladimir Putin - 4:40
Putin Sees President Bush’s Agenda to Spread Democracy as a Threat - 8:35
Putin’s ‘Red Line’ & the 2008 Russian Invasion of Georgia - 16:38
President Obama’s Relationship with Putin - 20:59
Vice President Biden and Putin: Shaped by the Cold War - 22:52
Russia Seizes Crimea From Ukraine in 2014 - 28:11
Russia’s Interference in the 2016 U.S. Election - 33:00
Putin and President Trump - 35:30
Putin, President Biden and Russia’s 2022 Invasion of Ukraine - 41:25
Credits - 51:27
Love FRONTLINE? Watch hundreds more documentaries on our channel: ua-cam.com/channels/3ScyryU9Oy9Wse3a8OAmYQ.html
Hello USA..why USA want to be "king" in this world?..how about crimes in Iraq at times BUSH as president of America..so many people's dies..now .how about president Joe Biden handle war in Palestine..?so many innocent people's killed by Israeli terrorist army..!!
Why nobody talk about that China has imprisoned more than 1 million Uyghurs! Why nobody talk about that Mongolian, during their expansion of Mongol empire, has slaughtered more than 100 million around the world, which, more horribly all done by blades and arrows. Why everyone think that Chinese is a more decent ruler who deserve take control of Siberia.
Putin is the kind of guy who reads all terms and conditions and clicks "i disagree"
😂 this got me laughing
true
@kennedymwatha7634 You copied this comment from the comment sections of one of his interviews. Apart from the fact that you stole somebody’s comment it is actually funny.
Terms? Like NATO boundaries?
I am the person who never reads anything and clicks on agree, I say Yes, when i have to No, say No when I have to say Yes, sometimes I say Yes when I have to say Yes and sometimes I say No when i have to say No.
Many could say, I might be a mental case that needs serious attention from every world renowned asylum & physician on this planet, but it is all Crazy, i know😅
28:57 " Putin sending his military to a neighboring country was such a shock "...,say the exact people who had imvaded countless foreign countries ...😅😅😅
underrated comment.
Under the name of freedom and democracy, so it must be a good thing. ;)
Exactly!! Lol
say those people who used atomic bombs in Japan against peaceful cities - Hiroshima and Nagasaki
Title :"Oil deposits discovered on Antarctica!"
President Biden: "Democracy will prevail. Criminal, terrorist regime of Penguins will be dealt with!"
Now that the truth is coming out this documentary looks more and more ridiculous!
Lmao, Bush saying "we're a peaceful nation" while having the blood of millions of women, men and children on his hands is just pinnacle of irony
Absolutely! Right on point.
You nailed it 💯%
(So true )
Again left-wing Americans talking about the unjust invasion of Iraq. Why do you forget about the thousands of deaths of Iraqis who wanted to live in a democratic country, but Saddam decided to completely deprive them of their lives? Why do you forget about the millions of Kurds whom Saddam poisoned with chemical weapons? Why do you forget about the invasion of Kuwait, whose consequences led to an environmental disaster (due to burning oil) and, as a result, a million cancer cases? Why do you forget Iraq's war against Iran, in which many millions died?
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Father and son were two of our worst presidents
In a distant future this video will be used to teach how US intelligence not only manipulated foreign nations but also it`s own nation
Exactly they fail to realise "democracy" has an expiry date, even for the creators of it.
I agree.
Well it still doesn’t justify Putin invading Ukraine 🇺🇦 does it? Do you people know how many innocent women and children have died?
I agree😊
Using tax dollars to lie to and manipulate the people they force to pay for this propaganda.
When can we get an unbiased political documentary about Russia and Putin?
Aaron Mate probably has something out.
@@Dpinks7522what is the video called that Aaron mate did ?
The Russian side of war... or something like that... It made zelansky rolling in his grave and all lefties and globalist puppet calling this documentary as normalising evil bigoted russia lolol 🤣😁🤡🤡
Author Masha Gessen, Russian, best you will find. "The Man Without A Face." (You do read?)
this is brutal neocon proaganda at its most deranged. and part of reason americans are a lobotomized people.
Anthony Blinken callin someone liar is hilarious
I loose my count for how many times americans discovered who Putin really is
Yea
😁 yet they never learn.
It is the problem of a democracy that doesnt allow dictators because they only get 8 years. Each of our presidents takes some time to learn. Each, except for Biden tried to give Putin a reset opportunity.
seriously. flip the subject to general armageddon a bit. that's where we are heading anyways
The author of this video, when talking about the Russia-Georgia conflict in 2008, forgot to mention to us that the UN officially declared Georgia an aggressor in this conflict. This is not a very convenient fact for the context of this video.
Not the UN but the European Commission, but you are right, Georgia was really the aggressor, by the way, the European Commission changed its decision after 6 years
@@anodkato1707 "Not the UN but the European Commission" - The Chairman of the UN General Assembly, Miguel d'Escoto Brockmann, at a press conference at UN headquarters (63rd session on September 17, 2008), officially stated: “By invading South Ossetia, Georgia committed an act of aggression and violated the UN Charter.”
😂😂😂
That's the same reason they tend to ignore the Dagestan War and the second Chechen war
Exactly👍
If Iraq was fair game then so is Ukraine 😂😂
There are literally no similarities between Ukraine and Iraq. Iraq under Saddam Hussein's rule started numerous wars against its' neighbors in the middle east. Hussein himself wasn't a good guy, he was a tyrant whose death Iraqis celebrated.
Ukraine did not start any wars against its' neighbors, Zelensky unlike Hussein is a democratically elected president of Ukraine.
What you did is called "whataboutism". American invasion of Iraq was wrong but it doesn't justify what Russia did to Ukraine
@@robertking4645 That's where you are confused at. It has a lot to do with everything. If Bush has the right to go into somebody else country and remove the president then so does Vladimir Putin shut your fucking mouth and mind your business dude. You don't even know what's going on in this world. What the United States did was beyond wrong. It was murder and now look they. Caused in the region. You are white so you are never going to see things for what it really is. You are going to put on your rose colored glasses and just go with the regular program. If United States can do it, what makes Russia not able to do it? President Bush should have been in jail
@@robertking4645 The only reason they attract Saddam Hussein was for oil. As soon as he started burning his oil fields that's when they attacked him because that's what it really was about. If you are that naive you need to go look up this stuff. It's facts. You are just a dummy who don't know what's going on in the world
Exactly Saddam kept iran in check
@@robertking4645It does actually. If Russia lets Ukraine join NATO it would give access to the USA to station their troops in the country. And probably place their nuclear weapon there as well. All ukraine had to do was agree that they wouldn't join NATO. Let's say if russia places their troops on US borders,what would you think will happen ?. Move on to iraq. So what does justify the US to kill saddam hussein ? They claimed that iraq has WMD. They didn't attack iraq because saddam hussein was a bad guy but because they made a false accusation that iraq has WMD backed by israel. I think nentanyahu's full speech is still somewhere in the medsos. He talked about how these countries will threaten israel's existence in the future
You know, sometimes pretending to be a fool is the smartest thing.
A Fool For Christ
"It is proper to play the fool at the appropriate occasion." ~~~ The Bard
1000 percent
Vladimir Putin is a very beautiful man
Why nobody talk about that China has imprisoned more than 1 million Uyghurs! Why nobody talk about that Mongolian, during their expansion of Mongol empire, has slaughtered more than 100 million around the world, which, more horribly, all were done by blades and arrows. Why everyone think that Chinese is a more decent ruler who deserves taking control of Siberia.
The American movies are the best truth indicators- when you watch them, you know that the truth is totally opposite.
Obviously this video hurt your feelings.
The reason why eastern Europe hates Russia is imperialism, lack of economic opportunity that get, dictatorship... Look at Russia's Only Eastern Europe puppet Belarus, do they rich or poor? Look at Poland a country choose the path to erase dictatorship and communism in their ideology do they got richer or poorer in when they communism and now at capitalism
Like Crimson tide?
@@change691Not obvious to me. Get a grip.
@@change691LE ORANGE MAN BAD! Oh please🥱🥱🥱🥱🥱🥱
Bush saying "we are a peaceful nation" is surrealistic. Like all American democracy.
Yes he forgot the Atomic Bomb in Iroshima🎉etc etc
And destroying hundreds of countries
well...we live in a world.
And it’s clear that this is why Putin smiled at Trump because he is not a gold digging dog chasing after other countries’s fuel, lithium , other resources… and taking their lives for it.
It was very funny indeed
Frontline is awesome 👍🏻 I need to hear this.
Putin's speech in Munich was taken out of context. I recommend that you watch his speech in full and understand that he was indignant that a country in which the death penalty is prohibited publicly executes the ruler of another country. he also asks directly about the expansion of Nato and new American military bases in Bulgaria and Romania
goodplace=stupid?=Russian trolls?=MAGA?=the rapist Trump's supporter?
This 👆 but again are we really surprised that they took it out of context with this narrative...
the speech is still available on yt if anyone is interrested
Imagine Russia causing problems to the USA in Cuba or mexico...it would have been different story.
Putin made a promise that he would never use a country against another. Instead of being thankful, Democrats still do the opposite that
ENG-LUNDIANS ' DESCENDANTS ARE CRIMINALS
Buddy missed the whole part about election interference lol
@@noone4474 after they sponsored UkrAine uprising and forced regime change
As an American I stand with you brother
Putin isn’t wrong about most of our foreign policies, we are terrible when it comes to regime change, makes complete sense why he wouldn’t like US at all.
He is wrong though. US was racist with its regime change and only targeted the Middle East (brown people). It didn’t have much to do with the color revolutions in Eastern Europe (white people) except encourage democracy. So Putin is paranoid on us involvement and fails to see his role in the revolutions
I don't think "regime change" is included in the modern-day foreign policy of the US. It just happens that regime change is almost always possible only from an Autocrat/Communist type of government to a more democratic type. The west will always support and welcome that change of course, and Russia will always prevent that. That is how it will always be.
Putin hates US not because of his strong beliefs in sovereignty of every country. The only reason is putin’s fear. He doesn’t want to die saddam’s or gaddafi’s death
Russian bot everywhere
...and we do not like him....
Why isn't this on our other news channels
Why nobody talk about that China has imprisoned more than 1 million Uyghurs! Why nobody talk about that Mongolian, during their expansion of Mongol empire, has slaughtered more than 100 million around the world, which, more horribly, all were done by blades and arrows. Why everyone think that Chinese is a more decent ruler who deserves taking control of Siberia.
Truer advice has never been given. ❤❤❤❤❤
Why nobody talk about that China has imprisoned more than 1 million Uyghurs! Why nobody talk about that Mongolian, during their expansion of Mongol empire, has slaughtered more than 100 million around the world, which, more horribly, all were done by blades and arrows. Why everyone think that Chinese is a more decent ruler who deserves taking control of Siberia.
Putin is living proof how to deal with the U.S foreign policy
It is not that. He was willing to cooperate with the US but from bush to Obama and now Biden with the stupidity ruined everything. Now Putin won't trust the west one bit anymore. Despite still open for western companies to continue their business in Russia
True
True
💯
PBS = MSM AIDs
YOUR tax dollars go to these fools to pump out propaganda against YOU.
Like Musk said to Igor F off PBS.
It's still strange to think that in the time we've had 5 Presidents in the U.S., Putin has been either President or Prime Minister during all that time
Yep, but his dictatorship won't last for much longer.
That is the system they have, I don’t see anything wrong, is better than having a president ( United States) receiving orders from the elite
Like the queen?
@@eavyeavy2864 Does Biden make any meaningful decisions, do you think?
don't forget, that you have a deep state, a "swamp" like Trump said, and he is right. There are people in US. They are in shadow, but they are rule this country since Kennedy was killed, and they don't want to loose their power
It’s crazy when you realize where Putin got his playbook from
Very interesting
Did anyone noticed how and why Syria was completely ignored in this video
*LOTS* of important things were completely ignored in this video! It's a deep-state propaganda film!
Not me.
Yes
There's a lot completely ignored in this video. I'm as opposed to the Russian invasion of Ukraine as anyone but it's ridiculous how much this piece leans into the "Putin actually thinks the United States has had ulterior motives and it's foreign policy has had harmful consequences" bit, which is just objectively true and plain obvious to the rest of the world. Then again PBS basically is US State media so I guess that's to be expected.
Two words American version
As an American, listening to the interviews with Blinken, Yovanovitch, Sullivan, Bolton... is profoundly insulting and embarrassing.
They call him a liar when they are bigger liars themselves.
Why? Those men are doing what’s in America’s interests. What else should they do, try to be objective about things? Why? Their job is to push the American agenda. That’s good and that’s exactly what they should be doing. It should inform their world view. If a secretary of state gets interviewed and starts saying “You know America is just as bad because of x y z and imperialism etc etc imperialism” then I want someone else to be our secretary of state.
@@rinoking88
🤣🤣🤣🤣👍
@ohdear8888 “You know america is just as bad because of xyr..” that’s literally every democrat talking point and justification for all of there horrible policies
@@miguelfluendez88
Might want to look a little deeper into each of their backgrounds. Their actions are literally who your reply refers to.
loved this
This is a really good documentary showing the progression of putin and the US
Why nobody talk about that China has imprisoned more than 1 million Uyghurs! Why nobody talk about that Mongolian, during their expansion of Mongol empire, has slaughtered more than 100 million around the world, which, more horribly, all were done by blades and arrows. Why everyone think that Chinese is a more decent ruler who deserves taking control of Siberia.
"US Presidents come and go but their policies remain the same." - Vladimir Putin.
THE TRUTH EVERYTHING U SAID IS THE TRUTH🚬🗿
Russia's president came and stayed through dictatorship 😅 but it was nice try to spread the dictator's propaganda. 🫳 🎤
@@steveborgmalta Hey, but it is ok to spread the American double stadard, right? Or American exceptionalism?
Amen 🙏
@@commanderiosifstalin4938 Am I lying? Three U.S. presidents have changed while Putin has been President. Are you naive enough not to understand that this happens partly because he kills and jails his opposition? What double standards? These are facts. Putin was elected with over 75% of the votes. Such high margins are huge red flags for dictatorships. You can see similar patterns in Belarus, Congo, Uganda and so on.
During the Bush years they could have mentioned the wars in Chechnya and the Baltic states joining NATO, while during Obama and Trump's years they forgot to mention Syria.
But that would either make Republicans look good or Democrats not always be our saviors. This is Frontline's leftist agenda, not news.
@Michael Singleton yeah I'm not a Republican but I did feel/see the bias against Trump watching this. If you're gonna criticize previous US presidents for failing on Russia, then you can't ignore Obama failing his "red line" on Syria or how Mitt Romney tried to warn Obama about Russia being a rival only for Obama and Dems to brush it off at the time. Plus it was under Trump's presidency that the US started sending lethal aid to Ukraine. Feels very important in the history of modern US/Russia relations.
They should also have mentioned the cause of the troubles in Ukraine 2014 which ultimately led to this situation today!
Great point.
@@irynaohara6645 As well as the Divison of territory during the Soviet Union that was cohesive, and after the break up that is causing these problems today.
Well Done
Watching this after watching the Tucker Carlson interview with Putin in 2024 reveals the biased nature of this documentary.
You missed the whole point bru 🤦♂️ just like trump you fell victim to the lies and manipulation of Putin
As if Tucker Carlson's interview wasn't biased. If anything, watching putin speak directly confirmed many things described in this documentary. The guy is a revanchist, obsessed with the restoration of what he considers to be "russian greatness", he denies neighboring countries their right to exist based on his twisted view of history.
I hope all viewers are aware of what American Democracy means.
We are a republic!
@@tommyverenini4653 You only know that because its been brought up so much in the last couple of years!
aah... u do know that americans were forced to give up their freedoms in exchange for security bcoz of a certain bush lead 911 action team right..... how can u claim democracy if u dont have freedom in the first place?
@@chhansen9813 Because YOU say so? I have known that for years. I paid attention to history. Nice assumption!
@@tommyverenini4653 LMMFAO! BS!
When Bush said I looked at his eyes and I could see his sense of his soul: Putin's reaction is priceless 😂😂
🤣🤣🤣 Буш, который не мог открыть открытую дверь "заглянул в душу"??? Это не просто смешно, это дико смешно. Он себя то в зеркале не всегда видит. Какое самомнение!😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@juliablake9427😂😂😂😂
It is really hilarious that they spoke like in movie :D
yea putin and baby g bush had something going they love money and hate there own people in there country
USA and NATO wants the Capitalism World and Western Centralization.
Some Random KGB Officers in 2000:
1 year later ???
It’s funny to see these pictures of Putin in black and white (grey) collars accompanied by a gloomy announcers voice.
Why nobody talk about that China has imprisoned more than 1 million Uyghurs! Why nobody talk about that Mongolian, during their expansion of Mongol empire, has slaughtered more than 100 million around the world, which, more horribly, all were done by blades and arrows. Why everyone think that Chinese is a more decent ruler who deserves taking control of Siberia.
If the us government find someone strong, they say we don't approve it like they were the owners of this planet 😂
you're correct..they never looking to the mirror that they're hypocritical country
Zelensky is strong, and liked by the USA...
@@nicolasoltonstrongest summoning jutsu for sure
And then we proceed to send in the CIA and foment anger, protests and trouble, eventually toppling the leaders the US does not approve of. We are a war mongering country who should take care of our business at home. Look at the mess Biden has put us in today. Sickening. We have veterans who fought for our freedom which Biden's actions cause to be made homeless over and over again. Our veterans are kicked out of housing to make room for the many criminals and illegals that Biden invites to come into our open southern border.
So you’re justifying this POS Putin? You people are sick
How nice of the CIA to write, produce, and to supply all the interviews. They completely ignored the Crimea elections in which they overwhelmingly voted to join the Russian Federation.
And Putin led up to it in 2007 with some words about "democracy" at a world conference. What democracy exists in Russia?
the washington post jounalist saying putin had racism towards obama was one of the stupidest things to have been said amidst the seriousness of the russia ukraine issue
It was most funny moment🤣
Absolutely.
Their idea of understanding global politics is differentiating between different shades of skin color. It's mind boggling these are supposed to be intellectuals.
Thats what they do. Trumps foreign policy was superior to the other.
I don't know how to like this a million times.
Bush : Looked the Man in the Eye, and I got a sense of his soul.
Putin: 😁😁😁
What do you get from the soul if you try to kill it ?
Soulless
Putin has a soul?
@boardcertifiable he doesn't have democracy in his heart! - President Clinton to President Yeltsin.
iraq : 😭😭
@@ihatesummers3153 AFGANİSTAN SYRİA LİBYA ....
I love how you call him racist just basing on made up stuff 😂
RAS TERKUAT DAN BENAR KENYATAAN,
BAIK IBU JALANG MIGRAN,INVASI KEAMERIKA, BERANAK PINAK LANTAS MENGINVASI NEGARA APA TIDAK TAUNAMANYA,
😘SAYA MENYUKAI INI 😘😘👏👏
vatnik bot
@@mcmaster2722 how so
This is typical PBS alt left propaganda. making idiot Biden who Obama said was the dumbest person ever in foreign policy to be a tough guy with Putin what a joke. And the fact is the intelligence agencies did lie about the interference in the 2016 election. The only known election interference was the Obama administration in England’s Brexit election and Israel’s election Obama use taxpayer dollars to interfere with two different countries and their elections ! FACTS ❗️This documentary is nothing but DNC propaganda.
You have a point. Obama was an empty suit. As for Biden his dementia gets worse geometrically. I do hope there’s a debate between Trump and Biden.
I like how its "Putin gets away with Georgia" right after usa unvaded iraq
The audacity of this documentary, trying to paint Putin as the villain, while at the same time displaying the attrocities Bush did without any importance is soooo stupid amazing.
This documentary, actually paints why Putin is the good guy.
😂😂😂, putin don't need anyone to help hem look like a villain. The guy walks like a mobster bet the guy sees the godfather and scarface movies every night.
@@Ivan-tm9pd yet he's the one fighting for family, values and truth. Amazing.
@@abrahamcanales132 how is he fighting for family values and truth?
I find it funny the guy who obviously cant see thru the bullshite is name Ivan lmao....Ivan Drago another attempt by us to paint Russians as the "bad guys". I bet Ivan must think we (yes, I'm an american citizen) are the "good guys". Ivan you silly boy.
In war there is no good guys and bad guys. Everyone loses except the ones who profit from it. Who are they? The ones that are in your screen telling that ukraine is winning, Russia is losing, and we need to keep sending billions to Ukraine to protect their "democracy". Its 2023, any updates about how well this is workin out for ukraine? Yeah we help butcher those people, having them as our front line crash test dummies. There will be no ukraine when its over and the way its goin now, shite there might not be any world if WE keep poking at as ivan describes a "mobster". I'd say hes actually an extremely patient man that has put up with alot of OUR bullshit because he cares about his country and people. He dont wanna go to war with us, not cuz he scared to lose, but because he knows there will be no one left to stand victorious. Think about it....just sit and think about it. By the way Putin actually only showed respect and some liking to trump...deny it with your own eyes. Your problem not mine. I'm proud to be american but when your wrong, your wrong, and we have been doing everything wrong for a last couple years. We've been dead wrong, and the whole world sees it except us. Putin isn't a pushover and wont be bullied by US, and that's why we dont like him cause he'll stand up to us. I respect that stance in any man on this planet. END THE WAR...IF YOU DONT WANT TO END THE WORLD YOU DUMBFUX IN DC. Maybe that's what they want. Who fuckin even knows at this point what the fuck they want
Trump 2024 there is no other option
@@abrahamcanales132😂 good joke
Let a man find himself. The truth is the answer to his personal experience with purpose.
How spineless is Bolton? If he was so smart when he was in the room, then why was he so incompetent at advising Bush and Trump? He's always the "I told you so" guy.
Bolton is the real fool.
He was an advisor
He's a War Crimes Walrus what do you expect
What did you expect? It was baby Shrub whose legacy is "My Pet Goat," and the Dumpster, whose legacy is granny panties on the golf-course.
@@nutsackmania expect more war, for lack of better advisement..
"In Russia, nothing is more dangerous than the appearance of weakness." Peter Stolypin, a provincial governor under the last Romanov tsar, Nicholas II.
People often Make the mistake of trying to compare Russian people or any other people from that region to the US. Night and day. I've been there. And it was very Humbling.
@@GrayGamer889 I didn't understand what you meant.
@jim2376 Then why do you people mourn the Czar as if he was Russia's Martin Luther King Jr?
@@BolshevikCarpetbagger1917 Objection. Assumes facts not in evidence. Sustained.
@@jim2376 Start by reading the comments section of virtually every video of the Romanovs. I pose the question again. Why is Czar Nicky II so cherished in the West?
John McCain's face says it all
expressed a true feelings about his family. Because, he is truthful human being.
A number of years ago, I wanted to do something to accelerate my time to being financially independent. I ended up investing 1k grands January with Diego Dias Cardoso, now I have an extra $700k. Thinking about getting first rental property
I can see you know about him too. Having assets and not being able to profit from them can be very frustrating, big thanks to Diego Dias, as I make huge profits trading with him on weekly basis. He's definitely the best.
I've got quarter million to invest, but I want to ensure profits My friends say I shouldn't buy properties yet, as there is a makert crash coming. Love to give him a try
Well, when it comes to long term investment and improving one's portfolio with time, the person for the job is Diego Dias Cardoso Check. No doubt
This is not the first time I'm hearing about Diego Dias Cardoso and his testimonials but I have no idea on how to reach him.
Or on telegram
West colonialism is already in the world. But they market it as a Democracy.
Into the eyes of a real person will see the Integrity of a friend. There's a saying "actions speak louder than words". 🇵🇭
you had marcos.... twice.
Rip.....❤
31:19 i wanna see what this guy crying tears of joy would look like. 😂
Amazing how they completely fail to mention WHY Russia went into Georgia.
Why?
@@minadiesel4506 Because Georgia was attacking civilians and Russian peacekeepers.
@@myronplatte8354 Just as Poland attacked a German radio station and thus provoked an invasion in 1939. The Nazi’s methods don’t change over time.
@@Rezistons So? This is irrelevant.
@@myronplatte8354we Russians wish to take Alaska as we owned Alaska before. We invading Ukraine for that exact reason so why not Alaska? We need daddy Putin to do this. America is weak. Probably don’t even have a military now
"Putin sees..."
"Putin thinks...."
I want to learn this skills these people have, to be able to get inside someone's head and know how he sees/thinks!
Thank you very much. These guys are thinking for Vladimir
oh, yes, even on my channel, for some reason people think for me. You don't have to say anything, and they'll start building theories about what you might have said... also with such a serious face 🤮🤢
THANK YOU! Usually this channel produces high quality content, but this one is so clearly biased and people using telepathy just to make Russia a villain -- like people forgot how bad USA actually is in it's own agendas. . I think that Putin and Russia are World's last hope of defense against USA (that doesn't mean that Russia is innocent or Putin tho)
me too :-)
Putin is not our enemy. The leaders of usa are the enemy.
Quotes I Pulled From This....
1. "Confronted With Donald Trump Is Like An Open Field In Front Of A Football Player Carrying A Football. Putin Thought Trump Was A Fool!"
2. "He Learned How To Play Donald Trump Like A Violin."
3. "Putin Saw Him As Gullible, Stupid, & Easily Manipulatable... He Braided Him Like A Braid!"
Exactly. Period. Point Blank. WAKE UP PEOPLE!!!
No doubt. And Sleepy Joe just called this dangerous man an s.o.b. (!). Joe, please go.
this will not age well
Cryptocurrency investment is one of the best way to earn more money, this is the best time to concentrate on BTC, ETH, BNB and other crypto investment....you can earn more coins investing... quite a passive way to earn.. Success depends on the action or steps you take to achieve it. Design yourself within your mind! A high level of Positive Self-image is the key!
@Byron Westbrick Her technical analysis is good.
@Camp Johnston That was my case till I came across Beatrice O Wendy.
@Camp Johnston All you need as a beginner to make good profit from cryptocurrency is a professional trader who will trade on your behalf else you may make huge losses.
Working with a pro trader is a good option for newbies who are ready to invest. Investing in cryptocurrency is one of the best decision i made last year.
The most overlooked aspect of acquiring the skill of trading is self image work...
there are few people i trust less than putin. they include virtually everyone interviewed for this 'documentary'
Facts
Lol love it. Anthony blinken 💩 John Bolton 💩, interviewers 💩
Мало тебя те кому "доверяешь" опускали? Продолжай!
Big cap
Me to and I’m American.
OK. I am a citizen of Russia. In this movie, the Americans tell me that former KGB agent Vladimir Putin is hellbent to restore the power of the Russian Empire.
OK, I've heard you.
Will there be any disadvantages? :3
30:20 Yep
It seems to me that the West does not fully understand what it is facing. I will explain - I live in a remote village on the edge of Russia, but nevertheless there is almost no Internet here, but people know about events in the world. When a Ukrainian rocket hit a house in the Kursk region on the territory of Russia 4 months ago, the next day 15 people from my village went to the front voluntarily
NOBODY CAN WIN OVER RUSSIA
Slava Rossii
Yet You sit in your home, good story, bot
@@imsusanov2287 damn, you still don’t understand what you face with
1500 Russian volunteers a day. But in Ukraine men and women between the ages of 25 and 70 are being pulled off the street, out of gyms and stores. The war is over the only thing left to be settled is how many more Ukrainians have to die before a negotiation happens.
The narrator's voice should be saved and used in other documentaries even 100 yrs from now
With AI it'll be possible.
You right about that voice....I think Chapelle used him in an episode...
we are close to that already with artificial intelligence, James Earle Jones will be Darth Vader forever, he's signed a contract that Disney can synthesize his voice from here on out
Voice ai could save it
America by pushing its democrazy hated by many, tries to advance its dominance which often result in wars, like Iraq, Afghanistan, Lydia. Syria. The US failed its democrazy advancement and chaos manage to in Syria. Will Ukraine become a shining beacon of democracy ??
Add russian subtitles, please.
As I approach my 70s, I often find it entertaining to go back and watch how ridiculous US propaganda is and was, although the problem is, like this show, that its often so dumbed down that I can never seem to force myself to get through a whole show without turning it off because of the ridiculous shading and twisting of true history that I have actually lived through and witnessed.
OK boomer
@@wasdgamings ...actually if I were a boomer, I would likely already be in my 70s, I'm a joneser, a member of the so called lost generation that came between the boomers and the Xers, to which no specific social engineering was targeted at, although the dates for jonesers has been manipulated too and combined in with the boomers because so many of the jonesers just adopted the social engineering and marketing that was aimed at the boomers.
Keep in mind here, that the boomers were the first US generation to be greatly influenced and manipulated by television, as were and are most individuals of all generations hence, the generation classification itself is used to identify what particular social engineering and marketing that each generation hence was or is exposed to, however as a member of the "lost" generation, I had the unintended advantage to look at one or all. and consequently i noticed the changes between them perhaps more so than many others that were specifically being targeted and basically never completely vibed with any of them.
Further, I am at the very beginning of the so called lost generation, before such loss was noticed and patched up. I never adopted or incorporated the social engineering/marketing targeting the boomers or those generations that followed, and rather than looking to any of the post TV generations for insight, I looked more to the WW2 and WW1 generations (as well as first editions of books) for guidance and education - to which my immediate boomer elders were already in the process of distancing themselves from their elders, parents and their knowledge base as a result of the social engineering/marketing and related control of pop culture via television that was already targeting them, just as current generations are so targeted and manipulated. Hence the boomers were also known for their "tune in, turn on and drop out" pop culture.
This disconnect between elders, parents and their offspring provided for a block or disconnect in the ability for parents and other elders to pass down their acquired living experience and prime source knowledge, as such, this functioned to force the generations that followed to be more dependent on mass media and the written word as virtually their only source for historical information, of course both mass media and the written word can be colored, shaded and/or re-written to conform with any particular narrative or agenda that the controlling "elites" wish to present. :-)
I agree. I'm 30 and I've seen Americans being tricked in supporting wars abroad. By the time the Ukraine war came I knew there was so much more to the story. For example the 2014 coup in Ukraine which ousted the Russian friendly Ukrainian government that was democratically elected
@@stratomoryaan entire essay 😭
@@number1soobinstan😂
Americans most dangerous power is to portray anyone that don't bow down to them as villain to the whole world when they are the bullies 😂😂 Anthony Blinken is the most dangerous man for the rest of the world
Putin literally is a villain. Ask anyone in Ukraine, Poland, Georgia, Finland, Estonia, Latvia or Lithuania what they think of him. If you think America is a bully, you would think the same of putin
Bush saying "we are a peaceful nation"
Every person talking here is Biased and it makes the documentary loose credit coz we not hearing anything from the other side or someone disagreeing with America 🇺🇸
No matter what but Putin really got some characters that attract a lot of people
Its Putin's raw nationalist appeal,works the same way FDR did
At this very moment in time,Russia is the (supposedly)second strongest nation on earth,while simultaneously being in one of the most isolated geopolitical horrible landscape one could possibly imagine
And Putin's narcissistic optimistic nationalist appeal that one day Russia will tear the west down the same way they tore down the Warsaw Pact
Also the trauma of a Democratic government by Boris Yeltsin,a complete shitshow
Who Medvedev? Lavrov? Patrushev? Peskov?
Is your mom attracted ?
@@nicolasoltoni think by "characters" he meant a will, like the man of character. You get it?
@@VSYAC I think so. But who are they, if not the ones I mentioned?
All those presidents don’t amount the courage of Vladimir Putin long live mother Russia 🇷🇺
Wecome❤❤❤❤
Wrong? I'm sorry to say with all respect to you, sir. President Putin never thought about President Trump what you said.
Забавно как данная документалка выставляет Путина злодеем, при этом очевидно что Америка толкнула его на это противостояние.
I disagree with you. The negative energy only comes from the interviewers in this documentary but you could see some parts of it giving him the main character vibe. Well I don’t like Putin but the way he gave his speech at Munich German was really brave and bold. Aside from nukes and soldiers they couldn’t match the US but he spoke is on the point and honest. That’s admirable.
@@Anistotle what makes America the one to criticize anyone they destroyed beautiful countries Since 1945, the United States has invaded or intervened in over 50 countries, including military invasions and covert operations.
But the thing America is the who controls most media and it's hard get unbiased opinions like what there motivations are and becomes stereotypical words like comminists and etc. I want information bro😢
Don't worry my Russian brother.
The world no longer follow west.
Putin winnnnnnnnnn
Russia, along with India supported us in Bangladesh during our Liberation War of 1971. Today, Putin had allowed Russia provided us scholarships to study in Russia. Russia along with India helped us in Bangladesh War.
😍
Bro remember USA send aircraft carrier to stop our liberation war. But Russia was fast and first who entered in the bay of Bengal Ocean before USA. And it's helped a lot for Bangladesh ❤😊
Wow, he has been through a lot of presidents.
Тут явно не хватает этого комментария:
Было малое село
Да на Волге где-то.
Очень девкам не везло
Во селенье этом.
Шла молва по всей Земле По каналам разным,
Что у девок на селе
Не было оргазма
ПРИПЕВ: Эх-ма, зёма, не было оргазму, Эх-ма, зёма, не было его!
И гадал весь род людской Над загадкой бился,
Что за парадокс такой
Во селе случился.
Вроде все у девок есть: Джинсы, сигареты,
Совесть есть, и ум, и честь, А оргазма нету!
Приезжали к ним надысь Бабки-ворожеи.
Девки очень напряглись,
Аж помыли шеи.
Бабки лезли под подол, Купали в купели, Применяли панадол,
Но не преуспели...
Написали девки в
Местную газету:
Помогите нам хоть вы, больше мочи нету!
Что, естественно, друзья,
То не безобразно,
Потому никак нельзя
Жить нам без оргазма!
Тут узнало все село
С телетайпной ленты
То, что дело их дошло
Аж до президента.
И сказал тогда народ:
«Путина харизма
Очень сильную дает встряску организму!» ПРИПЕВ: Эх-ма, зёма, встряску организму!
Эх-ма, зёма, встряску органу!
Девки глянули в окно:
А в окне все ближе
Едет Путин в кимоно
И на горных лыжах.
Девки выскочили вон
В чем их мать родила... Поглядел на девок он.
Тут их и накрыло!
ПРИПЕВ Эх-ма, зёма, тут их и накрыло, Эх-ма, зёма, тут их и накрыло!
Very nice documentary,
We would like to see alo a ducumentary about USA presidents, also about wars in Cambodia, Vietnam, Yugoslavia, Afghanistan, Iraq,Sirya, Libya, and many more counties and their war, expecially who start the war and how many casualties have all together in all those conflicts and wars.
Especially the very very sad story about former Yugoslavia, unique country with values and harmony totally destroyed by deep state of America... never forgiven or forgotten
This documentary is just straight propaganda
@@svetlana7904 Broz-Tito was a dictator ,
even with the fact that he made country
live better than before him .
He , just like a Putin , prolonged his term
until the time of his own death ,
even arrested his own wife ( !!! ) , etc.
Nevertheless , there were also good things
as federalisation in 70's , mixed economy
and other stuff . So , don't consider
all regimes and states as terrible or ideal ,
there are always both minuses and pluses .
And all these communists and socialists
are just too radical and conservative either
( if you ask me , I am social-democrat )
hawai
good one ,was thinking of it also , ofc us will finds putin but not themselves
One thing i have to say ,putin,russia and ussr bring voice and strength to global south
By bombing precious grain ships so people starve en masse right? Great help 👏👏👏
52:47 minutes is lies.... enjoy this work of fiction
Not everybody in the whole world.stop it this our content that will continue sparking hatred between America and Russia
I didn't knew America is so pure and perfect😀😀
😁😁😁😁😁
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂🤣
@@Ramtinthangofficial have you heard the opposite?
@@Ramtinthangofficial the whole report 😂
I want Will Lyman to narrate my life. There is no better ASMR than his voice in a Frontline documentary.
Absolutely right he’s the best of the best
It's either him or James Earl Jones to do my voice-mail.
Me too!
@@timgriffin3368 lol 😂
If it was not for the USA... Russia would have not been in Ukraine
Bush junior was thinking Putin would be just another Russian president willing to be humiliated like Boris Yeltsin was by the USA .
That Bush line is…😂 Like most of the asinine crap that came out that man’s mouth, all you can do is laugh.
The dead who have died under American cannons since World War II will never laugh again (Korea, Congo, Vietnam, South and Central America, Grenada, Serbia, Iraq, Libya, Afghanistan, Syria...etc...etc.
@@vilmabohunicka6021 The dead don’t laugh, and there are plenty of Russians who put people to the sword after staring into their souls too. Stalin immediately comes to mind. My point was you just have to laugh at G.W. Bush because obviously his soul judging was way off.
@@shannonbrown5913 Stalin was not Russian, he was Georgian.
@@RafaelGonzalez-vs2bu I have heard that before. I usually don’t note it, but I will in the future. 👍🏽
@@RafaelGonzalez-vs2bu , historically this is a distinction without a difference. We're not talking about the relative merits of Georgian versus Russian native dance. Perhaps you're not old enough to remember, but I certainly recall that throughout the Cold War the names Russia and the Soviet Union (of which Georgia was a part) were synonymous. So as a political matter, which is the one that matters here, Stalin was Russian. Full stop. Don't play games here. This is serious stuff.
"I have survived your predecessors, and I will survive you."
-Vladimir Putin
🤢🤮
Imagine having same guy as president from birth to middle age, just say your a king already.
Despotic and depressing.
@@abdiganiaden United Kingdom had queen Elisabeth II. as supreme despot on the throne since 1953 up to 2022. Saudi King - Abdullah is the supreme leader and commander of Saudi Arabia since 1940's. Or good old friend of Joe Biden - Xi Jin Ping who is the general secretary of the Communist Party of China.
@@abdiganiaden as long as he keeps the country strong and moving forward. That's great.
Not some m0r0n in the west that serves the interests of the elite at the expense of the middle class
Lol. This is the end for him. Democracy lives because dictators die. People die ideologies live forever
You never knw what bulling is untill you get bulled and calling someone a bully you have to be afraid of him
Democracy is a western value, alien for rest of the world. That value has to be revalued in terms of natural revolution. A president is native to their homeland, why counterpart would expect similar value, puppets other than new opinions which can be settled down by dialogues and series of discussions.
Putin played agains America alone for a long time still fighting for his country. What a strong man. He made russian proud.
Naaa all he has done is send Russian man to die in a war they don't support
Why the Russia's only puppet county Belarus is poor while those Russia ally in past that let go communism and dictatorship like Poland was prosperous now... No wonder eastern Europe hates Russia because Russia is economic failure
👏💪👍
Yeah, especially those hundreds of thousands of russian men that were killed by ukrianians in the last two years.
I'm sure hundreds of thousands of young talented people that left Russia for Europe and the US are really proud of Putin.
Dear America, leave other countries and their views alone. Even if they don't align with yours
Russia’s literally invading another country at this exact moment💀
@@Ryandeanchickenpeen They do? Which one, Iraq?
@@harderway8568 nope but they beat us to invading Afghanistan💀
@@Ryandeanchickenpeen The US/NATO practically invented invading other countries
nope. other countries are low on transgender people
This is so painful to watch
You know whats really funny....im an American citizen and find myself more understanding of putin and why he does what he does....we deserve this as Americans who are distracted by domestic homeland issues and lack the knowledge to elect leaders who are strong foreign policy makers and can redifine what our purpose is on the global stage.
Which should be to withdraw and stop interfering in foreign governments on an attempt tp usurp power in our direction/favoritism. When will america wake up?
Yo, for sure it is a surprise to receive a replay after 2 months (but watched this just now). I have to dissagre with you. As much as i dont hate/like RU or USA, a poker face or a hooker face is all any country can sustain. Most countries are the latter, but there comes the poker face.
EDIT (as it may be unclear): US and RU are big and powerful, even if on some random day of the year they are not, they must pretend to be (in any way possible).
Of course you will find it funny in presence of underappriciated liberty and comfort. Of course you will understand Putin better because the defening music is good to hear from a vast distance.
The reason why eastern Europe hates Russia is imperialism, lack of economic opportunity that get, dictatorship... Look at Russia's Only Eastern Europe puppet Belarus, do they rich or poor? Look at Poland a country choose the path to erase dictatorship and communism in their ideology do they got richer or poorer in when they communism and now at capitalism
There are so many inaccuracies with this documentary. I thought I would give PBS another opportunity but between now and my last breath it will be the last time I watch anything put together by this channel. SMH 🙄
What do you expect of a group of Western funded news media built for western interests
It’s pure gaslighting and pure propaganda worse then what USSR did lol
I have never seen such a stream of lies against Putin. It's just unbelievable.
I agree
Where are the inaccuracies.
That was great. He is a smart man
All of this must be true and that's why the US was so happy when Tucker Carlson went to Moscow and interviewed President Putin
No mention of the reasons given by Putin on why they went into Ukraine, a very one sided interpretation of what happened
Award worthy propaganda. The amount of lies from our favorite criminals is staggering. Words like liberty, democracy and freedom, good 1, I love it! lol
When Putin looks at someone, he decides whether he is looking at either Predator or Prey. God help the latter.
😂
Fools like you are what embolden that cynic kgb. You call yourself an American?! I CANNOT BELIEVE HOW PATHETIC REPUBLICANS HAVE BECOME. DEMS at least stick to their bleeding heart race card loving shenanigans. But REPUBLICANS CLAIM TO BE THE TRUE AMERICAN PARTY YET THEY LITERALLY ADVOCATE IF NOT ADMIRE THE ONE PERSON WHO REPRESENTS EVERYTHING THIS COUNTRY HAS FOUGHT AGAINST FOR LITERALLY NEAR-HALF OF THIS COUNTRY'S EXISTENCE. WTF I SWEAR I NEVER THOUGHT ID SAY THAT I WISH REAGAN WOULD COME BACK. GODAM AT LEAST THEN REPS HAD SOME DAMN PRIDE TO BE AMERICANS FOR BETTER OR WORSE. THIS NEW WAVE SEEM TO BE WILLING TO DESTROY THEIR OWN COUNTRY AT ALL COSTS. BOTH PARTIES HAVE TAKEN FOR GRANTED WHAT DEMOCRACY IS BECAUSE THATS ALL THEY HAVE KNOWN. WE HAVE FORGOTTEN WHAT THE ALTERNATE REALITY COULD BE.
same with US. US only respects nuclear powers
You're talking about a guy that sleeps and lives in a bunker.
I dunno. He looks like an inbred midget to me.
Nice documentary
One honest man against five successive crooks