Firebox "Wood Flame" Gas Burner -Trangia Alternative? Comprehensive Review

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 27 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 96

  • @zero-ol2nt
    @zero-ol2nt Рік тому +8

    One underrated touch to this burner compaired to the trangia burner is the metal clips are rounded off. The trangia clips were really sharp often times scratching or tearing some materials. I rounded off my trangia burner clips with sandpaper. Good to see the firebox burner already solved this 👌

    • @MarkYoungBushcraft
      @MarkYoungBushcraft  Рік тому +2

      Yes, good point. I noted that but forgot to include it. Thanks for commenting

  • @jasrVid
    @jasrVid Рік тому +6

    Mark, thanks for the work of evaluating these stoves. I grew up in Alaska and have used canister stoves in many cold conditions. When it is colder than 0F i use a tea candle to heat the canister. This has worked to -40 every time.

  • @melissahoffman4687
    @melissahoffman4687 Рік тому +3

    The beauty of multifuel stoves. More than one option of cooking time, plus warmth. These burners would be a great necessity for rocket and wood gasifier stoves too. The rocket and wood gasifier stoves would be the perfect wind screen.

    • @MarkYoungBushcraft
      @MarkYoungBushcraft  Рік тому +2

      Interesting idea. Something I should be able to test. Thanks for commenting

  • @imnotthere
    @imnotthere Рік тому +1

    Thank you for reviewing the firebox combination with various stoves.

  • @1eyedjacksRwild
    @1eyedjacksRwild Рік тому +2

    I am looking forward to receiving mine. You did a good job reviewing this Mark. Thanks!

  • @denisgrehan242
    @denisgrehan242 Рік тому +5

    Another excellent thorough review Mark. Well done.

  • @GearSkeptic
    @GearSkeptic Рік тому +2

    Oooh. I think I want one!
    Great review, sir. I hadn’t seen this before. Thanks!

    • @MarkYoungBushcraft
      @MarkYoungBushcraft  Рік тому

      Great value option to the Trangia for sure. Thanks for commenting

  • @rodoutdoors
    @rodoutdoors Рік тому +4

    I couldn't find many reasons to use a remote canister stove unless it's very cold and need to use a heat pipe. A much lighter weight stove that sits on top of the canister would work just as well. Using the diffuser to grill looks like a great reason. Thanks for the video.

    • @neemancallender9092
      @neemancallender9092 Рік тому +7

      I always use a remote stove
      1. Stability
      2. because it is low it is away from tent fabric
      3. Mush easier to protect from ind with a better burn

    • @MarkYoungBushcraft
      @MarkYoungBushcraft  Рік тому +1

      Thanks for commenting

  • @Stoney_AKA_James
    @Stoney_AKA_James Рік тому +2

    I use the Firebox Titanium G2 stove exclusively and this is an interesting product, thanks Mark

    • @MarkYoungBushcraft
      @MarkYoungBushcraft  Рік тому

      I have the Gen 2 in titanium as well. Great stove. This burner just add to the versatility. Thanks for commenting

  • @Saltfly
    @Saltfly Рік тому +6

    Hey Mark, I got mine today. I barely turned the collar just a smidge and covered about 1/10 of the air holes and it richened up the mixture and stopped sputtering out at wide open throttle. Still a nice blue flame but really works nice. Like you I don’t run mine at wide open. But it sure is cool to be able to adjust it.

    • @MarkYoungBushcraft
      @MarkYoungBushcraft  Рік тому +3

      Yes, I alos have learned about adjusting the collar a bit. I will be making an update video soon. Thanks for commenting

  • @tomthomas1458
    @tomthomas1458 Рік тому +1

    Very informative and professionally developed. Thank you.

  • @Rayzer2368
    @Rayzer2368 11 місяців тому +1

    Outstanding information on everything; very in-depth! Thank you for such a thorough review.

  • @jamesabond9332
    @jamesabond9332 Рік тому +1

    I have never had any problems with the burner pot - also just received from firebox the upgrade it make it easy for the adjustment mixture you don’t need any tools now

    • @MarkYoungBushcraft
      @MarkYoungBushcraft  Рік тому

      Waiting on my upgrade now (takes longer to get to Canada) so I can make an update video. Thanks

  • @nvrumi
    @nvrumi Рік тому +2

    Thanks for a well done review. I just received my burner and have yet to run it. I was looking for a way to grill for one person here at the house as well as out in the field. This looks like a way to do it.
    I think adding a foldable or roll-up windscreen might be a useful addition to the kit in the field.
    I love this stuff. It is so much fun.

  • @bmac1209
    @bmac1209 Рік тому +1

    Another GREAT thorough review Mark. Much appreciated!!

  • @Saltfly
    @Saltfly Рік тому +11

    It’s already ridiculous how much money I’ve spent with that company. And now this. Well here I go again.

    • @MarkYoungBushcraft
      @MarkYoungBushcraft  Рік тому +1

      LOL...yeah, so easy to do. Thanks for commenting

    • @heldenkreuz
      @heldenkreuz Рік тому +1

      Yup 🤣

    • @nvrumi
      @nvrumi Рік тому +1

      I have to laugh because I do it too. I was just thinking how nice a titanium Firebox G2 would be in the 4Runner...

    • @Saltfly
      @Saltfly Рік тому +1

      @@nvrumi that’s my favorite stove of all.

  • @mkcrowder2257
    @mkcrowder2257 Рік тому

    I have been waiting for this review - thanks! Your thorough analysis helped me make my decision.

  • @terryw.milburn8565
    @terryw.milburn8565 Рік тому +1

    Great Demo & Tests, Thanks Mark, Steve's Good People ! ATB T God Bless

  • @dansklrvids7303
    @dansklrvids7303 Рік тому +1

    Fantastic, thorough review!

  • @melissahoffman4687
    @melissahoffman4687 Рік тому +2

    You can also use the diffuser for baking.

    • @MarkYoungBushcraft
      @MarkYoungBushcraft  Рік тому +1

      I would think so but I would suggest still using a spacer inside the oven. Thanks for commenting

  • @eyeofthetiger4184
    @eyeofthetiger4184 Рік тому +1

    G'day Mark, excellent review and demo mate. Outside of Triangia, didn't know these types of designs existed, that sure is think'n ......... INSIDE the box, lol.
    Diffuser; great little addition, I assume it would work much the same with a small frypan, probably still get some sort of central hotspot, but that'd take any fat dripping out of the equation.
    It does off course mean you need the firebox to use it. The same thing with legs to use it autonomously would be even better again IMO. But hey, as is; a windsheild and multifuel option for fire ban days, best of both worlds, love it.
    Also, it's still an important consideration, but I reckon gas efficiency becomes less of an issue, since in emergency you've always got wood to fall back on, (and contained), regardless of restrictions.
    Cheers Duke.

    • @MarkYoungBushcraft
      @MarkYoungBushcraft  Рік тому +1

      Hi Duke. The nice thing about this burner is that oit will fit in almost every setup that a Trangia would fit in. Yes, the diffuser will help with hot spots on pots and pans as well. Thanks for commenting

  • @patriciaribaric3409
    @patriciaribaric3409 Рік тому +3

    I think the creator was chillin to some oldies on vinyl records when he got this idea.

    • @MarkYoungBushcraft
      @MarkYoungBushcraft  Рік тому

      Steve is a classic for sure. Actually, a great piece of kit that add to the versatility. Thanks for commenting

  • @viewsandreviews180
    @viewsandreviews180 Рік тому

    Thank you for this review. You always do a comprehensive review.

  • @neemancallender9092
    @neemancallender9092 Рік тому +2

    I use the top to a tin can
    I use a side cutting tin opener like from Ikea
    Works excellently as a defuser

    • @MarkYoungBushcraft
      @MarkYoungBushcraft  Рік тому

      A diffuser is a great addition to any cook system. Thanks for commenting

    • @carmenmartinez2882
      @carmenmartinez2882 Рік тому +1

      I do the same, I keep several lids and I find all kinds of uses for them.

  • @patrickmcconnon
    @patrickmcconnon Рік тому

    Great review. Could see clearly what you mean about how the flame behaves when the tap is fully open.

    • @MarkYoungBushcraft
      @MarkYoungBushcraft  Рік тому

      I have learned that it actually works best when not run at full blast. Thanks for commenting

  • @markmartello
    @markmartello Рік тому +4

    Great review Mark. I wonder about the defuser plate when used with a frying pan? Most small burners, and even medium sized burners, create such a hotspot in the middle of the pan that it makes them hard to use. Does the defuser solve that? Thanks again.

    • @MarkYoungBushcraft
      @MarkYoungBushcraft  Рік тому +3

      I won't say it solves the issue but so far, the diffuser has been great for reducing risk or burning from hot spots. Thanks for commenting

    • @markmartello
      @markmartello Рік тому +1

      @@MarkYoungBushcraft thanks again.

  • @thewheelchairprepper8070
    @thewheelchairprepper8070 Рік тому

    Excellent Review ....THANKS MARK!

  • @redsorgum
    @redsorgum Рік тому +1

    The diffuser plate is a good addition, I would definitely use it. Did the flame act in the same way with the diffuser on it, as it did with the pot? I have the same grill, it has come in handy a few times. ✌️🇺🇸🇨🇦✌️

  • @shaztec
    @shaztec Рік тому +1

    Great review as always Mark. Do you know if this burner has pressure regulator like some other canister stoves?

    • @MarkYoungBushcraft
      @MarkYoungBushcraft  Рік тому

      No, it is a standard un-regulated burner. Thanks for commenting

  • @willisblevins4190
    @willisblevins4190 10 місяців тому +1

    Very good

  • @axeljohnson4587
    @axeljohnson4587 Рік тому +1

    Using this gas burner with the Trangia would give the stove excellent wind protection. Do you get the same level of wind protection with it in the Firebox stoves?

    • @MarkYoungBushcraft
      @MarkYoungBushcraft  Рік тому

      The Firebox is good but a Trangia system would be better for wind protection. Thanks for commenting

  • @melissahoffman4687
    @melissahoffman4687 Рік тому +1

    I love that you can use butane, propane, and an alcohol burner when wood is too moist to burn. This must be "Wood Plan A, Alcohol burner Plan B, Then gas burner Plan C."

    • @captainuralify
      @captainuralify Рік тому +2

      Don't forget charcoal and wood pellets. I enjoy using charcoal in theese.

    • @MarkYoungBushcraft
      @MarkYoungBushcraft  Рік тому +1

      I agree, good to have options or backups. I also agree about pellets and charcoal. Thanks for commenting

  • @lapicker1010
    @lapicker1010 Рік тому +1

    I’m curious to know if you tried this in your Trangia setup. Does it snap into the Trangia as securely as the Trangia burner does?

    • @MarkYoungBushcraft
      @MarkYoungBushcraft  Рік тому +1

      Yes, I have the Trangia 25 cook system and it fits in perfectly. Thanks for commenting

  • @marcin1138
    @marcin1138 Рік тому

    How it compares to Trangia? Especialy in cold weather? Trangia's gas leading pipe gets hot improoving efficiency in low temperatures :)

    • @MarkYoungBushcraft
      @MarkYoungBushcraft  Рік тому +1

      It will not work as effectively in very cold weather when compared with the Trangia version. Thanks for commenting

    • @marcin1138
      @marcin1138 Рік тому

      Thank you Mark for reviewing stuff and answering questions ❤

  • @brianbartulis9709
    @brianbartulis9709 Рік тому +1

    The diffuser is a great idea for cooking drippy meats...
    I messed up a 500 series Coleman single burner, cooking Polish sausage/brats on a simple sticks whacked from the woods, held up at angle leaning on the guard(s) of my large camp knife. Two sticks, two sides of the guard is two brats. 'n how fast 'n simple the knife stuck to earth was.
    ~ I thought the grease just burning up after was fine. It ended up rotting out the burner. :-l
    ~~ Nice li'l burner they thunk up.
    I just don't think I'll ever go with li'l canisters of gas fuel. Pumper like Coleman fuel equipment does a nice flame for me.

    • @MarkYoungBushcraft
      @MarkYoungBushcraft  Рік тому +1

      Fair enough. I have started using a diffuser on a number of stoves. Lots of advantages. Thanks for commenting

  • @smd482000
    @smd482000 Рік тому +1

    Cool

  • @jimf1964
    @jimf1964 Рік тому

    So I’m definitely not a gas stove expert, but wouldn’t that adjustment be more for the type of gas or something? And aren’t there pure propane cylinders for colder weather?
    As for the full vs medium, seems like the jets are also blasting right to the outside, and around the pot, and not right into the pot.
    Plate is awesome, and the wide pattern seems awesome for spreading the heat. Surprising for such a small head
    Good for summer campers.

    • @MarkYoungBushcraft
      @MarkYoungBushcraft  Рік тому +1

      I can see why you might think that but I did try it with propane and it burns the same. Steve actually designed it for a softer flame, A diffuser of some type can really help for everything other than boiling. Thanks for commenting Jim

  • @shawnr6117
    @shawnr6117 Рік тому +1

    The burner on my gas stove is so wide I have to use it on low with small pots because if I don't it takes longer and wastes fuel

    • @MarkYoungBushcraft
      @MarkYoungBushcraft  Рік тому

      Yes, that is a good point. Using gas stoves on high can waste a lot of fuel. Thanks for commenting

  • @QantasNeverCrashed
    @QantasNeverCrashed Рік тому +1

    Does anyone know if this stove will fit into a Trangia windshield?

    • @MarkYoungBushcraft
      @MarkYoungBushcraft  Рік тому

      Yes it will. I have the 25 and it fits perfect. Thanks for commenting

  • @SnowyAspenHills
    @SnowyAspenHills Рік тому

    Has anyone tried this in a Trangia kit with the diffuser?

    • @MarkYoungBushcraft
      @MarkYoungBushcraft  Рік тому +1

      I waited before replying so I could give it a try. It works perfectly in my 25. Thanks for asking

    • @SnowyAspenHills
      @SnowyAspenHills Рік тому

      @@MarkYoungBushcraft Thanks for checking. The diffuser plate should make for a more even heat spread when using the Trangia frying pan.

    • @SnowyAspenHills
      @SnowyAspenHills Рік тому

      Tested. Works well, simmering in a pot is very good as is controlled frying pretty much avoiding hotspots.
      One could manage with a Trangia original burner but the FB gives more control.

  • @johnatkins9401
    @johnatkins9401 4 місяці тому +1

    I think it's a bunson burner.

  • @terryshrives8322
    @terryshrives8322 Рік тому

    All your heat is shooting sideways, that is the largest contributor to the poor performance.

  • @Chris66able
    @Chris66able 9 місяців тому

    Just admit that the Firebox gas adapter is complete rubbish.