Це відео не доступне.
Перепрошуємо.
Why are people anti-Semitic? | What's Behind Prejudice? Episode 4 | BBC Ideas
Вставка
- Опубліковано 20 лип 2020
- Why are people anti-Semitic? What is behind anti-Semitism? As part of our series on the root causes of various forms of prejudice, US comedian Alex Edelman explores what's behind anti-Semitism.
Why are people racist? 👉 • Why are people racist?... .
Watch all of our playlist looking at root causes of prejudice here: 👉 • WHAT'S BEHIND PREJUDICE?
Made by BBC Northern Ireland.
Subscribe to BBC Ideas 👉 bbc.in/2F6ipav
____________________________
Do you have a curious mind? You’re in the right place.
Our aim on BBC Ideas is to feed your curiosity, to open your mind to new perspectives, and to leave you that little bit smarter.
So dive in. Let us know what you think. And make sure to subscribe! 👉 bbc.in/2F6ipav
Visit our website to see all of our videos: www.bbc.com/ideas
And follow BBC Ideas on Twitter: / bbcideas
#bbcideas #prejudice #antisemitism
Hi - we welcome discussion and debate in the comments on our channel, but abusive comments will be removed. There’s more on prejudice and its root causes in our playlist: ua-cam.com/play/PLMrFM-P68Wh658vBKZzVQcbrruK2BPCY5.html
There’s plenty to remove at the moment! Bunch of racist scum in the comments
Expelled 109 times?
OY VEY shut it down
Africa - For blacks
Asia - For asians ect........
Israel and EVERYWHERE for Jews.
"It used to be that an anti-semite was someone that hated Jews. Nowadays it is someone Jews hate." ~ Hejo Meyer, holocaust survivor
"Anti-Semitic? It's a trick. We always use it to stifle legitimate criticism of Zionist Israel." ~ Shulamit Aloni, former Israeli cabinet member and winner of 2000 Israel Prize
"It’s a trick we always use: when somebody from Europe or US is criticising Israel we bring up the Holocaust or call them antisemitic. It’s very easy to blame critics of Israel as antisemitic” ~ Also Shulamit Aloni
The problem is that you can't criticise Israel without being called anti-semitic.
Israeli will defend its self to the last british soldier
@@Mo-hc9lc who's defending the black Jews in Israel from the racist white israelis??
You shouldn’t be labeled as that if you have a valid criticism with the government. Every person I talk to when they criticize Israel goes back to the Jesuits as if they were all complying with Israel’s government.
The problem is that most criticism of Israel IS actually just antisemitic. The reason Israel calls people out so much is because a barrage of people hate them simply for existing, not just because they "can't take constructive criticism." Israel is not a perfect nation, far from it, but it is very hard to hear how to improve from outsiders when everything is caught in a noise of "all Jews are greedy, evil, crafty coin grabbers" and "Tel-Aviv should be bombed."
You could say that about any other race out there when somebody criticizes their behavior. The people of that group will just say, "You are just racist towards me blah blah blah"...
Question: Why is Anti-Semitism only pertains to Jews. And not Arabs or Ethiopians who are also semitic people?
It's because Anti-Semitic has taken on a social context. In other words, it's like the term African-American. You can be a black person in the US who's NEVER set foot in Africa, yet can legitimately call yourself an African-American. In contrast, someone who's white who's born to American parents in Africa CANNOT legitimately call himself African-American solely because he's white. Why? Because the term no longer literally means what it used to mean, it's taken on a social context.
because antisemitism is a made up word by mid 19th century none Jewish philosophers to give Judenhass (the hatred of Jews in German) that had religious connotation, a scientific (=racial) connotation and is mean ever since to be the racial hatred of Jews.
Bear in mind the Semitic isn't a race unless you believe in Nazi racial theory but an anthropological word that define a group of languages including Arabic and Hebrew.
Excellent point. Jews are not the only Semitic people. Arabs are Semites too - look it up. Using the term "anti-Semitic" to describe a dislike or hatred of Jews is incorrect.
It really doesn't matter what you call it, it's irrelevant
@@ZORGIN No, it is not irrelevant at all. Talking about the price of tea in China is irrelevant to this conversation, not the demonym for the people of this conflict.
This video is part of our playlist looking at some of the root causes of prejudice. Why are people racist? Why are people homophobic? Why are people sexist? You can watch them all here 👉 ua-cam.com/play/PLMrFM-P68Wh658vBKZzVQcbrruK2BPCY5.html
“One day my spirit will rise up and people will now I was right.”
Based and Austrian painter pilled
Holy shit what is wrong with this comment section
@@fudgysundaee it can be at times but not the point
@@jelly.212 If there wasn't any censorship, you would find this everywhere.
@Zilla
What?? I am Jewish and i assure you we don't control the press
“The truth is like a lion, set it free and it will defend itself.”
Love it!
Racist
@@sumitup8109 the truth is racist?
@@Rh-sl2kt If its the truth then prove it.
@@yesitis1012 i asked a question you dumb silly
Um just look at Israhell's behaviour towards the Palestinian people.
@williamhatton6826that’s all you have? Really?
After watching the video I´m still wating for the answer. Why are people anti-Semitic? Didn´t find the other episodes
So far it seems like just because they can. Because they don't recognize Christ as the savior can be enough to get the idiots going, they can join in on the hate train fun. You can find an excuse to hate any group I suppose and convince yourself it's a good reason to hate them. Humans are easy to manipulate.
because many, many jews are involved in an international marxist conspiracy which is covered rather frequently on the Times of Israel. The problem is that they won't openly say this which would actually put out the fire, instead they insist their people can do no wrong ever. Gentiles would actually be like, "oh, ok so it's just a group of far left jews not all jews" but videos like this actually help build more racism. It's like they WANT to be hated.
why antisemitism
it could also be due to many reasons like
1) how they've taken control of our political parties and made them subservient to Israeli interests. AIPAC THE ISRAELI LOBBY. CORBYN STEIMER LABOUR. TORIES.
2) how they've taken control of our media and made it a thought crime to criticise Israeli crimes against humanity. PEACE PROPOGANDA AND THE PROMISESD LAND
3) it could be how they've taken control of our financial institutions and weaponised it against our own people and take over our national resources. CLOSING BANK ACCOUNTS OF ORGANISATIONS CRITICAL OF ISRAELI WAR CRIMES
4) it could be how they practice racist nepotism to take over our corporations by hiring their own race. JEWISH CIRCULAR COMMUNITY
5) it could be how they attack anyone that democratically and legitimately tries to change this corrupted system of racist control they've created. CORBYN, UN, HUMAN RIGHTS WATCH, MEDIA. EVEN GOING SO FAR AS TO SHOOT JOURNALISTS DEAD.
gee, i wonder which of these it
if you don't believe any of this is true. Ask yourself this why does every country in the west grovel to Israel, every prime minister, every president, every chancellor grovels to Israel.
Do you think that behaviour is normal?
It certainly wasn't when trump was doing it to putin. but it seems normal when our western leaders do it to Israel.
Imagine our politicians grovelling to china to win an election in our country. Can you truly say it doesn't stink of a deep state conspiracy, that your country is not a free country but a slave and thus you are
the heads of the Catholic Church that is minority in Germany were asked after the war why the Holocaust occurred and replied if Jews exist then all the teaching of Jesus are wrong.
Pagans converted to Christianity that emerged from Judaism and needed to delegitimate Judaism and demonize it to prove to be the real true religion.
It would take years to have a real explanation.
'Why are people anti-semitic?'
Why 109 nations?
Why are you an incel whose parents don't love you? We all have questions
@@Luca-nu2zg I'm not, why are you anti-semitic for no reason at all?
@Hesh Shshsh thanks for emphasizing that point, a lot of idiots miss that part :) they confuse conspiracy theory for fact, it’s quite sad
@Hesh Shshsh they’re dismissed as conspiracy theories because there’s no evidence of them being true, there’s only evidence of it being fabricated to harm groups of people, and no it’s not millions of people, it’s just a small group of bigots who believe anything that suits their small minded world view because they’re uneducated. Go back to breaking into the White House in the name of “q anon”
@Hesh Shshsh and notice how you said “feel that way” instead of “believe this” because it’s all based on your emotions. You hate the world because you think you’re oppressed, so you jump on the hate train of any vulnerable population because you can and you’d believe me if I told you the earth was ruled by aliens. Next callerrrr
How did 109 countries came up with the same conspiracy theory ?
@JoggaStoppa™ 111 now? Including Guatemala?
@JoggaStoppa™ my list only goes to Gautemala unfortunately :( just checked, both in 2021, recent
@PoO BoOZki ain't a theory. It's a fact. Interest is fraud. If I have 1,000,000 in my bank. 10 people in the country each get 100,000 loaned out. They get 1% interest rate so they have to pay back 1,010,000 as a collective. Pls explain where in the kentucky fried fu*k they will get that magical 10,000 from. They will be in debt forever.
No conspiracy. Parasite race. Yeah
Non jews have been historically very intolerant. Is that something new to u?
"The Jew cries out in pain as he strikes you "
Old Polish proverb
Found no evidence of it's origin.
I am assuming it's pretty new invention by antisemites.
عظيم .فهم أصحاب غدر وخيانه .ولا ذمه لهم ولا عهد .
Racist
Poles were openly a nation of extreme antisemitic with 10% Jews of the total population and now a nation of openly extreme antisemitic with virtually no Jews.
How is it to hate Jews and then Worship Jesus as your God when he was Jewish all your life?
That sounds like polish people tbh
If a student was expelled from 109 other schools and wanted to enroll at your school, would you let him?
They weren’t; myth
What did the student do to get expelled? Surely you'd know
@@musiccriticism ooh who do we have here ?mr weiss hahaha
One student vs an entire group of people is totally different.
I mean, if they didn't say why, people would immediately assume that they did something bad. so, good analogy.
Why are people anti-Semitic? I tried to give an honest answer, but my response was removed by UA-cam.
@@MaxVax-dh7rh Thanks!
@@koshersa1t Of course! How stupid of me... I forgot how opinions can be proven false nowadays.
Authoritarianism is alive and well and your opinion must conform to the party line
109 countries.
What's your solution then Adolf?
saying it like its good
Based
You can help by EXPANDING THIS LIST
0 love from your parents
I want to find out why antisemitism exists. I have been wondering about this for a long time now but I have not found the answer.
Stinking RATS that’s what
Same reason anti-dozens-of-other-things exist. Failure to control an animalistic urge to find an "enemy" to destroy.
@Adam Johnson there's nothing simple about hatred of the Jews. There are only about 14 million Jews in the world yet by any measure they are an extraordinary race of people who excel in every aspect and level of achievement in all aspects in life from politics to banking and from science to the arts. Antisemeticism dates back to ancient times and that Hitler and Germany exterminated 6 Million Jews (with the agreement and aid from most European countries) is something that I find extremely difficult to get my head around.
People get angry, so they want to blame someone instead of doing something about it.
Look up Israel's intentional attack of the USS liberty. Look up the survivors and what they say about it
Maybe the reason anti-semitism extents so far is because the group in question is truly *THAT* nefarious
How? Because there have been bad jewish people in power? Theres bad everyone in power. Your average jewish person is doing nothing wrong. I think israel should exist purely because of people like you. Jews need a break from this bs
Sure! women are raped becouse how they dress, lol same logic
Yeah I’m like super nefarious dog
No, the left hates them because they're rich and powerful, the right hates them because they tend to support the left.
Anti semitism is not just restricted to the Jews it actually means any type of discrimination against the both Jews and Arabs. However!!!! The practical implementation is only used for Jews and not just the Jews, but rather any type of criticism against Israel 🇮🇱 (with all of its crimes against humanity).
If the Israeli government even thinks people are criticizing them they shout: anti semitism!!!
@@alexandraxox
Are you the only Semitic people? Do you want to steal and distort our offspring and justify your crimes against us, O European Jews, we Semitic people, mean all the Semitic peoples, but the anti-Jews only belong to you, the white Jews of Europe. The name is misleading and has corrupt interests in order to reject the Arabs completely from Semitism because
Antisemitism is discrimination against Jews. The term was coined in Europe for hate against Jews. Arabs are not, and have never been, subjected to antisemitism.
@@alexandraxox i hate the world
Regardless how the western MSM's twist the stories around, the Zionist government of Israel are notoriously known for anti-Semitic themselves.
The word antisemitism has nothing to do with semites
Entropy always increases in a closed system.
they hijack whatever term they please. "hygienic" is a great word to describe their neonatal ritual. absolutely vile. the shame must be unbearable.
This term started because Jews were the only immigrants in the UK for many years and they were considered to be of Semitic origin. Although many Jews
are of Semitic origin , many are not. In Modern English Anti-Semitic means anti Jew. Just as we say black and white people , when they are not strictly black or white.
@@toolatehello3345 lol, wait until you find the origin of the word israel.
Thank you for telling the truth people just need to go back where they come from because at one point in time non of these people were around they just want to get rid of the original people
The devil 😈 knows his people and that's why he's sending All these people to destroy the good people believe me the day is coming when the non original people has to go because it's impossible to love ♥️ a sheep in snake 🐍 skin's and bye the way the whole world 🌎 is waking up to religion lies and tricks
I’ll never understand antisemitism, because the Jewish community ALWAYS had a positive contribution to the country where they lived in. Think of all the important artists and scientists in Europe. The Jewish community never complained and always took care of herself! And what I love most about Jewish people is their sense of humor. Their ability to laugh about their own situation, no one beats that!
OK (((eisenberg)))
Hahahaha
Read the Protocols.
Read the Talmud, they don't even hide.
@Elliot Mason do you know what they might be referring to? people misinterpret the quran all the time so I don't want to make assumptions
@Elliot Mason how do you know its fake?
@Elliot Mason Okay, so in order to dispute me you can only attempt to insult me?
Okay Jew, whatever.
You got nothing.
You can't even write properly.
The Talmud is available online.
@Elliot Mason I'm not "debating" with somebody who deletes their comments, edits their comments and reports mine so that I can't respond properly. You're an embarrassment.
Ask Rothschild and Rockefeller
Just because a small handful of people are better off than the others, it doesn't mean "zey rule ze vurld!"
@@seacatlol831 it’s in Torah how To deal with gentiles
@@IMZLEGEND1 could you give me a specific passage to look at
Only one of those families was Jewish.
what if?
and crazy idea i know
but what if
it has to do with their behavior and not some mindless prejudice?
What if your mom evicts you from her basement?
Are you implying that all Jews act in a manner so similar and bad, that people have a right to judge them simply based on their religion/ethnicity?
@@davidkresch
Yes
@@KittySnicker
Your not clever nor funny
@@savagepeasantiv8805 and you're a bigot. We've all got our own problems, don't we?
I’m getting Jew fatigue
The BBC clearly is not in a position to give lectures on this issue, given the recent revelations!
If Judaism is an ideology, then being prejudice against it is totally within the realm of freedom of speech. The fact that Jews have identified themselves as a race is actually bad, because now you have conflated something that can change with something that can't. At any given point of time, you can choose to not believe in Judaism, you can literally become atheist, buddhist, any other religion. You can't change that you were born in Israel. Being born in Israel doesn't mean your a Jew either, unless you practice the religion. It's like y'all can't wrap your heads around this.
thing is, jews are a race. You look at enough of them and you can tell. They really are a race.
Judaism is a race.
they believe a hew has a special soul, that isn't like a gentiles. their souls are above ours, whether they are atheist or practicing doesn't matter.
vice versa they also believe the souls of gentiles are akin to cattle and we belong to them as slaves as their property as promised by god to them.
Anti-Semites are far more devoted to the idea of a ‘Jewish race’ than self-identifying Jews. Their favorite sentence is ‘He’s not White he’s Jewish.’
He doesn't DENIED any of the arguments. He just doesn't like to be call crafty, but doesn't DENY they are CRAFTY.
Are you joking?? If I call you, a person I don’t know in any way, crafty would you need to defend yourself at all? I have no right to make that claim because I know nothing about you.
he says it's a crafty racist conspiracy that antisemites say, that jews don't belong locally, that they are international.
then he says all jews have a loyalty and belonging to Israel.
do the maths.
Satans Chosen
What’s actually satanic is saying that about people you know nothing about
i wonder what this guy's opinions are of the diversity for israel movement
From the looks and sounds of it, they need a lot more diversity than what they have! Sad but true!
Check out the schnoz on this guy
Ikr lmao. Living the stereotype.
Childish comment
@@behindyou666 It was a well observed and highly based comment. Now be quiet.
@@chaosnexxus9255 14
@@chaosnexxus9255 I'm pakistani and I've got a kind of big nose. Who cares
Jews are Hitittes not Semitic. Genesis 26:34 Esau married Yudith (Jewess)
Edomites, central europeans, eastern europeans, canaanites, khazars…… and now apparently we are hittites…..
Can’t wait for my next discovery of what I’m actually according to the internet
Watched the entire video 2x and still have no idea what it is or isn't.🤷🏾♀️
@pete haskell Thank you!
It's an ideology. These people are just trying to conflate it with culture so that way you can't criticize their system of belief without being labeled as a racist. It's fundamental to control and power.
If you're wondering why people resent Jews, it probably has something to do with the ultimate hubris required to identify yourself as chosen by God, coupled with some of the more obnoxious tenets of orthodox Jews, like not sitting in the same row as a woman.
It has nothing to do with this. We do not see ourselves as "better than", this idea is false and misleading. We are hated because we are a minority with a strong identity and we are easy to scapegoat and demonize, that's why Antisemitism is called "the oldest existing form of hatred". Your points don't hold.
Jews in German rejected their choseness, it did not stop the hate.
Also some Christians and Muslims claims to be God's chosen, yet they are mostly tolerated.
@@KingPingviini That's bullshit, people talk shit on Christianity and Islam on a day to day basis. People literally made a church to worship Satan, which no matter what is the ultimate enemy of all 3. Which, by the way, they all worship the exact same god, which is why Revelation talks about the endtimes and the 7 headed beast, because that's the final conflict of religion, all different while originating from one. It's why the statue of Babylon breaks in David's dreams. It's all metaphor, and it's kind of true. These people all argue religion and ideology even going as far as to kill each other, yet they all come from the same origin.
And like most people, it's low threshold IQ, so they think that their ideology, which can change based on mentality, is their race. Same way people nowadays title themselves as stoners, or goths or emos, or whatever sub group they wanna identify as.
Read the Bible, they where chosen by God, they rejected Christ and Christians are now chosen but God still has a plan for Israel. Christ will come back to save them. They will accept Jesus in their hearts
Semitism is defined as policy or predisposition favorable to jews. By definition this would mean that semitism means policies or predispositions that are less favorable to non-jews. If you believe in true egalitarianism and justice, you would be anti-semitic by definition, since you cannot favor one group over another. Seeing as how jews are very tribalistic and practice semitism towards each other, anti-semitism is the natural response from others. Thus, semitism causes anti-semitism.
Jews are not a monolithic group. Trump’s approval rating was 70% among Israelis, but only 20% among American Jews. Israel is the Jewish state but some of the biggest critics of Israel have been Jews: Noam Chomsky, Steven Spielberg, Bernie Sanders. Karl Marx was a Jew, but so was Milton Friedman.
1030 Countries 109 Times
Based
"With the notable exception of Lenin (Vladimir Ulyanov), most of the leading Communists who took control of Russia in 1917-20 were Jews. Leon Trotsky (Lev Bronstein) headed the Red Army and, for a time, was chief of Soviet foreign affairs. Yakov Sverdlov (Solomon) was both the Bolshevik party’s executive secretary and - as chairman of the Central Executive Committee - head of the Soviet government. Grigori Zinoviev (Radomyslsky) headed the Communist International (Comintern), the central agency for spreading revolution in foreign countries. Other prominent Jews included press commissar Karl Radek (Sobelsohn), foreign affairs commissar Maxim Litvinov (Wallach), Lev Kamenev (Rosenfeld) and Moisei Uritsky.
Lenin himself was of mostly Russian and Kalmuck ancestry, but he was also one-quarter Jewish. His maternal grandfather, Israel (Alexander) Blank, was a Ukrainian Jew who was later baptized into the Russian Orthodox Church."
When you say Ukrainian Jew, you mean Ukrainian Israelite/Hebrew?
@@poop464 All of these people are converted into Judaism and not from the tribe of Judah. They speak Yiddish not Hebrew, and have no bloodlines from Isreal in the bible, which is not the Israel they founded in 1948, to further the lies & confusion, for they are the synagogue of Satan, spoken of in the bible.
Hamas are Semitic people. So you're saying we should love ALL Semitic people, or just the European Ashkenazis?
Free Palestine
Ask Hamas.
free Palestine 🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
1-no.
2-your comment no one cares for it.
3-get out you anti semitic
@@can5722 1-no.
2-your comment nobody cares for it.
3-get out you anti Semitic.
0:14 look at the nose.
*plotting intensifies*
@williamhatton6826fr
no prejudice just behavioural pattern.
Too bad the author is not entirely honest and conveniently omits a number of aspects of the issue. Just one example, - it would be so refreshing to hear from a man such as himself just one sentence, something along the lines of 'it's also super unfair when so many peace-loving people get labelled anti-Semitic JUST because they dare critise Israel for its apartheid politics', that's it. No, he won't say it, if he did he would be immediately 'cancelled' by his co-believers.
fact he doesn't shows why antisemitic beliefs exist.
when you refuse to condemn racism committed by your own race, when talking about racism committed against your own race.
one rule for thee, another for me.
rules apply to you, but not to me.
peace loving people that call Israel and Apartheid and compares it to Nazi Germany?
you are antisemitic for sure
Humans are not antisemitic but they are against semitization & Semitism of ecopoloitical or social status for exceptionality inside NON-SEMITIC nations.
Isn’t it just anti capitalism? But the anger is misplaced.
in a way. but the anger is misplaced intentionally.
depends if the racist nepotism conspiracy theories are true
Weird how when orban said he’s fighting secretive, crafty, anti national money speculators… the Jew assumed he meant him
Ok so uhh
When you say anti semitic, you're referring anti jew eh?
THEN WHY IS IT CALLED ANTI SEMITIC?!
They made it up, to hide behind it
Yes, because that’s how it was historically used. Because, Jewish people were considered a middle eastern population in Europe, and it was coined by the antisemite “Wilhelm marr”.
Antisemitism is a rational response to Semitic behavior
@Elliot Mason If you're gonna call someone uneducated, the least you can do is use proper grammar.
@Elliot Mason Take AIPAC for example. This is a Jewish organization which lobbies the US government to send billions of dollars to Israel every year. The State of Israel, also a Jewish organization, then uses that money to kill Palestinians and expand its borders through the settlement program. Many Americans dislike their money being used for such purposes, and blame the people who run AIPAC (Jews) for wasting their money.
That’s like saying “how come every friend group stopped hanging out with me?”
For no good reason
Zorban didn't identify anybody specific in the very clip you showed us. I think you're revealing to us who it is you don't like.
Oh come on. You *know* who he's talking about. What a crafty little way of pretending you don't.
@@lsjt8924 if you're calling me 'crafty' you're proving my point - I'm not Jewish.
@@angelomaldini3316 Uh yeah - no shit you're not Jewish. But it's interesting, you immediately associated that word with Jews - proving my point. There are dog whistles that are immediately associated with Jews whether or not the term is explicitly used.
@@lsjt8924 he was not inferring Jews - you were inferring Jews. And then you used the word crafty towards a non-jews. You made it obvious by your poor victim-points loving bitching.
@@angelomaldini3316 no actually I wasn’t inferring Jews, I knew he’s not Jewish lol... and I don’t see myself as a victim and I’m not left wing at all, I’m just pointing out a fact that the person I was speaking to proved to be true.
Does anyone have a link to the original Viktor Orban speech video?
cz its real and not a prejudice
I'm anti semitic and proud
that's really sad
people like you are the reason i have no hope for the future
@@sassafrassauce
It should be the opposite
If we take power from them we shall have a bright future
@@Bruh73129 who hurt you into having such hate for a people who have never done anything to affect your personal life. i hope you find peace and love in your heart sometime soon.
Come to World truth Videos. Beyond Infinity here.
Semetic=is relating to or denoting a family of languages that includes Hebrew, Arabic, and Aramaic and certain ancient languages such as Phoenician and Akkadian, constituting the main
Remeber! antisemitism means judephobia, has nothing to dow tih semites, at all
The reason people are anti Semitic are for reasons like a Jew can charge anyone interest but to charge another Jew interest is forbidden. Kind of comes across hypocritical and crafty, plus many other reasons...
Based on fact or ignorant bullshit, dude?
@Prometheus Sure, sport. I'm sure you have many years of studying Jewish law behind you. It's bullshit. Thanks for your contribution.
@Prometheus Enept? Point well made. I'd love to chat but I have to go back to controlling the world...
@Prometheus Would you like a high-interest loan? (Assuming you're not Jewish, that is.)
@Prometheus Seriously? Who knows if you're being honest or not. I don't really care. 75 years after my grandparents survived the Holocaust (fact), I have to increasingly put up with half-witted anti-Semites becoming either increasingly emboldened to sprout their idiotic hate. Or, I have to tolerate anti-Semitism hiding behind anti-Zionism, which often is coming from white people who themselves are living on land that was snatched from indigenous peoples. 75 years ago, we hid and hoped. History showed that didn't work too well. And, no, I don't believe you and your wife are Jews based on your previous comments.
And Swatika is Hindu.. Not Nazi.. Stop fake information
I'm proud Anti Semitic.
I think u mean anti Zionist... Arabs and many Ethiopian are semetic
@@NubiansNapata Ah yes.
Zionists should suffer. Their ideology is based on fake superiority complex, violence and hatred for other religions.
Salute to you sir
How did the algo get me to this vid? I was looking for Ye vid
what israel is duing in gaza actually tells a lot why ‘it’ existed
Look what they are doing now
Hahahaha what makes you came here you Muslim Islamist anti Semitic get out
What would u call an Arab who insults and abuse Jew or the Jew who insults and abuse Arab(religion,country&people)!?
I wonder Bcuz both are came from the same root.
I would call that person a Jew hater
@@user-xp4jr1mq8t I ha tree juice
How many PAC's in the US cater to foreign countries other than Israel?
It's called hooked Cross and not Swastika
The Arab and African Ethiopia also semitic people
Semitic derives from Shem one of Noah’s sons and he also had 2 other sons Ham and Japheth it’s impossible for and African Ethiopian to be Semitic or Shemitic because they come from the line of ham
The closest analogy to chews must be cancer.
@Elliot Mason Do you know of any closer analogy? Cancer? I think cancer is the best analogy.
@Elliot Mason Calm down. Could you think of any better word to describe the horrible actions of a single people for all this time? I really cannot come up with any. But when your God is below, and not above, anything goes. That's why they are the way they (you) are in the end. Just look at you for example. You have absolutely no honor. Had you had the slightest honor you would acknowledge these things and reject this wickedness. But you don't.
Instead you spend your time defending it.
@Elliot Mason Imagine a group of people so awful, that laws have to be made against telling the truth about them.👌👌
Based Islamist Christian radical anti Semitic comment
@@oscargreatgive a specific example of us Jews being so awful
Anti- zionism is not anti-Semitism.
It is.
Of course people in the comments will try to justify it, I’m sorry but no matter how convinced you are you will never ever be able to justify hatred of people you don’t know, no matter how many times you feel superior to us or whatever you thing
White Jewish people claiming Israel is too funny to me.
Clearly you have no knowledge of history or of the identity of Jewish people. Go read online about where we came from. We are Middle Eastern, even in Europe the Middle East and North Africa we weren't concidered "White" by white Europeans and Arabs. Israel has been our homeland since 4000 years ago
@@user-xr5kp6qz8gAmen brother
@@user-xr5kp6qz8gno you're not. You're Khazars
Deliberately avoiding the question you yourself posed, leads me to believe there may be valid reasons for hating Jews but you don't want to express them. Apart from doing their best to copy Nazis by their behavior in Palestine, I cant' think of any other reasons. Anti-Semitism may or may not be justified but you have not addressed the issue apart from repeating many times that it exists.
USS Liberty
Hating an entire category of people is never justified.
@Joseph Kay
Let me make it clear right from the start that I have no time for those who think that belief in a God they were brought up to follow is an excuse to hurt people who were brought up to believe in a different God. The whole idea of religion disgusts me but that is not the point here.
I am not asking why people hate Jehovah's Witnesses or Moslems or Christians. I am asking why they hate Jews but all I get is "oh poor me, why does everyone hate us".
I am hoping that maybe you can explain in language that an outsider can understand.
I urge you to try to keep emotion and prejudice out of it and just give me the reason you believe Jews are generally disliked.
If I say anything that you disagree with or upsets you in any way then please calmly explain why it is wrong.
I originally came to this video in the hope of answers but got nothing. Please enlighten me.
In response to your first sentence:
You are right which is why I asking.
I am not saying that the following impressions are correct but no-one is coming up with a reason why they disagree.
Most people would try to protect their country in the best way they can, even if they don't have the enormous wealth and weapons of their aggressor.
Most Jews believe Palestine belongs to them so that gives them the right to invade it and kill the people living there who have nowhere else to go.
The Nazis had bigger and better weapons and believed Austria and Poland belonged to them.
The fact that Jews suffered under the Nazis is undeniable. Do Jews think this gives them the right to copy what was done to them?
Jews are hated throughout the world and not just those trying to take commit genocide and taking over land that does not belong to them.
In response to your second sentence:
Sorry but suggesting that cholera can't be bad because smallpox is worse is not a good argument.
I hope that is not the best you have.
In response to your third sentence:
To my knowledge, other religions have not been targeted because some of their followers have accomplished great things, so what you say makes no sense.
@Joseph Kay
Hello Joseph,
First let me thank you for the time and trouble you took to present a well thought out and informative reply.
A great deal of what you say is fair and makes a lot of sense and I am now a lot wiser than I was before about recent history
You deserve a response and I am far from certain if I am able to come anywhere near being able to express myself so eloquently..
Before I go on, please allow me to correct something you maybe unaware of. The expression is not “escape goat” but “scapegoat” .
One or two of the reasons for the hatred of Jews that you brush off, may very well contribute more than you think, whether or not you think they are fair.
Have you asked why the Nazi party was so successful in portraying the Jews as money grabbing and evil? As you say, they successfully earned money that they kept within their gang rather than spending it in the general community. They were ( and probably still are) happy to sell things to outsiders but only buy things from other Jews. This is not dissimilar to trade imbalances we see today between nations. America is unhappy with China for that very same reason. It would have been very hard for the Nazi propaganda to have been so successful if people did not already resent what they could see happening. Not much has changed since the war. Jews look after themselves, often at the expense of others. I am not saying that Jews are not allowed to do this. I merely offer this as a reason some people don’t like them.
Stories regularly appear in the press about Jews building settlements on land that does not belong to them and then defending them with a force that Palestinians could not hope to match. This reinforces the impression that Jews are a gang of thieving thugs.
Jews control the media which makes it a lot easier to silence dissent.
Every time, someone dares to suggest that not everything Jews do is necessarily good, there is always a retraction and apology the next day. To the lay person, this may give the impression that someone in a powerful position has threatened to destroy that persons livelihood, or even worse. Rightly or wrongly people are afraid of Jews, just like they are afraid of the mafia.
People do not like the mafia because they make people lives a misery and spread fear, and fear breeds hatred.
Is it unreasonable to liken Jews to the mafia?
The mafia takes over any property they want , by force if necessary. That is what Jews do.
The mafia looks after its own and woe betide anyone who dares to get in their way. That is what Jews do.
If Jews stopped behaving like Jews, there would be no reason to hate them, but so long as it profits them to carry on the way they do, they are unlikely to see any reason to change.
I do not expect for one second that what I have had to say comes close to explaining why people hate Jews, but it is all I can come up with at the moment.
On a final note I have a small anecdote that does not explain anything at all but happens to be true and I have never understood what happened.
I once had a good Jewish friend in Australia. A group of us were enjoying an evening together in his flat when a woman knocked on the door selling something. He invited her in to join us and all was happy and convivial for a while. Then someone asked if she was making much money selling that stuff. She replied “I don’t earn much at all because my boss is really Jewish”. Boy did the atmosphere change. In a menacing voice, my friend calmly said “Not all Jews are like that. See I gave you something to eat and drink and welcomed you into my home.” He then warned her to be careful what she said in future and threatened to tell her boss. I do not believe that her remark was intended to be malicious in any way. I was surprised that my friend was so quick to make her feel small but perhaps there is something about the Jewish culture that explains it.
That took a lot more effort than I expected :-)
Like what they are doing to the Palestinians
It’s called KARMA mate .eye to eye
Karma for what?
What do you mean karma? What did we do
@@avabamman9491 YOU CONTROL THE WORLD
@@Liagiv FOR DESTROYING THE WORLD
@@novoid5761 Jeez, someone's drank the kool-aid.
Israeli is an interesting point of contention. Thousands of years ago, the Hebrew tribes which took Israel from the native Israelites, kinda kept to the precedent of right to conquest. You win by the sword, you lose by the sword, and the Hebrews ended up losing Israel. Obviously that doesn’t justify antisemitism in the slightest sense, but it also puts their original claim to Israel on shaky ground. Many peoples have called the region of Israel home, with many different motives, and many different claims to ownership. Should countries really be formed around these ethnic nations and religious groups, or instead around democratic values? Which will create a more just, stable and sustainable society which works to push the progress of all people? The Israeli policies about the Gaza Strip make it clear that a nation of people can be horribly oppressed and murdered in one generation, and then may proceed to horribly oppress another nation of people in the next. I guess my point is no one is above scrutiny, because we are all human, which is why democracy is more important than nationalism.
Ok jew
That's actually a good point.
And Israel really does a bad job in representing Jews,especially when the rise of the far right has now really fueled anti semitism really badly Just look at any conspiracy theory-most if not all have anti semitism as a crucial point.
I think its just like how Iran and Saudi Arabia do a very bad job in representing Muslims and Islam.
I personally not entirely against the existence of Israel. If a historically oppressed community wants some land in the middle east to call their home then there's nothing wrong.However,that doesn't mean we also endorse the ethno centrism.
Palestine and Israel should both exist together since both communities call it their home and Jerusalem is a very important place for both of them and the Christians.
I always think people tend to go to extremes in these cases. You are either Israel gets everything or Palestine gets everything. Which is wrong in both cases.
The logical thing is for both to exist peacefully but ofc that seems like a dream.
@@lalitthapa101 _If a historically oppressed community wants some land in the middle east to call their home then there's nothing wrong._
On the expense of what? Palestinian blood? Shut up
@@red-sv2qf Now when did I say it was good at the expense of Palestinian blood?! I'm against how Israel Is functioning now but not against the idea of them having a land for themselves.And its not just any piece of land either,it was their home once.They were all forced out from it. Now reading this,People automatically assume this means PALESTINIANS SHOULD BE REMOVED!!! But that's not it. Cause the Palestinians are just as native to the land.
A two state solution is the best one but you can't have good things in this world I guess.
So please try to understand points here.
Every country in the world is made from tribes invading , although it is highly likely that the Hebrews were actually decedents from the Canaanites rather than the biblical records which are incorrect. historically.
Kicked out of 109 countries more to come
why were they kicked out though?
Hi 🤓
Based
I can’t believe fool likes ur comment
@@IMZLEGEND1 defies comprehension that
Good commentary. My main observation about Jews is that they're so incredibly clever. And use that cleverness to benefit the world.
Right… (dr. Evil voice).
They never learned to be acceptable neighbors.
For Apparent Reasons
My guess is, is that some individuals are just abusive in general, and they are going to give it to somebody, Jewish or not, but there are others who may have had an unfavorable encounter with one who declares him/herself Jewish, and have never reconciled it within his own soul, chomps on the bit, and like a rabid animal, never lets it go. I have had to talk myself off of the ledge when I noticed that I was about to adopt a prejudice also. I needed to remind myself that the person that had treated me without value was just one person among their nationality. I wanted to lash out in a stereotypical fashion. I was wronged, but luckily. with some thought, and a bit of reflection, I knew.....that I was 'better' than that!! Also, I have been discriminated against by those who have other unsettling feelings towards me, personal feelings towards me as a human, having nothing to do with being Jewish or not, but it is just tossed up in the air, like a sordid bag of tricks, and I totally resent them, for not only have they disparaged a part of who I am, but that they have 'also' therefore, disparaged a part of those that I love. I certainly do not deem those rascals as superior to myself. Quite the contrary. I've got other words of choice for them, of which I will refrain from instead. It's a jungle out there, Jane!
how you explain then that people that never met Jews are very antisemtic?
the reason because antisemitism is a primitive but very attractive worldview.
It’s just so specific though. And it’s always been around. I figured maybe it started as a Christian thing, but almost nobody that is anti semetic is loudly Christian. Like he said, there are anti-semites on both sides
@@Ryandeanchickenpeen
It is started developed and propagated by Christianity; appropriated by Muslims and European nationalists in from the 19th century on.
Antisemitism is in the basis of Christian worldview even today.
Not enough that your comment is pure ignorance you got even likes.
what a shame
At least its not Jews fault and their religious behavior has nothing to do with it.
People love it when someone comes to your community claiming they are "gods chosen" then do everything they can to isolate themselves while treating others outside their relation like "beasts of the land"
The BBC regularly fans the flames.
I need to reiterate that, of the four bigotries described in the series, at least three have religious power behind it. And, if you think about it, the other one has, too.
Jeffrey Combs is one of my faves!
Is this comment supposed to be profound lol.
That's like saying
Of all the evils in the world, most of them involve concious planning behind it. Therefore concious planning is bad
There’s very little that doesn’t have a religious power behind it.
The juwes are the ones who will not be blamed for nothing
Except you because you’re so persecuted. Everyone blames you. But not the Jesuits. You are the one being persecuted huh? Oh please.
@@UnknownUserName9999 Do you speak English?
@@thunor3656 sorry I only speak Jewish
Listen. The sons of Abraham Isaac and Ishmael. The sons of Isaac, Jacob and Esau. Jacob is the grandfather of the Israelites. Esau is the grandfather of the European Romans.
Ishmael, the grandfather of the Arabs.
And Ishmael had a daughter named Nesma, the wife of Esau, and the grandmother of the European Romans.
After all these family ties and blood, even Islamophobia and hatred of Arabs should be considered anti-Semitism.
It is concidered anti-Semitism, but anti-Semitism is largly pointed towards Jews.
It's crazy to me that you think these 12 tribes are the origin for the rest of the world, despite the rest of the world having stories of their origins at times when they say these people went out to create these other societies.
His stand up is pretty damn solid.
Anti semitic spotted
@@mayurborah2111 I don't get it?
@@mayurborah2111 I'm not being cute, he actually is a talented comedian. Check him out sometime
@@willkoestner4159 shses one of those doesnt eat bacons on saturday folks
I heard he’s a really good dancer, I saw a video of him dancing in Israel. Just look up dancing Israelis
no reason I'm sure
it's just a pure cohencidence
@@jewtarokujosteinberg8001 What?
Holodomor, USS LIberty, Russian Revolution, Pornography, Slavery, Fiat currency, Usury, etc
@@SlickyFats so does that make all Jews bad?
@@cani5761 even the anti-Zionist ones?
Lol u have the option to opt in ? 😂😂
The amount of contradictions is crazy🤣🤣🤣
That was quite interesting. Thanks!
BBC Ideas. Theirs or you get censured. GTFOH
What is really sad is that no one feels sorry for the Jewish people a lot of people think they deserve to be hated.
no one likes a hypocrite. ppl think hypocrites deserve karma.
dues are the most racist people on the planet. the only apartheid colonialist state left on earth and every yew will defend it.
can you blame people when seeing a racist nazi, being a victim of racism?.
ppl will feel it is deserved, that it is just desserts. it puts a smile to people's faces when karma hits back so eloquently.
disclaimer tho, i don't believe all yews are like this. but most large majority are.
and publicly all of them who speak, will vocally defend the apartheid state of Israel and refuse to condemn its poisonous racism.
Can't spell Jew without "ew"
Why the fok is my comments about the reasons why anti-semitism exists keep getting deleted?
_UA-cam?_
I have always said they would find someone else to hate probably the Catholics. Personally I have struggle with my Jewish identity I was raised Catholic but have always identified with the Jewish faith. As Israel is concerned I agree it is complex.
@@gardenia4882 You can be raised Catholic by your parents.
@@manifestman132 but you lose your catholic identity if not practicing Catholicism anymore
The Israeli “ Jews” don’t act the same, they can be no religious still call themselves Jews
Thinking that being Jewish is ONLY religious as how it was and shall be, your problem will disappear.
it's only complex for those who don't want to admit to the truth and be just. that zionism is racism and israel is a nazi apartheid state.
they hide their crimes and their racist disposition by phrases like its complicated.
it isn't.
it wasn't in 1930s Germany, and it isn't today in Israel.
Alex Edelman is the most hilarious guy. A comic genius! A man I truly respect.
and cute. :)
@@thebeardedseeker5633 so very much so.
How can anyone be serious about respecting a chew? That is ridiculous man. 😀
Too bad he wasn't entirely honest about the issue there.
The word Anti-Semetism wasn't something the Jews brought up. It was French concept. The Western Church criticism of the Eastern Churches like the Coptics, Syriacs and Assyrians could be argued as a form of Christian against Christian anti-semetism. Being afraid of Muslim Arab refugees from Syria can be a form of anti-semetism.
Not true look up Webster definition of antisemitism it’s for Jews
Idk where you got that retarded idea from 🤣🤣
It’s a form of denial that another human being exists .
I started disliking Jews when I learned what jews think about gentiles and how you Jews hurt us gentiles. Suck the milk of the nations/gentiles, etc. I learned the Communism was led by Jews, etc. So I started wishing you would leave us alone. But you always want to live amongst us, even though you hate us, you need to suck our milk as Isaiah prophesized.
Fear, angst, phobia, anxiety creates painfully false sense that certain people try to harm you. So sad, but paranoia is nowadays world religion and more and more people join unknowingly. Anti-semitism is just another form of rejection, false projection of an imagined enemy and as they say you know the best defense is a good offense. Why do they need enemy? Cause they feel useless, lost, total waste, a disaster, or they hate to see others winning or live in harmony or simply a normal life. Lots of people suffer mental health issues, their only hope to find someone to hate to justify their overwhelming feelings. Or they could turn to doctor, but it's too expensive and can't help anyway. FB will help, closed echochamber, where they see their views confirmed. We don't want more friends any more, just followers who can raise our self-brand, vacant maketing value. This is a twisted weird world and it just getting worse... sigh... There is only one race.
Ok, that makes sense.
People blame their issues on others.
Why do they hate and oppress me so?
What does Semitic mean?
Higher
@@Mo-hi9hw really? Where can I find that ?
@@dominicanvic9 You do not need to search for it, this is the meaning of the word in the Semitic languages
@@dominicanvic9 because i’m a Semite and Semites are the descendants of Abraham from his sons Ishmael and Isaac
@@Mo-hi9hw. There are Semitic languages. Meaning “higher” languages. Is that correct?
The origins of antisemitism go all the way back to the Old Testament. It started with the story of Abraham and Sarah lying to Pharaoh about Sarah’s status as an ‘unmarried woman’ in order to be 'treated well' and gain access to the highest levels of power in Egypt. Pharaoh and his harem come down with a "mysterious illness" (venerial disease) and Pharaoh confront Abraham about his trickery and kicks Abraham and his followers out of Egypt. So there you have, Pharaoh kicking Abraham out of Egypt was the first act of antisemitism.
anyone who knows the truth is
I'm tired of these communities. We have little communities popping up everyday.
I have always been confused on this issue and why anti-semitism exist.
Because.
“Different bad!”
Its a sad and nihilistic view that people will have a problem with others who are different. Someone i care about judges me for being a catholic. Another said in rage that my cousin is burning in hell and that i should attack him for not being a catholic. Stereotypes of hatred brought on by war and propaganda creates that toxicity.
because the number of them involved in major influential roles in marxist politics, sexual perversions, economic and racial warfare.
@@johndoe-ek6vlproof?
@@saltyaphid3195 start paying attention to the authors of biased articles, names of politicians pushing it. I know I'm wasting my time though as you are on their side. But most people with a brain already know.
@@johndoe-ek6vl ok but even so, why? Because jews are an organized people? Jews are one of the least orgajized religions
Oy vey. Your nose touch my screen rabbi