Well we have to remember that when Wind Waker released it was to a resounding disappointment to Zelda fans,, and players alike. People really did not like the departure from the previous games to this one where it was very childlike visually, and the traversal was via ship on open water instead of riding through the land on horseback. so because of that alone I would have to say is the reason it didn't make it on the list.
Editor of the Top 10 vids here... Yes, the SNES list is still cookin' (but not by me) I'm sure you all noticed the format change with the much shorter time length and somewhat faster pacing. Goofy answer? We ran out of budget after the PS2 vid. Serious answer? Health reasons. The PS1 and Fighting Game list vids messed my body up! I hope you all still enjoy it though.
I hope this isn't a permanent change. The long length and fine editing of those insane streams is half the draw, imo. Your work on those is godlike. That being said, thanks again and please take care of yourself!
I would replace Twilight princess with Wind Waker since Twilight Princess is just better on the Wii and came out at the same time. I'm truly sad to not see Luigi's Mansion, but I get why it's not on here lol
As a Fire Emblem fan I would say that Fire Emblem Path of Radiance is one of the underrated GameCube games, considering how niche Fire Emblem was in the west at the time, it's understandable that it didn't get much exposure and people are missing out on one of the best titles
Yep. I’m glad Awakening was able to save the franchise. But at the time when people were raving about Awakening all I thought was how they missed out on the previous Fire Emblems, especially Path of Radiance.
@@gamzillio there are a total of 651 games on GameCube, granite most of those are on other consoles (same with the list from this video) but I still rest my case
@ Bro you know what I mean. The point is how much there is to do in the overworld. I fail to see how Wind Waker would be "boring" in comparison to other games with similar scale. Wind Waker's sea is WAY more interesting than BOTW which fills empty space with korok seeds.
@Marisquizo11 I dont think you actually played original wind waker in a while. The sea is almost empty with not much to do other than grab rupees or go to the next island.
I don’t see how Twilight Princess which is far more linear and railroads you constantly into boring sections like the wolf gameplay made it in the top 2
@@TehParismio have you watched the others simmons puts like 5 rpgs per list, im not saying its top 10 but not to be in the 30 they listed is wild. also they dont like melee but it was 2
they have 5 RPGs in their list my dude and i feel like most would put Paper Mario over Fire emblem, Baten and the GC baulders gate, again not saying it should be in their top ten but it shouldve been acknowledged
The game cube has 10 or 15 truly good games. What do you want them to discuss? If they only had one game per franchise or genre like they did on the PS2 they would have a hard time thinking of 10 games.
Considering the doods' ages, it makes sense why, at least to me. I'm a late 90s dood, and had a different and amazing GameCube experience, and my top ten isn't theirs. Things like having younger family members over for Kirby Air RIde or Mario Baseball.
I get why people say this but remember, it was MEANT to be a GC exclusive. Hell they did a lot of promotion at E3, through outlets and otherwise making clear how big of a game RE4 was going to be and it was only gonna be playable on the GC. It won GOTY while being said exclusive and I still have my copy of it that says "Gamecube Exclusive". Yes they re-released it on Ps2 later with some more content and then to practically everything else later. (Except OG Xbox) But saying RE4 is not a gamecube game is like saying Splinter Cell is not an Xbox game cause it was later re-released on Ps2 with new content. (Cause that version does have a few missions exclusive to it)
Prime at 6 is nuts. It successfully transitioned Metroid into 3D. To Max's point, you gotta bitch with a gamecube, if they aint got Melee or Double Dash, then what are they even doing?
I'm happy it's on the list, but definitely agree. Prime was revolutionary for the metroid franchise. The release of the switch reminded that's its in my top five games ever made.
There was a lot of "discourse" regarding the list, but everything with Twilight Princess made me laugh! The misunderstanding with "dogshit" and "the dog shit!", and it making the top 3 was acceptable
@@luischeco3009 Multi-Platform game that runs better on the Xbox version. It's the same game 4 times. Team battles are boring. The plot is really weak. Extra missions are pure padding. Special stages operate poorly, it's better to NOT boost or even do anything. You will just catch up on your own. Great OST. The voicecast (minus Tails) really gave it their A-Game.
The fact that James Bond 007: Nightfire wasn't even on the list makes me sad. It had an original story campaign, the gunplay felt good and the MP was GoldenEye levels off fun. Also the loading-screen tips still make me and my old buddies laugh. "If you can see the enemy, he can probably see you too!"
RE4 is so legendary that it not only redefined and paved the way for genres, but one of its cancelled versions even became Devil May Cry, a game so iconic in its own right. DMC went on to inspire legendary franchises, and even game franchises from a decade or so before it attempted to do what it did, these are the likes of Castlevania, Shinobi, Metroid and a recent example of this would be Final Fantasy with 16.
The one time Kenny doesn't get all his games murdered is him protecting RE1. And he got it exactly where it needed to be. Also Max is right about Twilight Princess.
I know the exact game Max is thinking of with the "arms crossed with claws" pose... and it's not even a GameCube game (it's Shin Megami Tensei III: Nocturne)
That's the iconic Demi-Fiend pose but he looks like that on key art and not any American box art for Nocturne. Baten Kaitos did have the guy doing the pose, as Max correctly remembered
DoubleDash is one of the best MarioKart games out there. No other MarioKart has a two rider function plus fun drift mechanic. You can dodge blueshells by purely drifting and reshells as well. If anything its one of the most skilled MarioKarts" there is. It's also the first game to introduce 16 player MarioKart with LAN Capabillities.
1- The Legend of Zelda: The Wind Waker 2- Metroid Prime 3- Super Smash Bros. Melee 4- Resident Evil 4 5- The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess 6- Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door 7- Eternal Darkness: Sanity's Requiem 8- Animal Crossing 9- Soul Calibur II 10- F-Zero GX Honorable mentions: 11- Mario Kart: Double Dash!! 12- Pikmin 2 13- Luigi’s Mansion 14- Fire Emblem: Path of Radiance 15- Viewtiful Joe
It’s usually Max prioritizing public opinion and his friends prioritizing personal preference. It gets a little inconsistent, but it was an entertaining list. It is worth mentioning that before the Smash games that came out after Melee, everyone and I mean EVERYBODY loved Melee and not just the diehards. It is an important GameCube game that deserves its place, even if people prefer later entries.
@@SolidBren Yea obviously. Max is prioritizing public opinion and I don't think he should. I already know what the public thinks, I want to know what they think.
My list for this goes like : 1- Wind Waker 2- Mario Sunshine 3- Metroid Prime 4- Mario Kart Double Dash 5- Twilight Princess 6- Metroid Prime 2 7- Luigis Mansión 8- Melee 9- Stars Fox Adventures 10- RE4
Easily in my Top Favorites Super Mario Sunshine TLOZ Windwaker Eternal Darkness Bloody Roar Primal Fury Soulcalibur II TLOZ Twilight Princess Pokémon Colosseum One of Nintendos Best Consoles.
I haven't watched the video yet but I want killer7 on the list even if it gets removed. I'm pretty sure they have never played it though. Edit: oh shit. Exactly what I expected and it happened immediately.
I feel like this list really shows the age difference between me and these guys. I was around preteen for GameCube's prime, I think the group would have been more late teens/early twenties. The choices in their games, and what I would have chose, reflects that a lot I think. Not a huge age difference, but an impactful gap.
You can't have RE1 and 4 on the list and then completely ignore Wind Waker my guys, like holy crap how do you not even have that on the white board. Also if we're doing this whole 'multiplatform's best version/most known version' then Twilight Princess is a Wii game.
Respect to Simmons for at least nominating DK Jungle Beat to be on the list. That game is so severely overlooked (though understandable, given its bongo controller gimmick). It legit has some of the best level design of any platformer ever. Every stage feels like a rollercoaster ride, and it’s one of those rare games where it feels incredibly fun to replay stages over and over to try and 100% and perfect them, even as a casual player. It’s no wonder the dev team went on to make Mario Galaxy after this, because it’s genuinely on the same level of quality, and should unironically be included on every ”top platformers of all time” list. It’s really that good.
my top ten list (gc games i played in my childhood) 1. F zero gx 2. Windwaker 3. Metroid Prime 1 4. Ikaruga 5. viewtiful joe 6. viewtiful joe 2 7. double dash 8. Soul Calibur 2 9. Tony Hawks Underground 2 10. Super monkey ball 2
Metroid Prime better be at the very least in the tenth spot EDIT: It got farther than I thought with them, but they put it in 6 AAAAAAAH I was hoping they'd take it to at least top 5
IAF, Sunshine has a horrible level design (Pachinko and the red coins leaf level) , it's too damn riddled with glitches and bugs, plus the sections without FLUDD are way more difficult than they should, so I kinda understand it not being there, Luigi's mansion or The Thousand Year Door not even getting a mention is wild
Imagine if the put the OOT x Master Quest release you got for pre ordering Wind Waker. Which after learning that Shigeru Miyamoto cringed the first time he saw Wind Waker’s art style, I’m positive was done to salvage sales as possible.
Killing me that they kept holding up the list next to a poster of Phantasy Star Online yet that game didn't even get in the pre-trimmed list. The GC version of that game was fantastic.
Not having Wind Waker on the list is diabolical
Twilight Princess being 3 is based as hell. its not as good as wind waker but its so underrated
Well we have to remember that when Wind Waker released it was to a resounding disappointment to Zelda fans,, and players alike. People really did not like the departure from the previous games to this one where it was very childlike visually, and the traversal was via ship on open water instead of riding through the land on horseback. so because of that alone I would have to say is the reason it didn't make it on the list.
Wind waker was really boring and disappointing sorry
😂😂 thanks for commenting this now I don’t have to waste my time watching a trash list😌
it's not that good. TP beats WW everytime.
Editor of the Top 10 vids here...
Yes, the SNES list is still cookin' (but not by me)
I'm sure you all noticed the format change with the much shorter time length and somewhat faster pacing.
Goofy answer? We ran out of budget after the PS2 vid.
Serious answer? Health reasons. The PS1 and Fighting Game list vids messed my body up!
I hope you all still enjoy it though.
Don't worry, take care and thanks for the fun edits! Do you know if they'll do the top 10 up until the switch?
Get well soon! Also thanks for the informations. Keep shining! 👏
No problem bro. Your health should always be the first priority. Good luck with SNES
I hope this isn't a permanent change. The long length and fine editing of those insane streams is half the draw, imo. Your work on those is godlike.
That being said, thanks again and please take care of yourself!
All good Brunty, i do hope feeling better now
It’s crazy how efficient they are without Steve in the debate
But he is literally the voice of reason in these vids
I love Steve :'(
He's at his absolute worst during these things. Makes everything personal for no reason and becomes the biggest child.
@sh00ner oh like max wasnt sulking during the ps2 vid and being vindictive to others about his made up 'other systems'rule
@@willywitchdoctor You're crazy if you think I'm going to debate about this.
I’m a firm believer that Luigi’s Mansion should be up there, but I’m not mad at this list
Grad You Respect it. Max say RE4 is scarier than Luigi Mansion.
It hurts even more when SA2 was shafted because “better version on different console” but it didn’t even make it to the debate…
i was thinking the same shit
Luigi’s mansion? Paper Mario? Wind waker? Mario sunshine? Did you even own a GameCube? Dafuq
sunshine was on the list 10:10
Paper Mario was N64 and Windwaker gets beat out by Twilight Princess, but I agree that Luigi's Mansion should have at least been mentioned
@@TheManCaveYTChannel Luigi and paper Mario are cool but are far from top 10 games
@@KHChaosrules Paper Mario is IN the GameCube dude... They launched a remake for the Switch not that long time ago
No Super Monkey Ball 1/2 either 😢
Rating Star Fox Adventures over Assault should merit hard labor.
Genuinely surprised that Max has never played Viewtiful Joe. He’s such a Capcom guy and him not playing it was a shock
No windwaker even on the list? Am I drunk?
No, they put one Zelda on the list. And yes, and RE1 and RE4 are same Franchise.
The first thing i thought and looked up in comments. WTF is wrong with your faces...
@@UnclePaul1995 Zelda TP and WW are way more similar to each other than fkng RE1 and RE4, they even talked about that lol
I would replace Twilight princess with Wind Waker since Twilight Princess is just better on the Wii and came out at the same time. I'm truly sad to not see Luigi's Mansion, but I get why it's not on here lol
@@goldenboy2740 Now heres a question for this argument, which is better wii / wii u Twilight Princess or Wii u Wind Waker
Monkey Ball 2 getting killed instantly created an ulcer in my stomach
As a Fire Emblem fan I would say that Fire Emblem Path of Radiance is one of the underrated GameCube games, considering how niche Fire Emblem was in the west at the time, it's understandable that it didn't get much exposure and people are missing out on one of the best titles
Understandable, but these guys aren't Fire Emblem fans (like you are). I don't think it would have changed their opinions.
This game was so good
Yep. I’m glad Awakening was able to save the franchise. But at the time when people were raving about Awakening all I thought was how they missed out on the previous Fire Emblems, especially Path of Radiance.
Justice for Black Knight? Best Fire Emblem Villain?
Path of Radiance is a classic
Oh wow that was qui- wait 21 minutes? Not an hour? Did they actually agree on something and not argue?!
There weren't a lot of games on GC.
They condensed it, it was an hour in the unedited Yovideogames version
@@gamzillioApparently they didn’t play a lot of GameCube games because Twilight Princess (a port) and Twin Snakes being in a top 10 is criminal
@@xzb7644 I don't know if you could call Twilight Princess a port when it came out at the same time as the Wii version and it runs better on GameCube
@@gamzillio there are a total of 651 games on GameCube, granite most of those are on other consoles (same with the list from this video) but I still rest my case
Wind Waker not being on there is criminal
They said in the full video that the sea was boring. Which to me sounds like hipocrisy coming from the guys that stan other open world games
@@Marisquizo11no zelda game before breath of the wild was open world. Wind waker, like most zelda games, is linear.
@ Bro you know what I mean. The point is how much there is to do in the overworld. I fail to see how Wind Waker would be "boring" in comparison to other games with similar scale. Wind Waker's sea is WAY more interesting than BOTW which fills empty space with korok seeds.
@Marisquizo11 I dont think you actually played original wind waker in a while. The sea is almost empty with not much to do other than grab rupees or go to the next island.
I don’t see how Twilight Princess which is far more linear and railroads you constantly into boring sections like the wolf gameplay made it in the top 2
No Luigi's Mansion but having Twin Snakes in the top ten is a kick to the nuts.
Mario Sunshine and Mario Kart is on the List.
I love Twin Snakes.
Custom Robo is still one of my personal peak gameplay experiences on the gamecube.
Glad someone said this, I effin loved that game!
Thousand year door?????????
You're asking the crew who 3 out of the 4 who's mostly known for fighting games to add a rpg on tier list.
@@TehParismio have you watched the others simmons puts like 5 rpgs per list, im not saying its top 10 but not to be in the 30 they listed is wild. also they dont like melee but it was 2
What about it? Not even the best rpg on GameCube and there are only like 4 of them
they have 5 RPGs in their list my dude and i feel like most would put Paper Mario over Fire emblem, Baten and the GC baulders gate, again not saying it should be in their top ten but it shouldve been acknowledged
Mario Kart, Mario Sunshine, and Mario DDR is on the list, We don’t need another Mario Game on the List. Top Ten Mario Games, Perhaps?
It's shocking how short these are without Steve's imput
PS2 gets a 1 hour+ super cut and GamCube gets 20 minutes? I feel the snub.
They are more decided on gamecube than ps1 plus they got better at speeding up the process by knowing when they're games a lost cause
I think the editor earned himself a break at this point, don't you?
The game cube has 10 or 15 truly good games. What do you want them to discuss? If they only had one game per franchise or genre like they did on the PS2 they would have a hard time thinking of 10 games.
most of the games are ports, be honest. gamecube was always the underdog of its generation no matter how you spin it.
Considering the doods' ages, it makes sense why, at least to me. I'm a late 90s dood, and had a different and amazing GameCube experience, and my top ten isn't theirs. Things like having younger family members over for Kirby Air RIde or Mario Baseball.
IMMEDIATELY shooting down viewtiful joe hurt my heart
Wut, RE4 is better?
@ it is. Good thing 9 other games can make the list
@@jaealxndr Max is more Capcom Fan than Nintendo Fan. Funny that Max be like “Don’t Ask Me For S..h” at the End.
@@UnclePaul1995 I know. I watched the live. I didn’t ask you to tell me max’s interests
@@jaealxndr Just a Warning to Respect His Opinion.
"Max doesn't want A THOUSAND STINKY GUYS on Twitter yelling at us!" 😭
Oh boy, it's another tierlist
*Pulls out the meme of the guy pointing at the incoming tornado*
As insane as leaving Wind Waker out is, they gave F-Zero GX the respect it deserves and that makes me one happy racing game fan.
No Eternal Darkness? and instead Re4 which was barely an exclusive?
I get why people say this but remember, it was MEANT to be a GC exclusive. Hell they did a lot of promotion at E3, through outlets and otherwise making clear how big of a game RE4 was going to be and it was only gonna be playable on the GC. It won GOTY while being said exclusive and I still have my copy of it that says "Gamecube Exclusive". Yes they re-released it on Ps2 later with some more content and then to practically everything else later. (Except OG Xbox) But saying RE4 is not a gamecube game is like saying Splinter Cell is not an Xbox game cause it was later re-released on Ps2 with new content. (Cause that version does have a few missions exclusive to it)
These 4 look reasonable
Surely viewtiful and waker make the list right 🥲
Prime at 6 is nuts. It successfully transitioned Metroid into 3D. To Max's point, you gotta bitch with a gamecube, if they aint got Melee or Double Dash, then what are they even doing?
I had a bitch with a gamecube, and she indeed had Melee and Double Dash
Prime is easily 1 for me on Gamecube
I'm happy it's on the list, but definitely agree. Prime was revolutionary for the metroid franchise. The release of the switch reminded that's its in my top five games ever made.
SSX Tricky on Game Cube has an uncomfortable chunk of my time-line I can never get back! Haha.
There was a lot of "discourse" regarding the list, but everything with Twilight Princess made me laugh! The misunderstanding with "dogshit" and "the dog shit!", and it making the top 3 was acceptable
I appreciate Max going to bat for melee. He gets the hype even if he’s not the one behind the controller enjoying it
No Luigi's Mansion.
Not a single Mario Party.
No Pokemon Colosseum.
No Mario Sluggers.
No Paper Mario Thousand Year Door
No Sonic heroes?
@@luischeco3009
Multi-Platform game that runs better on the Xbox version.
It's the same game 4 times.
Team battles are boring.
The plot is really weak.
Extra missions are pure padding.
Special stages operate poorly, it's better to NOT boost or even do anything. You will just catch up on your own.
Great OST. The voicecast (minus Tails) really gave it their A-Game.
No kirby air ride
@@xarezarcs4125 oh true!
The fact that James Bond 007: Nightfire wasn't even on the list makes me sad. It had an original story campaign, the gunplay felt good and the MP was GoldenEye levels off fun.
Also the loading-screen tips still make me and my old buddies laugh. "If you can see the enemy, he can probably see you too!"
RE4 is so legendary that it not only redefined and paved the way for genres, but one of its cancelled versions even became Devil May Cry, a game so iconic in its own right.
DMC went on to inspire legendary franchises, and even game franchises from a decade or so before it attempted to do what it did, these are the likes of Castlevania, Shinobi, Metroid and a recent example of this would be Final Fantasy with 16.
The one time Kenny doesn't get all his games murdered is him protecting RE1. And he got it exactly where it needed to be.
Also Max is right about Twilight Princess.
I know the exact game Max is thinking of with the "arms crossed with claws" pose... and it's not even a GameCube game
(it's Shin Megami Tensei III: Nocturne)
He was thinking of Baten Kaitos 1.
That's the iconic Demi-Fiend pose but he looks like that on key art and not any American box art for Nocturne. Baten Kaitos did have the guy doing the pose, as Max correctly remembered
DoubleDash is one of the best MarioKart games out there. No other MarioKart has a two rider function plus fun drift mechanic. You can dodge blueshells by purely drifting and reshells as well. If anything its one of the most skilled MarioKarts" there is. It's also the first game to introduce 16 player MarioKart with LAN Capabillities.
They must have hated it because of Baby Park, which is hilarious because that's the best track to play in competitive
@@djpegao Possibly, but BP is Iconic. Complete Chaos as its supposed to be.
1- The Legend of Zelda: The Wind Waker
2- Metroid Prime
3- Super Smash Bros. Melee
4- Resident Evil 4
5- The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess
6- Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door
7- Eternal Darkness: Sanity's Requiem
8- Animal Crossing
9- Soul Calibur II
10- F-Zero GX
Honorable mentions:
11- Mario Kart: Double Dash!!
12- Pikmin 2
13- Luigi’s Mansion
14- Fire Emblem: Path of Radiance
15- Viewtiful Joe
For shame, not having Wind Waker or 1000 Year Door even on the initial list
The fact that Ultimate Spider-Man is missing from this list is a crime against all spider people
I remember watching this one live on stream - gonna be fun to watch this one with the hilarious editing :)
killer7 first cut hurts
No PSO? No Sonic Adventure 2 Battle? No Super Monkey Ball? No Pikmin? No Paper Mario? No Wind Waker? I'm calling fraud. Get the strap! 😆
Omfg no one talked about sonic adventure 2...or PSO. God damn sonic adventure was good.
I’m happy that Rogue Squadron snuck in at 10, but there should have been a few Mario games on that list.
I'll be honest Ive never met anyone who likes twin snakes enough to put it in top 10 gamecube games of all time. Not mad just genuinely surprised
No Wind Waker or Luigi's Mansion :(
Nope, just Mario Sunshine and Twilight Princess.
No Luigi's Mansion, Wind Waker, Pikmin, Paper Mario 2 or one of the four Mario Partys?
Nope, just Mario Kart Double Dash.
I'm shocked this is only 20 minutes when the Dreamcast, PS1, and PS2 debates were feature length
You can thank Steeb not being involved in the debate/allocation
mario partys not up there is crazy, Tales of Symphonia not up there is wild🎉
The length of this video tells you how much their connection with the GameCube wasn't as strong
WHERE'S DAY OF RECKONING 2?
9:27 STONE COLD MAX
10:45 VIRTUA FIGHTER TIGER GAME!
I like 1 better TBH.
No Sonic Adventure 2 Battle??! Man that really hurts 😢
Prince of Persia wasnt even nominated
No Custom Robo is insane.
I'm gonna sound like such a zoomer but I've never seen a GameCube irl so I'm here for the vibes 😅
that melee placement feels wrong. If none of the four of you like it that much, don't put it high. It's your list, there's no obligation.
It’s usually Max prioritizing public opinion and his friends prioritizing personal preference. It gets a little inconsistent, but it was an entertaining list.
It is worth mentioning that before the Smash games that came out after Melee, everyone and I mean EVERYBODY loved Melee and not just the diehards. It is an important GameCube game that deserves its place, even if people prefer later entries.
@@SolidBren Yea obviously. Max is prioritizing public opinion and I don't think he should. I already know what the public thinks, I want to know what they think.
My list for this goes like :
1- Wind Waker
2- Mario Sunshine
3- Metroid Prime
4- Mario Kart Double Dash
5- Twilight Princess
6- Metroid Prime 2
7- Luigis Mansión
8- Melee
9- Stars Fox Adventures
10- RE4
Double dash and Mario Sunshine not being top 10 is pure EVIL. 2 RE games? come on guys NO just NO.
I luckily started my GameCube collection before the collector craze came knocking, i got most of my favorite games back
i love these videos so much, the chaos brings me such joy and Steeb's crashouts are hilarious
Easily in my Top Favorites
Super Mario Sunshine
TLOZ Windwaker
Eternal Darkness
Bloody Roar Primal Fury
Soulcalibur II
TLOZ Twilight Princess
Pokémon Colosseum
One of Nintendos Best Consoles.
No day pf reckoning is crazy
This needs to be an hour long Dood (minimum).
Found myself watching these recently. So glad a new one just dropped. The emotions and edits are so pure. 😂😂
This list is lacking without Eternal Darkness, Windwaker, or Super Monkey Ball.
Eternal Darkness deserves to be in the Top 10 more than Twin Snakes
@androidps1440 The Sanity meter/system should have automatically put in top 10.
I haven't watched the video yet but I want killer7 on the list even if it gets removed. I'm pretty sure they have never played it though.
Edit: oh shit. Exactly what I expected and it happened immediately.
No Wind Waker is absurd, it’s definitely better than Twilight Princess
If gotcha force isn't on here ima crash out
We know it ain’t. Even though it should be.
I feel like this list really shows the age difference between me and these guys. I was around preteen for GameCube's prime, I think the group would have been more late teens/early twenties. The choices in their games, and what I would have chose, reflects that a lot I think. Not a huge age difference, but an impactful gap.
Metroid Prime is top 3 at least
☝️this guy gets it! 😂
Would've replaced twilight with windwaker tbh
these lists are great, top tier content
Where is the long video? 21 minuten are not enough for me!
You can't have RE1 and 4 on the list and then completely ignore Wind Waker my guys, like holy crap how do you not even have that on the white board. Also if we're doing this whole 'multiplatform's best version/most known version' then Twilight Princess is a Wii game.
Respect to Simmons for at least nominating DK Jungle Beat to be on the list. That game is so severely overlooked (though understandable, given its bongo controller gimmick).
It legit has some of the best level design of any platformer ever. Every stage feels like a rollercoaster ride, and it’s one of those rare games where it feels incredibly fun to replay stages over and over to try and 100% and perfect them, even as a casual player. It’s no wonder the dev team went on to make Mario Galaxy after this, because it’s genuinely on the same level of quality, and should unironically be included on every ”top platformers of all time” list.
It’s really that good.
12:24 is Max confusing Twin Snakes with Metal Gear Solid 2?????
Symphonia getting cut and no Wind Waker even on the board should be a punishable offense. Crying and throwing up in the club rn.
no paper mario TTYD is crazy, this list is wack asf
I see Mario Sunshine and Mario Kart in the Video.
I hope the next top 10 YoVG debate are NES and RPG, I can imagine how bloody that last one could end up
No Thousand Year Door, Star Fox Assault, Metroid Prime 2 Echoes, or Wind Waker? I guess we can disregard this list entirely.
my top ten list (gc games i played in my childhood)
1. F zero gx
2. Windwaker
3. Metroid Prime 1
4. Ikaruga
5. viewtiful joe
6. viewtiful joe 2
7. double dash
8. Soul Calibur 2
9. Tony Hawks Underground 2
10. Super monkey ball 2
GX ist still the best futuristic Racing Game to date. 👍
This comment means everything to me
Damn that a really good list!
No Windwaker? No Luigi's Mansion? No Pikmin? Damn.
We need a movie where they have to decide before the end of the world, in order to save the world.
I appreciate the usage of Haven's ost in these videos, such an amazing game.
Metroid Prime better be at the very least in the tenth spot EDIT: It got farther than I thought with them, but they put it in 6 AAAAAAAH I was hoping they'd take it to at least top 5
Mario Sunshine not being in the top 10 makes this list completely invalid by law
I'm literally shaking rn
IAF, Sunshine has a horrible level design (Pachinko and the red coins leaf level) , it's too damn riddled with glitches and bugs, plus the sections without FLUDD are way more difficult than they should, so I kinda understand it not being there, Luigi's mansion or The Thousand Year Door not even getting a mention is wild
I would defend Mario Superstar Baseball with my life! My personal favorite of the sports games on GameCube.
Lots of games missing on this list! But I’m excited to watch you guys argue 😂
Castlevania: Aura of Holy Might (Track 1 - Awake, Circle of the Moon, Out Today)
Imagine if the put the OOT x Master Quest release you got for pre ordering Wind Waker. Which after learning that Shigeru Miyamoto cringed the first time he saw Wind Waker’s art style, I’m positive was done to salvage sales as possible.
Putting SC2 before Metroid Prime is crazy work
Having twin snakes anywhere near top 10 should be studied
*OMG GameCube!!* 💙
RIP Custom Robo😢
This being so much shorter than the others when Steve is mostly uninvolved is really funny
Killing me that they kept holding up the list next to a poster of Phantasy Star Online yet that game didn't even get in the pre-trimmed list. The GC version of that game was fantastic.
Warioworld “the raunchy open world one with the badass bosses” is my favourite. Also Pikmin and Paper Mario TTYD.
Also known as the "Resident Evil 4 and who they invite to the cookout" list
Steb enters as the agent of chaos.
It's almost too appropriate
21 minutes, what era of peace and prosperity have we entered?
No Windwaker or Double Dash is crazy, but all in all I actually do respect this list quite a bit.
They need to do top 10 games of all time at some point, because this is a peak series
I'm just surprised Twin Snakes made it to top 10. The idea of it is much better than the real thing.