Youngeun being out here shining. The one out of two people I truly wanted to get in kep1er sadly my other did not (ruiqi) but youngeun was truly needed for the group
Thank you for making this video, it mustve taken a lot of time and your efforts are really impressive!! I think another thing to consider is the type of performances they went to. Members like Hiyyih, Xiaoting, Yujin and Dayeon went to dance performances, which had more members so less lines while Yeongeun and Mashiro had a 3 member vocal based performance for the combination mission, giving them a lot of singing opportunities, and Chaehyun was also attracted to vocal based performances. Dayeon and Xiaoting also got centre for Shine, which i didnt realsie how many more lines that gave them omg I still can't believe Hiyyih barely has a minute of lines in total on the show, that's insane to me, she barely got to showcase anything with that ngl, no wonder ppl were so criticial about her getting into the lineup. And Hikaru???? I'm so surprised, I feel like she had way more lines, or maybe her performances were just that memorable haha. I hope Hiyyih, Hikaru and Yeseo will have more opportunities in the future.
Poor Hiyyih why, she chose those parts and is totally respectable. If you remember, in the Shoot team nobody wanted to do the main vocal and Bahiyyih had the opportunity to volunteer to have more lines.
@@EddyisReady u cant use that as something to use as evidence for anything here that was from the show. and also its pretty obvious that they dont choose their lines. because when they did the part switch to wa da da it was pretty clear she wasnt ok with her non existant lines.
GUYSSSS DONT REMIND ME!!! My heart hurts with that line distribution! Hikaru and Bahiyyih were treated so bad... I should’ve never expected anything from that evil company
@@alistamizhia2198 i'm sorry I read ur comment then saw the replies 😭 it's kinda hilarious for me 😭 but the line distribution and the screentime in wa da da just making me scream for the whole day :'D it was bad so much even in other songs, hoping that for their comeback, they get more lines and screentime
I think they covered the Christmas song because they were the only unit without a member with covid. They've been divided into units based on height so far (their reality show, vlives, etc). I think Mashiro and perhaps Yujin are definitely gonna be in the vocal line
@@christalmaysarzata96 she's literally one of the weakest vocals of the group, aside from hikaru and maybe dayeon and yeseo, so i doubt she'll get many
@@ll-cb3py bahiyyih can be top5 or 6 in vocals. she hits the right notes, stable and relaxed singing but her cons are she has a quiet singing style that can sometimes appear as less expressive and powerful. having a quiet singing style doesn't mean you are less capable. being loud isn't the same as being strong in vocals. shouting isn't the same as singing. but so far all of kepler has some solid vocals, kinda like slightly above average to really good vocalists like chaehyun and youngeun
@@ll-cb3py She definitely isn't one of the weakest among the group vocals but more like the groups vocals are weak, I have watched multiple videos and also a video of a vocal trainer (or something) ranking kep1er vocals and they ranked bahiyyih 5th so she is right in the middle and also can improve as well so no, she isn't one of the weakest vocalist in the group
@@beomblast saw someone i follow claim that the ranking would be Chae>Youngeun>= Bahi. Chae is the only one with support and Youngeun/Bahi are relaxed around G4 so yeah she's definitely on top of Kep1er's vocal
Fun Fact! Bahiyyih actually got the Killing Part in Shoot! The "Maybe, Maybe Not" part was switched from Vocal 3/4 to Bahiyyih. As well as a couple of lines from Vocal 1. Interesting that Mnet chose to edit a whole fake rivalry over Fu Yaning and Sui Ruiqi switching parts, but never showed how Bahiyyih got those lines...
Hopefully it won’t, especially with these line distributions it was based on the girls auditioning for a certain position and votes instead of them being assigned
@@empresswilliams8102 well.. she actually have 10 seconds include the (hey) lines 💀 well it's bad too. I was hoping she get better line in other songs but it just dissapointed me. Hiyyih and hikaru barely get lines even for screentime i think. Hope for their comeback, the company give them better lines and screentime
@@KevZ7. I think they meant that she was the only one who made it in her groups in Connect and Combination, while all the other ones didn’t make it into Kep1er
Chaehyun is the only who survived in yes or yes, and she is also THE ONLY ONE who survived in my sea😁 so.. hikaru is NOT the only one.. get your facts straight sweety..
the way youngeun says "I'll kiss you good bye" is soooooo satisfying. it sounds better than the original version with rose and jenni imo. idk if its cuz her voice is so clear or what but it makes my skin shiver with how good it is.
I know it's good and her vocals are amazing (I know it) but you didn't have to bring up Rosé and Jennie into this You should've just said her vocals are great and not compare them
I think it’s understandable, each member of each sub group decided the positions for every performance, unfortunately they always were in groups with members better at singing rapping or dancing
They often chose either groups focused on dance or big groups, so it's logical if you really think about it. Bahiyyih also advertised herself as a dancer (she really should've gone for vocals in my opinion, but as an untrained dancer, she's actually pretty decent according to professional dancers) while Hikaru preferred rapping, which means less lines unfortunately.
To be fair we can’t really compare cause some of them were in 3 groups some solo while others 9 and so on and also another thing is the girls voted for each parts every time they practice for a new mission so line distribution can’t really be fair if 1. The girls didn’t try out for a specific line or 2. The girls didn’t get voted for the line they want
honestly how are you supposed to support and vote for someone to become an idol with only a minute of them singing throughout the entire show. mnet did bahiyyih very wrong. she wasn't showcased properly, neither were anyone else who didn't at least get 2 minutes... maybe if they had less participants more girls would have more time to be able to show their talents...
Ironically, I feel like the hate train and lack of screentime actually benefited her in a sense that it gave her what I call "The Blackpink Effect." When you starve a fanbase by only feeding them crumbs, eventually like birds they're going to come back for more and sometimes bring friends who'll bring their friends and so on... I mean, Hiyyihlights were dedicated in a way that I've only seen in a from fanbases like ARMYs or something. Plus, I feel like when you're an outsider and see all this stuff over every social media platform about how horrible such and such contestant is, but you go to her fancam and see her actually be decent, if not good or great, it's easy to see her as an underdog and grow attached. So Mnet kinda gave her an unintentional underdog arc too lmao 🤣
the members who performed pick their own line or the members have the privilege to vote who will sang a part of the song. The show has nothing to do with the line distribution.
@@pinkkryboard157 I'm not really specifically speaking about line distribution. How about they do more songs in the show in general, rather wasting minutes of show on evil editing or fake cringey drama. I just think the show's structure is the main issue. They focus too much on less important/unfunny things that are supposed to be entertaining, but are usually just very forced and cringe. I think the majority of people who was survival shows are there for the performances, and the girls personalities. However the fake drama and other wastes of times, like the useless judges imo, is the real problem I find in the show. If the premise is for us to choose individual girls to become an idol in a group, why are we seeing so little of the girls performance and other screentime, in exchange for stupid drama and reactions from the judges.
@Des And? People can be fans of both??? If someone was an ARMY before they started listening to TXT, are they only an ARMY forever and nothing else? Is their status as a fan of TXT never established because they heard about them because they debuted after BTS? If you were a Reveluv, could you never also be a MY?
i'm so proud of them, watching this video make me want to cry TwT all of them have unique voices ! it's gonna be incredible when they will debut ! thank you for this video, it was needed
@@levitatingstan6526 not really, if two people want the same part it's voted who the best and like all the other produce we know some just pick their friend, like when Dayeon and Caibing wanted to be leader, all the Chinese member chose Caibing, and it's the same for kill part or singing/raping part, so no she can't totally chose and she's a sweetheart, so she probably take the least wanted part for avoid problem in group (in gp999)
bahiyyih and youngeun thooo they're the most relaxed stable vocals, I kinda don't like how greedy(trying hard) some of the members rap or sing but I'll wait for improvements
Don't like another dream beacause of their unfair line distributions. Can't believe hiyyih only have the "너와 함께" part, does it even a line? feel like it's an adlid ps. the song is beautiful but when I listen to it I feel sorry for her. Let's make hiyyih famous! Let's make a name for her!(not only for her but for the entire group) Hiyyihlights fighting! Kepler fighting! Kepler's fan fighting!
@@goldyd144 which makes me think hiyyih is definetly getting more lines which is amazing. But also makes me think Hikaru's lines won't improve even after debut.......it's probably gonna be more dance and vocal based considering mnets other groups. I feel so bad because Hikaru is the only full fledged rapper in the group 😔
@@reekmisa True. Luckily, Hikaru's Korean is improving fast! Xiaoting's the one I'm worried about when it comes to lines. Also, Dayeon and Youngeun auditioned as rappers too. Xiaoting can as well. And Yujin! Man, this group really is full of all-rounders now that I think about it!
@@goldyd144 omg true. They are literally so good. And yes xt's korean has been improving but I'm afraid it's not at amazing debut point. She might just sing some adlibs and the " wa da da da " 💀💔
@@goldyd144 well... even in debut song she barely get lines and screentime. In other song she has the least lines too :')) hoping the company would give her better lines and screentime too :")
Yes it's complicated, for example Yujin in Bubble pop or Chaehyun in My Sea. For Another Dream, Yeseo is for half the song in the center of the stage but it is complicated to define since apart from a few moments nobody moves. i try to do my best!
The fact that all of them except for Bahiyyih got 17 seconds or more from the demo stage means mnet really wanted to eliminate hyuba from the start and use Heuning Kai's name to attract more viewers.
I need a video like this one but with screentime instead of lines, or one of how much time each member spent speaking on camera or at least the little interview like parts(tho that could be a video on its own) or even just about how much time the camera spent focus on them, like only them or close ups shots of them (that could also be a video on its own) I'm sure the numbers would change, and probably even out between most of the members except for my bahiyyih :c
This is not a request for you to make them, I'm sure these kind of videos take ages to make, so I'm not asking you to make them, I'm just expressing it, but of course you can make them if you like these ideas, I'll definitely watch them
A kind of screen time Distribution but on the entire show? I can try to do it but it's gonna take a long time and i don't know if i'll succeed to finishing it. Before, I will first make the other requests that I received but you can follow the progress with this link that I update regularly ^^ docs.google.com/document/d/1MrUhqag8PhNTlgqrE0Q3wjO85LdYerC_IFiDG31KjPI/edit?usp=drivesdk Thank you ! (I hope you understand me and I apologize for my bad English)
Yes, a screen time distribution video on the entire show, I know it would take really long to make, so it's okay if you never do it, but if you do, a big thank you in advance, and maybe it would be easier to make a video per episode and then a final video with the total amount of screentime per member. I'll be checking the link, thank you c: Also, you don't need to apologize your english is fine, don't worry, and it is not my first language either
it's sad that mnet prevented huenin from singing enough lines to show her talent, it was obvious that they didn't want her to be in the final lineup, whatever all the girls sing beautiful and they will surely shine in kep1er once they debut (and with the correct distribution of lines of course)
The lines were decides by the girls not mnet and hiyyih wasn't confident so she doesn't get a lot of lines its her choice tho but in shoot she gained more confidence that's why she got a lot of lines and she shined a lot, confidence is really needed.
@@ningster6144 Exactly, Youngeun was a example of a very confident trainee and was always ambitious which is also why she got a lot of lines during the show. She knew what she wanted and went for it without any hesitation which in those type of scenarios are really good for getting more lines in the end.
@@arstan8092 Not entirely, in part the participants are allowed to decide and participate in the preparation of the presentations but in the same way the production intervenes, it is assumed that the end is perfect the presentation and give a more attractive show to the public but this is not always the case, we only saw small segments,but we do not know what happened behind the scenes, even some participants have said that they received some indications from the staff and then edited them in production to generate controversy. We must also be aware of the constant changes in voting dynamics and the screen time given to each participant, Huenin was not the only victim, kpop groups are for sale, and mnet cares about the korean market, if they consider that a girl is not going to like the koreans it immediately hinders it, Huenin seems like the clearest example to me, but there are many other kids from other survival shows who suffered the same thing.
@@vanessagonzalez1314 I agree there was alot of evil editing (Mostly against chinese trainees, not bahhiyeh), i was never saying anything against that, but we have not had anything leaked about that mnet specifically changed peoples roles when the people was deciding on roles etc. Could she have been unfairly edited, sure. But the lines she got from what we have seen was given by the trainees and not mnet staff. This discussion was only discussion on line distribution, which has been shown pretty well to be the trainees choice. I think the best examples for evil editing are Su Ruiqi, Cai Bing and Fu Yaning. They was the ones truly treated horribly by Mnet directly thanks to the editing. The main mistreatment bahhiyeh got was that she did not get enough screentime, but that could simply be because she was not going for big lines and we do not really know. But the chinese trainess was literally painted as evil, bad people and disrespectful while having consistantly shown to be some of the most if not the most talented people on the show, i did not see a single edit like that of bahhiyeh.
the fact that the very last line of this compilation was a voice crack says a lot about the voters of this show and kpop stans in general only going for visuals and not talent
this is not fair enough bc in the demo stage some of them where soloist or some where only with one or two more trainees, meanwhile other were with more girls. the same happen in the combination mission. thats way the distribution is very different.
I hope the line distribution in Kepler will be fair, because it's okay during the show the difference between the quantities (they chose their performances)
i'm sorry but look at ALL OF THOSE SECONDS MNET CUT OF HIYYIH. daaaaaaaaamn also thank you for not including the times of non singing parts (I.e. after how you like that for xiaoting)
Bahiyyih :((( issokay if fans continue supporting her the company will eventually feel more pressured to give her more lines (it has happened in other grps b4)
To be honest the main thing which pushed Youngeun to the top was the third performance. I think it was either lucky or genius on her part to choose a vocal position with 3 members in it. This would have given her more screen time as compared to members who were in the 6 people or 9 people groups. She only sang the chorus which was 50% of the song allowing her to boost her screentime. As compared to the Hikaru and Mashiro whose song had slightly less lines and on top of that was evenly distributed.
It’s gonna be really interesting to see how the future of Kep1er goes considering they have a lot of members who shine in dance and rap, yet usually Produce groups tend to focus on vocals. I wonder if we’re gonna see more rap from them in the future.
I'll probably do it, nevertheless it's a very long video to make and i ain't got much time for editing these days, so i apologize but it'll take a little while ^^
Dayeon has completely changed when I compare her mission from the beginning with that of Ice Cream (SLAYED) (I hope Bahiyyih will have many lines in the future of Kep1er) :)
yeah, but bahiyyih doesn't even have an advantage (top 3) in every ability (vocal, rap, dance, sp), she is always last in everything except winning in popularity :)
if you want your bias get more line, don't choose them to debut in group. go get them solo don't debut in group especially with 9 members. the program show who can get more lines, it means her quality is higher than others. my bias not young eun, but daeyon and support for yujin, but i respect my bias don't got more lines, it depends on their quality of voice and technic. from snsd eras, group with 9 members will never get everyone happy with the lines, but its depending on voice that could make a song sounds better. toxic fans that tell about lines has been started from their debut and it will make other fandom laught to kep1ian. those fans fill never been satisfied and will always make a noise about part line.
![Which ILLIT member has the most lines in RUNEXT ? [LINE DISTRIBUTION]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/DowVAomxQPc/mqdefault.jpg)
![[Girls Planet 999] 18명의 참가자들! '응답해줘 OVER' @9IRLS NI9GH A9IT #GirlsPlanet999](/img/n.gif)
Youngeun being out here shining. The one out of two people I truly wanted to get in kep1er sadly my other did not (ruiqi) but youngeun was truly needed for the group
same
who is ruiqi? sorry i am new to the group 😅
@@maxreczonytrandomgamesmore6029 Ruiqi was another trainee in gp999 survival show who did not end up making it into the debuting group sadly.
wow they both was my picks too!
btw in gp999 was so many nice girls ㅠㅠ
Youngeun the ACE of the group 🦊
Youngeun really said ✨social distancing✨ She started out as a rapper and dancer and now she’s main vocal. Truly an ace.
shes not a main vocalist
@@jichhuushe’s
@@user-rq9gb1jg5r chaehyun is main vocal
Thank you for making this video, it mustve taken a lot of time and your efforts are really impressive!!
I think another thing to consider is the type of performances they went to. Members like Hiyyih, Xiaoting, Yujin and Dayeon went to dance performances, which had more members so less lines while Yeongeun and Mashiro had a 3 member vocal based performance for the combination mission, giving them a lot of singing opportunities, and Chaehyun was also attracted to vocal based performances. Dayeon and Xiaoting also got centre for Shine, which i didnt realsie how many more lines that gave them omg
I still can't believe Hiyyih barely has a minute of lines in total on the show, that's insane to me, she barely got to showcase anything with that ngl, no wonder ppl were so criticial about her getting into the lineup. And Hikaru???? I'm so surprised, I feel like she had way more lines, or maybe her performances were just that memorable haha. I hope Hiyyih, Hikaru and Yeseo will have more opportunities in the future.
Thank you so much ! 🥰
I hope too !
Exactly we barely saw bahiyyih lol
Bahi didn’t show up much but whenever she did she didn’t flop and she did really well in fiesta and ice cream
Hiyyihr had massive international votes for her. Finishing 1'st there.
Hikaru made her lines memorable like a killing parts❤
Youngeun : Main Vocal, Main Rapper, Main Dancer, Variety Star. Queen does it all.
Poor Hiyyih and Hikaru but woah Youngeun have so much lines, I love it
Poor Hiyyih why, she chose those parts and is totally respectable. If you remember, in the Shoot team nobody wanted to do the main vocal and Bahiyyih had the opportunity to volunteer to have more lines.
@@EddyisReady u cant use that as something to use as evidence for anything here that was from the show. and also its pretty obvious that they dont choose their lines. because when they did the part switch to wa da da it was pretty clear she wasnt ok with her non existant lines.
@@kpopjinja we are talking about gp999, not the debut lol
@@kpopjinja we are talking bout gp999, she never went for a big role
@phantom thief alibaba Fr😭
Youngeun:
have so many talents = have so many lines
Well deserved
Shut up
@@vernonjc1818 its true tho +confidence that's how she got many lines
Youngeun totally got yena vibe.... Ace queen and effortless funny!!!
Youngeun snatch all the main vocal and vocal 1 position throughout the competition
Same us Yujin though😭😭
I feel bad for Bahiyyih and hikaru! Hope kep1er treats them better
Well...
well...
Well...
GUYSSSS DONT REMIND ME!!! My heart hurts with that line distribution! Hikaru and Bahiyyih were treated so bad... I should’ve never expected anything from that evil company
@@alistamizhia2198 i'm sorry I read ur comment then saw the replies 😭 it's kinda hilarious for me 😭 but the line distribution and the screentime in wa da da just making me scream for the whole day :'D it was bad so much even in other songs, hoping that for their comeback, they get more lines and screentime
1st Youngeun
2nd Dayeon
3rd Chaehyun
This three also The one who covers taeyeon This christmas i think they are the vocal line? Hmm
I think they covered the Christmas song because they were the only unit without a member with covid. They've been divided into units based on height so far (their reality show, vlives, etc). I think Mashiro and perhaps Yujin are definitely gonna be in the vocal line
@@user-kp7iz4dr8l pretty sure they were the ones picked bc they might be the vocal line+ mashiro
And there are people out there who truly believe Youngeun won't be a main vocal
Youngeun really said social distancing
I love the tear drop in Don't Go. Legendary right on the beat.
and she isn’t
SEO YOUNGEUN QUEEN!!! In my opinion she deserves more lines and screen time in Wa Da Da. I also wish she had rapping lines :(
Bahiyyih vocal is incredible great I love her vocal tone sooo much..I hope she got a lot more lines when debut song release.
I wish that too
@@christalmaysarzata96 she's literally one of the weakest vocals of the group, aside from hikaru and maybe dayeon and yeseo, so i doubt she'll get many
@@ll-cb3py bahiyyih can be top5 or 6 in vocals. she hits the right notes, stable and relaxed singing but her cons are she has a quiet singing style that can sometimes appear as less expressive and powerful. having a quiet singing style doesn't mean you are less capable. being loud isn't the same as being strong in vocals. shouting isn't the same as singing. but so far all of kepler has some solid vocals, kinda like slightly above average to really good vocalists like chaehyun and youngeun
@@ll-cb3py She definitely isn't one of the weakest among the group vocals but more like the groups vocals are weak, I have watched multiple videos and also a video of a vocal trainer (or something) ranking kep1er vocals and they ranked bahiyyih 5th so she is right in the middle and also can improve as well so no, she isn't one of the weakest vocalist in the group
@@beomblast saw someone i follow claim that the ranking would be Chae>Youngeun>= Bahi. Chae is the only one with support and Youngeun/Bahi are relaxed around G4 so yeah she's definitely on top of Kep1er's vocal
Youngeun really deserves her lines !!!
Shoot! is Bahiyyih's era, she got a lot of lines in this song
While I think it was Yujin's era, she shined a lot
Bahiyyih had iconics lines and Yujin was Main vocal so they both shined ^^
@@juno1765 this song can be for both of them, they were stunning
Fun Fact! Bahiyyih actually got the Killing Part in Shoot! The "Maybe, Maybe Not" part was switched from Vocal 3/4 to Bahiyyih. As well as a couple of lines from Vocal 1. Interesting that Mnet chose to edit a whole fake rivalry over Fu Yaning and Sui Ruiqi switching parts, but never showed how Bahiyyih got those lines...
@@juno1765 What's wrong with you? People can't even praise Bahiyyih now? 😒
If the line distribution in WA DA DA is like this I'm sueing the company
Hopefully it won’t, especially with these line distributions it was based on the girls auditioning for a certain position and votes instead of them being assigned
Well....
aha-
@@lillysm bahiyih getting like 6 seconds of line time
@@empresswilliams8102 well.. she actually have 10 seconds include the (hey) lines 💀 well it's bad too. I was hoping she get better line in other songs but it just dissapointed me. Hiyyih and hikaru barely get lines even for screentime i think. Hope for their comeback, the company give them better lines and screentime
ACE YOUNGEUN
I love how you connect the lines of them by the arrange of songs nice video✨
Thank you so much
The fact that Hikaru was the only person in each of her groups that survived until Snake
despite having few lines, she was iconic in every performance
wait am I dumb or I didn't understood your comment ?
@@KevZ7. I think they meant that she was the only one who made it in her groups in Connect and Combination, while all the other ones didn’t make it into Kep1er
Chaehyun is the only who survived in yes or yes, and she is also THE ONLY ONE who survived in my sea😁 so.. hikaru is NOT the only one.. get your facts straight sweety..
@@thelordnaevis4946 chaehyun did it too lol
xiao youngeun and dayeon are such all-rounders
BIG YES
KIM DAYEON... from underrated to POPULAR... HUHU WELL DESERVE K01
??? Dayeon was never underrated
Wdym
DAYEON FIGHTING !! 🥺💗
Youngeun all-rounder 🤍🤍🌟
Bahiyyih literally the most underrated vocalist, wakeone better give all of them a fair line distribution.
They didn't
This aged like spoiled milk
LMAOOOOOOOO hello from the future, WakeOne hates her and she’s assigned adlib duty for 2.5 years.
the way youngeun says "I'll kiss you good bye" is soooooo satisfying. it sounds better than the original version with rose and jenni imo. idk if its cuz her voice is so clear or what but it makes my skin shiver with how good it is.
Good technique
@@ubergamer2010 agreeeee she has excellent technique I really love her voice
In what second??
I know it's good and her vocals are amazing (I know it) but you didn't have to bring up Rosé and Jennie into this You should've just said her vocals are great and not compare them
@@alicekim0316 Ya always finding something to be offended about. I said what I said
i hope bahiyyih has more lines so she can show off the talent that everyone says she has and that i've never seen
i love 13:22 - 13:44, it went by so smooth
The effort yo make this, So good! Good job
Thank you so much !
Youngeun - 177.3s
Dayeon - 132.8s
Chaehyun - 132.1s
Yujin - 127.2s
Xiaoting - 116.5s
Mashiro - 112.9s
Yeseo - 106.2s
Hikaru - 95.5s
Bahiyyih - 76.8s
episodes were basically movie length, there is no good reason that Hikaru and Hiyyih have less than 100 sec all together throughout 12 episodes.
I think it’s understandable, each member of each sub group decided the positions for every performance, unfortunately they always were in groups with members better at singing rapping or dancing
Actually it was 2hrs long episode 😭😭
@@reekmisa That makes it even worse
They often chose either groups focused on dance or big groups, so it's logical if you really think about it. Bahiyyih also advertised herself as a dancer (she really should've gone for vocals in my opinion, but as an untrained dancer, she's actually pretty decent according to professional dancers) while Hikaru preferred rapping, which means less lines unfortunately.
there were literally 99 trainees and throughout the majority of the show more than 30 people at once
Youngeun:
the most talentend=the most lines
To be fair we can’t really compare cause some of them were in 3 groups some solo while others 9 and so on and also another thing is the girls voted for each parts every time they practice for a new mission so line distribution can’t really be fair if 1. The girls didn’t try out for a specific line or 2. The girls didn’t get voted for the line they want
youngeun really the best i love her
honestly how are you supposed to support and vote for someone to become an idol with only a minute of them singing throughout the entire show. mnet did bahiyyih very wrong. she wasn't showcased properly, neither were anyone else who didn't at least get 2 minutes... maybe if they had less participants more girls would have more time to be able to show their talents...
Ironically, I feel like the hate train and lack of screentime actually benefited her in a sense that it gave her what I call "The Blackpink Effect." When you starve a fanbase by only feeding them crumbs, eventually like birds they're going to come back for more and sometimes bring friends who'll bring their friends and so on... I mean, Hiyyihlights were dedicated in a way that I've only seen in a from fanbases like ARMYs or something.
Plus, I feel like when you're an outsider and see all this stuff over every social media platform about how horrible such and such contestant is, but you go to her fancam and see her actually be decent, if not good or great, it's easy to see her as an underdog and grow attached. So Mnet kinda gave her an unintentional underdog arc too lmao 🤣
the members who performed pick their own line or the members have the privilege to vote who will sang a part of the song. The show has nothing to do with the line distribution.
@@pinkkryboard157 I'm not really specifically speaking about line distribution. How about they do more songs in the show in general, rather wasting minutes of show on evil editing or fake cringey drama. I just think the show's structure is the main issue. They focus too much on less important/unfunny things that are supposed to be entertaining, but are usually just very forced and cringe. I think the majority of people who was survival shows are there for the performances, and the girls personalities. However the fake drama and other wastes of times, like the useless judges imo, is the real problem I find in the show. If the premise is for us to choose individual girls to become an idol in a group, why are we seeing so little of the girls performance and other screentime, in exchange for stupid drama and reactions from the judges.
o.o
@Des And? People can be fans of both??? If someone was an ARMY before they started listening to TXT, are they only an ARMY forever and nothing else? Is their status as a fan of TXT never established because they heard about them because they debuted after BTS? If you were a Reveluv, could you never also be a MY?
So proud of Youngeun
Dayeon fighting!! Kep1er fighting!! ❤❤
xiaoting didnt have that many lines yet her few lines made such a big impact lol she still was the main character of the show
have less than 100 sec lines but has the most fancam views, yes that is Huening Bahiyyih and Ezaki Hikaru [love love]
their power ❤🔥
i'm so proud of them, watching this video make me want to cry TwT
all of them have unique voices ! it's gonna be incredible when they will debut !
thank you for this video, it was needed
Thank you for watching this ! I'm so proud of them too, I'm so happy for them !
Bahiyyih consistently has a least lines both in the tournament and after debut.
She could pick her lines in gp999 so there’s no excuse there
@@levitatingstan6526 not really, if two people want the same part it's voted who the best and like all the other produce we know some just pick their friend, like when Dayeon and Caibing wanted to be leader, all the Chinese member chose Caibing, and it's the same for kill part or singing/raping part, so no she can't totally chose
and she's a sweetheart, so she probably take the least wanted part for avoid problem in group (in gp999)
@@fantomeblack6560yes and she also was not confident to try some parts :(
although Hikaru&Hiyyih got the least lines, they still slayed throughout the show. Same goes for the chae,yujin,youngeun,yeseo,xiaoting,mashiro,dayeon
Youngeun Ace
Youngeun deserved these lines😍
bahiyyih and youngeun thooo they're the most relaxed stable vocals, I kinda don't like how greedy(trying hard) some of the members rap or sing but I'll wait for improvements
Someone : Bahiyyih cannot reveal his talents for the whole show
Meanwhile: her parties and time ...
🙂🙂🙂
Don't like another dream beacause of their unfair line distributions.
Can't believe hiyyih only have the "너와 함께" part, does it even a line? feel like it's an adlid
ps. the song is beautiful but when I listen to it I feel sorry for her.
Let's make hiyyih famous! Let's make a name for her!(not only for her but for the entire group)
Hiyyihlights fighting! Kepler fighting! Kepler's fan fighting!
Luckily, Kep1er is re-recording Another Dream! We'll see how she does there.
@@goldyd144 which makes me think hiyyih is definetly getting more lines which is amazing. But also makes me think Hikaru's lines won't improve even after debut.......it's probably gonna be more dance and vocal based considering mnets other groups. I feel so bad because Hikaru is the only full fledged rapper in the group 😔
@@reekmisa True. Luckily, Hikaru's Korean is improving fast! Xiaoting's the one I'm worried about when it comes to lines. Also, Dayeon and Youngeun auditioned as rappers too. Xiaoting can as well. And Yujin! Man, this group really is full of all-rounders now that I think about it!
@@goldyd144 omg true. They are literally so good. And yes xt's korean has been improving but I'm afraid it's not at amazing debut point. She might just sing some adlibs and the " wa da da da " 💀💔
@@goldyd144 well... even in debut song she barely get lines and screentime. In other song she has the least lines too :')) hoping the company would give her better lines and screentime too :")
youngeun social distancing
Watching this hurts me. It shows the other girls as well. 9 in our eyes, but 99 in our eyes 🤧❤
Dayeon a complete ACE!
Can u also do a centre distribution like this
Okay, I'm taking your request into account, it's a long video to make so it won't be released right away, but I'll do it as soon as possible! Thanks!
Wouldn't it not make sense esp on solo perf and the vocal songs (combination mission and another dream)?
Yes it's complicated, for example Yujin in Bubble pop or Chaehyun in My Sea. For Another Dream, Yeseo is for half the song in the center of the stage but it is complicated to define since apart from a few moments nobody moves. i try to do my best!
The fact that all of them except for Bahiyyih got 17 seconds or more from the demo stage means mnet really wanted to eliminate hyuba from the start and use Heuning Kai's name to attract more viewers.
I need a video like this one but with screentime instead of lines, or one of how much time each member spent speaking on camera or at least the little interview like parts(tho that could be a video on its own) or even just about how much time the camera spent focus on them, like only them or close ups shots of them (that could also be a video on its own)
I'm sure the numbers would change, and probably even out between most of the members except for my bahiyyih :c
This is not a request for you to make them, I'm sure these kind of videos take ages to make, so I'm not asking you to make them, I'm just expressing it, but of course you can make them if you like these ideas, I'll definitely watch them
A kind of screen time Distribution but on the entire show? I can try to do it but it's gonna take a long time and i don't know if i'll succeed to finishing it.
Before, I will first make the other requests that I received but you can follow the progress with this link that I update regularly ^^ docs.google.com/document/d/1MrUhqag8PhNTlgqrE0Q3wjO85LdYerC_IFiDG31KjPI/edit?usp=drivesdk
Thank you !
(I hope you understand me and I apologize for my bad English)
Yes, a screen time distribution video on the entire show, I know it would take really long to make, so it's okay if you never do it, but if you do, a big thank you in advance, and maybe it would be easier to make a video per episode and then a final video with the total amount of screentime per member.
I'll be checking the link, thank you c:
Also, you don't need to apologize your english is fine, don't worry, and it is not my first language either
Thank you ^^
it's sad that mnet prevented huenin from singing enough lines to show her talent, it was obvious that they didn't want her to be in the final lineup, whatever all the girls sing beautiful and they will surely shine in kep1er once they debut (and with the correct distribution of lines of course)
I mean lines was from the looks of it decided by the members in the different groups, not mnet...
The lines were decides by the girls not mnet and hiyyih wasn't confident so she doesn't get a lot of lines its her choice tho but in shoot she gained more confidence that's why she got a lot of lines and she shined a lot, confidence is really needed.
@@ningster6144 Exactly, Youngeun was a example of a very confident trainee and was always ambitious which is also why she got a lot of lines during the show. She knew what she wanted and went for it without any hesitation which in those type of scenarios are really good for getting more lines in the end.
@@arstan8092 Not entirely, in part the participants are allowed to decide and participate in the preparation of the presentations but in the same way the production intervenes, it is assumed that the end is perfect the presentation and give a more attractive show to the public but this is not always the case, we only saw small segments,but we do not know what happened behind the scenes, even some participants have said that they received some indications from the staff and then edited them in production to generate controversy. We must also be aware of the constant changes in voting dynamics and the screen time given to each participant, Huenin was not the only victim, kpop groups are for sale, and mnet cares about the korean market, if they consider that a girl is not going to like the koreans it immediately hinders it, Huenin seems like the clearest example to me, but there are many other kids from other survival shows who suffered the same thing.
@@vanessagonzalez1314 I agree there was alot of evil editing (Mostly against chinese trainees, not bahhiyeh), i was never saying anything against that, but we have not had anything leaked about that mnet specifically changed peoples roles when the people was deciding on roles etc. Could she have been unfairly edited, sure. But the lines she got from what we have seen was given by the trainees and not mnet staff. This discussion was only discussion on line distribution, which has been shown pretty well to be the trainees choice. I think the best examples for evil editing are Su Ruiqi, Cai Bing and Fu Yaning. They was the ones truly treated horribly by Mnet directly thanks to the editing. The main mistreatment bahhiyeh got was that she did not get enough screentime, but that could simply be because she was not going for big lines and we do not really know. But the chinese trainess was literally painted as evil, bad people and disrespectful while having consistantly shown to be some of the most if not the most talented people on the show, i did not see a single edit like that of bahhiyeh.
Shine is a cursed song for me.
Wen Zhe got 0 seconds of lines. LIKE HOW is that even allowed...
For me Wen Zhe got 1.2s like Mashiro but it's really not enough..
20:58 y’all hear that 💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀
ano-another dr-reEeEeeammm
😭
It was good 😌
THAT'S SUCH A CREATIVE IDEA!!!
the fact that the very last line of this compilation was a voice crack says a lot about the voters of this show and kpop stans in general only going for visuals and not talent
Great Video :3! Keep going ×.×
Thank You ^^
Yujin in bubble pop-
dayeonnie
this is not fair enough bc in the demo stage some of them where soloist or some where only with one or two more trainees, meanwhile other were with more girls. the same happen in the combination mission. thats way the distribution is very different.
Xiaoting is such an underrated singer😭 im glad they used her talents in gp999 she deserved it
I hope the line distribution in Kepler will be fair, because it's okay during the show the difference between the quantities (they chose their performances)
honestly i expected it to be youngeun bc she was the only one in a 3 member vocal team in the third mission, she even got the center position
mashiro too though
@@jakerubio726 their song had a lot of raps and dancing and she wasnt the center
Kep1er ❤
Te falto una linea de Yeseo en fiesta,cuando hace la parte de Yena
the effort wow
Conclusion: Bahiyyih underrated vocalist
i'm sorry but look at ALL OF THOSE SECONDS MNET CUT OF HIYYIH. daaaaaaaaamn
also thank you for not including the times of non singing parts (I.e. after how you like that for xiaoting)
Bahiyyih :((( issokay if fans continue supporting her the company will eventually feel more pressured to give her more lines (it has happened in other grps b4)
Can't believe Hikaru only has this much screen time but she stands out.
さすがヨンウン
Me expecting Xiaoting to have most maybe bcs she stood out sm lol
ひかるは少ない秒数の中で素晴らしいパフォーマンスを見せた。
海外勢はもっとひかるを評価するべき。
Shen xiaoting
I love this line distribution 🔥 Mnet do it like this in kep1er pls ✊😎
To be honest the main thing which pushed Youngeun to the top was the third performance. I think it was either lucky or genius on her part to choose a vocal position with 3 members in it. This would have given her more screen time as compared to members who were in the 6 people or 9 people groups. She only sang the chorus which was 50% of the song allowing her to boost her screentime. As compared to the Hikaru and Mashiro whose song had slightly less lines and on top of that was evenly distributed.
xiaoting queen
It’s gonna be really interesting to see how the future of Kep1er goes considering they have a lot of members who shine in dance and rap, yet usually Produce groups tend to focus on vocals. I wonder if we’re gonna see more rap from them in the future.
AS EXPECTED OUR ACE YOUNGEUNNIEEEE
I think the official will be like this too hahahah lol
Welll..you are not wrong…
This team got soo many good rapper…even yonggeun are so good at it!!!
theres a reason we call it msnake when talking about bahiyyih
総じて言える。もし仮にボラ様がデビューしてたらえぐい事になってた。
Can you an IZ*ONE version please? of PRODUCE48
I'll probably do it, nevertheless it's a very long video to make and i ain't got much time for editing these days, so i apologize but it'll take a little while ^^
can you do this for my teenage girl? 😍
I miss rapper Xiaoting! Wakeone give her a rap!
hiyyih is so underrated i love her so much
Youngeun desserved the MAIN VOCAL IN KEP1ER
I think that mashiro is from Mafia
This shows
Dayeon has completely changed when I compare her mission from the beginning with that of Ice Cream (SLAYED)
(I hope Bahiyyih will have many lines in the future of Kep1er) :)
yeah, but bahiyyih doesn't even have an advantage (top 3) in every ability (vocal, rap, dance, sp), she is always last in everything except winning in popularity :)
@@ryanramadan367 like kura in izone
what is utopia without bora
idk if yk but in the completion mission it was dayeon singing and you put seconds for hikaru
omg wait im being delusional im so sorry i saw it wrong
I'd love to compare these to Bora's lines-
9:40 the songs more like yujin than yeseo
it's yeseo bc she was in the center
バヒエよく入れたな笑笑
if you want your bias get more line, don't choose them to debut in group. go get them solo don't debut in group especially with 9 members. the program show who can get more lines, it means her quality is higher than others. my bias not young eun, but daeyon and support for yujin, but i respect my bias don't got more lines, it depends on their quality of voice and technic. from snsd eras, group with 9 members will never get everyone happy with the lines, but its depending on voice that could make a song sounds better. toxic fans that tell about lines has been started from their debut and it will make other fandom laught to kep1ian. those fans fill never been satisfied and will always make a noise about part line.
poor bahiyyih :(
Mashiro makin lama makin dikit :(