@@orayang76 I’m grad she quit the show mnet naver show her face and she barely pass that elimination she wouldn’t pass next round anyway why she has to waste her time and her health for this shit show. At least she don’t have to stand up for 3 hours like those c trainee in the last episode
Kotone didn't have any screen time, even at that episode they just evil-edited Liang Q/Jiao instead of showing them writing their lyrics. But, Kotone is a queen. Despite having like 0 screen time, she MADE herself more popular after that and immediately became one of my fav contestants there.
@@eggceptionalskz4021 Haha she was in Boombayah demo stage but that was more Hikaru focused (and Shana too). And her hair always on her face during that stage didn't help at all
@@y.ello._.w correct me if I’m wrong, but I think it’s because her group has absolutely no ties to Korea or mnet. Her group is also in the AKB48 umbrella of groups, which is arguably a far larger corporation than mnet, so she is very well protected
@@y.ello._.w yea she is in snh48, theyre pretty big in chinese so i dont think shes very scared. plus shes chinese, mainland chinese people aint afraid to voice their opinions
I just love how unfiltered and straight forward Chinese trainees are. They are really brave to expose mnet like that😂 well deserve after they treat them unfairly and special mention to Kotone diss rap it will reamin iconic well done Kotone you did great❤ one of the best rapper in gp 999❤❤❤
@@sskxsiwan8872 it's in the first couple seconds of the video: "Blackpink Lisa broke 2 Guinness world records for "Lalisa". What about this loser from gp999 hahaha"
And blackpink stans still say their fandom isnt toxic... Dont exclude your toxic fans blinks, everytime your fellow fans become toxic, yall say they are not part of your fandom. They are, and its your job as non toxic stans to educate them, or call them out on their bullshit.
@@teea8376 its so pathetic, doah won the auditions to participate on GP999 that was her own doing with her own talents, this blonk loser has done nothing for their life and are living based on someone's else achievements
@@Ico_ it's because of the vote system tho mnet don't rigged it,they changed the vote system to one pick vote so yaehh but yaeh mnet does alot of evil editing or less screentime to the trainee
@@Ico_ it's because they put the first rank as a second choice when they want to vote for the ratio kcj gp but at the final they focus on their first pick, that's why the rank went down
@@Ico_ They didn't rig it for once. The only "rigging" mnet did was evil editing and screentime to ensure at least some of the girls they wanted to debut would debut. 1st dropped to 9th because everyone thought Xiaoting was safe. Once the interim votes showed her in 16th place, people voted for her like crazy so she'd debut (thank god).
I didn't like the show, the worst show i have ever watched. They have many talented girls, but unprofessional organizer. The show is build on racism, xenophobic and unprofessionalism. We can see that, so imagine what worst is happening being the scenes! Because of Mnet, people are taking their anger toward the poor girls, who have nothing to do with it.
The fact that they segregate the contestants by their nationality, seems sus. Like if they want to show unity, they make it like pd48 where in it shows unity and it shows more on their talents instead of nationality. That's why it sucks.
@@youareblessed6753 the show look like it had lots of favorism and mistreatment just bcs of the girls nationality. lots of the c girls are being mistreat and evil edited while the k girls was made to look like the group savior. during demo stage, the good songs are given to the k girls while the c girls were given the worst song and the song was out of their range. if u can see, the gave some of the judges and contestants (yujin) songs to the c girls making their performance look more worst since they're being compared to the original and the song itself was not their range. the j girls was ignored most of the time, they were barely given screen time aside from a few. and some c girls also said that only 2-3 of the staff was nice to them and they weren't given any dictionary or any translators during the process making the k and c girls having lots of miscommunication and the c girls getting easier to be evil edit. in the end, the c girls got a lot of mistreatment during the show just bcs if their nationality. well that's kinda sums it up. sorry if there's any mistake
Poor Xu Ziyin. She just got so stressed talking about gp999. When she got out , I knew something weird happened, because she was so stressed that episode
It’s because there aren’t any immediate ramifications for them, they aren’t debuting and I’m guessing they have no immediate plans to enter the Korean entertainment industry in the near future, hence its fine
Expose mnet but join mnet program and getting hope for debut from mnet show????mnet evil editing is arround the world,who's didnt know??yet still so many trainee/foreign come to mnet show??sorry for my bad english
The fact that Mnet chose to evil edit Liang Jiao instead of showing how Kotone wrote her own rap lyrics in a language that wasn't her mother tongue? Damn msnake
wow i just now realized that mnet give C-group the songs where the original artist are there (twinkle, siren, helicopter) and the girls just realized that on that very same day they performing? poor girls TT
Even after getting out, a lot of them seem hesitant to talk much about the show other than just "hehe im back". I'm sure there is a restriction on what they can and cannot say but i feel like its shady
i believe in their contract they signed an NDA :( plus its mnet which is literally a huge company, so speaking out against them would prob run ur chances of success
only people who don't want to be an idol in Korea could maybe talk shit about mnet, but chiayi for example cant because it'll cause trouble for her team. Also they definitely have a contract like ziyin said
I mean thanks to the c group, this is the first time we know whats behind the show even tho this is not all, Cuz we probably only hear rumors but nothing from the trainees on a past survival program
I mean I bet you some shady stuff went on with produce. But because korean and Japanese people are more timid than Chinese people, they didn't speak up.
6:51 No, it's not true. Someone asked Su Ruiqi to sing her own song which is "摘星", you can hear that she spoke the song's name after singing helicopter (7:11). So she was actually explaining that she didn't really remember the lyrics of her song "摘星" because she didn't listen to it that much. So it's not related to helicopter. 🙈
@@nodwragon8935 what happened was during ruiqi's live, a lot of people were asking her to sing songs (even songs that she didnt perform, like uml and shoot) and someone asked her to do helicopter :)
Wait so mnet chose the songs for them to do on the demo stage...? So they could just give you something you're totally not good at and you just had to look like you sucked even if you were good at a different style?
Yes. If u watch ep1-2. They give better song to K Group, then J group, the worst is C Group, mostly not suit their vocal range or strength. Those song all related to mentors or seniors song, in order to create some drama.
XiaYan, Liang, XuZiyin and other C Group girls said the same thing. They can't chose the song they likes and suitable their vocal range, style. Mnet even control their hairstyle and colour of hair.
Yes and mnet also chooses the sequence of performance. If u saw xu ziyin's live 9:00 she said they had to film with 30hrs+ of no sleep and 12hrs of starvation so those that performed earlier had more advantage than those who performed later and were more lethargic. Btw xu zi yin performed 2nd last which may be why she didnt perform well.
Ma Yuling said that she was put into Twinkle for the audition, a vocal song, even tho she listed her best position as dance. Want Yale basically taught her how to sing well enough to perform the song a few days before
what uhm what i have watched her since that drama with arin from oh my girl and some fanatics performances, but i never thought she was that young and even younger than me what. actual woah thanks for letting us know omg
Kpop trainees nowadays are very young, even 11 or 12 years old kid can be trained to be idols. They even have survival shows for kids now (the show of MBC i don't remember the name) I think because of that they mature very early
In case you didn't realize, the whole training system in korea has always been like this except the drama. I think aside from K-trainees having less drama, C-trainees is not as exposed to the culture like when they used the "age card" and such that's why they are easier target for editing. Meanwhile, J trainees are usually shy because of the impressions from the previous survival show that makes them almost invisible in the show.
Yes ofc different cultures might affect the editing outcome. From my experience (I went to high school & university that majority of my classmates are South Korean, Chinese and Japanese), my South Korean friends (age 15-24 through this period) in general are individualist, but they do have the the strict hierarchy about age and all, also some of them might have strong opinion, but most of them would choose not to speak it out in front of everyone right away (happened in the show a few times ). On the other hand, Chinese people (around my age) in general are pretty individualist too (my professor conducted a study on this, basically bc of the one child policy etc), they tend to have strong opinions AND have no problem saying it out loud and some people (like me lol) would feel somewhat intimidated sometimes. This is also why there's a lot of drama on the C-trainees. Lastly, from my observation, my Japanese friends are the most 'conservative'. They can be fun and all but they're like the quiet kid that just do their thing and won't bother anyone else (in comparison to my two other group of friends) . I rarely see them strongly say their opinion out loud to anyone. They prefer to talk it out calmly if they think it was too problematic. I was also told once by my friend that being loud make an impression that we're rude to them sometimes. Anyway, ofc there are different types of people in different places, not here to stereotyping, but watching the show I can't help but feel like it's so fascinating how much culture can shape the people.
@@sunshineinthesky2532 I'm learning Japanese and what you said is true that Japanese are usually quiet and more reserve. I think that's why I can pretty much be friends with Japanese. I had Chinese and Korean classmates to but due to awkwardness and cultural differences it's hard for me to be friends with them.
Fun fact: Doah was the main rapper for Rollin Rollin back in Produce 48! So no, she's definitely not a loser, the way GP999 was arranged just screwed her over. It's not her or any of the contestants fault the show and its system was so messed up.
my bias was kim doah and daMN her ENGLISH was so iconic why hasn't she debuted yet??? she's such an asset to have w her english skills since kpop girl groups are tryna go global and stuffs
aint fanatics the one gg that got harassed by the staff? that’s why rayeon looked so familiar. if i remember correctly, someone got slapped. i hoped the girls get better treatment
@@concerneddog4786 yeah, I didn’t know that the manager was hitting the members until yt recommended a video about it! no one’s talking about the incident at all… I feel very sorry for the group :( doah is such a gem, I truly hope her and her fellow group mates can escape that company
I guess when you're trained in Korea as a kpop trainee, in one way or another, idols are trained to subconsciously "fear the system". They're afraid of doing this, eating that, saying this, being at a certain place, going out with another idol, make friends with the opposite gender, etc. For non-korean trainees that train outside of Korea, the culture will vary. So to see them open and honest, you can roughly tell that where they come from, it's ok to be open and honest and it's not a stigma to them. If it's just 1 or 2, then we can maybe say it's just their personalities. But if most, or all of them are open and honest, then it becomes more obvious its a industry culture thing.
By choosing the songs for the preliminaries - which either showcased the participants' talents or became a stumbling block - MNET basically had indirect influence over how the initial votes would turn out. If they can show you struggling, then the chances of people voting for you can be reduced. Also, MNET basically took all the screentime meant for J-trainees, and used it to attack C-line so they can keep most of the K-line in the debut lineup. It's all over the entire series: Angel edits - K line Evil edits - C line Leftovers - J line
The Doah 1, that blonk is so rude wth!!! Ziyin's reply at the end is so witty AHAHAH 'I learn that one can sing after 30 hours of no sleep with 12 hours of hunger & thirst'
Wth would you watched someone's live just to dissed them. Doah did handle that hate comment perfectly. And lmao I admire how the C group keeps on spilling tea about the show. Though its still limited cuz they might get sued idk. MNET did them dirty. Plus that Kotone dissing MNET will forever be iconic lol.🤷♀️
Omg not sleep for 30 hours and not eat nor drink for 12hours?? That's worse.. It can lower their imune system. I barely felt like alive after not sleep for 24 hrs (my heart beating so fast too) so imagine her😢
The Su Ruiqi bit is completely wrong. She's literally talking about her own song "Zhai xin" that she never got to hear much after it was released. Has nothing to do with helicopter lmao
Well some of the c groups said that out of all the staffs, only 2 or 3 staffs that are really nice to them, the c groups. All of the others are basically treat them bad and i wonder if what happend to Ziyin was because of that. I mean, i know that especially that 1st demo stage, it would take more than 15 hours to get everything finished recording. But its so bad that they cant even get a meal in between like BRUHH
Su Ruiqi said that "I didn't hear this song many times" was actually referring to another Chinese song "摘星", which was also shown in the subtitles before.
mnet used chinese trainees to build up drama for the show's ratings, and I fcking hate them for that. C-group deserves more. They even know mnet evil edited them, now I know why c-group care for each other that much, 'coz they know that they only have each other if things go unexpected.
Just want to say this is also evil editing. I am not a fan of Ruiqi but as others have pointed out in the comments, Ruiqi did not say that she forgot the lyrics of Helicopter. She said she forgot the lyrics of a different song. There is no misunderstanding or misinterpretation by the interpreter here. The interpreter simply did not interpret the name of a Chinese song which she clearly said the name after singing Helicopter. The whole portion where Ruiqi sang part of this Chinese song was simply cut off from your edit. If you do not understand Chinese, please do not do such edits that combine the interpreter's interpretation out of context. Please at least fix this in your description if you are not going to re-edit your uploaded video to fix this error.
Even master Tiffany said she gave lots of advices but only a few was aired, idk why mnet always love to do things in the hardest possible way, is it so hard to be normal and kind in life?
@7:11 Su Ruiqi was reading a comment that was requesting her to sing her solo song "Seize the Light". So she meant she forgot the lyrics to her own song due to not being able to hear it many times after it was released (since she joined g999 soon after)
i'm confused. Ruiqi's one has nothing to do with "the truth of Girls Planet 999" tho? she just forgetting lyrics, she even forgetting her own song lyrics LOL 07:11 she said 摘星(seize the light), that's her own song, later she said"我忘記歌詞了" "i forgot the lyrics" in chinese she covered few clc songs way before the show, hobgoblin and no oh oh.
@@sxuvr2973 that she better be purely Korean as nationality next time she appears in a Korean tv show because they received a lot of mistreatment and evil edit just because they were chinese
@@sxuvr2973 KTV means karaoke in Chinese, and Purely K is one of the biggest Karaoke bands in China, but in this matter she was mentioning how she will go as purely Korean, as if that’s how you win survival shows.
@@sowhat1674 The fact that people fall for the editing just baffles me, like at this point any scenario that seems tense or evil should just be considered an evil edit, it's Mnet we are talking about lol. I heard when Cai Bing saw the episodes she was like "Oh so that's what the other trainees said", meaning the translation what they were given on the spot was just pure garbage 🤡
@@sowhat1674 It's honestly been so obvious that a lot of stuff has been mistranslated, a lot of "conversations" didn't really add up with the reactions. Wish people could just see behind Mnet's editing. It's so sad for the girls like, they didn't even debut and some went off the show with a worse reputation which was completely manipulated.
@@mariaf.7244 I mean just because it happened in season 2 doesn't mean it's still okay lol. No drinking and eating when you need to practice or perform is just unacceptable.
The rude comment to Kim Doah. He/she is comparing her to lalisa, why not comparing her to him/her? She can sing, dance, have fans, and brave to go to this shows. He/she is unknown, talent-less, behind the screen troll. Easy to judge others, even if they were better than you!
I honestly don't get why they couldn't chose their song for the demo stage, like, at least let them do that. That's why some of those stages were a little off because it wasn't a song they fell comfortable with... ugh I'm lowkey pissed
well….y’all should watch youth with you 2 if you want an actual wholesome produce show 😭 I expect nothing better from mnet even with their other shows like SMTM
YES. I loved all the YWY seasons. They really know how to give fair screentime, encourage friendship, and show wholesome storylines. I rooted for and loved every single trainee from beginning to end. Unlike the weird and uncomfortable tension in all of Mnet's shows. Chinese licensed Produce 101 even suffers from this
The fact that its already exposed that their first stage was selected by mnet, c trainees were evile edited and mistranslated but still some mnets loyal children especially yujin stans are still throwing hate on yaning' we go up thing and getting 1000 of likes. They should be grateful that yaning made your fav and the show relevant.
I really don't understand how kpop stans/fandoms work. There are a lot of them that are really toxic, just like some yujin stans that you mentioned. Donno why they hate yaning so much but yujin loves yaning and is very close friends with yaning (as can be seen on gp999 as well). So I really don't understand how they can hate yaning even if their stan (yujin) loves her, isn't that like going against your stan? Man I'm so confused 😕😕
that yujin yaning situation was in august and yet ppl are still talking about it? are they closeminded or what literally mnet do t for the promotion of the show (bad publicity is still publicity) and mnet did great with that. funny those haters think it is not scripted T^T
Although many Group C players have been warned by MNET and even threatened to sue But if they don't say it, a push of idiots has no idea how bad MNET treats them
ziyin haven’t slept for 30h and haven’t eaten for 12h before performing siren?? wtf was it like that with everybody? that’s why the first performances were so different from ywy2, they all were probably in bad conditions and did their worse. this is unbelievable
It's the entertainment industry. It's not all butterflies and rainbows. It's a tough world in that business. You can be very talented but still have little fans. Thats just how it is.
At this rate, I wish Mnet faces legal consequences for messing with the contestants' representation on screen. Indirect manipulation of votes is still manipulation. However, I fear it may be difficult because the contestants belong to countries that operate under different legal systems. It'd be hard to prosecute for discrimination when they're not legally protected under Korean law.
Now here's the thing: there are professions where staying up with no sleep for a certain time can be justified and even important, like something that's essential to humanity, say nurses and doctors. I also imagine it's expected for soldiers on duty to be able to forego sleep for a while. Even so I think these should be super-well paid jobs. Foregoing food and sleep for days when you're a teen pretty much, heck even a young adult should not be normalized and I don't know what the fuck is wrong with this entire world for praising things like this. Especially not for an entertainment program. Let alone it not being healthy for these girls who are only mnet's cash cows at this point, but it also sends many disturbing messages to kids and young adults that they, too, should die to achieve their dreams. Noone should ever make you think you need to die to live.
Some agency needs to sign Kotone, she's too good not to debut. I also hope the final group doesn't get any hate for Mnet's bad behavior. The girls themselves didn't do anything wrong.
there have been rumors (actually not rumors, but spoilers from ceo of 143 ent, home to mashiro and yeseo) that kotone, manami, and ruan might be scouted by 143.
I haven't watched gp999. I don't know who is who?. But few days back i accidentally saw medusa performance. A long girl with a unique snakelike hairstyle caught my attention instantly. It was not just bcoz of hairstyle but also bcoz of her voice and her beauty and stage presence. So powerful. I didn know her name. I left it like that. Ignored it. Then accidentally this video came up. I watched it without much interest. Then a girl who sang helicopter caught my attention. I instantly liked her voice n face n attitude. Then i got to know that she is the same girl from the medusa performance. I just came to know of her name. Su ruiqi. My god. Its a loss. By losing her we lost. She has got some talent. Now i just hope she debut at some other company. She is unique. I don't know by what standard they are judging. Defenitely not by the standard of talent for music. She has got a beautiful voice, stage presence amazing, rapping top-notch, attitude the best.
No food for 12 hours? To wait for all those contestants to finish their demo?🤨🤨 I know the shoots are long, but damn, can they not let them eat or something while waiting. That's torture
I hope people understand mnet was never fair especially because of them having a history of manipulating votes,editing,contestants and categories + songs in their shows especially because someone spoke out against mnet saying in their survival shows on the first stage ever infront of the judges no water would be offered to the contestants even when asked for so they had no choice but to practice before going on stage and have to sing with a dry throat which is obviously gonna be showing that the person sucks at singing but they don't it's just mnet was being bad with the contestants.
suruiqi said she forget her song sezie the light. she didn't say helicoper. the translater did not translate the whole words. so there are some misunderstanding
![[Girls Planet 999] Is Cai Bing evil edited in Ep7?](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/xJHlIDXXCyg/mqdefault.jpg)
![[Girls Planet 999] Is Cai Bing evil edited in Ep7?](/img/tr.png)
kotone's diss rap will always remain iconic she dissed mnet on a mnet show
along with GD's diss on a mnet ceremony
Pentagon member Kino did it on Road to Kingdom too…I love that energy.
@@cindih78 what did he say?
@@cindih78 yea i want to know too
they did that on produce 101 too. i was surprised they even let them?
Xu Ziyin: "This is really a show that... challenges our human limits"
Sounds like Hunger games...
Mnet just trying to recreate Squid Game in the most legal looking way
She gave up and ran away Prolly her limit was lower than others
That sounds really scary...
@@orayang76 I’m grad she quit the show mnet naver show her face and she barely pass that elimination she wouldn’t pass next round anyway why she has to waste her time and her health for this shit show. At least she don’t have to stand up for 3 hours like those c trainee in the last episode
Kotone didn't have any screen time, even at that episode they just evil-edited Liang Q/Jiao instead of showing them writing their lyrics. But, Kotone is a queen. Despite having like 0 screen time, she MADE herself more popular after that and immediately became one of my fav contestants there.
fr its just sad that the possible actual main rapper is eliminated ;(
Kotone's 1 of my picks. But I liked her since pretty U. I really like her rap and how deep her voice is.
@@lornacabria7969 her "so ice ice baby" was sooo good😻
@@lornacabria7969 same! ive actually been obsessed with her so ice ice baby but i dont know her bcs of lack of screen time TT
@@eggceptionalskz4021 Haha she was in Boombayah demo stage but that was more Hikaru focused (and Shana too). And her hair always on her face during that stage didn't help at all
Kim Doah's "I don't really care is iconic"
her english pretty clear and good
When I saw the chat, i thought 'is this someone from xxx fandom?' & sadly I was right
can doah speak english? im curious to know 🥰
@@maaduufan5140 What is xxx fandom?
@@maribong3113 There's no context. That person was just being toxic for no reason
respect for liang qiao's bravery girlie really said out loud how mnet evil edited her lmao
She be like: "No I don't take any sue or lawsuit shits let's spill the teas"
She is from SNH48 she is untouchable
@@Ramses060784 can u tell me why she is untouchable? is it because shes in another country?
@@y.ello._.w correct me if I’m wrong, but I think it’s because her group has absolutely no ties to Korea or mnet. Her group is also in the AKB48 umbrella of groups, which is arguably a far larger corporation than mnet, so she is very well protected
@@y.ello._.w yea she is in snh48, theyre pretty big in chinese so i dont think shes very scared. plus shes chinese, mainland chinese people aint afraid to voice their opinions
I just love how unfiltered and straight forward Chinese trainees are. They are really brave to expose mnet like that😂 well deserve after they treat them unfairly and special mention to Kotone diss rap it will reamin iconic well done Kotone you did great❤ one of the best rapper in gp 999❤❤❤
Because china can back them uo
they bag up money from china meanwhile if u’re ktrainee that still want to debut it’s gonna be hard path if u mess up with cj ent
Until they speak against china, then you banned
I wish the uploader put yanings clips about how mnet made her say those words to yujin and the evil editing/cutting
“Guys just ignore that chat, i don’t really care” 👑
What did the chat say tho
@@sskxsiwan8872 it's in the first couple seconds of the video:
"Blackpink Lisa broke 2 Guinness world records for "Lalisa". What about this loser from gp999 hahaha"
@@teea8376 oh thank i didnt see it
And blackpink stans still say their fandom isnt toxic... Dont exclude your toxic fans blinks, everytime your fellow fans become toxic, yall say they are not part of your fandom. They are, and its your job as non toxic stans to educate them, or call them out on their bullshit.
@@teea8376 its so pathetic, doah won the auditions to participate on GP999 that was her own doing with her own talents, this blonk loser has done nothing for their life and are living based on someone's else achievements
Qiao also literally said “I’ll tell you more after they release the hostage” AND SHE MEANT HER SISTER 💀
the way mnet making such a strick rules, making me think that something suspicious happened back there
Have you seen the way the ranks of some contestant went super low on the final episode.. Like come on now. First that drops to 9... yeah sure.
@@Ico_ that was because they change the rules of the last day of voting to benefit Koreans voters even more, the disrespect is real
@@Ico_ it's because of the vote system tho mnet don't rigged it,they changed the vote system to one pick vote so yaehh but yaeh mnet does alot of evil editing or less screentime to the trainee
@@Ico_ it's because they put the first rank as a second choice when they want to vote for the ratio kcj gp but at the final they focus on their first pick, that's why the rank went down
@@Ico_ They didn't rig it for once. The only "rigging" mnet did was evil editing and screentime to ensure at least some of the girls they wanted to debut would debut. 1st dropped to 9th because everyone thought Xiaoting was safe. Once the interim votes showed her in 16th place, people voted for her like crazy so she'd debut (thank god).
I didn't like the show, the worst show i have ever watched. They have many talented girls, but unprofessional organizer. The show is build on racism, xenophobic and unprofessionalism. We can see that, so imagine what worst is happening being the scenes! Because of Mnet, people are taking their anger toward the poor girls, who have nothing to do with it.
TRUE!!!!
Agreed. It's a shame.
What do u mean by that
The fact that they segregate the contestants by their nationality, seems sus. Like if they want to show unity, they make it like pd48 where in it shows unity and it shows more on their talents instead of nationality. That's why it sucks.
@@youareblessed6753 the show look like it had lots of favorism and mistreatment just bcs of the girls nationality. lots of the c girls are being mistreat and evil edited while the k girls was made to look like the group savior. during demo stage, the good songs are given to the k girls while the c girls were given the worst song and the song was out of their range. if u can see, the gave some of the judges and contestants (yujin) songs to the c girls making their performance look more worst since they're being compared to the original and the song itself was not their range. the j girls was ignored most of the time, they were barely given screen time aside from a few. and some c girls also said that only 2-3 of the staff was nice to them and they weren't given any dictionary or any translators during the process making the k and c girls having lots of miscommunication and the c girls getting easier to be evil edit. in the end, the c girls got a lot of mistreatment during the show just bcs if their nationality. well that's kinda sums it up. sorry if there's any mistake
Poor Xu Ziyin. She just got so stressed talking about gp999.
When she got out , I knew something weird happened, because she was so stressed that episode
lmao only Chinese contestants are brave enough to expose Mnet. Yall better not believe Mnet evil editing lmao.
It’s because there aren’t any immediate ramifications for them, they aren’t debuting and I’m guessing they have no immediate plans to enter the Korean entertainment industry in the near future, hence its fine
Expose mnet but join mnet program and getting hope for debut from mnet show????mnet evil editing is arround the world,who's didnt know??yet still so many trainee/foreign come to mnet show??sorry for my bad english
@@erlinar7113 bc they can be more famous from the show
The fact that Mnet chose to evil edit Liang Jiao instead of showing how Kotone wrote her own rap lyrics in a language that wasn't her mother tongue? Damn msnake
wow i just now realized that mnet give C-group the songs where the original artist are there (twinkle, siren, helicopter) and the girls just realized that on that very same day they performing? poor girls TT
Even after getting out, a lot of them seem hesitant to talk much about the show other than just "hehe im back". I'm sure there is a restriction on what they can and cannot say but i feel like its shady
i believe in their contract they signed an NDA :( plus its mnet which is literally a huge company, so speaking out against them would prob run ur chances of success
Yeah, Ziyin said if they said anything about the programme, Msnake will send them a letter from their lawyers
only people who don't want to be an idol in Korea could maybe talk shit about mnet, but chiayi for example cant because it'll cause trouble for her team. Also they definitely have a contract like ziyin said
I mean thanks to the c group, this is the first time we know whats behind the show even tho this is not all, Cuz we probably only hear rumors but nothing from the trainees on a past survival program
I mean I bet you some shady stuff went on with produce. But because korean and Japanese people are more timid than Chinese people, they didn't speak up.
Plot Twist: SRQ was paid to say “Mnet is the best” when they had a sports challenge with the other groups and C group won
LMAOO when she said that i was like "ruiqi did you get paid to say ?" HAHAHAHA
Lol sury did not said that msnake just translated Ment is the best.
@@wynnnai5628 omfg that’s so mnetty 😂
the fact that she didnt even say mnet is the best, she said "as expected from mnet" but they mistranslated it.
"as expected of mnet" could actually have more than 1 meaning. But mnet was desperate to beautify themselves
6:51 No, it's not true. Someone asked Su Ruiqi to sing her own song which is "摘星", you can hear that she spoke the song's name after singing helicopter (7:11). So she was actually explaining that she didn't really remember the lyrics of her song "摘星" because she didn't listen to it that much. So it's not related to helicopter. 🙈
And I don't understand the context in this video, because Su Ruiqi performed Snapping on the show and not Helicopter.
Really makes me question the authenticity of these translations then👀
@@nodwragon8935 Yeah.. I think it's fine even if Su Ruiqi really didn't remember the lyrics of helicopter🤣🤣🤣
@@zzyz7751 ooh do you mean the translations in this video?
@@nodwragon8935 what happened was during ruiqi's live, a lot of people were asking her to sing songs (even songs that she didnt perform, like uml and shoot) and someone asked her to do helicopter :)
I just hope that Mnet's main victims Yaning and Caibing (aka best friends) will spill some tea about their situation one day.
Wait so mnet chose the songs for them to do on the demo stage...? So they could just give you something you're totally not good at and you just had to look like you sucked even if you were good at a different style?
Yes. If u watch ep1-2. They give better song to K Group, then J group, the worst is C Group, mostly not suit their vocal range or strength. Those song all related to mentors or seniors song, in order to create some drama.
XiaYan, Liang, XuZiyin and other C Group girls said the same thing. They can't chose the song they likes and suitable their vocal range, style. Mnet even control their hairstyle and colour of hair.
Yes and mnet also chooses the sequence of performance. If u saw xu ziyin's live 9:00 she said they had to film with 30hrs+ of no sleep and 12hrs of starvation so those that performed earlier had more advantage than those who performed later and were more lethargic.
Btw xu zi yin performed 2nd last which may be why she didnt perform well.
Ma Yuling said that she was put into Twinkle for the audition, a vocal song, even tho she listed her best position as dance. Want Yale basically taught her how to sing well enough to perform the song a few days before
@@Evelyn-oy4ue ahn jeong min was also ex sm member. And also just looking at the helicopter performance was enough to tell that it was staged.
BUT I CANT STILL BELIEVE DOAH'S JUST 17 SHE SEEMS REALLY MATURE
what uhm what i have watched her since that drama with arin from oh my girl and some fanatics performances, but i never thought she was that young and even younger than me what. actual woah thanks for letting us know omg
@@victoriawise550 i really want her in I-land
@@victoriawise550 she was born on 2003 😭
Kpop trainees nowadays are very young, even 11 or 12 years old kid can be trained to be idols. They even have survival shows for kids now (the show of MBC i don't remember the name) I think because of that they mature very early
17...what?!
In case you didn't realize, the whole training system in korea has always been like this except the drama. I think aside from K-trainees having less drama, C-trainees is not as exposed to the culture like when they used the "age card" and such that's why they are easier target for editing. Meanwhile, J trainees are usually shy because of the impressions from the previous survival show that makes them almost invisible in the show.
Did you get paid by Mnet? How much to change your words? Mnet never change since produce series. So this is NOT new to us.
@@MA-pb5bc 🤫
Yes ofc different cultures might affect the editing outcome. From my experience (I went to high school & university that majority of my classmates are South Korean, Chinese and Japanese), my South Korean friends (age 15-24 through this period) in general are individualist, but they do have the the strict hierarchy about age and all, also some of them might have strong opinion, but most of them would choose not to speak it out in front of everyone right away (happened in the show a few times ). On the other hand, Chinese people (around my age) in general are pretty individualist too (my professor conducted a study on this, basically bc of the one child policy etc), they tend to have strong opinions AND have no problem saying it out loud and some people (like me lol) would feel somewhat intimidated sometimes. This is also why there's a lot of drama on the C-trainees. Lastly, from my observation, my Japanese friends are the most 'conservative'. They can be fun and all but they're like the quiet kid that just do their thing and won't bother anyone else (in comparison to my two other group of friends) . I rarely see them strongly say their opinion out loud to anyone. They prefer to talk it out calmly if they think it was too problematic. I was also told once by my friend that being loud make an impression that we're rude to them sometimes.
Anyway, ofc there are different types of people in different places, not here to stereotyping, but watching the show I can't help but feel like it's so fascinating how much culture can shape the people.
@@sunshineinthesky2532 I'm learning Japanese and what you said is true that Japanese are usually quiet and more reserve. I think that's why I can pretty much be friends with Japanese. I had Chinese and Korean classmates to but due to awkwardness and cultural differences it's hard for me to be friends with them.
I hope by that you mean the entire training system is toxic af??
Fun fact: Doah was the main rapper for Rollin Rollin back in Produce 48! So no, she's definitely not a loser, the way GP999 was arranged just screwed her over. It's not her or any of the contestants fault the show and its system was so messed up.
my bias was kim doah and daMN her ENGLISH was so iconic why hasn't she debuted yet??? she's such an asset to have w her english skills since kpop girl groups are tryna go global and stuffs
she debuted in a group called fanatics
She debuted in a group called fanatics
She already debuted after being on Produce48! She came on GP999 with her members Chiayi and Rayeon to bring recognition to Fanatics
aint fanatics the one gg that got harassed by the staff? that’s why rayeon looked so familiar. if i remember correctly, someone got slapped. i hoped the girls get better treatment
@@concerneddog4786 yeah, I didn’t know that the manager was hitting the members until yt recommended a video about it! no one’s talking about the incident at all… I feel very sorry for the group :( doah is such a gem, I truly hope her and her fellow group mates can escape that company
Chinese trainee are so straight forward and honest
I guess when you're trained in Korea as a kpop trainee, in one way or another, idols are trained to subconsciously "fear the system". They're afraid of doing this, eating that, saying this, being at a certain place, going out with another idol, make friends with the opposite gender, etc. For non-korean trainees that train outside of Korea, the culture will vary. So to see them open and honest, you can roughly tell that where they come from, it's ok to be open and honest and it's not a stigma to them. If it's just 1 or 2, then we can maybe say it's just their personalities. But if most, or all of them are open and honest, then it becomes more obvious its a industry culture thing.
By choosing the songs for the preliminaries - which either showcased the participants' talents or became a stumbling block - MNET basically had indirect influence over how the initial votes would turn out. If they can show you struggling, then the chances of people voting for you can be reduced. Also, MNET basically took all the screentime meant for J-trainees, and used it to attack C-line so they can keep most of the K-line in the debut lineup. It's all over the entire series:
Angel edits - K line
Evil edits - C line
Leftovers - J line
30 hours didn't sleep 12 hours empty stomach??? that's pretty darn inhumane isn't it?
doah is such a queen please ive been stanning since pd48 she deserve a better company
I think the company is good they just don’t have much money
Saaaaammmeee. I'm still salty she got eliminated and didn't get the planet pass dkdosjsnxm.
@@niqueh2828 the company literally a worded them.
The Doah 1, that blonk is so rude wth!!!
Ziyin's reply at the end is so witty AHAHAH 'I learn that one can sing after 30 hours of no sleep with 12 hours of hunger & thirst'
Wth would you watched someone's live just to dissed them. Doah did handle that hate comment perfectly. And lmao I admire how the C group keeps on spilling tea about the show. Though its still limited cuz they might get sued idk. MNET did them dirty. Plus that Kotone dissing MNET will forever be iconic lol.🤷♀️
Once there back in China all Mnet can do is send letters that they cannot enforce
yale looks like she broken out from prison lmao🤣
Omg not sleep for 30 hours and not eat nor drink for 12hours?? That's worse.. It can lower their imune system. I barely felt like alive after not sleep for 24 hrs (my heart beating so fast too) so imagine her😢
The Su Ruiqi bit is completely wrong. She's literally talking about her own song "Zhai xin" that she never got to hear much after it was released. Has nothing to do with helicopter lmao
Well some of the c groups said that out of all the staffs, only 2 or 3 staffs that are really nice to them, the c groups. All of the others are basically treat them bad and i wonder if what happend to Ziyin was because of that. I mean, i know that especially that 1st demo stage, it would take more than 15 hours to get everything finished recording. But its so bad that they cant even get a meal in between like BRUHH
man the chinese rip off of produce always gave the contestants food during the long demo stages. the real mnet shows truly suck in comparison.
@@ahnhyungseobhaveyoulearnth8286 do you mean youth with you 2? not sure if you should call it a chinese rip off version 😅
ola theres i also meant produce camp too hehe
@@ahnhyungseobhaveyoulearnth8286 ohh i see!
Most of these are Chinese trainees exposing😭😭😭. This shows the unfair treatment 😭😭😭❤️💔
Kotone rap diss will be forever iconic😌valid no debat..Imagine diss mnet at mnet survival show..Only kotone can do that🤝
Su Ruiqi said that "I didn't hear this song many times" was actually referring to another Chinese song "摘星", which was also shown in the subtitles before.
the fact that most of the girls are from C Group, they're unfiltered that's why I like them.
Exactly Mnet targeted to c group the most for evil edit.
Notice how most of them are chinese. Bruh, they're built different💀that's why I love them
the way ziyin was talking abt the conditions on survival shows is so awful
Cause MNET didn't treat C-trainees well
Mnet: You’re not allowed to talk about anything regarding the show
C group trainees: say sike
If the Idol School girls were outspoken as planet girls, that would be iconic
Some videos were made tho. The conditions on idol school were the worst, inhumane even.
8:50 xu ziyin saying “wow!” lol seems like yu shuxin’s wow left an impact during qcyn
I am now actually so glad that Xu Ziyin left earlier! She literally had zero screen time despite working so hard! 😩
mnet used chinese trainees to build up drama for the show's ratings, and I fcking hate them for that. C-group deserves more. They even know mnet evil edited them, now I know why c-group care for each other that much, 'coz they know that they only have each other if things go unexpected.
Xu Xiyin was participate in YWY2 she fully know how different they treat to trainnees.
other trainee: we have a limit to talk about gp 999 mnet might send us warning
liangqiao: they evil edited me!!!!!!!
Just want to say this is also evil editing. I am not a fan of Ruiqi but as others have pointed out in the comments, Ruiqi did not say that she forgot the lyrics of Helicopter. She said she forgot the lyrics of a different song. There is no misunderstanding or misinterpretation by the interpreter here. The interpreter simply did not interpret the name of a Chinese song which she clearly said the name after singing Helicopter. The whole portion where Ruiqi sang part of this Chinese song was simply cut off from your edit. If you do not understand Chinese, please do not do such edits that combine the interpreter's interpretation out of context. Please at least fix this in your description if you are not going to re-edit your uploaded video to fix this error.
Even master Tiffany said she gave lots of advices but only a few was aired, idk why mnet always love to do things in the hardest possible way, is it so hard to be normal and kind in life?
I click because Yale is in the thumbnail and I am even happier you used my vid and give credits. Thank you for uploading videos like this! :D
I'm waiting for queen Bing to spill the tea
@7:11 Su Ruiqi was reading a comment that was requesting her to sing her solo song "Seize the Light". So she meant she forgot the lyrics to her own song due to not being able to hear it many times after it was released (since she joined g999 soon after)
i'm confused. Ruiqi's one has nothing to do with "the truth of Girls Planet 999" tho?
she just forgetting lyrics, she even forgetting her own song lyrics LOL
07:11 she said 摘星(seize the light), that's her own song, later she said"我忘記歌詞了" "i forgot the lyrics" in chinese
she covered few clc songs way before the show, hobgoblin and no oh oh.
Wait am I the only who just now knowing that Doah can speak English very well
whooa the first armyblink troll also commented on swan from purple kiss' live and wow they should get sued.
He does that to eg’s vlives as well. It’s small d energy.
I remember Jiao saying “It’s been a while since I went to KTV, guess I’ll go Purely K next time.”
I really didn’t understand what she meant can you explain it to me?
@@sxuvr2973 that she better be purely Korean as nationality next time she appears in a Korean tv show because they received a lot of mistreatment and evil edit just because they were chinese
@@sxuvr2973 KTV means karaoke in Chinese, and Purely K is one of the biggest Karaoke bands in China, but in this matter she was mentioning how she will go as purely Korean, as if that’s how you win survival shows.
No food or drinks for 12h you gotta be kidding me. Hows that even humane...
@@sowhat1674 The fact that people fall for the editing just baffles me, like at this point any scenario that seems tense or evil should just be considered an evil edit, it's Mnet we are talking about lol. I heard when Cai Bing saw the episodes she was like "Oh so that's what the other trainees said", meaning the translation what they were given on the spot was just pure garbage 🤡
@@sowhat1674 It's honestly been so obvious that a lot of stuff has been mistranslated, a lot of "conversations" didn't really add up with the reactions. Wish people could just see behind Mnet's editing. It's so sad for the girls like, they didn't even debut and some went off the show with a worse reputation which was completely manipulated.
Well they did in produce season 2 too. It reminded me of IU saying she didn't drunk or eat nothing for more than six hours sometimes
@@mariaf.7244 I mean just because it happened in season 2 doesn't mean it's still okay lol. No drinking and eating when you need to practice or perform is just unacceptable.
Yale remains me of weightlifting fairy Kim bok joo
The first one- gurl Lisa is known global YES OFC These girls are not so stop comparing to these girls😒
The rude comment to Kim Doah. He/she is comparing her to lalisa, why not comparing her to him/her? She can sing, dance, have fans, and brave to go to this shows. He/she is unknown, talent-less, behind the screen troll. Easy to judge others, even if they were better than you!
I really love Xu Ziyin's voice..it's so smooth deep and her speech is so polished.
i saw a picture of Wang Yale and searched all the gp999 contestants for her becuz i think she is really pretty!!💜
Me too the first time I saw her first releasephoto I immediately fell in love hihi
I honestly don't get why they couldn't chose their song for the demo stage, like, at least let them do that. That's why some of those stages were a little off because it wasn't a song they fell comfortable with... ugh I'm lowkey pissed
Dang Su Ruiqi vocal is pretty good and I'm sure she can rap, too.
I love Su Ruiqi so much. I dont wanna support mnet new debut girlgroup
why does Yale looks like that one person who broke out of prison gosh i love her so much😭😭
Kotone deserves better
well….y’all should watch youth with you 2 if you want an actual wholesome produce show 😭 I expect nothing better from mnet even with their other shows like SMTM
True. I cant help but compare YWY with these korean shows. It sucks. YWY is better in all aspects 😅
YES. I loved all the YWY seasons. They really know how to give fair screentime, encourage friendship, and show wholesome storylines. I rooted for and loved every single trainee from beginning to end. Unlike the weird and uncomfortable tension in all of Mnet's shows. Chinese licensed Produce 101 even suffers from this
Chiayi really said “:) perhaps…” to all the questions haha.
i still cant believe sui rui qi didnt make it-
Kotone diss rap will go down in history, and Ill make sure no one forgets about it.
the c trainees bringing down mnet and i love it
The fact that its already exposed that their first stage was selected by mnet, c trainees were evile edited and mistranslated but still some mnets loyal children especially yujin stans are still throwing hate on yaning' we go up thing and getting 1000 of likes. They should be grateful that yaning made your fav and the show relevant.
I really don't understand how kpop stans/fandoms work. There are a lot of them that are really toxic, just like some yujin stans that you mentioned. Donno why they hate yaning so much but yujin loves yaning and is very close friends with yaning (as can be seen on gp999 as well). So I really don't understand how they can hate yaning even if their stan (yujin) loves her, isn't that like going against your stan? Man I'm so confused 😕😕
that yujin yaning situation was in august and yet ppl are still talking about it? are they closeminded or what literally mnet do t for the promotion of the show (bad publicity is still publicity) and mnet did great with that. funny those haters think it is not scripted T^T
I really wanted Wang Yale and Fu Yaning to make it through. I loved watching what little I saw of them.
liang twins are so fearless i can't 😭
Xu ziyin poor girl 😭
Although many Group C players have been warned by MNET and even threatened to sue
But if they don't say it, a push of idiots has no idea how bad MNET treats them
Doah laughing her ass off with that comment is a mood im shaking
Bro the c group girls don't care about shit they will still diss and expose mnet if they want they are the bravest.
DUDE DOAH IS FLUENT IN ENGLISH HELLO I AM SURPRISED NO ONE TOLD ME THIS😭😭
whoever wrote that to Kin Do Ah I hope u never get to see BTS and BlackPink live
Ziyin: I'm not allowed to say anything.
Liang Qiao: Lawyers? Anyways, evil editing go brrr
I feel like they disrespected a lot of the Chinese contents
"guys just ignore that i dont really care" LMFAOOOOO
I wish all this girls can be very happy, and have a lot of good opportunities. I'm so sorry girls.
ziyin haven’t slept for 30h and haven’t eaten for 12h before performing siren?? wtf was it like that with everybody? that’s why the first performances were so different from ywy2, they all were probably in bad conditions and did their worse. this is unbelievable
It's the entertainment industry. It's not all butterflies and rainbows. It's a tough world in that business. You can be very talented but still have little fans. Thats just how it is.
Umm being mistreated is not okay you're normalizing toxic environment in the Music Industry Its not fine
@@chriswasnotfound6078 i dont particularly like it but I do realize that that's just how it is.
@@chriswasnotfound6078 sweet summer child detected lol
At this rate, I wish Mnet faces legal consequences for messing with the contestants' representation on screen. Indirect manipulation of votes is still manipulation. However, I fear it may be difficult because the contestants belong to countries that operate under different legal systems. It'd be hard to prosecute for discrimination when they're not legally protected under Korean law.
Su Rui Qi look like twin of Jeonghan of Seventeen. Whenever I see her I feel the same .
Same here.. they are literally like twins and almost have the same personality - cheerful and choaitic
Actually also my sister said that to me that he looks like Yoon Jeonghan
RIGHT
BRUH, I always thought her face was kinda familiar especially when she’s in her neutral expression
yooowww i didn't know! Kotones rap meant like that! Omg! Girl!!! 👏👏👏 Well done for saying that to Mnet!
Wow, thank you for the credit! ❤️
shim seungeun was eliminated WAYYYY too early
Do you know what she said??
@@Lily-vw3mx Nope LOL
@@keysea7676 :((( I hope someone can translate it😅😅
yea, she caught my attention a lot
Now here's the thing: there are professions where staying up with no sleep for a certain time can be justified and even important, like something that's essential to humanity, say nurses and doctors. I also imagine it's expected for soldiers on duty to be able to forego sleep for a while.
Even so I think these should be super-well paid jobs. Foregoing food and sleep for days when you're a teen pretty much, heck even a young adult should not be normalized and I don't know what the fuck is wrong with this entire world for praising things like this. Especially not for an entertainment program. Let alone it not being healthy for these girls who are only mnet's cash cows at this point, but it also sends many disturbing messages to kids and young adults that they, too, should die to achieve their dreams. Noone should ever make you think you need to die to live.
C grp best grp. nothing can change my mind.
Agreed
Some agency needs to sign Kotone, she's too good not to debut. I also hope the final group doesn't get any hate for Mnet's bad behavior. The girls themselves didn't do anything wrong.
there have been rumors (actually not rumors, but spoilers from ceo of 143 ent, home to mashiro and yeseo) that kotone, manami, and ruan might be scouted by 143.
@@seungminsforeheadyourarelysee are you sure about it?! It's great 👍👍👍
Kotone will debut in TripleS.
I remember when Lisa little bit upset with xu ziyin at youth with you
I haven't watched gp999. I don't know who is who?. But few days back i accidentally saw medusa performance. A long girl with a unique snakelike hairstyle caught my attention instantly. It was not just bcoz of hairstyle but also bcoz of her voice and her beauty and stage presence. So powerful. I didn know her name. I left it like that. Ignored it. Then accidentally this video came up. I watched it without much interest. Then a girl who sang helicopter caught my attention. I instantly liked her voice n face n attitude. Then i got to know that she is the same girl from the medusa performance. I just came to know of her name. Su ruiqi.
My god. Its a loss. By losing her we lost. She has got some talent. Now i just hope she debut at some other company. She is unique. I don't know by what standard they are judging. Defenitely not by the standard of talent for music.
She has got a beautiful voice, stage presence amazing, rapping top-notch, attitude the best.
No food for 12 hours? To wait for all those contestants to finish their demo?🤨🤨 I know the shoots are long, but damn, can they not let them eat or something while waiting. That's torture
I hope people understand mnet was never fair especially because of them having a history of manipulating votes,editing,contestants and categories + songs in their shows especially because someone spoke out against mnet saying in their survival shows on the first stage ever infront of the judges no water would be offered to the contestants even when asked for so they had no choice but to practice before going on stage and have to sing with a dry throat which is obviously gonna be showing that the person sucks at singing but they don't it's just mnet was being bad with the contestants.
Not eating and drinking for 12hrs omg that's y most girls became so think 🥺
suruiqi said she forget her song sezie the light. she didn't say helicoper. the translater did not translate the whole words. so there are some misunderstanding