Comardy can't be the sniper killer because they literally followed the killer after the final events of the game. There was a physical vehicle that your colleague police chief saw and chased down to the house, which lead to the confrontation of the killer who was then killed by comardy. He does have a mental break after that but The split personality thing is just a red herring. It's like you skipped the ending of the game lol
Exactly. Because Comardy was the one to kill the sniper killer, maybe the entity (and all the tortured souls with it) invaded his mind instead, whisking his soul away
Have to disagree with you on your analysis R. If you play the last mission as the sniper killer, you could interact with all 3 detectives including Comardy. So the ending is more likely Comardy going insane after killing the sniper killer, rather than him being the original sniper killer
Also if comardy was the original sniper, the desk lady from the hotel should have noticed him from the night before and she doesn't seem like she recognized him at all. I think whatever the creature was that controlled the original sniper started to control and corrupt the detective as the detective started to figure out where and who the sniper is.
@@briang4470 Plus, If Comardy is diagnosed with D.I.D. (Dissociative Identity Disorder) then from Comardy's perspective the Sniper Killer shouldn't exist since he's the killer. So, That means the Sniper Killer and Comardy are two separate characters, and HQ ( the Cosmic Being) is the puppet master controlling the Sniper Killer. Granted both Comardy and Sniper Killer has the same taste for the same brand of cigarette and statement about it. But, I'm leaning over that it's a coincidence and the Devs trying to throw the player/viewer off course.
@@WispyBlueBricksGPX Similar to what I've said before; if Comardy is the killer, Then how can killer conveniently be there driving off; besides Dutch saw the killer too, so that proves that Comardy and the killer are too seperate individuals and it wasn't a hallucination . Plus, How can Comardy be at two places at the same; He was at parade when before the chase unfolded. Unless he has teleportation abilities, Lol.
Wrong analysis at the end imo, Comardy CANNOT be the Sniper Killer, - the timing is way off during the mayor assassination. - Comardy would literally need to teleport in order to be right next to Dutch and the other cops when the mayor is shot. - Who is driving the escaping car ? A Ghost ? It certainly cannot be an halluciation since Dutch also see the car. As for the weird visions Comardy has, it is very plausible that the entity is hunting for another "host". Just my 2 cents.
I want to add the receptionist at the motel did not say anything when Carmardy interviewed her. If he was the killer, the receptionist would've seen the exact same face and said something. I also theorize the "men in black" are a shadow organization that recruits the killers. Carmardy saw them in the hobo scene, and they were bathed in green light, which is usually seen during parts where there will be some void shenanigans.
Hans in actually alive as seen in sneak peeks for Jordan Kings next game called "Killview" which is set in the early 1990s since we can see in the background Sara from Bloodwash and her son Nicky who's playing with a dog and this confirmed since in a different post we played as Sara and is with her son Nicky who's wearing the same clothes as the kid in the background of Killview and speaking of Hans we can also see him selling Corn magazine's so yeah he didn't died I believe he was knocked out just wanted to point that out for you 😊
He can't have been the sniper killer, as in the final sniper killer mission, you can go and talk to comadery, dutch, and the chief. That was when I realized he WASN'T. But I do think the entity is real, as it chose comadery probably due to the fact he became a vegetable
The killer was Jeffrey. (Jef for short) You can found a couple of notes telling you is ful name in the basement. That cop's name isn't Jeffrey. And this game is taking place in a shared universe. A lot of the characters from the dev other games are in this one. That monster is real in his other game. Besides, when you're the killer.. you can literally talk to the main cop who's looking for the killer at that holiday event. You can talk to him, the chef, & the main cop's best friend. There lines isn't one they would've said to a fellow cop.
I think that after he killed Sniper Killer and the Entety which is from Jordan Kings second ever game Tonight it Follows that was controlling the Sniper Killer ended up taking over Comardy and he became the next killer for this Entety and I believe that both of them weren't the first one since we find a lot of different documents which suggests that there we're different killers before Sniper Killer and the was used as a hideout for other killers but that's just a theory A GAME THEORY!!!!!
I agree, also in the Parade section The Killer Shoot the Major from the Church Tower and Comardy was on the Road with 3 Officers. Also, the Chase scene at the End wouldn't work unless Dutch was also a Hallucination.
Damn, now that I havent thought about yet, in a twisted way I can kind off imagine the next killer disposing of the old one, but I am not sure if the fact that the sniper killer was proficient has any role in this play. I am sure we're intionally thrown off by the fact that Comardy smokes the same brand of cigarettes, like something doesnt add up. Is the "sniper killer" just a persona taken up by everyone fitting the ability? I mean Comardy in the end does seem to just "become" the sniper killer, it doesnt make a lot of sense that he was the sniper killer all along, desk lady not recognizing him, the major shot mission where he needed to teleport to be the Killer as well as drive the car. It kinda makes sense that "The Sniper Killer" is more of a persona taken up by those under the influence of the Monster. Then again, why does this work? Who was the last Sniper Killer? Why is it that Comardy lost it.. since in my opinion the final explanation that his mind broke from the stress release just doesnt work, I can rather accept that its "empty" because his sould went to hell. By the way... Does anyone ever check who all the people in the cell block and in the room at the end are? Depending, it could be a collection of prior killer and its victims, the killers locked up and under control while its victims collected... something like that. Also what about Jeff? Who is he? Is he just the current "sniper killer"s soul slipping from his body? Could he be the namesake? I just dont get it, something is amiss, maybe thats the point of the story... Someone has to dig up everything related and be really thorough, this is insanity shit
Im being honset puppet combo always pull wild twist in their games. Despite it being horror game studio. They do twists that leave you wonder adout game plot. The actions of characters and what to theorize
One of the Ghost that appears behind Comardy is the office worker from Bloodwash that was killed by the Womb Ripper and he was also seen in Ding Dong Dead as Rex's father and his wife was Pamela who was killed by the Sniper Killer since the both look the same and Rex's uncle was Gary from The Booty Creek Cheek Freak who was killed by the Cheek Freak so this basically means that Rex lost his hole family and and uncle by these killers and his brother who was the Ding Dong Ditcher Ripper was shoot by his psychiatrist Dr. Pleasent who is seen at the end of this game it's onasly tragic that Rex's is now an orphan and has no one left of his family which is just depressing 😞😭
@nxrvzna sure you have Bloodwash,Ding Dong Dead,Night at the Gates of Hell,The Booty Creek Cheek Freak,The Evil in the House of Dr. Fleshenstein,Tonight if Follows,SkiFreak,The Summoning along side his other future games like Killview,Inferno City Massacre,Shotgun,Pizza Face,Beyond the Gates of Hell,Bloody Bibble Camp,Heebie Jeebeis,American Football 3D,Staked,Ms. Vengance,SkiFreaks,TBCCF 2:deceaking,DDD Chapter 2 those are all I can remember
This is one of the most unique ways of making a killer possess by an evil entity, that if a person kills the previous killer, they get possessed and become the next killer repeating the cycle until the entity get destroyed
But this doesn't make sense for him to be the sniper killer. We play as the sniper killer, and during the last sniping mission, we can talk to Detectives Comerdy and Dutch - as the sniper killer. Also, Dutch and Comerdy DID chase someone back to that house - someone who was driving another vehicle who Dutch could see as well as Comerdy. Comerdy, even though the game tries to suggest it with the cigarette stuff and the fact he was the only one who knew the journalist students were going to that alleyway, literally couldn't have been the killer based off the ending events of the game because at the asylum, Dutch says Comerdy killed the sniper killer, so it's impossible for Comerdy to be the sniper killer. I know the game tries to suggest Comerdy is the killer based on the hints that it gives with the security camera footage, Comerdy's visions and hallucinations, and the cigarette stuff, and the bit with the journalist students, but Dutch literally drove the car they used to chase the sniper killer back to his house, Dutch saw someone speed away from the shooting and was following someone with Comerdy in the passenger seat. It makes no sense for Comerdy to be the killer, something broke with the plot logic of this game.
Because his not. You can found notes in the basement with the killers real name. It's Jeffrey & that monster is real. It's from the devs other game. A couple of characters from his other game is in this one. Playing the same roles as in those games. The monster was real in his other game
The game has so many potentials to make the plot twist hits very hard, but they planted too many red herrings trying to convince you Comerdy is the Sniper killer. THEN they threw all of that out of the window in flavor of including the in-universe entity and SUPERNATURAL!1!!11!!!1 part of Puppet Combo's niche. That's most of the complains I've been seeing from other videos.
The real killer is the writer. What i think was going on with the whole story is that the ex gov sniper was working at that factory and got possessed by the entity. The subway phone was hijacked by entity and the sniper guy was told by entity to stop in the stalls and had to take her in the train when she escapes. Its all in the entity cause we are focusing on the mental and psychological but its simply just supernatural. The entity stayed in the crime scenes watching your investigation, hindering progress. The guard that survived told the investigators that he saw the killer was faceless before he died. That was not the sniper he saw but the entity In the end, the sniper killer was the guy you took in the house cause the entity had no more use for him and gave no more supernatural instructions. When you defeat the entity, it chooses you as the next victim to control. Giving you the walkietalkie to give you instructions. Since previous guy was ex government the walkietalkie was giving him instructions as if it was government themselves. The walkietalkie will give next victim police related instructions against the innocent Sorta poorly written story that had a too good build up
You might think that most evidence point to comardy NOT being the killer... but! Maybe, to compliment his new found fantasy he went to a random guy's house locked him in the basement (or he was scared and hide) and then procceeded to live his fantasy staying at this guy's house and using his car. On the last mission maybe he (the original house owner) was the one in the car and the one that he killed (explaining what dutch siad about comardy "shooting the killer") . The calls were from a friend of the original person living there wich probably worked somewhere before getting trapped. That person might have also gotten insane like comardy (mass hysteria?) and thus explaining coming along for the last ride at the parade. Or maybe he just forced him to play along.
I like the idea that maybe the killer wasn't Jeff and he just is taking over Jeff's home or identity or whatever. But the voicemails state that Jeff quit his job so that would be pretty unlikely timing, to kidnap him right after he quits. Also the explanation that the kidnapped Jeff is driving the car makes no sense. There's no reason for him to have come with the killer, there's also no hint/indication that there's someone with the killer, and it doesn't make any sense why he would drive back home
We played as the sniper killer during the last mission and we see both Dutch and Comerdy together even when the sniper killer escape in his car Dutch pickup Comerdy before going after the sniper killer. The sniper killer can't be Comerdy
I dont know if anyone else has mentioned this but the game seems to take place before cell phones and so the number the journalist calls would most likely be the detectives office phone... making it even more likely that the supernatural entity is real.
I think this would be a great horror film where the killer is a mad psychotic sniper who belives hes doing the work for a good cause stopping criminals but hes murdering innocent lives out of a sick dilusion and i like the moments in the killers perspective its interesting
Not related to this but I hope puppet combo sees this comment and finishes that Santa Claus game they were working on. I was actually invested in the story that they were telling there.
I think I can use this for an idea for a Call of Cthulhu tabletop role playing game story. Set in a different time period, but same general kind of story.
I was a 3rd grader during The Beltway Sniper attacks in my area, most kids at my school during October didn't know why we had to stay in the building during recess but my parents told me some man was shooting people randomly and even children were getting killed, that killer reminds me of them(John Allen Muhammad and Lee Malvo)
...no? The asylum scene established that Comardy KILLED the killer. All similarities between the killer and him were red herrings. The cops _chased the killer._ They _saw him._ Comardy was in plain sight the whole time during the parade.
11:55 I know it's a game But jeez shooting people at the cemetery Imagine going to pay your respects to your homeboy and You can dab him off because you're both dead
he’s not the killer because they confirmed that he killed the sniper killer during that ending. I just got done watching mainlybadasshero play this also you come in contact with Comardy😂😂 so how’s he the killer I would believe he becomes the next sniper killer at the end
I'm all for Detective Comardy being the killer. However, at the end of the game, Dr. Pleasant says that he killed the Sniper Killer. So that technically means the detective can't be the killer.
SPOILERS! . . . . . . . . The Sniper Killer and Detective Comardy possibly being one and the same was really just a Red Herring. Also I defintiely wasn't expecting the monster from Tonight It Follows to make an appearance as the final boss in this game.
Challenging work, out of doors I guarantee you won't go angry. At the end of the day, as long as there's two people left on the planet. Someone is gonna want someone Dead
The nutjob at the cemetary you question say that this case is part of a bigger picture, there are characters from other puppet combo games like the Captain from night at the gates of hell and there is always this green mist around. Could it be this is a prequel to night at the gates of hell (pls correct me if I’m wrong about the name of the game) But my theory is that the sniper was being possessed by a demon who is preparing chaos around the city, since puppet combo universe are probably shared, it’s possible that demons are corrupting people (even for years) in order to sow chaos before they attack, it’s like an end times sign to signal the attack.
Now we need Feed Me More Billy to come out. we've been waiting 4 years now. And in the end, where the Sniper Killer gets shot, I wish he was wearing something very similar as the Zodiac. I also been keeping count of the victims 53.
Mm no, that last analysis is just wrong, not a theory, not an opinion, it's just wrong, comardy is NOT the sniper, you could literally talk to him while on the parade and even had dutch chased him down, he's just not the same person.
Main thing Jeff is the sniper killer as the archives tell his full name he became delusional and had split personalities the voice recording was the sane version of him himself talking to his i guess delusional version of himself half his side is a normal guy named jeff who built his house and the other side is his "sniper killer organization side" So the true thing is Jeff is insane the neighbour were demons talking to him because jeff didnt have any neighbours he went insane living alone he tried to cope with living alone by going on missions elimating targets
Wait a minute that creepy guy with the red glasses he was in blood wash and was a zombie in midnight at the Gates of hell is there some sort of connected universe?
yup, some other references are Dr. Pleasant (the psychologist) who's in Ding Dong Dead, and Womb ripper killer is also mentioned when talking to Detective Dutch
12:20 why is that creepy guy from the laundromat video game here? The creepy guy that told the woman protagonist who is pregnant that she's going to die that night
Not guilty due to reason of they literally _watched the killer flee the tower, then flee town in a red car, then confirm the real killer's body in the real killer's lair._ This youtuber ignored half the game, including THE FINAL DIALOGUE, in order to make up his own conclusion.
You didnt mention the men in black throughout the game (first sighting being in the carvival), which is a really bad oversight as it's central imo to the entire plot. You see the two MIB the first time at the top of the carnival sign, while playing as the reporter, so very clearly MIB were real and were following the crime scenes. This is the same two MIB you see twice later in the game, and the MIB that even Butch references were looking for the detective. They're also at the basketball/gang scene before at the same time the sniper is sniping them, so they seem to be aware of the killer and who his targets will be .. This dispells a lot of your conclusions, primarily it's unlikely this is just all a delusion. You also didn't connect the Jeff from voicemail being the sniper killer (as there's mail in the killer's basement addressed to a Jefferey you missed), which also means the detective was probably not the sniper. Furthermore Butch and the detective both chase the sniper to his home, and since Butch was the one driving, it doesn't make sense if the Detective was the Sniper. There's also no explanation as to who the guy the detective kills if the detective is also the sniper, as the doctor later confirms that the detective really did kill the sniper/suspect. This game story is terribly bad anyway and its not surprising theres no actual sufficient explanation to any of this that doesnt immediately contradict several other plot points
@@davinmcdonald3989you can talk to comardy along with dutch and chief during the mayoe assassination mission, the fact that the receptionist didn't recognize you from the motel and lastly dutch was the one that chased the killer to their house and notes on the basement giving the killers name
Who could've seen that coming? 💀
Me💀
Me💀
can you do the bathhouse remake chilla's art?
gori cuddly carnage story explained
My dawg
" I'm not a crazed gunman dad, I'm an assassin. The difference is one's a job and the other's mental sickness!"
It can be argued... its a thin line
TF2
Yep😅 i agree
“Dad put….put mom on the phone….”
the crazy part is that both cant be identified
Comardy can't be the sniper killer because they literally followed the killer after the final events of the game. There was a physical vehicle that your colleague police chief saw and chased down to the house, which lead to the confrontation of the killer who was then killed by comardy. He does have a mental break after that but The split personality thing is just a red herring. It's like you skipped the ending of the game lol
That's what I said in my post.
Exactly. Because Comardy was the one to kill the sniper killer, maybe the entity (and all the tortured souls with it) invaded his mind instead, whisking his soul away
Plus the hotel clerk saw the killer then saw comardy less than an hour later and made no mention of it being the same person.
not entirely that could of been his own delusion he might of actually been only driving the black car, and escaped
That’s probably because there isn’t actually a human in the radio, comardy got possessed and became the sniper killer
Have to disagree with you on your analysis R.
If you play the last mission as the sniper killer, you could interact with all 3 detectives including Comardy. So the ending is more likely Comardy going insane after killing the sniper killer, rather than him being the original sniper killer
Also if comardy was the original sniper, the desk lady from the hotel should have noticed him from the night before and she doesn't seem like she recognized him at all. I think whatever the creature was that controlled the original sniper started to control and corrupt the detective as the detective started to figure out where and who the sniper is.
@@briang4470 Plus, If Comardy is diagnosed with D.I.D. (Dissociative Identity Disorder) then from Comardy's perspective the Sniper Killer shouldn't exist since he's the killer. So, That means the Sniper Killer and Comardy are two separate characters, and HQ ( the Cosmic Being) is the puppet master controlling the Sniper Killer. Granted both Comardy and Sniper Killer has the same taste for the same brand of cigarette and statement about it. But, I'm leaning over that it's a coincidence and the Devs trying to throw the player/viewer off course.
@@briang4470 yes! This made me change my mind on Comardy being the killer. You made an excellent point! Very observant…. 👍🏻
@@fr3ddyscott4884 Explain the car chase
@@WispyBlueBricksGPX Similar to what I've said before; if Comardy is the killer, Then how can killer conveniently be there driving off; besides Dutch saw the killer too, so that proves that Comardy and the killer are too seperate individuals and it wasn't a hallucination . Plus, How can Comardy be at two places at the same; He was at parade when before the chase unfolded. Unless he has teleportation abilities, Lol.
Wrong analysis at the end imo, Comardy CANNOT be the Sniper Killer,
- the timing is way off during the mayor assassination.
- Comardy would literally need to teleport in order to be right next to Dutch and the other cops when the mayor is shot.
- Who is driving the escaping car ? A Ghost ? It certainly cannot be an halluciation since Dutch also see the car.
As for the weird visions Comardy has, it is very plausible that the entity is hunting for another "host".
Just my 2 cents.
I want to add the receptionist at the motel did not say anything when Carmardy interviewed her. If he was the killer, the receptionist would've seen the exact same face and said something.
I also theorize the "men in black" are a shadow organization that recruits the killers. Carmardy saw them in the hobo scene, and they were bathed in green light, which is usually seen during parts where there will be some void shenanigans.
Hans in actually alive as seen in sneak peeks for Jordan Kings next game called "Killview" which is set in the early 1990s since we can see in the background Sara from Bloodwash and her son Nicky who's playing with a dog and this confirmed since in a different post we played as Sara and is with her son Nicky who's wearing the same clothes as the kid in the background of Killview and speaking of Hans we can also see him selling Corn magazine's so yeah he didn't died I believe he was knocked out just wanted to point that out for you 😊
He can't have been the sniper killer, as in the final sniper killer mission, you can go and talk to comadery, dutch, and the chief. That was when I realized he WASN'T. But I do think the entity is real, as it chose comadery probably due to the fact he became a vegetable
B R O T H E R
The killer was Jeffrey. (Jef for short) You can found a couple of notes telling you is ful name in the basement. That cop's name isn't Jeffrey. And this game is taking place in a shared universe. A lot of the characters from the dev other games are in this one. That monster is real in his other game. Besides, when you're the killer.. you can literally talk to the main cop who's looking for the killer at that holiday event. You can talk to him, the chef, & the main cop's best friend. There lines isn't one they would've said to a fellow cop.
I mean out of all killers a sniper is the most efficient at being stealthy
I'd say poisoners are.as half the time authoritys aren't even 100% sure the victim was even poisoned until multiple other victims die the same way.
@@pipebombpete.6861And reasonably, they can dump some poison down, then leave the area.
Oh definitely, especially if they can work the environment against the victims.
I think that after he killed Sniper Killer and the Entety which is from Jordan Kings second ever game Tonight it Follows that was controlling the Sniper Killer ended up taking over Comardy and he became the next killer for this Entety and I believe that both of them weren't the first one since we find a lot of different documents which suggests that there we're different killers before Sniper Killer and the was used as a hideout for other killers but that's just a theory A GAME THEORY!!!!!
That's a pretty good theory, 👍
I agree, also in the Parade section The Killer Shoot the Major from the Church Tower and Comardy was on the Road with 3 Officers. Also, the Chase scene at the End wouldn't work unless Dutch was also a Hallucination.
Agreed
Yeah the killer is Jeffrey... Short for Jeff
Damn, now that I havent thought about yet, in a twisted way I can kind off imagine the next killer disposing of the old one, but I am not sure if the fact that the sniper killer was proficient has any role in this play.
I am sure we're intionally thrown off by the fact that Comardy smokes the same brand of cigarettes, like something doesnt add up.
Is the "sniper killer" just a persona taken up by everyone fitting the ability?
I mean Comardy in the end does seem to just "become" the sniper killer, it doesnt make a lot of sense that he was the sniper killer all along, desk lady not recognizing him, the major shot mission where he needed to teleport to be the Killer as well as drive the car.
It kinda makes sense that "The Sniper Killer" is more of a persona taken up by those under the influence of the Monster.
Then again, why does this work?
Who was the last Sniper Killer?
Why is it that Comardy lost it.. since in my opinion the final explanation that his mind broke from the stress release just doesnt work, I can rather accept that its "empty" because his sould went to hell.
By the way... Does anyone ever check who all the people in the cell block and in the room at the end are?
Depending, it could be a collection of prior killer and its victims, the killers locked up and under control while its victims collected... something like that.
Also what about Jeff?
Who is he?
Is he just the current "sniper killer"s soul slipping from his body?
Could he be the namesake?
I just dont get it, something is amiss, maybe thats the point of the story...
Someone has to dig up everything related and be really thorough, this is insanity shit
Im being honset puppet combo always pull wild twist in their games. Despite it being horror game studio. They do twists that leave you wonder adout game plot. The actions of characters and what to theorize
And sometimes they're like: "It was all the time, and Eldrich thing."
Actually Puppet Combo publishes these games under the Torture Star Video label, the devs are Jordan King aka Black-Eyed Priest.
@@fenrirsrage4609 thanks you very much for information
One of the Ghost that appears behind Comardy is the office worker from Bloodwash that was killed by the Womb Ripper and he was also seen in Ding Dong Dead as Rex's father and his wife was Pamela who was killed by the Sniper Killer since the both look the same and Rex's uncle was Gary from The Booty Creek Cheek Freak who was killed by the Cheek Freak so this basically means that Rex lost his hole family and and uncle by these killers and his brother who was the Ding Dong Ditcher Ripper was shoot by his psychiatrist Dr. Pleasent who is seen at the end of this game it's onasly tragic that Rex's is now an orphan and has no one left of his family which is just depressing 😞😭
holy shit
i was gonna make a snarky remark about how you have no life but now i realised that im just a sad lonely drunk fuck you
can you tell me all the games at tharre connected to sniper killer
also tell me the order of the games i should watch them as
@nxrvzna sure you have Bloodwash,Ding Dong Dead,Night at the Gates of Hell,The Booty Creek Cheek Freak,The Evil in the House of Dr. Fleshenstein,Tonight if Follows,SkiFreak,The Summoning along side his other future games like Killview,Inferno City Massacre,Shotgun,Pizza Face,Beyond the Gates of Hell,Bloody Bibble Camp,Heebie Jeebeis,American Football 3D,Staked,Ms. Vengance,SkiFreaks,TBCCF 2:deceaking,DDD Chapter 2 those are all I can remember
This is one of the most unique ways of making a killer possess by an evil entity, that if a person kills the previous killer, they get possessed and become the next killer repeating the cycle until the entity get destroyed
Yeah it was good
But this doesn't make sense for him to be the sniper killer. We play as the sniper killer, and during the last sniping mission, we can talk to Detectives Comerdy and Dutch - as the sniper killer. Also, Dutch and Comerdy DID chase someone back to that house - someone who was driving another vehicle who Dutch could see as well as Comerdy.
Comerdy, even though the game tries to suggest it with the cigarette stuff and the fact he was the only one who knew the journalist students were going to that alleyway, literally couldn't have been the killer based off the ending events of the game because at the asylum, Dutch says Comerdy killed the sniper killer, so it's impossible for Comerdy to be the sniper killer.
I know the game tries to suggest Comerdy is the killer based on the hints that it gives with the security camera footage, Comerdy's visions and hallucinations, and the cigarette stuff, and the bit with the journalist students, but Dutch literally drove the car they used to chase the sniper killer back to his house, Dutch saw someone speed away from the shooting and was following someone with Comerdy in the passenger seat.
It makes no sense for Comerdy to be the killer, something broke with the plot logic of this game.
Because his not. You can found notes in the basement with the killers real name. It's Jeffrey & that monster is real. It's from the devs other game. A couple of characters from his other game is in this one. Playing the same roles as in those games. The monster was real in his other game
The game has so many potentials to make the plot twist hits very hard, but they planted too many red herrings trying to convince you Comerdy is the Sniper killer. THEN they threw all of that out of the window in flavor of including the in-universe entity and SUPERNATURAL!1!!11!!!1 part of Puppet Combo's niche. That's most of the complains I've been seeing from other videos.
To be honest a horror game where the killer uses a gun as their main weapon is a concept not that much used.
Detective Comedy is a fitting name,
considering his entire outfit looks like a joke haha.. haha... ha...
🫥
Honestly love when I see a post, best chill and analyse videos around, much love❤
The real killer is the writer.
What i think was going on with the whole story is that the ex gov sniper was working at that factory and got possessed by the entity.
The subway phone was hijacked by entity and the sniper guy was told by entity to stop in the stalls and had to take her in the train when she escapes.
Its all in the entity cause we are focusing on the mental and psychological but its simply just supernatural.
The entity stayed in the crime scenes watching your investigation, hindering progress.
The guard that survived told the investigators that he saw the killer was faceless before he died.
That was not the sniper he saw but the entity
In the end, the sniper killer was the guy you took in the house cause the entity had no more use for him and gave no more supernatural instructions.
When you defeat the entity, it chooses you as the next victim to control.
Giving you the walkietalkie to give you instructions.
Since previous guy was ex government the walkietalkie was giving him instructions as if it was government themselves.
The walkietalkie will give next victim police related instructions against the innocent
Sorta poorly written story that had a too good build up
You might think that most evidence point to comardy NOT being the killer... but!
Maybe, to compliment his new found fantasy he went to a random guy's house locked him in the basement (or he was scared and hide) and then procceeded to live his fantasy staying at this guy's house and using his car. On the last mission maybe he (the original house owner) was the one in the car and the one that he killed (explaining what dutch siad about comardy "shooting the killer") .
The calls were from a friend of the original person living there wich probably worked somewhere before getting trapped. That person might have also gotten insane like comardy (mass hysteria?) and thus explaining coming along for the last ride at the parade. Or maybe he just forced him to play along.
I like the idea that maybe the killer wasn't Jeff and he just is taking over Jeff's home or identity or whatever. But the voicemails state that Jeff quit his job so that would be pretty unlikely timing, to kidnap him right after he quits. Also the explanation that the kidnapped Jeff is driving the car makes no sense. There's no reason for him to have come with the killer, there's also no hint/indication that there's someone with the killer, and it doesn't make any sense why he would drive back home
We played as the sniper killer during the last mission and we see both Dutch and Comerdy together even when the sniper killer escape in his car Dutch pickup Comerdy before going after the sniper killer. The sniper killer can't be Comerdy
Yep and you can talk to both of them when you're playing as the killer too
Bro it is criminal how much subscribers you have, you deserve more
Sniper killer was on another level
Bro where is cory,he needs to play this game dang
I dont know if anyone else has mentioned this but the game seems to take place before cell phones and so the number the journalist calls would most likely be the detectives office phone... making it even more likely that the supernatural entity is real.
So they finally released this game. I remember the demo being a lot different and better at times, but the final product is still fun and enjoyable
Thank you for posting everyday ❤love the story mode
I think this would be a great horror film where the killer is a mad psychotic sniper who belives hes doing the work for a good cause stopping criminals but hes murdering innocent lives out of a sick dilusion and i like the moments in the killers perspective its interesting
Another great video as usual
Not related to this but I hope puppet combo sees this comment and finishes that Santa Claus game they were working on. I was actually invested in the story that they were telling there.
Me too
rule number 1 in hunting.. "innocence" doesn't exist. everyone is guilty of something.
They need to start making uncut versions of their games because this game obviously had a few levels cut out from the teaser
1:30 i thought someone knocked irl i got small heart attack
I think I can use this for an idea for a Call of Cthulhu tabletop role playing game story. Set in a different time period, but same general kind of story.
What happened to “Hans”, doctor Frankenstein in the beginning? He wasn’t mentioned as one of the victims. Only Pamela.
Man, i got jumpscared from the right and left knocking 😂
i used to pray for times like this
You used to pray for times where there was a guy who was a serial killer by sniper??? WILD 😂
@@oceangalaxy704 Meek Mill Song
@@animatorsparadise1 yea that’s cool but I like my idea better lol
Theres so much lore behind dectective Comardy and the sniper killer but u told in a nutshell.I wish if u make an another whole video on it:)
YES another puppet combo video
14:10 Isn't that the creepy bus guy from Bloodwash?
It is.
I was a 3rd grader during The Beltway Sniper attacks in my area, most kids at my school during October didn't know why we had to stay in the building during recess but my parents told me some man was shooting people randomly and even children were getting killed, that killer reminds me of them(John Allen Muhammad and Lee Malvo)
That goddamn knock gets me every time
...no? The asylum scene established that Comardy KILLED the killer. All similarities between the killer and him were red herrings. The cops _chased the killer._ They _saw him._ Comardy was in plain sight the whole time during the parade.
11:55 I know it's a game But jeez shooting people at the cemetery Imagine going to pay your respects to your homeboy and You can dab him off because you're both dead
The neighbor in the hole of the fence looks similar to the “weird man on the bus” in bloodwash
Some of the characters from the dev other game are in this one. It's a shared universe. Like how that monster is in his other game.
Actually you do meet the Creepy Guy from the Bus at the Cemetary and later on is taken in to be interrogated by Comardy.
he’s not the killer because they confirmed that he killed the sniper killer during that ending. I just got done watching mainlybadasshero play this also you come in contact with Comardy😂😂 so how’s he the killer I would believe he becomes the next sniper killer at the end
Great video!
I'm all for Detective Comardy being the killer. However, at the end of the game, Dr. Pleasant says that he killed the Sniper Killer. So that technically means the detective can't be the killer.
But then again, the cigarettes and the payphone scene should be a dead giveaway that it's the detective. I guess it's just contradicting information.
Because the killer was Jeffrey. Not that cop with a different name. There's notes in the basement saying his full name
really? @@jeremyhall2727
Comardy becomes the next Sniper killer if the Post-Credits scene is to be believed.
@@WILLHAVENGAMING WRONG
It's been awhile since you upload puppet combo, I miss this💜
Yes, I missed these games. I think I'll do even more similar styles from different devs
SPOILERS!
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
The Sniper Killer and Detective Comardy possibly being one and the same was really just a Red Herring.
Also I defintiely wasn't expecting the monster from Tonight It Follows to make an appearance as the final boss in this game.
Sniping's a good job, mate!
Challenging work, out of doors I guarantee you won't go angry.
At the end of the day, as long as there's two people left on the planet. Someone is gonna want someone Dead
@@gamer-ninja3522 challenging work out of doors
@@gamer-ninja3522 I guarantee you won't go angry
@@gamer-ninja3522 cause at the end of the day
@@gamer-ninja3522 as long as there's two people left on the planet
i’m too early. when i get home from my exam i’ll update🕺
sure, hope you did well on your exam
96/100. i can’t complain woke up to a nice commentary to do my idle gta tasks too🏌️♂️
youtube deleted my response but i got a 96/100 and a great video to watch after my nap🤷♂️😂
It’s really cool how there’s more voice acting
“Professional have standards” a wise man said
Isn't the creepy guy the same one from bloodwash?
Yes
They had many references. Womb ripper killer from bloodwash was mentioned, Dr pleasant from ding dong dead and some more
Why is every german in a videogame called Hans and speaks almost no english are will still in 1944 or what? ='D
It's called being racist.
@@jeremyhall2727 true
The nutjob at the cemetary you question say that this case is part of a bigger picture, there are characters from other puppet combo games like the Captain from night at the gates of hell and there is always this green mist around.
Could it be this is a prequel to night at the gates of hell (pls correct me if I’m wrong about the name of the game)
But my theory is that the sniper was being possessed by a demon who is preparing chaos around the city, since puppet combo universe are probably shared, it’s possible that demons are corrupting people (even for years) in order to sow chaos before they attack, it’s like an end times sign to signal the attack.
Les goo, new vid on a Friday morning
Now we need Feed Me More Billy to come out. we've been waiting 4 years now. And in the end, where the Sniper Killer gets shot, I wish he was wearing something very similar as the Zodiac.
I also been keeping count of the victims 53.
Mm no, that last analysis is just wrong, not a theory, not an opinion, it's just wrong, comardy is NOT the sniper, you could literally talk to him while on the parade and even had dutch chased him down, he's just not the same person.
I can't believe I got real scared by the window after this!😵
In the sequel he will time travel to shoot jfk again
Hmmmm this reminds me of Manny Pardo
HLM2 fans will get it
Comardy ISN'T the sniper killer
Main thing Jeff is the sniper killer as the archives tell his full name he became delusional and had split personalities the voice recording was the sane version of him himself talking to his i guess delusional version of himself half his side is a normal guy named jeff who built his house and the other side is his "sniper killer organization side" So the true thing is Jeff is insane the neighbour were demons talking to him because jeff didnt have any neighbours he went insane living alone he tried to cope with living alone by going on missions elimating targets
what is the music playing at the end of the video it starts at 15:06
Its "murderhouse ost". I don't remember which one though, sorry. Just scroll through the playlist and you'll find it.
wat is the outro song called
After the sniper killer killed the mayor, dutch and comardy chased the killer in his car. But comardy was the sniper killer, then who drove that car?
Guys what if he's Jeff and he's leaving messages for himself as like idk to make him remember
Glad Jay kubs scoutz was one of the voices actors
I guess I'm as confused about the ending as everyone else I thought I was going crazy!
Wait a minute that creepy guy with the red glasses he was in blood wash and was a zombie in midnight at the Gates of hell is there some sort of connected universe?
yup, some other references are Dr. Pleasant (the psychologist) who's in Ding Dong Dead, and Womb ripper killer is also mentioned when talking to Detective Dutch
12:20 why is that creepy guy from the laundromat video game here? The creepy guy that told the woman protagonist who is pregnant that she's going to die that night
First rule of Fight Club is you do not talk about Fight Club.
Sniper killer, Qu'est-ce que c'est
Damn... not guilty due to reason of insanity.
Not guilty due to reason of they literally _watched the killer flee the tower, then flee town in a red car, then confirm the real killer's body in the real killer's lair._ This youtuber ignored half the game, including THE FINAL DIALOGUE, in order to make up his own conclusion.
@@NieroshaiTheSableyeah pretty much
Maybe the factory is a reference to the CIA training facility?
You didnt mention the men in black throughout the game (first sighting being in the carvival), which is a really bad oversight as it's central imo to the entire plot. You see the two MIB the first time at the top of the carnival sign, while playing as the reporter, so very clearly MIB were real and were following the crime scenes. This is the same two MIB you see twice later in the game, and the MIB that even Butch references were looking for the detective. They're also at the basketball/gang scene before at the same time the sniper is sniping them, so they seem to be aware of the killer and who his targets will be .. This dispells a lot of your conclusions, primarily it's unlikely this is just all a delusion. You also didn't connect the Jeff from voicemail being the sniper killer (as there's mail in the killer's basement addressed to a Jefferey you missed), which also means the detective was probably not the sniper. Furthermore Butch and the detective both chase the sniper to his home, and since Butch was the one driving, it doesn't make sense if the Detective was the Sniper. There's also no explanation as to who the guy the detective kills if the detective is also the sniper, as the doctor later confirms that the detective really did kill the sniper/suspect. This game story is terribly bad anyway and its not surprising theres no actual sufficient explanation to any of this that doesnt immediately contradict several other plot points
I guess Detective Comardy had *T H I C K S K I N*
Meet the SNIPER
Professionals have standards
Killers in movies/games:
Using guns ❌
Using anything else ✅
this one chose a different path tho
Clutch video on a Friday R
Clutch on a slow Friday R
Isn't the guy in the interrogation room the guy on the bus in Blood Wash
This one has to be inspired by Targets right
Ethan actually does wins this one
Wow. Crazy-
lets be honest clearly the sniper killer is a Combine sniper. lmao
I enjoyed this one.
me too :)
The knock at 1:32 made me jump....... why you do this to us R?
When I watch the video am I the only one thinking about the D.C sniper? Or is it just me?
My prediction of the ending was correct.
Not really, GamerSault got a few details wrong.
@@fenrirsrage4609 what was it?
@@davinmcdonald3989you can talk to comardy along with dutch and chief during the mayoe assassination mission, the fact that the receptionist didn't recognize you from the motel and lastly dutch was the one that chased the killer to their house and notes on the basement giving the killers name
Being Jeffrey
@ yep
Cool
JEFF IS THE SNIPER KILLER
actually he does seem to receive amesseage from some one on his walkie talkie in the bathroom you here the sounds of mumbled speech.
DC sniper
You should tray this horror game name. The
fear bussiness
You know it’s bad when hitmen two job?
Professional have standards
Something's up with dr pleasant though
Detective Comedy