No Regrets [Bramblestar/Squirrelflight] PMV

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 17 чер 2020
  • "And although I find it hard to re-live her, I know that I would always forgive her."
    -
    -
    -
    -
    Wow, cant believe i finished a wip I made way back in 2018! This project was always near and dear to my heart, its such a perfect song for Bramblestar and how he thinks back on his life with Squirrelflight throughout the many years they had together, I knew eventually I'd HAVE to finish this or else it'd be such a disservice.
    I'm not much of a Squirrelflight lover, I actually don't like her that much, she was especially oh so infuriating in her super edition, I'm much more of a Bramblestar fan- but I can appreciate her, and I think this song does her some justice. She truly was a very selfless cat in her time, it's not crazy to me that now after all this time, she finally wants something for herself, which is what i THOUGHT she achieved by having Alderheart and Sparkpelt but I guess that's not enough for her...
    Im getting ahead of myself- I mentioned I made this storyboard back in 2018, so the time period of this video is set i guess in Bramblestar's Storm? Basically, the end of the 5th arc/The Last Hope. I truly believed they should've remained broken up, but still close friends. After all they've been through, I can't imagine them ever separated. I'm pretty neutral on the bramblesquirrel ship, but much prefer them just as friends.
    Anyway, I think the song's pretty self-explanatory. I love this self-reflection I have Bramblestar going through, that although he had the right to feel hurt, I think in the Reveal scene, he should've been there for Squirrelflight. especially when Squirrelflight's nearly always been there for him, despite the TNP group going their separate ways, his behavior about Squirrelflight getting close to Ashfur, his defense of Hawkfrost, ect. He can still be hurt, but it was never Squirrelflight's fault. I think, as a fandom, we should be a bit less pissed about Brambleclaw's behavior and more understanding of him, and a little more mad at Leafpool. She did drag Squirrelflight down with her! I'm just sayin'! Leafpool's novella is RIGHT there!
    I also love at the end when Bramblestar does forgive her, Squirrelflight makes that one jab that I KNOW she absolutely would, saying she'd do it all the same over again. No Regrets! And
    Bramblestar only chuckles to himself because yup, thats squirrelflight! It stings but he totally deserves that, and loves her anyway.
    Sorry, I just have a lot of feelings about Bramblestar, and this video in particular! Hope yall've enjoyed!
    Patreon: www.patreon.com/user?u=6220606
    Ko-Fi: ko-fi.com/A2532RB0
    Tumblr: @projectshadovv
    Twitter: @sadmachlne666 (the i is a lower case L)
    Audio: "Welcome to Castle Irwell" by Crywank
    Programs: Paint Tool Sai 2, Sony Vegas Pro 11.0
    Characters: Brambleclaw/star, Squirrelflight, Lionblaze, Jayfeather, Hollyleaf, Tawnypelt, Stormfur, Feathertail, Crowfeather, Ashfur, Hawkfrost, and Leafpool
    Series: Warrior Cats
  • Фільми й анімація

КОМЕНТАРІ • 547

  • @NegativeWhispers
    @NegativeWhispers  3 роки тому +634

    if you come in on here wanting spouting on about how i, or anyone else here, should watch moonkittis video, just shut up right now. it is extremely disrespectful and condescending and im sick of it. I dont want to turn comments off, but if i get any more promotions for moonkittis videos, im turning them off. I stand by what i say and in believe, i know how to form my own thoughts and opinions, and youre free to disagree and think whatever you want. i dont need a bunch of moonkitti worshippers to pressure me to watch an hour long video on a couple i care very little for.

    • @catstray4374
      @catstray4374 3 роки тому +103

      Dear you don't have to listen to all these stupid comments, you have an amazing skill to create amazing things. Keep making them. The world lacks such talented people as you.
      sorry for my english i just russian uga buga xd

    • @yara8196
      @yara8196 3 роки тому +77

      I stan you😔😭💕
      Bramblestar don’t deserve this hate:c
      Your pmv is amazing!!

    • @movedtocupowarriors4205
      @movedtocupowarriors4205 3 роки тому +161

      I do not like Bramblestar at all, but when people pressure their opinions onto someone else it makes me pretty upset.

    • @oranges1008
      @oranges1008 3 роки тому +94

      Cup O Warriors I agree, squilf deserves better but moonkitti fans can’t go and attack older content that is as posted before her video, people can continue loving characters and how they see them.

    • @newtsinsuits237
      @newtsinsuits237 3 роки тому +106

      I would slightly disagree with you that anyone’s pressuring you they just want to express they’re opinion on the whole bramble subject. I do get being frustrated with a bunch of people telling you to watch it but they’re definitely not moonkitti worshippers it’s just the video goes into in-depth explanation of brambles abusive and toxic behavior towards squirrel from the start of them being together. I recommend the video to people because it’s incredibly well made and easy to understand and considering my disabilities don’t allow me to explain things properly it’s a good thing to listen to when you have the time! To me people refusing to admit that bramble was toxic and abusive to squirrel and trying to make there wrong doings equal is part of the problem of people going against victims in real life. I understand you’re frustrated and such but just know that some people, like myself, who are victims of abusive people, like bramble, feels like abling or defending his behavior which is just so wrong and bad. Hope this’ll help you understand the other side!

  • @facelessfigure7985
    @facelessfigure7985 4 роки тому +433

    I like how you had shown their age by giving them a greying muzzle.

  • @monietea6174
    @monietea6174 4 роки тому +790

    I really love that you included the parts where he was just being a happy proud dad because I know in the books after the reveal he showed little emotion for the loss of Hollyleaf and the parental feeling for his two adoptive sons (or at least what I can remember). I was always a little sad the Erins never wrote that aspect of Bramble reflecting on those moments he had with Holly, Jay, and Lion

    • @maireadxx
      @maireadxx 4 роки тому +35

      I agree but in Bramble Stars storm it reveals how much he cares for them still and how much her misses Holly leaf

    • @monietea6174
      @monietea6174 4 роки тому +9

      @@maireadxx oh actually don't think I read that one :-0 thank you

    • @maireadxx
      @maireadxx 4 роки тому +28

      MonieTea no problem :3 I feel the reason he didnt seem sad was because he is a very concealed character. He doesnt like talking about his feelings. I feel he got so mad at Squirrel because of what he went through with Hawk frost

    • @_kirb_
      @_kirb_ 4 роки тому +27

      Tbh I find myself increasingly frustrated with how the Erins handle loss. I remember when there was a dead cat in the camp and there were cats just joking around...in fact that happens all the time in different ways. I've come to realize it isn't that the cats are supposed to be optimists but it's just awkward writing. I know Bramble in general was written to be a bit harsh though I also know it was sometimes forced.

    • @frankigoldwater4603
      @frankigoldwater4603 3 роки тому +10

      Yess! I love how much he thinks about Hollyleaf in Bramblestars storm, because it really didn't touch on it in the main books. I think Brambleboi was just awkward and wasn't sure how to express his feelings to them after everything happened

  • @hahstudios2753
    @hahstudios2753 4 роки тому +217

    This is very random but I wanna say how much I love the fact that brambleclaw has darker splotches of brown fur kinda matching Tawnypelt and helping point out their siblings. That’s just a really great design choice

  • @fatimaanimales
    @fatimaanimales 4 роки тому +364

    I cry when Bramblestar remembers Hollykit ;__; he's a good papa

  • @Parasolhyena
    @Parasolhyena 4 роки тому +436

    I love the designs, I don't know how you do it but you make Bramblestar look both like a big bad and a big fluffy good boy!

    • @kpina9178
      @kpina9178 3 роки тому +6

      The big bad part thanks to the mustache, no doubt

  • @Elkemistical
    @Elkemistical 4 роки тому +570

    I'm not the biggest fan of Brambleclaw in general, even before this whole "hEs abUsiVe to SqUiRrel". But this made me wanna pat his lil fluffy head because the two of them have been through a lot ya know? The song is really fitting and it made me appreciate him a lil more 👏

    • @deltastar4147
      @deltastar4147 4 роки тому +3

      Wait what, I've stopped reading the books after omen if stars so can you explain I'm.curious

    • @lol42069.
      @lol42069. 4 роки тому +47

      @@deltastar4147 i think in Squirrelflight's Hope he treats her like trash lmao

    • @shadespenguin4854
      @shadespenguin4854 3 роки тому +4

      @@lol42069. Yeah, but she forgives him and everyone still hates him.

    • @lol42069.
      @lol42069. 3 роки тому +23

      @@shadespenguin4854 i never actually liked him. preferences i guess

    • @digits9010
      @digits9010 3 роки тому +39

      Delta Star hes just shown a pattern of abusive behavior towards squirrel, and tbh i wish she would leave him for good.

  • @Dreamy_Requiem
    @Dreamy_Requiem 4 роки тому +166

    i still stand by my thought that the hunters forgot how to write brambleclaw-star after tnp .___. he def starts feeling like an entirely different character to me after reading recent stuff with him in it.

    • @aposterous4126
      @aposterous4126 3 роки тому +12

      Absolutely. I mean honestly I’m kinda glad his character changed, he’s so much easier for me to read after TNP (he really was an insufferable jerk to me during that arc, but so are most warriors characters)
      Ik that’s now what you meant, but still. He’s alright as a character, never really amazing. Sometimes horrible. Just your average warrior cat.

    • @jadedesigns6171
      @jadedesigns6171 2 роки тому +7

      Ikr
      Brambleclaw is my favorite character, but bramblestar sucks

  • @cardfoxcrab
    @cardfoxcrab 4 роки тому +252

    THIS. THIS IS EVERYTHING I LOVE ABOUT BRAMBLECLAW. and its the ONLY thing i love about his character, everything else is trash (except for his interactions with hawk, tiger the first, and fire)
    thank you for portraying it so beautifully hjhhhj

  • @Stormwolf4
    @Stormwolf4 3 роки тому +73

    I really wish the Erins were able to really show this more emotional side of Bramblestar. From books alone, it is hard to really defend him, but he'll always be one of my favorites, through and through. You really showed his fatherly side in this, how he really did care for his children, even reminiscing about taking care of them. This brings a lot of emotions, and it so well done! The end part is perfect, cause like you said, I easily see Squirrelflight, even in her old age, making a comment like that. And of course Bramblestar being like, "Yep, that's the cat I feel in love with."

    • @Oscar_The_Magnificent
      @Oscar_The_Magnificent 2 роки тому +1

      👏👏👏

    • @puppydogs68
      @puppydogs68 2 роки тому

      You should watch the video called “Bramblestar is worse.”

    • @Stormwolf4
      @Stormwolf4 2 роки тому +2

      I have

    • @CANINETHEROPY
      @CANINETHEROPY 2 роки тому +5

      @@puppydogs68 But why lol

    • @veronica3662
      @veronica3662 Рік тому

      ​​@@puppydogs68 oh stfu, that's disrespectful
      Don't get mad because someone likes a character you don't

  • @bashfulwolfo6499
    @bashfulwolfo6499 4 роки тому +70

    Out of all the cats on the journey, I liked Bramble the most. He went through a lot, and at some points I could relate to him.
    I really love what you did with this video too (and I love Crywank), it was a nice ending.
    [Note]
    I haven't read Squirrelflight's Hope since she's one of my least favorite characters but I don't relate to Bramble like that if he is abusive-
    But I have gone through a toxic relationship with my boyfriend, no physical stuff but it just felt like we were both really unhappy and it was mentally abusive for both of us. We're still together to this day, we're much better now than that horror of a time.
    Also brambles mustache is so adorable why aren't we talking about it more

  • @adenova6260
    @adenova6260 4 роки тому +58

    Omg this is so lovely! I really love how you showed their age in the end with the gray streaks and whiskers. Bramble and Squirrel were my otp when I was little, and while their relationship wasn't shown as lovey dovey all the time, they fought through all of their hardships throughout the books and forgave each other. I appreciate how you depicted that.

  • @SPARKALSTHECAT
    @SPARKALSTHECAT 3 роки тому +234

    Why is everyone fighting why can't we just agree that this pmv is amazing ?
    I hate bramblestar but I love this pmv. Its gorgeous and emotional

    • @randomcomment1286
      @randomcomment1286 3 роки тому +4

      Yes

    • @winterlou2617
      @winterlou2617 3 роки тому +3

      Don't talk nonsense. "I hate Bramblestar, but I love this PMV"? Are you confused about values? If you hate Bramblestar, you have nothing to do here.

    • @koraissomeone
      @koraissomeone 3 роки тому +54

      @@winterlou2617 you don't have to like a character to enjoy a pmv about them yk?

    • @l_uxsides
      @l_uxsides 3 роки тому +44

      @@winterlou2617 there's such a thing as appreciating the art but not the subject matter

    • @Oi-nr3kw
      @Oi-nr3kw 3 роки тому +34

      @@winterlou2617 that was rather closed minded of you. Everyone is allowed to enjoy the style, tweening, expressions, as well as the effort put into this whole pmv while disliking one of the characters. Hell I am not a fan of Bramblestar myself, but this may be one of my favorite pmvs.

  • @Imdying47
    @Imdying47 Рік тому +15

    Honestly this is amazing, it shows how much they both struggled after Hollyleaf revealed the secret, the Erin’s wrote Bramblestar so bad after the secret was revealed, he seemed to have no emotion, they could’ve even added more emotion to when Hollyleaf died, I do like the fact that they had him be super angry with Hawkfrost.

  • @justabridget
    @justabridget 4 роки тому +233

    I wish they wrote Brambleclaw/star a bit more differently. You think after he had such an evil father, he would try and not become like him, but then you see him kind of “mistreating” Squirrelflight and stuff, and it makes you wonder, what happened? I was hoping he could forgive Squirrelflight and still treat Jayfeather and Lionblaze like somewhat sons. Not totally father them but be supportive of them.

    • @OkamiRose
      @OkamiRose 3 роки тому +48

      I agree. It's rough because I wanted to like him as a kid reading The New Prophecy, but reading it now I can't un-remember him as a dick in the future, and the result of bad writing and lore only made him worse.

    • @JlMMOTHY
      @JlMMOTHY 3 роки тому +44

      The Erins do a good job at destroying characters with a lot of potential

    • @jadedesigns6171
      @jadedesigns6171 2 роки тому +5

      @@JlMMOTHY yep

    • @DarkShadows713
      @DarkShadows713 2 роки тому +14

      Idk I feel like he kinda always mistreated her, from the very beginning. But I definitely agree with you, it would've been such a great story to see him become a great guy after everything his father did. But instead of that, it seems in the end Firestar was right from the first time he saw Bramblekit.

  • @user-nd9ne6gw4b
    @user-nd9ne6gw4b 4 роки тому +33

    I like Tawnypelt's and Brambleclaw's designs!
    Also, Squirrelflight looks so cute.

  • @Starrykitkat1
    @Starrykitkat1 4 роки тому +29

    This is adorable! Everyone says they should break up and that they hate Bramblestar, but I can't think that when I remember everything he and Squirrelflight went through together! They are two of my most favorite cats in the series and this perfectly shows their relationship! Them being old with grey muzzles also tugs my heart a little.

    • @ravenclawthestral3964
      @ravenclawthestral3964 3 роки тому +8

      I used to love bramble until he became an emotionally manipulative dick.

    • @Starrykitkat1
      @Starrykitkat1 3 роки тому +11

      @@ravenclawthestral3964 my opinion is really Brambleclaw good, Bramblestar bad, I want his character to either very much change, or please just have him die

    • @itisamystery.5090
      @itisamystery.5090 3 роки тому +14

      @@Starrykitkat1
      I can wholeheartedly agree with your statement here. I loved, and always will love, the old BrambleSquirrel ship *before* the authors decided to pull a 180 and drastically change his character out of the blue.

    • @JlMMOTHY
      @JlMMOTHY 3 роки тому +13

      I might even begin to start forgiving Bramble if he actually gave Squirrelflight a sincere apology. In Squirrelflight's hope, he said that "we shouldn't have let things get so bad". He used the word "we", and didn't even acknowledge his disgusting behavior. What he did destroyed Squirrelflight's mental state. Intentional or not, he treated her like dirt.
      I just feel bad for what Squirrelflight's Hope did to decent character. I used to like him.

    • @mak.thewriter7802
      @mak.thewriter7802 3 роки тому +1

      @@JlMMOTHY nice nickname, and yes, you're right

  • @heckporter
    @heckporter 3 роки тому +19

    Rewatching this because it’s great. Reading the comments section bc I hate myself. This fandom stupid as HELL. No one bothers to read anything or respect the boundaries creators have. Shut UP! EVERYONE!

  • @vixxdaemon3874
    @vixxdaemon3874 3 роки тому +31

    Y'all are fucking gross throwing accusations at someone who just wanted to make a pmv with characters from a children's book series and had THEIR OWN INTERPRETATION DIFFERENT FROM CANON of said characters.

  • @RUBYthedragon
    @RUBYthedragon 2 роки тому +11

    The bit where he looks at adult Jay and Lion. Then sees Hollykit and thinks “im so glad I did them” is SO powerful. You didn't need to show her death to just FEEL how he is feeling in that moment. Very amazing use of showing not telling. And who's chopping onions? Not me at 3:00am showing this video to friends and ugly crying

  • @SpaceCatz
    @SpaceCatz 8 місяців тому +4

    Looking back on this after reading thunder this is an amazing pmv and really shows their relationship in the best way. Brambleclaw/star had his issues as a mate to squilf for sure but they grew together. Whether it was growing apart or growing closer we watched their journey from the beginning.

  • @Russetmask
    @Russetmask Рік тому +9

    It's been two years and I still can't get over how beautiful this video is. I watch it like once a month, I just love the message, characters, song choice, and most of all your style! ugh, just beautiful!

  • @SamOfTheSparkle
    @SamOfTheSparkle 3 роки тому +59

    This video is so cute! I especially love the character design! Great job!
    I also find it silly and rude about how people are saying that you and other people who commented on this vid are saying to watch Moonkitti's video about Bramblestar. People seem to forget that this vid was uploaded BEFORE Moonkitti's vid. And even tho I'm not a big fan of Bramblestar, and I do see him as abusive, please take note that the creator made this vid before Moonkitti's vid made alot of people realize about Bramblestar and Squirrelflight's relationship. Even if the creator still likes the ship, its their opinion. I still find it a cute PMV! And hey... We have fanfiction.

    • @wok9
      @wok9 3 роки тому +11

      I choked on that last line, thank you for existing.

  • @lightdragon8849
    @lightdragon8849 4 роки тому +22

    0:36 - oh... My heart :< I read "New prophesy" before other and I really liked Bramle, Storm, Squirrel, Feather, Crow and Tawny as group of friends. I was sad when they stop being pals.
    Also, great job! This is beautiful PMV :3

  • @mosquito2545
    @mosquito2545 2 роки тому +8

    Everyone is soo...
    *fluffy*

  • @RUBYthedragon
    @RUBYthedragon 4 роки тому +17

    oh man.
    This made me a fan of Brambleclaw

  • @qwmuffin
    @qwmuffin Рік тому +9

    i really like this because i feel this captures the exact tone of their relationship that the erins were going for. but squilf and bramble definitely could have been written better though and it sucks what we actually ended up with. their relationship is more annoying to read than anything imo.

  • @foxygrin
    @foxygrin 4 роки тому +17

    0:34 I really liked how you included this, I always get a little emotional whenever any of the sundrown place group reunite. I wish they would have written in a conversation of Brambleclaw and Crowfeather considering they're both the three's dads. I know it's still possible, but it gets more and more unlikely...

  • @That_Ozian
    @That_Ozian 3 роки тому +5

    Everyone’s so fluffy!!!! And seeing the Grey in their pelts made me tear up

  • @artistic8696
    @artistic8696 4 роки тому +11

    Squirrelflight’s puppy eyes I- MY HEART!!

  • @mataschmata
    @mataschmata 3 роки тому +67

    bro i am SO sorry about all the stans flooding in here giving you shit about this video,
    do i think brambleclaw was an abusive pos to squirrelflight? yeah. do i feel the need to seek out videos that paint their relationship in a positive light to shit on the artist and accuse them of being an abuse apologist for their personal interpretation of fictional cats? fucking NO?? my god! if moonkitti saw the way these people were behaving on behalf of her video i'm convinced she'd be disgusted.
    honestly the point i got from this amv was not "squirrelflight and bramblestar so good and wholesome

    • @ZevMaximus
      @ZevMaximus 3 роки тому +8

      This is literally the best comment on this video.
      Zenka your art is fantastic as usual. Don't listen to all the rest of this bs.

  • @carmenlynx8636
    @carmenlynx8636 4 роки тому +16

    I just finally reading Sunrise and this so convenient that you uploaded this, while I was reading the book, idk y, but I actually felt the pain that Brambleclaw felt once he realized that he was being lied too. Love your art and please keep up the AWESOME work!!!

  • @Marinin
    @Marinin 3 роки тому +43

    Oh dude, I've been watching this video for such a long time (since you posted it)
    I really really love this! Nowadays it's getting harder and harder to like a character, or even to make a design for one, because that will always have someone to complain about it or claim you are a horrible person because of this. People get so much rage and hate in the wc community because of opinions, when, in reality, it's just fictionals cats lmao.
    Great job! I love your work so much! I love both bramble and squilf and I think you made them so realistic!

  • @littlefanggz8570
    @littlefanggz8570 4 роки тому +7

    OH THANK YOU THANK YOU THANK YOU FOR THIS AMAZING PMV, I LOVE THAT YOU SHOW BRAMBLE’S HAPPY TIMES where he‘s a good dad and he cared for those around him. Im a huge bramble fan and this really puts a smile on my face to see that his life and his troubles are put to light and shown that not always Squirrelflight was right, both of them have been through a whole lot and need a break!

  • @trickypelt7962
    @trickypelt7962 4 роки тому +5

    i love brambleclaw/star dude. I love how there relationships are and I hope Bramblestar doesn't die in the newest book series and Squirrelflight can have one more pair of kits with him like she wanted to.

  • @madc1568
    @madc1568 4 роки тому +8

    And then everything goes to shit when bramble gets possessed

  • @wastedaydreams7662
    @wastedaydreams7662 3 роки тому +34

    i can’t tell you how many times i’ve played this over and over again since first watching it. i’ve always adored your art style and i think this song choice goes perfectly with the story your telling here. i’m sorry people are pushing their opinions in your comment section just cuz of Moonkitti’s recent video. i found her vid very interesting but it would never make me enjoy your art here any less. thanks for sharing your content with us

  • @Alphablood_
    @Alphablood_ Рік тому +4

    I love this PMV and i love Bramble too! :)

  • @cloudear3887
    @cloudear3887 Рік тому +6

    People should know that Bramblestar was better after Squirrelflight’s hope, don’t hate on them because they made a Bramblestar PMV

    • @lemonballs
      @lemonballs 11 місяців тому +3

      even moonkitti says not to idolize her and go after bramble fans.

  • @NITEBEARR
    @NITEBEARR 25 днів тому

    still one of my favorite warrior pmvs to this day. absolutely awesome stuff

  • @aldernic_animal
    @aldernic_animal 2 роки тому +12

    I'm so glad to see im not the only one who doesn't think bramble is an awful abusive character. I love this so much.

  • @ccowpoke
    @ccowpoke 5 місяців тому +2

    I love them so much.

  • @emmasmitherman8389
    @emmasmitherman8389 4 роки тому +3

    This was so heart wrenching in the best way. The detail in the designs and the expressions is stellar. Well done! Also, I greatly appreciate reading your detailed descriptions after each video! It’s great to have questions answered before having to ask them.

  • @kihendeaeyodele3529
    @kihendeaeyodele3529 4 роки тому +7

    I’m legit impressed that you didn’t forget the scar hawk left on brambleclaw.. and the size difference between each cat surprised me too like you’re rly good lol

  • @joltyflare
    @joltyflare 3 роки тому +10

    Really wish people would stop hating on people for liking a ship. Anyway, I really like this PMV! It's so sweet and adorable, especially watching them age together and all the conflicts they go through...wow you visualized them quite epically in under two minutes, it's amazing!!

  • @raccoonartz4140
    @raccoonartz4140 4 роки тому +3

    All those emotions hit me right in my little heart, you made a wonderful job.

  • @Rainkatify
    @Rainkatify 4 роки тому +53

    I totally agree about all of ur analysis in the description!! Squirrelflight was def dragged down with leafpool and manipulated by leaf+starclan and I never see people talk about that. I love this pmv so much, i think that it rlly exemplifies how brambleclaw and squirrelflight are both incredibly flawed and deserve each other because only they can understand and forgive one another. Theres a lot of love there )":

    • @SkiggsMoDiggs
      @SkiggsMoDiggs 4 роки тому +15

      Leafpool was such a bitch doing that to Squirrelflight! She was a great cat and sister and still is, but that was a move that I will always be disgusted by. I won't ever forget she did that to her own sister and I won't entirely forgive that yet, since she never offered a proper apology to her sister.

    • @KZFathom
      @KZFathom 3 роки тому +7

      same, really. i mean, she hurt people, but the whole narrative was trapped by starclan. squirrel literally had ghosts visiting her telling her to take her sister's kids lmao, and nobody defied starclan before. she really didn't do anything, but some people are still mad at her and not the cat gods.

    • @wolfiethetimberwolf1363
      @wolfiethetimberwolf1363 3 роки тому +2

      @@KZFathom Yeah, they told her to and then got mad at her for doing it. Like, what??

  • @luisaaraujo6433
    @luisaaraujo6433 4 роки тому +4

    this is so great. if we're talking about character design, the shapes are distinct and i could recognize the characters by their silhouettes. if we're talking about the song, it was a great choice and fits perfectly. the backgrounds are well done, the coloring and artstyle look amazing, the expressions in the character's faces are so good. really, outstanding job, i love it and it did make me cry a lil bit.

  • @Insomniacjpeg
    @Insomniacjpeg 4 роки тому +2

    Oh man this hurts but it's so beautiful.. You know how to capture such strong emotions. I love your work so much. ❤❤❤

  • @skylerstemper4627
    @skylerstemper4627 4 роки тому +2

    I love this!!!! The part where the travel squad was together and then they all went separate ways really got me! It’s probably the best I’ve seen it represented!

  • @mataschmata
    @mataschmata 4 роки тому +6

    thank you for making em like brambleclaw a little more

  • @Blue-mj5gm
    @Blue-mj5gm 2 роки тому +4

    There's a little tear in my eye ngl. The song's lyrics hit right on point. You also managed to make me feel for Bramble, even though I don't like him much in the books because of how he totally abandoned his family after Hollyleaf's reveal.

    • @FantasticFawnleap
      @FantasticFawnleap Рік тому +2

      Dude he didn’t abandon anyone!

    • @Blue-mj5gm
      @Blue-mj5gm Рік тому +2

      @@FantasticFawnleap he basically stopped being a father to the three

    • @FantasticFawnleap
      @FantasticFawnleap Рік тому +2

      @@Blue-mj5gm he was hurt dude!

    • @FantasticFawnleap
      @FantasticFawnleap Рік тому +2

      @@Blue-mj5gm and he didn’t abandon them!

    • @SmurfleTheSmurf
      @SmurfleTheSmurf Рік тому +4

      @@Blue-mj5gm just ignore them, they’re everywhere. just some random headstrong kid.

  • @emisev4162
    @emisev4162 4 роки тому +7

    AWWWWWWW THIS IS BEAUTIFUL. I LOVE THE DESIGNS YOU HAVE FOR THESE FLOOFY BOIS. AND I THINK ITS SO CUTE HOW YOU ADDED THE GREY IN THEIR MUZZLES WHEN THEY AGE! That’s so coooolllllllll!!!!!

  • @citrusnail8509
    @citrusnail8509 4 роки тому +2

    Ohhmygosh I absolutely adore this AAA I love seeing this side of bramblestar being portrayed and the song fits so well!!!

  • @woodelf1329
    @woodelf1329 4 роки тому +5

    This is so beautiful! I loved the little moments you included with Hollyleaf. Their relationship just warms my heart. I have watched all of your PMVs and I love all them, just such perfect music choices and of course the ART just packs the perfect emotion.
    And its nice to hear someone who not completely trashing Brambleclaw! While he is not my absolute favorite, I do have a soft spot for him. And I think you explained it perfectly in the description.

  • @grimm6176
    @grimm6176 3 роки тому +4

    you outdid yourself man! this is so beautiful. they had such a complicated relationship but i love squirrelflight so much. this song seems to capture her so well... i love your designs, your style and just- gah! it's so amazing!!

  • @leefee5369
    @leefee5369 3 роки тому +5

    This is AMAZING! I love the charters and how they interact each other! Though I don't support their relationship this really shows their emotions and friendship :)

  • @shimmerstar7386
    @shimmerstar7386 4 роки тому +5

    I really love this pmv great music choosing and amazing arts!!!
    Things like this can be really hard to find in this fandom nowadays(especially after Squirrelflight’s hope) so many people are just like Bramble bad abusive go die and Squirrel yay great

  • @tricksfollies9549
    @tricksfollies9549 3 роки тому +3

    I appreciate the 8-bit version of "Sweet Victory" at the end. Amazing and beautiful PMV btw!

  • @ThrowableOwl
    @ThrowableOwl 3 роки тому +11

    I like this drawing.
    Cats look different, they have different physiques and hair lengths.
    The kittens look like kittens, and not simply as a small adult cats.
    And the newborn Trinity is so cute!
    I haven't read the book and I study warrior cats from Wikipedia and fan videos.
    I'd often heard that Bramble was terrible with Squirrel, but it was nice to see them as a good couple.
    A couple who quarrel and make up, becomes closer and more tolerant of each other. A real loving couple.
    I wish that was the truth. This is better!

  • @Bitchypoetsblog
    @Bitchypoetsblog 4 роки тому +15

    Squirrelflight didn't Describe all her pain she did all those things for leafpool cuz sh loved her and Everyone took it the wrong way Squirrelflight did it for love for her sister shes a inspirational character and she was flaws so that's what makes a good character

    • @jackisbored2608
      @jackisbored2608 3 роки тому +2

      Squirrelflight is my favorite character, I think Bramblestar is an abusive piece of crap (he reminds me of a *former* crush)

    • @Onyxseyes
      @Onyxseyes 11 місяців тому

      @@jackisbored2608 Squirrelflight is equally abusive and it’s disgusting that you people never point it out. Their both toxic and abusive toward eachother stop putting all the blame on bramble.

    • @milksnake-milkshake4415
      @milksnake-milkshake4415 9 місяців тому

      @@Onyxseyeswhat did squilf do

  • @skitterspider1280
    @skitterspider1280 4 роки тому +1

    FAVE CRYWANK SONG!!!!! bramble and squirrels tragic and fractured relationship is both really grating and sad to think about and you captured it perfectly!!! also the added detail of the roadtrip gang growing apart after the journey made me :((

  • @eidolism759
    @eidolism759 3 роки тому +1

    I keep coming back to watch this, absolutely wonderful pmv

  • @lulabiebyi8999
    @lulabiebyi8999 4 роки тому +2

    Yay!!! New AMV to obsess over!! I’ve literally watched your Mary AMV over 1000 times, now I can do it to this!! ❤️

  • @iidalus
    @iidalus 4 роки тому +2

    oh wow this is wonderful..... i love all the complex emotions in it!!! and your designs are god-tier i love bramblestars mustache ♥

  • @blairewildflower
    @blairewildflower 4 роки тому +1

    omg 🥺 🥺 🥺,,, tysm for making this, it’s beautiful.

  • @goblinhound
    @goblinhound 4 роки тому

    This is absolutely outstanding omg,,, i love crywank sm and the song choice is just perfect for the narrative you portrayed!!!!

  • @ozymandias7
    @ozymandias7 7 місяців тому +1

    HECK YEAH i am always always here for dad bramble!!! this is a very lovely pmv :D

  • @sophiahenriquez-py2wc
    @sophiahenriquez-py2wc 6 місяців тому +1

    What gorgeous character designs and colors ❤

  • @doveydeath
    @doveydeath 4 роки тому +2

    This is fantastic! I love brambles emotion in this

  • @SusanTheBee
    @SusanTheBee 3 роки тому +1

    This pulls so much at my heartstrings...
    Thank you for this beautiful piece of art :)

  • @category_M
    @category_M 4 роки тому

    I'm crying, the best friends part and hollykit part really get me. Good job

  • @Beetleboltz
    @Beetleboltz 4 роки тому +2

    Wow im actually crying from this thank you its amazing

  • @nullwood6630
    @nullwood6630 2 роки тому +4

    hi i love this interpretation of bramblestar so much….

  • @vuIturecuIture
    @vuIturecuIture 4 роки тому +34

    i love this song so much and i never realized how well it fits these two! i’m a huge fan of brambleclaw and while i don’t like squirrelflight much, i definitely appreciate what you did with her here. their mistakes and faults are very human (cat??) and i like that you gave them that depth :) beautiful work !!!!!

  • @mary_ms_jay233
    @mary_ms_jay233 4 роки тому

    Aaaaah how dare you make me cry like this... Thank you for this! Its beautiful!

  • @moonlobotomy9061
    @moonlobotomy9061 4 роки тому +3

    I just realized this but oh my god squirrelflights face at 0:14 is so so so sad 🥺 all your expressions are amazing

  • @siiri9699
    @siiri9699 4 роки тому

    This is so good! The song fits so well for these two 👌

  • @yudream6570
    @yudream6570 4 роки тому

    I truly love this pmv, designs, expressions, compositions, everything is perfect. I get emotional by watching this ;^; thank you

  • @Lemon-mp9cq
    @Lemon-mp9cq 4 роки тому +1

    Aww this is amazing it really shows how both cats felt in these situations-!

  • @axel6437
    @axel6437 4 роки тому +3

    I love watching you work on this in streams

  • @LilLalachuTheStar
    @LilLalachuTheStar 4 роки тому +2

    THIS IS AMAZINGGG

  • @Ash-zq8us
    @Ash-zq8us 4 роки тому +1

    THIS IS SO GOOOD OMLLLL

  • @axelf9947
    @axelf9947 3 роки тому +2

    tHIS IS THE BEST THING IN THE WHOLE WORLD OH MY GOD I LOVE YOU

  • @techodaria588
    @techodaria588 4 роки тому +4

    I don't see Bramblestar like this but I LOVE THIS PMV AAAA

  • @calicotuft6697
    @calicotuft6697 9 місяців тому +2

    absolutely beautiful :) i didnt pay much attention to their relationship but i still like this alot lol

  • @wheat_5923
    @wheat_5923 4 роки тому +42

    I love the designs and literally everything about this and I do agree that Bramble seems misunderstood by many. But then again I haven’t really read many recent-ish books. Also, can we all agree that Leaf dragged down so many other cats because she couldn’t handle the consequences of her actions? Like, damn. Squirrel received a much worse punishment than her for just trying to be a good sister.

  • @Alexia-se5vp
    @Alexia-se5vp 4 роки тому +1

    This is just amazing. Ive eecent stubbled upon ur YT not to long ago and im just inlove with your videos and drawins

  • @xcrane4616
    @xcrane4616 4 роки тому +1

    :0 THAT WAS AMAZINGGG! I THINK I SHED A TEAR AT SOME POINT :'0

  • @Feezee223
    @Feezee223 4 роки тому +1

    This looks so good!

  • @anyothername5437
    @anyothername5437 4 роки тому +2

    Oh this is such a good depiction of their relationship!! 😃

  • @songbird6414
    @songbird6414 4 роки тому +22

    I don’t care what the fandom thinks. Brambleboi is my favorite character from this series, closely followed by Ivypool, and I was never happier reading a book than when he became leader after Firestar.

    • @FabulousFeathertail
      @FabulousFeathertail 4 роки тому +6

      I agree!

    • @ravenclawthestral3964
      @ravenclawthestral3964 3 роки тому +3

      Hmph.

    • @unknownuser6390
      @unknownuser6390 3 роки тому +8

      @@ravenclawthestral3964 its sad that you write under every "i like bramble" comment. Get some help and stop trying to shame that character. Its a fckn childrens book. People dont have to listen to your sh*t or have to agree with you.

  • @k.k.k.k.k.k.k.ke.
    @k.k.k.k.k.k.k.ke. 3 роки тому +5

    I cried.

  • @F1SHB0NEZ_
    @F1SHB0NEZ_ 3 роки тому +12

    I have always had a soft spot for Brambleman, and I am still devastated in what his character became with the whole Squirrelflight situation. I feel like he's a big softie in reality but him and Squirrelflight just weren't meant to be. He's a good dad but him and Squirrelflight should've just remained friends.

    • @Borzoink
      @Borzoink 2 роки тому

      Fuck bramblestar 😍

    • @Onyxseyes
      @Onyxseyes 11 місяців тому +2

      @@Borzoinkstay mad weirdo

    • @FantasticFawnleap
      @FantasticFawnleap 9 місяців тому

      @@Borzoinkflip B%#%hflight!

  • @dawn2941
    @dawn2941 2 роки тому +2

    This song fits them so well

  • @Helen_Art
    @Helen_Art 4 роки тому +2

    What a great Bramble PMV! I liked the part where he gets separated from his friends, it was actually something that surprised me when I read the book, (a little bit sad, but understandable). Also, I like the cute style of your characters! :3

  • @kaylynnxxx2145
    @kaylynnxxx2145 4 роки тому +2

    awwee love your Bramblestar design it' wonderful ❤❤❤❤❤

  • @Jackaxed
    @Jackaxed 4 роки тому

    this was so good and emotional holy cow.... this was a work of art (all the stuff you so is, but still-- it stands to be said)... your art is fantastic as always and i LOVE your designs and how chonky and fluffy you make the cats... but also oh my god the EMOTIONS i felt during this... the vibe of growing more distant with someone you love but still being there for them? so powerful! i also really wish they were just divorced friends, it feels like they went down different paths and they aren't quite on the same page anymore, but they do love each other still as friends.

  • @flutteringflora
    @flutteringflora 5 місяців тому

    These designs are so good!! Amazing pmv

  • @coralfriend4347
    @coralfriend4347 4 роки тому +2

    Why do the ending scenes that state "Thanks for watching!" give you the feels-