ranking the performances from episodes 3 and 4 of boys planet

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 8 вер 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 57

  • @multifandom-6041
    @multifandom-6041 Рік тому +116

    3:46 i agree with g group interpreted the song's vibe better
    they have youthful image and the arrows thing of wumuti and jay is cute
    4:30 also yes

  • @linn4823
    @linn4823 Рік тому +136

    I agree with this ranking, KTL g will remain superior even if they didn’t win the Mcountdown perf🙌

    • @liezltan1887
      @liezltan1887 Рік тому +7

      Yes they are the best sadly k group won so 1 of them will perform, sad for G group only the team of KTL have the highest votes, in total they are the 2nd highest score

    • @kimiberger
      @kimiberger Рік тому +4

      knetz will never give G group the win unless they are WAY ahead or unless it's clear that K group stuffed up bad. I kind of believe that (G) love me right was less stable, but it was better interpretation. And Jay was better than Hui. Case closed.
      Im satisfied that K group got the win. But Jay should have won the main vocal match up.

  • @danyy4903
    @danyy4903 Рік тому +83

    I'm obsessed with boys planet

  • @rosmarius8006
    @rosmarius8006 Рік тому +51

    IM SO GLAD IM NOT THE ONLY ONE THAT GENUINELY THINKS G’S LOVE ME RIGHT WAS JUST BETTER!

  • @sai7285
    @sai7285 Рік тому +73

    i think the g group lmr over k group lmr is not unpopular for atleast international fans.I personally think it was biased and the difference btw points for hui and jay is ridiculous..

    • @w.s.p.y9756
      @w.s.p.y9756 Рік тому +6

      i think so too... hui is an amazing singer no doubt but jay's voice just fits the vibe and the song better.

    • @sai7285
      @sai7285 Рік тому +1

      @@w.s.p.y9756 exactly

  • @alanfitzgerald6567
    @alanfitzgerald6567 Рік тому +38

    This is probably the most accurate list tbf. I honestly thought most acts were excellent for a live performance, but that KTL.... I would buy that in a heartbeat! 😍

  • @mengyan.5s
    @mengyan.5s Рік тому +16

    Well, who doesn't like Matthew? He's too adorable AND talented to not be liked!
    And I agree almost entirely with your ranking.
    I would have just switched "Hot Sauce" (K) and "Aju Nice" (G).

  • @javiercampillay6045
    @javiercampillay6045 Рік тому +20

    Love the top3, for me Jay was the main character in the first mission. The 60 votes was a choice but wtv

  • @liezltan1887
    @liezltan1887 Рік тому +31

    Lets be honest:
    1.Kill this love (G group): are the best for me out of all performance(100%)
    2. Love me right(G group): i think they did much better and they enjoyed performing plus wow Jay the vocals is so good.
    3. Back door(k group): they are good too especially Jong woo(i think the center) his the star..
    P.s i think Danger(G group) are much better than K group but they lose maybe they are not popular

  • @a.n.8972
    @a.n.8972 Рік тому +11

    the live audience voting is so stupid and it has such a big impact like make it make sense

    • @raisha99
      @raisha99 Рік тому +2

      and stupid mnet had to make it k vs g for the benefits, now most g group trainees lost benefits so many of them will be eliminated😔

    • @neodipity
      @neodipity  Рік тому

      yeah 💀

  • @teumedeobi
    @teumedeobi Рік тому +6

    omg finally someone who has the exact same thoughts as me for the love me right perfs!

  • @0.o457
    @0.o457 Рік тому +12

    me personally i think jays voice fit better w the song compared to hui, n i also think haruto did better w the rap but 🤷‍♀️

  • @simran12354
    @simran12354 Рік тому +5

    With Jeong ichan from danger k group who was off tune actually was sick so it wasn't that he cracked it was that he could reach that note because his throat was so sore
    He cried after stage apparently and that's why maybe why he got more votes because they felt sorry for him
    Hwanhee from k group kill this love sang the highnote with vocal nodules and by the end of the performance he could barely speak 🤯
    I'm so impressed how he still pulled it off

  • @platiniuamsp1858
    @platiniuamsp1858 Рік тому +16

    love me right korean verision was amazing,my favorite performance for now! I loved jay high note too ! we need to make jay debut here !!

  • @homegurlx
    @homegurlx Рік тому +16

    Omg debut Jay! I literally can't stop watching that performance. All the members looked like they were having so much fun! Made me even smile.

  • @genieveedejesus6189
    @genieveedejesus6189 Рік тому +3

    Personally i prefer the Kgroup for Love me right. I rewatched multiple times both performance while waiting for ep 5. the feeling i have during the first time i heard and watch G group performance to my 5th time watching is quite different. Like it became normal.
    While for k group i still keep on rewatching and loving every part of their performance.
    Tho both group gave me overly excitement feeling.
    1) Kill this love G group
    2) Love me Right K group
    3) love me right G Group
    4) Back Door K Group

  • @tami6666
    @tami6666 Рік тому +2

    also, most in lmr g group were pretty great individually too than kgroup. k group somehow felt off individually and all i see was hanbin and hui. but not mentioning the main vocal and center part, i think g group did pretty great esp the rap line. and as a group they have more chemistry.

  • @sweetiarmy9351
    @sweetiarmy9351 Рік тому +23

    Personally I liked K love me right more... Cause it was overall better than G group.. It felt like K group has already debuted..But from G group I liked Haruto's rap more...😄😄

    • @cuteboiji
      @cuteboiji Рік тому +3

      totally agree with you! hui did the adlibs better than jay and hanbin was >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> wumuti ofc + anthonny.... wasn't good... haruto did amazingly though

    • @sweetiarmy9351
      @sweetiarmy9351 Рік тому +1

      @@cuteboiji yeah totally agreed👍👍

    • @jaeminsrightfoot
      @jaeminsrightfoot Рік тому +8

      @@cuteboiji jay's singing had way more flavour, wumuti slayed his vocal parts (tho hanbin did way better as the center) so i dont know what ure talking about

    • @jaeminsrightfoot
      @jaeminsrightfoot Рік тому +5

      @@sapphire6806 the way jay sang his notes had more flavour to me idk. since hui did his own notes whilst jay stuck to the original exo high notes, it was more nostalgic for me as an exol? plus the 'fry' or 'growl' jay did made it really enjoyable. hui slayed but jay was more soothing to listen to? i know hui was more technical (ofc because hes hui) but im saying jay's vocals were flavourful

  • @ppuppuppu
    @ppuppuppu Рік тому

    MATTHEW IS THE PERFECT PICK OMG LET'S SUPPORT HIM TILL THE END😭 YOU'LL END UP LOVING HIM MORE THAN YOU THOUGHTGSGSJSKSK

  • @lapassiondeslps
    @lapassiondeslps Рік тому +1

    FINALLY a ranking I agree with! i would just switch postion 1 and 2! And YES, IT DOESN'T make sense!
    i just discovered your channel so i'm going to watch your videos, i love this one!

  • @haramlovemail
    @haramlovemail Рік тому +1

    k group lmr was more stable in vocals, but tbh g group lmr was more creative imo, they added so much and all the hearts were so cute

  • @zhanghao0101
    @zhanghao0101 Рік тому +1

    The perfect thumbline ♡

  • @purasubs
    @purasubs Рік тому +7

    I must disagree xD
    I cant really rank place 1-3 as I think each of the performances I would see at high ranking are good in different ways:
    - G Group: Kill This Love
    for real, the line up for this group is insane, it contains 3 members (Matthew, Keita, Zhang Hao) I wish to see in final lineup and they did so well... like they were just so well rounded and looked good together... this team sounded the best vocal wise the best to me. the member I couldnt take my eyes of was matthew, hes sooo good and charming... if he didnt liked the part he ended up getting, he shined and appealed the most (to me)
    - K Group: Back Door
    Im a stay and this is maybe one of my most favourite songs... but I also know they are insanly hard to cover as their songs are energy consuming and you have to give it 200%... I think the main vocal was weak here, I wish they would have picked TaeRae (also my top9 pick) as hes really stable and fits the song sooo well. What I found the most appealing is for this performance is that you saw and felt them having fun onstage and the freaking center, sorry but he killed it... he was a mix of Changbin and Hyunjin and Im sure he was very memorable and thats why their team won the final votes...
    - K Group: Love Me Right
    To be honest, I thought K group wouldnt be able to "beat" G group after I saw their performance, they were sooooo good... but dang.... the stage presence of K team was insane... even if vocal wise I think Jays vocal fit the song better, the others did better job at their parts and they really enjoyed the stage and I also felt that members liked each other and didnt see each other as rivals but members who they love and support... I think HanBin and Hui did well leading the team.

    • @Vidaminhavidadura
      @Vidaminhavidadura Рік тому

      Yea I thought I was looking at some of jinnie’s fancam, they really had study his way of performing back door

  • @0seunggf
    @0seunggf Рік тому +3

    first time i agree with someone on every single one ranking
    thumbs up 👍

  • @MeowMeow-yq6ef
    @MeowMeow-yq6ef Рік тому +1

    Mnet's decisions are always questionable, but when they decided to broadcast the elimination which lasted 50 minutes and shows us only one survivor........ 🗿
    I still feel mentally abused by this

  • @lory8355
    @lory8355 Рік тому +1

    Fighting 💪
    Boys Planet ✨️🥰❤️

  • @purivanple6742
    @purivanple6742 Рік тому +4

    Lets be honest, most of the K group winning by just ONE standout contestant. And I think G group aren't just one team to win over.
    LOVE ME RIGHT -
    Aside from Hui popularity and also Sung Hanbin popularity, there's nothing can fight over G group Jay, Wumuti & Haruto talent. As we can see for the whole performance G is better than K. And guess what? MNET purposely put K Group at the end of the episodes, why? to make everyone was shocked, and you can see how was the editing, they purposely repeat the pre-chorus part sang by Hui which is really annoying. And also the adlibs part, they make it twice or three times of it repeating.
    DANGER -
    Aside from the rapper offtune, I dont get it why K group will win the whole performance by their MAIN VOCALS are really sucked to make the whole performance ruined. And yet they are winning over G team? Nonsense. And why does K win at the end? They have Lee Daeul in the team which gains most of the votes. And see how much time they repeat the part where he is singing.
    Please be fair to foreign contestant, snake MNET !

    • @inasulmillah3279
      @inasulmillah3279 Рік тому

      The order of appearance is based on who won the arm wrestling, who that won will choose appear first or second

  • @parvathiharidas2057
    @parvathiharidas2057 Рік тому +2

    omg... finally someone who thinks G lmr did better. they gave of the vibe way better compared to the K group. mnet did so bad to G groups

  • @akio1489
    @akio1489 Рік тому +2

    Also, why they compare g vs k? Like... Of course k group get more vote because they in korea. For example like ichika vs junghyung(?), Ichika did better without crack Voice but get only 3 vote and junghyung get 29
    The g group trainee now only like 20 top 52. Many talented trainee that get no screentime (even K group)
    Why dont they just mix the group, it's much better

    • @neodipity
      @neodipity  Рік тому +1

      because mnet want as few foreign trainees as possible 😐

    • @akio1489
      @akio1489 Рік тому

      @@neodipity yeah just mnet things😌☝🏻

  • @tofubbang715
    @tofubbang715 Рік тому +1

    They shouldve at least let a g group go to mcountdown too its unfair for them lol

  • @thedxrito
    @thedxrito Рік тому

    stray kids enjoyer?? i have no choice but to sub

  • @raisha99
    @raisha99 Рік тому

    I agree with you 100%

  • @brianj439
    @brianj439 Рік тому +2

    3:41 THANK YOU! LMR G Group was ROBBED!

  • @jamilaphillips2180
    @jamilaphillips2180 Рік тому

    I 👍 agree with your pick

  • @MsJosielai
    @MsJosielai Рік тому

    Totally agree with you

  • @j.c.85
    @j.c.85 Рік тому +2

    Hui >>>> Jay... There's a difference between singing and shouting